On 30 September 2026, the Fourth Chamber of the General Court of the European Union delivered its judgment in Case T-323/25, Vladimir Avetisyan v Council of the European Union (ECLI:EU:T:2026:608), and annulled four European Union acts of March and September 2025 insofar as those acts kept the applicant’s name on the sanctions lists adopted over Russia’s actions against Ukraine. The applicant had been listed in June 2024 as the director general and founder of a Russian management company serving clients in the electronic-components sector. He then sold his entire shareholding in October 2024, produced a notarised sale contract and an official company-register extract, and asked the Council to reassess his situation. The Council maintained the listing twice in 2025 without, in the Court’s view, carrying out an updated assessment. The Court therefore found a manifest error of assessment and annulled the two 2025 maintaining acts as far as they concerned him, while rejecting his claim for damages and ordering each party to bear its own costs. The ruling does not end the story: later maintaining acts and a possible appeal by the Council mean the practical freeze continues, as the European Union’s own sanctions tracker still returns an active 2026 designation entry for the same person. The analysis below is general in scope: it explains the review standards and the remedies available in any comparable listing, and it states no finding about any individual’s situation beyond the facts sourced from the judgment itself. Part I sets out why the 2025 relistings were annulled. Part II explains, from a French practitioner’s perspective, how any listed person can challenge a European Union listing and manage frozen funds from France.
I. Why Did the General Court Annul the 2025 Acts Keeping the Applicant on the Russia List?
A. What Reason Did the Council Give for Keeping a Former Manager on the List?
European Union sanctions against Russia rest on two parallel instruments: Council Decision 2014/145/CFSP, which defines the political framework, and Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014, which is directly applicable in all Member States and imposes the asset freeze itself. Both instruments were amended in early 2022 to widen the designation criteria. The criterion applied in this case, known as criterion f), targets persons who materially or financially support the Russian government. In the words of Article 2(1)(f) of Decision 2014/145, as amended: à des personnes physiques ou morales, des entités ou des organismes qui apportent un soutien matériel ou financier au gouvernement de la Fédération de Russie, qui est responsable de l’annexion de la Crimée et de la déstabilisation de l’Ukraine, ou qui tirent avantage de ce gouvernement
. Article 3(1)(f) of Regulation No 269/2014 mirrors that wording and adds the operative freeze: all funds and economic resources belonging to listed persons are frozen, and no funds or economic resources may be made available to them. Anyone dealing with a European bank from Paris to Warsaw meets this mechanism daily: once a name sits in Annex I of the regulation, every bank in the Union must freeze without waiting for a national transposing measure.
By Decision (CFSP) 2024/1738 of 24 June 2024 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/1746 of the same day, the Council added the applicant’s name to those lists. The statement of reasons read, in full: De par sa qualité de directeur général et fondateur de LLC RBA-Management, Vladimir Avetisyan est responsable de ses actes et il apporte donc un soutien matériel au gouvernement de la Fédération de Russie, qui est responsable de l’annexion de la Crimée et de la déstabilisation de l’Ukraine.
The longer reasoning explained that RBA-Management is a Russian management company providing legal, accounting, corporate-security and other management services, working with clients specialised in the supply of electronic components, and that it manages JSC Compel, which takes part in electronic-component import schemes and supplies microelectronic components of strategic importance to Russian industry, including the military industry. On 6 September 2024 the Council sent the applicant its evidence file, registered as WK 7807/2024 and dated 31 May 2024, and on 12 September 2024 it adopted the first maintaining acts keeping him on the lists.
Events then moved in two opposite directions. The applicant filed a review request on 31 October 2024, invoking a complete change of personal situation: he stated that he had resigned from his functions and sold 100 percent of the shares of RBA-Management on 29 October 2024 to a Mr Gurin, under a notarised contract recording a sale price of 14,700,000 roubles, about 161,000 euros, a sale confirmed by an extract of the Russian unified state register of legal entities dated 7 November 2024 naming Mr Gurin as founder. The Council answered by letter of 17 March 2025, then adopted Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/527 on 14 March 2025, and Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894 on 12 September 2025, each time maintaining the applicant on the lists on the same ground as before: his past responsibility for the acts of RBA-Management. The Council dismissed the new evidence as lacking probative value, describing the resignation as apparent only, the sale price as derisory, and a supporting opinion from the applicant’s Russian lawyer as a document prepared for the proceedings. Those four 2025 acts became the target of the action for annulment decided on 30 September 2026.
B. Why Did the Court Find a Manifest Error of Assessment?
The Court examined the evidence in two stages, and the first stage already weakened the Council’s position. It is true that a memorandum from the applicant’s own Russian lawyer, drafted for the purposes of the case, carries little probative weight. But the Council’s attack on the sale itself collapsed: its claim that the agreed price was derisory rested on a misreading of the contract, which records 14,700,000 roubles and not the figure cited by the Council. The contract takes the form of a notarial deed, which gives it a degree of probative value, and the transfer is independently confirmed by the Russian company-register extract of 7 November 2024. Hence the Court’s blunt finding: C’est donc à tort que le Conseil soutient que les preuves produites par le requérant étaient dépourvues de valeur probante.
