KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Live in America and Just Got a French Property Tax Bill: Taxe Fonciere, Second-Home Taxe d’Habitation, the 60% Surcharge, and How to Pay or Fight It From the US

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Live in America and Just Got a French Property Tax Bill: Taxe Fonciere, Second-Home Taxe d’Habitation, the 60% Surcharge, and How to Pay or Fight It From the US

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Every autumn, thousands of Americans who own a vacation apartment in Paris, a stone house in Provence, or a flat near the kids studying abroad open their mailbox, or their online tax account, and find an envelope from the French tax administration they did not expect. It is September or October, the purchase closed months ago, the notaire (the French public officer who handled the closing) mentioned property taxes in passing, and now the bill is real: several hundred or several thousand euros, payable within weeks, with unfamiliar line items and, in many cities, a second bill on top of the first. Some owners discover a surcharge of up to 60 percent they never heard of at the closing table. Others find they are being taxed as the occupant of a flat they barely used, or that the apartment they rent out on a short-term platform for most of the year still triggers a full residence tax in their name.

This article explains, for an American owner with no French legal background, the two local property taxes France bills you for each year, who legally owes each one, how the amounts are built, how to pay from a United States bank account before the deadline, and how to challenge a bill that is wrong. French legal terms are translated at first use. Every decisive rule below is quoted from the statute or the court decision that states it, with a link to the official French source, so you can check the law yourself or hand it to your advisers.

I. What France is billing you for: the two yearly local taxes on your French second home

A. Taxe fonciere: the owner tax on your French building, fixed by the situation on January 1

The taxe fonciere sur les proprietes baties, literally the property tax on built properties, is the tax every owner of a French building pays each year. The statute states the rule in one sentence: “La taxe foncière est établie annuellement sur les propriétés bâties sises en France à l’exception de celles qui en sont expressément exonérées par les dispositions du présent code.” In plain English: any built property in France is taxed every year unless the tax code expressly exempts it. Your nationality, your residence, and the fact that you pay income tax in the United States change nothing. If you own the apartment, you owe this tax. If you hold the property through an SCI (societe civile immobiliere, the family property company many foreign buyers use), the company receives the bill and it is paid out of the company, which in practice means out of your pocket.

The second decisive rule is the snapshot rule. “La taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties, la taxe foncière sur les propriétés non bâties et la taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires sont établies pour l’année entière d’après les faits existants au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition.” The tax for the whole year is set by the facts existing on January 1. Sell your Paris flat in March and you still owe the full year; buy in February and the seller owed it, which is why the notaire normally splits the bill pro rata between seller and buyer at closing and has the buyer reimburse the seller for the months after the sale. If your closing statement contained a line for prorated property tax, that is what it was. If you bought late in the year and received no bill the following autumn, check with the seller or the notaire before celebrating: the bill may have gone to the former owner, and the reimbursement clause in your deed may still bind you.

How is the amount built? The starting point is the valeur locative cadastrale, the cadastral rental value: a theoretical yearly rent the administration assigns to your property based on its size, comfort elements, and category. That base is then multiplied by the tax rates voted each year by the commune (the municipality), the intercommunal body, and, in some cases, special-purpose syndicates. On top of that come add-ons, most visibly the TEOM (taxe d’enlevement des ordures menageres, the household waste collection tax), which appears as a separate line computed on the same base. Two identical apartments in different towns can therefore produce very different bills, and a commune that raises its rate raises your bill even though your apartment has not changed. Paris rates and suburban rates differ substantially, which is why an American comparing notes with a friend who owns in another region should not expect matching numbers.

The base itself is not frozen. The statute provides: “Il est procédé, annuellement, à la constatation des constructions nouvelles et des changements de consistance ou d’affectation des propriétés bâties et non bâties ainsi qu’à la constatation des changements d’utilisation des locaux”, a yearly review the statute extends to further valuation items. New construction, an extension, a converted attic, or a change from office to residential use is picked up and repriced. The administration also revalues the bases nationally each year by a coefficient tied to inflation, so a bill that climbs three to seven percent with no local rate vote is usually that national update at work, not an error. Conversely, a demolition, a genuine state of ruin, or a long vacancy of a building unfit for use can reduce or remove the base, but you must declare the change and prove it; the administration does not inspect your property on its own.

