KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Siblings and I Inherited a House in France and We Cannot Agree: How Americans Exit Indivision, Force a Sale, or Buy Each Other Out

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Siblings and I Inherited a House in France and We Cannot Agree: How Americans Exit Indivision, Force a Sale, or Buy Each Other Out

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your mother died owning a small stone house in the Dordogne. You live in Chicago, your sister lives in Austin, and your brother has lived in Lyon for a decade. The French notaire — the public officer who settles every French estate — writes to all three of you with the same news: you now own the house together, each holding an undivided one-third share. Your sister wants to sell immediately and split the money. Your brother wants to keep the house and spend summers there. You are caught in the middle, eight time zones away, wondering whether one sibling can block the other two forever. The answer, under French law, is no — but getting out takes a procedure, and every shortcut has a price tag.

French co-ownership on death is called indivision: several people own the whole property together without any physical division, each holding only a fractional right over everything. It is nothing like the clean American idea of splitting assets and walking away. Yet French law refuses to let anyone be trapped in it. As this guide explains, an American heir can always force the exit — through an agreed division, through a court-approved sale carried by a two-thirds majority, or through a full judicial partition — and a recent Paris judgment shows exactly how judges choose between these paths. Along the way you will meet the occupancy payment the sibling who uses the house owes the others, the 2.50 percent division tax, and the reason a court-ordered auction is treated as the last resort rather than the starting point.

I. What Inheriting a French House With Your Siblings Really Means

A. Can One Sibling Block the Sale of Our French House Forever?

No. The single most important sentence in French co-ownership law reads: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In plain English: nobody can be forced to remain in undivided co-ownership, and a division of the property — the partage — can always be demanded, unless a court or a signed agreement has temporarily frozen it. A sibling who simply refuses to sell, refuses to answer letters, or refuses to sign anything cannot freeze the situation permanently. The law gives you the tools to move forward without that sibling’s cooperation; what changes is only how formal, how slow, and how expensive the exit becomes.

That freedom cuts both ways, because while nobody can force you to stay, nobody can act alone either. Day-to-day management of the house — paying the property tax, insuring the building, hiring a roofer — is governed by majority logic. Under Article 815-3 of the Civil Code, the co-owners holding at least two-thirds of the undivided rights may, at that majority, handle administrative acts for the property, give a general management mandate to one of themselves or to an outsider, sell shared movable items to pay the debts of the co-ownership, and sign or renew ordinary leases. They must inform the other co-owners, failing which the decisions cannot be held against them. But anything serious — selling the house itself, mortgaging it, or giving it away — requires everybody’s consent. So with three equal siblings, two of you can keep the lights on and the insurance paid, but you cannot sell the roof over the third sibling’s objections without going further down the legal path described below.

One daily-life rule surprises American families more than any other: the sibling who actually uses the house owes money to the ones who do not. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code provides that every co-owner may use and enjoy the shared property consistently with its purpose and compatibly with the others’ rights, and then adds the sting: “L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité.” Whoever enjoys the house privately owes the others an occupancy payment, unless you agreed otherwise. If your brother in Lyon spends every summer in the Dordogne house while you and your sister never set foot in it, he builds up a debt to the two of you month after month — a debt the notaire will settle in the final accounts before anyone receives a euro. Get a written agreement early, ideally through the notaire, either setting that payment or waiving it while you negotiate the final split; silence only manufactures a future fight about how much the summers were worth.

Two practical warnings complete the picture. First, long exclusive use does not quietly become ownership: Article 816 states that “Le partage peut être demandé, même quand l’un des indivisaires a joui séparément de tout ou partie des biens indivis, s’il n’y a pas eu d’acte de partage ou une possession suffisante pour acquérir la prescription.” A sibling cannot defeat your exit by arguing that ten summers of sole occupation extinguished your rights. Second, if your surviving parent is still alive and co-owns with you — the classic case where a widowed mother holds rights alongside the children — remember that the surviving spouse who inherits together with children takes either the usufruct (lifetime use) of everything or one-quarter in full ownership under Article 757 of the Civil Code, which grants “à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens” when children are involved. A usufruct changes every calculation in this guide, because the bare owners cannot sell full title without the usufructuary. Read our companion explanation of what the American surviving spouse gets and how that choice is made before assuming the siblings alone decide.

B. What Does Splitting a French House Actually Cost in Tax and Fees?

Before choosing your exit route, price it. Dividing a French estate triggers three layers of cost that American families rarely anticipate: the inheritance tax on receiving your share, the registration tax on the division itself, and the notaire’s bill for running the procedure. Each has its own official scale, and each rewards planning.

