KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can an American Use a U.S. LLC to Own French Real Estate? Beneficial Ownership, Tax, and Estate Risks

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can an American Use a U.S. LLC to Own French Real Estate? Beneficial Ownership, Tax, and Estate Risks

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Can an American buy a house, apartment, or rental property in France through a U.S. Limited Liability Company (LLC)? In principle, a foreign company can acquire French real estate. That answer, however, does not make the structure simple, tax-neutral, or invisible. A French notary must identify the entity, verify who controls it, establish that its representative has authority to sign, trace the funds, and understand the intended use of the property. French tax rules can then apply to the building, the rent, the entity, the sale, and the transmission of the membership interests.

The central question is not whether a U.S. LLC exists under the law of Delaware, Wyoming, or another state. It is how France characterizes the LLC for each legal purpose. The United States may treat a single-member LLC as disregarded for federal income tax, while France may examine the entity as a separate legal person. A multi-member LLC may be treated as a partnership in the United States without automatically receiving the same treatment in France. The result affects the purchase deed, annual reporting, rental income, capital gains, wealth taxation, estate planning, and the evidence required when a member dies.

This article gives an American buyer a practical legal map. It distinguishes direct ownership, a French Société civile immobilière (SCI), and a U.S. LLC; explains the main French and treaty rules; identifies the documents that prevent a closing from stalling; and sets out questions to resolve before signing a compromis de vente, the preliminary French sale agreement. It does not replace a coordinated French legal and U.S. tax opinion for a particular LLC, family, property, or state-law operating agreement.

I. Can an American use a U.S. LLC to own French real estate?

A. What does the LLC actually own in France?

A U.S. LLC is not a French SCI. An SCI is a French civil company commonly used to hold and manage real estate. A U.S. LLC is a foreign legal entity created under state law. The first practical distinction is therefore ownership: if the deed names the LLC as purchaser, the LLC—not the American member personally—becomes the registered owner of the French property. The member owns an interest in the LLC and has the rights given by the operating agreement and the law governing that LLC. That separation can be useful for administration, but it also creates a second legal layer at every important event.

French company law illustrates the difference between the concept of a company and the particular form chosen. Article 1832 of the French Civil Code states: “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes”. The provision describes the French contractual foundation of a company; it does not turn a U.S. LLC into an SCI. Likewise, Article 1833 of the Civil Code provides: “Toute société doit avoir un objet licite et être constituée dans l’intérêt commun des associés.” Those rules are helpful reference points for a French lawyer reviewing the purpose, governance, and actual operation of a foreign entity, but the LLC’s formation, member rights, and internal authority still require the relevant U.S. documents and choice-of-law analysis.

The notary will normally want the LLC to be clearly identified in the purchase contract and the authentic deed. The file should explain its exact legal name, state of formation, registration number, registered agent or address, current good-standing status, managers or authorized persons, members or controlling persons, and power to acquire real estate. The notary may request the articles of organization, operating agreement, certificate of existence or good standing, incumbency evidence, a member or manager resolution approving the purchase, and a power of attorney if someone signs in France. The required form varies with the state, the LLC agreement, the notary’s file, the bank, and the transaction.

Documents issued in the United States may need a certified French translation and an apostille or another form of authentication. An apostille does not prove that the transaction is commercially sensible, that the person signing has authority under the operating agreement, or that the structure produces the intended tax result. It authenticates the origin of a public document. The American buyer should have the corporate authority package reviewed before making the final offer, not the evening before the deed signing.

The property’s use must also be stated accurately. A French holiday home used by the members is not the same project as a long-term rental, a furnished tourist rental, a renovation and resale business, or a property used by a French operating company. A personal-use property may raise questions about occupation without rent, private benefits, insurance, utilities, and the accounting treatment of expenses. A rental property raises income tax, local tax, registration, bookkeeping, and possibly VAT or business-tax questions depending on the activity. Calling the purchase an “investment” while allowing unrestricted private use creates an avoidable evidentiary problem.

Acquisition does not depend on French immigration status. An American may generally buy property without becoming a French resident, and ownership does not itself create a visa or residence right. The immigration consequences are outside this article’s scope. The relevant point for the LLC is that the buyer’s residence, citizenship, place of management, and tax status remain facts to document even when the legal owner is a U.S. entity.