Do not count on an exemption. The code exempts public buildings, farm buildings used for agriculture, and a closed list of special cases, plus age-and-income relief for modest households that the statute reserves in practice to residents occupying their main home, such as the provision that “Les redevables âgés de plus de soixante-quinze ans au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition sont exonérés de la taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties pour l’immeuble habité par eux, lorsque le montant des revenus de l’année précédente n’excède pas la limite prévue à l’article 1417” (within the income cap that provision sets). An American nonresident holding a French second home should assume the full rate applies and treat any relief as a bonus to verify, never as a starting assumption. And note the timing: the taxe fonciere bill arrives in late summer with a payment deadline in October, so the shock described at the top of this article follows the legal calendar, not a mistake.

B. Taxe d’habitation on second homes: the occupant tax that survived, and the surcharge of up to 60 percent

The taxe d’habitation, the residence tax, was abolished for main homes, but it survives in full for second homes, which is exactly what your French vacation apartment is in the eyes of the administration. The current statute names it plainly: “La taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires est due pour tous les locaux meublés conformément à leur destination d’habitation autre qu’à titre principal”, a rule that catches any furnished unit used as a dwelling other than as a main home, including units that are also subject to business tax, with only premises used exclusively for professional purposes escaping. Two words do a lot of work here. “Meuble,” furnished, means the unit must be fitted out for habitation; a genuinely empty, unfurnished shell is a different case, but a pied-a-terre with a bed, a table, and a hotplate is furnished. “Autre qu’a titre principal,” other than as a main home, means the administration classifies your Paris flat as secondary the moment your main home, the foyer where you live most of the year, is in the United States. You do not elect this classification; it follows from where you actually live.

Who pays this second tax? Not necessarily the owner. “La taxe est établie au nom des personnes qui ont, à quelque titre que ce soit, la disposition ou la jouissance des locaux imposables.” The bill goes to whoever has the disposition or enjoyment of the unit, which in practice means the occupant on January 1 under the same snapshot rule quoted above. If you occupy your own second home, owner and occupant are the same person and both bills land on you. If a long-term tenant occupies it on January 1, the tenant is normally the one liable for the taxe d’habitation, which is why an American landlord who rents a flat unfurnished year-round does not pay it. If the flat sits with a short-term tenant or an Airbnb guest on January 1, the answer is less intuitive and the courts have settled it against owners, as explained below.

Then comes the line that doubles the pain in many cities: the majoration, the surcharge. “Dans les communes mentionnées au B du I de l’article 1406 bis, le conseil municipal peut, par une délibération prise dans les conditions prévues à l’article 1639 A bis, majorer d’un pourcentage compris entre 5 % et 60 % la part lui revenant de la cotisation de taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires due au titre des logements meublés.” In designated communes, the town council may vote to increase its share of your second-home residence tax by anywhere from 5 to 60 percent. The designation targets municipalities with a marked imbalance between housing supply and demand, defined by the statute as “Une commune appartenant à une zone d’urbanisation continue de plus de 50 000 habitants dans laquelle il est notamment constaté un niveau élevé des loyers, un niveau élevé des prix d’acquisition des logements anciens ou un nombre élevé de demandes de logement par rapport au nombre d’emménagements annuels dans le parc locatif social”, with parallel criteria for other communes further down the same article. Paris and much of Ile-de-France, the Paris region, fit this high-demand urban profile, so owners there are the most likely to see this extra line, and at the higher end of the range. The surcharge appears on the same bill, calculated on the communal share, and it is voted locally, so it can appear, grow, or stay flat from one year to the next without any national law changing.

A related trap awaits owners who leave a flat empty. Outside the high-demand zones, towns may vote to tax dwellings left vacant for more than two years: “Les communes autres que celles visées à l’article 232 peuvent, par une délibération prise dans les conditions prévues à l’article 1639 A bis , assujettir à la taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires, pour la part communale et celle revenant aux établissements publics de coopération intercommunale sans fiscalité propre, les logements vacants depuis plus de deux années au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition.” Leaving your apartment vacant does not make the tax go away; in the wrong commune it can keep the tax alive indefinitely. An American who bought “for later,” left the unit empty for three years, and assumed no occupant means no occupant tax is the textbook victim of this rule.

