KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Eisenauer v. France: Strasbourg Lets Unenforced DALO Housing Orders Stand — Article 6 After 12 May 2026

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Eisenauer v. France: Strasbourg Lets Unenforced DALO Housing Orders Stand — Article 6 After 12 May 2026

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 12 May 2026, the European Court of Human Rights handed down a judgment that should have shaken French administrative law. Ten households, all recognised as priority cases under France’s enforceable right to housing, had won final court orders directing prefects to house or rehouse them. Years later, as of June 2025, not one of them had received a housing offer, with delays running from two years and ten months to eight years. The prefects had not even appealed the orders. And yet, by five votes to two, Strasbourg found no violation of Article 6 paragraph 1 of the Convention. The judgment, delivered in French only, is Eisenauer and Others v. France (nos 47090/22 and nine others), and it marks the most important shift in a decade in how the Court treats the enforcement of judgments against the State.

For anyone facing the French administration with a court decision in hand, the ruling matters far beyond housing. It reframes enforcement of social-policy judgments as resource management rather than debt collection, and it rewards States that build compensatory machinery around non-enforcement. This analysis explains what the Court decided, how it departs from its own Tchokontio Happi v. France judgment of 9 April 2015 (no. 65829/12), and which remedies in France still produce results after Eisenauer.

I. What the Court decided in Eisenauer and Others v. France

A. Nine years of ignored rehousing orders: the facts behind application no. 47090/22

France’s enforceable right to housing, known as DALO, starts from a simple statutory promise. Article L. 300-1 of the Construction and Housing Code provides that the right to decent and independent housing is guaranteed by the State to persons residing lawfully in France who cannot secure it by their own means. The scheme created by the Act of 5 March 2007, followed through the Senate legislative file, works in two stages. First, a mediation commission in each department designates priority applicants who must be housed urgently, under Article L. 441-2-3 of the Construction and Housing Code. Second, where no suitable offer arrives within the regulatory period, Article L. 441-2-3-1 opens a specific remedy before the administrative court: the applicant may seek an order that the State provide housing, and the judge may attach a penalty payment to the injunction. The statute states that the applicant “peut introduire un recours devant la juridiction administrative tendant à ce que soit ordonné son logement ou son relogement”, in other words, a direct action to have housing ordered.

The Eisenauer applicants had travelled exactly that road and won. Each had been recognised as a priority case, each had obtained a final order from the administrative judge directing the prefect to house or rehouse them, in some cases backed by a penalty payment. The prefects did not challenge those orders. They simply did not execute them, for want of available dwellings. The Court records that the applicants had not applied to the enforcement judge for liquidation of the penalties, while some of them had claimed damages from the administrative courts for the harm caused by the delay and received compensation.

The scale of the underlying crisis is documented inside the judgment itself through public reports. Since 2008, about 207,399 priority households have been housed, but in 2020 alone 18,208 such households obtained housing while 77,684 recognised households were still waiting for an offer, some for one to thirteen years. In 2020 the administrative courts registered 1,468 damages claims in this field, examined 891, and ruled for the claimants in 765 cases, a success rate of 85.9 percent. The High Committee for housing rights notes that the flat-rate compensation set by the Council of State stands at 250 euros per person per year, adjustable upward for unfit housing, young children or disability, and adds that, beyond compensation, what households seek above all is a roof over their heads. Geography matters enormously: 771 such claims were registered in Paris against 321 in Montreuil, 161 in Cergy and none in Réunion, and 55 percent of all DALO lettings in 2025 went to Île-de-France. Anyone litigating in Paris therefore operates in the most congested forum in the country, where delay is structural rather than accidental.

The third-party intervention of the Defender of Rights sharpened the systemic diagnosis. She argued that non-enforcement of rehousing orders reveals a structural defect of the DALO scheme as a whole, evidenced both by the volume of complaints reaching her office and by the stream of cases arriving in Strasbourg, and she warned that in a context of generalised shortage the enforceable right remains at times theoretical and a source of dashed hopes, with court actions failing to secure its effectiveness. The Government answered with production figures and reform promises: 24,950 lettings to DALO households in 2025, a prime-ministerial “Relance logement” plan backed by 500 million euros in 2026 support for social housing, a target of 125,000 new social dwellings, and a new “MonDALO” information system meant to digitise applications and shorten processing. The Court took note of these efforts without treating any of them as a substitute for housing the applicants, yet weighed them as proof that the authorities were seeking a balance between competing public and private interests rather than abandoning the field.

