KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Dublin Airport flights cancelled today in Storm Boelo: compensation, refund or rerouting under EU261?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Dublin Airport flights cancelled today in Storm Boelo: compensation, refund or rerouting under EU261?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Strong winds from back-to-back storms disrupted Dublin Airport this weekend, and on Sunday airlines cancelled around 30 flights from the day’s schedule, according to DublinLive, which quoted the airport stating via X that gusting winds in Ireland and poor weather at airports overseas had resulted in airlines cancelling around 30 flights from that day’s Dublin Airport schedule. The same report recorded that nine outbound and ten inbound flights had already been cancelled by 4 p.m. on Saturday, and that passengers were told to keep in direct contact with their airline about the status of their flight. The wider storm system also left about 90,000 properties without power after two storms struck Britain, according to The Guardian on 26 October 2026. For a passenger holding a cancelled Dublin departure, including a flight to Paris or another French airport, the legal question splits in two. The fixed compensation of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, known as EU261, can be refused where the operating carrier proves weather incompatible with the flight and proves that every reasonable measure was taken. The refund or rerouting choice, and meals, hotel and transport while waiting, follow a different logic and do not vanish because the sky was dangerous. This article explains both sides, with the proof a judge will expect.

I. Dublin Airport flights cancelled today: does storm weather cancel your compensation?

A. Flight cancelled due to storm compensation: the weather must make the flight impossible

Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 covers first the passenger departing an airport in a Member State. Its Article 3 covers passengers departing from an airport located in the territory of a Member State to which the Treaty applies, a scope the French courts apply to departures from a Member State airport: Tribunal judiciaire de Bordeaux, 19 March 2025, No 23/01923. A departure from Dublin therefore falls squarely inside the Regulation, whatever the nationality of the operating carrier, because the same article adds that it applies to any operating air carrier carrying the passengers concerned. An arrival into Dublin from a third country is narrower: the Regulation applies there only where the operating carrier is a Community carrier and the passenger has not received benefits, compensation and assistance in that third country. The passenger must also hold a confirmed reservation and, outside a cancellation, present for check-in as specified or, where no time was indicated, not later than 45 minutes before the published departure time. Keep the booking confirmation and the cancellation message: they are the first two exhibits of any later claim.

Article 5 then organises cancellation as three distinct rights, and confusing them is the most common error in storm cases. Cancelled passengers are offered assistance under Article 8, meaning the refund or rerouting choice examined in Part II. They are offered care under Article 9, meaning meals and, where the new departure is expected the next day, hotel and airport transfers. They also have a right to the fixed compensation of Article 7, unless they were informed early enough with a suitable rerouting, or unless the extraordinary-circumstances defence of Article 5(3) succeeds. That defence is worded narrowly. As the Cour de cassation restates Article 5(3), as interpreted by the Court of Justice: « un transporteur aérien effectif n’est pas tenu de verser l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 s’il est en mesure de prouver que l’annulation ou le retard de trois heures ou plus à l’arrivée à destination d’un vol sont dus à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises » (in English: an operating air carrier is not obliged to pay the Article 7 compensation if it can prove that the cancellation or an arrival delay of three hours or more is caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken). Two cumulative elements appear on the face of the text: an extraordinary cause, and proof that the cancellation could not have been avoided even with every reasonable measure. A storm over Ireland can supply the first element. It never supplies the second by itself.

Weather is named in recital 14 of the Regulation, among the events that can amount to extraordinary circumstances, as meteorological conditions incompatible with the operation of the flight concerned. The operative word is “incompatible”. Rain over Dublin, a wind warning in the county, or disruption elsewhere in the network does not answer the legal test. The conditions must be incompatible with operating the flight concerned, at its time, on its route, with its aircraft and crew constraints as proved in the file. French courts apply that sentence literally. On 16 January 2026, the Tribunal judiciaire de Nantes refused Article 7 compensation after finding, in its own reasoning, « les conditions météorologiques étant incompatibles avec la réalisation du vol concerné » (in English: the meteorological conditions being incompatible with the operation of the flight concerned). The Tribunal judiciaire de Bordeaux, on 19 March 2025, accepted the same defence only after the carrier produced METAR information showing reduced visibility, a EUROCONTROL report and an irregularity sheet, and the court stated the safety hierarchy plainly: « Tout risque touchant à la sécurité des passagers prime sur l’obligation de résultat de la compagnie aérienne. » (in English: any risk affecting passenger safety takes precedence over the airline’s obligation to achieve the result). Safety prevails over departure. Safety does not dispense with proof.

