KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Stopped With More Than EUR 10,000 Undeclared? What the ECHR Decided on 20 October 2026 — and What French Customs Can Still Seize at the Border

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Stopped With More Than EUR 10,000 Undeclared? What the ECHR Decided on 20 October 2026 — and What French Customs Can Still Seize at the Border

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 20 October 2026, the European Court of Human Rights, sitting as a Chamber, notified its judgment in Aksoy v. Serbia (application no. 4320/15): a Turkish national travelling through Serbia with more than 10,000 euros in cash, who had failed to declare the money to customs, had been fined and had the cash confiscated — and the Court held that the confiscation, on top of the fine, breached his right to the peaceful enjoyment of his property. The press release issued by the Registrar the same day, ECHR 259 (2026), records a finding of a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, with 51,000 euros awarded for pecuniary damage and 2,000 euros for costs and expenses. For anyone who flies in or out of France with cash in a bag, the ruling matters directly: the 10,000-euro declaration threshold applied in Serbia is the same threshold French customs apply at every French border post, and Strasbourg has now condemned the same pattern twice in sixteen months. The earlier case, Aksüngür and Others v. Serbia (nos. 69080/13 and four others, judgment of 24 June 2025, final on 24 September 2025), involved five men stopped at Serbian borders between 2012 and 2014 — one of whom, the third applicant, is recorded in the judgment itself as living in Soisy, France, and was stopped on 4 June 2013 at the Batrovci crossing while travelling back from Türkiye toward France with 24,800 euros, of which 14,800 euros were seized. And in France itself, the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation quashed part of a Nancy appeal ruling on 2 April 2025 precisely because the judges had imposed the 50-percent customs fine automatically and ordered confiscations without checking the statutory conditions. This article explains what Strasbourg decided today, what French customs can and cannot do with your cash, and the two legal shields — one French, one European — that every traveller should know.

I. What Strasbourg decided on 20 October 2026: a missing customs form does not allow the State to take everything

A. Aksoy v. Serbia: fined and stripped of his cash for an undeclared sum over 10,000 euros — a violation of the right of property

The applicant, Mehmet Alı Aksoy, is a Turkish national who was born in 1966 and lives in Stade, Germany. His case, as summarised in the Registry press release of 20 October 2026, is short and familiar to any border lawyer: the case turned on Serbian customs confiscating cash above 10,000 euros found on the applicant as he travelled through Serbia, because he had not declared it. The Serbian courts had punished him twice for the same omission — a fine, and then the confiscation of the money itself. Before the European Court he argued exactly that: he argued that confiscation heaped on top of a fine was an unlawful and disproportionate interference with his right to the peaceful enjoyment of his property under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. The Chamber agreed. Its finding — a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 — now frames the analysis of every similar file. The damages follow the finding: 51,000 euros for pecuniary damage and 2,000 euros for costs and expenses, listed in the release for that judgment immediately after the violation finding. Three features of the ruling deserve attention from readers in France. First, the Court accepted that fighting money laundering is a legitimate aim — it always does — and still found a violation, which means the defect lies in the severity and automaticity of the sanction, not in the existence of customs controls. Second, the applicant was only transiting through Serbia: he was not importing the money into the Serbian economy, a situation directly comparable to millions of passengers who change planes at Paris-Charles de Gaulle or drive through France between two other countries. Third, the judgment is a Chamber judgment notified in writing on 20 October 2026, and it lands only sixteen months after the Court had already condemned the identical Serbian mechanism — which is why the reasoning of that earlier case now reads like the instruction manual for Aksoy.

