KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Hand Luggage Goes Free on Flights to France: What You Really Get and How to Claim

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Hand Luggage Goes Free on Flights to France: What You Really Get and How to Claim

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

October 2026 brought the headlines many travellers had waited years to read: hand luggage fees are on the way out in Europe, and airlines will have to let passengers bring cabin bags without charging extra. The story travelled fast through the British, American and Irish press, and it matters directly if you fly to or from France. But the headlines also got an important detail wrong. Europe has not voted you two free suitcases. What the European Parliament adopted on 7 July 2026, by 646 votes to 12 with three abstentions, and what the Council gave its final clearance to on 13 July 2026, is more precise and, for a lawyer, more interesting: every air passenger will have the right to carry on board, without extra cost, one personal item such as a small bag or backpack, and airlines, intermediaries and search portals will have to display the fare inclusive of carry-on allowance from the very start of the booking process. Airlines may still sell cheaper tickets to passengers who travel without hand luggage, and checked baggage remains a separate market where price freedom continues to rule.

For an international audience with a French connection, three questions follow. First, when does this actually apply, given that the Council says the updated rules will enter into force 12 months and 20 days after publication in the Official Journal, which points to late 2027. Second, what exactly becomes free, what stays payable, and which compensation rights survive the reform untouched. Third, and most practically, how do you enforce all of this from France: which court, who carries the burden of proof, which provisions of the French Consumer Code bite on drip pricing, and what the French procedure looks like, from the written claim to mediation and the report to the Direction generale de l aviation civile. This analysis answers those questions with the official texts, the judgments that already govern your current claims, and the new provisions that will govern your future ones.

I. EU free hand luggage on flights to France: what is actually free and what you keep

A. Is cabin baggage now free on flights to France and what does the fare have to show

The starting point is the provisional agreement reached in the Conciliation Committee between Parliament and Council negotiators, confirmed by the plenary on 7 July 2026. The European Parliament press release states the new position in plain terms: the new rules include a right to carry one personal item on board at no extra cost, with a small bag or backpack given as the example. Read carefully, that sentence draws the boundary of the new right. One personal item travels free in all circumstances. A small bag or a backpack that fits under the seat is the illustration the text gives. The reform does not create an unconditional right to a large wheeled cabin suitcase plus a personal item on every ticket. That is the correction to apply to the viral summaries promising two free bags on every European flight.

The second half of the mechanism is about price display rather than about a second free bag. The Parliament insisted that airlines, intermediaries and search portals must always display the fare inclusive of the carry-on allowance from the very start of the booking process. The same paragraph adds the safety valve the airlines obtained: The text adds that airlines may offer cheaper tickets to passengers who choose to travel without hand luggage. Put together, the architecture is clear. The headline price you see when you search for a Paris to New York, Paris to London or Paris to Rome flight must already contain the carry-on allowance, so that comparison between carriers becomes honest. A carrier that wants to unbundle can still do so, but only downward, by offering a cheaper ticket without hand luggage, never by advertising a stripped fare and adding the cabin bag later in the purchase tunnel.

This matters because the purchase tunnel is where the abuse lived. For years, low cost carriers advertised eye catching base fares and then added cabin bag fees, priority boarding charges and seat selection costs step by step, a practice consumer lawyers call drip pricing. The new display rule attacks that practice at its root for every booking made through an airline website, a travel intermediary or a price comparison portal. From a French law perspective, the reform arrives on ground that was already prepared. Article L111-1 of the Consumer Code provides that “Avant que le consommateur ne soit lié par un contrat à titre onéreux, le professionnel communique au consommateur, de manière lisible et compréhensible, les informations suivantes : 1° Les caractéristiques essentielles du bien ou du service”, and it lists as item 2° “Le prix ou tout autre avantage procuré au lieu ou en complément du paiement d’un prix en application des articles L. 112-1 à L. 112-4-1”. Article L112-1 adds the general price information duty: “Tout vendeur de produit ou tout prestataire de services informe le consommateur, par voie de marquage, d’étiquetage, d’affichage ou par tout autre procédé approprié, sur les prix et les conditions particulières de la vente et de l’exécution des services”. A fare that hides the cabin bag supplement until the third screen of the booking flow sits uncomfortably with both provisions, and the European reform now says so expressly for air transport.

