KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Data Was Leaked by a Company in Another EU Country: How to Complain to the CNIL and Claim Damages from France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Data Was Leaked by a Company in Another EU Country: How to Complain to the CNIL and Claim Damages from France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

This week, two data-breach stories topped the news in northern Europe. In Britain, the BBC reported on 21 October 2026 that a hospital worker had looked up a patient’s medical file and told her she had cancer days before her consultant was due to give her the results. In Denmark, the Scandinavian press reported the same day that a department-store chain had warned members of its loyalty club that their names, addresses and purchase histories may have been compromised, after intruders entered parts of its computer systems. The chain said it had called in outside experts, reported the incident to the police and to the Danish data protection authority, and stressed that no payment-card data was involved. Neither story happened in France. Both raise the question this article answers: when the company that lost your data sits in another European country, can you act from France, complain to the French authority, and claim money before a French court? Search demand is real: on 21 October 2026 the query “data breach” was an active trending topic in Britain at more than 10,000 searches, with rising queries including “data breach compensation”, “gdpr” and “ico data breach”.

French law gives you two doors, and they do not exclude each other: a complaint to the Commission nationale de l’informatique et des libertés, which can sanction the company, and a lawsuit for compensation, where only a judge can award you damages. A recent example shows the first door working at full power: on 14 May 2026 the Conseil d’Etat rejected the appeal of the French mobile-gaming publisher Voodoo against a 3 million euro fine imposed by the CNIL, with a compliance order backed by a daily penalty and publication of the decision. The explanations that follow are general in scope: they describe the complaints, checks and remedies available in any comparable situation and do not describe the situation of Voodoo, about which this article makes no finding.

I. Can I Complain to the French CNIL About a Data Breach by a Company Based in Another EU Country?

Yes, and you do not need to be French or to live in France to start. The General Data Protection Regulation gives every data subject a direct right to turn to a supervisory authority, in particular in the Member State of his or her habitual residence, place of work or place of the alleged infringement. That is the rule of Article 77(1) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of 27 April 2016. If you live in France, work in France, or were in France when your data was collected or leaked, the CNIL is a natural entry point, even if the company itself is established in Denmark, Ireland, Germany or any other Member State.

A. Which authority handles your complaint when the company sits abroad?

Cross-border cases follow a cooperation system with a lead authority. Article 56 of the Regulation organises this cooperation around a lead authority: the authority of the country where the company has its main establishment takes the lead for cross-border processing, under a cooperation procedure with the other authorities concerned. In practice, your complaint filed in Paris may therefore be shared with, and decided together with, the authority of the country where the company has its main base. That does not make the CNIL a mailbox: where the matter relates only to an establishment in France or substantially affects only people in France, the CNIL remains competent to handle the complaint itself. Where French residents are the ones affected, the CNIL keeps a genuine role.

On the French side, the status of the CNIL is written in domestic law. Article 8 of Law No. 78-17 of 6 January 1978 states: “La Commission nationale de l’informatique et des libertés est une autorité administrative indépendante.” The same article continues: “Elle est l’autorité de contrôle nationale au sens et pour l’application du règlement (UE) 2016/679 du 27 avril 2016.” And it describes complaint handling in these terms: “Elle traite les réclamations, pétitions et plaintes introduites par une personne concernée ou par un organisme, une organisation ou une association, examine ou enquête sur l’objet de la réclamation, dans la mesure nécessaire, et informe l’auteur de la réclamation de l’état d’avancement et de l’issue de l’enquête dans un délai raisonnable, notamment si un complément d’enquête ou une coordination avec une autre autorité de contrôle est nécessaire” (Article 8, Loi No. 78-17). In other words, the CNIL examines or investigates the complaint as far as needed and must keep you informed of progress and outcome, including where coordination with another European authority is required.

French law also provides a remedy against the authority itself. A CNIL decision that concerns you can be challenged before the administrative courts, and the Voodoo case discussed below shows that route in action: the sanction travelled all the way to the Conseil d’Etat, which reviewed it on appeal. A complaint that leads nowhere is therefore not the end of the road.

