KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Jonathan Black-Branch Arrested in France: Could French Citizenship Block Extradition to Canada on Fraud Charges?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Jonathan Black-Branch Arrested in France: Could French Citizenship Block Extradition to Canada on Fraud Charges?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 23 September 2026, the Winnipeg Police Service confirmed that Jonathan Black-Branch, the disbarred former dean of the University of Manitoba faculty of law, had been arrested in France and that the matter was then before the French court system, with further information to be provided only if the extradition application succeeds and he is returned to Winnipeg, as reported by CBC News. CTV News subsequently reported that a French court had confirmed his detention following an arrest in April 2026, and Justice Canada confirmed that Canada has requested his extradition to face a criminal charge in Manitoba.

The underlying file, as documented by the Canadian press, is substantial. A Canada-wide arrest warrant was issued on 30 March 2026 on a charge of fraud over $5,000. A months-long disciplinary hearing conducted by the Law Society of Manitoba had found that more than $600,000 of university funds were misspent during his tenure as dean, a position he held from 2016 before leaving suddenly in 2020. He was disbarred in Manitoba in 2024 and fined $36,000, the university sued him for nearly $700,000, and in 2026 the Bar Standards Board for England and Wales barred him a second time, describing his conduct in Manitoba as blatant and sustained dishonesty. Whether the former dean holds French citizenship is publicly unknown at the time of writing, and that single unresolved fact could determine the entire outcome.

The analysis below is general in scope: it describes the verifications and procedural steps useful in any comparable Canada-France extradition case and makes no finding about the situation of Mr Black-Branch, which only the courts seized of the file can assess. What it offers the international reader is the view from inside the French procedure that will decide the case: the nationality bar that forbids France from surrendering its own citizens, the double-criminality test applied to fraud, and the exact path of an extradition request through the French prosecutor’s office and the chambre de l’instruction. No finding of guilt is made here; the proceedings are ongoing and the presumption of innocence applies in full.

I. Can France refuse to surrender a suspect to Canada? The nationality bar that could decide the case at the threshold

A. France does not extradite its own nationals: the absolute bar in Article 696-4 and the 1988 Franco-Canadian treaty

French extradition law starts with a prohibition, not a procedure. Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: “L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise”. Extradition is not granted where the requested person holds French nationality, assessed at the time of the offence for which surrender is sought. This is a mandatory ground for refusal. Where it applies, there is nothing left to weigh: no balancing of the seriousness of the fraud, no examination of the evidence gathered in Manitoba, no discretion for the requesting state to overcome. The French judge verifies nationality, and if the answer is yes, the request fails.
That is why the question of citizenship dominates the press coverage of this case. A professor of transnational criminal law interviewed by CTV News put the alternative in plain terms: where the person arrested in France does not hold French citizenship, the extradition process could be very straightforward, whereas French citizenship would change everything, because France, like a number of European countries, does not extradite its citizens. The observation is legally exact, and it explains why the first battle in any Paris extradition file is fought over passports, civil-status records and the precise date on which nationality was held, since the statute expressly measures nationality at the time of the offence, not at the time of the arrest.

The bilateral framework between the two countries does not alter this rule. Extradition between France and Canada rests on the convention d’extradition entre le Gouvernement de la République française et le Gouvernement du Canada, faite à Ottawa le 17 novembre 1988 (published in France by Decree No. 90-19 of 3 January 1990), published in France by Decree No. 90-19 of 3 January 1990. A treaty organises cooperation; it does not override the statutory prohibitions of the requested state. The Canadian press correctly reports that all the legal tools are in place for a request of this kind to proceed, but those tools operate within the limits of Article 696-4: the treaty opens the door, while French nationality, if established, closes it.

Refusal, however, does not mean impunity. French criminal law follows its citizens abroad. Article 113-6 of the Criminal Code provides: “La loi pénale française est applicable à tout crime commis par un Français hors du territoire de la République. Elle est applicable aux délits commis par des Français hors du territoire de la République si les faits sont punis par la législation du pays où ils ont été commis.” France may therefore prosecute its own national in France for conduct committed in Canada, provided the conduct is also punishable under Canadian law for délits. This is the mechanism the Canadian commentators describe when they say that French authorities would typically prosecute the person in France instead: surrender is refused, but the file can be taken over by the French prosecutor, and the same alleged conduct may still be tried, under French law, before a French court. For the victims and the requesting state, the practical consequence is a transfer of forum rather than an end of proceedings; for the defence, it is a different trial, under different rules of evidence and sentencing, in which the Canadian investigative file must be converted into a French prosecution.