Start with the inheritance tax, because it hits first. France taxes the French house even when the deceased and the heirs all live in America: Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code expressly submits to French transfer duties the real estate located in France where the deceased was not domiciled in France for tax purposes. Your Chicago address changes nothing about the French tax claim on the Dordogne house. The good news is the parent-to-child allowance: Article 779 of the General Tax Code grants “un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés” — 100,000 euros free of tax on each living child’s share, renewable every fifteen years for gifts. Above that allowance, the Article 777 scale climbs from 5 percent on the first 8,072 euros through 20 percent between 15,932 and 552,324 euros, up to 40 and 45 percent on the largest shares. Worked examples of these brackets on a French house, including how the U.S. foreign tax credit softens the double hit, are set out in our guide to what American children pay when they inherit a French house. And where both countries claim tax, the bilateral estate-and-gift-tax treaty signed on November 24, 1978, as later amended — whose official text is published by the U.S. Congress at Treaty Document 109-7 — organizes relief so the same value is not fully taxed twice.

Then comes the tax most families have never heard of: the division itself is taxed. Article 746 of the General Tax Code provides that “Les partages de biens meubles et immeubles entre copropriétaires, cohéritiers et coassociés, à quelque titre que ce soit, pourvu qu’il en soit justifié, sont assujettis à un droit d’enregistrement ou à une taxe de publicité foncière de 2,50 %.” Every partition of estate property between co-heirs pays a 2.50 percent registration duty. Note the trap hidden in the rest of that article: the reduced rates of 1.80 and then 1.10 percent apply only to partitions following a divorce, a legal separation, or the breakup of a civil partnership — never to a succession partition between siblings. Budget the full 2.50 percent on the value of the property being divided, plus the publicity and notaire disbursement costs that ride along with any French real-estate deed.

Finally, the notaire’s own bill. In an agreed division the notaire drafts the deed of partition and earns scaled emoluments; in a court-ordered partition the tribunal appoints a notaire, fixes an advance on fees, and splits it among the heirs. To calibrate expectations, consider a recent Paris partition case in which the court ordered three heirs to advance 5,000 euros toward the appointed notaire’s fees, payable in equal shares within weeks of the judgment — a vivid reminder that judicial exits start costing money long before anyone is paid out. Our breakdown of what the notaire charges an American heir, with a priced example and the remedies against an excessive bill, lets you audit every line before you sign. And the official starting point for the whole process remains the French administration’s own guidance: the service-public.fr page on the rules for inheriting, also available in English for the order and rights of heirs.

II. How Americans Actually Get Out When the Siblings Disagree

A. Can Two Siblings Out of Three Force the Sale Without a Trial?

Yes — often without a full trial, through two different doors. The first door is the agreed partition, the partage amiable: everybody signs a single deed, drawn up by the notaire, that allots each heir a lot matching that heir’s rights. Lots need not be identical bricks; one sibling can take the house while the others take the bank accounts, the investment portfolio, or cash, with the imbalance corrected by an equalization payment called a soulte. Where the estate holds several properties, the notaire composes balanced lots; where one asset dominates — the classic single-house estate — the sibling who keeps the house pays the others a soulte for the difference. No judge, no auction, one deed, one 2.50 percent duty. From the United States, a sibling can sign through a power of attorney legalized with an apostille rather than flying to France, a mechanism detailed in our guide to selling a French house without leaving America. The agreed route fails the moment one sibling refuses to sign, disputes the valuation, or contests the accounting — and that is exactly when the statute sends you to court.

The second door is the two-thirds shortcut of Article 815-5-1 of the Civil Code: “l’aliénation d’un bien indivis peut être autorisée par le tribunal judiciaire, à la demande de l’un ou des indivisaires titulaires d’au moins deux tiers des droits indivis” — the sale of an undivided property can be authorized by the court at the request of co-owners holding at least two-thirds of the rights. It does not apply where the property itself is split between usufruct and bare ownership, nor where a protected co-owner is involved, but for three equal siblings it means two of you can petition the court together. The procedure runs through a notaire: the two-thirds majority formally declares before a notaire its intention to sell, the notaire serves that intention on the dissenting sibling within one month, and the court then authorizes the private sale on the proposed terms unless the minority shows a concrete reason to refuse. This is faster and far cheaper than a full judicial partition, and it keeps the sale on the open market — where a Dordogne farmhouse or a Paris apartment fetches its true price — instead of under the auctioneer’s hammer.

Use this shortcut with your eyes open. The petitioning majority must present a genuine sale project — price, buyer or marketing plan, terms — not a bare wish to be rid of the minority. The dissenting sibling is heard and can argue that the price undervalues the house, that an agreed partition was within reach, or that the accounts between co-owners were never settled. Courts verify that the sale serves the common interest of the undivided owners rather than punishing the holdout. And remember the boundary of the ordinary two-thirds powers recalled earlier: routine administration yes, but disposing of the house itself always needs either unanimity or this specific court authorization. Two siblings who sign a private sale contract behind the third sibling’s back have sold nothing enforceable against that sibling — a mistake that has sunk more than one family arrangement before the notaire refuses to publish the deed.

