KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Cruise Ship: When Can a Passenger Bring an Injury Claim Under Canadian Maritime Law?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Cruise Ship: When Can a Passenger Bring an Injury Claim Under Canadian Maritime Law?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The search for “cruise ship” in Canada raises a practical legal question for a passenger injured during a voyage. A fall on a gangway, a fall inside a terminal and an injury during a separately organised shore excursion may occur within hours of one another. Canadian maritime law can treat them differently. The booking and the exact point at which the injury happened can matter as much as the port on the itinerary.

Part 4 of the federal Marine Liability Act gives force of law to the passenger liability provisions in Schedule 2. They govern qualifying international carriage and also extend to certain journeys under a contract that start and finish in Canada. For an injury claim governed by those provisions, the passenger needs evidence of the stage of the journey, the cause and consequences of the injury, and the date of disembarkation. In some types of ship incident the law presumes fault unless the carrier establishes the contrary. In an ordinary injury claim, the passenger will generally have to prove fault.

This guide explains the Canadian federal rules as at 20 November 2026. It is general information about foreign law. Its examples are hypothetical and show what to document at the ship, gangway or terminal, which booking details identify the carrier, and why a written incident report and the formal deadline serve different purposes.

I. Establish whether Canadian passenger liability rules cover the injury

A. Read the itinerary and identify who agreed to carry you

Start with the contract, including the ticket, booking confirmation and applicable terms. Keep the names of the place of departure and destination as written, even if they are the same. Preserve the scheduled intermediate ports, any later itinerary and the notice of a changed call. The contract and schedule answer legal questions independently of the passenger’s home address or the location of the travel agency. A round trip can be international even though there is a single place of departure and return.

Article 1(9) of the Convention in Schedule 2 defines international carriage by reference to the contractual departure and destination. It includes carriage between two different states, and carriage beginning and ending in the same state if the contract or scheduled itinerary includes an intermediate port of call in another state. For such carriage, Article 2(1) gives alternative connections to a state party. Look at the flag or registration of the ship, the place where the carriage contract was made and the contractual place of departure or destination. Section 38 of the Act treats Canada as a state party for these purposes. A Canadian port call can affect the classification of the route. An intermediate call should still be distinguished from the contractual departure or destination when applying Article 2.

There is a separate route into the rules for Canadian trips. Section 37(2)(a) extends Articles 1 to 22 to carriage by water under a contract from a place in Canada to the same or another place in Canada, directly or by way of a place outside Canada. Suppose the ticket is for a round trip from a Canadian port and the ship is scheduled to return there. Start by recording that the contract has both Canadian endpoints. If the cruise also has a scheduled foreign stop, keep that part of the record too. The domestic extension and the international definition each need to be checked on their own terms. Conversely, for a trip between foreign ports bought by someone who lives in Canada, residence alone leaves the Article 2 question unanswered.

A journey with several tickets can create a different issue. Put separately purchased ferry rides, transfers and excursions in their own rows. For each, record who was to provide the transport, what was included in the price and whether it was booked as part of the cruise or under a separate contract. Section 36 modifies the Convention definitions for Canadian application, including by reading carriage by sea as carriage by water. That can make the form of the transport and the contractual arrangements more important than what the holiday brochure calls it. A separate activity with exposure to aquatic risks also deserves a closer look. Section 37.1 sets a specific exception for adventure tourism where its conditions are met, including greater risk than ordinary passenger carriage, special safety equipment and procedures, and risks presented and accepted in writing. A form described as a waiver, taken on its own, establishes only one part of that inquiry at most.

Identify the legal role of each organisation on the paperwork. Article 1 distinguishes the carrier, on whose behalf or by whom the carriage contract was made, from a performing carrier, the owner, charterer or operator that actually performs all or part of the carriage. A traveller can buy a journey through one intermediary, obtain a ticket identifying a contracting carrier and board a vessel run by another organisation. The name at the top of the credit card receipt can help locate the booking. The carriage contract, the operator and the role of any agent are the next things to establish.

Article 4 provides that entrusting performance to a performing carrier leaves the contracting carrier responsible for the entire carriage under the Convention. The performing carrier is subject to the Convention for the part it actually performs. Where both are liable, the Convention makes their liability joint and several to that extent. In a case involving a transfer boat, obtain the details of the transfer arrangement before assuming that the cruise operator ran the boat or that a separate operator’s involvement excludes responsibility for the carrier named in the ticket. Keep the ticket terms, each carrier’s legal name and the exact part of the journey that each performed. The purpose is to identify the right party or parties from the transport arrangements.

