Your father lived in Florida, died in Florida, and left a house in Dordogne. You expect one tax bill, in France, where the house stands. Then the American accountant tells you the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the federal tax agency of the United States, also counts that French house in the American estate, and you picture paying full inheritance tax twice on the same walls and roof. This guide explains why that fear is understandable but overstated, and what to do in the correct order so the second country gives you a dollar-for-dollar credit for the tax paid to the first. The mechanism is the Convention between France and the United States of November 24, 1978 for the avoidance of double taxation on estates, inheritances and gifts, completed by the protocol of December 8, 2004. France taxes the French house because it stands in France. The United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on their worldwide estate, wherever the assets stand. The treaty then says the country of the second filing must subtract the tax paid in the country with the primary right, within limits. For an American family that means: settle France first, with a French declaration de succession (the French estate return filed through a notaire, the French public officer who settles estates), pay the French droits de succession (French transfer tax on death), keep every receipt, then claim the foreign death tax credit on the American Form 706 (the United States Estate Tax Return) under Section 2014 of the Internal Revenue Code. Done in that order, with matching valuations and clean proof, most families pay the higher of the two taxes, not the sum. Done in reverse, or with mismatched values, they leave money behind or trigger penalties on both sides.
I. Why France and America both tax the same French house
A. Why does France tax a French house even when the owner died in America?
France taxes real property by location. A maison (house), an appartement (apartment), or bare land standing in France falls into the French succession net even if the deceased never lived in France, never held French nationality, and died in Houston or San Diego. The French tax administration does not need the heir to live in France either. If the building is in France, the French return is due.
The connecting rule is Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code, the Code general des impots. The Cour de cassation (the French supreme court for civil and criminal matters) recalls its wording in these exact terms:
«Selon ce texte, sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit les biens
meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B et ceux reçus par l’héritier, le donataire ou le légataire qui a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de cet article.», as stated in the Cour de cassation ruling of November 18, 2020, No. 18-14.242.
In plain English for an American reader: property is caught when the deceased had French tax domicile, or when the heir has French tax domicile, and in practice French real estate is always caught because it is situated in France. The leading decision on the mechanism is Cour de cassation, commercial chamber, November 18, 2020, No. 18-14.242, a case about assets placed in an American revocable trust. The Court states the triggering event with precision:
«En application de ce texte, le fait générateur des droits de mutation à titre gratuit est constitué par le transfert de propriété, qui, s’agissant de biens placés dans un trust, s’opère par l’effet de la distribution de l’actif du trust au bénéficiaire final, au jour de sa clôture, laquelle peut être postérieure au décès du constituant.», as stated in the Cour de cassation ruling of November 18, 2020, No. 18-14.242.
Translation: the tax is triggered by the transfer of ownership, and for assets held in a trust that transfer happens when the trust distributes to the final beneficiary at its closing, which can be after the settlor died. American families who hold a French house through a California living trust should read that sentence twice. The French notaire (the French public officer who records title and files the estate return) will not release the house on the strength of the American trust certificate alone. France looks through the trust to the real transfer, taxes it, and requires a French acte de notoriete (the notarial deed that names the heirs) and, for real estate, an attestation immobiliere (the notarial deed published at the land registry that updates title to the heirs names).
The French deadline is short and territorial. Article 641 of the General Tax Code provides:
«Les délais pour l’enregistrement des déclarations que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès sont : De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.», as stated in Article 641 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance.
When the deceased died outside metropolitan France, which covers a death in the United States, the French estate return is due within one year of death. Interest and the standard late penalties accrue after that, and the land registry will not update title until the return is filed or guaranteed. The return itself is mandatory under Article 800 of the General Tax Code:
«Les héritiers, légataires ou donataires, leurs tuteurs ou curateurs, sont tenus de souscrire une déclaration détaillée.», as stated in Article 800 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance.
Only very small estates are excused, and a French house always exceeds those thresholds. In practice the American heir signs a French declaration de succession prepared by the notaire, with a detailed valuation of the house, the mortgages and deductible debts, the prior gifts, and the shares of each heir.
Valuation follows French rules, not the Zillow estimate or the county appraisal. The house is declared at its market value on the day of death, the v valeur venale (the price a willing buyer would pay on the open market). Furniture inside a furnished second home can be valued under Article 758 of the General Tax Code by a detailed estimate. Debts are subtracted only when proved. Article 768 of the General Tax Code states:
«Pour la liquidation des droits de mutation par décès, les dettes à la charge du défunt sont déduites lorsque leur existence au jour de l’ouverture de la succession est dûment justifiée par tous modes de preuve compatibles avec la procédure écrite.», as stated in Article 768 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance.
