KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Central Arizona Floods: How Can You Document a Federal Flood-Insurance Claim?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Central Arizona Floods: How Can You Document a Federal Flood-Insurance Claim?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

If floodwater has reached your home in central Arizona, the first insurance question is not simply how much the repairs will cost. It is which policy applies, what that policy covers, and what you must send to the insurer to support the amount you claim. A homeowners policy and a federal flood policy may be separate contracts even when the same company handles both.

Start by finding the declarations page, checking that the policy was in force at the time of the loss, and preserving photographs, receipts, repair estimates, and correspondence. If the contract is the federal Standard Flood Insurance Policy for a dwelling, its proof-of-loss rules are specific: a notice that damage occurred and a signed, sworn statement of the amount claimed perform different functions. A written denial also opens questions about administrative appeal and a possible lawsuit, with separate time limits.

The federal rules discussed below apply to the dwelling form identified in the regulations; a private flood policy, a commercial form, or a condominium association policy may have different terms. The decisions discussed below report particular disputes. The practical checks are general and make no findings about the present situation of any party named in those decisions.

I. Which policy might cover the damage, and what evidence matters?

A. Identify the contract and separate building damage from contents

Gather every property-insurance declarations page that was in effect when the water entered. The declarations page identifies the insured location, policy period, coverages, limits, deductible, and insurer. Compare the address and the dates with the property and the loss you are reporting. A billing notice, mortgage statement, or application may be useful for locating the policy, but it is not a substitute for reading the policy actually issued.

Arizona’s Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions consumer guidance explains that homeowners coverage generally excludes flooding and that separate flood coverage may be needed. It is consumer guidance, not the text of your contract. Do not assume either that a homeowners policy covers an outdoor flood or that every water loss is excluded. A roof leak, a broken indoor pipe, a drain backup, and water overflowing across a neighborhood can raise different questions under different policies.

For a National Flood Insurance Program policy, identify whether the declarations page says the coverage is federally administered and which form applies. Under federal 44 C.F.R. § 61.13, the Standard Flood Insurance Policy forms are set out in the appendices to the regulation. The discussion here focuses on the federal dwelling form in 44 C.F.R. Part 61, Appendix A(1). Check the form and effective dates on your own documents before applying it.

A participating private insurer may issue an NFIP policy in its own name. Federal 44 C.F.R. § 62.23 describes these Write Your Own companies and their role in adjusting, settling, paying, and defending claims under the policy. The presence of a private insurer’s name therefore does not by itself mean the coverage is a private flood product. Ask for the actual flood-policy form, not just the name on a payment receipt.

Read the declarations page together with the sections for building property and personal property. Under the federal dwelling form, building coverage and contents coverage address different categories; personal property coverage must have been purchased. A tenant may own furniture and clothing without owning the walls or the building. A homeowner may have building coverage but no purchased contents coverage. A condominium unit owner should compare any individual policy with the association’s coverage and documents. Do not combine all three situations into one assumed limit.

Make two inventories. In the first, list the parts of the dwelling that show physical damage: for example, interior walls, flooring, installed equipment, doors, or a damaged foundation. In the second, list personal property, including its location, quantity, approximate age, purchase information if available, and observed condition. Record which rooms or areas were affected. The categories give the adjuster a way to follow the evidence and help you identify whether an estimate omits an item.

Also note the deductible and the applicable limit for each coverage. The federal dwelling form states that building and personal-property deductibles are separate for a flood loss. For an illustration only, if an otherwise covered building loss is assessed at $18,000 and the applicable building deductible is $2,000, the amount before applying other policy conditions and the coverage limit would be $16,000. That arithmetic does not establish that the loss is covered or that the insurer must use your estimate.

For a mortgaged property, look for the mortgagee or other loss payee on the policy. The federal dwelling form contains a mortgage clause addressing interests in building-loss payments. Keep the lender’s information with the claim records and ask how a payment involving a lender will be handled. Ownership, insurance limits, the amount of a mortgage, and the amount of a covered loss are separate facts; one does not automatically establish the others.

When a policy is missing, request a complete copy, including endorsements, declarations, and any written notices affecting coverage. Record when and how you requested it. If there are multiple carriers, identify which one issued each policy and preserve each claim number separately. These simple steps prevent a photograph or estimate sent for one coverage from being mistaken for a complete submission under another.

B. Document the water’s path and distinguish flood from other causes

The federal dwelling form requires direct physical loss by or from a flood as defined in that form. Evidence of water on a floor matters, but so does the broader condition outside the dwelling and the path by which water reached it. When safe to do so, photograph the surrounding ground, the points where water entered, marks on exterior and interior walls, and the damaged items. Save images of the same area from before the event if you have them, and retain the original files with their available dates.

Write a factual chronology while the observations are fresh. Record what you personally saw, approximately when you saw it, where the water appeared to come from, and whether it receded. Distinguish a firsthand observation from something a neighbor reported or an inference made later. If more than one process may have contributed, such as surface water and a backed-up drain, keep the relevant observations for each rather than choosing a cause solely to fit a policy label.