B. Record exactly where the injury happened and what you were doing

Article 1(8)(a) covers the passenger while on board and during embarkation or disembarkation. It also covers transport by water between land and ship if the cost is included in the fare or the carrier put the auxiliary vessel at the passenger’s disposal. The same paragraph excludes the period during which the passenger is in a marine terminal, station, on a quay or in or on another port installation. Keep the distinction between the place of the incident and the operation underway. A report that only says at the port leaves out the facts needed to apply the paragraph.

Take three hypothetical arrivals. In the first, a passenger is descending the ship’s gangway under crew direction and falls before reaching the quay. The record should show where on the gangway the fall happened, who controlled its use and how the passenger was moving at the time. In the second, a passenger has finished leaving the vessel, enters a terminal and trips while collecting a bag. Record the terminal location and what had already happened at the ship. The passenger exclusion in Article 1(8)(a) matters in the second example. The Convention’s rules for cabin luggage at a terminal, in Article 1(8)(b), do not establish that a person injured in the same location was still within carriage.

In the third example, a passenger is injured on a boat taking passengers from the ship to shore. Keep the fare breakdown, the boarding instructions and any timetable provided on board. Those documents can establish whether the transfer was included or whether the carrier supplied the auxiliary vessel for the passenger’s use. If the accident happened later on an excursion, record the point where the transfer ended and the excursion began, together with the separate booking and the operator. The close timing is useful for reconstructing the day, but Article 1 makes the character of the transport and the stage of the journey relevant to the legal question.

Make a contemporaneous sketch or note showing the deck, opening, landing or walkway involved. Mark the point where the incident started and where the person ended up. An injury can occur after an initial hazard, and a photograph of the final position alone may not establish where it began. Identify who saw the event and who arrived afterwards. Keep their accounts separate. If staff recorded the place differently, ask for the written report or its reference and identify the difference in factual terms. Relevant records might include boarding scans, transfer schedules, incident logs or photographs of the route. Ask promptly for relevant material to be preserved. A request for preservation does not guarantee access to the material.

If the boundary is uncertain, state the facts for each possible account. A passenger may describe a fall as occurring at the foot of the gangway while the operator records it as occurring on the quay. A useful chronology distinguishes where the passenger’s foot slipped, which structure they were on and where they came to rest. If the ferry or transfer boat was involved, add who directed boarding and who supplied the vessel. Those facts can support or defeat an argument about carriage and help identify anyone who controlled the area. If the incident falls outside the Convention’s passenger coverage, a different claim requires its own legal and factual assessment. Do not carry the Convention deadline or its fault rules over to that claim without checking.

II. Build the evidence for liability and protect the time for a claim

A. Establish what caused the injury and what loss followed

Article 3(1) of Schedule 2 links carrier liability to damage resulting from an incident during carriage caused by the fault or neglect of the carrier or its servants or agents acting within the scope of their work. Article 3(2) puts the burden of proving that the incident occurred during carriage and the extent of the damage on the claimant. For an ordinary fall on an internal stair, start with evidence of the actual condition of the surface, lighting and handrail, the presence of a warning and any other factual explanation that can be checked. The occurrence of a fall alone leaves several possible causes open. Evidence may show what was present when the passenger fell, when it was first observed and who controlled the area.

Article 3(3) applies a rebuttable presumption of fault in specified situations. For personal injury it covers an injury arising from or connected with shipwreck, collision, stranding, explosion, fire or a defect in the ship. If there are grounds to believe that a defect caused the injury, identify the physical feature at issue and preserve what connects it to the incident. A general suspicion about maintenance tells the reader little about the failure that allegedly occurred. The presumption concerns fault. The claimant still needs to establish that the incident was within carriage, that the injury was connected with the relevant event and the extent of the resulting loss. In other injury cases, the claimant must prove fault or neglect. Article 6 also allows liability to be reduced or removed if the carrier proves that the passenger’s fault or neglect caused or contributed to the harm, in accordance with the law of the forum hearing the case.

For a Canadian vessel, section 106 of the Canada Shipping Act, 2001 gives the vessel’s authorised representative duties that include developing procedures for safe operation and emergencies and ensuring that crew and passengers receive safety training. A safety procedure or record can be relevant evidence where it deals with the incident. If a claim concerns a manoeuvre during boarding, for instance, identify the relevant instruction and distinguish the practice observed on the day from the written procedure. Section 106 does not replace the questions in Article 3. Establish whether the provision applies to the vessel and explain how the alleged failure is connected to the injury before drawing conclusions about liability.

Record the harm with the same precision as the incident. Keep the shipboard medical record, any record of referral to shore, the first medical assessment ashore and later records that explain diagnosis or changes in treatment. A receipt shows that a payment was made. Keep the accompanying document that explains what it was for and how it relates to the injury. For missed work, preserve the dates, employment record and any confirmation of time lost. If there was a pre-existing condition, the chronology needs to distinguish earlier symptoms and treatment from any change after the incident. A claimant’s initial description, medical notes and later account can each be evidence. Where they differ, find out why, and preserve the originals.

