KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
French Naturalization by Decree for Americans: Requirements, Interview, and How to Challenge a Refusal

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

French Naturalization by Decree for Americans: Requirements, Interview, and How to Challenge a Refusal

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for years on renewable residence permits, you file French tax returns, your children go to a French school, and now you want the French passport without giving up your American one. For most Americans in that situation, the path is naturalization by decree, a discretionary grant signed by the French government after a file review and an in-person interview. It is not the same track as citizenship by blood through a French parent, which this firm explains in its guide to proving French citizenship by descent and winning the nationality certificate, and it is not the marriage track either. This article walks through the decree track from start to finish: the five-year residence rule and its exceptions, the language and values test, the money and clean-record checks drawn from real court rulings, the online filing steps, the eighteen-month answer clock, and the exact appeal route when the administration says no or tells you to come back later. Every decisive rule below is quoted from the statute or decision that states it, with a link beside it, so you can check the source yourself before you file.

I. Can an American living in France qualify for French naturalization by decree?

A. How many years of residence in France must an American show, and who gets a shorter wait?

The starting point is a single sentence of the Civil Code: Article 21-15 of the Civil Code provides that, outside one narrow special case, acquisition of French nationality by decision of the public authority results from a naturalization granted by decree at the request of the foreign national. The official wording reads: “Hors le cas prévu à l’article 21-14-1 , l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger.” Two ideas matter in that sentence. First, you must ask; nothing is automatic, however long you have lived in France. Second, the grant is a decision of the public authority, which means the administration enjoys discretion. Meeting every written condition does not create a right to the decree, and courts review refusals only for legal error, not to substitute their own view of whether you deserve citizenship.

The residence condition has two layers. The general rule, stated by Article 21-17 of the Civil Code, is five years: “Sous réserve des exceptions prévues aux articles 21-18 , 21-19 et 21-20 , la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande.” Habitual residence means France must actually be the center of your life during those five years, not merely a mailing address. For an American, that normally means five years of continuous lawful stay under valid residence permits, a real home in France, and daily life organized here. Keep every permit, every renewal receipt, tax notices, pay slips, school certificates, and lease or utility records across the whole period, because the file reviewer reconstructs those five years document by document. A second, separate sentence adds a trap at the end of the road: Article 21-16 of the Civil Code states that “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation.” Even after a perfect file, you must still live in France on the day the decree is signed. Do not plan a permanent move back to the United States while the file is pending.

Three groups of exceptions shorten or remove the five-year wait, and each is worth checking before assuming you must wait the full term. First, Article 21-18 of the Civil Code cuts the qualifying period to two years for three profiles: “1° Pour l’étranger qui a accompli avec succès deux années d’études supérieures en vue d’acquérir un diplôme délivré par une université ou un établissement d’enseignement supérieur français ; 2° Pour celui qui a rendu ou qui peut rendre par ses capacités et ses talents des services importants à la France ; 3° Pour l’étranger qui présente un parcours exceptionnel d’intégration, apprécié au regard des activités menées ou des actions accomplies dans les domaines civique, scientifique, économique, culturel ou sportif.” An American who earned a French university degree after two years of successful higher education in France is the most common beneficiary here. The talent and exceptional-integration routes exist but demand concrete proof, not self-description: publications, awards, documented civic work, or an official record of service.

Second, Article 21-19 of the Civil Code lists cases where a person may be naturalized with no qualifying period at all, including a foreign national who has actually served in a unit of the French army, a person who has rendered exceptional services to France or whose naturalization is of exceptional interest to France, and a person granted refugee status. Each of these follows its own evidentiary path, and the exceptional-interest route requires a reasoned opinion process through the Council of State. Third, Article 21-20 of the Civil Code removes the waiting period for a person who belongs to the French cultural and linguistic entity, where French is an official language of the person’s country, or French is the person’s mother tongue, or the person shows at least five years of schooling in a French-language school: “Peut être naturalisée sans condition de stage la personne qui appartient à l’entité culturelle et linguistique française, lorsqu’elle est ressortissante des territoires ou Etats dont la langue officielle ou l’une des langues officielles est le français, soit lorsque le français est sa langue maternelle, soit lorsqu’elle justifie d’une scolarisation minimale de cinq années dans un établissement enseignant en langue française.” That route rarely fits an American educated in English in the United States, but it can fit one raised in a francophone household or schooled in French.

