KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
ECHR Advisory Opinion of 29 September 2026 on Fixed Tax Penalties: When a Fine Breaches Your Property Rights and How French Courts Must Review It

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

ECHR Advisory Opinion of 29 September 2026 on Fixed Tax Penalties: When a Fine Breaches Your Property Rights and How French Courts Must Review It

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 29 September 2026, the European Court of Human Rights delivered a new advisory opinion that every company facing a heavy tax fine in France should read. At the request of the Supreme Court of Ukraine (request no. P16-2026-001, under Protocol No. 16 to the European Convention on Human Rights), the Strasbourg Court ruled on two questions that also arise daily before French judges: when does a fixed-rate tax penalty breach the right to property, and may a national judge apply a lower penalty that the statute does not provide? The case behind the request is striking. A Ukrainian company selling fuel and alcohol, OvruchHazAvto, was fined 22,576,700 hryvnias — about 1,640,000 euros at the time — under a rule imposing an automatic fine of 200 percent of the value of goods sold through a cash register missing from its licence appendices. The fine was nearly three times the company’s assets, for an unintentional breach the company had remedied itself. The Ukrainian courts set the fine aside; the tax authority appealed; the Supreme Court stayed the proceedings and asked Strasbourg for guidance on 4 December 2025. The opinion delivered today gives three concrete proportionality criteria and draws a clear line on the judge’s power to rewrite the scale of penalties. For taxpayers in France — where fixed majorations of 10, 40, 80 percent and flat fines apply automatically — the opinion confirms and sharpens weapons that already exist before the French judge, as the Court of Cassation recalled on 12 February 2025 and the Conseil d’Etat on 25 February 2025.

I. What the European Court decided on 29 September 2026

A. When is an automatic tax fine disproportionate? The three criteria for reviewing a fixed-rate penalty under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1

The Ukrainian Supreme Court asked Strasbourg, in substance, two things: on which criteria a fine set at the flat statutory rate of 200 percent of the goods sold may be regarded as a disproportionate interference with the right protected by Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, and whether a national court may refrain from applying the statute and impose a more lenient sanction of its own choosing. The Court answered the second question first in its reasoning, because only a court that has found the statutory penalty disproportionate needs to know what it may do next. The press release issued by the Registrar on 29 September 2026 (ECHR 238 (2026)) summarises the dispute: the company had used, between 18 January 2023 and 20 June 2023, a cash register that was not listed in the appendices of its trading licences, in breach of section 17 of the Ukrainian Law No. 481/95-VR of 19 December 1995, and the tax authority applied the flat 200 percent rate, producing a fine of 22,576,700 hryvnias. Both the Zhytomyr Administrative Court and the Administrative Court of Appeal had set the assessment aside, noting that the fine was nearly three times the company’s assets, that the company had remedied the breach itself, and that no harm to the public interest had been shown.

On the substance, the Court recalled the structure of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1: any interference by a public authority with the peaceful enjoyment of possessions must be lawful and pursue a legitimate aim in the general interest, and the legal system, taken as a whole, must contain safeguards against a disproportionate control of the use of property in individual cases. The opinion is explicit that Strasbourg does not hand down an exhaustive checklist: the Court has regard to the specific circumstances of the case, that is, the concrete facts as established by the national courts, and States enjoy a wide discretion in tax matters, which commonly involve political, economic and social assessments. Within that margin, the opinion identifies three families of criteria that may prove relevant to the fair balance in a case such as the one pending in Kyiv: the choice of the means employed to achieve the aim pursued and their appropriateness to those aims; the impact of the means employed on the company in question; and the conduct of the company. In plain terms: was the automatic rate a suitable tool for the goal, what did the fine actually do to this business, and how did this business behave — intentional fraud or remediable mistake, cooperation or obstruction, harm caused or none.