B. What can the CNIL actually order against the company?

A complaint is not symbolic. When the president of the CNIL considers that a breach can be fixed, Article 20(III) of Law No. 78-17 (Article 20, Loi No. 78-17) allows a graduated response: “le président de la Commission nationale de l’informatique et des libertés peut le rappeler à ses obligations légales ou, si le manquement constaté est susceptible de faire l’objet d’une mise en conformité, prononcer à son égard une mise en demeure, dans le délai qu’il fixe.” A formal notice with a deadline comes first; sanctions come from the restricted formation, the CNIL’s sanctioning body, after an adversarial procedure opened by a report from a commission member who does not sit in the sanctioning formation, with the company heard before any sanction is voted The company sees the rapporteur’s report, files observations, and can be represented or assisted before any sanction is voted (Article 22, Loi No. 78-17).

The scale of available measures is substantial. For serious processing, Article 20(IV)(7) of the same law provides: “A l’exception des cas où le traitement est mis en œuvre par l’Etat, une amende administrative ne pouvant excéder 10 millions d’euros ou, s’agissant d’une entreprise, 2 % du chiffre d’affaires annuel mondial total de l’exercice précédent, le montant le plus élevé étant retenu. Dans les hypothèses mentionnées aux 5 et 6 de l’article 83 du règlement (UE) 2016/679 du 27 avril 2016, ces plafonds sont portés, respectivement, à 20 millions d’euros et 4 % dudit chiffre d’affaires.” (Article 20, Loi No. 78-17). Alongside fines, the restricted formation can order the company to comply, suspend data flows, limit or ban processing, and publicise its decision, since “La formation restreinte peut rendre publiques les mesures qu’elle prend.” (Article 22, Loi No. 78-17) In urgent cases, Article 21 allows provisional steps, including: “L’injonction de mettre en conformité le traitement avec les obligations résultant du règlement (UE) 2016/679 du 27 avril 2016 ou de la présente loi ou de satisfaire aux demandes présentées par la personne concernée en vue d’exercer ses droits, qui peut être assortie, sauf dans le cas où le traitement est mis en œuvre par l’Etat, d’une astreinte dont le montant ne peut excéder 100 000 € par jour de retard à compter de la date fixée par la formation restreinte” (Article 21, Loi No. 78-17).

The Voodoo ruling illustrates the full chain. By decision No. SAN-2022-026 of 29 December 2022, the CNIL’s restricted formation imposed a 3 million euro fine for a breach of Article 82 of Law No. 78-17, the provision on trackers and advertising identifiers, together with a compliance order and publication. The Conseil d’Etat, 10th and 9th chambers combined, 14 May 2024, No. 472221, summarised the penalty as follows: the formation “a prononcé à son encontre une sanction pécuniaire de 3 millions d’euros à raison d’un manquement constaté au titre de l’article 82 de la loi n° 78-17 du 6 janvier 1978, assortie d’une injonction de mettre en conformité son traitement de données dans un délai de trois mois à compter de la notification de la délibération, sous astreinte de 20 000 euros par jour de retard”. The operative part is one line: “Article 1er : La requête de la société Voodoo est rejetée.” (CE, 14 May 2024, No. 472221). The fine, the three-month compliance deadline, the 20,000 euro daily penalty and the publication all survived judicial review. For a victim, the lesson is practical: a CNIL complaint can force a foreign-operating company to fix its systems and can produce a public decision that later supports a damages claim, but the fine itself is paid to the State, never to you. Compensation is the second door.

II. Can I Claim Damages in France for a Leak by a Foreign Company?

Yes. The right to compensation belongs to the individual, not to the authority, and it can be exercised before the courts of your own country of residence. Article 79 of the Regulation preserves every administrative and non-judicial remedy, including the CNIL complaint, alongside a direct right to go to court for anyone who considers that the processing of his or her data breaches the Regulation. Complaining to the CNIL therefore never closes the courtroom door. Jurisdiction is claimant-friendly: As to where to sue, the Regulation lets you choose between the courts of the country where the company is established and the courts of the country where you habitually live, except against a foreign public authority acting in its official capacity. If you habitually live in France, you may sue in France even when the company is established elsewhere in the Union.

A. What a French judge requires: a violation, a real loss, and a causal link

The foundation is the compensation rule of Article 82: anyone who has suffered material or non-material damage because of a breach of the Regulation is entitled to compensation from the controller or processor. French courts read this exactly as written: infringement plus damage plus causation. The Cour de cassation said so on 24 June 2026 in a widely noted employment-data ruling (Soc., No. 24-22.792): “Aux termes de ce texte, toute personne ayant subi un dommage matériel ou moral du fait d’une violation du présent règlement a le droit d’obtenir du responsable du traitement ou du sous-traitant réparation du préjudice subi.” (Cass. soc., 24 June 2026, No. 24-22.792).