One more family point belongs in this section because Americans often file with children in mind. Article 22-1 of the Civil Code gives the naturalization a collective effect for minor children: a minor child whose parent acquires French nationality becomes French automatically if the child shares the parent’s habitual residence, or lives alternately with that parent after a separation or divorce. The same article adds a strict formality for decree cases: the child’s name must appear in the decree. So list every minor child who lives with you in the application and check the published decree when it comes out. A child forgotten from the decree does not get the automatic effect, and fixing that later costs time and a second procedure.

B. What language, values, clean-record, and financial proof does the administration actually test?

Language comes first because it is the most mechanical filter. Article 21-24 of the Civil Code requires every applicant to show assimilation to the French community, in particular through sufficient knowledge, appropriate to the applicant’s background, of the French language, history, culture, and society, plus knowledge of the rights and duties that come with French nationality and adherence to the essential principles and values of the Republic. The statute then describes the expected language level in functional terms: “L’intéressé justifie d’un niveau de langue lui permettant au moins de comprendre le contenu essentiel de sujets concrets ou abstraits dans un texte complexe, de communiquer avec spontanéité, de s’exprimer de façon claire et détaillée sur une grande variété de sujets.” In practice, the administration applies the official benchmark published by the public service: oral and written French at least equal to level B2 of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages, proved by a French diploma or a language certificate, as explained on the official service-public.fr page on proving your French level for nationality. That page is the reference to trust for Americans choosing between the French knowledge test and the French evaluation test, because it states the B2 rule, the accepted diplomas, and the two narrow exemptions: a medical impossibility documented by a medical certificate, or a refugee or stateless person over seventy who has lived in France at least fifteen years with a valid residence permit. The two approved test certificates expire fast: attestations for the knowledge test and the evaluation test must be less than two years old on the day you file, a detail confirmed by that same official language-proof page. An American who passed a French test three years ago for a residence card must sit it again for the nationality file.

The interview is where language, history, culture, and values are checked together. After the file is found admissible, the applicant is summoned to a prefecture interview whose stated purpose is to verify assimilation, including adherence to the essential principles and values of the Republic, with the official citizen’s booklet available beforehand for preparation, according to the official service-public.fr guide to naturalization by decree. At the end of that interview, the applicant signs the charter of rights and duties of the French citizen, a step required by Article 21-24 of the Civil Code itself: “A l’issue du contrôle de son assimilation, l’intéressé signe la charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français.” Missing the summons without a legitimate reason can end the file without examination, a warning carried by that same official naturalization guide. Prepare the interview the way the reviewer conducts it: in French, out loud, on concrete topics such as the meaning of secularism, the organization of public powers, major historical markers, and your own daily participation in French life. Written certificates never replace the spoken impression you make in that room.

That interview impression can decide the file, and a recent Council of State ruling shows why every word there counts. In a nationality dispute decided on 20 March 2023, Council of State decision no. 461575, the judges upheld the government’s opposition after finding, from the reports of the prefecture interviews, that the applicant adopted a way of life marked by ignorance of the essential values and principles of French society: “Il ressort des éléments versés au dossier, notamment des propos qu’elle a tenus au cours des entretiens menés par les fonctionnaires de la préfecture de l’Essonne chargés de l’instruction de son dossier, que Mme A… adopte un mode de vie caractérisé par une méconnaissance et une ignorance des valeurs et principes essentiels de la société française.” That case concerned a declaration through marriage rather than a decree, so its statute differs, but the procedural lesson crosses over directly: prefecture officers write reports of what you say, courts treat those reports as faithful unless you prove otherwise, and vague or dismissive answers about French values become the written basis for the refusal. Go in having thought, in French, about what you will say on equality between women and men, secularism, and the duties of a citizen, because those are the subjects the reports always cover.

Good conduct is the next gate, and it is stricter than many Americans expect. Article 21-23 of the Civil Code bars naturalization for anyone who is not of good conduct and morals or who has received one of the convictions listed in Article 21-27: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’est pas de bonnes vie et moeurs ou s’il a fait l’objet de l’une des condamnations visées à l’article 21-27 du présent code.” The cross-referenced Article 21-27 of the Civil Code then sets the automatic bars: convictions for crimes or offenses against the fundamental interests of the Nation or acts of terrorism, and, whatever the offense, any sentence of six months imprisonment or more without suspension: “Nul ne peut acquérir la nationalité française ou être réintégré dans cette nationalité s’il a été l’objet soit d’une condamnation pour crimes ou délits constituant une atteinte aux intérêts fondamentaux de la Nation ou un acte de terrorisme, soit, quelle que soit l’infraction considérée, s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis.” The same article extends the bar to persons under a non-lifted expulsion order or an unexecuted ban from French territory. Beyond those automatic bars, the good-conduct standard lets the administration weigh the rest: recent fines, repeated offenses, unpaid taxes, or ongoing proceedings can all feed an unfavorable assessment even without a disqualifying sentence. The official naturalization guide adds a practical document rule for applicants who have lived in France less than ten years: an original foreign criminal-record extract, or an equivalent document, from each country of residence, which for an American means requesting the proper federal or state record early, since those requests take weeks and the file cannot be completed without them.

