KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
BYD Ti7 UK buyers and the EU design ruling: driving, importing or reselling the car in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

BYD Ti7 UK buyers and the EU design ruling: driving, importing or reselling the car in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Searches for the BYD Ti7 in the United Kingdom jumped again this weekend, together with the query jaguar land rover byd lawsuit, and the reason is a court decision. In a judgment in summary proceedings delivered on 20 November 2026 (ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:34365), the preliminary relief judge of the District Court of The Hague held, on a provisional basis, that the Ti7 infringes a registered EU design held by Jaguar Land Rover for the current Defender, and ordered the BYD companies established in the European Union to stop importing, producing, offering, selling, storing or delivering the model anywhere in the Union. According to the press release published by the court, BYD had announced deliveries to consumers in the United Kingdom from January 2027, the judge declared that the court had no jurisdiction over the BYD company established in the United Kingdom, and the decision remains provisional until a court rules on the merits. In a statement reported by Reuters and relayed by CnEVPost on 22 November, BYD said that it designed the Ti7 independently, that it disagrees with the ruling and that it will appeal.

For a British buyer, the practical questions that follow concern France as much as the Netherlands: can a car bought in the UK be driven on French roads, can it be brought over when moving to France, can a dealer or a private importer sell one to French customers, and which French court would hear a dispute. The developments that follow are general in scope: they describe the checks that are useful in any comparable situation, under the EU design regulation and the French Intellectual Property Code, and they do not describe the situation of BYD or of Jaguar Land Rover, about which this article makes no finding. For a broader view of how design, trade mark and copyright disputes are handled in France, see our page on intellectual property and design law in France.

I. BYD Ti7 in the UK and the EU: what the Hague court decided on 20 November 2026

A. The EU design ruling of 20 November 2026 and why it reaches France

The facts set out below come from the published judgment and from the court’s press release; they are reported as the court records them. The claimant is Jaguar Land Rover Limited. The defendants are two BYD companies established in the Netherlands, BYD Europe and BYD Nederland, together with BYD companies established in France, Sweden, Denmark, Germany, Hungary, Poland and Italy, a company named BYD Mobility, and BYD UK, which is established in the United Kingdom. Jaguar Land Rover relied on six registered EU designs, most of them filed in 2018, in classes 12.08 (motor cars) and 12.16 (roofs for vehicles), and on the UK designs that were split off from them. The judgment records that, with leave granted on 14 August 2026, Jaguar Land Rover carried out a protective evidence seizure on 24 August 2026 against BYD Europe and BYD Nederland, that the seizure was allowed on the basis of the EU designs, and that it was refused in so far as it relied on the UK designs.

The press release explains the background in a few lines. BYD introduced the Ti7 on the Chinese market in 2025, wishes to bring it to Europe and announced that it could be delivered to consumers in the United Kingdom from January 2027. Jaguar Land Rover argues that the car copies the Defender of the type known as L663, on the market since September 2019 and covered by several EU design rights. In the summary proceedings, Jaguar Land Rover asked for the Ti7 to be withdrawn from sale immediately in both the United Kingdom and the European Union, even though, according to the same press release, BYD said that it currently had no concrete plans to place the Ti7 on the EU market. Jaguar Land Rover also asked for a corrective notice and for access to documents relating to the trade in the vehicle.

On jurisdiction, the judge distinguished three groups of defendants. For the two Dutch companies, the judge held that the court had international jurisdiction over the claims based on the EU designs under Articles 119(1), 120(a), 121(1) and 129 of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 of 11 March 2026 on European Union designs, which replaced Regulation (EC) No 6/2002 when it entered into force on 1 July 2026, and that, under Article 122(1) of that regulation, that jurisdiction extends to the whole of the European Union. For the other companies established in the Union, the judge accepted jurisdiction because the claims against them and against the Dutch companies concern the same situation, the promotion and offer of the same vehicle. For BYD UK, against which the claims rested only on the UK designs, the judge declared that the court had no jurisdiction.

