KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Suitcase of 92 Snakes and Lizards Seized at Cologne Airport: What French Law Does to Wildlife Smugglers Landing at Paris CDG

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Suitcase of 92 Snakes and Lizards Seized at Cologne Airport: What French Law Does to Wildlife Smugglers Landing at Paris CDG

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 15 October 2026, customs officers at Cologne Bonn Airport stopped a 45-year-old Mexican firefighter who had, in the words of the German customs spokesman, looked conspicuously nervous as he walked through the green nothing to declare exit. They tested him for drugs, and the test came back positive for cocaine. Then they opened his suitcase. Inside, hidden in shampoo and cream bottles, plastic containers and balls of socks, were 37 live venomous snakes, vipers and rattlesnakes among them, and 55 lizards including iguanas. Some of the animals were being kept in inhumane conditions. Others had already died during the journey from Mexico City via Istanbul. The man, who has not been named, told officers he had brought the animals back as a favour for a Brazilian acquaintance. He was denied entry to Germany and put on a plane back to Istanbul, while the surviving animals were taken to a snake farm. The story, reported by the BBC on 15 October 2026, is grotesque, but it is not anecdotal: German customs recorded more than 1,300 seizures last year involving over 56,600 protected animals and plants or products made from them, and six years ago the same airport had already intercepted 26 rare reptiles, ten of them dead, smuggled inside parcels of toys and sweets from Mexico and destined for private buyers in Germany.

For an international reader, the interesting question is not whether the snakes survived. It is what happens when the same suitcase lands one runway further west, at Paris Charles de Gaulle. France applies the same European machinery as Germany, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species implemented through Council Regulation (EC) No 338/97 of 9 December 1996, but it adds its own border procedure, its own criminal courts, and some of the heaviest wildlife penalties in Europe. A traveller stopped at Roissy with protected reptiles in a suitcase faces three successive walls: the European permit wall at the border post, a possible refusal of entry with placement in the airport waiting zone, and a criminal prosecution for smuggling protected species that carries three years of imprisonment and a 150,000 euro fine. This article explains each wall, with the texts and the recent French decisions that enforce them.

I. Stopped at the airport with protected animals in your suitcase: what happens at the French border?

The first thing to understand is that the Cologne interception was not a German invention. The green exit control, the seizure, the refusal of entry and the confiscation all flow from European Union law that binds France in identical terms. When customs at Paris Charles de Gaulle open a suitcase full of reptiles, they run the same script, and the French version of that script is documented in statutes, in European regulations directly applicable in France, and in recent court decisions.

A. Do I need a CITES permit to bring a reptile into France?

Yes, and the permit must exist before the animal reaches the border. The international starting point is the Washington Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, known as CITES, which lists protected species in three appendices according to the degree of threat. Inside the European Union, that convention is implemented, with rules stricter than the convention itself, by Council Regulation (EC) No 338/97 of 9 December 1996 on the protection of species of wild fauna and flora by regulating trade therein, a regulation available on the official EUR-Lex portal at Council Regulation (EC) No 338/97. The regulation sorts species into four annexes, A to D, and its Article 4 governs every introduction of a protected specimen into the Union. For the most strictly protected species, those in Annex A, introduction into the Union requires prior checks and presentation, at the border customs office of the point of entry, of an import permit issued by the management authority of the Member State of destination. For Annex B species, which cover a large share of traded reptiles, the same architecture applies: introduction is subject to the necessary checks and the prior presentation, at the border customs office, of an import permit issued by the management authority of the Member State of destination, granted only if the scientific authority considers that the introduction would not harm the conservation of the species and if the applicant proves that the accommodation for a live specimen is adequately equipped to conserve and care for it properly.

Three consequences follow for a suitcase like the one seized at Cologne. First, the permit must be presented at the border customs office at the point of introduction, which means before or at the moment of entry, never after the seizure. Second, the applicant must already hold documentary evidence that the specimens were obtained lawfully in the country of origin, in practice a CITES export permit or re-export certificate issued by the competent authority of the exporting country. Third, for live animals, the authorities check the destination accommodation. A tourist who lands with vipers in shampoo bottles fails all three tests at once.

French domestic law adds a second layer that is even broader. Article L. 412-1 of the Environment Code provides that the production, collection, capture, detention, transfer for consideration or free of charge, use, transport, introduction from any origin, importation under all customs regimes, exportation and re-exportation of all or part of non-domestic animals and their products, as listed by joint orders of the environment minister, are subject to declaration or to authorisation by the administrative authority: Article L. 412-1 of the Environment Code. The phrase importation under all customs regimes matters: there is no regime, no green channel, no personal luggage exception that silently authorises the import. Either the traveller holds the declaration receipt or the authorisation, or the import is unlawful.