Financing adds another layer. A French lender may underwrite the American member, the LLC, the property, or all three. It may ask for U.S. tax returns, bank statements, evidence of the origin of the down payment, entity financial statements, a personal guarantee, and an explanation of how the LLC is taxed in the United States. A French bank and notary will also apply anti-money-laundering controls. The French definition is direct: Article L. 561-2-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code says that “le bénéficiaire effectif est la ou les personnes physiques” who ultimately control the client or for whom the transaction is carried out. In plain English, the LLC cannot be used as a substitute for identifying the human beings behind it.

That identification is not limited to the person signing. The notary will want to understand the ownership chain, trusts, nominee arrangements, voting agreements, and any person who can appoint or remove the manager. A certificate listing the LLC as owner is not enough if the underlying member or trust information is inconsistent. If the person who formed the LLC is not the person funding the purchase, the file should explain the relationship and the transfer of funds. If a family trust, foundation, or another holding company is involved, the file becomes more complex rather than more private.

There is also a practical governance question: who can decide to sell, refinance, renovate, rent, or allow a family member to occupy the property? The operating agreement should answer those questions before the purchase. A French notary cannot safely rely on a vague email saying that one member “handles France” when the LLC agreement requires a member vote or manager approval. A clear written resolution should identify the property, purchase price, financing, signer, and authority to execute the French deed and related documents.

B. Will France recognize the U.S. tax classification?

France does not automatically copy the U.S. federal tax label. The U.S. “check-the-box” classification is a U.S. tax election; it does not decide how a French tax authority, court, bank, or notary sees the entity. A single-member LLC may be disregarded for U.S. federal income tax, so its income is reported by its owner. A multi-member LLC may be treated as a partnership, with income flowing to members. An LLC may also elect corporate treatment. Each description can be accurate in the United States while producing a different French analysis.

The French administration’s official commentary on the France–U.S. income tax convention discusses U.S. LLCs in the context of transparent entities. Its explanation distinguishes an LLC treated as a partnership from a single-member LLC disregarded for U.S. tax purposes. The practical lesson is that the U.S. tax classification must be proved, not assumed. A French adviser will want the operating agreement, the federal election if one exists, tax returns or classification evidence, ownership percentages, and the identity of the person treated as receiving the income. The relevant BOFiP commentary on the France–U.S. convention is useful evidence, but it is an administrative interpretation and must be applied to the actual facts.

For treaty purposes, transparency is not a magic password. The 2004 protocol to the France–U.S. income and wealth tax convention addresses partnerships and similar transparent entities, but benefits depend on the conditions in the convention. A U.S. owner cannot simply assert that the LLC is transparent and demand that France treat the property as if the member bought it personally. The income’s source, the entity’s classification, the residence of the member, the person entitled to the income, and any limitation-on-benefits condition must be checked.

The treaty’s real-estate rule is particularly important on exit. Article 13 of the France–U.S. income and wealth tax convention provides: “Les gains provenant de l’aliénation de biens immobiliers situés dans un Etat contractant sont imposables dans cet Etat.” In English, a gain from selling immovable property located in a contracting state may be taxed by that state. The same article defines French immovable property broadly for some purposes: it includes shares or rights in a company whose assets, or value, are at least 50 percent connected directly or indirectly to French real estate, and rights in a partnership, estate, or trust to the extent their value derives from French real estate. An LLC interest therefore requires a treaty analysis; it is not safe to assume that selling an interest always moves the gain outside France.

The convention also contains a wealth rule. Its Article 23 states that wealth constituted by shares or rights in a company whose assets or value are at least 50 percent derived directly or indirectly from French real estate may be taxable in France. The official French text of Article 23 uses the threshold and indirect-value language. The French wealth tax currently known as impôt sur la fortune immobilière (IFI) is fact-sensitive, has exclusions and debt rules, and should not be calculated from the LLC’s bank balance alone. A U.S. member who is French-resident, or whose French real-estate interests cross the applicable thresholds, needs a specific IFI review.

An LLC can also create a mismatch between the entity’s accounting and the member’s tax return. France may tax French-source rent at the entity level or attribute it through a transparent analysis, while the United States may report the same rent on the member’s return. The treaty’s double-tax relief mechanism is not an automatic refund: the income must be correctly characterized, the tax must be imposed on the right person, and the relevant credit limitations must be respected. Keep a schedule matching the French property, the LLC books, French tax filings, U.S. returns, exchange rates, and distributions for every year.