The distinction matters because the federal dwelling form has defined terms and exclusions. It generally excludes direct loss caused by earth movement, including land subsidence, even if flood caused the movement, while preserving the specifically insured forms of mudflow and certain land subsidence caused by shoreline erosion described in its definitions. It also addresses sewer or drain backup and seepage differently when there is a flood in the area and the flood is the proximate cause. The specific wording and the evidence of cause control; calling wet soil a mudflow is not enough.

In Pecarovich v. Allstate Insurance Company, 309 F.3d 652 (9th Cir. 2002), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on October 31, 2002 reversed summary judgment and remanded a dispute involving water and damage to land beneath a home, finding factual issues under the policy then before it. The ruling did not itself award payment for the loss. This historical interpretation involved an older policy and is not presented as a statement of the current federal dwelling form or a complete statement of current law. For a present claim, preserve evidence of both the water and the resulting damage, and compare it with the actual current contract.

In the later, nonprecedential Pecarovich v. Allstate Insurance, 135 F. App’x 23 (9th Cir. 2005), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on June 6, 2005 addressed a waiver issue under that older policy and remanded for a determination of whether the loss was covered and, if so, the amount. The memorandum did not establish coverage. It is relevant here as the subsequent history of that particular dispute, not as a statement of current law. For your own file, keep the decisions and your facts distinct, and do not assume that a resemblance determines the outcome under a different policy form.

If an engineer, contractor, restoration company, or adjuster prepares a report, keep the entire report and its attachments. Ask what was observed, what documents or photographs the author used, and whether the conclusion separates new flood damage from preexisting conditions. A useful estimate identifies quantities, materials, unit costs, and the location of the work. If an estimate changes after walls or flooring are opened, preserve both versions and explain what new observation caused the change.

Before discarding damaged materials, address immediate health and safety needs and document what you reasonably can. Photograph the item, its location, distinguishing details, and the damage; retain samples or records where feasible and ask the insurer about its inspection process. The federal dwelling form directs the insured to separate damaged from undamaged property as soon as reasonably possible and prepare an inventory with supporting bills, receipts, and related documents. Safety decisions and the circumstances at the property may affect what can reasonably be preserved.

Receipts for emergency work, cleanup, or alternative accommodation are worth keeping, but do not presume they all fall within the same coverage. The federal dwelling form excludes additional living expenses while an insured building is being repaired or cannot be occupied, and it contains specific rules for debris removal and loss-avoidance measures. Another policy or assistance program might be relevant, but its eligibility cannot be decided from the flood-policy form alone.

II. How do you submit the claim and respond if the insurer disputes it?

A. Give notice and prepare the signed, sworn proof of loss

Tell the correct insurer about the loss in writing and retain a copy of the message and any acknowledgment. The federal dwelling form calls for prompt written notice. Include the policy and claim identifiers, the insured address, a description of the loss, and a reliable way for the carrier to arrange an inspection. If you report a loss by phone, a written follow-up can create a clearer record of what you reported and when.

Under the federal dwelling form’s Article VII.G, a proof of loss is the insured’s statement of the amount claimed, signed and sworn to, with specified supporting information. The form generally requires that it be sent within 60 days after the loss; the same provision says the insured must still send it if an adjuster does not provide the form or help complete it. Check promptly for any written FEMA extension or other applicable direction for the specific event and policy. Do not assume that an extension granted after a different disaster applies to this one.

The required information under Article VII.G includes the date and time of loss, a brief explanation of how it occurred, the insured’s interest in the property, other potentially applicable insurance, relevant changes in title or occupancy, building specifications and detailed repair estimates, known mortgagees or other claimants, occupancy information, and an inventory of damaged personal property. Organize these materials by coverage and keep a copy of what was actually sent. A claim number by itself does not contain this information.

In Flick v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company, 205 F.3d 386 (9th Cir. 2000), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on February 15, 2000 affirmed summary judgment where the insured had not provided the sworn proof of loss required within the period in the policy then at issue. The decision illustrates why notice and a proof of loss should be tracked separately. This historical example reflects the policy and record then before the court; it is not presented as a complete statement of current flood-insurance law.

In Ferraro v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance, 796 F.3d 529 (5th Cir. 2015), the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on August 6, 2015 affirmed summary judgment where the additional amount sought was not supported by a signed and sworn supplemental proof of loss. An estimate or a note promising more information did not resolve that problem on the record before the court. The decision concerns the Fifth Circuit, not binding Ninth Circuit precedent for an Arizona property. In the unrelated civil-rights case Brown v. Pouncy, No. 22-30691 (5th Cir. 2024), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on February 19, 2024 cited Ferraro for the limited point that out-of-circuit decisions are persuasive rather than binding; Brown did not decide a flood-insurance claim.

That distinction helps when new damage or a higher repair estimate emerges. Compare the amount in the statement you signed with the amount in the latest detailed estimate and ask the insurer how to submit an amended proof under the applicable policy and any written extension. Preserve the correspondence, the earlier submission, and the later supporting material. Do not assume that merely informing an adjuster of a higher figure has accomplished every formal step, or that a supplement is automatically available after the relevant period.

