KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Bourne Lincolnshire Tobacco Factory Bust: When Can Possessing Unstamped Cigarettes Be an Offence?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Bourne Lincolnshire Tobacco Factory Bust: When Can Possessing Unstamped Cigarettes Be an Offence?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The search phrase ‘Bourne Lincolnshire tobacco factory bust’ has been trending in the United Kingdom. It raises a practical question about the law in England and Wales. When can possessing cigarettes without a compliant duty-paid mark lead to a criminal charge, and what can happen to the goods? The answer depends on whether the goods needed the mark, what the person actually did with them and which provision is alleged to apply.

This article explains the law as at 20 November 2026. The examples are hypothetical and the method is general. The search phrase establishes no facts about any particular goods, premises or investigation. Whether a particular packet required a mark, whether anyone possessed or sold it and whether there is evidence of deliberate duty evasion are questions that would need to be established separately.

For someone sorting through stock records or a seizure notice, the practical starting point is to identify the goods and the legal basis stated on the document. A prosecution about a person’s conduct and a dispute over whether seized goods were liable to forfeiture involve different questions. The distinction matters especially when a written claim about the goods is subject to a deadline while the circumstances of the seizure are still being investigated.

I. When cigarettes need a fiscal mark and who can be liable

A. Establish whether the goods needed the mark

Section 8G of the Tobacco Products Duty Act 1979 defines the goods at the centre of the offence. They must be tobacco products subject to fiscal marking which lack a compliant duty-paid fiscal mark. The section treats a duty-paid fiscal mark as one indicating that excise duty has been paid on the products. Compliance depends on the requirements applicable to the particular description of goods. An absent mark is one possible issue. A mark that fails an applicable requirement can also bring goods within the definition.

Under section 8C of the same Act, fiscal marking regulations can govern matters such as the mark’s content, appearance, how it is carried and its position. There may be other writing on a packet, including brand information or warnings. When the question is compliance with the fiscal-marking rules, the relevant comparison is between the packet and the fiscal requirements that apply to it. A description on an invoice can help identify the product and its route into stock, but the physical packet is the evidence of which marks it actually carries and how they appear.

Part IV of the Tobacco Products Regulations 2001 puts the scheme into operation. Regulation 21 includes cigarettes in the specified products. Regulation 22 sets out when specified tobacco products must carry the mark, subject to the exceptions in regulation 23, and addresses the packaging of products that require it. A useful fact to pin down early is whether the concern relates to the retail packets or only to an outer delivery box. A record that simply describes a pallet or carton as unmarked may leave open what was found on the packets it contained.

Regulation 23 makes the destination and status of the goods relevant. Under paragraph (1)(a), goods outside the home-use market can fall within the exception if they are neither delivered to home use nor otherwise made available for it. Those conditions work together. For example, an entry in a stock system describing a consignment as intended for export might help explain its planned destination. The records of what subsequently happened, including any transfer to a retail outlet, would matter when assessing whether the conditions remained satisfied. The intended destination cannot tell the whole story once the goods have moved.

Another exception under regulation 23(1)(b) concerns specified duty relief and compliance with its conditions. Regulation 23(1A) sets out a separate route for certain goods privately acquired for the buyer’s own use and transported by that buyer to the United Kingdom where the relief would have applied except for the quantity, the required declaration was made and duty was paid. Each part matters. A statement that cigarettes came from abroad, for instance, tells you little about who bought them, who carried them, why they were brought in or what was declared. Conversely, the lack of a domestic mark does not eliminate a properly evidenced exception. These provisions have their own conditions and are not a general permission to supply imported cigarettes to others.

A realistic example is a delivery containing several product lines, only some of which have an adequate paper trail. Treat each disputed line separately. An import document for one consignment may identify the date, supplier and shipment reference, but those details only help with a disputed packet if there is a way to connect the shipment to that packet. A matching description without a traceable delivery record may leave uncertainty. A record showing the match between the delivery and the stock is more informative, particularly if goods of the same type came from multiple deliveries.

The same caution applies to photos. A photo can show the appearance of a packet at a particular moment. Its value is greater when it can be tied to a stock entry, an inventory reference or a contemporaneous account of where and when it was taken. Where packaging is disputed, keep together any existing photos of the different faces of the packet and the description in the seizure inventory. If a record concerns outer packaging, identify it as such. That makes it easier to compare like with like rather than infer the condition of each retail packet from a single image.

For readers comparing the procedure with a matter in France, the firm’s English-language legal information on French law covers a separate legal system. The analysis here follows the legislation applicable in England and Wales.

B. Identify the conduct and the person said to be responsible

Section 8G(4) covers a number of acts. It includes possession, transport and display, as well as selling, offering for sale or otherwise dealing in the goods. A completed sale is therefore unnecessary if a different act covered by the subsection is established. A question about a delivery driver, for example, is likely to centre on transport and the relevant consignment. A question about stock arranged for customers could involve display or an offer for sale. Describing all of these situations simply as selling can obscure what would actually have to be proved.