The structure should therefore be chosen only after answering four classification questions in writing:

  • Is the LLC a separate legal owner under its state law, and who has authority to bind it?
  • Is it disregarded, a partnership, or a corporation for U.S. federal tax, and can that status be documented?
  • Will France treat the French-source income as received by the LLC, its members, or another taxable person?
  • Does the intended treaty article apply to the actual owner, income, gain, or wealth—not merely to the label “LLC”?

If any answer is uncertain, the buyer should pause the structure decision, not the property search. The same property can be purchased directly, through a French SCI, or through the U.S. entity, but the contracts, tax filings, and succession consequences are different.

II. What are the French tax, estate, and compliance risks?

A. What taxes and reports apply to the LLC and its owner?

The most overlooked French risk is often not the purchase duty. It is the ongoing tax profile of a foreign entity that owns French real estate. Rent from a French property is French-source income. A U.S. LLC that rents the building may face French corporate income tax or another French regime depending on its legal form, activity, and classification. Article 206 of the French General Tax Code brings within corporate income tax, among other entities, legal persons carrying out a profitable operation. Its wording includes “toutes autres personnes morales se livrant à une exploitation ou à des opérations de caractère lucratif.” Article 209 of the same Code then refers to profits from enterprises operated in France, specified French-source income, and income allocated to France by an international tax convention.

This is not only a theoretical risk. The Conseil d’État has addressed foreign companies receiving income from French property. In 30 May 1980, no. 12790, it accepted that a Swiss company renting a French apartment could be subject to French corporate income tax even without a French permanent establishment. In 18 January 1984, no. 24343, the Conseil d’État considered a foreign entity conducting profitable operations in France. In 31 March 1993, no. 82395, it examined a Liechtenstein entity holding French properties. These decisions do not decide every LLC case, but they make one point clear: absence of a French office does not, by itself, make French real-estate income disappear from the French tax system.

The 3 percent tax on the market value of French real estate is a separate trap. It is known as the taxe sur la valeur vénale des immeubles (TVVI), meaning the tax on the market value of buildings. Article 990 D of the General Tax Code provides that legal entities which directly or through an interposed entity own French buildings or real rights over them are liable for a tax described as a “taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale” of those buildings or rights. The official French tax administration explanation of the 3 percent tax expressly includes French and foreign legal entities and direct or indirect ownership.

The rate does not mean that every U.S. LLC will ultimately pay 3 percent each year. There are exemptions and declaration routes. The correct approach is to test the LLC against the current text, document the exemption, and calendar any annual declaration. Article 990 E of the General Tax Code includes an exemption where an entity declares, no later than 15 May, the situation, composition, and value of the French property and the identity and address of members holding more than 1 percent, among other conditions. A U.S. LLC should not rely on an informal statement that it is “small” or “foreign.” The property value, ownership chain, business use, treaty position, and disclosure must be checked for the relevant year.

Current law also deserves attention when the entity has no French permanent establishment. Article 990 FA of the General Tax Code provides that an entity subject to the declaration obligations under Articles 990 E and 990 F, when it has no French permanent establishment, must designate a person or entity domiciled or established in France to receive communications, procedural documents, and notices connected with the 3 percent tax. A compliance failure can therefore become a service-of-process problem as well as a tax problem. The buyer should identify who will receive French tax correspondence before closing.

Local property taxes remain distinct. The entity or occupant may face taxe foncière, the annual property tax, and the rules for taxe d’habitation or other local charges depend on the property’s status and use. If the LLC runs furnished rentals or another business, additional registration and tax questions can arise. These amounts cannot be inferred from the purchase price or from the fact that the owner is a U.S. taxpayer. The notary’s closing statement is not a substitute for a recurring French compliance calendar.

Sale taxation requires two parallel calculations: the tax on selling the building and the tax on selling the LLC interest. The treaty may allocate taxing rights differently depending on whether the transaction is an asset sale or an interest sale, the type of entity, the percentage of real-estate value, the seller’s residence, and the buyer’s status. The French tax administration may require a filing or withholding at the time of sale. A U.S. tax return may also report the transaction, with basis, depreciation, currency, and entity-classification issues. The member should obtain a written sale model before contributing funds or refinancing the property.

Do not confuse TVVI with capital-gains tax, local property tax, income tax, or estate tax. Each has a different base, event, declaration, and relief mechanism. An LLC that is acceptable for purchase financing can still be expensive to operate if the annual property-value declaration, rental filings, accounts, and U.S. information returns were never planned.