The Court of Justice gave the concept its general test on 22 December 2008 in Wallentin-Hermann, C-549/07. In the formulation repeated by the Cour de cassation from that case law, extraordinary circumstances cover « les événements qui, par leur nature ou leur origine, ne sont pas inhérents à l’exercice normal de l’activité du transporteur aérien concerné et échappent à la maîtrise effective de celui-ci » (in English: events which, by their nature or origin, are not inherent in the normal exercise of the activity of the air carrier concerned and are beyond its actual control). A gust front that closes a runway direction, winds beyond the operating limits applied to that departure, or weather at the destination or alternate that makes the flight concerned inoperable can meet that description. Routine winter weather that the carrier’s normal operation must absorb, a rotation already dislocated for internal reasons, or a cancellation decided long after conditions had become compatible again, points the other way. The distinction is factual, flight by flight. That is why two passengers in the same terminal on the same afternoon can lawfully receive different answers: one flight was inoperable in the proved wind window, another was cancelled for the knock-on positioning of an aircraft that the carrier could reasonably have replaced. The Cour de cassation restated that two-condition test as recently as 23 September 2026, appeal No 25-14.563, in a long-delay case caused by a passenger’s medical emergency: the events must be outside normal operations and beyond actual control, « ces deux conditions étant cumulatives et devant faire l’objet d’une appréciation au cas par cas » (in English: those two conditions being cumulative and requiring a case-by-case assessment). That ruling decides a medical-diversion delay, not a storm cancellation, and only its restatement of the cumulative test is used here. Only the judge decides which side of the line a given flight occupies.

B. Cancelled flights Dublin Airport today: who proves extraordinary circumstances?

The fixed sums at stake are those of Article 7, set out by the Bordeaux court in its reasoning as « 250 euros pour tous les vols de 1500 kilomètres ou moins » (in English: EUR 250 for all flights of 1,500 kilometres or less), EUR 400 for intra-Community flights of more than 1,500 kilometres and other flights between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometres, and EUR 600 for the remaining flights, distances being measured by the great-circle route method. A Dublin to Paris sector falls in the first band by distance; the point here is method, not a promise for any individual ticket, because the relevant distance is assessed by reference to the final destination where the passenger arrives late following the cancellation. Article 7 also permits a 50 percent reduction where rerouting brings the passenger to the final destination within two, three or four hours of the scheduled arrival, depending on the band. Article 5(1)(c) separately removes compensation where the passenger was informed at least two weeks before departure, or between two weeks and seven days with a rerouting departing no more than two hours earlier and arriving less than four hours later, or less than seven days with a rerouting departing no more than one hour earlier and arriving less than two hours later. A same-day storm cancellation at Dublin will rarely meet those information windows, so the contest concentrates on Article 5(3), exactly as the Nantes and Bordeaux cases show.

