An American who owns a French second home may continue to receive a taxe foncière bill even after a fire, flood, structural defect, or official safety order has made the property impossible to occupy. In French, taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties means the annual local property tax on built property. The fact that a house is empty, damaged, or unusable does not by itself cancel that tax. A limited relief called a dégrèvement may be available, but Article 1389 of the French Tax Code is narrower than the everyday idea of an “uninhabitable home” exemption. It principally addresses a dwelling normally intended for rental that has become involuntarily vacant for at least three months. A personal-use vacation home is therefore in a difficult position unless the evidence shows a genuine rental purpose. This guide explains the distinction for a U.S. owner, the documents that can prove the claim, the month-by-month calculation, the deadline, and the procedure for challenging a refusal. It also separates taxe foncière from second-home housing tax and vacancy taxes, and explains why the France–U.S. tax treaty does not replace the domestic French claim.
I. Can an American claim a French taxe foncière reduction for an uninhabitable second home?
A. Why French property tax remains due even when the house cannot be occupied
The first question is not whether the owner is American. It is what the property is, where it is located, and what legal use it had. Article 1380 of the French Tax Code states: “La taxe foncière est établie annuellement sur les propriétés bâties sises en France à l’exception de celles qui en sont expressément exonérées par les dispositions du présent code.” In plain English, built property situated in France is assessed annually unless a specific statutory exemption applies. A U.S. passport does not create a different tax base or a special exemption for a house in France.
For the broader annual-tax framework, see our guide to French property tax for American second-home owners.
This is a tax on ownership of the built property, not a charge calculated by the number of nights the owner sleeps there. That distinction matters for an American who uses the house only in July, keeps it closed during the winter, or cannot visit because an insurer has restricted access. Ordinary non-use is not the same thing as the legal vacancy that can trigger Article 1389. The owner can still be liable while the property is empty, furnished, secured, or awaiting a contractor.
The assessment is also annual. Article 1415 of the French Tax Code provides: “La taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties, la taxe foncière sur les propriétés non bâties et la taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires sont établies pour l’année entière d’après les faits existants au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition.” The relevant facts on January 1 normally determine the annual bill. Article 1389 is a specific exception that adjusts the tax for an eligible period after the statutory conditions are met; it is not a general rule that the tax disappears whenever the house becomes uncomfortable or unlivable.
The tax base is not the American market value of the home. Article 1388 of the French Tax Code refers to the valeur locative cadastrale, meaning the cadastral rental value used for French local-tax purposes. It is a statutory valuation concept, not a rent that the American owner personally receives. The annual assessment is then combined with rates set by the relevant local authorities and with ancillary amounts shown on the notice. A reduction claim therefore needs to identify the exact tax notice and its legal components, rather than simply state that the property has no rental income.
For a second home, there may also be a separate taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires, or housing tax on second homes. The official Service-Public explanation of second-home housing tax distinguishes a furnished dwelling that is not the owner’s principal residence and explains the occupation declaration. A damaged house can therefore raise more than one issue: the annual taxe foncière, the housing tax applicable to a furnished second home, and, in some areas and circumstances, a vacancy-related tax. A request under Article 1389 concerns the property tax and should not be presented as an automatic cancellation of every local tax appearing on the account.
The same distinction applies to the French declaration of occupation. Under the current version of Article 1418 of the French Tax Code, owners must provide information about the nature of occupation of housing premises, including the reason for a vacancy when the premises are vacant. For an American owner, the online form in the “Gérer mes biens immobiliers” service can be unfamiliar. The declaration is administrative information used to manage local taxes; changing the occupation label to “vacant” does not itself grant an Article 1389 reduction. The claim still requires the separate proof of legal eligibility.
“Uninhabitable” is likewise a factual description, not the complete statutory test. A municipal safety order, an insurer’s expert report, or an engineer’s report may show that occupation was unsafe. It can help establish that the absence of a tenant was not a casual choice. It does not, alone, show that the house was normally intended for rental, that the owner had made it available to tenants, or that the vacancy affected a legally separable part for at least three months. The tax office can ask what the property was intended to do before the damage and what the owner did afterward.
That is why the owner should first classify the factual situation:
- A house used solely by the American family as a vacation home is normally a personal second home. Its being empty or unsafe will not ordinarily satisfy the rental-vacancy category in Article 1389.
- A house acquired and maintained as a long-term rental, advertised to tenants, and temporarily unavailable because of an event outside the owner’s control may fit the statutory route.
