KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Buttock Augmentation: Can You Get Your Deposit Back if Private Surgery Is Cancelled in England?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Buttock Augmentation: Can You Get Your Deposit Back if Private Surgery Is Cancelled in England?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The search term “buttock augmentation” is trending in the United Kingdom. For someone in England who has already booked private surgery, a practical question arises if the clinic cancels after taking payment: which part of the money can the clinic keep? The answer starts with the booking documents and the reason the operation fell through. A deposit credited against the price of surgery, a separately priced appointment that took place and a charge triggered by cancellation each need their own explanation. A single entry on a card statement can cover more than one of them.

A patient whose operation was cancelled outright is in a different position from one offered a workable replacement date. A cancellation for clinical reasons raises another distinction. The clinician’s decision about whether to operate and the trader’s decision about what to retain require separate analysis. A refund dispute can therefore be assessed without challenging the decision to stop or postpone surgery.

Hassan Kohen, a lawyer at the Paris Bar, explains the general approach under English consumer contract law as at 20 November 2026. The examples are hypothetical. They cover private bookings in England and focus on money already paid, including what evidence helps when the clinic says an advance payment was non-refundable.

I. Identify the contract and what the clinic cancelled

A. Find out who promised the surgery and what the deposit bought

Start with the written quote, the booking confirmation, the receipt and the version of the terms supplied before payment. The name at the top of the clinic’s website can differ from the legal name on the receipt. The receipt may also show that a booking business collected money on behalf of another provider. Look for the part of the documents that says who agreed to arrange the surgery, who agreed to supply it and who undertook to handle refunds. Where the operation was sold as a single package, the total price and the breakdown of the advance payment help explain the nature of that promise.

Section 2 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 defines traders and consumers for the services rules. A business or professional can act through someone acting in its name or on its behalf. A patient paying for a procedure for personal reasons will ordinarily be acting outside their trade or profession. Section 48 applies the services chapter to contracts for traders to supply services to consumers, subject to the limits in that provision. The commencement order brought the relevant rules into force for ordinary service contracts from 1 October 2015, with transitional rules for earlier contracts. The examples here assume a recent booking and a private consumer contract.

Consider two bookings where the patient paid the same £900. In the first, the written quotation shows a single operation and a £900 advance against the package price. The booking confirmation identifies a provider and a date. In the second, the documents show a £250 appointment, booked and paid for separately, and £650 credited against surgery to be arranged later. If the appointments and the paperwork match those descriptions, the second patient can identify which £650 relates to surgery straight away. The first patient needs the provider to explain where any proposed deduction comes from. In either booking, the documents may tell a different story from an accounting label used after cancellation.

Section 50 of the Consumer Rights Act can make information given by or on behalf of the trader contractually binding where the consumer took it into account in deciding to book or in making a decision about the service after booking. Qualifications given on the same occasion and changes expressly agreed by both sides matter. A written assurance that the advance would be returned if the provider cancelled can therefore be significant. So can a contemporaneous warning that the date was provisional until a particular assessment took place. Preserve the whole exchange, including the question that prompted the answer and any attachment the provider sent with it.

A separate charge for an appointment that took place calls for a closer look at what was agreed and delivered. An appointment may have had a standalone price payable for that service, or it may have been advertised as included in a package whose main purpose was the operation. A clinic that allocates part of a package price to work already done should be able to identify the work, the contractual basis for the deduction and how it calculated the amount. When the appointment itself is disputed, section 49 requires reasonable care and skill in the performance of the service. Deciding that a delivered appointment fell short of that standard requires evidence about the service itself.

Written records also help distinguish the company that sold the package from the provider that supplied a particular part of it. For example, a hospital name on a proposed admission form may identify the venue while the quote names a different company as the provider responsible for the booking. A consistent set of terms, invoices and payment confirmations can connect them. Where different firms issue separate invoices, keep those chains apart. This is a guide to English law from the perspective of a Paris-based law firm.

B. Distinguish a cancelled operation from a postponement or a clinical refusal

Read the actual cancellation message alongside the last confirmed booking. Note who sent it, what they said had happened, whether the original date was lost, and whether the provider proposed another date or merely promised to get in touch later. If the parties disagree about who cancelled, the first message ruling out the original booking can matter more than the subject line of a later administrative confirmation. A patient who declined an alternative date after the clinic withdrew the original one should record those two steps separately.

The date itself may be a term of the contract. Check whether it was fixed, whether the contract stated how it would be fixed, and whether binding information under section 50 supplied a date. Where none of those routes fixes the time and the contract provides no method for fixing it, section 52 implies performance within a reasonable time. What is reasonable depends on the facts. An agreed booking window, the purpose communicated to the provider and the length and certainty of any proposed replacement can help establish what happened and whether the provider complied.