B. What Happens If We End Up in Court — and Will the Judge Really Auction the House?

When no agreement is possible and no two-thirds majority carries the sale, the statute provides the heavy machinery: the judicial partition, the partage judiciaire. Article 840 of the Civil Code sends you to court “lorsque l’un des indivisaires refuse de consentir au partage amiable, s’il s’élève des contestations sur la manière d’y procéder ou de le terminer” — where one co-owner refuses the agreed division, where disputes arise about how to conduct or complete it, or where the accounts are too tangled for a private deed. Jurisdiction is rigid: Article 841 gives “Le tribunal du lieu d’ouverture de la succession” — the court of the place where the succession opened, generally the deceased’s last domicile — exclusive power over partition actions and every dispute arising from the undivided ownership or the partition operations. For a parent who died domiciled in France, that is the local tribunal judiciaire; in Paris, these cases flow to the specialized second chamber, second section, whose judges handle nothing but successions and partitions. An American heir does not file in Chicago or Austin and does not ask a U.S. court to divide a French house — the French court alone decides, and a U.S. judgment purporting to split French real estate would need a separate French enforcement proceeding to have any effect on the land registry.

The court’s first reflex is not to sell but to organize. The standard judgment opens account-settlement, liquidation, and partition operations, appoints a notaire to run them, orders every heir to hand over all useful documents, and sets the notaire a one-year deadline to produce a draft liquidation statement — with a judge assigned to supervise and a fee advance split equally among the heirs. That is precisely what the Paris succession court did on February 3, 2025, in a case opposing five heirs over a Paris apartment and a Riviera villa: it ordered “l’ouverture des opérations de comptes, liquidation et partage judiciaire de la succession” with a named notaire, a 5,000-euro fee advance split in equal shares, and a supervision calendar — and in the same breath it rejected the requested auction of both properties. The message for American families is direct: filing for partition buys you a supervised accounting and a neutral professional, not an instant sale.

Auction — the licitation — is genuinely the last resort, and the statute says so almost poetically. Article 1686 of the Civil Code provides: “Si une chose commune à plusieurs ne peut être partagée commodément et sans perte ; Ou si, dans un partage fait de gré à gré de biens communs, il s’en trouve quelques-uns qu’aucun des copartageants ne puisse ou ne veuille prendre, La vente s’en fait aux enchères, et le prix en est partagé entre les copropriétaires.” Only property that cannot be conveniently divided without loss, or that nobody will take, goes under the hammer. The procedural code confirms the hierarchy: the court orders partition where it can take place, and the auction sale only where its strict conditions are met. In that February 2025 Paris judgment, the heir demanding the auction argued that a villa worth over 1.9 million euros and a Paris apartment worth over 3 million made the estate impossible to divide in kind — and lost. Other heirs showed the estate also held additional properties, a stock portfolio, and cash, so balanced lots remained feasible; one heir affirmatively sought attribution of the villa against a soulte; and the court found the auction premature while the accounts between heirs were still unestablished and the valuations disputed. For your family, the lesson is concrete: before asking a judge to auction the Dordogne house, expect to be asked why lots cannot be composed, who is willing to take the house with a soulte, and whether the occupancy payments and expenses have even been tallied.

Run the decision tree in order, then. First, negotiate an agreed partition with a serious valuation — ideally a joint expert appraisal all siblings accept — and settle the occupancy indemnities and expense reimbursements inside the same deed. Second, if two of three siblings agree to sell, use the two-thirds court-authorized sale and keep the property on the open market. Third, if positions are truly frozen, file for judicial partition at the court of the succession’s opening, ask the notaire for attribution of the house to the sibling who wants it against a soulte, and treat auction as the fallback you invoke only by proving that division in kind is impossible or loss-making. At every stage, keep every sibling formally informed through the notaire: unserved decisions are unenforceable against the sibling left in the dark, and American distance is no excuse once registered letters and electronic service reach across the Atlantic.

Conclusion

Three American siblings, one French house, three different plans: French law has seen this family a thousand times, and its answer never varies. Nobody stays trapped — Article 815 guarantees the exit — but nobody walks away unilaterally either. The sibling who lives in the house owes the others an occupancy indemnity; the two siblings who agree can push through administration and, via the court, an open-market sale; the dissenting sibling is protected by notice, valuation, and a judge who prefers attribution with a soulte over the auctioneer’s hammer. Price the journey before you start — inheritance tax above each 100,000-euro allowance, the 2.50 percent partition duty, the notaire’s bill — and sequence it from cheapest to heaviest: agreed deed first, two-thirds authorized sale second, supervised judicial partition last. Handled in that order, the Dordogne house stops being a transatlantic stalemate and becomes what your mother intended it to be: an inheritance, divided.

📄 Official circular