Deceptive fare construction is also caught by the prohibition of unfair commercial practices. Article L121-1 of the Consumer Code states that “Les pratiques commerciales déloyales sont interdites”, and explains that “Une pratique commerciale est déloyale lorsqu’elle est contraire aux exigences de la diligence professionnelle et qu’elle altère ou est susceptible d’altérer de manière substantielle le comportement économique du consommateur normalement informé et raisonnablement attentif et avisé, à l’égard d’un bien ou d’un service”. Article L121-2 details misleading practices and provides that “Une pratique commerciale est trompeuse si elle est commise dans l’une des circonstances suivantes : 1° Lorsqu’elle crée une confusion avec un autre bien ou service, une marque, un nom commercial ou un autre signe distinctif d’un concurrent ; 2° Lorsqu’elle repose sur des allégations, indications ou présentations fausses ou de nature à induire en erreur et portant sur l’un ou plusieurs des éléments suivants : a) L’existence, la disponibilité ou la nature du bien ou du service”. A traveller who chooses a flight because the displayed price looked lowest, then discovers at payment that the cabin bag which the advertisement implied was included costs extra, is the textbook illustration of an economic decision distorted by presentation. Once the new regulation applies, that dispute largely disappears for carry-on, because the displayed fare must include it.

To understand why the reform stopped where it did, you need the precedent that governed checked baggage. On 18 September 2014, in case C-487/12 concerning a Spanish dispute with Vueling, the Court of Justice held that Article 22(1) of Regulation 1008/2008 on price freedom precludes national rules forcing airlines, in all circumstances, to carry checked baggage meeting certain weight conditions within the ticket price with no supplement permitted In other words, under the price freedom of Regulation 1008/2008, charging a supplement for checked hold baggage is lawful in principle, and a Member State cannot force airlines to include it in all circumstances. The 2026 reform does not touch that holding for hold baggage. It changes the cabin specifically: one personal item free as of right, and carry-on included in the displayed fare. Hold luggage stays in the Vueling world of price freedom, cabin baggage moves into the new world of transparency plus a guaranteed free personal item.

The political context explains why the reform finally moved after what the Parliament rapporteur called more than thirteen years of deadlock. The revision of Regulation 261/2004 has been on the table since the Commission proposal of 2013, file 2013/0072(COD), and the hand luggage question became explosive when Spain s consumer rights ministry fined several low cost carriers a combined 179 million euros in November 2024 for practices including charging for larger cabin bags, as reported by Reuters at the time, with Ryanair accounting for 108 million euros and Vueling 39 million euros of that total according to the same reporting. The ministry rejected the airlines appeals and at least one carrier announced it would take the fight to the Spanish courts, so those fines should be read as an enforcement signal rather than a final judicial word. But the signal worked: the issue moved from national consumer ministries to the European legislator, and the conciliation deal of June 2026, confirmed in July, is the answer.

Two practical boundaries complete this first picture. First, timing. The Council press release of 13 July 2026 states that the updated air passenger rules will enter into force 12 months and 20 days after publication in the Official Journal. Publication had not yet occurred when this analysis was written, so application belongs to late 2027, and airlines have that preparation year to adapt booking engines. Until then, the current rules apply, and your current claims are judged under current law, which the second part of this analysis explains. Second, scope. The reform revises Regulation 261/2004, whose Article 3 covers passengers departing from an airport located in a Member State, as well as passengers flying from a third country to the European Union on an EU carrier where they received no equivalent benefits or assistance there. Every flight leaving France is therefore covered. A flight from New York, London or Montreal to Paris is covered when the operating carrier is an EU airline. Travellers should note the asymmetry this creates on routes served by non EU carriers inbound to France, and British travellers should check carefully which regime their booking falls under, since the reform is EU law, not worldwide law.

B. EU261 compensation in France in 2027: amounts, delays and the new claim deadlines

The hand luggage provisions made the headlines, but the bulk of the reform concerns the compensation machinery that already protects millions of passengers every year, and the good news for travellers is that the core of it survived. The Parliament negotiators resisted pressure to dilute existing passenger rights, and the compensation levels are maintained exactly where they stood: 250 euros for journeys up to 1,500 km, 400 euros for intra EU journeys of more than 1,500 km and other journeys between 1,500 and 3,500 km, and 600 euros for all other longer journeys. Airlines will have the possibility to reduce compensation by half for their longest journeys if passengers are offered re-routing to their final destination or if the arrival delay does not exceed four hours, but the headline amounts do not move.

