KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Selling Your French Main Home as an American: France’s Full Exemption, the IRS $250,000 Rule, and Filing on Both Sides

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Selling Your French Main Home as an American: France’s Full Exemption, the IRS $250,000 Rule, and Filing on Both Sides

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought an apartment in Paris or a stone house in the Dordogne, lived in it for years as your real home, and now you are selling it to move back to the United States or to buy elsewhere in France. Your French notaire tells you the sale will owe zero French tax because the property was your main home. Then your American tax preparer tells you the same sale produces a taxable gain on your United States return, with no French tax available to credit against the American bill. Both are right. This article explains why the two systems reach opposite results on the same deed, what each side demands from you, and how to close the file cleanly in both countries. The French side turns on one question: did the property constitute your main home on the day of the sale, and can you prove it with documents the tax courts accept. The American side turns on a different question: does your dollar gain fit inside the federal exclusion for the sale of a main home, and what remains above it. Read the French part first, because losing the French exemption makes everything more expensive, and keep every invoice and utility bill from day one, because both countries will judge your paper trail.

I. France exempts your main home entirely, but only if the facts fit on the day of the sale

French law starts from a broad rule and then carves out the main home completely. The statute provides that capital gains realized by individuals on the sale for consideration of built or unbuilt real estate are subject to income tax under the standard computation rules: “les plus-values réalisées par les personnes physiques ou les sociétés ou groupements qui relèvent des articles 8 à 8 ter , lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 V à 150 VH” (CGI, art. 150 U, I). The exemption then follows immediately: these provisions do not apply to buildings “Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession” (CGI, art. 150 U, II, 1). The test is assessed on the day of the sale, not over your whole ownership, and it covers the full gain with no holding-period condition and no ceiling. For an American living in France, the first building block is French tax residence itself: you are treated as domiciled in France when you have your household or your principal place of stay there, since “Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal” (CGI, art. 4 B). Once you are a French resident selling the home you actually live in, the exemption is in principle yours. The litigation starts when the administration doubts that the home you sold was really your main one.

A. How an American proves the sold home was really the main home on sale day

The Paris administrative court of appeal decided the case of a taxpayer who bought an apartment on avenue Charles Floquet in the 7th arrondissement of Paris in December 2009 and sold it in June 2012, claiming the main-home exemption while the administration answered that the flat was a second home. The court discharged the additional tax and social charges, and its reasoning is a practical checklist for every American seller. The taxpayer produced electricity bills showing normal consumption from the start of 2011 until April 2012, two letters from telephone operators dated December 2010 and January 2011 about installing an ADSL line and high-speed internet access, a parking-space rental form from November 2010, and evidence of furniture spending for fitting out the apartment. The administration objected that he had kept his previous address on official documents, company deeds, and sales of buildings and securities in 2011 and 2012, that he had kept his old home in Draveil, and that the Paris flat had even been charged housing tax as a second home in 2010 and 2011. The court answered that, in the particular circumstances, “le seul fait que M. A…ait conservé son adresse précédente sur certains documents ou à l’occasion de l’établissement de certains actes ne saurait conduire à regarder l’appartement de Paris, dont l’occupation effective à titre principal est établie par les documents susmentionnés, comme une résidence secondaire” (CAA Paris, 29 May 2019, No. 18PA01317). It added the point that matters most for short stays: “La seule circonstance que l’occupation à titre principal de cet appartement, à supposer qu’elle puisse être regardée comme limitée à 11 mois, ait été brève, n’est pas de nature à remettre en cause le bénéfice de l’exonération prévue par les dispositions du 1° du II de l’article 150 U du code général des impôts visant les cessions des biens qui constituent la résidence principale des cédants au jour de la cession” (CAA Paris, 29 May 2019, No. 18PA01317). Three lessons follow for an American file. First, effective occupation beats paperwork addresses: utility consumption, an internet subscription in your name, a parking lease, and furniture invoices outweigh the address printed on older deeds. Second, even a short occupation of around eleven months can qualify, so a relatively quick resale after moving in is not fatal by itself. Third, a housing-tax bill issued as a second home does not decide the income-tax question, though you should still get the housing-tax record corrected, because the administration will brandish it. Build this file before you list the property: put the electricity and internet contracts in the name of the occupant, keep twelve months of consumption bills, keep furniture and moving invoices, update your address on your French income-tax return, and keep proof of where your children went to school and where you actually slept.