On the merits, the judge examined only the first EU design, registered on 27 April 2018 under number 005248580-0004, and left aside the challenges to the validity of the five others. The press release summarises the reasoning: the design is characterised by its rounded shoulders and corners, the signature panel forming the rear pillar, the wheel arch cut-outs with rounded corners, the continuous window line, the proportions and therefore the overall silhouette; those dominant features are found almost identically in the Ti7, and the differences put forward by BYD, numerous as they are, were judged not striking enough to change the overall impression produced on the informed user. The judgment also records that the parties agreed that some of the claimed elements are partly functional or belong to a family resemblance found in successive generations of the Defender since 1948, which narrows the scope of protection, and that the judge therefore looked at the specific combination of features shown in the registration.

The order itself is precise. The judgment orders the BYD defendants, with the exception of BYD UK, to cease within one week of service any infringement of that first EU design in the European Union, and more specifically to stop importing, producing, offering for sale, selling, storing, delivering or otherwise trading in the Ti7. The judge explained that, since the Ti7 has not yet been placed on the EU market and the defendants had given no undertaking on that point, an EU-wide prohibition was appropriate, and that it should be addressed to the national companies, including the French one, because they handle the sale of BYD cars in their local markets. The other claims, including the corrective notice and access to documents, were rejected for lack of interest at this stage. The press release adds that, because this is a summary procedure, Jaguar Land Rover must bring proceedings on the merits within six months of the judgment, failing which the prohibition imposed on BYD may lose its effect.

Why does a Dutch judgment matter for France? The answer lies in the nature of the right. Article 1(3) of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 provides that an EU design has a unitary character and equal effect throughout the Union, and that its use may only be prohibited in respect of the whole of the Union. A registered EU design is therefore one title covering all Member States, France included, and a court whose jurisdiction rests on the defendant’s domicile can rule on infringements committed or threatened in any of them. French courts apply the same logic. In a case concerning a car manufacturer’s Community designs for alloy wheels, the Paris Court of Appeal held on 16 November 2022 that « s’agissant d’un modèle communautaire déposé, c’est à juste titre que le tribunal a étendu la mesure d’interdiction à l’ensemble du territoire de l’UE » (as a registered Community design was concerned, the court was right to extend the prohibition to the whole territory of the EU). The Hague order therefore covers French territory, and its addressees include the company in charge of sales in France.

B. Why the ruling leaves UK sales to UK law, and what an EU design protects

The second lesson of the judgment is negative, and it is the one British readers are looking for. The press release states that the judge declared the court without jurisdiction over the alleged infringement by the BYD company established in the United Kingdom, and that the judge rejected the claims against the Dutch companies concerning the UK design rights because it had not been sufficiently shown that those companies were involved in offering the Ti7 in the United Kingdom. The judgment adds that the Ti7 is offered and promoted in the United Kingdom by BYD UK, which is not a subsidiary of BYD Europe. The decision therefore does not decide whether the Ti7 may be sold in the United Kingdom. The UK designs relied on by Jaguar Land Rover are national rights of the United Kingdom, split off from the EU designs, and their scope is a matter of UK law. This article does not discuss UK law; it explains what the EU design and French law mean for a British owner, dealer or importer whose car, or business, crosses the Channel.

To understand what is protected, the starting point is the definition of a design. Under Article L511-1 of the French Intellectual Property Code, a design protects « l’apparence d’un produit, ou d’une partie de produit, caractérisée en particulier par ses lignes, ses contours, ses couleurs, sa forme, sa texture ou ses matériaux » (the appearance of a product, or of part of a product, resulting in particular from its lines, contours, colours, shape, texture or materials). The EU regulation follows the same approach: under its Article 19, protection is conferred on the features of appearance shown visibly in the application for registration, which is why the judge in The Hague compared the registered views with photographs of the vehicle, front, side, rear and top.