- A furnished holiday rental or occasional Airbnb listing requires a careful analysis. Short stays alone do not answer whether the property was offered for rental throughout the relevant period.
- A commercial or industrial building follows a different branch of Article 1389 and is not the ordinary route for a residential second home.
In other words, the strongest answer to “my French second home is uninhabitable; can I stop paying?” is usually “not automatically.” The stronger legal question is “was this dwelling normally intended for rental, was the rental interruption independent of my will, did it last at least three months, and can I prove the precise eligible months?” That is the framework a French claim must address.
B. When Article 1389 can cover a property normally intended for rental
Article 1389 of the French Tax Code is the central rule. Its first paragraph states that taxpayers may obtain a property-tax reduction in the event of vacancy of a house “normalement destinée à la location,” meaning normally intended for rental, and its second sentence imposes three conditions. The text says: “Le dégrèvement est subordonné à la triple condition que la vacance ou l’inexploitation soit indépendante de la volonté du contribuable, qu’elle ait une durée de trois mois au moins et qu’elle affecte soit la totalité de l’immeuble, soit une partie susceptible de location ou d’exploitation séparée.” A dégrèvement is a remission or reduction of an assessed tax. It is not a waiver that arises merely because a building is unusable.
The first condition is legal purpose. A personal second home is not transformed into a rental property simply because the owner once considered renting it, asked a realtor for an estimate, or listed it for a few weeks. Evidence should show a real rental plan: a management agreement, rental advertisements, a normal asking rent, prior leases, tenant applications, a continuing relationship with a letting agency, or written records showing that the owner was seeking tenants. If the property was always reserved for the owner’s family, the Article 1389 claim is weak even if a storm or fire later prevents occupation.
The second condition is effective vacancy and involuntariness. The French tax authority will want to see both the physical interruption and the reason it was outside the owner’s control. A fire, flood, major water leak, structural movement, or official order can be relevant. So can a serious condominium defect if the owner took reasonable steps to obtain repairs. The evidence should establish the date on which the dwelling could no longer be offered or occupied in its intended rental condition and the date on which it became available again. A vague statement such as “the house was bad for most of the year” leaves the tax office unable to calculate the statutory period.
French administrative case law shows why the owner must prove personal diligence. In Conseil d’État, 29 August 2008, no. 300444, a co-owner argued that serious defects in the common areas made the apartment vacant. The Conseil d’État required the analysis to focus on that taxpayer’s own will, then held on the facts that she had not shown the necessary steps toward the condominium bodies. The decision records the practical question: did the owner take the necessary steps to have the condominium carry out the work needed to remedy the disorder and secure the building? For an American living thousands of miles away, emails to the property manager, registered letters, meeting minutes, votes, contractor requests, and insurance correspondence may be decisive.
The third condition is duration. The vacancy must last at least three months. The period is not measured by how long the owner feels unable to use the house, and it is not necessarily the same as the insurer’s claim period. If a flood occurs on April 10 and the home is ready for a tenant on September 20, the potential full-month period generally begins on May 1 and ends on September 30, subject to the other conditions. If the property was only partly affected, the affected part must be capable of separate rental. A bedroom that cannot be used may not automatically be a separable rental unit; an independent apartment or separately rentable floor may be easier to analyze.
The “normally intended for rental” requirement deserves special attention for short-term rental activity. In Conseil d’État, 14 April 2008, no. 289978, the property was offered for rental throughout the year, although the owner rented it for short periods. The court rejected the idea that short leases alone proved that the property was not normally intended for rental. But the taxpayer still lost on the evidence because she did not establish that the vacancy was independent of her will. This means that a short stay is not automatically disqualifying, but it is also not enough by itself. The owner must show a genuine year-round rental offer and an involuntary interruption.
The official tax guidance is more cautious about seasonal property. The BOFiP guidance on Article 1389 explains that the relief concerns residential premises intended to be rented and actually offered for rental, and notes that properties allocated to seasonal rental are generally excluded. The distinction between the 2008 case and the general administrative guidance is important. A large property offered to the market throughout the year, even through short stays, is not the same as a family vacation home that is occasionally offered when the owner does not want to use it. The file should describe the actual rental calendar, not rely on the label “vacation rental.”
