KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
City Hall Can Buy the Paris Apartment You Just Agreed to Buy: Deposit, Loan, and the Price Fight for American Buyers

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

City Hall Can Buy the Paris Apartment You Just Agreed to Buy: Deposit, Loan, and the Price Fight for American Buyers

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You found the one: a two-bedroom apartment in the 11th arrondissement, high ceilings, a fireplace that actually works, and a seller who accepted your offer. You sign the compromis de vente, the preliminary sales contract, wire the deposit to the notaire’s escrow account, and start comparing movers from New York to Paris. Then your notaire calls with a sentence no American buyer expects: the seller has filed a déclaration d’intention d’aliéner, a declaration of intent to sell, and the City of Paris now has two months to step into your shoes and buy the apartment instead of you. This is the droit de préemption urbain, the urban preemption right, and it applies to thousands of Paris transactions every year.

Preemption is not an American concept, so here is the short version. In zones covered by a local land-use plan, the city can substitute itself for the buyer at the price and conditions stated in the seller’s declaration. Your signed compromis does not stop this. It simply waits. If the city stays silent for two months, you proceed. If it preempts, your purchase dies and a sale between the seller and the city takes its place. Everything an American buyer cares about, the deposit sitting in escrow, the mortgage approval with an expiration date, the exchange rate drifting while you wait, plays out inside that two-month window and the price negotiation that can follow it.

This article explains the procedure the way it actually hits a foreign buyer: the freeze on your purchase, the protections for your money while the city decides, and your real options when the city says it wants the apartment, including when it offers less than your agreed price. French terms are explained as they appear, and every deadline below comes with the statute or decision that sets it.

I. Your Purchase Is Frozen for Two Months: How the Declaration Works and What Protects Your Money While Paris Decides

A. Why the Seller’s Declaration Comes First and Your Deed Must Wait

The mechanism starts with the seller, not with you. Any sale covered by the preemption right is subject, on pain of nullity, to a prior declaration filed by the owner with the mairie, the town hall, of the place where the property sits. That declaration must state the price and the conditions of the planned sale, or in the case of an auction, the estimate or starting price. This is article L. 213-2 of the Code de l’urbanisme, and the penalty is stated in its first line: no declaration, no valid sale. Cities create these zones by local vote wherever a land-use plan exists, under article L. 211-1 of the same code, and they use the power to pursue the public-interest development purposes listed in article L. 210-1, from housing programs to urban renewal and land reserves.

In practice, your notaire handles the filing and inserts a condition suspensive, a suspensive condition, of non-exercise of the preemption right into your compromis. The national public-service guide for selling property in a preemption zone confirms the choreography: you may sign a promise of sale with the buyer of your choice, but that contract must carry the condition that the city does not preempt, and the final acte authentique, the notarized deed of sale, cannot be signed until the city has waived its right or its time has run out (service-public.fr, sale in a preemption zone). That single clause is what keeps your compromis alive but frozen: neither side can force the closing while the city holds the file.

The city’s clock runs two months from receipt of the declaration, and silence is a decision. In the words of the statute: “Le silence du titulaire du droit de préemption pendant deux mois à compter de la réception de la déclaration mentionnée au premier alinéa vaut renonciation à l’exercice du droit de préemption.” The same article lets the city pause that clock once, with a single request for documents about the building’s condition and contents, or by asking to visit the property. The clock restarts when the documents arrive, when the owner refuses the visit, or when the visit takes place, still under article L. 213-2. So the freeze can stretch slightly past two calendar months, but it cannot be extended indefinitely by administrative silence dressed up as procedure.

Two Paris specifics matter enormously for American buyers of apartments. First, Paris operates two intensities of the right: in reinforced preemption sectors, a declaration is always required no matter what is sold, while in simple sectors, some sales are exempt, and the city publishes a parcel-by-parcel map so a buyer can check which regime covers an address (City of Paris, declarations of intent to sell). Second, the main exemption buyers hope for is narrow. Under article L. 211-4 of the Code de l’urbanisme, the simple preemption right does not apply to the sale of individual residential units that have been under condominium (copropriété) ownership for at least ten years. Many classic Paris apartments meet that description, which is genuinely good news, except that the exemption covers only the simple right. In a reinforced sector, the declaration is mandatory anyway, and Paris has placed large parts of its housing stock under reinforced coverage. Never assume the exemption applies: ask the notaire to confirm the parcel’s status with an urban-planning information notice before you treat the deal as purge-free.