B. of Article 6 despite unreasonable delay: how the majority reasoned

The Court begins where applicants would hope, by restating the orthodox doctrine. It recalls the established principle that enforcement of final and binding judicial decisions forms an integral part of the trial within the meaning of Article 6 paragraph 1, citing Hornsby v. Greece of 19 March 1997 (no. 18357/91) and Burdov v. Russia (no. 2) of 15 January 2009 (no. 33509/04), and it confirms that an unreasonably long delay in executing a binding judgment can breach the Convention, assessed against the stakes for the applicant, the complexity of enforcement and the conduct of the authorities. In the Court’s own doctrinal terms, enforcement is the final and indispensable stage of the trial. The Convention, the Court recalls, guarantees no right to housing as such, yet disputes over social housing fall under the civil limb of Article 6, and domestic authorities enjoy latitude in social and economic policy, particularly for allocating limited resources.

Applied to the facts, the Court makes four findings that together decide the case. First, the prefects never contested the applicants’ right, and the penalty payments attached to the injunctions were actually paid into the national fund for supported housing, automatically since the 2016 reform introduced what the judgment calls the “automaticité de l’obligation de verser l’astreinte”. Second, the domestic courts awarded damages to those applicants who claimed them, repairing the harm from delayed enforcement. Third, the housing shortage documented by the Court of Audit, the High Committee and the interministerial housing authority shows authorities confronting a genuine crisis, especially in Île-de-France where most applicants live. Fourth, and decisively, the Court holds that even though full enforcement was never achieved, the authorities must be regarded as having set up machinery ensuring “un commencement d’exécution”, a beginning of enforcement, through the combination of penalty payments without compensatory function at collective level and damages at individual level.

The conclusion follows in two short paragraphs that will be quoted for years. The Court states that it cannot conclude that the incomplete enforcement breached Article 6 paragraph 1, even while expressly acknowledging that the enforcement delays in the case were unreasonable. To decide otherwise, it adds, in a field of social and economic policy where national authorities enjoy a wide margin of appreciation, would lead the Court to interfere with the domestic enforcement system to an extent incompatible with the subsidiarity principle. The operative part joins the applications unanimously, declares the Article 6 complaints admissible unanimously, decides by six votes to one to examine them only under Article 6 paragraph 1 rather than Article 8, and holds by five votes to two that there was no violation. The French Government, notably, had not defended the merits at all: it left assessment “à la sagesse de la Cour”, to the wisdom of the Court, while insisting that State services were fully mobilised and that the applicants’ situation was temporary.

Procedurally, the Government’s posture deserves attention from foreign readers unfamiliar with Strasbourg litigation. Apart from Ms Eisenauer’s application, on which it filed no observations on the merits, the respondent State left the assessment of the complaints to the wisdom of the Court while arguing at the just-satisfaction stage that the applicants were all destined to be rehoused and that their hardship was temporary. That stance, combined with general measures adopted in execution of the Tchokontio Happi judgment, allowed the majority to present France as a cooperating respondent managing a crisis rather than a recalcitrant debtor. The Court also emphasised that the domestic framework itself imposed an obligation of result for housing eligible persons, and that the Government had failed to show that the sole enforcement tool, the penalty action, was effective, a concession that makes the eventual finding of no violation all the more striking. Readers should therefore not mistake the outcome for an endorsement of French performance: the judgment records unreasonable delays, an ineffective sole remedy, and unappealed orders, then excuses them by the scale of the challenge and the existence of parallel financial circuits.