Review the document before signing it. The federal dwelling form places responsibility on the insured to use personal judgment about the loss amount and justify it. Check the address, named insured, date of loss, figures for building and contents, supporting inventory, and information about other coverage. If an estimate is disputed, identify the items in dispute and the supporting evidence; a precise written explanation is more useful than an unexplained total.

Federal 28 U.S.C. § 1746 provides for a dated declaration under penalty of perjury in circumstances described by that statute. Whether a particular document satisfies the applicable flood-policy requirement depends on its wording and the governing law. Do not treat an unsigned list, a casual email, or a contractor’s estimate as interchangeable with the insured’s required statement merely because the documents contain a dollar amount.

Send the submission using a method accepted by the insurer and retain the submission, attachments, delivery information, and acknowledgment. If a file is too large or a form cannot be transmitted, document the difficulty and ask for an accepted alternative. The goal is a record that shows not only that a claim was opened but also what proof and supporting documents the carrier received.

B. Read a denial closely and choose the appropriate next procedure

If the insurer pays less than requested or sends a written denial, compare its explanation with your declarations, proof of loss, photographs, and itemized estimate. Identify the precise disagreement: whether a flood occurred, whether a particular item was damaged by it, whether the item falls within the coverage purchased, how the loss was valued, or whether a required claim document was supplied. Different disagreements call for different evidence.

For example, if the insurer’s estimate omits a damaged wall, locate the photographs and the contractor’s room-by-room measurements. If the issue is depreciation, ask how age and condition were determined and compare the calculation with the policy’s applicable settlement provision. If the carrier attributes damage to an earlier event, locate records showing prior condition or repair. A new document should answer a stated reason for the decision, not merely repeat the total you seek.

Federal 44 C.F.R. § 62.20 sets out an NFIP administrative appeal after the insurer’s final written denial of all or part of a claim. It requires a written appeal to FEMA within 60 days from the date of that decision, together with the denial, identifying claim information, the basis for the appeal, and relevant supporting documentation. The regulation also requires compliance with the Standard Flood Insurance Policy’s claim requirements. Read the denial and the regulation together before assembling the appeal.

An appeal packet can pair each reason for denial with the document that addresses it. For a disputed repair quantity, the useful attachment may be a room-by-room estimate with measurements. For an asserted preexisting condition, it may be a dated photograph and an invoice for earlier repairs. For an alleged missing proof, it may be the signed submission and evidence of delivery. Label attachments accurately and preserve the complete packet sent, not only the cover letter.

Do not confuse appeal with appraisal. The federal dwelling form provides an appraisal procedure for a disagreement over actual cash value or, when applicable, replacement cost and the amount of loss. Section 62.20 says disputes that are or have been subject to appraisal cannot be appealed under that section, and an issue on which an appeal is filed is no longer subject to appraisal or other pre-litigation remedies under the regulation. The choice deserves attention to what is actually disputed and which mechanism the policy permits.

A lawsuit is a separate procedure. Article VII.O of the federal dwelling form states that a suit to recover under that policy must start within one year after the date of written denial of all or part of the claim and be filed in the United States district court for the district where the insured property was located at the time of loss. Federal 42 U.S.C. § 4072 separately addresses an action against the Administrator following disallowance or partial disallowance in the circumstances it describes, using the date of mailing of notice. Identify the insurer and the applicable provision; do not assume the identity of the proper defendant from a policyholder’s mailing address alone.

Section 62.20 expressly says that an administrative appeal does not extend the time limitations in the Standard Flood Insurance Policy and that the one-year suit period begins with the insurer’s written denial. It also addresses the effect of litigation on an administrative appeal. Keep the written denial and its envelope or electronic delivery record, and treat the appeal and any possible suit as separate steps. The rules for a private flood-insurance contract are not established by this federal appeal regulation.

If several letters address different parts of a claim, keep each complete letter and the documents it references. A request for more information, an estimate, a payment, and a written partial denial may have different functions. This article does not resolve which communication starts a particular period in a disputed file; that depends on the actual documents and the governing authority. Avoid calculating a date solely from a conversation or from a later appeal acknowledgment.

Finally, organize the file so another reader can reconstruct it: policy and declarations first, then a dated sequence of notices, inspections, estimates, signed proofs, payments, denials, and responses. Keep originals and copies of the supporting photographs and invoices. A well-organized file cannot create coverage, but it makes it easier to see what the policyholder requested, what the insurer decided, and which factual or procedural issue remains unresolved.

Conclusion

For a central Arizona flood loss, begin with the exact policy and its effective coverage, then build a factual record of the water, the damaged property, and the amount claimed. Under the federal dwelling form, written notice, the signed and sworn proof of loss, an administrative appeal, and a lawsuit are distinct steps. Preserve the documents that support each step and check the governing time limits against the written policy, the applicable regulation, and any event-specific written extension. A careful comparison of the insurer’s actual reason with the evidence in the file gives the next decision a firm foundation.

📄 Official circular