One more rigidity to absorb early. If the price or the conditions change after filing, because of an error on the price, a forgotten easement, or a dispute over the agent’s commission, the safe course is a corrective filing through the notaire that restarts the two-month period: the declaration must state the price and conditions of the planned sale, and the sale is valid only as declared, on pain of nullity under article L. 213-2. An informal side letter changing the economics binds no one against the city. For an American buyer watching the dollar-euro rate and a mortgage clock, a careless price amendment that restarts the purge is an expensive mistake. And the sanction for skipping the declaration entirely is severe: according to the City of Paris, failure to file for a covered property can void the sale for five years from the signing of the notarized deed (City of Paris, declarations of intent to sell). That five-year exposure is why no Paris notaire will close without a clean purge.

B. Your Deposit and Your Ten-Day Exit During the Limbo

While the city decides, your money is governed by protections that were written for exactly this kind of waiting period. Start with the ten-day withdrawal right. Any non-professional buyer of residential property may withdraw within ten days counted from the day after the first presentation of the letter notifying the contract, as article L. 271-1 of the Code de la construction et de l’habitation provides. The Cour de cassation applied this to a late withdrawal in a decision every buyer should read: the buyer had received the notified promise on September 4 and mailed the withdrawal on September 15, and the court held the withdrawal out of time, because the ten-day period and the civil-procedure counting rule state the same principle and their effects do not add up. In the court’s words: “Les articles L. 271-1 du code de la construction et de l’habitation, selon lequel l’acquéreur non professionnel peut se rétracter dans un délai de dix jours à compter du lendemain de la première présentation de la lettre lui notifiant l’acte, et 641, alinéa 1er, du code de procédure civile, suivant lequel lorsqu’un délai est exprimé en jours, celui de l’acte, de l’événement, de la décision ou de la notification qui le fait courir ne compte pas, expriment la même règle.” And the conclusion, short and final: “Il en résulte que leurs effets ne se cumulent pas.” (Cass. Civ. 3e, December 19, 2024, No. 23-12.652). The counting rule itself is article 641, paragraph 1, of the Code de procédure civile: “Lorsqu’un délai est exprimé en jours, celui de l’acte, de l’événement, de la décision ou de la notification qui le fait courir ne compte pas.” Count carefully, because the agency or seller will.

During that withdrawal period, no money may move. Article L. 271-2 of the same code prohibits anyone from receiving any payment from the non-professional buyer, directly or indirectly, before the withdrawal period expires, with narrow statutory exceptions for new-build and similar contracts. When an agent with a financially guaranteed status handles the file, the deposit may be handed to that professional, and the statute commands the refund on withdrawal: “Si l’acquéreur exerce sa faculté de rétractation, le professionnel dépositaire des fonds les lui restitue dans un délai de vingt et un jours à compter du lendemain de la date de cette rétractation.” For an American wiring funds from abroad, the practical lesson is to send the deposit only to the notaire’s or the authorized agent’s escrow, never to the seller, and to keep the wire receipt: the twenty-one-day refund runs from the withdrawal, and a clean paper trail is what makes it enforceable.

The second shield is the mortgage condition. When the contract states that the price will be paid, even partly, with loans, the sale is automatically subject to the suspensive condition that those loans are obtained, under article L. 313-41 of the Code de la consommation, which also requires the parties to state the loan financing in the contract in the first place (article L. 313-40). Two sentences of that article decide most American buyers’ fate. First: “La durée de validité de cette condition suspensive ne peut être inférieure à un mois à compter de la date de la signature de l’acte ou, s’il s’agit d’un acte sous seing privé soumis à peine de nullité à la formalité de l’enregistrement, à compter de la date de l’enregistrement.” Second, if the condition fails: “toute somme versée d’avance par l’acquéreur à l’autre partie ou pour le compte de cette dernière est immédiatement et intégralement remboursable sans retenue ni indemnité à quelque titre que ce soit.” In plain terms, a refused mortgage kills the deal and returns every cent of the deposit, with no penalty and no negotiation. The public-service guide on loan conditions notes that parties typically allow forty-five to sixty days after the promise to secure the loan, and that the period can never be shorter than one month (service-public.fr, loan suspensive condition).