II. What the ruling changes for applicants facing France

A. From Tchokontio Happi to Eisenauer: the enforcement test moves from result to process

The contrast with Tchokontio Happi is stark and deliberate. In that 2015 case, also about an unexecuted DALO rehousing order, the Court had found a violation of Article 6 after about three and a half years of non-enforcement, rejecting the argument that a shortage of resources could justify leaving the applicant without housing. Commentators cited in the 2026 debate observe that Eisenauer involved delays of up to eight years with the same resource defence, yet produced the opposite outcome, and the majority offers no direct reconciliation. The difference lies in what happened between the two judgments: France built, and the Court has now blessed, a system in which unenforced orders trigger automatic financial flows and compensatory litigation, so that non-enforcement is managed rather than simply suffered.

Constitutional scholars writing in English in July 2026 describe the move as a quiet revolution from corrective to distributive justice. Under the Burdov lineage, the State was treated as a bilateral debtor: a court had established a debt, and lack of funds was no excuse. Eisenauer treats the State instead as a manager of scarcity, allocating a limited stock of dwellings among competing priority households, with the judge supervising the reasonableness of the process rather than guaranteeing individual performance. The creditor no longer holds an unqualified right to performance; she holds a right to have her claim processed within a system of competing priorities. The lineage the Court itself recites, from Hornsby through Burdov, Camara v. Belgium of 18 July 2023 (no. 49255/22) and M.K. and Others v. France of 8 December 2022 (nos 34349/18 and two others), is therefore preserved in words while its substance narrows: enforcement remains part of the trial, but in social policy the trial is satisfied by a reasonable management scheme plus compensation.

The two dissenting judges refuse that bargain. Judge Serghides objects first that the majority examined the complaints only under Article 6 paragraph 1, by six votes to one, and entirely ignored Article 8, which protects the substance of the right to respect for one’s home rather than its enforcement. When a complaint is examined exclusively through another provision, he warns, the specific normative substance of the omitted provision risks remaining unarticulated. His deeper challenge goes to the margin of appreciation: what does a wide margin in social and economic policy have to do with the judicial guarantee of a fair trial? The joint dissent of Judges Serghides and Zünd adds that enforcing rehousing orders requires more than ordinary enforcement machinery, demanding coordinated action among courts, administrators and social services, yet concludes that the obligation remains one of result and that a violation should have been found. For future applicants, the dissents map the two escape routes from Eisenauer: plead the substantive right under Article 8 alongside Article 6, and demonstrate that the State’s machinery amounts to inaction rather than managed scarcity. Admissibility strategy before Strasbourg increasingly turns on exhausting and documenting every domestic lever, a discipline familiar to practitioners who handle stalled French proceedings and the remedies that keep an ECHR application alive.

The doctrinal cost is visible in the authorities the majority had to distinguish without overruling. The Burdov line had hardened into an obligation of result, confirmed for systemic non-enforcement in Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine and Olaru and Others v. Moldova in 2009 and extended to non-pecuniary obligations in Gerasimov and Others v. Russia in 2014, whose paragraph 168 the judgment itself cites on delay assessment. Subsidiarity now does the work that lack of funds could not do openly: citing Burmych and Others v. Ukraine, the Court reasons that ordering full enforcement would interfere with the domestic rehousing system beyond what subsidiarity permits. The analytical shift matters for every social-rights case in the Council of Europe area, because any State can now argue that its unenforced judgments reflect managed scarcity rather than breach, provided it channels penalties into a fund and keeps a damages window open. The dissenters’ answer is that supervision of a reasonable process cannot replace the guarantee that a final judgment means something, and that Article 8, which the majority declined to examine, would have forced the Court to weigh the applicants’ actual living conditions instead of the State’s budgetary architecture.

B. DALO remedies that still work in France: penalty liquidation, damages and the administrative judge

Eisenauer does not leave applicants powerless; read closely, it prices each domestic remedy and tells litigants which ones the Court weighs. Three levers exist, and the judgment shows the cost of neglecting any of them. The first is liquidation of the penalty payment. Under Article R. 778-8 of the Code of Administrative Justice, where the president of the administrative tribunal finds that the injunction has not been executed, “il procède à la liquidation de l’astreinte”, he liquidates the penalty in favour of the housing fund. The Council of State confirmed the route in its decision of 29 October 2021 (no. 453661), holding that where the prefect fails to execute an injunction to house an applicant, the applicant may seise the court that ordered housing so that it records non-enforcement and liquidates the attached penalty. The Eisenauer Court expressly noted that the applicants had never sought such liquidation, and counted that inaction in the State’s favour. The lesson for current files is direct: file the liquidation request systematically once the deadline passes, because Strasbourg now treats the penalty circuit as part of enforcement itself, and an applicant who skips it arrives in Strasbourg with an incomplete record.