Two further points complete the picture at this threshold stage. First, dual nationality does not help the requesting state: where one of the nationalities held is French, the bar applies, because the statute looks only at whether the person has French nationality. Second, the burden of establishing the facts falls on documents, not assertions. A defence team in Paris verifies civil status, naturalisation decrees, consular registrations and the chronology of nationality against the dates of the alleged offences, because Article 696-4 anchors the assessment to the time of the facts. Where the offence is presented as a course of conduct spread over several years, as expense-related fraud allegations typically are, each period must be mapped against the nationality timeline. An error of a few months on either side can decide whether the bar applies.

B. The path of the file in France: diplomatic request, 48 hours before the prosecutor, consent or the reasoned opinion of the chambre de l’instruction

Once the requested person is located and arrested, often further to an Interpol red notice circulated at the requesting state’s initiative, the French procedure follows a strict and rapid sequence. Article 696-8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires that “toute demande d’extradition est adressée au gouvernement français par voie diplomatique”, accompanied by a conviction, an order committing the person for trial, or a warrant of arrest or equivalent judicial act, together with the applicable legal provisions and possibly a statement of the facts. The diplomatic channel matters: an arrest on the ground does not necessarily mean the formal file has already arrived in Paris, and practitioners expect a phase of back-and-forth while the requesting state assembles the documents the treaty and the statute demand. Press reporting that the process is ongoing before the French courts, with no further detail available, corresponds to this ordinary phase of file-building and judicial verification.

The first judicial moment comes very fast. Article 696-10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: “Toute personne appréhendée à la suite d’une demande d’extradition doit être conduite dans les quarante-huit heures devant le procureur général territorialement compétent.” Within forty-eight hours of apprehension, the requested person must be brought before the territorially competent prosecutor general, who verifies identity, notifies the person of the request in a language they understand, and advises them of the right to counsel of their choice or court-appointed counsel, with access to the file from that moment. The statute attaches nullity to failures in these notifications, which is why experienced extradition counsel in Paris scrutinise the first procès-verbal before anything else: a defective 48-hour presentation can poison the entire procedure.

The prosecutor then puts the decisive question: does the requested person consent to be extradited? Article 696-13 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states: “Lorsque la personne réclamée a déclaré au procureur général consentir à son extradition, la chambre de l’instruction est immédiatement saisie de la procédure.” Consent leads to a simplified track, with appearance before the chambre de l’instruction within five working days, verification of identity and consent on the record, and a fast route toward surrender. Where, on the contrary, the person declares they do not consent, Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: “Si, lors de sa comparution, la personne réclamée déclare ne pas consentir à être extradée, la chambre de l’instruction donne son avis motivé sur la demande d’extradition.” The court must give a reasoned opinion, normally within one month of the appearance, and that opinion is unfavourable where the legal conditions are not met or there is an obvious error. The statute adds a severe filter on appeal: a petition to the Cour de cassation against the opinion “ne peut être fondé que sur des vices de forme de nature à priver cet avis des conditions essentielles de son existence légale”, that is, only on formal defects capable of depriving the opinion of the essential conditions of its legal existence. In plain terms, there is no appeal on the merits of surrender; the fight must be won before the chambre de l’instruction, on legality, not on sympathy.
Detention runs alongside this procedure and deserves separate attention, because the press reports that the former dean is being detained. French law allows the chambre de l’instruction to keep the requested person under judicial control or in detention while the opinion is pending, but the Cour de cassation polices the boundary strictly. In a ruling of 9 August 2023 (No. 23-83.192), the Criminal Chamber recalled that “la personne réclamée est mise d’office en liberté si l’avis de la chambre de l’instruction repousse la demande d’extradition”: where the court’s opinion rejects the request, the requested person must be set free as of right. Defence teams therefore treat every hearing as two cases in one: the opinion on surrender, and the liberty of the client. Applications for release may in any event be filed at any time: Article 696-19 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that “La mise en liberté peut être demandée à tout moment à la chambre de l’instruction selon les formes prévues aux articles 148-6 et 148-7 .” In practice, counsel combine the release request with the attack on the merits, arguing that a file weakened on nationality, double criminality or limitation cannot justify continued detention. The reported timeframes follow from this architecture: surrender within weeks where the person consents, many months where every condition is contested, first on liberty, then on the opinion, then before the executive authority to which the diplomatic request was addressed, since the chambre de l’instruction gives an opinion while the request itself is directed to the Government.