The same decision recalls the Court of Justice framework that binds every French judge. On the judgment of 4 May 2023, Österreichische Post (C-300/21), as restated by the Cour de cassation (Cass. soc., 24 June 2026, No. 24-22.792): “- la simple violation des dispositions de ce règlement ne suffit pas pour conférer un droit à réparation ; – il s’oppose à une règle ou une pratique nationale subordonnant la réparation d’un dommage moral, au sens de cette disposition, à la condition que le préjudice subi par la personne concernée ait atteint un certain degré de gravité ; – aux fins de la fixation du montant des dommages-intérêts dus au titre du droit à réparation consacré à cet article, les juges nationaux doivent appliquer les règles internes de chaque État membre relatives à l’étendue de la réparation pécuniaire, pour autant que les principes d’équivalence et d’effectivité du droit de l’Union soient respectés (CJUE, 4 mai 2023, n° C/300-21, Österreichische Post).” Three consequences follow: a bare violation is not enough, no minimum seriousness threshold may be imposed for non-material damage, and the amount is set under national law subject to equivalence and effectiveness. On the judgment of 25 January 2024, MediaMarktSaturn (C-687/21): “- le droit à réparation prévu à cette disposition, notamment en cas de dommage moral, remplit une fonction compensatoire, en ce qu’une réparation pécuniaire fondée sur ladite disposition doit permettre de compenser intégralement le préjudice concrètement subi du fait de la violation de ce règlement, et non une fonction punitive ; – la personne demandant réparation au titre de cette disposition est tenue d’établir non seulement la violation de dispositions de ce règlement, mais également que cette violation lui a causé un dommage matériel ou moral (CJUE, 25 janvier 2024, n° C-687/21, MediaMarktSaturn Hagen-Iserlohn GmbH).” Compensation must make up the loss actually suffered, nothing more; and the claimant proves both the violation and the damage it caused.

Applied by the Cour de cassation, that standard is strict. The Paris court of appeal had awarded an employee 5,000 euros for the employer’s unlawful use of personal data. The chamber quashed (Cass. soc., 24 June 2026, No. 24-22.792): “En statuant ainsi, alors que la simple violation du règlement général sur la protection des données n’ouvre pas, à elle seule, droit à réparation et qu’il lui appartenait d’apprécier si le salarié établissait que la violation de ce règlement qu’elle avait constatée avait causé au salarié un dommage matériel ou moral, la cour d’appel a violé le texte susvisé.” The operative part follows: “CASSE ET ANNULE, mais seulement en ce qu’il condamne la société Natixis à payer à M. [P] la somme de 5 000 euros à titre de dommages et intérêts pour exécution déloyale du contrat de travail, l’arrêt rendu le 30 octobre 2024, entre les parties, par la cour d’appel de Paris”. An established GDPR violation with no proven loss means no damages.

Two first-instance rulings from 2025 show both sides of that line. In Paris, on 13 February 2025 (RG No. 21/07085), a claimant sought 5,000 euros for an alleged refusal of access to his personal data, relying on Article 1240 of the Civil Code and Regulation 2016/679. The court recalled the text: “1. Toute personne ayant subi un dommage matériel ou moral du fait d’une violation du présent règlement a le droit d’obtenir du responsable du traitement ou du sous-traitant réparation du préjudice subi. 2. Tout responsable du traitement ayant participé au traitement est responsable du dommage causé par le traitement qui constitue une violation du présent règlement.” It then rejected the claim outright: “Il sera relevé que M. [Y] [N] ne verse aux débats aucune pièce permettant de démontrer le caractère illicite d’une collecte ou d’une utilisation de ses données personnelles par la société D&P FINANCE, devenue la S.A.S. IMAGINE, ou une infraction commise par la société D&P FINANCE, devenue la S.A.S. IMAGINE au règlement susvisé qui lui aurait causé un préjudice certain en lien causal avec ces prétendues violations” — so the damages claim was rejected. No proven unlawful act, no certain loss, no causal link: the claim failed entirely.