The decisive test is the overall impression. Article 11 of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 provides that the scope of protection of an EU design includes any design which does not produce on the informed user a different overall impression, and that the degree of freedom of the designer is taken into account. French law uses almost identical terms for national designs. Article L513-5 of the Code provides that « La protection conférée par l’enregistrement d’un dessin ou modèle s’étend à tout dessin ou modèle qui ne produit pas sur l’observateur averti une impression visuelle d’ensemble différente » (the protection conferred by the registration of a design extends to any design which does not produce on the informed observer a different overall visual impression), and Article L511-4 adds, for the assessment of individual character, that « il est tenu compte de la liberté laissée au créateur dans la réalisation du dessin ou modèle » (account is taken of the freedom left to the designer in creating the design). For a car, whose architecture is partly dictated by technical and regulatory constraints, the designer’s freedom can narrow the protection of an earlier design, as the Hague judgment acknowledges for the elements described as functional; the comparison then focuses on the specific combination of the remaining features, which is what the judge in The Hague examined.

The Cour de cassation has given two clarifications that a French court would apply to any car case. First, the comparison concerns the product as a whole, not one detail. In a judgment of 23 June 2021 published in its Bulletin, the commercial chamber ruled that « la protection conférée par l’enregistrement d’un dessin ou modèle, national ou communautaire, s’étend à tout dessin ou modèle qui ne produit pas sur l’observateur averti une impression visuelle d’ensemble différente » (the protection conferred by the registration of a design, whether national or Community, extends to any design which does not produce on the informed observer a different overall visual impression), and it quashed a decision which had compared only the stems of two wine glasses instead of the glasses as a whole. Second, the informed observer is not the average consumer. In a judgment of 29 March 2017 (No 15-20.785), the same chamber quashed a decision which had taken the tourist buying a souvenir as the reference person, recalling that the informed observer is endowed with particular vigilance, « que ce soit en raison de son expérience personnelle ou de sa connaissance étendue du secteur considéré » (whether because of personal experience or of extensive knowledge of the sector concerned). Applied to vehicles, that observer would be expected to know the market, the existing body styles and the usual design features, and to notice more than a passer-by would.

Finally, the regulation distinguishes two kinds of protection. Under Article 20(1) of Regulation (EU) 2026/715, a registered EU design confers on its holder the exclusive right to use it and to prevent any third party not having the holder’s consent from using it. Under Article 20(4), the holder of an unregistered EU design can only act against use that results from copying, and use resulting from an independent work of creation by a designer who may reasonably be thought not to be familiar with the earlier design is not regarded as copying. Which of these regimes applies is therefore the first question to check in any design dispute, before any comparison of shapes.

II. Taking a car covered by an EU design injunction to France: private use, import and resale

A. Driving a UK-bought car in France: the private and non-commercial use exception

A British motorist is not a party to the Dutch proceedings: the Hague order is addressed to the BYD defendants named in it. That is not, however, the end of the analysis, because the design right exists independently of the order and can be invoked against anyone. Article 20(2) of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 lists among the acts that the holder may prohibit the making, offering, placing on the market or using of a product incorporating the design, and the importing or exporting of such a product. French law is to the same effect: Article L513-4 of the Code prohibits, without the consent of the owner, « la fabrication, l’offre, la mise sur le marché, l’importation, l’exportation, le transbordement, l’utilisation, ou la détention à ces fins, d’un produit incorporant le dessin ou modèle » (the making, offering, placing on the market, import, export, transhipment, use, or stocking for those purposes, of a product incorporating the design). Read alone, the words use and import could seem to reach a person who simply drives a car across the border.

The answer comes from the limitations of the right. Article 21(1)(a) of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 provides that the rights conferred by an EU design shall not be exercised in respect of acts done privately and for non-commercial purposes. French law contains the same exception for national designs: Article L513-6 of the Code states that « Les droits conférés par l’enregistrement d’un dessin ou modèle ne s’exercent pas à l’égard » (the rights conferred by the registration of a design are not exercised in respect of), in its first point, of « actes accomplis à titre privé et à des fins non commerciales » (acts done privately and for non-commercial purposes). Two conditions are set, and they are cumulative: the act must be private, and it must not pursue a commercial purpose.