II. Would a Canadian fraud prosecution survive the French double-criminality test? Charges, time limits and the defence checklist

A. Fraud over $5,000 and escroquerie: France compares conduct, not labels

Extradition requires that the same conduct be punishable on both sides. Article 696-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure sets the thresholds for the requesting state’s penalties and then states the French side of the test: “En aucun cas l’extradition n’est accordée par le gouvernement français si le fait n’est pas puni par la loi française d’une peine criminelle ou correctionnelle.” In no case will France grant extradition where the act is not punishable under French law as a crime or a délit. A fraud charge laid in Manitoba must therefore find its mirror in French criminal law, and the comparison bears on the facts alleged, not on the name of the Canadian offence.

The natural mirror is escroquerie. Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code defines it as follows: “L’escroquerie est le fait, soit par l’usage d’un faux nom ou d’une fausse qualité, soit par l’abus d’une qualité vraie, soit par l’emploi de manoeuvres frauduleuses, de tromper une personne physique ou morale et de la déterminer ainsi, à son préjudice ou au préjudice d’un tiers, à remettre des fonds, des valeurs ou un bien quelconque, à fournir un service ou à consentir un acte opérant obligation ou décharge.” Fraud is the act, by use of a false name or false status, by abuse of a true status, or by fraudulent manoeuvres, of deceiving a natural or legal person and thereby inducing them, to their prejudice or that of a third party, to hand over funds, valuables or property, to supply a service, or to consent to an act creating an obligation or a discharge. It carries five years’ imprisonment and a 375,000 euro fine. Commentators interviewed in the Canadian press consider this test straightforward on these facts, noting that French criminal law plainly punishes fraud, and the structure of the Canadian allegations, expense claims charged to university endowment funds, meals said never to have taken place, personal education and travel presented as professional spending, maps without strain onto the French categories of abuse of a true status and fraudulent manoeuvres. If the conduct described in the Canadian file is taken as alleged, the double-criminality condition would appear capable of being satisfied, subject to the verification of the precise documents transmitted through the diplomatic channel.

The Cour de cassation has just confirmed how this comparison works, in a fraud case decided weeks before this article. On 12 August 2026 (No. 26-84.479), ruling on the surrender of a woman sought under a European arrest warrant for conspiracy and fraudulent property transactions, the Criminal Chamber approved judges who had held that “les faits poursuivis en l’espèce étant susceptibles d’être qualifiés en droit français d’escroqueries et d’association de malfaiteurs, la condition de la double incrimination n’exige pas que les infractions soient identiques dans l’État membre d’émission et dans l’État membre d’exécution”. Offences need not be identical on both sides; it suffices that the conduct prosecuted abroad is capable of receiving a French criminal qualification. The same ruling adds a second lesson for fraud defences: “il ne leur appartient pas d’apprécier la bonne foi de Mme [S] ni l’opportunité des poursuites”, as the Court endorsed. It is not for the surrender judge to assess the good faith of the requested person or the wisdom of the foreign prosecution. Two cautions are required for precision. First, that decision was given in the European arrest warrant framework, not in classic extradition, so its reasoning illustrates the French judicial method rather than deciding an extradition file. Second, the lesson cuts both ways: counsel cannot invite the chambre de l’instruction to retry the Manitoba file or to acquit on the facts, but neither can the requesting state demand surrender on labels alone. The court checks that described conduct fits a French offence, and that check is a genuine filter, not a rubber stamp.

Limitation is the second filter inside the double-criminality section, and it is often underestimated. Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure also bars extradition “Lorsque, d’après la loi de l’Etat requérant ou la loi française, la prescription de l’action s’est trouvée acquise antérieurement à la demande d’extradition”, that is, where prosecution is time-barred under either the requesting state’s law or French law before the request. Spending that is said to date back to 2016-2020, an arrest warrant issued in March 2026, an arrest in France in the spring of the same year: a defence team reconstructs the chronology act by act, applies both limitation regimes, and tests whether any counts survive on each side. Where part of the conduct is time-barred, surrender may be refused for those counts while remaining available for the rest, which reshapes the negotiation over consent and the scope of any eventual trial under the specialty rule. This chronological work is unglamorous, but in files built on years of expense claims it frequently decides more than the doctrinal debates.