The trigger does not move either. Passengers keep the right to be reimbursed or re-routed on cancellation, and to claim compensation for delays of more than three hours, for cancellation less than 14 days in advance, or for denied boarding. That three hour threshold is not in the original 2004 text; it comes from the Court of Justice case law that equated long delays with cancellations for compensation purposes, and French courts apply it daily. On 17 February 2021, in a dispute between a passenger and Vueling over a Milan to Paris flight diverted from Orly to Roissy Charles de Gaulle, the First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation restated the rule this way: “peut bénéficier de l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 le passager d’un vol qui a atteint sa destination finale avec un retard de trois heures ou plus par rapport à l’heure prévue initialement et cette destination finale est définie comme étant celle figurant sur le billet présenté au comptoir d’enregistrement ou, dans le cas des vols avec correspondance, la destination du dernier vol”. The reform locks that judge made three hour rule into the legislative landscape rather than reopening it, which is why the rapporteur could present the vote as replacing uncertainty with clear rules.

Airlines keep their classic escape route, but it is now fenced. Compensation can be refused where the delay or cancellation was caused by events beyond the carrier s control, and the new text provides an open list of such extraordinary circumstances, including natural disasters, war, weather conditions, unruly passengers, and strikes by airport, air navigation or ground handling service providers. An open list means the enumeration guides without exhausting, so litigation will continue about new fact patterns, but the structure of the defence is unchanged: the airline must prove both the extraordinary event and that it could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken. The French formulation of that burden is settled. In the same 2021 Vueling ruling, the Cour de cassation recalled the Article 5(3) defence, under which an operating carrier owes no Article 7 payment where it proves that the cancellation or the arrival delay resulted from extraordinary circumstances unavoidable even with all reasonable measures taken, and it grounded the test in the Court of Justice case law under which extraordinary circumstances are events which, by their nature or origin, are not inherent in the normal exercise of the carrier s activity and escape its effective control. A permanent night flight ban at an airport, which was the airline s argument in that case for the Orly diversion, did not automatically qualify, and carriers invoking strikes, weather or air traffic control restrictions will have to show concretely why no reasonable measure could have avoided the outcome on that flight.

The duty of care for stranded passengers is clarified in useful detail. In all cases, operators must look after waiting passengers with refreshments every two hours of waiting time, a meal after three hours, and overnight accommodation where needed during long delays, capped at three nights where the disruption is beyond the airline s control. This is assistance, not compensation: it is owed regardless of the cause, and it cannot be replaced by a voucher pressed into your hand at the gate while you pay for your own hotel.

Around compensation, the reform adds a series of concrete new rights that read like a catalogue of the most frequent traveller complaints. Passengers will be able to take the return leg of a two way ticket even if they did not use the outbound flight, without any additional fee, which kills the no-show clause that used to cancel your return when you missed the outward journey. The press release states the rule directly: passengers will be able to use the return leg of a return ticket even where they skipped the outbound flight, at no additional charge. Families are protected by an adjacent seating right: carriers must place any person accompanying a child below the age of 14 on an adjacent seat without extra charge, and the same protection extends to passengers with disabilities or reduced mobility and to pregnant women. Passengers with disabilities also gain an express right to compensation, re-routing and assistance where they miss a flight because the airport failed to help them reach the gate on time. Two classic irritants disappear as well: airlines will no longer charge for correcting spelling errors in a name or for a printed boarding pass where the passenger has already checked in, and boarding passes must be obtainable digitally at check-in without forcing the passenger to create an account or install an application.

Finally, the reform imposes discipline on the claims process itself, and this is where future litigation in France will concentrate. Passengers who choose reimbursement over re-routing must receive it automatically. Carriers must send clear compensation instructions within four days of the end of the disrupted journey, without requiring any account or application. Then the clock runs: passengers will have nine months to file a compensation request, while airlines will have thirty days to pay or to invoke extraordinary circumstances, explain the refusal and point passengers to complaint handling. Nine months to claim and thirty days for the airline to pay or reason its refusal gives French practitioners the harmonised time frame they always lacked, and it will sit alongside the national limitation periods that French courts continue to apply to current files, as the second part explains.

II. Airline charged you or refused compensation in France: how to enforce it

A. Airline refuses EU261 compensation in France: who must prove what before the judge

Until the new regulation applies, and even afterwards for the principles it preserves, your dispute with an airline over a flight to or from France is decided by the current Regulation 261/2004 as interpreted by the Court of Justice and applied by French courts. Three French reference points structure every file, and each of them favours the passenger who arrives with documents in order.

The first is the burden of proof, decided in the passenger s favour. In the 17 February 2021 Vueling case, the trial court had rejected the claim on the ground that a delay of more than three hours was not established, even though the aircraft had landed at Roissy Charles de Gaulle at 00:18 instead of Orly at 22:30. The Cour de cassation quashed that reasoning, recalling that under the Civil Code provision on the burden of proof it is for the airline to prove that it performed its obligations. Concretely, once you prove your booking, your boarding and the actual arrival time at the destination shown on your ticket, it is for the airline to demonstrate that you reached your final destination with less than three hours delay, or that extraordinary circumstances exonerate it. An airline that answers your claim with a generic reference to operational reasons or weather, without flight specific evidence, has not discharged that burden. Keep your electronic ticket, your boarding pass, screenshots of the actual arrival time and any message from the carrier: those documents fix the facts, and the law then moves the burden to the other side.