Here is where the two clocks collide for Americans. The city’s two-month purge and your mortgage window run at the same time, but a French bank’s approval has its own expiry, and a preemption decision in week seven can strand a loan approval calibrated for a closing in week eight. Negotiate the loan condition’s duration with the purge in mind rather than accepting the template: align it to cover the full declaration period plus the document-request suspension, keep the bank informed that the closing date floats on the city’s waiver, and remember that if preemption kills the sale, the failed-condition refund rule returns your deposit regardless of what the seller thinks is fair. Buyers who handle the French closing from the United States often do so through a notarized power of attorney rather than flying back for each step, a process described in detail in our guide to signing the French deed from America with a power of attorney and apostille, which also helps when the purge pushes the signing date around.

II. When Paris Says “We Are Buying It”: Your Options and the Fight Over Price

A. Preemption at Your Price, Preemption at a Lower Price, and the Judge Who Sets the Number

When the two months end, three outcomes are possible, and only the first is uneventful. The city stays silent, the waiver is acquired, and your purchase proceeds to the notarized deed on its original terms. The city preempts at exactly the price and conditions in the declaration, in which case the sale happens with the city as buyer and your compromis falls away. Or the outcome that generates all the litigation: the city wants the property but not at your price, and offers less. That third path is where American buyers need to understand the rules cold, because the seller’s response decides whether any sale happens at all and when your deposit comes home.

French law gives both sides an exit when they disagree on price, and it says so in a single article both parties quote back at each other. Article L. 213-7 of the Code de l’urbanisme provides that where there is no agreement on price, the owner who declared the intent to sell may later withdraw the offer, and symmetrically: “De même, le titulaire du droit de préemption peut renoncer en cours de procédure à l’exercice de son droit à défaut d’accord sur le prix.” If the dispute goes to the court that sets expropriation prices and that court fixes a number, the parties get one more window: for two months after the judgment becomes final, each side may accept the court-set price or walk away from the transfer altogether. The statute then warns: “Le silence des parties dans ce délai vaut acceptation du prix fixé par le juge et transfert de propriété, à l’issue de ce délai, au profit du titulaire du droit de préemption.” Silence after a court price means the city owns the property. That is the mirror image of the two-month declaration silence, and confusing the two is the most common misunderstanding foreign buyers bring to the table: silence during the declaration phase kills the preemption, while silence after the court fixes the price completes it.

The price itself, when the parties cannot agree, is set by the expropriation judge, and the statute strips the award down to the bare asset value. Article L. 213-4 states: “A défaut d’accord amiable, le prix d’acquisition est fixé par la juridiction compétente en matière d’expropriation ; ce prix est exclusif de toute indemnité accessoire, et notamment de l’indemnité de réemploi.” No accessory indemnity, and in particular no indemnité de réemploi, the resettlement supplement that normally compensates an expropriated owner for the cost of buying an equivalent property. A seller who expected the buyer’s price plus moving compensation gets the bare judicial value instead, which is exactly why sellers so often prefer to withdraw the offer rather than accept the city’s number.

A recent Paris-area decision shows the whole sequence in real life, including the part sellers find hardest to accept. The expropriation judge in Créteil had fixed the acquisition price of a co-owned apartment lot at 71,355 euros as occupied, rejecting the owners’ claim of 120,600 euros as free of occupation. On appeal, the public land body for the Paris region, the EPFIF, used the exit door the statute gives it and renounced the acquisition while the price appeal was pending. The Paris Court of Appeal simply recorded the outcome: “Donne acte de la renonciation de l’EPFIF à acquérir le bien appartenant à Monsieur [M] [P] et Madame [P] née [T]”, then drew the procedural consequence, “Constate que la procédure en fixation du prix du bien des consorts [P] est sans objet” With the buyer gone, there was nothing left to price. The court then refused every financial consolation the sellers requested for the years of limbo: “Rejette la demande des consorts [P] de condamner l’EPFIF à leur verser la somme de 16’100 euros au titre de l’indemnité pour perte de loyers”, and likewise rejected the 10,275 euros claimed as an immobilization indemnity, awarding only 3,000 euros in procedural costs on appeal (CA Paris, Pôle 4, Chambre 7, October 23, 2025, RG 24/04616, applying article L. 213-7). The reasoning quoted the statute back at the parties at length, recalling that “Aux termes de l’article L 213-7 du code de l’urbanisme à défaut d’accord sur le prix, tout propriétaire d’un bien soumis au droit de préemption, qui a manifesté son intention d’aliéner le dit bien, peut ultérieurement retirer son offre.” Three lessons for an American buyer fall out of this case. First, the preemptor itself can walk away over price, which means a preemption decision is not a guaranteed sale even for the seller. Second, the limbo years generate no compensation: neither lost rent nor immobilization damages survived. Third, the evicted private buyer is simply out of the transaction, left to recover the deposit through the failed suspensive conditions rather than through any claim against the city.