For the most common situation, a UK resident who owns a car personally and drives it to France for a holiday, a family visit or a weekend in Paris, the wording of the exception corresponds closely to the facts: the owner uses the car for their own purposes, outside any trade. The limits of what can be said must, however, be stated clearly. None of the French decisions consulted for this article applies the private-use exception to a vehicle driven across a border by its owner, and the regulation contains a specific exception only for the equipment of ships and aircraft registered in a third country that temporarily enter the Union (Article 21(1)(f) to (h)), with nothing equivalent for road vehicles. The protection of the private motorist therefore rests on the general exception and on the facts of each case, and the reasoning above describes how the texts are written rather than a solution already confirmed by a French court.

The situation becomes less clear as soon as a commercial element appears. A car registered to a company and used for business trips, a vehicle used for paid passenger transport or deliveries, a demonstration car taken to a trade fair, or a vehicle offered for hire to third parties does not fit easily into the wording private and non-commercial. In those cases, the use of the vehicle on French or EU territory could be analysed as use in the course of trade, which the exception does not cover. A business that plans to send such a vehicle into the Union, even occasionally, should therefore look first at the registration status of the design and at any court order in force, rather than assume that the private-use exception will apply.

Moving to France with a car bought in the United Kingdom raises the same question in a more lasting form. The legal analysis under design law is the one set out above: bringing one’s own car for one’s own use falls within the terms of the private, non-commercial exception, while bringing a vehicle in order to sell it falls outside them. The administrative rules on registering in France a vehicle coming from a non-EU country, which involve their own conformity requirements, are a separate matter that this article does not address.

Customs controls deserve a word, because British readers often ask whether a car could be stopped at the border. The EU design regulation gives the holder a specific right, in Article 20(3), to prevent third parties from bringing into the Union, in the course of trade, products from third countries that have not been released for free circulation, where the design is identically incorporated or cannot be distinguished in its essential aspects. The condition in the course of trade is written into the text. French law also allows the customs administration, under Article L521-14 of the Code and « En dehors des cas prévus par la réglementation communautaire en vigueur » (outside the cases provided for by the Community rules in force), on the written request of the design owner, to « retenir dans le cadre de ses contrôles les marchandises que celui-ci prétend constituer une contrefaçon » (detain, in the course of its controls, the goods which the owner claims to be infringing). The same article provides that the detention is lifted automatically if, within ten working days of notification, the applicant has not justified provisional measures ordered by a civil court, proceedings brought before a civil or criminal court with the required guarantees, or a criminal complaint. These mechanisms are designed for goods moving in commercial flows; none of the decisions consulted for this article concerns a private car driven by its owner.

B. Importing or reselling in France: infringement, evidence seizure and the Paris court

For traders, the analysis is far less favourable. The first point concerns exhaustion of rights, which is the rule that allows a product, once lawfully sold, to circulate freely. Under Article 23 of Regulation (EU) 2026/715, the rights conferred by an EU design do not extend to acts relating to a product placed on the market in the European Economic Area by the holder of the design or with the holder’s consent. A vehicle first sold in the United Kingdom, which is outside the European Economic Area, by a company other than the design holder does not meet either condition. An independent importer who buys such cars in Britain and offers them to customers in France cannot, on the wording of the text, rely on exhaustion to justify the resale.

Importing, offering or selling a product that falls within the scope of a design without the holder’s consent is an act of infringement. Article L521-1 of the Code provides that any infringement of the owner’s rights as defined in Articles L513-4 to L513-8 « constitue une contrefaçon engageant la responsabilité civile de son auteur » (constitutes an infringement engaging the civil liability of its author), and Article L522-1 extends these provisions to EU designs: « Les chapitres Ier et Ier bis du présent titre sont applicables aux atteintes portées aux droits du propriétaire d’un dessin ou modèle communautaire. » (Chapters I and I bis of this title apply to infringements of the rights of the owner of a Community design.) Regulation (EU) 2026/715 provides that references to the repealed Community design regulation are to be construed as references to it, in accordance with the correlation table in its Annex III. Ignorance is no defence in civil proceedings. In a case concerning a registered Community design for a staircase, the Paris Court of Appeal recalled on 8 October 2025 that « la bonne foi est inopérante en matière de contrefaçon » (good faith is irrelevant in infringement matters), and upheld the finding of infringement against a company that had presented and offered the product on its website. In civil proceedings, a dealer who did not know about the design, or about a foreign court order, is therefore exposed in the same way as one who did.