A limit of liability is a separate issue from proving damage. Article 7(1) gives the personal injury figure in units of account per carriage. Article 9 identifies those units as Special Drawing Rights and supplies the basis for currency conversion. The printed figure of 175,000 is expressed in those units and cannot simply be read as Canadian dollars. Section 40 of the Marine Liability Act provides a mechanism for amending the Schedule to implement a change to the limits. Article 13 sets a specific threshold for loss of the right to limit, involving intent to cause the damage or recklessness with knowledge that such damage would probably result. Check the current wording and any applicable limitation rules before putting a value on a claim. An amount expressed in a statutory limit tells you the potential ceiling under that provision, while the evidence of loss supports the amount actually sought.

B. Calculate the deadline and check the forum before negotiations take over

The formal deadline for a personal injury claim under the Convention generally runs from the date of the passenger’s disembarkation. Under Article 16(1) and (2)(a), the period is two years. Record both the date of the accident and the date on which the passenger disembarked. A scheduled return date may differ from the actual disembarkation date because an injured passenger goes ashore earlier. Keep the medical transfer record and itinerary if that happens, and establish what the relevant disembarkation was. An unresolved difference between two dates is a reason to work from the earlier plausible deadline while it is checked.

For example, if a passenger is injured during carriage on 3 July and disembarks on 6 July, the disembarkation date is the starting point in an ordinary personal injury calculation under Article 16(2)(a). A report sent to the carrier on 12 July and an assessment that arrives in August do not provide later starting dates under that provision. Subject to any applicable rule on counting time, suspension or interruption, plan for formal commencement before the two-year period runs out. Article 16(3) refers grounds of suspension or interruption to the law of the forum hearing the case, and sets a three-year outer limit by reference to actual or scheduled disembarkation, whichever is later. The normal two-year period still needs to be protected. Article 16(4) allows an extension by a written declaration of the carrier or written agreement of the parties after the cause of action has arisen. Do not assume that acknowledgement of a complaint, an offer to investigate or ongoing correspondence amounts to such an extension.

Record the available connections for the forum question while gathering the accident evidence. Article 17(1) lists possible forums in a state party. These can include the defendant’s permanent residence or principal place of business or the contractual place of departure or destination. The claimant’s domicile or permanent residence, and the state where the contract was made, can provide additional options subject to the conditions that the defendant has a place of business and is subject to jurisdiction there. Article 17(2) also allows an agreement on a forum or arbitration after the incident. Keep the contract, the booking location and the carrier’s legal details. Under Article 18, a pre-incident clause restricting the claimant’s options under Article 17(1) is void. That protection still leaves the claimant to establish that a chosen forum meets the Convention’s requirements and can hear the claim.

Separate the incident report from a demand for payment and from any formal commencement document. An onboard report usually records an account for the operator. A later letter can identify the allegations and ask for records or a response. For Article 16, the question is whether the action was brought in time under the applicable procedure, or whether there is a legally effective basis for a different deadline. Keep a copy of each document and proof of what happened to it, including when it was sent, when it was acknowledged and, where relevant, the record of filing. Do that for each proposed defendant if more than one party may be responsible.

Put the records into a single timeline with the incident, disembarkation, medical care, report and any response dated separately. Keep the carrier’s correspondence complete, including the attachment that may contain an offer or procedural condition. If the booking was made by one passenger for several people, identify who was injured and who entered the contract. A family booking does not by itself show who can sign a release or extend time on another person’s behalf. Where there is a dispute over responsibility for a transfer or shore activity, keep any parallel correspondence in the same file, with the activity and operator clearly identified. That makes the distinction between a claim arising during carriage and a possible claim against a separate operator legible.

A traveller who lives in France may also need to deal with French booking or insurance paperwork. The Paris law firm’s English-language overview concerns the French legal context. Where the Canadian passenger regime applies, the Canadian connection, the relevant stage of carriage and the Convention’s own time and forum provisions remain the matters to establish for the maritime claim.

Conclusion

For a cruise ship injury claim in Canada, start with the itinerary and the carriage contract. Identify the contracting carrier and the operator involved in the particular part of the journey. Record where the injury began and whether the passenger was on board, embarking, disembarking, in a qualifying water transfer or already in a port facility. Those facts help establish whether the Convention applies and where to direct requests for records.

Then identify what caused the injury. The presumption for specified ship incidents can affect proof of fault. The passenger must still be able to prove the connection to the injury and the loss. Record disembarkation independently of the accident and the first report, and establish the available forum early enough to act within the applicable period. An accurate timeline and a copy of the actual booking help resolve both questions before evidence is lost or time expires.

📄 Official circular