The second reference point is the time limit for suing, and it contains a trap that has defeated many claims. Airline defence letters sometimes invoke the two year limitation of the Montreal Convention to declare a compensation claim out of time. The Cour de cassation closed that argument on 10 October 2019 in a case opposing Air France to two passengers claiming under Articles 5 and 7 of Regulation 261/2004 and under Article 14 for failure to provide the information notice. The Court recalled the Court of Justice position that “le délai dans lequel les actions ayant pour objet d’obtenir le versement de l’indemnité prévue aux articles 5 et 7 du règlement n° 261/2004 doivent être intentées, est déterminé par le droit national de chaque Etat membre”, because the standardised compensation sits outside the Warsaw and Montreal conventions. Applying French national law, it approved the trial court s conclusion that “la demande était soumise au délai de prescription quinquennale de l’article 2224 du code civil”. Article 2224 of the Civil Code provides that “Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer”. For current files, the practical consequence is significant: a standardised compensation claim under Regulation 261/2004 is an autonomous action governed by the five year ordinary limitation, not by the two year Montreal period, and a refusal letter that invokes Montreal to close a 2023 or 2024 file deserves a second look. The coming nine month claim window of the reform will harmonise the first step of the process, but it does not rewrite the national limitation applicable to court action, so promptness remains the safest strategy.

The third reference point is the French Consumer Code, which is where hand luggage fee disputes will increasingly be fought, both now and under the new display rule. The general weapon is Article L212-1: “Dans les contrats conclus entre professionnels et consommateurs, sont abusives les clauses qui ont pour objet ou pour effet de créer, au détriment du consommateur, un déséquilibre significatif entre les droits et obligations des parties au contrat”. Airline general conditions that let the carrier change the baggage allowance or add fees after the price was displayed are exposed twice. First, the unfair terms black list provides that clauses are irrebuttably presumed unfair where they have as their object or effect “Réserver au professionnel le droit de modifier unilatéralement les clauses du contrat relatives à sa durée, aux caractéristiques ou au prix du bien à livrer ou du service à rendre”. A fare that can grow unilaterally between selection and payment is exactly that configuration. Second, the grey list and the general test catch the surrounding architecture: loyalty traps, non refundable supplements presented as options, and conditions scattered across documents the passenger never saw before paying.

Baggage liability for loss, damage or delay follows a different track that should not be confused with standardised compensation, and French statute law marks the boundary. Article L6421-3 of the Transport Code states that “La responsabilité du transporteur aérien titulaire d’une licence d’exploitation délivrée en application du règlement (CE) n° 1008/2008 du 24 septembre 2008 établissant des règles communes pour l’exploitation de services aériens dans la Communauté est soumise, en ce qui concerne le transport aérien de passagers et de leurs bagages, aux dispositions du règlement (CE) n° 889/2002 du 13 mai 2002 modifiant le règlement (CE) n° 2027/97 relatif à la responsabilité des transporteurs aériens en cas d’accident et aux stipulations de la convention pour l’unification de certaines règles relatives au transport aérien international signée à Montréal le 28 mai 1999”. In plain terms, a suitcase lost between New York and Paris is a Montreal Convention file with its own declaration, notice and liability ceilings, while a three hour delay on the same journey is a Regulation 261/2004 file with standardised compensation. The two tracks can run in parallel on the same journey, and the new hand luggage right adds a third: a fee charged for the guaranteed personal item, once the regulation applies, is neither a liability question nor a compensation question but a straightforward breach of a directly applicable European right.

B. Claiming a hand luggage fee or flight compensation from France: the exact path

Procedure decides outcomes as much as substance, and France has a specific sequence that must be followed in order. The first step is always a written claim to the airline, and it should be built like a file, not like a complaint. Identify the booking reference, the flight number and date, the scheduled and actual arrival times, and attach the electronic ticket, the boarding pass and any receipt for expenses. State the legal basis precisely: Article 7 of Regulation 261/2004 with the distance band for a delay or cancellation claim, the information duty for a notice failure claim, or, once the reform applies, the free personal item right and the all-in fare display duty for a cabin bag fee claim. Ask for a specific sum and set a deadline for payment. This letter matters twice: it starts the negotiation, and it becomes exhibit one if the file goes further. Travellers dealing with a cancelled flight will find the same method applied to cancellations in our analysis of cancelled flights to and from France, refunds and EU261 compensation, which follows the identical claim architecture.