For practitioners, the lesson is concrete. A review file built on a notarised deed plus an official public-register extract is far harder to discard than press cuttings or self-serving statements, and a court in Luxembourg will check the Council’s arithmetic line by line.
The second stage goes to the heart of every relisting practice. By the time the Council adopted the March 2025 maintaining acts, its evidence file dated back to 31 May 2024 and predated the October 2024 sale. The applicant argued that the file was obsolete and that the Council had failed to factor in his changed situation. The Court agreed, relying on the wording of criterion f) itself: the persons covered are those who apportent
, in the present tense, material or financial support to the Russian government. That present-tense reading follows the judgment of 10 July 2024 in Rashevsky v Council (T-309/22 and T-739/22, EU:T:2024:455, point 173) and the opinion of Advocate General Biondi in the joined Latvia, Aven and Fridman appeal cases (C-440/24 P and C-441/24 P, EU:C:2025:854, point 115): support must exist on the date the maintaining act is adopted. The Court recalled the settled balance. A person who has left a structure does not automatically escape the lists, because past activities may still shape present conduct. But past functions, taken alone, can never justify keeping a name on the lists: prises isolément, les anciennes fonctions d’une personne ne sauraient justifier l’inscription du nom de cette dernière sur les listes en cause.
If the Council wishes to rely on the past, it must advance serious and consistent indicia that the person still maintains links with the structure at the date of the act. Here, the September 2025 statements of reasons relied exclusively on the fact that the applicant had, in the past, been responsible for the acts of RBA-Management. That backward-looking reasoning could not satisfy a present-tense criterion, so the single plea was upheld and the four 2025 acts were annulled insofar as they concerned the applicant.
Victory on annulment did not produce victory on damages. The applicant sought the non-contractual liability of the Union under Article 340 TFEU, arguing that the Council’s stereotyped reply of 17 March 2025 to his October 2024 review request had prolonged the freeze by about two years. He quantified his loss at 42,480 euros of rental income from a property in Yerevan, Armenia, plus 150,000 euros of lost turnover, because Armenian banks refused services to internationally sanctioned persons and blocked his plan to settle and invest there. The Court recalled the three cumulative conditions of Union liability, citing HTTS v Council (C-123/18 P, EU:C:2019:694) and Tokareva v Council (T-744/22, EU:T:2024:608): a sufficiently serious breach of a rule conferring rights on individuals, actual damage, and a direct causal link. Since the conditions are cumulative, the failure of one disposes of the whole claim without examining the others. The damages claim failed, the action was dismissed for the remainder, and because each side partly succeeded and partly lost, each was ordered to bear its own costs. The judgment also confirms a procedural point of general value: a Council appeal to the Court of Justice under Article 256 TFEU remains available within the statutory period, and the practical effects of the annulment for a regulation-type measure are deferred accordingly, which is one reason a courtroom win does not instantly reopen bank accounts.
II. How Can a Listed Person Challenge a European Union Listing and Unfreeze Funds From France?
A. Which Actions Can Be Brought in Luxembourg Against a Listing?
The first remedy is administrative and can be used at any time: any listed person may send the Council a reasoned review request with fresh evidence, such as proof of resignation, disposal of shares, or closure of the business line that grounded the designation. The Council periodically reviews every entry, and a documented change of situation must be examined rather than filed away. The present judgment shows what happens when that examination is skipped. But a review request alone rarely moves a file, so it should be prepared from the start as the exhibit bundle of a future court action: dated corporate documents, notarial deeds, official register extracts with translations, and a clear timeline separating the past from the present. A similar annulment obtained for an Iranian shipping group, analysed in our earlier review of the IRISL sanctions annulment and the procedure for challenging a freeze from France, followed exactly that method of pairing each Council allegation with a dated rebuttal.
The judicial remedy is the action for annulment under 263 TFEU, brought directly before the General Court in Luxembourg within two months and ten days of notification or publication of the contested act. Three pleas carry most cases. First, infringement of the rights of the defence as shaped by the Kadi case law (C-402/05 P and C-415/05 P): the Council must disclose the evidence against the person and state reasons precise enough to allow judicial review. Second, manifest error of assessment, which is the plea that succeeded here: the Court does not substitute its own foreign-policy judgment, but it verifies the material accuracy of the facts, the absence of a manifest error, and whether the facts still support the legal criterion on the date of the act. Third, breach of proportionality and of the right to property, which succeeds only where the freeze goes beyond what the objective requires. Because the Council renews the Russia lists roughly every six months, each maintaining regulation is a new challengeable act with its own deadline: winning against the 2025 acts, as here, leaves later maintaining acts intact, and the wave of new designations expected under the latest packages, described in our guide to challenging a new Russia listing and frozen account from France, must each be attacked within their own time limits.