In Aix-en-Provence, on 5 August 2025 (RG No. 22/03891), the outcome was the opposite because the loss was documented. A property manager had circulated the personal data of a family, including names of witnesses, doctors and health information, without consent. The court found that “il n’en demeure pas moins que la diffusion des informations portant atteinte à la vie privée des époux [I] leur a nécessairement causé un préjudice moral résultant des tracas auxquels ils ont dû faire face, directement liés à la divulgation d’informations personnelles concernant l’ensemble de leur famille par le syndic.” Backed by medical certificates and a degraded relationship with the whole building, that trouble was compensable: “la société CG IMMOBILIER sera condamnée à verser à Mme [N] [O] épouse [I] et à M. [Y] [I] la somme de 1.000 euros pour chacun, à titre de dommages et intérêts en réparation de leur préjudice moral.” But the court drew a line for the children: “En revanche, en l’état du jeune âge des enfants ([U] née le 6 juillet 2011 et [T] né le 1er septembre 2016), aucun préjudice moral spécifique résultant directement de la diffusion des informations portant atteinte à la vie privée de la famille [I] par le syndic n’est établie à l’égard des enfants mineurs.” The family’s claim rested on the Regulation, on the Law of 6 January 1978, on Article 9 of the Civil Code (“Chacun a droit au respect de sa vie privée. Les juges peuvent, sans préjudice de la réparation du dommage subi, prescrire toutes mesures, telles que séquestre, saisie et autres, propres à empêcher ou faire cesser une atteinte à l’intimité de la vie privée : ces mesures peuvent, s’il y a urgence, être ordonnées en référé.” — Art. 9, Code civil) and on Article 1240 (“Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer.” — Art. 1240, Code civil). Documented trouble won 1,000 euros per parent; undocumented harm for the children won nothing.

B. Where to sue from abroad and what to put in your file

Two jurisdictional routes converge on France. Under the Regulation, as explained above, you may sue where the company is established or where you habitually reside. Under French domestic procedure, Article 46 of the Code of Civil Procedure gives the claimant a choice in tort matters: “en matière délictuelle, la juridiction du lieu du fait dommageable ou celle dans le ressort de laquelle le dommage a été subi” (Art. 46, Code de procédure civile). If the leak reached you in France, the court of the place where you suffered the damage can hear the case. These are options, not guarantees: the court still checks that the defendant was properly summoned, that the claim is directed at the controller or processor responsible, and that the damage connects to France.

Erasure and access claims travel with the damages claim. Article 17 of the Regulation gives you the right to obtain erasure of your personal data without undue delay, in particular where the data were processed unlawfully. The Aix-en-Provence court applied exactly this logic when it ordered the deletion of the family’s data from the manager’s systems, including the customer portal, under penalty of 200 euros per day of delay. Asking a French judge for deletion plus damages in the same writ is standard practice.

Your file must prove three things, in this order. First, the violation: the breach notification email or letter, screenshots of exposed data, the company’s public statement, or a prior access request left unanswered. Second, the concrete loss: phishing attempts received after the leak, fraudulent purchases, time spent securing accounts, anxiety documented by a medical certificate, reputational harm among neighbours or colleagues, as in the Aix-en-Provence case. Third, the causal link between the two: dates showing the harm followed the breach, and no other leak explaining the same data. The Paris rejection shows what happens when the first and third elements are missing; the Aix-en-Provence award shows what happens when all three are present. Keep every notification, and file the CNIL complaint in parallel: the authority’s findings and any public sanction decision become exhibits that strengthen, but never replace, your own evidence of loss.

Conclusion

A data breach by a company in another EU country leaves an English-speaking victim in France with two usable doors. The CNIL can be seized on the basis of residence, workplace or place of the infringement, must keep you informed, may coordinate with the lead authority, and can impose compliance orders, daily penalties and fines up to 10 million euros or 2 percent of worldwide turnover, doubled in the gravest cases, as that confirmed 3 million euro penalty demonstrates. The civil courts can award compensation where you sue, including in your country of residence, but only for loss you prove: a bare violation is not enough, moral damage needs no minimum threshold yet still needs evidence, and each child, each parent, each claimant proves their own harm. Preserve the breach notice, record every consequence, complain to the authority and sue for the damage, each with its own evidence. That is the complete, realistic path from a leaked file abroad to an enforceable French decision.

📄 Official circular