On proof, the text places the burden on the carrier twice over. Article 5(3) exempts only the carrier which “can prove” the extraordinary cause and the unavoidable character of the cancellation. Article 5(4) adds that the burden of proving whether and when the passenger was informed of the cancellation rests with the operating air carrier. The Cour de cassation, first civil chamber, restated the carrier’s burden on 17 February 2021, appeal No 19-21.362, summarised in the official headnote as follows: the passenger whose flight arrives with a delay of three hours or more has a right to compensation unless the carrier proves an extraordinary circumstance, and the ministerial night ban at Orly in that case was held not to be such a circumstance: Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 17 February 2021, No 19-21.362. That ruling concerned an airport night restriction, not a storm, and it must not be transposed beyond what it decides. Its value for a Dublin storm file is procedural: the court does not ask the passenger to disprove the weather; it asks the carrier to prove an event outside normal operations and beyond its actual control, and to prove what it did about it. French general law on proof, cited in the visa of that 2021 ruling, points in the same direction for a party claiming release from an obligation: « Réciproquement, celui qui se prétend libéré doit justifier le paiement ou le fait qui a produit l’extinction de son obligation. » (in English: conversely, a person who claims to have been released must establish the payment or the fact which extinguished the obligation).

“All reasonable measures” is therefore an evidence exercise, not a slogan in a refusal email. In Pešková and Peška, C-315/15, on 4 May 2017, the Court of Justice described reasonable measures as measures which can actually be adopted by the carrier, which do not impose intolerable sacrifices in the light of its capacities, and which the carrier must demonstrate were actually taken in relation to the flight concerned. That case concerned a bird strike, and its fourth ruling, on deducting the extraordinary portion from a mixed-cause arrival delay, answers a delay question that a pure cancellation does not raise. Read with discipline, its transferable point is the standard of demonstration: for the flight concerned, with documents. For Storm Boelo, a carrier file that persuades will typically contain the METAR and forecast sequence for Dublin and the destination, the EUROCONTROL or airport capacity messages, the flight irregularity report tying the cancellation decision to those conditions, and the rerouting search showing what comparable transport existed in the relevant window. The Bordeaux judgment of 19 March 2025 is instructive precisely because the carrier produced that type of file; the Nantes judgment of 16 January 2026 also records the flight disruption report produced by the carrier before the court accepted the defence. A generic statement that “weather” caused the cancellation, without the flight-specific sequence, invites the court to find the defence unproved. The lightning-strike ruling of the Cour de cassation, first civil chamber, 12 September 2018, appeal No 17-11.361, shows the chronology a court credits: the aircraft at Bordeaux-Mérignac was struck by lightning at 8.39 a.m., aeronautical engineers declared at 9.32 a.m. that the damaged aircraft no longer met optimal safety conditions, the carrier decided at 10.25 a.m. to send a replacement aircraft from its London base, and rerouting on another carrier would only have been possible at 6.20 p.m.; on those findings the carrier had established that, « même en mettant en oeuvre tous les moyens en personnel ou en matériel et les moyens financiers dont il disposait, il n’aurait manifestement pas pu, sauf à consentir des sacrifices insupportables au regard des capacités de son entreprise au moment pertinent » (in English: even by deploying all the staff, equipment and financial means at its disposal, it clearly could not, without making intolerable sacrifices in the light of the capacities of its undertaking at the relevant time), have avoided the outcome. Lightning is not wind, and that case ended in a long delay rather than the Dublin cancellations; its method, a timed safety inspection followed by a timed replacement decision, is the template against which a Storm Boelo file will be read.

Three passenger situations recur in every storm wave and should be separated before any claim form is filed. First, the flight was cancelled inside the proved incompatible window and no reasonable rerouting that day would have cured it: Article 7 compensation will ordinarily fail, while Articles 8 and 9 remain, as Part II explains. Second, the flight was cancelled outside that window, or other comparable departures operated and the carrier cannot explain why this rotation alone had to fall: the compensation claim stays alive, and the passenger should demand the METAR sequence, the irregularity report and the rerouting search rather than accept the label in the refusal. Third, the case is mixed: weather started the disruption and a later, separate cause prolonged it. The decisions consulted for this article do not authorise a mechanical apportionment for cancellations, and no such rule should be invented by deduction from the delay ruling in Pešková. The safe course is chronological: fix, with timestamps, when the weather was incompatible, when the cancellation was announced, what rerouting was offered and when, and what the carrier says prevented each later option. That chronology, not the storm’s name, decides the compensation question.