This method is not new; it is the direct continuation of the Court’s property case law. In Mamidakis v. Greece (no. 35533/04, 11 January 2007), the Court found a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 where a customs fine exceeding 3 million euros for petroleum smuggling, plus joint liability for more than 4.9 million euros of fines imposed on others, had dealt the applicant’s finances a blow that the Court, in section 48 of the judgment, found disproportionate to the legitimate aim pursued. The lesson for tax fines is identical: the rate on paper is never the whole story; what matters is the concrete burden on the person fined, set against the aim of collecting tax and deterring fraud. A 200 percent automatic fine that wipes out nearly three times a company’s assets, for an offence the company committed unintentionally and repaired, is exactly the configuration in which Strasbourg’s three criteria bite hardest.

B. May the judge apply a lower penalty the statute does not provide? Strasbourg says no: the power to adjust fines comes only from domestic law

The second holding of the opinion is just as important, and it disappoints anyone hoping Strasbourg would give judges a free hand to rewrite penalty scales. The Court advised that the Convention does not prohibit the use of automatic sanctions: it had previously held that a system of administrative fines is not incompatible with the Convention so long as taxpayers can bring any decision affecting them before a court. But the Convention does not confer on national courts any particular power to reduce an automatic sanction, nor does it require States to ensure that they have one. The press release states it plainly: only domestic law can supply the mechanism, and the choice of appropriate means is for the State to make. Compatibility with Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 does not depend on the mechanism chosen but on whether the legal framework, viewed as a whole, provides safeguards to prevent disproportionate burdens — whether through powers of assessment and adjustment conferred on the courts and reviewed by the constitutional court, or through the statutory framework itself.

Two consequences follow. First, advisory opinions under Protocol No. 16 — which, as the Registry recalls, came into force on 1 August 2018 and has now produced nine opinions — are not formally binding; they guide the requesting court, which remains responsible for deciding the pending case. The Ukrainian Supreme Court must now apply the three criteria to OvruchHazAvto’s fine using the tools of Ukrainian law. Second, and decisively for French readers, everything depends on what French law already gives the French judge: full review of the principle and the amount of the penalty, constitutional review of the statutory scale, and the precise limits within which a penalty may be set aside or reduced. That is where France is well armed — and where the opinion of 29 September 2026 plugs directly into live French case law.

II. Your tax penalty in France: what the judge must verify and how to challenge it

A. French judges must already review every tax penalty concretely: full jurisdiction, fixed majorations, and the constitutional ceiling

French tax penalties look automatic, and in a sense they are: Article 1728 of the General Tax Code imposes majorations of 10 percent where no formal notice was sent or the return is filed within thirty days of notice, 40 percent where it is not, and 80 percent where an occult activity is discovered; Article 1729 provides that “inexactitudes ou omissions” lead to a majoration of 40 percent for deliberate failure, 80 percent for abuse of law within the meaning of Article L. 64 of the Book of Tax Procedures (reduced to 40 percent where the taxpayer neither initiated nor principally benefited from the arrangement), and 80 percent for fraudulent manoeuvres or concealment of part of a contract price; Article 1737 punishes fictitious invoices with a fine of 50 percent of the invoice amount; and Article 1741 punishes fraudulent evasion, “indépendamment des sanctions fiscales applicables”, with five years’ imprisonment and a 500,000 euro fine. But automatic on paper has never meant unreviewable before the judge. Tax surcharges are criminal in nature for the purposes of Article 6 of the Convention even when minor: in Jussila v. Finland (no. 73053/01, 23 November 2006, section 38), the Grand Chamber held that surcharges imposed by a rule with a deterrent and punitive purpose fall under the criminal head of Article 6 even where the amount at stake is minor. And where the administration imposes the punishment first, Article 6 requires subsequent review by a court with full jurisdiction: in A. Menarini Diagnostics v. Italy (no. 43509/08, 27 September 2011, section 59), the Court recalled that compliance with Article 6 does not prevent an administrative authority from imposing a penalty first, but requires subsequent review by a court with full jurisdiction, empowered to reform the administrative decision in every respect, in fact and in law.