B. The 2025 sister judgment the Court confirmed: vague law plus rubber-stamp review cannot justify confiscating a traveller’s savings

Aksüngür and Others v. Serbia, decided on 24 June 2025 by the Third Section, concerned five applicants — German, Turkish and dual nationals living in Germany, France and the Netherlands — stopped separately at Serbian border crossings between 2012 and 2014 on their way to or from Türkiye. Each carried more than 10,000 euros without declaring it. Each was allowed to keep 10,000 euros; the excess was seized, and the misdemeanour courts then confiscated it, in one case 60 percent of the seized sum (53,000 euros) and in the others the whole excess (sums between 14,425 and 25,020 euros), on top of fines of only 70 to 550 euros. The judgment’s appendix gives the French connection in black and white: the third applicant, Zekı Dınlemez, born in 1966 and recorded as living in Soisy, France, was checked on 4 June 2013 while travelling back from Türkiye toward France, with this result: officers found 24,800 euros in his jacket, seized 14,800 euros of it, and immediately returned 10,000 euros to him. A France resident therefore already lost nearly 15,000 euros of lawfully owned money under exactly the mechanism Strasbourg has now struck down twice. The Court’s method is the part French practitioners should memorise, because it applies word for word to French customs files. It asked itself the question every property case turns on: the remaining question was whether the national authorities, in applying the measures, had struck the requisite fair balance between the property rights and the general interest, allowing for the margin of appreciation left to the State in this field. Its answer is the passage future applicants will cite: in view of the foregoing, the Court found that a broad and imprecise legislative framework, combined with narrow domestic judicial review, could not secure the requisite fair balance between the general interest and the protection of the right to peaceful enjoyment of property under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. Two defects combined to produce the violation: a statute so vague that nobody could foresee whether the whole sum or only part of it would be taken, and domestic courts — including the Constitutional Court — that never examined the degree of fault, the lawful origin of the money, or whether the offence was even intentional. The operative part is unequivocal: a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 in respect of the applicants. The Court then applied Article 41 of the Convention, under which it affords just satisfaction to the injured party where domestic law allows only partial reparation. For the general principles it relied expressly on G.I.E.M. S.r.l. and Others v. Italy and — of particular interest to a Paris reader — on Grifhorst v. France (no. 28336/02, 26 February 2009), the French customs-fine case in which Strasbourg mapped out how proportionality review must work. In short, Strasbourg does not forbid States from policing cash at borders; it forbids them from taking everything automatically while the judge looks away.

II. Stopped by French customs with undeclared cash: the 50-percent fine, the 90-day retention, and how to get your money back

A. The French machine step by step: declaration at 10,000 euros, a fine of half the sum, retention — but confiscation only on strict extra conditions