B. Already moved out before the sale: the one-year tolerance and the two statutory safety valves

Americans often leave the home empty for months while it is on the market, after a transfer to another city or a return to the United States. French case law keeps the exemption alive in that situation, but only within a narrow window. The Versailles court of appeal states the rule this way: “un immeuble ne perd pas sa qualité de résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession du seul fait que celui-ci a libéré les lieux avant ce jour, à condition que le délai pendant lequel l’immeuble est demeuré inoccupé puisse être regardé comme normal” (CAA Versailles, 2 July 2024, No. 22VE02161). The court explains how normality is judged: the seller must have taken the necessary steps, given the reasons for the sale, the characteristics of the property, and the local economic and regulatory context, to complete the sale as quickly as possible starting from the foreseeable date of moving the household elsewhere. In that case the apartment in the 17th arrondissement of Paris stayed empty for seventeen months between the move to Garches and the sale for 2.25 million euros, and the court held that “Le délai de dix-sept mois au cours duquel l’immeuble cédé est demeuré inoccupé excède le délai d’une année constituant, en principe, le délai maximal dans un contexte économique normal, en vertu d’une tolérance de l’administration fiscale” (CAA Versailles, 2 July 2024, No. 22VE02161). The seller lost the exemption and the court concluded: “M. B… ne pouvait prétendre au bénéfice de l’exonération prévue au 1° du II de l’article 150 U du code général des impôts” (CAA Versailles, 2 July 2024, No. 22VE02161). The details explain why seventeen months failed: one agency mandate was never returned signed, another had expired without renewal, only two viewings were documented over the whole period, the price was cut without proof that the initial price was realistic, and no personal, family, or local market obstacle was shown. For your sale, the message is operational. Sign a valid written mandate with an agency and keep proof it was accepted, keep every viewing report and advertisement invoice, record each price reduction with comparable listings that justify the starting price, and keep evidence of any event outside your control that slowed the sale, such as a local planning freeze or a documented family emergency. A prestige property in a thin market is not an excuse by itself. If the vacancy stretches past one year, expect the administration to challenge the file, and organize your evidence as if the audit had already started. The one-year period is an administrative tolerance applied by the courts in a normal market, not a statutory deadline, so a longer vacancy can still qualify in genuinely exceptional circumstances, but the burden of proof is entirely on you.

Two statutory provisions rescue sellers who cannot meet the main-home-on-sale-day test. The first covers the American who has never owned a main home and sells a different dwelling to buy one: the exemption applies “Au titre de la première cession d’un logement, y compris ses dépendances immédiates et nécessaires au sens du 3° si leur cession est simultanée à celle dudit logement, autre que la résidence principale, lorsque le cédant n’a pas été propriétaire de sa résidence principale, directement ou par personne interposée, au cours des quatre années précédant la cession” (CGI, art. 150 U, II, 1 bis). The relief is proportional: it applies to the fraction of the sale price that the seller reinvests “dans un délai de vingt-quatre mois à compter de la cession, à l’acquisition ou la construction d’un logement qu’il affecte, dès son achèvement ou son acquisition si elle est postérieure, à son habitation principale”, and “En cas de manquement à l’une de ces conditions, l’exonération est remise en cause au titre de l’année du manquement” (CGI, art. 150 U, II, 1 bis). In practice, this helps the American renter in Paris who sells a rental studio or a inherited country house to buy the apartment the family will actually live in, provided none of the household owned its main home during the previous four years and the reinvestment happens within twenty-four months of the sale, a limit the statute states expressly and the notaire records in the deed. The second provision protects retirees who move into care: it exempts homes “Qui ont constitué la résidence principale du cédant et n’ont fait l’objet depuis lors d’aucune occupation, lorsque ce dernier est désormais résident d’un établissement mentionné aux 6° ou 7° du I de l’article L. 312-1 du code de l’action sociale et des familles si, au titre de l’avant-dernière année précédant celle de la cession, il n’est pas passible de l’impôt sur la fortune immobilière et n’a pas un revenu fiscal de référence excédant la limite prévue au II de l’article 1417 du présent code et si la cession intervient dans un délai inférieur à deux ans suivant l’entrée dans l’établissement” (CGI, art. 150 U, II, 1 ter). This matters for an American parent who retires in France and enters a care home: the former home must stay empty, the means conditions of CGI, art. 1417 must be met, and the sale must close within two years after admission, a time limit the statute fixes directly. Miss any prong and the exemption falls away.