The hardest lesson concerns owners who rent their French flat short-term. The Conseil d’Etat, France’s supreme administrative court, has repeated one rule in a string of decisions: the tenant on January 1 is normally liable, but “lorsqu’un logement meublé fait l’objet de locations saisonnières ou de courte durée, le propriétaire du bien est redevable de la taxe d’habitation dès lors qu’au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition, il peut être regardé comme entendant en conserver la disposition ou la jouissance une partie de l’année.” When a furnished unit is rented seasonally or for short stays, the owner owes the tax if, on January 1, he can be regarded as intending to keep use of it for part of the year. In the leading case, owners of three tourism-classified gites in Brittany, rented heavily through online platforms, argued that their high occupancy proved they kept nothing for themselves. The court annulled the lower court’s discharge and held: “Article 1er : Le jugement du 29 décembre 2023 du tribunal administratif de Rennes est annulé.” Being able to accept or refuse each short booking at will is precisely what shows you kept control, the court reasoned. The same outcome hit owners of a Juan-les-Pins apartment rented by the night online: the court found that “Cette circonstance permettant de regarder les intéressés comme entendant, au 1er janvier de l’année considérée, conserver la disposition ou la jouissance de leur logement au cours de cette année”, the court added, upholding the trial judge’s sovereign assessment of the facts. And the mirror case confirms the logic: a seasonal tenant in Palavas-les-Flots who occupied a furnished flat on January 1 under a fixed September-to-June lease was discharged, because “Par dérogation à ce principe, lorsqu’un logement meublé fait l’objet de locations saisonnières, le propriétaire du bien est redevable de la taxe d’habitation dès lors qu’il peut être regardé, au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition, comme entendant en conserver la disposition ou la jouissance une partie de l’année.” The owner who takes the flat back after the season keeps the tax; the genuine fixed-term seasonal tenant does not. For an American renting a Paris studio on a platform between personal stays, the message is blunt: you are very likely the taxpayer, even for a year in which guests occupied it most nights.

II. How to pay the bill from the United States and how to fight it when it is wrong

A. Read your avis, meet the October deadline, and pay from a US account without triggering penalties

Your avis d’imposition, the tax assessment notice, is the document that counts. It states the property, the base, each rate applied, the surcharge if any, the total, and the exact payment deadline, the date limite de paiement. For the taxe fonciere that deadline falls in October; the administration grants a few extra days for online payment, and smaller bills carry their own date, so read the notice itself rather than relying on last year’s calendar. Since 2023-era reforms moved everything online, nonresidents should assume the authoritative copy lives in their personal account on impots.gouv.fr, the tax administration portal, under the Espace Particulier. Paper notices still circulate, but mail forwarding to a US address is unreliable and never an excuse for late payment.

Payment method matters more for an American than for a French resident. Bills above 300 euros, which covers nearly every taxe fonciere and second-home residence tax bill, must under the administration’s standing guidance be paid by monthly or on-due-date bank debit or by direct online payment on the tax portal (service-public.fr guidance on paying and contesting these taxes). A US checking account is not SEPA-compatible, so a direct debit (prelevement) drawn on an American account will generally fail; the workable routes from the United States are online card payment through your impots.gouv.fr account or keeping a French or EU-zone account funded for the debit. Whichever route you choose, pay several business days before the deadline: cross-border card authorizations and time-zone confusion have pushed more than one owner past midnight Paris time into a penalty. And the penalty is automatic and heavy. “Donne lieu à l’application d’une majoration de 10 % tout retard dans le paiement des sommes dues au titre de l’impôt sur le revenu, des contributions sociales recouvrées comme en matière d’impôt sur le revenu, de la taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires , des taxes foncières sur les propriétés bâties et non bâties, des impositions recouvrées comme les impositions précitées et de l’impôt sur la fortune immobilière.” One day late costs ten percent. Calendar the deadline on receipt, pay early, and keep the confirmation.

Three practical habits prevent most American-owner problems. First, activate and monitor your online account before September: American owners who discover the portal only after the deadline routinely pay the 10 percent for nothing. Second, reconcile the bill against your deed: check the address and cadastral references, the occupancy box (owner-occupied second home versus rented), and whether the majoration line appears and matches your commune’s voted rate, which the town hall publishes with its annual budget deliberations. Third, keep every notice, receipt, and bank proof for your American tax file and hand them to your US accountant. These French local taxes sit outside the income taxes covered by the France-United States income tax treaty, so no treaty credit mechanism wipes them out; whether any limited US deduction is available under the capped state-and-local-tax rules is a question for your CPA, and the answer depends on your personal return, not on the French bill. Never skip a French payment in the hope that the American return will absorb it.