A remaining French mortgage, documented by the bank statement at death, is deductible. An informal family loan without paperwork is not. American probate debts paid after death without French proof are routinely rejected, which raises the French bill and, as we will see, caps the American credit.
Prior gifts matter because France aggregates them. Article 784 of the General Tax Code requires:
«Les parties sont tenues de faire connaître, dans tout acte constatant une transmission entre vifs à titre gratuit et dans toute déclaration de succession, s’il existe ou non des donations antérieures consenties à un titre et sous une forme quelconque», as stated in Article 784 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance.
If the American parent had already given the child 150,000 euros years earlier through a French donation (a recorded gift deed), that gift is recalled into the calculation for allowances and brackets under the rappel des donations (the rule that adds back gifts made less than fifteen years earlier). Hiding it exposes the heir to reassessment, while declaring it correctly preserves the treaty credit because the IRS will ask for the same history.
Finally, French forced heirship can disturb an American will that gave the French house to one child or to a new spouse. Article 913 of the Civil Code provides:
«Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.», as stated in Article 913 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
That protected share is called the reserve hereditaire (the minimum share the law keeps for children). Gifts and bequests that exceed the freely disposable part, called the quotite disponible (the share the deceased could freely give away), can be reduced at the request of the shortchanged child. Article 922 of the Civil Code builds the test mass:
«Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.», as stated in Article 922 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
American families are sometimes surprised that a French court can be seised at all when the deceased lived in Florida. The Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, April 14, 2021, No. 19-24.773, concerning a house in France given away before a death in Sweden, quashed an appeal ruling that had applied French law simply as the law of the place where the building stood, and required the lower court to reason under the succession law that actually governed the estate. The lesson for Americans is symmetrical: do not assume the French house is insulated by an American will, and do not assume a French forced-heirship claim automatically wins either. Identify the law applicable to the succession under the European Succession Regulation No. 650/2012 for deaths on or after August 17, 2015, or the prior French conflicts rules for earlier deaths, check any professio juris (a written choice of law in a will), and quantify the reserve before paying tax on shares that a court could later reorder.
B. Why does the IRS also count the French house in the American estate?
The United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on worldwide transfers. For an American citizen who owned a house in France, the French house is part of the gross estate under Section 2031 of the Internal Revenue Code, at its fair market value on the date of death or on the alternate valuation date six months later if elected. Residence is irrelevant. A citizen domiciled in Texas with a cottage in Brittany is taxed in America on that cottage just as if it stood in Texas.
The American filing threshold is far higher than the French one, which confuses many families. For 2024 to 2026 the federal basic exclusion is over 13 million dollars per person, indexed each year, so most middle-class estates owe no American estate tax at all. But owing nothing and filing nothing are different. When the gross estate plus lifetime taxable gifts exceeds the exclusion, the executor must file Form 706 within nine months of death, with a six-month extension available. Even when no American tax is due, the filed Form 706 is often the document that locks in the stepped-up basis for the later American capital gains calculation when the heir sells the French house, and it is the vehicle that claims the treaty credit.
The treaty that prevents the same euro of value from being fully taxed twice is the Convention between the United States and France signed on November 24, 1978, with the protocol signed on December 8, 2004. Its architecture is simple. Article 5 gives France the primary right to tax real property situated in France. The United States, as the country of citizenship or domicile of the deceased, may also tax that property under its worldwide principle, but must then allow a credit for the French tax paid on that same property, under the treaty article on relief from double taxation. The Joint Committee on Taxation explanation of the treaty, available at JCT explanation of the 1978 estate and gift tax treaty, summarises that the United States gives a full credit mechanism subject to the treaty limits, and the 2004 protocol explanation adds a technical guardrail: property that the United States can tax only because it stands in France, under the real property, business property or tangible movable property articles, enters the American taxable base only to the extent its net value exceeds 50 percent of all property taxable by the United States. In ordinary language, when the French house is a small part of a large American estate, the treaty keeps the American computation proportionate rather than letting situs property swamp the return.