Online offers aimed at French customers deserve particular attention, because the prohibited acts include the offer itself, not only the delivery. A British dealer’s web page in English, with prices in euros and delivery to France, is not a private act; whether it constitutes an offer on French territory is a question of fact that a French court would examine on the evidence, but it is the kind of material that a design holder collects first.

French procedure gives the design holder strong tools to establish and stop an infringement, and the Dutch evidence seizure of August 2026 has a direct French equivalent. Article L521-4 of the Code opens with the rule that « La contrefaçon peut être prouvée par tous moyens. » (infringement may be proved by any means), and allows any person entitled to sue for infringement to obtain, by an order made on an ex parte application, a bailiff’s visit to carry out « soit à la description détaillée, avec ou sans prélèvement d’échantillons, soit à la saisie réelle des objets prétendus contrefaisants » (either a detailed description, with or without the taking of samples, or the actual seizure of the allegedly infringing goods), together with related documents. Article R521-2 specifies that « La saisie, descriptive ou réelle, prévue à l’article L. 521-4 est ordonnée par le président du tribunal judiciaire compétent pour connaître du fond. » (the seizure, whether descriptive or actual, provided for in Article L521-4 is ordered by the president of the judicial court having jurisdiction over the merits). Article L521-4 also provides that the whole seizure is annulled at the request of the person whose goods were seized if the applicant does not bring proceedings on the merits within the period fixed by regulation.

Urgent measures are also available in France, as they were in The Hague. Article L521-6 allows any person entitled to sue for infringement to apply to the interim relief judge for « toute mesure destinée à prévenir une atteinte imminente aux droits conférés par le titre ou à empêcher la poursuite d’actes argués de contrefaçon » (any measure intended to prevent an imminent infringement of the rights conferred by the title or to stop the continuation of allegedly infringing acts), including against intermediaries, but only if the evidence reasonably available to the applicant « rendent vraisemblable qu’il est porté atteinte à ses droits ou qu’une telle atteinte est imminente » (makes it likely that the rights are being infringed or that such an infringement is imminent). The judge may prohibit the continuation of the acts, or order the seizure or handing over to a third party of the suspected goods « pour empêcher leur introduction ou leur circulation dans les circuits commerciaux » (to prevent their introduction into or circulation in commercial channels). The text is clearly directed at products in trade, which is consistent with the distinction drawn above between the private owner and the professional seller.

If infringement is established on the merits, damages are assessed on a broad basis. Article L521-7 requires the court to take into account separately the negative economic consequences for the holder, including lost profits, the moral prejudice, and « les bénéfices réalisés par le contrefacteur, y compris les économies d’investissements intellectuels, matériels et promotionnels que celui-ci a retirées de la contrefaçon » (the profits made by the infringer, including the savings in intellectual, material and promotional investment that the infringer has derived from the infringement), or, at the holder’s request, to award a lump sum higher than the royalties that would have been due. In addition, French law makes knowing infringement a criminal offence: Article L521-10 provides that « Toute atteinte portée sciemment aux droits garantis par le présent livre est punie de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 300 000 euros d’amende. » (any knowing infringement of the rights guaranteed by this book is punishable by three years’ imprisonment and a fine of 300,000 euros). The word knowingly matters: the criminal offence requires knowledge of the infringement, unlike civil liability.

Which French court would hear the case? For EU designs, the answer is centralised. Article L522-2 of the Code provides that « Un décret en Conseil d’Etat détermine le siège et le ressort des juridictions de première instance et d’appel » (a decree adopted after consulting the Conseil d’État determines the seat and territorial jurisdiction of the courts of first instance and appeal) competent for actions concerning Community designs. Article R522-1 refers those actions to the courts designated by « l’article R. 211-7 du code de l’organisation judiciaire » (Article R211-7 of the Code of Judicial Organisation), and that article reads: « Le tribunal judiciaire compétent pour connaître des actions en matière de marques de l’Union européenne, dessins et modèles communautaires, dans les cas et conditions prévus par le code de la propriété intellectuelle, est celui de Paris. » (the judicial court with jurisdiction over actions concerning European Union trade marks and Community designs, in the cases and under the conditions laid down by the Intellectual Property Code, is that of Paris). Courts outside Paris decline jurisdiction accordingly: on 7 January 2025, the Lyon judicial court held that « le tribunal judiciaire compétent pour connaître des actions en matière de dessins et modèles communautaires est celui de Paris » (the judicial court competent for actions concerning Community designs is that of Paris) and that the claims based on those designs fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Paris court.

