KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Black Friday Deals 2026: Can a California Shopper Challenge a Misleading Discount?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Black Friday Deals 2026: Can a California Shopper Challenge a Misleading Discount?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A price tag can make a deal look much better than the number at checkout explains. A television marked down from $1,000 to $600 appears to offer a $400 saving, but the useful question is what the $1,000 actually represents. Was it a former market price, a manufacturer’s suggestion, or a comparison with a different item? If you bought in California because a specific claimed reduction mattered to you, the answer can affect the evidence you need and the options you may have.

California law addresses false or misleading statements about price reductions, and federal trade guidance describes how to evaluate comparisons with a seller’s former price. Neither turns every disappointing purchase into an unlawful sale. The advertisement, its qualifications, the item bought, the seller’s pricing history and your own purchasing decision all matter. A screenshot alone can identify the claim, but it does not necessarily establish the history behind it.

The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the situation of any company named in a court decision. It focuses on California consumer law and identifies the narrower reach of federal court decisions applying that law. Start by preserving the offer and receipt, then distinguish what you know from what you would need the seller to explain.

I. When can a California sale price be misleading?

A. Separate the advertised saving from the price you actually paid

Begin with the whole offer as it appeared when you decided to buy. Record the product name, model, size or configuration, the seller, the crossed-out amount, the advertised price, the percentage reduction and any conditions visible nearby. Save the surrounding page or shelf label, not just a cropped number. A claim that says a price was previously charged is different from a comparison to a manufacturer’s suggested retail price. A discount applying to members, an offer requiring a coupon and a reduction applying only to a particular color also communicate different things.

For an illustrative $1,000-to-$600 offer, $400 is the arithmetic difference between the two displayed amounts; it is not automatically proof that this buyer saved $400 against the relevant market. If the original number describes a genuinely different basis, the shopper needs to identify that basis before judging the comparison. If the advertisement says the item was formerly $1,000, the next question is what evidence supports that representation in the relevant place and period. If the ad identifies a suggested price, ask whether the presentation makes clear what is being compared. These are checks on the communication as a whole, not a finding that any particular offer is false.

California Business and Professions Code § 17501 gives a specific rule for an advertised former price. It defines the advertised thing’s worth or value as the prevailing market price, wholesale or retail as applicable, at the time and in the locality of the advertisement. An advertised former price must have been that prevailing market price within the three months immediately before the advertisement, unless the advertisement clearly, exactly and conspicuously states when that price did prevail. The three months describe the comparison period in that provision; they are not a deadline for a shopper to file a claim.

That definition makes the details of the comparison important. The price of a different model, a different size or an item bundled with accessories may not answer what the advertised thing’s prevailing market price was. A single past listing can be useful evidence, but it is not necessarily the whole market. A shopper can note where and when the offer appeared, record the exact item, and distinguish the seller’s own prior price from evidence of market prices more broadly. If the ad provides a date for an older former price, save the date and its placement along with the price.

The Federal Trade Commission’s separate guide on retail-price and comparable-value comparisons, 16 C.F.R. § 233.2, addresses a different kind of claim: a comparison with prices charged by other sellers or with comparable merchandise. The guidance says the higher comparison should be based on fact and discusses whether the cited price is representative in the relevant trade area. It also says a comparison with a different item should make clear that the merchandise is different and should involve essentially similar quality. These are federal advertising guides, distinct from California’s statutory former-price rule.

The federal Federal Trade Commission’s guide on former-price comparisons, 16 C.F.R. § 233.1, describes a different but useful inquiry: whether the seller’s claimed former price was a genuine price openly and actively offered on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period. The guide says a former price is not necessarily fictitious merely because no sales occurred at it. It also cautions against implying that substantial sales occurred at a former price when they did not. This is federal agency guidance about advertising practices; the California statutory definition of prevailing market price is a separate rule.

Keep those inquiries apart. A record showing that a seller briefly listed an item at a high amount can prompt a question about the history of the offer, but duration alone does not answer every issue under either source. Conversely, the absence of a completed sale at the earlier amount is not automatically proof that the seller never genuinely offered it. A useful request asks for the basis of the comparison, the exact product and the dates on which the advertised former price applied. A useful record preserves the response without converting an unanswered question into an accusation.

California Civil Code § 1770(a)(13), quoted in this Ninth Circuit opinion and part of the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, identifies false or misleading statements of fact about the reasons for, existence of, or amounts of price reductions among the prohibited practices in covered consumer transactions. A statement about a reduction is therefore more than a calculation if it conveys a factual premise about the earlier price. Whether the provision applies to a particular purchase depends on the transaction and the facts; preserve evidence of both the stated premise and the purchase.

