KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
You Own a Second Home in France as an American: Annual French Taxes, What America Does With the Bill, and How to Challenge It

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

You Own a Second Home in France as an American: Annual French Taxes, What America Does With the Bill, and How to Challenge It

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought the stone house in the Dordogne, or the two-bedroom in Paris you use three weeks a year and rent out the rest of the time. The purchase is behind you, the notaire has been paid, and you assume the tax story is over until you sell. It is not. Every year, France sends owners of second homes a stack of bills that has nothing to do with income: a property tax on the building itself, a residence tax that still exists for second homes even though it was abolished for main homes, possibly a surcharge of up to sixty percent voted by the town council, and, once your French real estate passes a threshold, an annual wealth tax. As an American, you also have to decide what each of those French payments does on your United States return, because the answer is not the same for every tax, and getting it wrong means paying twice or claiming a credit the Internal Revenue Service will disallow. This article walks through the three French bills in the order you meet them, explains what survives the trip across the Atlantic and what does not, and gives you the exact deadlines and remedies to challenge a wrong assessment from the United States, with the statutes and court decisions that prove each point.

I. I Own a Second Home in France and Barely Live There: What French Taxes Hit Me Every Year?

A. Do I Pay the Taxe Fonciere and the Taxe d’Habitation Even If I Only Visit Two Weeks a Year?

Yes, and the reason sits in the first sentence of the property tax system. Article 1380 of the French General Tax Code provides, word for word: “La taxe foncière est établie annuellement sur les propriétés bâties sises en France à l’exception de celles qui en sont expressément exonérées par les dispositions du présent code.” In plain English, the taxe foncière, the French property tax on buildings, is assessed every year on every built property located in France, unless the Code expressly exempts it. Your physical presence is irrelevant. What matters is ownership, because article 1400 of the same Code states that “toute propriété, bâtie ou non bâtie, doit être imposée au nom du propriétaire actuel”, meaning every property must be taxed in the name of its current owner. If you bought the house, the bill comes to you, for the full year, even if you closed in November and spent one Christmas there.

The second rule Americans miss is the snapshot date. Article 1415 of the General Tax Code states: “La taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties, la taxe foncière sur les propriétés non bâties et la taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires sont établies pour l’année entière d’après les faits existants au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition.” The taxes are set for the entire year based on the facts as they stand on January 1. Sell on January 5 and you still owe the whole year’s taxe foncière. Buy on January 2 and the seller owes it, with only a private prorated reimbursement through the notaire’s closing statement if your purchase contract provides one. Nothing in the statute prorates by nights spent in the house.

The taxe d’habitation, the residence tax, is where Americans get the nastiest surprise, because it was abolished for main homes and everyone back in Ohio tells you it no longer exists. It still exists for second homes. Article 1407 of the General Tax Code says, word for word: “La taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires est due pour tous les locaux meublés conformément à leur destination d’habitation autre qu’à titre principal, y compris lorsqu’ils sont imposables à la cotisation foncière des entreprises.” Any furnished unit used as a dwelling for something other than a main home is caught, and the official service-public.fr page on the taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires confirms the test is whether you keep permanent private disposition of the place, as an owner, a yearly tenant, or even a gratuitous occupant. If the furniture is yours and you can walk in whenever your flight lands, you are liable.

Renting the house out for part of the year does not automatically save you. The Conseil d’Etat settled this for seasonal rentals in a decision American owners should read closely. In Conseil d’Etat, 8th chamber, December 23, 2024, No. 492174, owners of three furnished tourist cottages argued that heavy short-term rental occupancy meant they had not kept personal use of two of the cottages. The court restated the governing principle word for word: “lorsqu’un logement meublé fait l’objet de locations saisonnières ou de courte durée, le propriétaire du bien est redevable de la taxe d’habitation dès lors qu’au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition, il peut être regardé comme entendant en conserver la disposition ou la jouissance une partie de l’année.” When a furnished unit is subject to seasonal or short rentals, the owner owes the tax as soon as, on January 1, he can be regarded as intending to keep its disposition or enjoyment for part of the year. The court added that high occupancy rates, and the fact that owners accept or refuse bookings at will through the year, do not defeat that finding. The result followed in the operative part: “Le jugement du 29 décembre 2023 du tribunal administratif de Rennes est annulé”, and “Les conclusions de la demande présentée par M. et Mme A… tendant à la décharge des cotisations de taxe d’habitation à laquelle ils ont été assujettis au titre de l’année 2022 sont rejetées.” The discharge was reversed and the tax stood. For an American who Airbnbs a Paris apartment eleven months a year and keeps it one month, the message is blunt: keeping the keys is keeping the tax.