Two supposed escape routes regularly invoked by intercepted travellers deserve a clear answer, because European law closes both of them expressly. The first is transit: the Cologne passenger had travelled from Mexico City via Istanbul, and travellers sometimes argue that animals merely passing through should be exempt. the regulation does exempt specimens genuinely in transit through the Union from border checks and presentation, but only where a valid CITES export or re-export document stating the destination of the specimens was issued before shipment by the competent authorities of the exporting third country. Without that pre-issued document, the regulation requires seizure of the specimen, with possible confiscation unless the document is produced retrospectively under conditions set by the Commission. In other words, transit without papers means seizure, not free passage. And in any event, a passenger who walks through the green exit of the airport of arrival, as the Cologne man did, is entering the territory, not transiting through it.

The second escape route is the souvenir argument: a single animal, a gift, a personal pet. Article 7(3) of the regulation, on personal and household effects, derogates from the permit requirements only for dead specimens, parts and derivatives of listed species carried as personal effects, under conditions set by the Commission. Live venomous snakes in socks are never personal effects. French courts have applied the same strictness to commercial transactions in protected specimens. On 4 December 2025, the Paris Court of Appeal, Pole 4 Chamber 9-A, ruled in a case about a narwhal tooth fragment bought at auction at the Hotel Drouot for 9,000 euros plus fees, that the sale had taken place without the intra-Community CITES certificate required by the combined provisions of Article 8(1) of Regulation (EC) No 338/97 and Article 43 of Regulation (EC) No 865/2006 of 4 May 2006, and held: “Il est donc acquis que la vente n’aurait jamais dû avoir lieu”, the sale should never have taken place, because the transaction was prohibited unless the CITES certificate had been issued before the sale: Paris Court of Appeal, 4 December 2025, RG 24/15564. If a Paris auction house cannot sell a century-old narwhal tooth without a prior certificate, a traveller cannot walk through Roissy with 92 live reptiles and no papers at all.

B. Can France refuse me entry and hold me at the airport over smuggled animals?

The Cologne passenger was denied entry to Germany and flown back to Istanbul. France has an equivalent, fully codified procedure, and it can be applied to a wildlife smuggler exactly as it is applied to any traveller who does not satisfy the admission conditions. Article L. 332-1 of Code on the Entry and Stay of Foreigners and the Right of Asylum provides: “L’étranger qui ne satisfait pas aux conditions d’admission prévues au titre I peut faire l’objet d’une décision de refus d’entrée, sans préjudice des dispositions particulières relatives au droit d’asile et à la protection internationale ou à la délivrance de visas de long séjour”, meaning that a foreigner who does not satisfy the admission conditions may be refused entry: Article L. 332-1 of the Code on the Entry and Stay of Foreigners. Article L. 333-1 adds the enforcement arm: “La décision de refus d’entrée sur le territoire français dont l’étranger fait l’objet peut être exécutée d’office par l’autorité administrative”, the refusal decision may be enforced directly by the administration: Article L. 333-1 of the Code on the Entry and Stay of Foreigners.

In practice, the traveller is not simply put on the next plane within the hour. A foreigner who arrives by air and is not authorised to enter may be placed in a waiting zone at the airport for the time strictly necessary for departure. Article L. 341-1 states: “L’étranger qui arrive en France par la voie ferroviaire, maritime ou aérienne et qui n’est pas autorisé à entrer sur le territoire français peut être placé dans une zone d’attente située dans une gare ferroviaire ouverte au trafic international figurant sur une liste définie par voie réglementaire, dans un port ou à proximité du lieu de débarquement ou dans un aéroport, pendant le temps strictement nécessaire à son départ”: Article L. 341-1 of the Code on the Entry and Stay of Foreigners. At Paris Charles de Gaulle, that is the well-known Roissy waiting zone. Placement beyond the initial period requires the authorisation of a judge, the judge of freedoms and detention, and the statute surrounds the measure with rights that the administration must notify in a language the person understands: the foreigner placed in the waiting zone is informed, as soon as possible, that he may request the assistance of an interpreter and a doctor, communicate with counsel or any person of his choice, and leave the waiting zone at any time for any destination outside France. Article L. 343-1 provides exactly that: “L’étranger placé en zone d’attente est informé, dans les meilleurs délais, qu’il peut demander l’assistance d’un interprète et d’un médecin, communiquer avec un conseil ou toute personne de son choix et quitter à tout moment la zone d’attente pour toute destination située hors de France”: Article L. 343-1 of the Code on the Entry and Stay of Foreigners.