B. What do comparable court decisions show?

In Hinojos v. Kohl’s Corporation, 718 F.3d 1098 (9th Cir. 2013), the United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, on May 21, 2013, reversed dismissal of California consumer claims where the shopper alleged that purported discounts were based on false former prices and induced purchases he otherwise would not have made. The linked opinion notes that it was amended on July 8, 2013. The decision addressed allegations at the pleading stage, not a final finding that the advertised prices were false. For a shopper, the practical point is to preserve what the offer represented and explain how that representation affected the purchase, while recognizing that allegations must ultimately be supported. In Asercion v. Ulta Salon, Cosmetics & Fragrance, Inc., No. 26-cv-02442-RFL (N.D. Cal. Aug. 21, 2026), the United States District Court Northern District of California on August 21, 2026 cited Hinojos on the economic-injury requirement and dismissed a California unfair competition claim with leave to amend in a different website-privacy dispute. That later citation concerns economic injury; the privacy facts are not a ruling on a sale-price advertisement.

The false-discount decision helps separate the size of an advertised reduction from the reason the buyer spent money. The court rejected the idea that receiving the item at the advertised sale price necessarily defeated the pleaded injury. A buyer should not infer a guaranteed refund from that procedural ruling. Instead, write down the original decision accurately: whether the reduction mattered, whether you would have bought at all without it, and what other factors influenced the purchase. If you do not remember, say so rather than reconstructing certainty after the event.

In Panelli v. Target Corporation, No. 24-6640 (9th Cir. Apr. 17, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on April 17, 2026 reversed dismissal of California consumer claims involving an allegedly false, unambiguous thread-count statement. The court held that an alleged literal falsehood was not automatically unreasonable for consumers to believe simply because the alleged claim was physically impossible. The case concerned product labeling, not a former-price comparison, but it illustrates why the exact words and context of a specific representation matter when assessing an allegedly misleading offer.

The labeling decision provides a method, not a shortcut to a result about discounts. A court can analyze whether a representation is ambiguous and what it conveys to a reasonable consumer in context. For a price promotion, preserve the words that actually accompanied the crossed-out amount and the placement of any explanation. An isolated number copied into a note may omit whether it was called a former selling price, a suggested price or something else. Equally, an explanation that appeared only after checkout may not describe the offer as it appeared when the shopper made the decision.

In Brown v. The Brita Products Company, No. 24-6678 (9th Cir. Apr. 16, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on April 16, 2026 affirmed dismissal of a California consumer claim concerning an alleged omission about a water filter’s capabilities. The court concluded that the alleged expectation was unreasonable in light of the product’s disclosures. The dispute was about product performance rather than discount pricing; for a shopper examining a sale, it underscores the need to consider the actual claim and available qualifications rather than assume an unstated promise.

The three decisions do different work. Hinojos concerns allegedly false former prices and a buyer’s pleaded economic injury. Panelli concerns an allegedly literal product representation. Brown concerns an alleged omission and the reasonableness of the buyer’s expectation. The latter two decisions do not establish the truth or falsity of a particular discount. They are federal appellate decisions applying California law, and their conclusions must be read with their facts and procedural posture. A California shopper can use that distinction to organize a record without treating a different product case as a finding about a specific sale.

II. What should a shopper do after a questionable discount?

A. Build a usable record of the offer and the transaction

Make a small chronology while the details are accessible. Save the page address, a screenshot showing the date on your device, the complete product description and the price display. For a store purchase, retain a photograph of the shelf or tag if you have one and record the location. Keep the order confirmation, receipt, payment amount and any later adjustment in the same folder. If the offer changed between the product page and checkout, preserve each version separately rather than replacing the earlier image.

Capture the terms that could change the comparison: membership eligibility, required promo codes, quantities, selected options, shipping charges, seller identity and whether a marketplace page identified a third-party seller. Save the precise configuration, because a base model and a larger or upgraded model may have different prices. If a price applies only after a coupon, record both the price before the coupon and the final amount. When tax or a separately stated shipping amount appears, record it separately so you do not compare unlike totals.

A price-history record can have gaps. A saved page may show an asking price on one date, while the relevant question may concern a longer period or a market beyond one seller. A screenshot can also show a price without showing whether the same configuration was available for sale. Label each item of evidence accordingly: “my screenshot,” “my receipt,” “seller’s explanation,” or “another listing I observed.” Keep the original files where possible. Do not edit a screenshot to remove qualifications, and do not assume that a cached image proves the full pricing history.

Write a short account of what you saw before buying. Identify the particular representation, the amount you paid and why the representation mattered. If you compared two products, note what comparison you made and which features besides price influenced you. If a family member saw the ad but someone else paid, record that distinction. A contemporaneous account helps separate the buyer’s own experience from assumptions about what other people may have understood.