II. Dublin Airport departures cancelled: refund, rerouting, hotel and meals tonight

A. Dublin Airport flights cancelled tomorrow: choose refund or rerouting, carefully

Article 8 gives the cancelled passenger a choice, and the choice has consequences that must be understood before tapping accept in an application at midnight. The passenger is offered the choice between, first, reimbursement within seven days of the full cost of the ticket at the price at which it was bought, for the part or parts of the journey not made and for parts already made if the flight no longer serves any purpose in relation to the original travel plan, together with, where relevant, a return flight to the first point of departure at the earliest opportunity; second, rerouting to the final destination under comparable transport conditions at the earliest opportunity; or third, rerouting under comparable conditions at a later date at the passenger’s convenience, subject to seat availability. The seven-day period stated in the text concerns the reimbursement limb. No broader payment deadline for every head of claim should be deduced from it. Payment follows the methods of Article 7(3): cash, electronic bank transfer, bank orders or bank cheques, or, with the signed agreement of the passenger, travel vouchers or other services. A voucher imposed without that signed agreement does not match the method described by the Regulation for sums governed by that cross-reference, and the passenger who wants money should say so in writing and keep the exchange.

Choosing the refund ends the transport that the refund repays. The Nantes judgment of 16 January 2026 illustrates the trap with uncomfortable clarity: the carrier proved an information email offering the options in the Regulation, the passengers opted for reimbursement, the court recorded the bank-card repayments, and claims built afterwards on a rerouting the passengers said they had to find by their own means were dismissed, together with the Article 14 complaint in that case: Tribunal judiciaire de Nantes, 16 January 2026, No 23/02078. The lesson is practical, not moral. If the journey to Paris, to a connection, to work or to a family event still matters, do not select reimbursement while intending to demand the replacement flight as well. Ask, in writing, for rerouting at the earliest opportunity under comparable conditions, record the flights the carrier says are unavailable, and only then decide whether a self-bought alternative is a calculated expense or a certain loss. The Irish Aviation Authority states the same boundary in its air passenger rights guidance: a passenger who declined the following-morning rerouting and booked with another airline is only entitled to a refund for the unused cancelled flight from the original airline. A passenger who must travel regardless can still buy the other ticket; the purchase should be made with eyes open about which sum the original carrier will repay without a court fight.

Two related distinctions protect the rest of the itinerary. Where a city or region is served by several airports and the carrier reroutes the passenger to a different airport from the one booked, Article 8(3) places the transfer cost on the carrier: it bears the cost of transferring the passenger from the arrival airport to the airport for which the booking was made or to another close-by destination agreed with the passenger. For a Dublin passenger rerouted toward Paris through a different arrival airport, keep the transfer receipt and the message imposing the change. Separate tickets are the opposite risk. The Irish Aviation Authority answers the connecting-flight question directly in the same guidance: bookings made separately are regarded as separate contracts, and under the Regulation a refund will only be due for the cancelled flight. A Dublin to Paris ticket bought separately from an onward train or flight therefore needs its own protection: contact the second carrier at once, keep its conditions and its reply, and do not assume that the first carrier’s cancellation rewrites the second contract. Passengers whose flight formed part of a package should also notify the organiser without delay and keep both files distinct, because Article 8(2) itself separates the refund right where that right arises under the package-travel directive referred to in the Regulation. Readers who want the wider map of cancellation, long delay and denied boarding can consult our guide to challenging a refused flight-cancellation compensation claim based on extraordinary circumstances, then return to the storm-specific proof questions in this article.