Two practical points complete the border picture. First, the animals do not travel with the passenger. Under Article 7(2)(c) of Regulation No 338/97, specimens without the required export documents must be seized and may be confiscated, and in France seized live animals are entrusted to specialised structures while the criminal case runs its course, exactly as the surviving Cologne reptiles were taken to a snake farm. The cost of that care does not fall on the taxpayer by default: Article L. 415-3 of the Environment Code allows the criminal court, upon conviction, to charge the offender with the expenses incurred for the capture, sampling, keeping or destruction of the specimens that proved necessary. Second, a parallel file can open alongside the wildlife file. In Cologne, the cocaine test was positive but no drugs were found, so the case remained a wildlife and immigration matter. In France, a positive narcotics screening at the border leads to blood or urine confirmation under judicial supervision and can trigger a separate prosecution for transport or importation of narcotics, which follows its own rules and its own penalties. Travellers should understand that one suitcase can therefore generate two cases, and that the drug screening result never legalises the animals: each offence is assessed on its own evidence.

II. Smuggling protected species into France: what prison sentence, fine and confiscation do you face?

Once past the border, the case becomes a criminal file, and French criminal law treats wildlife smuggling as a serious offence, not as an administrative irregularity settled by a fine at the counter. The prosecution typically runs on two parallel tracks, the environmental track and the customs track, and recent decisions of the Court of Cassation show how courts calibrate each one.

A. Three years and 150,000 euros: the French wildlife offence and how the courts apply it

The foundation is the general prohibition. Article L. 411-1 of the Environment Code lists the acts forbidden for protected non-domestic animal species and their habitats: “sont interdits : 1° La destruction ou l’enlèvement des oeufs ou des nids, la mutilation, la destruction, la capture ou l’enlèvement, la perturbation intentionnelle, la naturalisation d’animaux de ces espèces ou, qu’ils soient vivants ou morts, leur transport, leur colportage, leur utilisation, leur détention, leur mise en vente, leur vente ou leur achat”, which prohibits, for these species whether alive or dead, transport, peddling, use, detention, offering for sale, sale or purchase: Article L. 411-1 of the Environment Code. A suitcase of vipers and iguanas checks almost every box of that list at once: capture, transport, detention, and intended sale or delivery.

The penalty is set by Article L. 415-3, in its version in force since 26 March 2025: “Est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 150 000 € d’amende : 1° Le fait, commis de manière intentionnelle ou par négligence grave, en violation des interdictions ou des prescriptions prévues par les dispositions de l’article L. 411-1 et par les règlements ou les décisions individuelles pris en application de l’article L. 411-2”, punishable by three years of imprisonment and a 150,000 euro fine, for acts committed intentionally or through gross negligence: Article L. 415-3 of the Environment Code. The same article then targets the smuggler’s exact conduct in its paragraph 3: “3° Le fait de produire, ramasser, récolter, capturer, détenir, céder, utiliser, transporter, introduire, importer, exporter ou réexporter tout ou partie d’animaux ou de végétaux en violation des articles L. 411-6 et L. 412-1 ou des règlements et des décisions individuelles pris pour leur application”, covering the detention, transport, introduction, import, export or re-export of animals in violation of the permit requirements. The same article doubles the fine when the offences are committed in the heart of a national park or in a nature reserve, allows the administration to settle certain cases by transaction before prosecution begins, and, as noted, lets the court charge the convicted person with the costs of capturing, sampling, keeping or destroying the specimens: “Lorsqu’une personne est condamnée pour une infraction au présent article, le tribunal peut mettre à sa charge les frais exposés pour la capture, les prélèvements, la garde ou la destruction des spécimens rendus nécessaires.”