The Supreme Administrative Court has also warned against treating building defects as automatically involuntary. In Conseil d’État, 29 June 2020, no. 434521, the dispute concerned an industrial facility, not a dwelling. The court stated that circumstances inherent in the building, including defects and administrative decisions taken because of those defects, did not by themselves establish that non-operation was forced. The case cannot be copied mechanically onto a residential fire or flood claim, but it is a useful warning: the owner must connect the defect to a concrete, unavoidable interruption and show what was done to remedy it. A decision to leave a damaged property untouched for years can be treated differently from an owner who promptly engages insurers, engineers, contractors, and the condominium.
A recent procedural decision reinforces the need for a complete file. In Conseil d’État, 29 June 2026, no. 513256, the taxpayer challenged property-tax assessments covering several years and argued, among other points, that the lower court had erred by considering that partial works or a sale could have been undertaken. The Conseil d’État stated that none of the grounds justified admission of the appeal and that the appeal was not admitted. This is not a merits ruling granting a reduction to every owner whose home is damaged. It does, however, identify the evidentiary pressure points that a claimant should address: whether practical works were possible, whether a sale was a genuine alternative, and whether the continuing vacancy really remained outside the owner’s will.
Finally, a sale does not automatically destroy a claim if the property remains genuinely offered for rent. In Conseil d’État, 5 June 2020, no. 423066, the court held that “La seule circonstance qu’un bien demeurant effectivement proposé à la location soit mis en vente n’est pas de nature à priver le contribuable du bénéfice du dégrèvement prévu au I de l’article 1389 du code général des impôts.” The French sentence means that placing a property on the market does not, by itself, defeat the relief when the property is still genuinely offered for rental. An American owner who is considering a sale after major damage should therefore preserve rental advertisements and agency instructions if the property remained available for tenants. Conversely, an owner who withdrew every rental offer and kept the home for personal use should not present a sale listing as proof of a rental purpose.
The practical answer is therefore conditional. A personal second home that is uninhabitable may support an insurance claim, a housing-tax correction, an assessment challenge, or another remedy, but Article 1389 normally requires more: a residential rental purpose, actual efforts to rent, an involuntary interruption, three months at least, and an affected whole or separately rentable part. The nationality of the owner does not relax those elements.
II. How should an American prove the claim and challenge the bill?
A. What evidence, calculation, and deadline should be sent from the United States?
An American owner should prepare the claim as a French administrative tax file, even if it is assembled from a U.S. address. Begin with the notice: identify the tax year, the cadastral references, the property address, the municipality, the assessed amount, and every ancillary line. Include the deed or ownership document if the tax office needs confirmation of the taxpayer, but do not make nationality the center of the argument. The center of the argument should be the Article 1389 timeline and the evidence of rental purpose.
The most useful evidence is organized by issue rather than placed in a random bundle:
- For rental purpose: prior residential leases, a letting-agency mandate, dated listings, market-rent estimates, tenant inquiries, applications, calendars showing availability, and records of rent negotiations.
- For the physical condition: photographs and videos with dates, the insurer’s adjuster report, fire or emergency-service records, an architect or engineer’s report, a municipal arrêté de mise en sécurité or other safety order if one exists, contractor estimates, and utility or access records showing when the premises could not safely be offered.
- For involuntariness: insurance notifications, claims correspondence, notices from the municipality or condominium, repair requests, registered letters, meeting minutes, expert appointments, and proof of reasonable efforts to obtain the works.
- For the period: a simple chronology with the event date, the first month after the event, the date the property became usable or rentable, and the full months claimed.
- For the calculation: a copy of each relevant tax notice, the annual amount, the number of eligible full months, and the requested reduction, with any separately affected unit identified.
There is no reason to wait for a perfect package before preserving the deadline. Send the claim with the evidence available, explain what additional report is pending, and supplement it promptly. Documents in English can be attached, but a concise French cover letter or French summary makes the legal issue easier for the local tax service to process. If a report is central to the dispute, a reliable French translation may be preferable to an unexplained technical document. Keep the original files, metadata, invoices, and proof of transmission.
The calculation is based on full months, not a daily percentage. The official impots.gouv.fr guidance on an unoccupied or vacant house explains that the relief is calculated by whole twelfths, beginning on the first day of the month following the start of the vacancy and ending on the last day of the month in which the vacancy ends. A simple illustration is useful:
- If an eligible rental house becomes unavailable on March 12 and is ready on August 4, the potential calculation period starts April 1 and ends August 31: five full months, subject to proof and the three-month condition.
- If a house becomes unavailable on November 10, 2025 and remains unavailable until February 15, 2026, the potential months are December 2025, January 2026, and February 2026. The claim must address each tax year separately because each notice covers an annual assessment.
