KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Living in France as an American: Naturalization by Decree, the 5-Year Residence, Language and Tax Tests, and How to Challenge a Refusal

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Living in France as an American: Naturalization by Decree, the 5-Year Residence, Language and Tax Tests, and How to Challenge a Refusal

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are an American citizen living in France. You have a carte de séjour, you pay French taxes, your children may attend a French school, and you now ask the direct question: can I become French while keeping my American passport, and what does Paris actually check before signing the decree? French nationality by decree, called naturalisation par décret, is the standard path for a foreign adult with no French parent and no French spouse. It is also the most demanding path, because no one has a right to it. The administration grants it as a favor of the state after verifying residence, language, work, taxes, and loyalty to the values of the Republic. This guide explains the whole route in practical order: first whether you qualify, then what the préfecture, the centralized administration since the ANEF online filing system, examines at the interview, then how long the answer takes, and finally how Americans challenge a refusal, an inadmissibility ruling, or an adjournment before the administrative court. It is written for an American reader with no prior French legal background. Every French term is explained at first use. Every decisive rule is tied to the exact article of the Civil Code and to recent court decisions that show how judges apply those articles.

The starting point is simple. Outside one narrow special statute, l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger. That sentence, from Article 21-15 of the Civil Code, carries three warnings that shape everything below. First, the initiative belongs to you: nothing happens unless you file a request. Second, the decision belongs to the public authority: even a perfect file can be refused on grounds of opportunity. Third, the grant takes the form of a décret, a formal order signed at the highest level of the executive and published in the Journal officiel, the official gazette where French laws and decrees appear. Americans who obtained French nationality through a French parent follow a different route, described in our guide on proving French citizenship by descent through a parent or grandparent, and spouses of French citizens use the marriage declaration described in our guide on claiming French citizenship through marriage to a French citizen. This article covers only the decree path, which is the path for Americans with no French bloodline and no French spouse.

I. How Long Must an American Live in France Before Applying for Citizenship

Eligibility for naturalization by decree rests on five pillars that the administration checks in the same order every time: age, residence, the length of that residence, assimilation to the French community, and good character including tax compliance and criminal history. Fail one pillar and the file stops. Americans should therefore audit themselves against each pillar before filing, because a premature application produces a refusal that stays in the file and must be disclosed in the next attempt.

A. Do You Really Need Five Full Years of Habitual Residence in France

The age condition is the shortest to state. Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a atteint l’âge de dix-huit ans. You must be eighteen on the day you apply. The same article allows one exception for a minor child whose parent has become French and who has lived with that parent in France for the five years before the request, but that exception concerns children, not the American adult reader of this guide. If you apply at seventeen, the request is inadmissible, which means it is rejected without any examination of its merits.

The residence condition has two faces that Americans often confuse: where you live and how long you have lived there. On the first face, the rule is absolute. Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation. Your residence, meaning the place where you actually and stably live, must be in France not only when you file but still on the day the decree is signed, many months later. An American who files from Lyon, then accepts a two-year work assignment in Chicago while keeping a Paris apartment, breaks this condition. The administration treats the center of your family, professional, and social life as the test, not the address on your lease. Keeping a French lease while living abroad does not satisfy the text. Conversely, an American who lives full time in Bordeaux, works remotely for a United States employer, sends children to a Bordeaux school, and files French tax returns as a French resident satisfies the residence test even though the salary comes from abroad, because the life itself is anchored in France.

On the second face, duration, the headline rule is the five-year stage. Sous réserve des exceptions prévues aux articles 21-18, 21-19 et 21-20, la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande. Five years of habitual residence immediately before the filing date. Habitual means continuous and stable, under a valid titre de séjour, a residence permit, for the whole period. Short vacations to the United States do not reset the clock. Long absences do. As a working benchmark used by prefectures, absences totaling more than roughly six months in a single year, or a single absence of more than a year, raise a presumption that residence has ceased to be habitual, and the applicant must then produce evidence such as maintained housing, continued French employment, children still schooled in France, and uninterrupted tax residence to rebut it. Students should note that years spent in France on a student permit count toward the five years on paper, but the administration examines professional insertion separately, and a student with no subsequent stable work is routinely adjourned rather than naturalized, as explained below.

