KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can an American Partner Inherit From a French PACS Partner? Will, Property, and Tax Rules

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can an American Partner Inherit From a French PACS Partner? Will, Property, and Tax Rules

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An American who lives with a French partner under a PACS can be surprised by the gap between everyday life and inheritance law. A pacte civil de solidarité, usually called a PACS, is a French registered civil partnership. It organizes a couple’s common life, property rules, and mutual support, but it does not make the surviving partner an heir automatically. If the French partner dies without a valid will, the American survivor may receive nothing from the estate, even after many years together. The result changes when the partners own property jointly, when a will gives the survivor a legacy, when children have protected inheritance rights, and when French and United States tax rules overlap.

This guide answers the practical question: can an American partner inherit from a French PACS partner? It separates ownership from succession, explains why a separate will matters, and shows how French inheritance-tax exemption rules interact with the France–U.S. estate and gift tax convention. It also addresses a French home, a U.S. will, the European succession rules, and the documents a surviving partner should gather. The PACS itself is not an immigration procedure; visa and residence questions belong to a different analysis. The focus here is a settled-life problem: protecting the survivor, preserving the home, and avoiding a tax or notarial surprise after death.

I. Can an American partner inherit from a French PACS partner after death?

A. Does a PACS make the American partner an automatic heir?

The short answer is no. French law defines a PACS as a contract, not as a marriage. Article 515-1 of the French Civil Code states: “Un pacte civil de solidarité est un contrat conclu par deux personnes physiques majeures, de sexe différent ou de même sexe, pour organiser leur vie commune.” In English, the PACS is a legal contract between two adults to organize their common life. The nationality of either partner does not turn the PACS into a marriage or create a reserved share in the other partner’s estate.

The registration step matters. Under Article 515-3, the partners make a joint declaration and the PACS is registered by the competent civil-status officer, notary, or, in the relevant international situation, a French diplomatic or consular authority. That registration proves that the partnership exists. It is not a will. A certificate showing that the American partner is the surviving partner therefore proves status, but it does not by itself transfer the deceased partner’s apartment, bank account, or investments.

The official French public-service explanation is unusually direct: “En l’absence de testament, vous ne pouvez pas hériter l’un de l’autre.” The same page explains that, for inheritance, PACS partners are treated as strangers to one another when no will exists. See Service-Public.fr, “Décès du partenaire de Pacs : quelles sont les règles de succession ?” That rule applies even when the survivor is an American citizen, even when the couple lived in France, and even when the survivor paid household expenses for years.

That result should be distinguished from the partners’ ownership during their lives. Under Article 515-4 of the Civil Code, PACS partners commit to a common life, material assistance, and mutual assistance. They may also be jointly liable for certain ordinary household debts. Those duties protect the functioning of the household; they are not a succession mechanism. A partner’s contribution to rent, repairs, utilities, or a mortgage does not automatically create ownership of the other partner’s separate asset.

Property ownership depends on the PACS regime and the deed or account records. Under Article 515-5, each partner generally keeps the administration, enjoyment, and free disposition of property that belongs exclusively to that partner. If exclusive ownership cannot be proved for an asset acquired during the relationship, the law can treat it as held in equal shares. Under Article 515-5-1, partners may choose an indivision regime, meaning co-ownership, for qualifying assets acquired after registration; the law then generally treats each partner as owning one-half, regardless of unequal financial contributions.

This creates two different questions after death. First, what portion already belonged to the American survivor? That portion is recovered as the survivor’s own property and is not inherited. Second, what happens to the deceased partner’s portion? That portion enters the estate and passes to heirs or beneficiaries under a will. For example, if a French apartment is registered in both names in equal shares, the survivor normally keeps the survivor’s half. The deceased partner’s half may pass to children, parents, or other heirs unless a valid will gives it to the surviving partner within the legal limits.

The contrast with marriage is also important. French marriage creates a statutory inheritance position for the surviving spouse, subject to the family circumstances and matrimonial regime. The rules for a spouse with children are set out in Article 757 of the Civil Code. A PACS partner does not receive the same default share. A PACS can offer practical protection, including housing protection, but it is not a substitute for a succession plan.