Suppose a provider says an operating session can no longer go ahead because it has lost access to the venue. It gives the patient a specific replacement appointment at a comparable venue two weeks later with the same promised provider and package. Compare that with an indefinite postponement accompanied only by a credit on the clinic’s system. In both cases the original slot is gone. In the first case there is an actual offer to compare with what was promised. In the second, the patient still needs to establish when the clinic expects to deliver and what commitment, if any, it is making. A right to move the date under the contract and the fairness of that provision also matter.

For a clinical cancellation, establish the agreed conditions before trying to classify the decision. An appointment may have been reserved subject to a fitness assessment, with terms explaining what would happen to the deposit if the assessment prevented surgery. The clinician may instead have postponed while awaiting more information. Ask for the clinic’s position on whether the booking has ended and what happens to each payment. If the clinic relies on an alleged failure to supply information, compare its account with the requests and responses as they stood at the time. The distinction affects the financial dispute because a trader may rely on different contract terms for a booking that ends after an assessment and a booking the patient chose to abandon.

A provider’s cancellation is also compatible with circumstances in which the contract gave it a valid right to cancel or suspend performance. The written terms and facts then tell you whether the event falls within that right and what follows financially. A general statement about events beyond the provider’s control leaves questions about the actual event, its effect on performance, any obligation to offer a replacement and what the contract says about advance payments. Even where the event excuses performance, the question of retaining money paid for the affected service still needs to be addressed.

In a borderline case, build the chronology around facts the documents can show. For example, a confirmation can establish the original date, a short message can establish that the clinic removed it and a subsequent email can establish that no replacement had been offered for several weeks. Those facts provide a basis for testing the provider’s position. An explanation based solely on a label such as patient cancellation leaves that chronology unanswered.

II. Test the deduction and calculate the refund

A. Work out whether the cancellation terms allow the clinic to retain the money

The starting point is the term the provider says applies. Identify its wording, when it was supplied and which event triggers it. A paragraph dealing with a patient who withdraws shortly before surgery may have little to say about a provider cancelling a session. If the wording can genuinely bear different meanings, section 69 of the Consumer Rights Act generally favours the interpretation most favourable to the consumer. Section 68 requires the trader to ensure written consumer terms and notices are transparent. The copy that appeared before the booking is more useful than a later revision of the provider’s standard terms.

Even a plainly written retention term can raise a fairness question. Under section 62, a term is unfair if, contrary to good faith, it creates a significant imbalance in the parties’ contract rights and obligations to the consumer’s detriment. The assessment takes account of the subject of the contract, the circumstances when the term was agreed and the other relevant terms. An unfair term does not bind the consumer, who can choose to rely on it. The section 64 exception for certain main subject matter or price assessments is limited. It requires transparency and prominence, and a dispute about a cancellation mechanism is different from comparing the price of surgery with the value of the service supplied.

Imagine a clinic can cancel at its discretion, requires the patient to forfeit every payment and offers neither surgery nor a replacement date. The imbalance to examine is what each side gets and gives up when that power is exercised. Compare that with a term that distinguishes a separately agreed assessment already performed from the balance allocated to an operation the provider will no longer supply. Under the latter arrangement the consumer can check the basis and amount of the deduction against the original bargain. Under the former, a demand to retain the entire sum calls for close scrutiny of what the term permits and why.

Section 57 also limits contractual exclusions and restrictions of liability for the services obligations. It protects liability under section 49 against exclusion, and liability under section 50 subject to that section’s rules on qualifications and agreed changes. It also restricts terms that would prevent recovery of the price or equivalent consideration in an appropriate case under the statutory obligations it covers. This matters when the clinic uses a term about deposits to answer an allegation that it failed to honour a binding refund promise or another protected obligation. In that situation it is worth setting out the promise and the facts showing what the provider did, so the term can be assessed against the particular liability asserted.

Where the trader says it incurred a cost, separate a genuine charge for a delivered service from preparatory costs it says the contract passes on to the patient. Suppose the trader deducts £300 for reserving a facility. The facts to check include whether the patient agreed to that charge, whether the facility levied it and whether any part was refunded or credited to the trader. A provider may have commercially sensitive documents, but it can still explain the nature of the charge, the contractual basis and whether it represented an unrecovered expense. An itemised account also helps identify a charge already included elsewhere, such as an assessment deducted twice under different descriptions.