The second step surprises many foreign claimants: in France, mediation is not optional decoration. The official service public guidance on delayed flights explains that without prior mediation where it is compulsory, the subsequent court claim will be inadmissible, and it directs passengers to the airline s mediator before any judge can be seised. File the mediation with the same exhibits plus the airline s refusal or its silence, and keep proof of filing. Mediation is free for the consumer, it interrupts limitation while it runs, and airlines settle a meaningful share of files at this stage rather than risk an adverse judgment that the passenger can then circulate.

The third step runs in parallel and costs nothing: the report to the Direction generale de l aviation civile. The service public portal provides a dedicated procedure to signal a dispute following denied boarding, delay or cancellation, and it expressly allows passengers to report a refusal of compensation or non compliant practices by the carrier. The DGAC is the French national enforcement body for air passenger rights: it does not award you damages, but it investigates patterns, it can sanction carriers, and a file number from the authority changes the tone of any subsequent negotiation. Where the dispute concerns fare display, drip pricing or unfair terms rather than delay compensation, the parallel authority is the DGCCRF, the consumer and competition administration, which receives reports of misleading commercial practices and can investigate and fine. A hand luggage fee imposed in breach of the future display duty, or a fare tunnel that hides the carry-on supplement until payment, belongs to both desks at once: contractual breach toward the airline, regulatory signal toward the authorities.

The fourth step is the French court, and jurisdiction is rarely the problem international travellers fear. For a flight bought online from a carrier that directs its activity to France, and a fortiori for any flight departing from a French airport, French courts are available, with the tribunal judiciaire hearing most passenger claims and simplified procedures for smaller amounts. The substantive advantages mapped in the previous section travel with you into that courtroom: the airline bears the burden of proving timely arrival or extraordinary circumstances, Montreal s two year period does not govern standardised compensation claims, and the Consumer Code provisions on unfair terms, pre contractual information and misleading practices apply to the fare construction as well as to the fee itself. One caution for non European readers: the reform is European law, and the Court of Justice precedents cited here bind courts in the Member States, but they do not bind foreign carriers operations outside the Article 3 scope recalled above. Check the operating carrier on your ticket, not only the logo on the booking page, because code share arrangements frequently split the marketing carrier from the operating carrier that owes the obligations.

A final practical note on evidence, because hand luggage disputes turn on screens. Save the booking flow: the fare as first displayed, each intermediate screen, the final price breakdown and the general conditions as accepted on the day of purchase, since carriers update them regularly. Photograph your bag against the airline s sizing frame at the gate if boarding is refused or a fee is imposed under protest, pay under explicit written protest rather than abandoning the flight, and keep the receipt. A fee line that appears only on the payment screen, after a headline fare that implied carry-on was included, is precisely the configuration the new display duty is designed to kill, and it is also the configuration Articles L111-1, L112-1, L121-1 and L121-2 of the Consumer Code already punish. Screenshots taken today win cases tomorrow.

Conclusion

The October 2026 announcements are real European law in motion, not airline marketing. Parliament confirmed the conciliation deal by 646 votes to 12 on 7 July 2026, the Council gave its final clearance on 13 July 2026, and the text will enter into force 12 months and 20 days after Official Journal publication, with application expected in late 2027. The content is now fixed: one personal item free on board for every passenger, fares displayed inclusive of carry-on allowance from the first screen, cheaper tickets without hand luggage as the only permitted unbundling, maintained 250, 400 and 600 euro compensation with the three hour trigger, an open list of extraordinary circumstances, automatic reimbursement, a nine month claim window against a thirty day airline response time, usable return legs, free adjacent seating for young children and vulnerable passengers, and free name corrections and boarding passes. Checked hold baggage stays under the price freedom confirmed by the Court of Justice in Vueling, and the Spanish 179 million euro enforcement wave remains under appeal, a signal rather than a final verdict.

For flights to and from France, the strategy follows from the texts. Until application, enforce current rights under Regulation 261/2004 with French procedure: written claim with full exhibits, compulsory mediation, parallel DGAC report, then the tribunal judiciaire where the airline must prove arrival times and extraordinary circumstances and where the five year ordinary limitation governs autonomous compensation claims. From application, add the two new weapons: the guaranteed free personal item and the all-in fare display, backed by the Consumer Code duties on price information and the prohibitions on unfair terms and misleading practices. In both periods, the file that wins is the file that was documented at the airport and in the booking tunnel, on the day, before the Airline s version becomes the only version.

📄 Official circular