Housing protection should not be confused with ownership. Article 515-6 of the Civil Code applies part of the surviving-spouse housing protection to a surviving PACS partner. It refers to the first two paragraphs of Article 763, which generally provides a one-year free enjoyment of the principal residence after death in the circumstances described by the statute. This can prevent an immediate loss of the home, but it does not make the survivor the owner. If the home belonged only to the deceased, the survivor may have a temporary right to occupy it while the estate is handled, followed by a possible sale, division, or transfer to the heirs.

Finally, the PACS ends on death. Article 515-7 sets out the dissolution events and their effective dates. If the partners signed or registered a partnership outside France, Article 515-7-1 addresses the conditions and effects of a registered partnership created under another state’s law. That private-international-law rule helps identify the legal status of the partnership; it still does not replace a will or settle the tax analysis.

The Court of Cassation applied the no-automatic-inheritance principle in a case involving a long concubinage relationship and a PACS. In its decision of June 1, 2016, no. 15-16.486, the première chambre civile referred to the fact that the relationship and PACS “n’emportent aucun droit pour le partenaire dans la succession du défunt.” The decision is available on Légifrance, Cass. 1re civ., June 1, 2016, no. 15-16.486. For an American couple, the practical lesson is simple: relationship history is evidence of a life together, not a replacement for a testamentary gift.

B. What must the will say, and what happens to children and French property?

A separate, valid will for each partner is the central protection. A will should identify the partner accurately, state what is being left to that partner, and be coordinated with the couple’s property deeds, bank accounts, retirement arrangements, life-insurance nominations, and any existing U.S. estate documents. A vague statement such as “everything to my partner” can create interpretation issues if the document does not identify the PACS, the assets, the governing law, or the beneficiaries who take if the partner dies first.

French formalities matter even when the testator is American. A handwritten French testament olographe, meaning a holographic will, must be written entirely by the testator, dated, and signed. Article 970 of the Civil Code states: “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur.” A typed document printed and signed at the bottom may fail as a French holographic will even if it would look familiar in the United States. A notarial will or another permitted form may be preferable when the estate includes French real estate or a child who may later challenge the instrument.

Each partner should sign their own will. A document signed jointly by both PACS partners can look efficient but may be invalid under French succession law. In its decision of July 4, 2018, no. 17-22.934, the First Civil Chamber held that a joint document could not be treated as a will and “ne peut valoir testament.” See Légifrance, Cass. 1re civ., July 4, 2018, no. 17-22.934. The reason is practical as well as formal: a testament must be revocable by its author, while a joint instrument can prevent one partner from changing their own succession plan independently.

The will can give the survivor a universal legacy, a legacy of a fraction of the estate, or a particular legacy of a specified asset or sum. Article 1002 of the Civil Code distinguishes universal, universal-by-fraction, and particular testamentary dispositions. In an American-facing will, those French categories should be translated into clear instructions. “I leave my entire estate” is different from “I leave my French home” or “I leave one-half of my estate after payment of debts.” The notary handling the succession must be able to implement the gift without guessing which language controls.

Children create a limit. French law protects a child’s réserve héréditaire, or protected share of the estate, when the statutory conditions are met. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines the protected share and the quotité disponible, meaning the portion that the deceased could freely give away. A child is generally entitled to one-half of the estate when there is one child, two-thirds when there are two children, and three-quarters when there are three or more children. The remaining portion is the disposable portion that can be left to the PACS partner. The exact calculation depends on the family, gifts made during life, assets located in different countries, and the law applicable to the succession.

The American partner is not a French forced heir merely because the partner is the surviving PACS partner. That means a will can protect the partner, but children may still bring a claim if the testamentary gifts exceed the disposable portion under the law ultimately applied. A U.S. will cannot be assumed to override French protected-share rules for French assets. Conversely, a French will should not be drafted without checking whether the deceased was a U.S. citizen, domiciled in a U.S. state, or had a U.S. estate plan that disposes of retirement accounts, trusts, or jointly held assets.

Property documents determine what the will can actually transfer. A will can transfer only what belonged to the deceased at death. If a French house was bought solely in the deceased partner’s name, the will may give that house to the American survivor, subject to the children’s protected share and any mortgage. If the house was jointly acquired, the survivor’s own share is outside the estate and only the deceased’s share is governed by succession. If the couple chose the PACS indivision regime, the notary must check the purchase deed, the PACS agreement, the acquisition date, financing evidence, and any later amendment before calculating the estate.