On top of the base residence tax, many towns vote a surcharge that stings. Article 1407 ter of the General Tax Code provides that “le conseil municipal peut, par une délibération prise dans les conditions prévues à l’article 1639 A bis, majorer d’un pourcentage compris entre 5 % et 60 % la part lui revenant de la cotisation de taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires due au titre des logements meublés.” In areas with a marked housing imbalance, the municipal council may increase its share of the second-home residence tax by five to sixty percent. Owners in mountain resorts challenged the decree that widened the list of qualifying municipalities, and the Conseil d’Etat dismissed them outright: in Conseil d’Etat, December 21, 2023, No. 488601, the operative part reads “La requête de la Fédération des associations de résidents des stations de montagne et autres est rejetée.” The extension of the surcharge zone survived, so an American chalet owner cannot count on the surcharge map shrinking. Only three narrow statutory situations earn a rebate of the surcharge on claim, essentially people forced by their job to live away from the main home, people moved into long-term care, and people prevented by a cause beyond their control from using the unit as a main home, and each requires a formal claim, not an automatic credit.

Finally, France makes you tell it how you use the place. Article 1418 of the General Tax Code states: “les propriétaires de locaux affectés à l’habitation sont tenus de déclarer à l’administration fiscale, avant le 1er juillet de chaque année, les informations relatives à la nature de l’occupation de ces locaux, s’ils en réservent la jouissance, ou s’ils sont occupés par des tiers.” Owners of residential premises must declare to the tax administration, before July 1 each year, how each unit is occupied, whether they keep its use or a third party occupies it. The declaration runs through the “Gérer mes biens immobiliers” section of your impots.gouv.fr personal account, and owners with no change since the last filing are dispensed from re-filing. Miss it after a change, a switch from vacant to second home, a new tenant, a unit you started keeping for yourself, and the administration taxes on stale data, which is how most wrong bills start. File it every June from America; it takes minutes and prevents most disputes described in part II below.

B. When Does My French House Trigger the IFI Wealth Tax as an American?

The impot sur la fortune immobiliere, universally shortened to IFI, is France’s annual tax on real estate wealth. It replaced the old ISF in 2018 and taxes only real estate, not bank accounts or stock portfolios. Article 964 of the General Tax Code creates it in one sentence, quoted word for word: “Il est institué un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers désigné sous le nom d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière.” Taxpayers fall in scope, the same article continues, “lorsque la valeur de leurs actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est supérieure à 1 300 000 €”, when the value of their qualifying assets exceeds 1,300,000 euros. For an American who does not have his tax domicile in France, the same article limits the reach to French assets: nonresidents are taxable on their French-situs real estate rights and on shares representing French real estate. And like the housing taxes, the test is frozen in winter: “Les conditions d’assujettissement sont appréciées au 1er janvier de chaque année.” If your Paris apartment plus your share of the family SCI passes the threshold on New Year’s Day, the year is taxable.

What counts is broader than the deed in your name. Article 965 of the General Tax Code builds the base from “la valeur nette au 1er janvier de l’année” of all your real estate rights, plus shares in companies and entities to the extent of the fraction of their value representing real estate held directly or indirectly. An American holding a French apartment through an American LLC, a French SCI, or shares in a property company cannot hide behind the entity: the look-through rule pulls the French bricks back into the base. The official service-public.fr page on who and what the IFI covers restates the same perimeter for non-specialists, and the detailed service-public.fr page on IFI declaration and payment walks through the filing mechanics.

Valuation is where American owners lose money twice, first by guessing high, then by missing the one discount they do not get. Article 973 of the General Tax Code sets the method, quoted word for word: “La valeur des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est déterminée suivant les règles en vigueur en matière de droits de mutation par décès.” Assets are valued under the same rules as for death duties, meaning fair market value, the price the property would fetch on the open market on January 1, supported by comparable sales, not by the purchase price you paid in 2019 or by an automated estimate. Then comes the sentence that costs second-home owners thirty percent: “un abattement de 30 % est effectué sur la valeur vénale réelle de l’immeuble lorsque celui-ci est occupé à titre de résidence principale par son propriétaire.” The thirty percent discount on fair market value applies only when the building is occupied as the owner’s main home. Your Dordogne second home gets no discount. Neither does the Paris pied-a-terre you lend to your children. Value each French property at one hundred percent of its January 1 market value, add the fractions held through companies, subtract qualifying debts, and compare the net total to 1,300,000 euros. The service-public.fr page on computing the IFI shows the progressive rate bands that apply once the threshold is crossed.