Three groups of exceptions shorten or remove the five-year wait, and Americans should check each one before assuming the full stage applies. The first group cuts the stage to two years for three profiles. Le stage mentionné à l’article 21-17 est réduit à deux ans : 1° Pour l’étranger qui a accompli avec succès deux années d’études supérieures en vue d’acquérir un diplôme délivré par une université ou un établissement d’enseignement supérieur français. An American who earned a French university degree after two successful years of higher education in France therefore files after two years of habitual residence, not five, provided the residence condition itself remains satisfied. The same two-year reduction covers a foreigner who has rendered or can render important services to France by ability and talent, and a foreigner whose integration record is exceptional in civic, scientific, economic, cultural, or sporting life. A published researcher recruited by a French laboratory, an athlete competing for a French club at the highest level, or an entrepreneur whose company created substantial employment in France can argue these cases, but the bar is deliberately high and the file must document the claim with contracts, publications, selections, or audited employment figures, not with general praise.

The second group removes the stage entirely for narrow profiles listed in Article 21-19 of the Civil Code, including a foreigner who served in the French armed forces, a wartime volunteer in French or allied forces, a person granted refugee status, and a foreigner whose naturalization serves the exceptional interest of France, in which case the decree follows a reasoned opinion of the competent minister and the advice of the Conseil d’État, the supreme administrative court that advises the government. Few American readers will fall in these categories, but recognized refugees among them should know the stage does not apply. The third group, in Article 21-20, waives the stage for a person belonging to the French cultural and linguistic entity who comes from a country where French is an official language, or whose mother tongue is French, or who completed at least five years of schooling in a French-language school. An American educated from childhood at a French lycée abroad, for example a graduate of a Lycée français with five years of French-language schooling who speaks French as a practical mother tongue, can invoke this waiver. The claim must be proved with school certificates and diplomas, because the administration does not take language background on trust.

One absolute bar sits above all the exceptions. Nul ne peut acquérir la nationalité française ou être réintégré dans cette nationalité s’il a été l’objet soit d’une condamnation pour crimes ou délits constituant une atteinte aux intérêts fondamentaux de la Nation ou un acte de terrorisme, soit, quelle que soit l’infraction considérée, s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis. Any unsuspended prison sentence of six months or more, for any offense, blocks acquisition. The same article extends the bar to a person under an expulsion order that was never withdrawn, a person under an unexecuted ban from French territory, and a person whose stay in France is irregular under immigration law. An American living in France without a valid permit at any point in the reference period should therefore regularize fully and build a clean period of regular stay before filing, because irregular stay alone justifies inadmissibility without further debate. The practical service-public summary of the whole process, including the online filing channel and the list of supporting documents, is published on the official portal at service-public.fr: Naturalisation par décret, which you should read alongside the code articles cited here.

B. Can You Prove Language, Loyalty, Work, Taxes and Good Character the Way the Interview Tests Them

Residence gets you through the door. Assimilation decides whether you stay inside. Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises. The same article adds two elements that Americans sometimes overlook: knowledge of the rights and duties conferred by French nationality, and adherence to the essential principles and values of the Republic. At the end of the assimilation check, the applicant signs the charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français, the charter of rights and duties of the French citizen, which restates those principles, values, and symbols. The signature is not a formality. Refusing the values the charter states, for example by declaring that religious rules override republican law in public life, has supported findings of non-assimilation in past litigation.