The second lever is the damages action against the State for faulty delay, which the Court treated as the individual complement to collective penalties. The Council of State’s line, illustrated by its decision of 12 March 2019 (no. 413991) on compensation for moral harm and disruption of living conditions after the State’s faulty failure to rehouse, anchors claims that tribunals grant at high rates: 85.9 percent success in 2020. Awards start from the 250 euro per person per year flat rate and rise with unfit housing, young children, illness or disability, so files must document overcrowding, medical certificates, school disruption and every month of waiting. These actions run under the general enforcement powers of the administrative judge: Article L. 911-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice allows the court to prescribe the required enforcement measure, and Article L. 911-4 adds that the court “peut fixer un délai d’exécution et prononcer une astreinte”, may set a deadline and impose a penalty. Used together, injunction, liquidation and damages turn a paper victory into financial pressure plus a documented history of State inaction, which is exactly the record that keeps a future Strasbourg complaint distinguishable from Eisenauer.

The third lever is the European application itself, reframed rather than closed. Eisenauer was decided on Article 6 alone because the majority refused, by six to one, to examine Article 8, whose first paragraph protects everyone’s right to respect for private and family life and the home. Future applications should plead Articles 8 and 13 together with Article 6 from the outset, forcing the Court to confront the substantive interference rather than dissolving it into enforcement management. Timing and evidence matter more than before: apply only after the liquidation request and the damages action have been pursued, quantify every year of delay against the two-year-ten-month to eight-year spectrum the Court tolerated, and show concretely that no coordinated rehousing effort touched the file, since the majority’s tolerance rested on proof of systemic machinery. For Paris and Île-de-France households, where 55 percent of national DALO lettings concentrate yet nearly eight hundred damages claims a year flow through the Paris tribunal alone, local specifics strengthen the file: the department of residence, the competent tribunal among Paris, Montreuil, Cergy-Pontoise or Versailles, the prefect bound by the order, and the “MonDALO” digital procedure the Government says will shorten processing. The Convention texts themselves remain the anchor: Article 6 paragraph 1 guarantees everyone a fair hearing within a reasonable time, and Article 13 promises an effective remedy before a national authority. Eisenauer narrows how Strasbourg reads those promises in housing cases; it does not repeal them, and a file that activates every French lever arrives as the managed-scarcity exception the majority left open.

A final practical point concerns sequencing and proof. Administrative tribunals rule quickly on DALO injunctions but slowly on damages, with a national stock of over two thousand pending indemnity claims recorded in 2020, so applicants should run both tracks in parallel: the injunction for the roof, the liquidation request for pressure, and the damages claim for compensation and for the Strasbourg record. Keep every prefectural letter, every commission decision, every month without an offer, and every medical or school certificate, because post-Eisenauer admissibility turns on demonstrating personal diligence against State machinery. Where the prefecture neither appeals nor executes, say so explicitly in each filing, since the Court noticed the prefects’ silence and still found for the State. And where health, disability or young children aggravate the wait, invoke the modulation factors the Council of State recognises, turning the flat-rate floor into an award that reflects real harm. Eisenauer rewards the applicant who enforces twice; it punishes the one who wins once and waits.

Conclusion

Eisenauer and Others v. France will be remembered as the judgment in which Strasbourg accepted that a court order can remain unexecuted for up to eight years without breaching Article 6, because penalty payments flowed, damages were available, and the housing crisis was real. Whether that compromise holds depends on what States do next: a management scheme that exists only on paper will look, on the next application, like the inaction the dissenters described. For applicants, the practical message is unsentimental. Win the DALO order, return to the judge to liquidate the penalty, sue for the harm each month of waiting causes, document everything, and plead the home itself under Article 8 rather than enforcement alone. The enforceable right to housing survives Eisenauer, but after 12 May 2026 it must be enforced twice: once before the French judge who orders it, and again through every procedure that proves the order was meant.

📄 Official circular