For a California unfair competition claim, Business and Professions Code § 17204 permits an action by a person who has suffered injury in fact and lost money or property as a result of the unfair competition, as well as enforcement by specified public officials. The Hinojos decision explains how allegations about a purchase induced by a claimed false discount were treated at the pleading stage. Save both the evidence of the statement and the evidence of the transaction; a complaint about an advertisement and a personal claim for a monetary remedy are not identical things.

If the item was returned, retain the return confirmation and the amount credited. If only part of a purchase was refunded, save a record of what remained. If a coupon or store credit was offered, note its conditions and whether you accepted it. These facts help describe the transaction as it actually stands; they do not by themselves decide whether any remedy remains available. Avoid counting the crossed-out amount as your loss without explaining why that number reflects the financial consequence you are claiming.

A practical written request to the seller can be factual and specific. Identify the product, the purchase and the representation you observed. Ask what the reference price meant and what information supports it, then state the resolution you are seeking. A clear request can distinguish a correction to an order from a dispute over the advertised comparison. Keep a copy of the request and response. If the response offers an explanation you cannot verify, record that as the seller’s explanation rather than treating it as established or rejecting it without evidence.

If you are still shopping, compare the actual payable price of comparable products across sellers and configurations. A product may be worth buying at its final price even when the displayed percentage is not useful to your decision. Conversely, a high advertised percentage does not show that the price is the lowest available elsewhere. The legal question about a representation and the practical question of whether a purchase meets your budget can be considered separately.

B. Match the possible response to the evidence and the remedy

First decide what result matters to you. You might want an explanation of the price comparison, correction of an order, a return under the applicable terms, or assessment of a claim for monetary relief. Each request requires different information. A seller may be able to explain an order quickly, while the history of a reference price may require records that a shopper does not possess. A request for information is useful because it identifies the missing fact without presuming the answer.

California Civil Code § 1780 identifies remedies for a consumer who suffers damage as a result of a practice made unlawful by § 1770, including actual damages, an injunction and restitution, subject to the statute and the facts of the case. The same section identifies other forms of relief and procedural requirements. The list is not a promise that every remedy will be awarded in every case, and different remedies address different harms. A request to correct an advertisement is not the same as calculating a buyer’s personal monetary loss.

For example, if the question is a refund of a specific purchase, gather the paid amount, the item and the result of any return. If the question is a price difference, identify the comparison and explain the basis for the amount requested. If the concern is an advertisement that other shoppers may see, preserve the current advertisement and its date, while keeping it separate from the offer you saw earlier. The question of what a court could order depends on the applicable law, the evidence and the requested relief.

Do not assume that the number printed after a minus sign is the amount recoverable. Suppose an item is marked from $1,000 to $600. The printed difference is $400, but an assessment of injury requires more than copying that figure. A shopper may need to explain what the item was worth to them under the circumstances and what purchase decision the representation affected. The documents may support a different calculation, and a court may evaluate competing evidence. Keep arithmetic, evidence and the legal theory distinct.

If several people bought the same product, each person should preserve their own experience. One shopper may have seen a different advertisement or purchased a different model. Another may have bought for reasons unrelated to the stated discount, or received a refund already. Similar-looking receipts do not automatically establish identical experiences. The court decisions above show why both the representation and its effect can matter; they do not establish that a group of purchasers is entitled to any particular collective outcome.

A consumer can also give information to an appropriate public agency. Under California § 17204, specified public officials can bring enforcement actions in addition to actions by qualifying private persons. A report can organize the offer, the transaction and the explanation received, with copies rather than unsupported conclusions. Public enforcement and a personal recovery are different paths; reporting a concern does not establish that an agency has found a violation or will obtain an individual refund.

Before choosing a formal route, identify the jurisdiction and the governing rules for the transaction. The California provisions discussed here should not be presented as a nationwide set of consumer rights. A purchase involving another state, another type of service or a different contractual arrangement may raise different questions. The federal guide provides a way to examine certain former-price comparisons, but it does not replace the California statutes or establish the outcome of a private claim.

Preserve the full record even if you pursue a straightforward return. A seller’s response, a corrected receipt or a refund can resolve the immediate problem or clarify what remains disputed. Keep the original offer, the actual payment and the eventual resolution together. If the evidence does not establish how a former price was used, describe that gap plainly. The strongest next step is usually the one that asks for the missing information while accurately stating the facts already known.

Conclusion

A California shopper questioning a Black Friday discount should start with the exact representation, the product and the actual payment. California law has a specific former-price rule and addresses misleading statements about reductions; federal guidance separately explains how to assess a seller’s claimed former price. The practical evidence is the complete offer, the receipt, the conditions and a reliable account of why the representation mattered. Court decisions show that the buyer’s allegations and the full context matter, while a decision allowing a claim to proceed is not a finding that a particular sale was deceptive. Ask for the basis of the comparison, preserve the response and distinguish a request for explanation, a return and a potential legal remedy.

📄 Official circular