The wording does not create a general exemption for a small quantity. A single packet and a large stock can raise quite different factual questions, but the analysis still starts with the product, the applicable marking requirement and the act alleged. The number of packets may help establish the context. It cannot substitute for identifying which goods were affected or who did what. Equally, the location of goods is one part of the factual picture. Where several people use a stockroom or vehicle, it may be necessary to distinguish access, handling and control instead of attributing everything found there to everyone associated with the place.

A delivery signature illustrates the point. It may identify who received a sealed shipment at a given time. A separate record may show who unpacked it, entered it into stock and decided where it would be held. The signature and those later records answer different questions. In a shop with several shifts, the time goods were booked in can be compared with the rota or handover log. These documents can help distinguish a person who was present during part of the day from someone who dealt with the specific goods. A job description can be useful, but actual responsibilities and contemporaneous records may be more informative when they do not align exactly.

Section 8G(4) is subject to cases prescribed in regulations. Regulation 25 of the 2001 Regulations includes supplementary rules about specified relief or penalty situations. Section 8G(5) also provides a defence where the person charged proves that the products were not required to carry a duty-paid fiscal mark. That is a specific statutory defence. For someone relying on it, the useful records are the ones that show why the marking requirement did not apply to those goods. A document asserting a general practice within a business will do less work than an identifiable declaration, duty record or stock movement that supports the particular exception relied on.

A manager of premises faces a different provision. Section 8H of the Tobacco Products Duty Act 1979 addresses a manager who permits the premises to be used for the sale of unmarked products. The definition includes someone entitled to control use of the premises, someone entrusted with their management and someone in charge of them. The question can therefore extend beyond the name above the door or the formal title attached to a job. The degree and source of actual authority over the premises are relevant, as are the facts that show whether the premises were permitted to be used for those sales.

Consider a shared site with a wholesale unit and a smaller independent retail counter. A lease may answer who has control over a defined part of the site. A trading agreement or written delegation may identify who runs the counter. A supplier invoice may show to whom particular goods were delivered. Together those records can clarify both what area is involved and how authority was divided. Where the allegation concerns sales from the counter, evidence from a separate storage area still has to be connected to the relevant sale activity and to the manager said to have permitted it.

Section 8H contains its own defence concerning goods that were not required to carry the duty-paid mark. It also allows an order, following conviction under subsection (1), prohibiting tobacco sales from the premises for a specified period of up to six months. The order is a possible consequence of that conviction. Its terms matter independently, because subsection (6) creates a further offence for a manager who permits use of the premises in breach of it. For someone reading any order actually made, the premises covered, its specified first day and the length of the prohibition are therefore important details.

II. How duty evasion and seizure change the questions

A. Separate a marking allegation from an allegation of deliberate duty evasion

Section 170 of the Customs and Excise Management Act 1979 deals with fraudulent evasion and related conduct. In the unpaid-duty situation covered by subsection (1), the provision addresses knowing acquisition of possession, or knowing involvement in specified dealings, with the necessary intent to defraud the revenue of duty payable on the goods. Subsection (2) separately addresses knowing involvement in fraudulent evasion or attempted evasion of duty, among other matters. This article concerns the duty branches of those provisions.

The difference can be seen by asking two questions of the same packet. Did the law require it to carry a compliant mark? Was this person knowingly involved in the conduct alleged under section 170 with the mental element that provision requires? Observing the packet may help substantially with the first question. Evidence about what a person was told, what records they made, what they authorised and how the goods actually moved can bear on the second. The absence of a mark alone leaves the second question unanswered.

For the duty allegation, it is also important to distinguish an amount recorded as unpaid in a notice from the evidence underpinning that conclusion. Product classification and the identification of the consignment affect whether a duty document is relevant to the disputed goods. Payment evidence without enough information to match the goods may leave a gap. A seemingly inconsistent document may turn out to relate to a different delivery or date. The record is most useful when it shows the chain from the identified consignment to the goods being examined, with unresolved breaks in the chain plainly marked.

Price and bookkeeping can provide context. A purchase price may prompt a question about whether duty was accounted for, but a figure on its own does not state what a buyer knew. Original purchase records, accounts and messages can show whether a price was explained as a discount, whether there was an agreed duty arrangement or whether the description of the goods changed between order and delivery. By arranging the records in date order, it becomes easier to test whether a person had the relevant information before taking the action alleged or learned it afterwards. Later discovery is a different event in the chronology.