If the exemption fails, the fallback is the ordinary second-home computation, and you should understand its moving parts even when you expect to owe nothing, because the notaire prices the risk of losing the exemption. The gross gain is the difference between the sale price and the purchase price: “La plus ou moins-value brute réalisée lors de la cession de biens ou droits mentionnés aux articles 150 U à 150 UC est égale à la différence entre le prix de cession et le prix d’acquisition par le cédant” (CGI, art. 150 V). The purchase price starts from what you actually paid, since “Le prix d’acquisition est le prix effectivement acquitté par le cédant, tel qu’il est stipulé dans l’acte” (CGI, art. 150 VB), and it is increased, with receipts, by transfer taxes and fees, which the seller “peut fixer forfaitairement à 7, 5 % du prix d’acquisition”, and by “dépenses de construction, de reconstruction, d’agrandissement ou d’amélioration, supportées par le vendeur et réalisées par une entreprise” (CGI, art. 150 VB). Keep two practical consequences in mind. First, work you paid for without invoices can still add a flat uplift once five years have passed: “Lorsque le contribuable, qui cède un immeuble bâti plus de cinq ans après son acquisition, n’est pas en état d’apporter la justification de ces dépenses, une majoration égale à 15 % du prix d’acquisition est pratiquée” (CGI, art. 150 VB). Second, bags of materials you bought yourself and handed to the contractor do not count: the Conseil d’Etat holds that the statute prevents adding the cost of materials the seller bought personally and handed to the contractor, even when a company performs the installation work (CE, 21 Nov. 2018, No. 414258). Always have the company bill the materials itself. Duration relief then shrinks the taxable base under a fixed schedule: “La plus-value brute réalisée sur les biens ou droits mentionnés aux articles 150 U , 150 UB et 150 UC est réduite d’un abattement fixé à : – 6 % pour chaque année de détention au-delà de la cinquième ; – 4 % au titre de la vingt-deuxième année de détention” (CGI, art. 150 VC), which wipes out the income-tax base after twenty-two years, while social charges follow a slower table to thirty years (service-public.fr, plus-value immobilière). The remaining net gain pays 19 percent income tax, since “Les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U à 150 UC sont imposées au taux forfaitaire de 19 %” (CGI, art. 200 B), plus 17.2 percent social charges, because social charges apply at the combined rate of 17.2 percent and a property held for more than 30 years is also fully relieved of social charges (service-public.fr, plus-value immobilière), the social charge falling on “Des plus-values, gains en capital et profits soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu” of French-domiciled individuals (CSS, art. L. 136-6). Large gains also attract a surtax: “La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €” (CGI, art. 1609 nonies G). When the main-home exemption applies, all of this falls to zero, which is exactly why the proof file described above deserves more attention than the arithmetic.

II. The IRS taxes the same sale with its own tests, and France’s zero leaves no credit to claim

The treaty between the two countries gives France the first word on French real estate: gains from the sale of real estate located in one treaty state fall within that state’s taxing power (France-United States tax treaty, Art. 13(1)). France uses that right and then chooses to exempt the main home, so the French tax on your sale is zero. The United States, which taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, applies its own main-home rule independently, and the treaty does not force the IRS to follow the French exemption. The American relief is a fixed-dollar exclusion, not a full exemption: a qualifying seller may exclude up to 250,000 dollars of gain, or up to 500,000 dollars on a joint return (IRS, Topic No. 701). Everything above the cap stays taxable in the United States even though France taxed nothing.