The territorial reach of a French decision depends on the ground of jurisdiction, exactly as in The Hague. Article 122 of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 provides that an EU design court whose jurisdiction is based on the defendant’s domicile or establishment, or on the other grounds listed in Article 121(1) to (4), rules on infringements committed or threatened in any Member State, whereas a court seised only because the infringement took place on its territory rules on that territory alone. Before the new regulation, the Paris court applied the same rule under the former Article 83 of Regulation No 6/2002, which it quoted in an order of 24 September 2026: « Un tribunal des dessins ou modèles communautaires dont la compétence est fondée sur l’article 82, paragraphes 1, 2, 3 ou 4, est compétent pour statuer sur les faits de contrefaçon commis ou menaçant d’être commis sur le territoire de tout État membre » (a Community design court whose jurisdiction is based on Article 82(1), (2), (3) or (4) has jurisdiction over acts of infringement committed or threatened in the territory of any Member State). In that case, the pre-trial judge accepted jurisdiction over the design claims against a manufacturer established in Spain and a distributor established in Italy, alongside French distributors, because the products had the same design and came from the same distribution chain, while declining jurisdiction over copyright and unfair competition acts committed outside France. For a trader, the practical consequence is that a single action in Paris against a company established in France can lead to a prohibition covering the whole Union, depending on the ground of jurisdiction relied on.

Two further points complete the picture for businesses. Transit is not a safe harbour: under Article 20(3) of the regulation, the holder can prevent products from being brought into the Union in the course of trade even when they are not released for free circulation, a right that lapses only if evidence is provided, in customs proceedings, that the holder cannot prohibit the placing on the market in the country of final destination. And a provisional decision is not a decision without effect: the court’s press release describes the order of 20 November 2026 as governing the period after the judgment until another court has assessed the case in full proceedings on the merits, subject to the six-month deadline for bringing those proceedings mentioned above.

In practice, a UK business that deals in vehicles covered by an EU design dispute can follow a simple sequence of checks. It can consult the public register of the European Union Intellectual Property Office, available through euipo.europa.eu, to see which designs are registered, for which products and since when. It can check whether a court order is in force, against whom and for which territory, by reading the published decision rather than press summaries. It can separate clearly its UK activity from any offer reaching customers in the Union, including through its website. And it can keep, for each vehicle that enters the Union, a record showing whether it travels as a private car of its owner or as goods intended for sale, since that distinction governs most of the answers set out above.

Conclusion

The order of 20 November 2026 is a provisional decision of a Dutch court, limited to the European Union and open to appeal, and it leaves the question of sales in the United Kingdom entirely to UK law. For France, three points stand out. First, a registered EU design is a single title with equal effect in every Member State, so a prohibition ordered by a court whose jurisdiction rests on the defendant’s domicile covers French territory, as the Paris Court of Appeal has confirmed for Community designs. Second, a private owner who drives a car bought in the United Kingdom to France for personal, non-commercial use falls within the terms of the exception provided by Article 21(1)(a) of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 and by Article L513-6 of the French Intellectual Property Code, although no French decision consulted for this article has yet applied that exception to a vehicle crossing a border, and any business use weakens the argument. Third, importing, offering or reselling such a vehicle in France is a commercial act outside that exception, without the benefit of exhaustion when the car was first sold outside the European Economic Area, and it exposes the trader to evidence seizure, interim prohibition, damages and, where the infringement is knowing, criminal penalties, before the Paris judicial court, which has exclusive jurisdiction over EU designs in France.

📄 Official circular