Declaring is part of the same return Americans already file. Article 982 of the General Tax Code directs taxpayers to enter the gross and net taxable values of the article 965 assets on the yearly income return, with supporting schedules. In other words, taxpayers report gross and net taxable values on the annual income return, with supporting schedules. For an American nonresident, that means the French income return carries the IFI annexes even in a year with no French rental income, and the valuation you write there binds you: undervalue aggressively and you face reassessment with penalties and interest; overvalue carelessly and you donate money to the Tresor every year until you correct it. Keep an appraisal file each January, comparable sales, agency estimates, notaire price databases, because the burden of proving your number will fall on you if the administration disagrees.

Two American-specific traps deserve emphasis. First, couples file jointly for IFI, married, PACSed, or in notorious cohabitation, so two American spouses who each think “my half is under the threshold” are taxed on the combined household real estate. Second, minor children’s real estate folds into the parents’ base when the parents have legal administration of the child’s property, which matters for Americans who put a French apartment in a child’s name for succession planning and discover the gift did not move the asset out of the IFI. Both rules sit in articles 964 and 965, and both surprise families who planned with United States gift concepts that France does not recognize.

II. Can I Credit These French Taxes in America and How Do I Challenge a Wrong Bill?

A. Will the IRS Give Me a Foreign Tax Credit for Taxe Fonciere, Taxe d’Habitation, or IFI?

Here is the sentence that decides the entire United States side of the problem. The Internal Revenue Service, in Topic No. 856 on the foreign tax credit, lists four tests a foreign levy must meet to qualify, and the fourth is categorical: the levy must be an income tax or a tax standing in for one. The same page explains the credit exists to soften double taxation when the same foreign-source income is taxed on both sides. The taxe fonciere is not an income tax. The taxe d’habitation sur les residences secondaires is not an income tax. The IFI is a wealth tax, not an income tax. None of the three annual holding bills described in part I passes the fourth test, so none of them generates a foreign tax credit on Form 1116. Americans who dump every French payment into the credit column invite the exact disallowance the IRS rules describe. The longer technical discussion in IRS Publication 514 on the foreign tax credit builds the same wall in finer detail.

That does not mean the money vanishes for United States purposes. Foreign real property taxes generally travel the deduction route instead: as itemized deductions on Schedule A, within the state and local tax limits Congress sets and changes. The deduction is worth less than a credit, dollar for dollar, and it helps only if you itemize, but it is the correct basket for the taxe fonciere on a personally used second home. Rental years add a second layer: French rental income from the house must be reported in both countries, with the treaty deciding which country taxes what and how double taxation is relieved for that income category. The mechanism is entirely different from the holding taxes, so keep two folders, one for the annual ownership bills that only deduct, and one for the rental income that flows through the treaty relief. Americans who mix the two, crediting fonciere against United States tax on rents, build a return that fails on both halves.

The France-United States treaty confirms the boundary rather than erasing it. The treaty’s official scope, summarized on the French administration’s BOFiP page presenting the France-United States tax convention, covers income taxes on each side, naming French income tax, corporation tax, payroll tax, and the former solidarity wealth tax among the covered French levies, with an extension clause for later identical or similar taxes. The consolidated treaty text itself is published by the French tax administration as a PDF of the Franco-American convention on income and fortune taxes. Read it as written: it organizes relief for income, and its fortune-tax history runs through the old ISF, not through local housing taxes. No treaty article converts a taxe d’habitation bill into a creditable income tax. Where the treaty does work, on French-source rental income and on the pensions and gains covered by our companion guides, it works through the standard credit and exemption-with-progression mechanics, which is why the rental folder and the ownership folder must never merge.

Two related United States filings ride alongside the house and deserve one line each because the penalties dwarf the taxes. If the French rent lands in a French bank account, the account itself may trigger FBAR and Form 8938 reporting, a subject treated in depth in our guide to FBAR, Form 8938, and French Form 3916 for Americans with French accounts. And if the second home is one piece of a move toward full retirement in France, the health coverage, pension taxation, and estate questions interact with everything above, as mapped in our pillar guide to retiring in France as an American. Neither filing changes the credit analysis, but both determine whether the house costs you paperwork penalties on top of correct tax.