- If only an independent apartment in a larger building is affected, explain why that part could be rented separately and identify the evidence for that unit. A general statement that the entire building was inconvenient may not establish a separately rentable part.
Article 1389 itself sends the claimant to the procedural deadline in Article R-star-196-5 of the Book of Tax Procedures. Article R*196-5 states: “Les dégrèvements de taxe foncière prévus par l’article 1389 du code général des impôts pour vacance d’une maison ou inexploitation d’un immeuble à usage industriel ou commercial, doivent être demandés au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle au cours de laquelle la vacance ou l’inexploitation atteint la durée minimum exigée.” In English, the claim must generally be made no later than December 31 of the year following the year in which the vacancy reaches the required minimum duration.
That rule is easy to miss when an American owner is waiting for the final insurance settlement. If the three-month minimum is reached during 2025, the Article 1389 claim deadline is generally December 31, 2026. If it is reached during 2026, the deadline is generally December 31, 2027. A continuing repair dispute does not justify assuming that the clock is suspended. Record the deadline when the three-month period is reached and send a formal claim before it expires.
The filing should also explain whether the requested months include the taxe d’enlèvement des ordures ménagères (TEOM), the household-waste collection charge often shown with property tax. The tax administration states that an Article 1389 reduction can extend to the property tax and related taxes assessed on the same basis, including TEOM. Do not assume that a separate housing-tax or vacancy-tax line follows exactly the same calculation. Ask for the legal treatment of each line rather than claiming a blanket refund.
There are other statutory routes that should not be confused with Article 1389. For example, Article 1383 of the French Tax Code provides that new constructions, reconstructions, and additions used as housing are exempt from built-property tax during the two years following completion, subject to the statute’s local-authority rules and limitations. A new French house that is also damaged may raise a new-construction issue and a vacancy issue, but they require different facts and dates. A repair project does not automatically restart or extend the two-year new-build period.
Likewise, a mistake in the cadastral description, ownership, assessment base, or local rate is an assessment challenge, not necessarily a vacancy claim. The Service-Public information on challenging local taxes explains that the taxpayer can ask the tax office for information about the cadastral rental value and contest the basis or amount. An American owner should plead every genuinely supported ground separately: Article 1389 for eligible rental vacancy, an assessment error if one exists, and another statutory exemption only if its conditions are met.
The France–U.S. treaty is relevant to the cross-border context but does not turn the French claim into a U.S. tax filing. The official consolidated France–U.S. convention on income and wealth identifies in Article 2 the French taxes covered by the convention and states in Article 6 that “Les revenus provenant de biens immobiliers … situés dans un Etat contractant sont imposables dans cet Etat.” That treaty rule can matter to rental income and the allocation of income-tax jurisdiction. It does not replace the domestic Article 1389 conditions for local taxe foncière. The local property-tax file should therefore be made to the French service responsible for the property, while any rental income and U.S. reporting are analyzed separately.
B. What happens if the tax office rejects the claim or confuses it with another tax?
The first procedural step is an administrative réclamation, meaning a formal tax claim or objection. Article R*190-1 of the Book of Tax Procedures provides: “Le contribuable qui désire contester tout ou partie d’un impôt qui le concerne doit d’abord adresser une réclamation au service territorial, selon le cas, de la direction générale des finances publiques ou de la direction générale des douanes et droits indirects dont dépend le lieu de l’imposition.” The claim goes first to the territorial tax service connected to the property, not directly to a French court and not to the Internal Revenue Service.
For an owner in the United States, use the contact information on the French tax notice and preserve the transmission record. Depending on access to a French online tax account, the claim may be sent through secure messaging, by mail, or through the channel indicated by the local service. The cover letter should state “réclamation contentieuse – demande de dégrèvement de taxe foncière au titre de l’article 1389 du CGI,” identify the notice and property, give the exact vacancy dates, set out the three statutory conditions, attach the evidence, and calculate the requested amount. Ask for a written receipt or decision. A French-language title is useful even when the supporting explanation is in English.
The legal nature of the claim is important. Article L190 of the Book of Tax Procedures describes contentieux claims as those seeking correction of errors in the assessment or calculation of taxes or the benefit of a right arising from a legislative or regulatory provision. An Article 1389 request is therefore not a courtesy request for the mayor or an informal request to waive a bill. It is a statutory tax claim supported by facts and evidence.