Money and work form the last substantive check, and court decisions describe it more bluntly than any brochure. The administrative courts repeat that the minister holds broad discretion and may lawfully consider how well the applicant is integrated, socially and professionally, and whether the applicant has resources sufficient to live durably and independently in France. The clearest statement comes from the Nantes Court of Appeal in a naturalization case decided on 8 July 2025, CAA Nantes decision no. 24NT02354: “L’autorité administrative dispose, en matière de naturalisation ou de réintégration dans la nationalité française, d’un large pouvoir d’appréciation. Elle peut, dans l’exercice de ce pouvoir, prendre en considération notamment, pour apprécier l’intérêt que présenterait l’octroi de la nationalité française, l’intégration de l’intéressé dans la société française, son insertion sociale et professionnelle et le fait qu’il dispose de ressources lui permettant de subvenir durablement à ses besoins en France.” In that case the applicant had never worked, lived essentially on benefits, and argued that health problems explained the situation, but the court found the file did not prove the health obstacle predated the decision and upheld the two-year postponement. An older ruling makes the same point with numbers: in CAA Nantes decision of 23 July 2018, no. 17NT01498, the applicant earned about 360 euros a month from two part-time jobs while receiving nearly 890 euros a month in benefits, and the court approved the postponement so she could complete her professional integration. For an American household, the message is concrete: salaried work or a stable independent activity, tax filings consistent with declared income, and resources that come mainly from work rather than benefits make the file far stronger than savings alone. A retiree with a steady American pension and clean French tax history can satisfy this test, but a household living mostly on social benefits while able to work should expect an adjournment.

II. How do Americans file the application and fight back after a refusal?

A. How do you file the ANEF application, what papers go in, and how long does the answer take?

Filing runs through the government’s online foreign-nationals portal, known by its French initials ANEF, with paper filing surviving only as a narrow backup for people who can document that online filing is impossible for them, as described in the official naturalization-by-decree guide. The fee is a 255-euro fiscal stamp, reduced in French Guiana, payable online for digital filings, and that same official guide lists it among the mandatory contents of the file. Build the file as the reviewer will read it: identity documents, proof of lawful residence across the whole qualifying period, proof of address and family situation, proof of work and resources with tax notices, the language diploma or recent test certificate, and civil-status records. On civil status, the rules are exacting: full copies plus originals in the language of the country of origin, a translation into French by a sworn or otherwise authorized translator for every foreign-language document, and no translation needed for a multilingual extract that already includes French, all set out in the official filing instructions. For Americans this means ordering full-form birth and where relevant marriage records with an apostille-compatible certification from the issuing state, then having them translated by a translator sworn before a French court of appeal. Start those orders months ahead: some states mail slowly, and the file cannot be registered complete without them.

Once the complete set of documents is handed over, a receipt is issued immediately, and that receipt starts the answer clock. Article 21-25-1 of the Civil Code states the rule in full: “La réponse de l’autorité publique à une demande d’acquisition de la nationalité française par naturalisation doit intervenir au plus tard dix-huit mois à compter de la remise de toutes les pièces nécessaires à la constitution d’un dossier complet contre laquelle un récépissé est délivré immédiatement. Le délai visé au premier alinéa est réduit à douze mois lorsque l’étranger en instance de naturalisation justifie avoir en France sa résidence habituelle depuis une période d’au moins dix ans au jour de cette remise. Les délais précités peuvent être prolongés une fois, par décision motivée, pour une période de trois mois.” Three consequences follow. First, eighteen months from the receipt is the default outside limit, twelve for applicants with ten years of habitual residence in France on the receipt date, and the administration may extend once, by reasoned decision, for three months, under that same Article 21-25-1. Second, the clock runs from the receipt for a complete file, so an incomplete submission that draws follow-up document requests pushes the real timeline back; answer every follow-up request inside the deadline the office sets, because ignoring it can get the file closed without examination, a sanction documented in the official filing guide. Third, any change after the receipt, such as a new address, a new job, a marriage, or a child, must be reported through the online personal account, since the decree must reflect an accurate situation on signature day and the reviewer rechecks residence at the end. If the outcome is favorable, the decree is published and can be consulted from the personal account created for the online application, again per the official post-decision instructions. At filing you may also request a French version of your surname or first names, or a French first name if you have none, which is decided together with the nationality file.