The same distinction applies to bank accounts and securities. A joint account may create a presumption or contractual access during life, but access to funds after death does not automatically prove that the survivor owns all of the balance. The notary may need statements showing contributions, the account agreement, the date of deposits, and the source of funds. A power of attorney also ends at death. The surviving partner should not continue to use the deceased’s card or online credentials as if the account were still a normal joint household account.

European succession law can help with the question of which country’s succession law applies, but it does not erase every conflict. The European Union Succession Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 generally addresses jurisdiction and the law applicable to cross-border successions. It can allow a person, within the regulation’s conditions, to choose the law of their nationality. The regulation does not govern tax, the status of natural persons, or the property consequences of a marriage or registered partnership. The will therefore needs two separate reviews: one for succession law and one for property and tax law.

Where an American partner is intended to inherit a French home, the safest file contains the PACS certificate, the PACS agreement and amendments, both passports and civil-status records, the deed of acquisition, mortgage statements, a list of children and prior gifts, every will, and a schedule of U.S. assets. The survivor should also preserve proof of the deceased’s last residence and domicile. Those documents enable the French notary to establish the estate and enable U.S. advisers to decide whether a federal or state filing is required.

A final point concerns witnesses and execution. In its decision of February 28, 2018, no. 17-10.876, the First Civil Chamber held that being a PACS partner did not by itself prevent one partner from serving as a witness to an authentic will naming the other partner as legatee. The Court described the status as “n’emporte pas incapacité à être témoin.” See Légifrance, Cass. 1re civ., February 28, 2018, no. 17-10.876. That decision does not make every signature valid; it illustrates why the exact form of the will and the circumstances of signing should be checked rather than inferred from the couple’s status.

II. How do French inheritance taxes and the France–U.S. treaty apply?

A. Is the American PACS partner exempt from French inheritance tax?

Once a valid will gives property to the surviving PACS partner, French domestic law generally provides a powerful benefit: the partner is exempt from French inheritance tax on that death transfer. Article 796-0 bis of the French Tax Code states: “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” In plain English, the surviving spouse and the surviving PACS partner are exempt from death-transfer duties. The exemption is linked to the legal status of the survivor at the opening of the succession, not to the survivor’s nationality.

This does not mean that every transfer between the couple is tax-free. The exemption concerns a transfer on death to the surviving PACS partner. A lifetime gift, a transfer made before the PACS is validly registered, a transfer to another beneficiary, or a transfer involving an invalid or dissolved partnership requires a different calculation. The estate file should prove the PACS registration and show that it was still in force at the date of death. A couple should not rely on the label used in an American document if the French civil-status records say something different.

French lifetime gifts have their own rule. Article 790 F of the French Tax Code provides an allowance of €80,724 for a qualifying gift to a PACS partner, subject to the conditions and clawback rule in the statute. That is different from the death exemption. If the couple transfers a French house, a share in a company, or cash during life, the notary must identify the gift, calculate the taxable base, consider prior gifts, and check whether the PACS remains in force under the statutory period. The survivor should not assume that a gift is better than a testamentary transfer simply because it happens earlier.

The general rates make the PACS distinction commercially significant. Article 777 of the French Tax Code contains the tables for gratuitous transfers, including transfers between spouses and PACS partners and transfers between unrelated persons. A person who is not legally recognized as a spouse or PACS partner can fall into the 60 percent rate for transfers between unrelated persons. That rate is not the rule for a valid death transfer to the surviving PACS partner because Article 796-0 bis supplies the exemption; it is a warning about the consequence of an invalid will, an unregistered relationship, a beneficiary who is not the partner, or a lifetime transaction that does not qualify for the relevant allowance.

The ordinary small allowance should not be mistaken for a substitute for the PACS exemption. Article 788 of the French Tax Code provides a €1,594 allowance in the absence of another applicable allowance, subject to the statute. That amount is nowhere near the value of a French home. The legal status and the will are what prevent an American survivor from being treated as an unrelated beneficiary for the death transfer.