Do not wait to see whether the tax office’s first telephone answer is favorable. A call can help identify the right service, but it does not necessarily preserve a formal deadline. Send a written claim, attach the notice, and keep a complete copy. If the property is jointly owned, identify each taxpayer and explain who is making the claim. If the owner has died, sold the property, or appointed a representative, include the authority documents that explain who may continue the administrative process.
A refusal may result from a factual finding rather than a disagreement about the word “uninhabitable.” Common reasons include: the house was a personal second home; there was no evidence it was effectively offered to tenants; the rental offer was only seasonal or occasional; the owner could have carried out reasonable repairs; the owner did not act with the condominium; the affected rooms were not separately rentable; the claimed period had not reached three months; or the claim was late. The response should address the specific reason, not simply repeat that the home was empty.
For example, if the office says the house was a personal second home, provide the rental mandate, dated advertising, prior leases, rent analysis, and tenant correspondence that existed before the damage. If it says the vacancy was voluntary, provide the insurance report, safety order, repair chronology, contractor delays, and evidence of repeated efforts to restore the premises. If it says the period is too short, recalculate by the full-month rule and show when the three-month minimum was reached. If it says the property could have been sold, explain why a sale did not remove the genuine rental offer, using the principle recognized in Conseil d’État no. 423066 where the evidence supports it.
The taxpayer must also distinguish Article 1389 from the taxes that often appear in the same cross-border conversation. The housing tax on a second home depends on the status and furnishing of the premises on January 1. The tax on vacant housing may follow its own statutory scope and exemptions. A house made unsafe by major work may justify a different request concerning a housing-tax surcharge, but that does not prove a property-tax reduction. Use the correct name of the tax on each line of the notice and ask the service to identify the legal basis for any refusal.
The recent Conseil d’État decision no. 513256 is particularly useful as a procedural warning because it involved a taxpayer who attempted to challenge multiple local taxes over many years. The court recorded that a claim concerning a tax not put into collection, and a claim made without the prior administrative complaint required by Article R*190-1, could be manifestly inadmissible. The lesson for an American owner is simple: identify the exact assessment, file the prior complaint, and do not combine unrelated taxes into a generalized request.
If the administration rejects the claim or grants only part of the requested relief, the next route is the administrative court. Article R*199-1 of the Book of Tax Procedures states that the action must be brought within two months after the taxpayer receives the administration’s decision, whether that decision arrives before or after the six-month period referred to in the provision. It also provides that a taxpayer who has not received a decision within six months may bring the case when that period expires. The court route is technical; a claimant should not assume that sending more emails to the tax office automatically preserves the judicial deadline.
For a claimant domiciled in the United States, the file should be designed for a French judge who has never seen the property. Add a one-page chronology, a plan or photographs showing the affected areas, a translation of the decisive technical findings, a map or cadastral reference, and a calculation that can be checked without reconstructing the entire insurance dispute. Explain the difference between a personal second home and a rental dwelling in the owner’s own words. If the claim concerns a condominium, identify the owner-specific steps and the dates of general meetings. If the property was listed for sale as well as rental, show that both offers coexisted and were genuine.
Payment should also be handled deliberately. Filing a claim is not a reason to ignore the payment date printed on the notice. If cash flow is a problem or the owner wants to request a suspension, that issue should be raised expressly under the applicable tax-procedure rules; it should not be assumed to follow from the Article 1389 claim. Keep proof of any payment, because a successful reduction may lead to a refund or credit process separate from the merits of the claim.
Finally, do not let the cross-border aspect obscure the local evidence. The France–U.S. convention, FATCA reporting, U.S. foreign-property records, and federal tax treatment of rental losses may matter to the owner’s overall position. But the French property-tax question remains focused on the French parcel, the French assessment, the Article 1389 conditions, and the French procedural deadline. A well-prepared claim states that boundary clearly and avoids asking the French service to decide an American tax issue it does not administer.
Conclusion
An American cannot normally obtain a French taxe foncière reduction merely by showing that a personal second home is uninhabitable. Article 1380 establishes the annual property-tax principle, while Article 1389 creates a narrow dégrèvement for a house normally intended for rental when the vacancy is independent of the owner’s will, lasts at least three months, and affects the whole property or a separately rentable part. The file should prove rental purpose, physical impossibility, owner diligence, exact dates, full-month calculation, and timely filing by December 31 of the following year after the minimum period is reached. A prior written complaint to the local tax service is required before court proceedings, and a refusal can lead to the administrative court within the applicable deadline. The France–U.S. treaty may govern rental-income questions, but it does not substitute for this domestic French analysis.