Domestic American law carries the same credit idea in Section 2014, which allows against the federal estate tax a credit for death taxes paid to a foreign country on property situated in that country and included in the American gross estate. The treaty and the statute point the same way: pay France on the French house, prove it, and subtract it in America within the ceiling. What the treaty does not do is erase differences in rates, allowances, or timing. France taxes each heir on the net share received, with the direct-line scale in Article 777 of the General Tax Code running from 5 percent to 45 percent by slices of taxable share. America taxes the estate as a whole above a high exclusion at a flat 40 percent marginal rate. France gives each child an allowance of 100,000 euros under Article 779 of the General Tax Code:
«Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit, il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.», as stated in Article 779 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance.
America gives one large exclusion to the estate. A child who inherits a 400,000 euro French house from an American parent can easily owe substantial French tax while the American estate owes nothing, in which case there is no American tax to credit against and the French bill simply stands. Conversely, a very large estate can owe American tax well above the French bill, in which case the credit wipes out the American tax on the French slice but leaves the balance payable in America. The planning point is to compute both sides on consistent values before moving money.
II. How Americans pay France first and recover the credit in America
A. How do Americans file and pay the French tax without overpaying it?
Start with title and law, not with the Internal Revenue Service. The French notaire needs the American death certificate with apostille (the international authentication stamp under the Hague Convention), the American will and any codicils with certified translation, the marriage and birth records that prove heirship, and the full gift history for the rappel rule. If the deceased chose American law in the will, produce that professio juris clause and check it against the European Succession Regulation: Articles 21 and 22 allow a person to choose the law of their nationality to govern the whole succession, which for an American means American law can govern the French house in principle, but French tax still applies and French forced heirship can return through the compensatory levy mechanism for children deprived under the chosen foreign law. Do not let anyone tell you that choosing American law removes French tax. It does not.
Take a priced example to see the French mechanics. A widowed American father, domiciled in Florida, dies in 2025 owning a free-standing house near Sarlat valued at 420,000 euros, with a remaining French mortgage of 40,000 euros documented at death, and two American children inheriting equally. Gross estate in France: 420,000 euros. Deductible debt under Article 768: 40,000 euros, leaving 380,000 euros net. Each child receives 190,000 euros. Each child subtracts the 100,000 euro allowance under Article 779, leaving 90,000 euros taxable per child. Apply the Article 777 direct-line scale: 5 percent up to 8,072 euros, 10 percent to 12,109 euros, 15 percent to 15,932 euros, then 20 percent above. The arithmetic gives roughly 402 euros on the first slice, 404 euros on the second, 573 euros on the third, and 14,814 euros at 20 percent on the remaining 74,068 euros, for about 16,193 euros per child, or about 32,386 euros for the family. Add the notaire emoluments, the land registry tax and publication costs for the attestation immobiliere, and the mortgage release statement. Those French figures become the ceiling of the American credit for that house: America will never credit more French tax than the American tax attributable to the same house.
Three French traps inflate that bill when Americans improvise. First, valuation gaps. If the declaration states 340,000 euros to save French tax but the Form 706 later states 420,000 euros to obtain a higher American basis, both administrations notice the mismatch and the treaty credit is computed on the lower proven French value. Use one defensible market value, supported by a French agent appraisal or notarial valuation at death, and use it on both returns, converting euros to dollars at the correct date-of-death rate. Second, missing debt proof. A mortgage statement dated months after death, or an American home equity line vaguely allocated to the French house, is rejected under Article 768, which demands proof of existence on the day the succession opened. Obtain the French bank attestation as of the death date before the loan is closed. Third, forgotten prior gifts. Article 784 obliges disclosure of earlier gifts in any form. A 2018 American wire described as a gift that funded the French deposit can be recharacterised in France as a taxable prior gift that consumes part of the 100,000 euro allowance. Disclose it, date it, and let the fifteen-year clock work. Gifts older than fifteen years drop out of the rappel, which is why old files must be kept rather than guessed at.
The French payment produces the paper the American return needs: the stamped declaration de succession, the avis de mise en recouvrement (the French tax assessment notice), the bank proof of payment to the French Treasury, the attestation immobiliere published at the service de publicite fonciere (the French land registry), and, when a trust was involved, the distribution resolution that closed the trust and transferred title. Without those, the American credit is theory. The Cour de cassation trust ruling cited above is the reason French notaires insist on tracing the distribution: the taxable transfer for trust assets is the distribution to the final beneficiary at closing. If the trust still holds the house on paper, France treats the succession as unsettled and the American credit has nothing to attach to.