The same discipline helps where the patient cancelled first. A term about late patient cancellation has to be read with the applicable statutory rules and against the particular facts. The provider’s position can differ where the patient withdrew at short notice from a session the clinic stood ready to deliver and where the provider had already said the promised service could not happen. In either case, record the separate facts before using a percentage schedule. A statutory fairness argument can be precise when it identifies the words that produce the disputed deduction and the evidence of how they were applied.

B. Put the amount, evidence and refund deadline in writing

Set out the figures in a short ledger. Start with the total paid, show each receipt and state which amounts you accept as earned charges. Then show any refund received and the remaining sum claimed. For instance, a patient paid £1,200, accepts a separately contracted and delivered £200 assessment and has already received £300 after the provider cancelled. The remaining claim on those assumptions is £700. If the clinic asserts another £150 deduction, that £150 is a distinct issue. Identifying it separately helps both sides see whether they disagree about the contract, whether work was done, the amount of the deduction or two of those things at once.

Choose the legal basis that corresponds to the facts. A patient may rely first on the provider’s own refund promise. When a covered services obligation is breached, section 54 sets out the statutory remedies and preserves other remedies where available in the circumstances, including damages, recovery of money paid where the basis for payment has failed, and the right to treat a contract as ended where that right exists. The section also prevents double recovery for the same loss. Where the entire payment was for an operation that will never take place, the reason for claiming that payment back should be stated separately from any claim for additional expenses.

Section 55 provides for repeat performance of a non-conforming service where feasible. If the consumer requires it, the trader must provide it within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience and at its own necessary cost. Repeat performance cannot be required if conforming performance is impossible. These rules are about curing a failure under the relevant parts of section 54. A replacement date offered following cancellation also needs to be assessed against the original agreement. Where a clinical assessment rules out surgery, the financial issue can be pursued without requesting an operation.

Section 56 permits an appropriate price reduction, up to the full price where appropriate. If the consumer also has the right to require repeat performance, the price reduction becomes available when conforming performance is impossible or when the consumer has required repeat performance and the trader fails to provide it within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. A breach of the reasonable-time obligation under section 52 gives a price-reduction right under section 54(5). The availability and amount of a reduction therefore depend on which obligation was breached and what happened afterwards. A credit entered on a booking account is different from returning money where a refund is owed.

The 14-day rule in section 56 has a specific starting point. A refund under that section is due without undue delay and within 14 days beginning with the day the trader agrees the consumer is entitled to it. The statute also requires use of the original payment method unless the consumer expressly agrees to another method, and bars the trader from charging a refund fee. Keep the message recording the trader’s agreement and distinguish its date from the date the operation was cancelled. Where the contractual terms provide a separate refund right, check the terms of that promise.

A written refund claim is strongest when it specifies the desired outcome and tells the provider which points need an answer. Include the booking as confirmed, the date and terms of the cancellation message, the amounts paid and the deduction you dispute. Request the version of the terms relied on if it differs from the one supplied with the booking. Where an alternative date was offered, record its timing and any material change to the provider, venue or package. Keep the original clinical communications where relevant and provide the material necessary to show why the booking ended and why any deduction is disputed.

If the payment was made using qualifying credit, section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 can give the debtor a corresponding claim against the creditor for a supplier’s breach of contract or misrepresentation. The provision requires a qualifying credit relationship. For a single item the supplier’s cash price must exceed £100 and be no more than £30,000, subject to the other statutory conditions. The cash price of the relevant item can differ from the deposit charged to the card. Where a booking intermediary collected the money or the documents show several items, the agreement, invoice and payment chain matter. The creditor needs the facts supporting the underlying claim and the record of any sum already returned.

For an ordinary claim founded on a simple contract, section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980 generally gives six years from the date the cause of action accrued in England and Wales. That date depends on what obligation is said to have been broken. An internal complaint or a discussion about settlement is a separate process, so the date relevant to the contract claim should be identified independently. The six-year rule described here concerns ordinary contract claims about payment and should be kept separate from any issue about injury.

Conclusion

When private buttock augmentation is cancelled in England, the refund turns on the contract, the reason the original booking ended and the payment attributable to services actually supplied. An advance against the operation and a fee for a separately agreed assessment can call for different treatment. The clinic’s right to postpone or cancel, the fairness of a term allowing it to keep money and the remedy available for a proven breach are also distinct questions.

The most useful record combines the original booking terms and price breakdown with the first cancellation or postponement message, any replacement offer and a ledger of the amounts paid and returned. Those documents help establish which party ended the booking, what each payment bought and whether a proposed deduction has a contractual and statutory basis. If the trader agrees to a statutory price-reduction refund, preserve that agreement too. Its date determines when the specific 14-day period begins.

📄 Official circular