On the American side, the filing depends on the LLC’s federal classification and the member’s profile. A single-member disregarded LLC, a partnership-classified LLC, and an entity that elected corporate treatment may trigger different federal returns and information forms. Foreign bank accounts, foreign financial assets, and French property may also affect FBAR or Form 8938 analysis. A U.S. CPA should map the French entity and the French property to the actual federal forms; the buyer should not reuse a domestic LLC checklist without that review.

Maintain an annual document set containing the French deed, property-tax notices, rental agreements, invoices, insurance, bank statements, market-value evidence, LLC minutes, ownership register, U.S. tax classification, French filings, U.S. filings, and proof of taxes paid. Keep translations and exchange-rate calculations with the source documents. This record is especially valuable if the property is sold, a member moves to France, the LLC changes its tax election, or a family member dies.

B. What happens on a sale, death, or family dispute?

An LLC may make the property easier to hold administratively, but it does not make the family’s legal problem disappear. The operating agreement should address death, incapacity, divorce, bankruptcy, a disagreement over sale, a member’s desire to exit, and the valuation of an interest. It should also state whether a membership interest can be transferred to a trust, spouse, child, or outsider; whether the company can buy back the interest; and who controls the property while the estate is being settled. These clauses must be compared with the member’s will, revocable trust, beneficiary designations, premarital agreement, and the succession law that may apply.

French direct co-ownership provides a useful comparison. The French word indivision means ownership of one asset by several people in undivided shares. Article 815 of the Civil Code states: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué”. In practical terms, a co-owner can generally seek an end to the co-ownership, subject to a court judgment or agreement delaying the partition. A company can replace that direct partition mechanism with membership rights and operating-agreement rules, but it replaces it with governance risk, valuation disputes, and creditor issues.

Management of an indivision also has its own thresholds. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code states that co-owners holding at least two-thirds of the undivided rights may perform certain acts of administration and give some mandates. That rule does not govern a U.S. LLC. The LLC’s operating agreement may require a majority, supermajority, or unanimous consent, and a French notary will need evidence that the required vote occurred. Families should compare the two decision systems before selecting the entity.

Contributions and improvements can also produce claims among co-owners. Article 815-13 of the Civil Code provides that when a co-owner improves an undivided asset at that person’s expense, the contribution must be taken into account according to equity. In an LLC, the equivalent issue may appear as a member loan, capital contribution, unreimbursed renovation, or an undocumented private expense. Decide in advance whether a member’s payment increases capital, creates a debt, or is a gift to the company. Keep invoices and written approvals.

A French SCI is not automatically better, but it offers a familiar French framework for family ownership. Its liabilities are not automatically limited in the way many Americans expect from an LLC. Article 1857 of the Civil Code states: “A l’égard des tiers, les associés répondent indéfiniment des dettes sociales”. An SCI’s statutes can organize management, approval of transfers, and the continuation of the company after a death, but the unlimited nature of the members’ liability must be accepted. A U.S. LLC may offer a different liability architecture under its governing state law, yet guarantees, misuse of the entity, tax recharacterization, insolvency, and French enforcement still have to be assessed.

French law also contains a specific rule for the company becoming single-member. Article 1844-5 of the Civil Code provides: “La réunion de toutes les parts sociales en une seule main n’entraîne pas la dissolution de plein droit de la société.” This is a rule about French companies, not a universal rule for U.S. LLCs. It is nevertheless a useful warning: the death or transfer of the second member should be planned under the LLC’s own law, and the family should not assume that the company automatically dissolves or automatically continues in the desired form.

Succession is where the American “wrapper” theory most often fails. An LLC interest is an asset that must pass through an estate or another valid transfer mechanism. The death certificate, will, probate or trust documents, operating agreement, member ledger, valuation, tax clearances, and authority of the personal representative may all be required. If the LLC owns French real estate, the French notary will still need to deal with the property, its title, taxes, and any deed or registration consequences. If the LLC interest is transferred to children, a spouse, or a trust, the transfer may trigger French gift or inheritance tax questions even when the underlying building is not conveyed by a French deed.

The France–U.S. estate and gift tax convention must be read separately from the income tax convention. France published the original convention in Decree no. 80-771 of 24 September 1980. The French tax administration’s official BOFiP summary of the France–U.S. estate and gift tax convention records that it applies to estates of persons who died and gifts made from 1 October 1980, and that the 2004 amendment entered into force on 21 December 2006. The 2007 decree publishing the amendment must be checked with the original treaty and the facts of the transfer.