French tax jurisdiction is separate from the rate or exemption. Article 750 ter of the French Tax Code can bring French-situs assets into the French inheritance-tax base when the deceased was not French tax resident, and it can also apply to a broader estate in other residence situations. French real estate is the clearest example: a house in France is not outside French succession-tax analysis merely because the beneficiary is American or because the couple kept a U.S. mailing address.

Tax exemption also does not eliminate filing, valuation, or notarial work. The notary must determine the estate, value assets at the relevant date, identify debts, confirm the beneficiary’s status, and complete the required French succession documents. The survivor may still need to provide a U.S. taxpayer identification number, a U.S. address, banking information, and documents showing the value and ownership of U.S. assets. A French inheritance-tax return may be required even where the amount of French tax is zero, depending on the estate and the filing obligation.

A useful example shows the difference. Assume the deceased French partner owned a €600,000 house alone and leaves it by a valid will to the American PACS partner. The will determines whether the transfer can occur, subject to children’s protected shares. Article 796-0 bis addresses the French death-transfer duty and generally makes the transfer exempt. The house still has to be valued and reported, the mortgage and other liabilities still have to be checked, and the transfer still has potential U.S. estate-tax and reporting consequences. If instead the couple was only engaged, or the PACS had never been registered, the survivor could face a radically different succession and tax result.

Before a will is signed, the couple should ask four questions: Is the PACS properly registered and still valid? Which assets are owned by each partner, and in what shares? Are there children, prior gifts, or U.S. trusts that limit the gift? Which assets should pass by will, by beneficiary designation, or by joint ownership? A French notary can answer the French succession and property questions; a U.S. tax adviser must separately test the federal and state consequences.

B. How should the estate coordinate France, the United States, and the treaty?

The France–U.S. convention on estates, inheritances, and gifts coordinates the two countries’ taxing claims; it does not turn a PACS into a marriage and it does not write a will. The official French tax administration publishes the international conventions index and the consolidated France–United States convention on estates and gifts. The convention addresses U.S. federal gift and estate taxes and French succession and gift duties, as stated in Article 2. It is applied by reference to residence, domicile, citizenship, asset location, and the internal law of each country.

Article 5 of the convention gives French real estate a clear starting point. It says: “Les biens immobiliers sont imposables par un Etat contractant si ces biens sont situés dans cet Etat.” A French house can therefore be taxable in France even if the deceased lived in the United States or the survivor is a U.S. citizen. The convention also contains rules for business property, bankable assets, life insurance, retirement-related rights, and other categories. The classification must be made asset by asset rather than by using the couple’s nationality as a shortcut.

The convention’s double-tax relief mechanism is equally important. Article 12 begins: “A moins que la présente Convention n’en dispose autrement, chaque Etat contractant perçoit son impôt et accorde les exonérations, abattements, crédits et autres déductions, conformément à sa législation.” In practical terms, each country starts with its own tax rules, then the convention may require an exemption, a credit, or another adjustment. The French PACS exemption comes from French domestic law, while the treaty can determine how a French tax and a U.S. federal estate tax interact. The treaty is not a promise that the same asset is taxed only once without a filing.

Article 13 sets time limits for a treaty-based credit or refund. Its rule compares the applicable domestic deadline with a period tied to the date of death or gift and, in the circumstances stated in the convention, a period after the definitive determination and payment of the tax. Article 14 allows a taxpayer who believes that the two countries’ measures create taxation inconsistent with the convention to submit the matter to a competent authority for a mutual agreement procedure. Those provisions are remedies and coordination tools; they are not a reason to postpone the first French notarial declaration or a U.S. filing.

An American survivor should separate three questions. First, is the survivor the legal beneficiary under a valid will and is the PACS exemption available in France? Second, does the United States impose federal estate tax because of the deceased’s U.S. citizenship, domicile, or U.S.-situs assets, or because the survivor receives property under a U.S. estate plan? Third, are there state-level consequences, income-tax basis issues, foreign-account reports, or information returns that the estate must address? The answer can differ when the deceased was a U.S. citizen living in France, a French citizen living in a U.S. state, or a dual national.