The language test is the most frequent reason Americans fail. The statute phrases it functionally. L’intéressé justifie d’un niveau de langue lui permettant au moins de comprendre le contenu essentiel de sujets concrets ou abstraits dans un texte complexe, de communiquer avec spontanéité, de s’exprimer de façon claire et détaillée sur une grande variété de sujets. In the Common European Framework that France uses, that description corresponds to level B2, independent user, and the implementing decree requires documentary proof: a French diploma, an approved language certificate at the required level, or the assimilation interview itself. An American who speaks fluent tourist French but cannot discuss an abstract topic, argue a point of view, or understand a complex text will not pass. The prefecture conducts an individual interview, called the entretien d’assimilation, entirely in French, covering your personal history, your daily life in France, French institutions, major historical dates, republican symbols such as Marianne, the tricolor, and the Marseillaise, the meaning of laïcité, secularism in public services and schools, and the rights and duties of citizens including voting, taxation, and compulsory education. Prepare for it as an examination, not a conversation. Bring dates, names, and concrete examples from your own life in France: the school your children attend, the association where you volunteer, the municipal elections in which you now hope to vote. Vague answers such as loving France and French food persuade no one.

Professional insertion and financial autonomy form the second great filter. Naturalization by decree is discretionary, and the administration lawfully considers whether you participate durably in French economic life. A stable employment contract, called a contrat à durée indéterminée, continuous self-employed activity with declared income, or a solid retirement with French tax residence all support insertion. Precarious, undeclared, or purely foreign-anchored situations weaken it. A recent illustration comes from the administrative court of appeal in Nantes. On 26 May 2026 that court upheld the rejection of a naturalization request where the file showed prolonged professional inactivity and an inability to assess language knowledge at the interview, holding that the minister could lawfully retain those grounds, a decision published as CAA de Nantes, 5ème chambre, 26/05/2026, 25NT00925. The applicant invoked a disability to explain both points, but the court found the evidence did not show that the condition had prevented all professional activity compatible with his health since 2010. Americans should draw three lessons. First, long unemployment without medical or family explanation damages the file. Second, language failure at the interview is recorded and weighed independently. Third, a health explanation must be documented with precise medical evidence linking the condition to the exact periods of inactivity, because general statements about illness do not suffice.

Tax compliance and the absence of debts to the public purse form the third filter, and Americans face a specific trap here. The prefecture consults the tax administration. Unfiled French returns, unpaid income tax, unpaid taxe foncière on a French house, or ongoing recovery proceedings signal that the applicant does not assume the duties of citizenship. Regularize everything before filing: file the missing returns, pay or formally dispute with receipts, and keep the avis d’imposition, the tax assessment notices, for at least the stage period. American readers must also keep their United States filings current, because unexplained inconsistencies between declared worldwide income in France and the means of subsistence shown in the file raise questions, even though the French decision applies French law. The cleanest files contain three to five years of French tax notices matching the declared professional activity, proof of health coverage, and no mention in the criminal record bulletin.

Good character closes the list. The six-month unsuspended prison sentence bar quoted above is only the floor. Below that floor, the administration still weighs suspended sentences, repeated offenses, driving under the influence, domestic violence, fraud, and any conduct showing disregard for republican values. Traffic fines paid on time do not matter. A pattern of offenses does. Polygamy is expressly treated as a failure of assimilation in marriage cases, and the reasoning extends by analogy: any stable family situation incompatible with French public order weakens a decree application. The Conseil d’État confirmed this logic in a marriage-declaration case on 30 November 2021, holding that a man who had lived in bigamy from 2014 to 2018 and fathered a child with his second wife was not sufficiently assimilated, in Conseil d’État, 2ème chambre, 30/11/2021, 451191. The lesson for decree applicants is direct: put your civil status in order under French law before filing, finalize any divorce abroad and have it recognized if needed, and ensure your livret de famille, the official family booklet, matches reality.

II. What Happens After You File and What If France Says No

Filing the request opens a regulated procedure with a clock, an interview, an investigation, and four possible endings: a favorable decree, a rejection, an inadmissibility ruling, or an adjournment that postpones the decision. Americans who understand the clock and the meaning of each ending react correctly instead of panicking or, worse, letting appeal deadlines expire while waiting for a miracle.