There is a final protection worth knowing for the day after a preemption. Property the city acquires this way must serve the public-interest purposes of the planning code, and if within five years the city decides to use or resell it for other purposes, it must first inform the former owners and offer them the property back on a priority basis, with the price set by the expropriation judge if they disagree, under article L. 213-11. That retrocession right belongs to the seller, not to the evicted buyer, so it does not resurrect your purchase, but it disciplines speculative preemptions and it is one more question your notaire can raise if a preemption looks opportunistic rather than program-driven.

B. A Paris-Specific Action Plan for American Buyers

None of this means Americans should avoid Paris apartments. It means buying them with the purge priced into the plan from the offer stage, the way Parisian professionals do. The checklist below follows the order in which problems actually strike.

Check the parcel’s regime before you offer, not after you sign. The City of Paris publishes which parcels sit under reinforced coverage and which under simple coverage, and its information notice tells you which applies to the address you are chasing (City of Paris, declarations of intent to sell). In reinforced sectors, expect a declaration for any deal; in simple sectors, test the ten-year condominium exception in article L. 211-4 with the notaire rather than assuming it. This single verification, done during the negotiation week, prevents the most painful surprise in the file: learning about the purge from the compromis instead of learning about it before the price.

Draft the compromis for a two-track timeline. The non-preemption condition and the mortgage condition should coexist with compatible durations: a one-month loan condition that expires before the city’s two months is a trap, because a preemption in week seven would arrive after your financing protection has lapsed. Set the loan condition to cover the full declaration period plus the possible document-request suspension, keep the forty-five to sixty day bank practice cited by the public-service guide in mind as a floor rather than a target (service-public.fr, loan suspensive condition), and require the seller to forward the city’s correspondence the day it arrives so the withdrawal and refund clocks can be computed on real dates. Remember the Cassation lesson on counting: the triggering day does not count, but the ten days do not double either, so calendar every deadline twice, once under the statute and once under the counting rule, before relying on it.

Freeze the deal terms once the declaration is filed. Any change to price or conditions calls for a corrective filing and a fresh two-month period, since the declaration must state the price and conditions of the planned sale on pain of nullity (article L. 213-2). If the diagnostics, the diagnostic de performance énergétique or the lead report, come back worse than expected during the purge, renegotiate inside the existing framework through the notaire with a formal corrective filing if the price moves, rather than with side letters that restart nothing and protect no one. And keep the financing bank in the loop: an approval letter that expires mid-purge can often be extended if the bank is warned early, while a bank that discovers the preemption from someone else may simply let the offer lapse, leaving you to restart the mortgage process from New York or California.

Plan for the worst case in writing before it happens. If the city preempts at your price, your compromis lapses and the deposit returns through the failed non-preemption condition, with the mortgage-condition refund in article L. 313-41 as the backstop: every advance sum is refunded immediately and in full, with no deduction and no indemnity of any kind. If the city offers less, do not expect to negotiate directly with the mairie over the seller’s head; the price discussion is between the seller and the city, with the expropriation judge as arbiter, and your role is to hold your position, preserve the paper trail of every sum advanced, and be ready to redeploy on the next apartment the day the waiver or the withdrawal arrives. The broader economics of a Paris purchase, notaire fees, escrow mechanics, and what each line of the closing statement pays for, are detailed in our guide to notaire closing costs when buying a house in France as an American, which pairs naturally with this article: read that guide for the money mechanics and this one for the timeline risk.

Conclusion

Paris preemption feels arbitrary the first time it hits, but it runs on written rules with written clocks. The seller declares price and conditions under article L. 213-2, and two silent months equal a waiver. Your deposit sits protected behind the ten-day withdrawal of article L. 271-1, the escrow and twenty-one-day refund of article L. 271-2, and the mortgage-condition refund of article L. 313-41. If the city wants the apartment for less than your price, the expropriation judge sets a bare value with no resettlement supplement under article L. 213-4, and either side may still walk away under article L. 213-7, as the Paris Court of Appeal confirmed when the regional land body renounced mid-appeal and the sellers recovered neither lost rent nor immobilization damages. Check the parcel’s reinforced or simple status before offering, align the loan condition with the full purge window, freeze the terms once filed, and keep the bank and the notaire on the same calendar. Handled that way, the two-month freeze becomes a known cost of buying in Paris rather than the surprise that kills the deal.

📄 Official circular