B. Challenge a wrong bill: the errors that win, the December 31 deadline, and the path to the administrative court

Wrong bills are common enough that the law organizes a full challenge track, and American owners should use it rather than overpaying quietly. The errors that succeed cluster into five families. The taxpayer is wrong: the bill names you as occupant when a long-term tenant held the lease on January 1, or names the tenant when the unit was a short-term rental you controlled. The statute anticipates exactly this correction: “Lorsque, au titre d’une année, une cotisation de taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires a été établie au nom d’une personne autre que le redevable légal de l’impôt, l’imposition de ce dernier, au titre de la même année, est établie au profit de l’Etat dans la limite du dégrèvement accordé au contribuable imposé à tort.” The wrongly billed person is discharged and the true taxpayer is billed instead. The base is wrong: the cadastral value still reflects an extension that was demolished, a ruin, or a misclassified comfort level, or the TEOM line is charged on a property outside the collection zone. The status is wrong: an unfurnished, uninhabitable unit taxed as a furnished second home, or a professional-use unit denied its exclusion. The surcharge is wrong: the majoration applied although the commune never voted it, voted it after the legal deadline, or sits outside the qualifying zones. And the bill is duplicated: a vacant-unit charge stacked on top of a residence tax for the same dwelling and year.

Procedure starts online and fast. The official guidance for contesting directs taxpayers to connect to their Finances publiques account on impots.gouv.fr, open the secure inbox, click write, and file under the claims motif: the portal’s own guidance walks you through opening your secure inbox, via the button at the top right of the account page, to reach the secure messaging channel. An American filing from abroad should write in French or in short bilingual sentences, attach everything as PDFs, and state precisely what is asked: discharge (degrevement), reduction, or correction, with the tax, the year, and the property references. A paper reclamation sent by tracked mail to the tax office of the property’s location remains valid and is the safer route when the online account is blocked, which happens to nonresidents more often than the administration admits. Either way, file first and argue second: the deadline below is strict and no amount of merit revives a late claim.

The deadline is the single most important sentence of this section. “Pour être recevables, les réclamations relatives aux impôts directs locaux et aux taxes annexes doivent être présentées à l’administration des impôts au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle, selon le cas : a) De la mise en recouvrement du rôle, de la notification d’un avis de mise en recouvrement ou de l’émission d’un titre de perception”; the same article lists further triggers for other cases. For a bill issued in autumn 2026, the claim must reach the administration by December 31, 2027. Mark that date the day the bill arrives. Your claim goes to the tax office first, which must answer; silence for six months counts as an implicit rejection and opens the courthouse door. The jurisdictional anchor is statutory: “Les réclamations relatives aux impôts, contributions, droits, taxes, redevances, soultes et pénalités de toute nature, établis ou recouvrés par les agents de l’administration, relèvent de la juridiction contentieuse lorsqu’elles tendent à obtenir soit la réparation d’erreurs commises dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions, soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire.” Calculation and base errors go to the administrative court, not to a civil judge and not back to the notaire. Once the administration has decided, expressly or implicitly, the appeal to the tribunal administratif (the first-level administrative court) must be filed “dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée.” Two months from the rejection, not a day more, and the competent court is the one where the property sits, so a Paris apartment means the Paris administrative court and Paris counsel, not a filing from a US court.

Build the file as if the judge will read only the exhibits. For an occupancy dispute: the lease or platform contracts, the January utility bills in the occupant’s name, proof of your US main home, and any tenant attestation. For a base dispute: dated photos, the demolition permit or contractor invoices, the diagnostic file from the purchase showing the true state, and the prior bills showing the jump. For a surcharge dispute: the commune’s published deliberation and rate, and evidence of the zone classification. For a short-term-rental dispute, be realistic after the three Conseil d’Etat rulings quoted above: arguing that heavy platform occupancy proves you kept nothing for yourself has already lost twice, in Rennes and Juan-les-Pins, while the only winning pattern is a genuine fixed-term seasonal lease to an identified tenant who held the unit on January 1. Pick battles the case law allows. And one warning for owners in Paris and Ile-de-France: the amounts, the surcharge lines, and the scrutiny of furnished rentals are all at their peak there, so Paris files deserve Paris counsel and should never be handled with a one-paragraph email in English alone.

Conclusion

An American who owns a French second home owes two yearly local taxes as a matter of course: the taxe fonciere as owner and the taxe d’habitation as occupant of a secondary residence, the latter potentially increased by a locally voted surcharge of up to 60 percent. Both are fixed by the situation on January 1, both arrive in autumn with an October payment deadline, both must be paid online or by bank debit once they exceed 300 euros, and any delay costs an automatic 10 percent. Errors are frequent and the law gives you a real remedy, but the remedy runs on rails: a claim to the tax office by December 31 of the following year, then, if needed, the administrative court within two months of the answer. Read each avis line by line the week it arrives, pay on time even while you challenge, assemble dated paper for every factual claim, and measure any short-term-rental argument against the Conseil d’Etat’s owner-liable case law before you file. Handled that way, the autumn envelope becomes an administrative routine instead of a crisis, and your French home stays what it should be: the asset, not the dispute.

📄 Official circular