For families with a surviving American spouse, add one French choice before computing tax. The surviving spouse can often elect between full ownership of one quarter or usufruct of the whole, meaning usufruit (the lifetime right to use the house and collect any rent) with the children taking nue-propriete (bare ownership without current use). The election changes who pays tax on what slice and at what age-based usufruct value, and it interacts with the American marital deduction. Make the election in the French deed, in writing, within the legal time limit, and carry the same shares into the American return. A French usufruct reported as full ownership in America, or vice versa, breaks the credit matching property by property.
B. How do Americans claim the French tax as a credit on the US return?
File France first, then America, and link them property by property. On Form 706, the French house is listed in the gross estate at its dollar value, typically on Schedule A for real estate. The French death tax attributable to that house is claimed on Schedule P for foreign death taxes, with a treaty-based claim referencing the 1978 Convention and Section 2014. The credit is limited to the lesser of the French tax actually paid on that property and the American federal estate tax attributable to that same property. Attach the French assessment and proof of payment, with certified English translations, plus the notarial deeds that prove the heir shares. If the French tax is not yet finally assessed when Form 706 is due, file the American return on time, pay any American balance net of the expected credit, and perfect the credit by the regulatory deadline with proof of payment, using the extension and protective claim procedures rather than letting the American return go late.
Currency and timing mismatches cause most lost credits. Convert the French taxable share into dollars at the rate in effect on the date of death for the gross estate, and follow the Form 706 instructions for the credit computation, which uses its own exchange rules for taxes paid later. Keep the French payment date proof because interest and penalties that accrue after the French one-year deadline are still part of the French payment but may not be creditable in America to the extent they exceed the tax attributable to the property. In other words, a late French filing can create a French surcharge that America does not reimburse. The one-year French deadline quoted above is therefore not only a French problem. It directly shrinks the American recovery when missed.
Domicile labels must match the treaty. Article 4 of the 1978 Convention defines fiscal domicile by permanent home and closer ties, not by passport alone. An American citizen who had lived full time in France for years may be treaty-domiciled in France, which changes which country taxes non-situs assets and which country gives the credit on them. For the French house itself the result rarely changes, because situs wins for real property in both the treaty and domestic law, but for the bank accounts, securities and American retirement plans in the same estate the domicile answer decides who credits whom. State the domicile analysis in the file, consistently on both returns, instead of letting the French notaire write French domicile while the American accountant writes American domicile for the same person at the same date.
Keep the after-filing chain intact. When the heir later sells the French house, the American basis is generally the dollar fair market value reported on Form 706, and the French capital gains computation starts from the French succession value, with different holding-period reliefs and social charges. Families that lowballed the French succession value to save French inheritance tax pay for it years later as higher taxable gain on sale, in France and, through the foreign tax credit on income tax, in America. Families that used one honest value, filed France within the year, paid, and credited the payment on Form 706, sell later with a coherent file: French declaration, French assessment, wire proof, Form 706 with Schedule P, treaty citation, and matching valuations. That file is also what answers an IRS examination or a French controle (a tax audit) without reopening the whole succession.
Practical checklist before wiring anything: apostilled death certificate and will with sworn translation in the notaire file; written choice-of-law analysis when the will names American law; single valuation memo used in both countries; mortgage attestation dated at death; complete prior-gift list for Article 784; written spousal election when applicable; French declaration signed within one year; French assessment and payment wires kept with translations; Form 706 filed within nine months plus extension with Schedule P treaty claim. Miss one and the credit still exists in law but shrinks or stalls in practice.
Conclusion
A French house owned by an American who died in America is taxed in France because it stands in France, and counted in America because the owner was American. The 1978 treaty does not choose one winner. It orders the payments: France first on the house, America second with a credit for the French tax on that house, capped at the American tax on the same house. The families who pay once, economically, are those who treat the two returns as one file: French title cleared through the notaire within the one-year deadline, debts proved under Article 768, allowances and brackets applied child by child under Articles 779 and 777, prior gifts disclosed under Article 784, reserve exposure checked under Articles 913 and 922 and the applicable succession law, then the American Form 706 claiming the treaty and statutory credit with identical values and full proof. The families who pay more than they should are those who file in the wrong order, use two values, miss the French year, or assume an American will or a living trust makes the French house disappear from either tax base. It does not. Settle France cleanly, credit America precisely, and the same house is taxed at the higher of the two levies, not at their sum.