The Court of Cassation drew the full consequence for France on 12 February 2025. In Cass. com., 12 February 2025, no. 23-14.047 (Les Hauts de l’Oumède), a company challenged the 80 percent majoration applied under Article 1729 for abuse of law, arguing that the court of appeal had merely asserted that the penalty was proportionate without any concrete assessment. The Court of Cassation quashed that reasoning and stated the rule in terms that mirror Strasbourg’s opinion of today: “Il résulte de ce texte qu’un recours de pleine juridiction doit être ouvert au contribuable pour permettre au juge de se prononcer sur le principe et le montant de la pénalité fiscale. Le juge, saisi d’une demande en ce sens, doit vérifier que la pénalité fiscale est proportionnée au comportement du contribuable dans les circonstances de l’espèce.” A court that confines itself to noting that the administration applied the statutory rate, without concretely assessing proportionality in the circumstances of the case, gives no legal basis for its decision. For a company fined in France, this holding is the domestic equivalent of the Ukrainian reference: the judge must weigh the behaviour, the facts, and the amount — not rubber-stamp the rate.

The administrative courts apply the same discipline to flat fines. On 25 February 2025, in CE, 25 February 2025, no. 499430 (Société Espinho), the Conseil d’Etat refused to transmit a priority question of constitutionality against the 50 percent fine of Article 1737 for fictitious invoices, but the refusal itself shows how proportionality is tested in France. The company argued that a rate fixed at 50 percent of an amount shown on a fictitious invoice is disconnected from its financial situation and from any loss to the Treasury, and therefore breaches the principle of proportionality of punishments in Article 8 of the 1789 Declaration — “La loi ne doit établir que des peines strictement et évidemment nécessaires”. The Conseil d’Etat answered on the merits of seriousness: by fixing the fine in proportion to the amount on the fictitious invoice, Parliament created a penalty whose base is linked to the nature of the offence, and “le taux de 50 % retenu ne peut être regardé comme manifestement disproportionné au regard de la gravité des manquements”, since the conduct involves professionals acting intentionally in the course of business. Read together with Strasbourg’s opinion, the message is coherent: a fixed rate survives where its base tracks the offence and the rate is not excessive for intentional professional misconduct — and it is vulnerable exactly where the Ukrainian case sits, an unintentional, remediated breach punished at 200 percent of turnover with a fine worth triple the company’s assets.

Above the judge stands the constitutional ceiling, which also caps the combination of penalties. When criminal prosecution for tax fraud under Article 1741 meets the fiscal majorations of Article 1728, the question of double punishment arises. In Cass. crim., 12 September 2018, no. 18-81.067, the criminal chamber transmitted to the Conseil constitutionnel the question whether Articles 1728 (1, a and b) and 1741, by allowing criminal and fiscal proceedings and penalties against the same person for the same facts, breach the constitutional principles of necessity and proportionality of offences and punishments derived from Article 8 of the Declaration. The order recalls the framework set on 24 June 2016 (decisions nos. 2016-545 and 2016-546 QPC): combined 40 and 80 percent penalties and criminal fraud sanctions are constitutional subject to three reservations — no fraud conviction where a court has definitively discharged the tax; criminal conviction reserved for the most serious concealment, judged by the amount evaded, the nature of the acts or their circumstances; and in all cases, the total of penalties imposed must not exceed the highest single penalty incurred. A fine that already absorbs or exceeds the taxpayer’s substance therefore has to be confronted not only with Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 but with this domestic cap.

France, finally, is no stranger to the Protocol No. 16 procedure itself — it invented its first use. By an interlocutory ruling of 5 October 2018, the plenary assembly of the Court of Cassation transmitted a request for an advisory opinion to the European Court, stayed its ruling, and, as the later judgment records, “La Cour européenne des droits de l’homme a rendu son avis consultatif le 10 avril 2019” — the opinion on surrogacy and the transcription of foreign birth records that led to Cass., ass. plén., 4 October 2019, no. 10-19.053. French supreme courts know how to ask Strasbourg, how to stay proceedings, and how to draw consequences from a non-binding opinion. A French court seized of a fixed-rate tax fine can therefore do openly what the Ukrainian Supreme Court has just done: suspend, refer to the constitutional judge by priority question where the statute itself is attacked, and in any event exercise the full review the Court of Cassation now demands. Readers of the firm’s English-language international practice in Paris will find the same method applied to cross-border sanctions and surrender cases: start from the European safeguard, then force the domestic judge to use every tool of domestic law.