French law starts from the same European rule Serbia applied: cash moving across borders must be declared from 10,000 euros. Within the European Union, the text in force states: “Les porteurs transportant de l’argent liquide, au sens du règlement (UE) 2018/1672 du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 23 octobre 2018 relatif aux contrôles de l’argent liquide entrant dans l’Union ou sortant de l’Union et abrogeant le règlement (CE) n° 1889/2005, d’un montant égal ou supérieur à 10 000 €, vers un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou en provenance d’un tel Etat doivent en faire la déclaration auprès de l’administration des douanes.” The same article defines who is caught, in deliberately wide terms: “Est considérée comme porteur toute personne physique qui, pour elle-même ou pour le compte d’un tiers, transporte de l’argent liquide sur elle, dans ses bagages ou dans ses moyens de transport.” The full provision is article L. 152-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code. Two extensions close the obvious loopholes. Cash sent without a carrier — a parcel, a courier envelope — is covered too: the customs officers may require the sender, the recipient or their representative to file a disclosure declaration, and they may hold the cash until that declaration is filed, under article L. 152-1-1 of the same code. And a sloppy or incomplete declaration is worth nothing: article L. 152-1-2 provides that “L’obligation de déclaration et l’obligation de divulgation mentionnées aux articles L. 152-1 et L. 152-1-1 ne sont pas réputées exécutées si les informations fournies sont incorrectes ou incomplètes ou si l’argent liquide n’est pas mis à la disposition de l’administration des douanes à sa demande, à l’occasion d’un contrôle lors d’un transport.” Declaring 9,000 euros while carrying 25,000, or refusing to show the cash when asked, is treated exactly like declaring nothing. The punishment is then set by article L. 152-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code, and travellers consistently underestimate it. First, the fine: “La méconnaissance des obligations déclaratives énoncées aux articles L. 152-1 à L. 152-1-2 et dans le règlement (UE) 2018/1672 du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 23 octobre 2018 relatif aux contrôles de l’argent liquide entrant dans l’Union ou sortant de l’Union et abrogeant le règlement n° 1889/2005 est punie d’une amende égale à 50 % du montant de l’argent liquide sur lequel a porté l’infraction ou la tentative d’infraction.” Half the undeclared sum — 12,400 euros on 24,800 euros — and the attempt is punished like the completed act. Second, immediate retention: once the offence is established, “ceux-ci peuvent prononcer la retenue temporaire de la totalité de l’argent liquide sur lequel a porté l’infraction ou la tentative d’infraction, pendant une durée ne pouvant être supérieure à trente jours, renouvelable jusqu’à un maximum de quatre-vingt-dix jours.” The officers do not need a judge to keep the whole sum for an initial thirty days, renewable up to ninety. Third, consignment: if the investigation requires it, customs may consign the cash, but only “sur autorisation du procureur de la République du lieu de la direction des douanes dont dépend le service chargé de la procédure, dans la limite de douze mois décomptés à partir du premier jour de la retenue temporaire.” A prosecutor therefore controls any retention beyond ninety days, capped at twelve months from day one. Fourth — and this is the point most travellers, and some officers, misunderstand — confiscation is not automatic. The cash is seized and confiscation may be ordered by the competent court only if, during the retention or consignment, it is established that the carrier holds or held objects suggesting customs offences, or if there are plausible reasons to think he committed or took part in customs offences; where the cash itself is no longer available, the court orders payment of an equivalent sum instead. And the statute provides the traveler’s ultimate safety net: “La décision de non-lieu ou de relaxe emporte de plein droit, aux frais du Trésor, mainlevée des mesures ordonnées.” An acquittal or a dismissal lifts every measure automatically, at the Treasury’s expense. Investigation and prosecution run under customs-code procedure. Note the distinction with a neighbouring mechanism readers sometimes confuse with customs retention: where funds are frozen under European Union sanctions listings, release runs through the Treasury authorisation procedure and annulment actions before the EU General Court, as explained in our analysis of the October 2026 EU sanctions wave and frozen funds in France — a different legal world from a traveller’s undeclared envelope, with different judges and different remedies. The same national customs rules apply at every French border post, including the Paris airports, where the place of the customs directorate determines which prosecutor authorises any consignment.

B. Your two shields when customs keep the money: a judge who must justify every euro, and Strasbourg watching over automatic confiscations