B. What can you do after a postponement, a rejection, or an inadmissibility decision?

Not every unfavorable answer has the same meaning, and the remedy depends on the label the decision carries. The administration’s answer can declare the file inadmissible, meaning a legal condition is unmet, or inopportune, meaning the grant is refused or postponed even though the file could be examined, and only a motivated decision lets you tell the two apart, as the official recourse section of the naturalization guide explains. If the ground for inadmissibility disappears, you may file again. If the file was judged inopportune, the decision takes one of two forms: rejection, which closes the door for now, or adjournment, which imposes a waiting period, for example to let you strengthen your professional integration, after which you may file a new request, following that same official recourse guidance. The statute behind that choice is quoted word for word in the case law: “Si le ministre chargé des naturalisations estime qu’il n’y a pas lieu d’accorder la naturalisation ou la réintégration sollicitée, il prononce le rejet de la demande. Il peut également en prononcer l’ajournement en imposant un délai ou des conditions. Ce délai une fois expiré ou ces conditions réalisées, il appartient au postulant, s’il le juge opportun, de formuler une nouvelle demande” from Article 48 of the decree of 30 December 1993 as quoted in CAA Nantes, 23 July 2018, no. 17NT01498. An adjournment is therefore not a final defeat but a timetable: use the imposed months to fix exactly what the motivation criticized, whether language level, work stability, resource independence, or tax arrears, and refile when the period expires.

Refiling too fast can kill the new file without examination. A fresh application filed less than five years after notification of a rejection may be closed without examination once the office has reviewed any new circumstances claimed, and a fresh application filed before an adjournment period has run out may likewise be closed without examination, under the rules restated in the official reapplication guidance. The proper move after a rejection or adjournment is therefore the administrative appeal to the minister in charge of naturalizations, called a hierarchical appeal, which must come before any court case. For online filers the appeal goes exclusively through the form in the personal account’s notifications section within two months of notification of the unfavorable decision, failing which it may be declared inadmissible, and for paper filers it goes by post to the Interior Ministry’s naturalization office within the same two-month period starting from notification, all detailed in the official appeal procedure pages. If the minister answers negatively, or says nothing for four months from receipt of the appeal, you then have two months to bring the case before the administrative court of Nantes, which has exclusive jurisdiction over these disputes, with the time running from notification of the negative answer or, where there is silence, computed from the acknowledgment of receipt of the administrative appeal, as that same official appeal guidance states. Mark every one of those starting points on a calendar the day each letter arrives: two months to appeal to the minister, four months of possible silence, then two months to reach the Nantes court. Missed appeal windows are the most common way Americans lose winnable cases.

Before the Nantes court, the argument must match what judges actually control. Because naturalization is discretionary, the court does not re-decide whether you would make a good French citizen; it checks competence, procedure, factual accuracy, legal qualification, and manifest error of assessment, and it annuls only when one of those is established. The two Nantes rulings quoted in this article show the standard applied to Americans and other applicants alike: files fail when work integration is incomplete and resources depend mostly on benefits, and they survive only when the applicant proves the administration misread the facts, as the courts reasoned in CAA Nantes, 8 July 2025, no. 24NT02354 and CAA Nantes, 23 July 2018, no. 17NT01498. A serious appeal therefore reads the motivation line by line, attaches dated proof for each criticized point as it stood on the day of the contested decision, and explains why the assessment was manifestly wrong rather than merely harsh. New facts that arose after the decision generally belong in a fresh application, not in the court file. And throughout the dispute, keep the parallel track in mind: many Americans pursue the appeal while quietly preparing the stronger refile, so that the end of the adjournment period or the five-year window meets a file that is already complete, translated, and up to date.

Conclusion

Naturalization by decree rewards the American who treats it as a multi-year project rather than a formality. Five years of habitual residence documented permit by permit, residence still in France on signature day, a B2 level of French proved by a recent diploma or test, a convincing prefecture interview closed by signing the citizen’s charter, a clean record on both sides of the Atlantic, and work-based resources consistent with your tax filings: those are the pillars, each stated by the statute or decision linked above. When the answer is no, read the label before reacting. Inadmissible means a missing legal condition to repair; rejected means a new departure after appeal and, if needed, a five-year pause; adjourned means a dated work plan ending in a stronger refile. The appeal route runs from the minister to the administrative court of Nantes on short, strict clocks, so calendar every deadline from the notification date. Prepared this way, the file of an American long settled in France presents the administration with the simplest possible decision, and gives a judge, if it ever comes to that, a record that speaks for itself.

📄 Official circular