Two accessory actions complete the Luxembourg toolbox. An application for interim measures under 278 TFEU can seek suspension of the freeze pending judgment, but the applicant must show a prima facie case, urgency in the form of serious and irreparable harm, and a favourable balance of interests; financial loss alone is generally considered reparable and therefore insufficient, which explains why suspension remains exceptional in sanctions cases. An action for damages under 268 TFEU and 340 TFEU follows the path recalled in this judgment: the breach must be sufficiently serious, the damage actual and quantified, and the causal link direct. The Safa Nicu Sepahan line of authority (C-45/15 P) shows that damages are obtainable where the Council listed without any sufficient basis, yet the present case shows the reverse side, where even a successful annulment does not automatically convert into compensation. Finally, points of law decided by the General Court can be appealed to the Court of Justice under 256 TFEU, which is why a first-instance annulment should be read together with the appeal risk before advising a client that the matter is closed. Questions of validity referred by national courts under 275 TFEU remain narrowly framed in foreign-policy matters, so the direct action under Article 263 stays the main road.
B. What Happens in France While the Listing Stands?
Regulation No 269/2014 applies directly in France: no French decree is needed for the freeze to bite, and every bank, insurer and payment institution must freeze immediately and refuse to make funds available to the listed person. French law then organises the surrounding machinery. The national asset-freeze regime of the Monetary and Financial Code allows the Minister for the Economy, acting alone or jointly with the Minister of the Interior, to order freezes for renewable six-month periods: see Article L562-1 for definitions, Article L562-2 and Article L562-3 for the ministerial freeze decisions, and Article L562-2-1 for the newer interference-prevention ground. Regulated entities must apply freezes and no-availability orders without delay through internal organisation and procedures, as required by Article L562-4-1 and detailed in Article R562-1 of the same code. In practice, French banks go further than the letter of the lists: de-risking leads them to close or refuse accounts of persons merely connected to a sanctioned environment, which is exactly the pattern the damages claim in this case described with Armenian banks refusing any service to sanctioned persons.
Against that background, three French-law tools matter. First, the Treasury’s sanctions unit (DG Trésor) administers authorisations and derogations: the European regulation itself provides exemptions for basic needs, legal fees, routine holding costs and humanitarian purposes, and a well-documented application can release specific payments even while the listing stands. Second, suspicious-transaction reporting runs in parallel: professionals subject to anti-money-laundering duties must report to the national financial-intelligence unit under Article L561-15, received by the unit described in Article L561-23 of the same code, so any unfreezing strategy must keep the banking record clean and consistent with the Luxembourg file. Third, the right to a basic bank account survives: Article L312-1 gives any person domiciled in France who holds no account the right to have the Banque de France designate an institution, which guarantees access to basic payment services but does not override a European freeze on the funds themselves. On the criminal side, the framework is tightening at both levels: the European Union has harmonised the definition of sanctions-violation offences, and the French proposition de loi no 2544 (Assemblée nationale, 17th legislature, text no 2544) aims to align French criminal definitions and penalties for violating Union restrictive measures. Moving frozen funds without an authorisation therefore exposes the person to prosecution in addition to the freeze itself.
The file-building lessons of the 30 September 2026 judgment translate directly into a Paris checklist. Prove the break with the past through public, verifiable instruments: notarised transfers, company-register extracts, resignation filings, and audited accounts showing the end of the targeted activity. Date everything, because the Court judges the situation as it stood when each maintaining act was adopted, and a stale evidence file is the Council’s recurring weakness. Address each review request to the Council in writing, keep proof of dispatch, and treat an absent or stereotyped reply as the starting point of the two-month action period rather than as a final answer. Coordinate the two tracks: the Luxembourg action attacks the listing, while the Paris track secures authorisations for living, legal-defence and business-preservation expenses and protects the right to a basic account. And quantify any damages claim from the outset with bank letters, refused-transfer slips and accountant-certified losses, because the rejection of the 42,480-euro and 150,000-euro heads of loss in this case shows that general assertions about closed accounts do not satisfy the cumulative conditions of Union liability.
Conclusion
The judgment of 30 September 2026 restates a simple discipline for the whole sanctions system: a listing must be earned again at every renewal, on present facts, not inherited from the past. A notarised exit, confirmed by a public register, defeated two maintaining acts because the Council reused an outdated file and a backward-looking statement of reasons. Yet the same judgment shows the limits of a Luxembourg victory: damages require a serious, proven and directly caused loss, costs follow partial success, later maintaining acts survive untouched, and an appeal remains possible. For anyone frozen in France, the practical conclusion is therefore threefold: challenge each maintaining act within its own two-month period with dated, verifiable evidence; run the Paris track in parallel through Treasury authorisations, clean banking records and the right to a basic account; and never move funds without an exemption, as criminal definitions tighten. An annulment opens the door, but only a coordinated procedure walks through it. The European Union’s sanctions tracker, which still returns an active 2026 designation entry for the same person, illustrates that each renewal must be challenged separately and that no single judgment clears every later act by itself.