B. Red notices, detention and leverage: how a Paris defence team works an extradition file week by week

The arrest itself usually begins with a signal, not a trial. When a person charged in Canada is known or believed to be abroad, cooperation between police forces is triggered, often through Interpol and its Lyon-based General Secretariat. As the transnational criminal law analysis reported in the Canadian press explains, the requesting country may seek a red notice, described as something like an international arrest warrant, whose purpose is to tell police in other countries that an individual is sought for arrest to face charges, so that crossing a border can lead to interception and arrest. Three precisions matter for anyone concerned. First, a red notice is not an arrest warrant and not an extradition order: it is a cooperation request owned by the requesting country, and Interpol itself stresses that information shared by member countries remains their property. Second, the notice may explain the arrest without proving that a complete extradition file already exists; assembling the treaty documents takes time, and there is commonly a phase of exchanges between officials on both sides. Third, from the moment of arrest, the clock of French procedural safeguards runs: the 48-hour presentation, immediate access to counsel and to the file, and the consent question before the prosecutor general. Anyone arrested in France on a foreign request should therefore treat the first hours as the most valuable part of the case: confirm identity without volunteering beyond what is required, demand an interpreter where needed, secure counsel experienced in extradition before answering the consent question, and have counsel photograph the file’s inventory, because everything later, nationality evidence, double-criminality argument, limitation chronology, release applications, depends on knowing exactly which documents the requesting state has transmitted and which are still missing.

Detention strategy follows. The reported detention of the former dean is consistent with files where the requested person is considered to present a flight risk, particularly after years during which a warrant was outstanding and the person moved between countries. But detention in extradition is not a preview of the sentence; it is a precaution attached to a procedure, and Article 696-19 allows release to be sought at any moment. Paris counsel typically argue release on several converging grounds: stable residence and voluntary surrender of travel documents, the time already needed to assemble the foreign file, health and family circumstances, and above all the strength of the legal challenges, since a judge is less inclined to detain where nationality, double criminality or limitation seriously dispute surrender. The 2023 ruling recalled above gives this argument its edge: an unfavourable opinion on surrender ends detention as of right, so every step that weakens the request simultaneously strengthens the liberty application. Readers following comparable cases, from cartel figures surrendered through European procedures to the recent large-scale operations against cross-border crime networks processed in Paris, will recognise the pattern: the liberty battle and the surrender battle are one battle fought on two fronts. This publication has previously analysed how France handles surrender files arising from major international operations and how Interpol-led campaigns translate into French detention and extradition litigation, as in the Kinahan surrender between Dubai, Dublin and France and the Interpol Operation Phoenix red-notice litigation in France, and the method described there applies directly here: verify the notice, verify the file, verify nationality, then fight surrender and detention together.

Timing is the final practical question, and the honest answer is that it depends on choices made in the first weeks. Consent to simplified surrender can compress the case to a matter of weeks; a full contest, with challenges to nationality, double criminality, limitation and detention, extends it to many months and sometimes beyond a year, particularly where the Cour de cassation is seized on a formal defect or where additional information must be requested from the requesting state through the diplomatic channel. Neither speed nor delay inherently favours one side. For the requesting state, delay risks limitation arguments and public-interest erosion; for the requested person, detention makes every month costly, while consent abandons the very defences, nationality included, that only the French judge can uphold. The professional reflex is therefore to refuse haste at the 48-hour stage, to map nationality, conduct-by-conduct criminality and limitation before any commitment, and to decide on consent only once that map is complete. In files where French nationality is credibly documented, the map points to refusal and possible prosecution in France; in files where it is absent, the map points to the quality of the foreign documents and to the calendar.

Conclusion

An arrest in France on a Canadian fraud warrant opens a procedure that is French from the first hour to the last: diplomatic request, 48-hour presentation, consent or reasoned opinion of the chambre de l’instruction, detention litigation, and the executive decision to which the request was addressed. Three questions organise every file of this kind. First, does the requested person hold French nationality assessed at the time of the facts, which alone would bar surrender while opening the possibility of prosecution in France? Second, does the conduct described abroad fit a French offence such as escroquerie, under a double-criminality test that compares facts rather than labels and that also runs through limitation on both sides? Third, is the file, as transmitted, complete and exact enough to justify both surrender and continued detention? Only the courts seized of the case can answer these questions for any individual, and no commentator’s analysis can replace their findings. But the structure is fixed, the safeguards are real, and the first hours, nationality papers, the procès-verbal of presentation, and the answer to the consent question, carry disproportionate weight. That is where extradition files are most often won or lost, long before anyone discusses the merits of the underlying fraud.

📄 Official circular