A. Fitting your dollar gain inside the $250,000 or $500,000 federal exclusion

The federal exclusion has three cumulative tests, and each maps onto facts you can organize before closing. First, the ownership test and the use test each require two years out of the last five: each test requires at least 24 months within the five years ending on the sale date, and the two qualifying periods may be different (IRS, Topic No. 701). The two tests can be met over different two-year periods within the same five-year window, but both must fall inside the five years ending on the sale date. Second, the exclusion is not repeatable at will: a seller who excluded gain on another home during the prior two-year period is generally barred from using the exclusion again (IRS, Topic No. 701). The detailed worksheets and the exceptions for moves caused by work, health, or unforeseen circumstances are in IRS Publication 523, which your preparer should run before you sign anything. Third, compute the gain in dollars the American way. Start from what you actually paid for the home, add the actual cost of improvements supported by contractor invoices, and subtract that basis from the euro sale price converted into dollars. Do not import the French flat-rate uplifts into the American computation: the 7.5 percent acquisition-cost allowance and the 15 percent no-receipt allowance exist only inside the French calculation of article 150 VB, and your American basis rests on money genuinely spent. The Conseil d’Etat’s materials rule quoted above should already push you toward contractor-billed invoices, which serve both countries at once. Currency movement is part of the gain, so a euro gain that looks modest can become a dollar gain above the cap after years of dollar weakness, and a euro break-even can still be an American taxable gain. Model the dollar figure with your preparer using the sale-year rate before you commit to a price, especially for Paris properties where the gain often exceeds $250,000 for a single filer. Above the cap, the painful symmetry appears: the treaty eliminates double taxation through a credit equal, for capital gains, to the amount of American tax paid, capped at the corresponding French tax on the same income (Treaty, Art. 24(1)(a)(iii)), which protects you on the French side, while on the American side there is simply nothing to credit, because the credit exists only for taxes actually borne abroad: a credit or deduction is available only for foreign taxes actually paid or accrued on the same income (IRS, Foreign Tax Credit). France charged zero, so no credit and no deduction arise. The excess over $250,000, or $500,000 on a joint return, is therefore taxed in the United States with no offset, and your state of residence may tax it as well, so have the state return modeled together with the federal one.

B. Closing the file on both sides without creating a second dispute

On the French side, the notaire does the heavy lifting at the signing table. The gain is computed on the official form, which includes a computation table that the notaire completes in practice (service-public.fr, plus-value immobilière), the exemption is claimed in the deed, and any tax due is paid at closing, so you leave the office with the French file closed. Your job is to arrive with the proof file from part I organized for the notaire and, if the administration later audits the exemption, for the tax office: dated utility bills, the internet contract, the parking lease, furniture and moving invoices, the income-tax returns showing the address, and the complete sale-mandate trail if the home stood empty. If you had already moved back to the United States before the sale and were no longer a French resident, a different French regime applies to you: non-residents face a specific levy, since “Sous réserve des conventions internationales, les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B , réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon les taux fixés au III bis” (CGI, art. 244 bis A), and the main-home exemption in its full form belongs to residents. Timing your departure and your sale date with advice, before either happens, is therefore worth more than any argument after the deed. Readers handling the mirror situation, a French second home sold from America, will find the remote-closing mechanics, powers of attorney, and diagnostics in our guide to selling a French second home from the United States and the full non-resident computation in our second-home capital-gains and treaty-credit analysis. On the American side, bring the French closing statement to your preparer, reconcile every euro of price, fees, and withheld amounts with the dollars reported, claim the section 121 exclusion on the return with the Publication 523 worksheet kept in the file, and do not file a foreign-tax-credit claim for French tax that was never paid. If the proceeds stay parked in a French bank account, your existing account-reporting duties continue under their own rules, detailed in our FBAR, Form 8938, and Form 3916 reporting guide. Keep the French deed, the 2048-IMM computation, and the dollar-basis file together for at least the American limitations period, because a sale that was clean in France can still be examined in the United States years later.

Conclusion

Selling your French main home as an American produces the strangest result in cross-border tax: France exempts the entire gain while the IRS taxes the dollars above $250,000, or $500,000 on a joint return, with no credit for the French tax that does not exist. Protect the French half first, because it is all or nothing. Live in the home through the sale date when you can, prove effective occupation with consumption bills and contracts in your name rather than addresses on old paperwork, and if you must leave before selling, sell within the one-year tolerance with a documented trail of mandates, viewings, and realistic pricing. Remember the two statutory lifelines, the first-sale reinvestment within twenty-four months and the care-home sale within two years, each with strict conditions that must all be met. Then handle the American half with the same discipline: verify the two-years-in-five ownership and use tests, check the two-year repeat bar, compute the dollar gain on real costs with contractor-billed invoices, and claim the exclusion while expecting tax on the excess. Done in this order, with both files closed at signing and on the return, the move costs you exactly what the law requires and nothing that surprise or sloppy paperwork would add.

📄 Official circular