B. Dublin Airport flights delayed and cancelled: meals, hotel and the complaint file

Care under Article 9 is owed while the passenger waits, and extraordinary circumstances do not switch it off. The operating carrier must offer meals and refreshments in a reasonable relation to the waiting time, hotel accommodation where a stay of one or more nights, or a stay additional to the one intended by the passenger, becomes necessary, transport between the airport and the place of accommodation, and two telephone calls, telexes, fax messages or electronic messages. For cancellation, Article 5(1)(b) triggers meals and communications, and hotel plus transfers where rerouting is reasonably expected to depart at least the day after the planned departure. Article 9(3) requires particular attention to the needs of persons with reduced mobility and those accompanying them, and to unaccompanied children; Article 11 gives those passengers priority and care as soon as possible in cancellation, denied boarding or delay of any length. A family sleeping on a terminal floor while the carrier’s desk issues no voucher, no hotel direction and no written notice is not a weather outcome. It is a care file, and it should be documented as one: photographs are less useful than timestamps, desk messages, the names of the counters visited, and itemised receipts for food, hotel and ground transport.

The Court of Justice settled the survival of care during an extraordinary event on 31 January 2013 in McDonagh, C-12/11, arising from the closure of part of European airspace after the Eyjafjallajökull eruption. Such circumstances, the Court held, do not release carriers from the care obligation in Articles 5(1)(b) and 9. Where the carrier failed in that care, the passenger can recover only reimbursement of the amounts which, in the light of the specific circumstances of each case, proved necessary, appropriate and reasonable to make up for the carrier’s shortcomings in the care provided, which is a matter for the national court to assess. Every word does work in a storm claim. Necessary excludes comfort upgrades chosen while a suitable offered hotel stood unused. Appropriate ties the expense to the wait the cancellation imposed. Reasonable invites the national judge to test the rate, the distance and the number of nights against the rerouting actually available. Keep the carrier’s offer, or the absence of an offer, beside each receipt; a bundle of invoices without the offer history asks the judge to guess, and judges dislike guessing in both directions.

Information and complaint complete the file. Article 14 requires the operating carrier which cancels a flight to provide each passenger affected with a written notice setting out the rules for compensation and assistance, and to provide the contact details of the designated national body in writing. Article 15 states that obligations to passengers under the Regulation cannot be limited or waived by a derogation or restrictive clause in the contract of carriage, and a passenger who was not duly informed and accepted less than the Regulation provides may take the necessary proceedings before the competent courts or bodies to obtain additional compensation. Article 16 requires each Member State to designate a body responsible for enforcement for flights departing its airports and for third-country flights arriving there, and allows any passenger to complain to a designated body about an alleged infringement at an airport in a Member State or concerning a flight arriving there from a third country; the European Commission publishes the list of national enforcement bodies for passenger rights on its Mobility and Transport pages. Sequence matters. Complain first to the operating carrier, as the Irish Aviation Authority directs passengers to contact the air carrier directly to resolve the complaint, with a single chronology and numbered exhibits: booking, cancellation notice with its time, Article 8 choice made or refused, care offered or missing, receipts, rerouting result, and the precise sum claimed under each article. Then, if the answer refuses everything by the single word “weather”, demand the flight-specific proof identified in Part I and seize the competent enforcement body or court with that refusal attached. The decisions consulted for this article state no general limitation period for these claims, and none is asserted here: limitation must be checked under the national law governing the chosen forum before time is allowed to run.

Conclusion

Storm Boelo explains why Dublin Airport searched so intensely this weekend; it does not decide any passenger’s claim by its name. Under Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, the EUR 250, EUR 400 or EUR 600 compensation can be refused only where the operating carrier proves meteorological conditions incompatible with the flight concerned and proves that the cancellation could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken, as the Nantes and Bordeaux courts required on documented weather files and as Wallentin-Hermann and Pešková frame the test. The refund within seven days or rerouting under comparable conditions, and meals, hotel, transfers and communications while waiting, survive the storm, with McDonagh limiting repayment of self-arranged care to sums that were necessary, appropriate and reasonable in the circumstances of the case. Choose refund or rerouting deliberately, protect separate tickets at once, demand the written notice, and build the chronology before arguing the label. No account in this article establishes that any particular Dublin flight was or was not lawfully cancelled, and no carrier’s responsibility for any individual cancellation is asserted: on the proved conditions of each flight, the signed contract and the documents produced, only the judge decides.

📄 Official circular