B. How to challenge a disproportionate tax fine from France: the file the judge is now waiting to see

The opinion of 29 September 2026 does not give the judge power to invent a penalty outside the statute — Strasbourg says so expressly — but it tells the taxpayer exactly what evidence makes a fixed penalty fall. The three criteria translate into a litigation file. First, the means and their suitability: show what the rate mechanically produces in your case, and whether the base of the penalty tracks any real fiscal harm. A majoration computed on duties that were paid late but paid in full, or a fine computed on turnover rather than on evaded tax, must be exhibited with the assessment notices, the turnover figures, and the ratio between the penalty and the Treasury’s actual loss. Second, the impact on the company: produce the balance sheet, the asset valuation, bank statements, and the cash-flow consequences of paying the fine — the Ukrainian courts were persuaded precisely because the fine reached nearly three times the company’s assets, the Mamidakis configuration. An individual or a small company that demonstrates that the fine absorbs its substance moves the case from routine collection into the zone where Strasbourg finds a disproportionate burden. Third, the conduct: good faith must be documented, not asserted. Spontaneous regularisation before any audit, immediate remediation as in the Ukrainian case, absence of prior penalties, cooperation with the auditors, and the unintentional character of the breach (a cash register missing from an appendix, a filing error corrected within days) all go to the behaviour the French judge must now assess concretely under the 12 February 2025 rule.

Procedurally, the path in France runs through the administrative courts in their full-jurisdiction tax function, after the prior administrative claim to the tax authority, and it must expressly ask the judge to rule on the principle and the amount of the penalty — the Court of Cassation’s holding is triggered only where the judge is “saisi d’une demande en ce sens”, so the claim for reduction or discharge must be pleaded as such, with figures and exhibits, not implied. Where the scale itself is the problem, the priority question of constitutionality remains available against the statutory provision, invoking Article 8 of the 1789 Declaration and the 2016 reservations on cumulation; the Espinho ruling shows the Conseil d’Etat will test the link between the base and the offence and whether the rate is excessive, so the QPC must be drafted around those two points rather than as a general complaint about severity. Where a criminal fraud prosecution runs alongside the fiscal penalty, the defence must police the constitutional cap recalled in the 18-81.067 reference: no fraud conviction after a definitive judicial discharge of the tax, prosecution confined to the gravest concealment, and a combined total that never exceeds the highest penalty incurred. And where the administration argues that the rate is the rate, the answer since 12 February 2025 is settled: the judge must verify proportionality to the behaviour in the circumstances of the case, and a judgment that merely recites the statutory calculation will be quashed. For companies based in Paris and the Ile-de-France, the competent administrative tribunal is the one of the taxpayer’s domicile or establishment, and the same exhibits — accounts, remediation proof, correspondence with the auditors — carry the same weight; no local variation changes the European test, but preparing the file early, before the collection notice becomes enforceable, preserves every option including suspension.

Conclusion

The advisory opinion delivered on 29 September 2026 changes no statute, and it binds no court — not even the Ukrainian Supreme Court that requested it. Its force lies elsewhere: it fixes, in one text, the three questions every judge in Europe must now answer before upholding an automatic tax fine — suitability of the means, concrete impact on the person fined, and conduct of that person — and it confirms that automatic penalties are lawful only inside a legal framework which, as a whole, prevents disproportionate burdens. In France that framework exists and has just been tightened: full review of the principle and amount of every fiscal penalty, concrete proportionality control since the Court of Cassation’s ruling of 12 February 2025, constitutional review of flat rates as in the Conseil d’Etat’s Espinho decision of 25 February 2025, and the cap on combined fiscal and criminal punishment. A taxpayer facing a fixed majoration or a flat fine should therefore stop arguing the rate in the abstract and start proving, with accounts and documents, that this rate on these facts is an excessive burden for this behaviour. That is the file Strasbourg described today, the file the French judge is now obliged to examine, and the file that decides whether a heavy fine stands or falls.

📄 Official circular