A. What Does the Prefecture Check at the Interview and How Long Does the Answer Take

Since the generalization of the ANEF online channel, the administration numérique pour les étrangers en France, most applications start with an online account, an uploaded file with civil-status documents, residence permits, employment proofs, tax notices, language diplomas, and the timbres fiscaux, the electronic tax stamps that pay the fee, followed by a summons to the préfecture, the state office representing the central government in each département, for the assimilation interview and the verification of originals. The official checklist on service-public.fr: Naturalisation par décret lists the documents, and you should treat that page as your packing list. American civil-status documents require recent full copies, sworn translation by a traducteur assermenté, a sworn translator registered with a French court of appeal, and where applicable an apostille under the Hague Convention or legalization, because the United States issues no livret de famille and French offices will not interpret American birth certificates generously. Order the apostilles early through the competent United States authority for each document, since some states take weeks.

At the interview, the agent verifies identity, reviews every original, tests French in a sustained exchange, questions you on history, culture, institutions, and the charter of rights and duties, and explores your family, professional, associative, and civic life. The agent then writes a report and the file undergoes an enquête, an investigation that includes police and intelligence checks, consultation of the tax and social-security bodies, and verification of the authenticity of foreign documents. Do not attempt to embellish. A false employment certificate or a concealed conviction destroys the file permanently, because fraud reveals exactly the opposite of assimilation: a willingness to deceive the Republic at the moment of joining it.

The administration is bound by a statutory clock once your file is complete. La réponse de l’autorité publique à une demande d’acquisition de la nationalité française par naturalisation doit intervenir au plus tard dix-huit mois à compter de la remise de toutes les pièces nécessaires à la constitution d’un dossier complet contre laquelle un récépissé est délivré immédiatement. Eighteen months from the day you receive the récépissé, the receipt certifying that your file is complete. The same article shortens the period when you have deeper roots: the period is reduced to twelve months if, on the day the complete file is acknowledged, you have had your habitual residence in France for at least ten years. Both periods may be extended once, by a reasoned decision, for three months. In practice, count eighteen months from the récépissé, add a possible three-month extension, and treat any silence beyond that point as a matter to raise with counsel rather than as an approval, because unlike some French procedures, the expiry of the period does not create an implied favorable decision in naturalization matters.

The four endings require distinct reactions. A favorable decision takes the form of a décret de naturalisation published in the Journal officiel with your name, followed by the possibility of requesting French identity documents and, for voters, registration on the electoral roll. An irrecevabilité, an inadmissibility ruling, means a threshold condition was missing: minority, insufficient residence length, irregular stay, or incomplete file. It is not a judgment on your merits, and you reapply once the missing condition is met. An ajournement, an adjournment, usually for two years, means the merits were examined but deemed premature: language still fragile, professional insertion too recent, taxes just regularized, or marriage too new to assess shared life. The proper response is to use the waiting period as a checklist, improve each weak point with dated proof, and reapply with a visibly stronger file. A decision de rejet, a rejection on the merits, is the hardest ending: assimilation denied, values rejected, or conduct incompatible with citizenship. It can still be challenged, but the next file must show a genuine change, because refiling an identical request after a rejection produces an identical answer.

B. How Do Americans Challenge a Refusal, Adjournment or Opposition Before the Court

Every adverse decision must state the remedies, the court, and the two-month deadline. Respect that deadline without exception, because a late appeal is inadmissible no matter how strong the merits. In practice the challenge follows two steps. First, an optional recours gracieux, a request asking the minister to reconsider, supported by new evidence such as a fresh language diploma, a permanent contract signed after the refusal, or proof that tax arrears are cleared. The gracious appeal does not suspend the two-month court deadline unless it is filed quickly and followed by a court appeal as a precaution, so file protectively before the courts while the ministry re-examines. Second, a recours contentieux, a court action for excess of power, asking the administrative judge to annul the refusal. The judge does not substitute personal judgment for the administration on opportunity, but verifies legality in full: competence, procedure, statement of reasons, exact application of the law, accuracy of the facts, and absence of manifest error of assessment. Where the administration relied on false facts, for example employment it claimed was undeclared when pay slips prove the opposite, or on a rule it misread, annulment follows.