Three recent rulings of the criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation show how these texts bite in practice, and each of them removes one excuse. The first concerns the mental element. On 18 October 2022, in a case where a company building a gas pipeline had failed to carry out ordered replanting and restoration work for protected species, the Court held that the offence of harming the conservation of natural habitats or non-domestic animal species can be committed by the simple failure to comply with the applicable prescriptions: “le délit, prévu par le 1° de l’article L. 415-3 du code de l’environnement, d’atteinte à la conservation des habitats naturels ou espèces animales non domestiques, en violation des prescriptions prévues par les règlements ou décisions individuelles pris en application de l’article L. 411-2 du même code, peut être consommé par la simple abstention de satisfaire aux dites prescriptions.” It added the decisive sentence for all negligence defences: “D’autre part, une faute d’imprudence ou négligence suffit à caractériser l’élément moral du délit”, a fault of carelessness or negligence is enough to establish the mental element of the offence: Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, 18 October 2022, no. 21-86.965. The company saw its 650,000 euro fine quashed only because the appeal court had not explained its reasoning on the company’s means, but the conviction mechanism itself survived. For the suitcase smuggler, the message is direct: there is no need to prove an intention to harm biodiversity; gross carelessness about permits is enough.

The second ruling is the closest to the Cologne facts, and it dates from this year. On 6 January 2026, the criminal chamber ruled on the case of a man convicted by the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal for Environment Code offences and smuggling of protected species, “pour infractions au code de l’environnement et importation en contrebande d’espèces protégées”, sentenced to a 5,000 euro suspended fine, confiscation and a customs fine, “l’a condamné à 5 000 euros d’amende avec sursis, une confiscation et une amende douanière.” The offender challenged the very constitutionality of the wildlife offences, arguing that the law was too vague, the punishment disproportionate, and the burden of proof reversed. The Court refused to refer any of the five constitutional questions to the Constitutional Council, and its three answers now frame every French wildlife file. On legality, it held that referring to regulation the definition of the protected heritage, the prohibited acts, the species concerned and the activities subject to authorisation does not breach the principle of legality, since Parliament did not delegate the determination of the constituent elements of the offences, which remains subject to review by the criminal judge: “le renvoi au pouvoir réglementaire de la définition, pour les délits incriminés par l’article L. 415-3, 1° et 3°, du code de l’environnement, des éléments du patrimoine naturel protégés, des motifs pour lesquels ils le sont, des différents actes interdits, des espèces ou catégories d’animaux concernés et des activités soumises à autorisation ou à déclaration, ne méconnaît pas le principe de légalité des délits et des peines, le législateur n’ayant pas délégué la détermination des éléments constitutifs de ces infractions, laquelle relève du contrôle du juge pénal.” On proportionality, it held that the penalties, which the judge has a duty to modulate according to the case, were considered necessary by Parliament to protect certain animal species and do not appear manifestly disproportionate to the aim: “les peines prévues par les dispositions contestées, que le juge a le devoir de moduler en fonction de la situation soumise à son appréciation, ont été considérées comme nécessaires par le législateur pour assurer la protection de certaines espèces animales, et n’apparaissent pas manifestement disproportionnées par rapport au but recherché”: Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, 6 January 2026, no. 25-86.937. The same decision confirms the dual-track structure of French wildlife cases: the offender was punished under both the Environment Code and customs law for smuggling, with a customs fine on top of the environmental sentence and confiscation of the specimens.

The third ruling removes the last excuse, the vested right. On 19 May 2026, the criminal chamber rejected the appeal of a pond owner convicted for destroying the habitat of protected species while dredging ponds over which he held ancient vested water rights. The Court approved the appeal judges for holding that even the holder of such rights cannot escape the public-order provisions on protected species: “son titulaire ne peut s’exonérer de respecter les dispositions d’ordre public des articles L. 411-1 et L. 415-3 du même code afférents à la conservation des espèces protégées ou de leurs habitats.” It drew the practical consequence: anyone planning works liable to affect protected species or their habitat must obtain the derogation provided by Article L. 411-2, even when holding vested water rights over the land: “il incombe au propriétaire d’un terrain qui souhaite effectuer des travaux susceptibles d’affecter des espèces protégées ou leur habitat d’obtenir la dérogation, prévue à l’article L. 411-2 de ce code, aux interdictions prévues à son article L. 411-1, même s’il bénéficie d’un droit d’usage de l’eau fondé en titre sur ce même terrain”: Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, 19 May 2026, no. 25-85.311. If a French landowner cannot invoke centuries-old rights to escape the permit requirement, a transit passenger cannot invoke the hurry of a connection.

French courts apply the same strictness to every form of cross-border coercion, and readers who follow surrender and detention cases will recognise the pattern: in October 2026 the criminal chamber twice blocked surrenders to foreign states on procedural and time-bar grounds, as analysed in the October extradition rulings. The logic is identical at the wildlife border post: the judge verifies, the administration must hold valid papers, and shortcuts do not survive review.