The survivor should not treat a French notarial certificate as a complete U.S. tax file. The U.S. adviser may need the death certificate, the French acte de notoriété—a notarial deed identifying the heirs and beneficiaries—the will, appraisals, the French succession declaration, proof of French tax paid or exempted, and the closing statements for real estate. For U.S. retirement accounts, life insurance, trusts, and jointly held accounts, the beneficiary designation and account agreement may control differently from the French will. A French notary and a U.S. adviser need to exchange the same asset schedule.

The treaty’s marital-deduction language also requires care. A PACS partner benefits from the French domestic exemption described above, but a treaty provision referring to a spouse, marital property, or a U.S. qualified domestic trust should not be assumed to treat every PACS arrangement as a U.S. marriage. The U.S. tax classification of a French PACS can depend on federal definitions and the specific asset. The couple should ask the adviser to state in writing whether the PACS is being treated as a marriage, a registered partnership, or another relationship for each U.S. tax purpose. A conclusion for French inheritance tax cannot simply be copied into Form 706, Form 706-NA, a state return, or an information return.

For a French home, the working sequence after death is usually as follows:

  1. Secure the property, bank accounts, insurance policies, and original estate documents without moving or distributing estate assets informally.
  2. Give the French notary the PACS evidence, both partners’ civil-status records, the will, the deed, mortgage records, and a complete family tree.
  3. Ask the notary to separate the survivor’s own ownership from the deceased’s estate share before anyone calculates inheritance tax.
  4. Obtain a valuation of the French real estate and the relevant date-of-death values of securities, accounts, insurance, and business interests.
  5. Send the French estate file, including the French tax result, to a U.S. estate-tax adviser before signing a final allocation or filing a U.S. return.
  6. Compare any French tax paid, exemption, or refund with the treaty credit rules and with the U.S. filing deadlines; keep proof of every position.

This process also protects against an avoidable evidence problem. If the survivor is abroad, the French notary may need a power of attorney, identity certification, certified civil-status documents, and an explanation of the survivor’s U.S. address and tax residence. A power of attorney authorizes representation; it does not create inheritance rights. The survivor should also check whether the deceased had a separate French will registered with the central wills database, an American will, a revocable trust, a beneficiary designation, or a prior gift that changes the estate.

Conflicts are possible even when both countries’ advisers act carefully. A French house may be exempt from French death-transfer duties for the PACS partner but still be included in a U.S. federal estate-tax calculation. A U.S. asset may be part of the U.S. estate but affect the French protected-share calculation depending on the law applicable to the succession. A treaty credit may require a formal claim after the amount of tax is definitive. The convention itself says that the authorities can consult through the mutual agreement procedure when taxation does not conform to the treaty. The right response is a coordinated file with a dated asset schedule, not an assumption that one country’s closing statement answers all questions.

For an American partner planning before death, the most valuable documents are usually a separate will for each partner, a current PACS certificate and agreement, a deed review for every French property, updated beneficiary designations, a U.S. asset and account inventory, and written instructions about the intended use or sale of the home. The will should identify the survivor and provide a fallback beneficiary if the survivor dies first. It should also be checked after a move between France and the United States, a marriage, a PACS amendment, a divorce, the birth of a child, a major gift, or a property purchase.

Conclusion

An American PACS partner can inherit from a French partner, but the PACS alone does not do it. Without a valid will, the survivor is not an automatic heir. With a properly executed and coordinated will, the survivor can receive a universal, fractional, or particular legacy, subject to the protected share of children and the ownership rights of co-owners. A French principal residence may receive temporary housing protection, but temporary occupation is not the same as ownership.

The tax result is often more favorable than the succession result: a valid transfer at death to the surviving PACS partner is generally exempt from French inheritance duty under Article 796-0 bis. That exemption does not remove the need to prove the PACS, value the estate, file where required, or test U.S. federal and state consequences. The France–U.S. convention can coordinate double taxation through asset-location rules, credits, deadlines, and competent-authority procedures, but it does not replace the will or the cross-border estate file.

The practical first step is a document review: PACS registration, property deeds, the couple’s separate wills, children and prior gifts, U.S. accounts, and the last tax residence of the deceased. If any of those points is unclear, resolve it while both partners can sign and explain the plan.

📄 Official circular