The most encouraging recent illustration for applicants is the Conseil d’État decision of 29 May 2026. A Moroccan spouse had obtained French nationality through marriage declaration, and the Prime Minister opposed it by decree for lack of assimilation. The Conseil d’État annulled the opposition, holding that nothing in the prefecture investigation report of 26 September 2022 or the follow-up interview of 13 May 2024 showed that she adopted conduct or views rejecting republican principles or deliberately kept herself apart from the national community, in Conseil d’État, 2ème – 7ème chambres réunies, 29/05/2026, 501856. The passage to remember states that Mme A… adopte un comportement ou soutient des thèses manifestant un rejet des principes essentiels de la République was not established on the evidence, so the opposition applied Article 21-4 of the Civil Code inexactly. The method matters beyond marriage cases because decree refusals for defective assimilation use the same vocabulary. The administration must prove its claim with concrete documents, not with impressions. An American whose file contains coherent proof of language, work, taxes, and civic life can therefore use this decision to demand that the judge verify each alleged defect against the actual exhibits instead of deferring to a summary.

The mirror decision every applicant should also read is the 30 November 2021 ruling cited above, Conseil d’État, 2ème chambre, 30/11/2021, 451191, where the opposition was upheld because the applicant had lived in bigamy for years. The two rulings together draw the line: the judge annuls when the administration asserts non-assimilation without evidence, and confirms when the file itself documents conduct incompatible with French public order. Position your appeal on the right side of that line. If the refusal cites insufficient language, attach a new approved certificate above the required level and request a fresh interview assessment. If it cites professional instability, attach the permanent contract, the last twelve pay slips, and the employer’s attestation, and explain the earlier gap with dated documents rather than general statements. If it cites tax debts, attach the clearance certificates and the notices for the last three years. If it cites a conviction, obtain the bulletin n°2 extract, show rehabilitation, training, or community service, and let time pass before refiling, because recent offending and citizenship do not mix.

Two practical cautions close this section. First, never let the two-month appeal period expire while negotiating informally with the prefecture. Promises made at a counter do not stop the clock. File the court action in time even while pursuing an amicable re-examination. Second, keep living the French life during the appeal: remain resident in France, keep employment, keep filing taxes, keep the language progressing, and keep every receipt. The judge examines the situation, and a stronger present file supports both annulment and, failing that, the next application. The nationality certificate, the certificat de nationalité française, and the French passport come after the decree, through the nationality registry and the consular or prefectural passport channel, and each has its own evidentiary demands, but none of them reopens the assimilation debate once the decree is signed. Win the decree stage and the rest is paperwork.

Conclusion

Naturalization by decree rewards Americans who treat it as a five-year project, not a form. Confirm eighteen years of age, secure five years of habitual residence under a valid permit with your life truly centered in France, or verify that a two-year reduction or a stage waiver applies to your studies, talents, or schooling. Bring the language to a level where you discuss abstract subjects with spontaneity and precision, learn the institutions and the charter of rights and duties, stabilize work, clear every tax debt, and keep conduct spotless. File a complete ANEF file with translated and apostilled American documents, perform at the assimilation interview, and count eighteen months from the receipt, twelve if you justify ten years of habitual residence on that date, plus a possible reasoned three-month extension. If the answer is no, read which ending you received, use an adjournment period to fix each weakness with dated proof, and challenge a refusal within two months while continuing to strengthen the file, because recent rulings show that judges annul unsupported findings of non-assimilation and confirm those grounded in the exhibits. Americans who follow this sequence give the Republic no lawful reason to doubt that they already live as French citizens and ask only for the decree that says so.

📄 Official circular