B. It was a favour for a friend: the defences that fail and the paperwork that saves you

Return now to the Cologne suitcase and test each defence a lawyer in Paris would hear in the police station. The man said he carried the animals as a favour for a Brazilian acquaintance. Under Article L. 415-3, paragraph 3, the offence punishes detention, transport, introduction and importation; it does not punish ownership. The courier who carries, the friend who receives, and the seller who profits are all within the same prohibition, each on his own acts. Acting for someone else divides neither the facts nor the penalty; at most, the court modulates the sentence between the organiser and the carrier, since the judge has, in the words of the 6 January 2026 ruling, the duty to modulate punishment according to the situation before him.

The second defence is ignorance: the traveller did not know the species were protected, did not know permits were required, did not read the regulation. Here French law draws a distinction that must be stated precisely, because the two 2026 and 2022 rulings each illuminate one side of it. For conservation-harm offences, a fault of carelessness or negligence suffices, and the offence can be committed by simple omission, so genuine ignorance of the ecological damage changes nothing. For permit-based offences under Articles L. 415-3, paragraph 3, and L. 412-1, the 6 January 2026 ruling is more demanding for the prosecution and more protective for the defence: it describes provisions “qui sanctionnent le non-respect, en connaissance de cause, de l’exigence d’une autorisation administrative pour détenir ou céder certains animaux d’espèces dont la liste est fixée par le règlement”, which punish the knowing failure to comply with the administrative authorisation requirement, adding that they do not create an irrefutable presumption of guilt: “n’instituent pas une présomption irréfragable de culpabilité.” A traveller who can credibly show he neither knew nor could have known that an authorisation was required keeps a real argument. But the bar is high: 92 reptiles of dozens of species, hidden in shampoo bottles and sock balls, vipers and rattlesnakes among them, carried through the green channel by a passenger who tested positive for cocaine, leaves almost no room for a credible claim of innocent mistake. Concealment is the opposite of good faith, and courts read it that way.

The third defence is paperwork produced too late: an export permit requested after the seizure, a certificate asked for retrospectively. Regulation No 338/97 answers in advance. Transit without a pre-issued export document leads to seizure, with confiscation unless the document is submitted retrospectively under Commission conditions, and the Paris narwhal ruling shows how French judges treat retrospective regularisation in the commercial context: the certificate had to be issued before the sale, and the sale should never have taken place. A permit obtained after interception may mitigate the sentence; it does not erase the offence committed at the border.

What, then, saves the lawful traveller, the collector, the scientist, the zoo or the relocating family? Only advance paperwork, in this order. First, identify the exact species and its CITES appendix and European annex, because the permit regime follows the listing. Second, obtain the CITES export or re-export permit from the country of origin before departure. Third, apply to the French management authority for the EU import permit and wait for its issuance, proving lawful origin and adequate accommodation for live specimens. Fourth, enter through a designated border customs office and declare the specimens spontaneously, with the documents in hand, instead of choosing the green channel. Fifth, keep every document, transport the animals in conditions that do not amount to mistreatment, which can add animal-welfare offences to the file, and contact counsel immediately if controlled, since statements made to customs and to the biodiversity inspectors of the French Office for Biodiversity shape the file from the first hour. The Cologne story needed none of this analysis to go viral. But for the next passenger tempted by an exotic souvenir, a favour for an acquaintance, or a profitable delivery, the French answer is already written in the codes and in three years of case law: the suitcase will be opened, the animals will be seized, entry will be refused, and the court will modulate a punishment that Parliament fixed at three years and 150,000 euros.

Conclusion

The Cologne seizure of 15 October 2026 will be remembered as a curiosity, 37 venomous snakes and 55 lizards in shampoo bottles, a nervous passenger, a favour for an acquaintance, a return flight to Istanbul. For French law, it is something more useful: a live demonstration of a machinery that operates identically at Paris Charles de Gaulle. European law requires import permits presented at the border customs office before entry, French law subjects importation under all customs regimes to declaration or authorisation, refusal of entry can be enforced directly with placement in the airport waiting zone under judicial supervision, and the criminal courts punish detention, transport and importation of protected species with three years of imprisonment and a 150,000 euro fine, on a dual environmental and customs track. Since January 2026, the Court of Cassation has confirmed that this architecture is constitutional, that negligence suffices, and that no vested right dispenses with the prior derogation. Travellers, collectors and professionals who move live animals across borders have therefore only one safe strategy: permits first, declaration second, green channel never.

📄 Official circular