The first shield is French and was forged on 2 April 2025. That day the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, on appeal no. 23-86.683 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:CR00445), partly quashed a Nancy Court of Appeal ruling of 17 October 2023 — full text on the Court of Cassation website. The facts could have come from Strasbourg: a man checked by customs while carrying 32,790 euros and 4,430 zlotys, none of it declared, sentenced at first instance to a 3,000-euro suspended fine plus confiscation of 22,760 euros, then hit on appeal with a 17,145-euro customs fine — exactly 50 percent of the seized sums — plus confiscation of the full 32,790 euros and the zlotys. The Court of Cassation quashed the penalties on two grounds that every defence file should now quote. On the fine, it laid down a rule of general scope: “le juge qui prononce une amende en application de l’article L. 152-4, I, du code monétaire et financier en répression du délit de transfert non déclaré de capitaux, en fonction du montant de l’argent liquide sur lequel a porté l’infraction, doit également motiver sa décision au regard de l’ampleur et de la gravité de l’infraction commise ainsi que de la personnalité de son auteur, quel que soit le montant de l’amende qu’il retient.” Even the statutory 50 percent is not a reflex: the judge must explain, by reference to the scale and seriousness of the offence and the personality of the offender, why this traveller pays this amount. In Nancy, the appeal court had simply noted that 17,145 euros corresponded to 50 percent of the seized sums, and the high court answered: “En premier lieu, la cour d’appel ne s’est pas expliquée sur l’ampleur et la gravité de l’infraction commise ni sur la personnalité du prévenu, qu’elle devait prendre en considération pour fonder sa décision.” On confiscation, the quashing is even more instructive: the appeal judges had ordered both confiscations without ever establishing that the carrier held objects suggesting customs offences or that plausible reasons pointed to such offences, as the statute demands — so the confiscations fell with the fine, guilt itself remaining intact. The procedural setting matters too: these cases are tried by the correctional court, with the customs administration appearing as prosecuting party, and appeals go to the correctional chamber of the court of appeal — the Nancy file went from a first-instance judgment to the appeal court and then to the Court of Cassation, and a Chambéry file that reached the high court on 15 January 2025 (appeal no. 24-80.465, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:CR00041, on the Court of Cassation website) followed the same correctional path from the Annecy correctional court. The duty to give reasons is not judicial courtesy; it is statute: article 485 of the Code of Criminal Procedure opens with “Tout jugement doit contenir des motifs et un dispositif.”, article 593 declares appeal and last-resort decisions void where “ils ne contiennent pas des motifs ou si leurs motifs sont insuffisants et ne permettent pas à la Cour de cassation d’exercer son contrôle et de reconnaître si la loi a été respectée dans le dispositif”, and article 512 extends the correctional-court rules to proceedings before the court of appeal. Concretely, a traveller who wants the fine reduced argues the three statutory lenses — modest scale, low seriousness, clean personality — and a traveller who wants the confiscation lifted forces the prosecution to prove the extra customs-offence link, which mere non-declaration does not supply. The second shield is European and arrived today. Where the French judge rubber-stamps an automatic confiscation, the Aksüngür-Aksoy line offers the exact vocabulary: vague framework, narrow review, no examination of fault, lawful origin or intent, no fair balance. Practical consequences follow. Declare spontaneously to the customs administration before any control, because the statute punishes the attempt as well and rewards nothing after detection. Carry and keep documents showing the lawful origin of the funds — withdrawal slips, sale deeds, loan contracts — since both the French confiscation test and the Strasbourg proportionality test turn on what the money is and where it comes from. If the cash is retained, require written notification of the grounds, keep every sealed inventory, and contest both the fine’s reasoning and the confiscation’s legal basis before the correctional court rather than accepting the 50 percent as fate. And where the domestic courts confirm an automatic forfeiture without individual examination, the file is, after the French courts have ruled, the precise fact pattern Strasbourg condemned on 24 June 2025 and again on 20 October 2026.

Conclusion

The missing form is expensive — up to half the cash in fines, plus weeks of retention — but it is not a blank cheque for the State. French law itself draws the line: declaration from 10,000 euros, a 50-percent fine that the judge must individually justify, retention capped at thirty days renewable to ninety, consignment only with a prosecutor’s authorisation within twelve months, and confiscation only where a genuine link to customs offending is proved, with automatic release on acquittal. Since 2 April 2025, any French penalty that ignores the scale of the facts and the personality of the traveller is a quashing waiting to happen; since 24 June 2025, confirmed on 20 October 2026, any European confiscation that takes everything without examining fault, origin and intent violates the right of property. The traveller’s side of the bargain is simple: declare before being checked, prove where the money comes from, and challenge every automatic figure. For the France resident stopped on his way home with 24,800 euros, for the German resident transiting with his savings, and for every passenger landing at Roissy with an envelope of family money, Strasbourg and the Court of Cassation now speak with one voice — the punishment must fit the person, not just the percentage.

📄 Official circular