The distinction between sections 8G and 170 also affects how to read the possible consequences. Section 8G(6) sets a fine on summary conviction. Section 170(3) sets out penalties for the different modes of conviction and includes the possibility of custody. Neither provision lets a reader infer a likely outcome from a packet’s appearance. The first step in reading a charge is to identify the section and subsection, the dates and the conduct alleged. Comparing those particulars with the contemporaneous records is more useful than relying on a broad description such as unpaid tobacco.

To take a purely hypothetical example, one member of staff may have booked in a delivery while another agreed the supply terms and handled the supporting records. A stock check later reveals a packaging discrepancy. The later discovery may be useful evidence of the condition of the packets at that point. It says much less about what information each person had when ordering, receiving or moving the goods. An accurate chronology should distinguish those moments and identify which document comes from which stage. That remains useful even where a person cannot reconstruct the entire supply chain immediately.

B. Read a seizure notice as a separate deadline

Section 139 of the Customs and Excise Management Act 1979 distinguishes powers to seize or detain goods liable to forfeiture from a power to detain goods reasonably suspected of being liable to forfeiture. It also points to the rules governing detention and condemnation. Section 8G(4) itself makes the unmarked products covered by that offence liable to forfeiture. A seizure notice is concerned with the legal status of the goods. It does not establish a person’s guilt under either of the criminal provisions discussed above.

Schedule 3 of the Customs and Excise Management Act 1979 sets out the process for challenging liability to forfeiture. Paragraphs 1 and 2 govern written notice of seizure, including when notice need not be given and how notice can be served. For example, paragraph 1 lists situations in which notice is unnecessary because a relevant person was present at seizure. This makes the date and circumstances of the seizure important even where the owner has yet to see a letter. A record of who was present and in what capacity can help make sense of the paperwork that follows.

Under paragraph 3, a person claiming that seized goods are not liable to forfeiture must give written notice of the claim within one month of the date of the notice of seizure or, where no such notice has been served on that person, within one month of the date of seizure. Use the statutory starting point rather than the date a stock reconciliation was finished or the day someone first read the file. Where service is in doubt, retaining the original notice, its envelope and any contemporaneous record of the seizure can help establish which date needs to be considered. The statute calls for written notice to the Commissioners at an office of customs and excise.

Paragraph 4 requires the claimant’s name and address. It includes a provision for a claimant outside the United Kingdom and the Isle of Man to specify a solicitor in the United Kingdom authorised to accept service and act on the claimant’s behalf. A business with a local site and an overseas owner should identify the actual claimant before assuming that the location of the site settles this requirement. The statute treats proper notice as consequential. An internal email about who owns the goods may be useful evidence, but it is distinct from the written claim required by the Schedule.

Paragraph 5 provides that the goods are deemed condemned as forfeited if the claim period expires without notice, or a notice given fails to meet the requirements of paragraph 4. Under paragraphs 6 and 8, a duly made claim leads to civil condemnation proceedings, where the question is whether the goods were liable to forfeiture at the time of seizure. This timing explains why later-acquired copies of existing records can still be relevant while a later change to the goods or their status does not by itself answer the question. It also explains why waiting for a criminal investigation to conclude can leave a claim about the goods out of time.

In a practical file, keep the goods schedule beside the stock and delivery evidence. If a notice lists several categories of goods, note which entries are being disputed and which records relate to each entry. Keep the written claim and evidence of when it was sent together. If there is also a communication about an interview or a criminal allegation, record its date and stated legal basis separately. This simple division helps prevent a reply about one matter being mistaken for the statutory step required in another.

Suppose a written notice lists goods seized from more than one part of a shared warehouse. One set of items can be traced to a consignment held by the operator. Another is said to belong to a customer. Before drawing conclusions from the address on the notice, compare the inventory with the warehouse records and identify the claimant for each disputed entry. A single account holder or storage address may appear against several sets of goods. Labelling the entries clearly also helps establish whether a statement about one group of packets is being applied to another group without evidence.

It can also help to write three dates beside each disputed entry where they are known: when the goods arrived, when they were seized and the date of any notice. The arrival date can guide the search for supporting invoices and payment records. The other dates matter under the separate statutory claim rule. A missing date should be recorded as a gap in the evidence. An estimate can guide a search for records, but should be clearly identified as an estimate if it appears in a chronology.

Conclusion

In England and Wales, a case involving cigarettes without a compliant fiscal mark starts with the goods. Establish which packets are in issue, whether the marking requirement applied and whether the records support an exception. Then identify the conduct alleged. Possession or transport under section 8G, permitting sales as a manager under section 8H and knowing involvement in fraudulent duty evasion under section 170 raise different questions about the person and the evidence.

Where goods have been seized, the written claim procedure adds a separate and potentially urgent question. Check the date of the seizure and any notice, identify who claims the goods and match the disputed entries to the contemporary records. How the goods were marked, whether duty was payable or paid and who dealt with them are matters that must be established on the evidence in any individual case.

📄 Official circular