B. How Do I Challenge a French Property Tax Bill From America Before the Deadline?

Most wrong bills American owners receive come from three banal causes: the July occupancy declaration was never updated, so a sold or newly rented unit is taxed as your second home; the town applied the surcharge to a unit that qualifies for one of the three statutory rebates; or the IFI valuation froze an old purchase price instead of the January 1 market value. The fix starts the same way every time, with a reclamation, a formal claim filed with the tax administration, and the deadline depends on which tax you attack. For the two local taxes, the taxe fonciere and the taxe d’habitation, article R*196-2 of the Book of Tax Procedures sets the limit word for word: “les réclamations relatives aux impôts directs locaux et aux taxes annexes doivent être présentées à l’administration des impôts au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle, selon le cas : a) De la mise en recouvrement du rôle, de la notification d’un avis de mise en recouvrement ou de l’émission d’un titre de perception”. A 2026 fonciere or habitation bill must therefore be challenged by December 31, 2027. For the IFI, which is a national tax rather than a local one, the longer general rule applies: article R*196-1 of the Book of Tax Procedures requires claims “au plus tard le 31 décembre de la deuxième année suivant celle” of the collection or payment event. A 2026 IFI charge can be challenged through December 31, 2028. Mark both dates the day the avis arrives in your impots.gouv.fr inbox, because a late claim is inadmissible no matter how right it is on the merits, and no judge can reopen it.

File the claim from America through your personal account on impots.gouv.fr, in the secure messaging section for the tax concerned, attaching everything that proves the January 1 snapshot was wrong: the closing deed if you had already sold, the yearly lease if a tenant occupied the unit on January 1, the employer’s transfer letter if you seek the job-related surcharge rebate, the comparable sales if you dispute an IFI valuation. Write the claim in French, one tax and one year per claim, stating the amount challenged and the legal basis in a single page. The administration answers with a full or partial admission, called degrevement, or a rejection. Silence has meaning too, and it leads to the second stage.

If the administration rejects your claim or leaves it unanswered, the dispute moves to the administrative court, and a second deadline takes over. Article R421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice provides: “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée.” The court can only be seized by an appeal against a decision, within two months of that decision’s notification or publication, and where the claim seeks payment of money it is admissible only after the administration has decided on a prior demand. In practice this means two months from the express rejection, with the parallel rule that prolonged silence becomes an implied rejection that opens the same court route. An American owner litigates without flying over: the tribunal administratif accepts filings and exhibits electronically, hearings can be handled through a French avocat, and the evidentiary core stays the same January 1 photographs of the case, leases, deeds, occupancy records, valuation comparables. The decisions cited in part I show courts enforcing these texts without sentiment, against owners as in the 2024 seasonal-rental ruling, and against the administration when its assessment misses the statutory conditions, so a well-documented file is worth building even from six thousand miles away.

One practical order of operations closes the loop. Each autumn, when the fonciere avis appears, compare the taxed owner, the property description, and any surcharge line against your June occupancy declaration and correct the declaration first if it caused the error. Each spring, rebuild the IFI file with fresh January comparables before signing the return. And each time you receive any avis, calendar the December 31 deadline of the following year, or the second following year for IFI, the same evening. The French property tax system rewards owners who contest early on paper and punishes owners who discover the deadline after it passes.

Conclusion

An American second home in France carries three recurring French charges and no American shortcut around them. The taxe fonciere falls on the owner as of January 1 for the whole year. The taxe d’habitation sur les residences secondaires falls on whoever keeps disposition of a furnished place, even one rented out most of the year, with a municipal surcharge of up to sixty percent in tight housing zones. The IFI reaches worldwide French real estate once the household’s net French property passes 1,300,000 euros on January 1, valued at full market value with no main-home discount. Across the Atlantic, the foreign tax credit does not absorb these bills because they are not income taxes, while the treaty organizes relief for the rental income the house may produce. The system is demanding but legible: declare occupancy before July 1, value honestly each January, challenge local taxes by December 31 of the next year and the IFI a year later, and take a rejection to the administrative court within two months. Do that, and the French second home stays what you bought it for, a place to land, not a file that grows.

📄 Official circular