That treaty does not mean that a U.S. citizen can place a French home in an LLC and remove it from every French tax analysis. The treaty considers domicile, citizenship, the situs of property, the type of asset, the identity of the transferor, and the identity of the recipient. The 2004 amendment also preserves important U.S. taxing rights over a U.S. citizen’s estate or gift in circumstances described by the treaty. French property and an interest in a property-heavy entity must be analyzed under the relevant treaty articles and domestic rules. Obtain the French succession opinion and the U.S. estate-tax opinion together; a one-country memo can miss the credit or classification problem in the other country.

Forced-heirship risk also remains a live planning issue. French réserve héréditaire is the protected portion of an estate reserved for certain descendants when French succession law applies. A U.S. LLC does not make children, a spouse, or other protected heirs vanish. The governing succession law, the deceased person’s habitual residence, a valid choice of law, the location and nature of assets, and the estate documents must be reviewed. A transfer made during life can also be tested as a gift rather than treated as an ordinary business transaction. Do not use an operating agreement to promise a family result that the will, trust, treaty, and mandatory succession rules cannot deliver.

Valuation is central. The value of an LLC interest may reflect the French property’s market value, debt, tax liabilities, rental contracts, minority status, transfer restrictions, and cash. A simple estimate based on the property’s purchase price is inadequate at a death or gift. The valuation should identify the date, the method, the debt, the condition of the property, the membership percentage, and the legal restrictions. Keep the appraisal with the estate file and update it when the property or ownership changes.

Before signing, use this practical sequence:

  1. Define the objective. Decide whether the property is for personal use, long-term rent, furnished rent, resale, or a family investment. State who may occupy it and who pays expenses.
  2. Map the owners. Identify every member, manager, trust, entity, controller, and source of funds. Confirm that the ownership chain can be disclosed to the notary and bank.
  3. Test the tax classification. Obtain written French and U.S. analyses covering rent, sale, TVVI, IFI, treaty relief, U.S. reporting, and currency.
  4. Review the entity authority. Confirm good standing, the signer’s authority, required votes, the power of attorney, and whether the operating agreement permits French real-estate ownership and the proposed use.
  5. Draft the compromis carefully. Name the LLC correctly, attach appropriate conditions precedent, address financing and document delivery, allocate taxes and costs, and allow enough time for translation and authentication.
  6. Prepare the succession file. Coordinate the operating agreement, will or trust, beneficiary designations, valuation method, transfer restrictions, and the France–U.S. estate and gift tax analysis.
  7. Calendar compliance. Track French property taxes, rental declarations, entity accounts, TVVI or exemption filings, tax correspondence, U.S. returns, and changes in members or managers.

Use a French SCI or direct ownership instead when it produces a clearer answer to the family’s real problem. Direct ownership may be easier for one buyer who wants a simple home. Indivision may be appropriate for two buyers who accept its exit rules and document their contributions. A French SCI may suit a family that needs French governance and gradual transfers, provided it accepts the liabilities and tax rules. A U.S. LLC may be justified where there is a genuine U.S. business, liability, financing, or estate-planning reason, but the reason should survive a French tax and succession review. A desire for secrecy, a promise of “no French tax,” or a copied internet diagram is not a sufficient reason.

For an American already under contract, the urgent questions are narrower: Is the LLC named correctly in the compromis? Has the notary approved the corporate document package? Has the French tax classification been written down? Has the 3 percent property-value exposure been tested? Can the signer’s authority be proved? Does the will or trust coordinate with the LLC agreement? Has a U.S. CPA reviewed the French property and the chosen federal classification? If any answer is no, seek advice before the deadline for the next contractual step.

Conclusion

For the wider purchase process, see our legal checklist for buying property in France as an American.

An American can often use a U.S. LLC to acquire French real estate, but the entity does not turn French property into an American-only asset. France can tax French rent and gains, require property-value disclosures, identify the human beneficial owners, and apply its own rules to the building, its use, its sale, and the estate of a member. The France–U.S. income and estate-tax conventions can allocate taxing rights or provide relief, but only after the entity, income, gain, wealth, domicile, and transfer are correctly classified.

The safest decision is made before the offer: compare direct ownership, a French SCI, and the U.S. LLC against the buyer’s actual use, financing, family, tax residence, succession documents, and exit plan. Then obtain a coordinated French notarial or legal review and U.S. tax review, preserve the evidence, and operate the chosen structure consistently. If the LLC is used, treat it as a real legal and accounting project—not as a privacy label attached to a French house.

📄 Official circular