Four European governments have reopened the political question that Brussels had deliberately kept alive: whether immobilised Russian central-bank assets can support a new financial instrument for Ukraine. Reuters reported on 27 August 2026 that Sweden, the Netherlands, Poland and Spain were pressing for the issue to return to the agenda of the 1–2 September meeting in Ireland. The figures explain the urgency: public reporting places the European stock at approximately €210 billion, with roughly €185 billion held through Euroclear in Belgium. The European Commission’s own 27 August briefing added an important qualification: it had not yet received the letter, but the subject had never left the agenda. This is therefore a live legal and political reopening, not a completed confiscation. For French companies, banks, funds and counsel, the immediate question is practical. What must be checked when a payment, security, account or contractual claim has a Russian connection, while the EU is considering how to use cash balances associated with immobilised assets? The answer requires three distinctions: sanctions freezing is not ownership transfer; extraordinary income is not the sovereign principal; and a French court’s enforcement rules do not decide the separate institutional dispute in Belgium. This analysis gives an insider view of those boundaries and of the evidence a French business should preserve before accepting or refusing a cross-border transaction.
I. Can the EU use frozen Russian assets without confiscating them?
A. What does “immobilised” mean for the €210 billion?
The first legal mistake is to treat every reference to “frozen Russian assets” as shorthand for a confiscation already decided. The European Council’s 18 December 2025 text uses a more cautious vocabulary. It records that the Union adopted, on the basis of Article 122 TFEU, exceptional, temporary and duly justified emergency measures to immobilise Russian assets on a more sustained basis. The same text calls for continued technical and legal work on a Reparations Loan based on cash balances associated with those assets. It also records a separate €90 billion loan to Ukraine for 2026–2027 backed by the EU budget headroom. The Council’s official account is available in the European Council conclusions on Ukraine.
Those words matter. Immobilisation normally means that the holder or intermediary cannot transfer, return, dispose of or otherwise deal with the relevant asset in the ordinary way. It does not, by itself, rewrite the title entry in the books of the Central Bank of Russia. A prohibition on transfer can be exceptionally durable without becoming a judicial declaration that the underlying principal belongs to the Union or to Ukraine. The legal theory of any future instrument would have to answer several separate questions: who owns the principal, who bears the repayment risk, who bears the risk of a Russian claim, what act authorises the use of the cash balance, and how the measure remains compatible with EU and international law.
The Council’s 12 December 2025 decision illustrates the interim approach. Its official description says that the regulation temporarily prohibits direct or indirect transfers of assets or reserves of the Central Bank of Russia, including assets held by entities acting on its behalf or at its direction. That is a restriction on movement, not an announcement that a private creditor or a Member State can simply seize the principal. The Council explanation of the transfer prohibition also identifies Council Regulation (EU) 2025/2600 as the relevant emergency instrument. A proposed reparation loan would still need its own legal, financial and risk architecture.
There is a second distinction between the principal and the income generated while an asset is immobilised. Interest, coupons, cash balances and other extraordinary revenues can be treated differently from the asset that produced them. The political debate has repeatedly focused on using cash balances or extraordinary revenues while leaving the principal immobilised. That does not make the proposal legally automatic. It means that the analysis may turn on the legal character of the income, the custodian’s obligations, counterclaims, taxation, insolvency risk, and the exact EU regulation authorising the movement or retention of that income.
French businesses should therefore read the word “frozen” with precision. A designation-based asset freeze under Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 applies to funds and economic resources belonging to, owned, held or controlled by listed persons and entities. Article 2(1) states: “All funds and economic resources belonging to, owned, held or controlled by any natural persons or natural or legal persons, entities or bodies associated with them as listed in Annex I shall be frozen.”
Article 2(2) adds that no funds or economic resources may be made available, directly or indirectly, to or for the benefit of listed persons or entities. The complete consolidated instrument is on EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 269/2014.
That regulation is not a complete legal description of the Central Bank of Russia question. A sovereign reserve measure can be based on a distinct EU act, while a listed private bank, company or individual can be subject to Regulation 269/2014. The two regimes may overlap in a payment chain, but they should not be collapsed into one. A French bank that sees a Russian counterparty is not entitled to conclude that every Russian balance is frozen under Article 2. It must identify the asset, the holder, the control chain, the applicable regulation and any specific prohibition on the transaction.
Regulation (EU) No 833/2014 supplies another layer. It contains sectoral, trade, financial and services restrictions relating to Russia. A transaction can be prohibited because of its object, service, technology, financing or involvement in a designated person even where a simple name search does not return a listed counterparty. The official text is available through EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 833/2014. The compliance question is consequently not “Is Russia involved?” but “Which rule applies to this asset, person, service, payment route and purpose?”
The EU’s anti-circumvention rule reinforces the point. Article 9 of Regulation 269/2014 says: “It shall be prohibited to participate, knowingly and intentionally, in activities the object or effect of which is to circumvent the measures referred to in Article 2.”
The phrase “object or effect” is operationally important. A structure that changes the name of a payer, routes funds through a third country or interposes a newly incorporated company does not become safe merely because the first search result is clean. The analysis must record why the transaction is not designed to make frozen value available or to defeat an EU restriction.
On the current state of the debate, the strongest defensible conclusion is narrow. Brussels has created a legal framework to keep Russian assets immobilised, has already used extraordinary revenues in support of Ukraine and has mandated further work on a possible reparations loan. It has not thereby completed a general transfer of the sovereign principal. The 1–2 September political discussion could produce a mandate, a technical proposal, a guarantee request or a new legal act. It cannot be treated in advance as a final confiscation decision.
B. Why are Belgium and Euroclear the legal pressure point?
The concentration of the European assets through Euroclear makes Belgium more than a political venue. It is the place where custody, settlement, operational continuity and litigation risk meet. If a significant share of the Russian central-bank cash is held through a Belgian infrastructure, any use of the cash balance must address the consequences for the custodian and for the Belgian State. The relevant questions include whether a claimant could pursue the custodian, whether a foreign judgment could be recognised, whether sovereign immunity applies to the reserve, whether countermeasures are lawful, and who would indemnify losses caused by a Russian action.
That is why the present proposal is better described as a risk-allocation problem than as a simple question of political will. One possible model is a loan whose repayment is postponed until Russia pays reparations, with the EU retaining the immobilised assets as a potential source of repayment. Another model could rely on extraordinary income or on cash balances without transferring the principal. A third could require guarantees from Member States, the EU budget or another public mechanism. Each model changes the litigation profile. It is not enough to say that a balance is “not confiscated” if the custodian is exposed to an action that claims damages for unlawful retention, or if the new instrument effectively appropriates the economic value of the reserve.
The European Council’s language deliberately preserves that legal work. It says the assets remain immobilised subject to EU law until Russia ceases its war of aggression and compensates Ukraine, and it calls on the Council and Parliament to continue examining the technical and legal aspects of a Reparations Loan. The text also says that Ukraine’s €90 billion loan is based on EU borrowing backed by the EU budget, with repayment only once reparations are received. This arrangement is politically linked to the Russian assets but is not identical to an immediate seizure of them.
French private law gives a useful warning about the limits of a slogan such as “state assets can be seized.” Article L111-1-1 of the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures requires prior judicial authorisation for protective or enforcement measures against property belonging to a foreign State. The official wording begins: « Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée ne peuvent être mises en œuvre sur un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger que sur autorisation préalable du juge »
. The full provision is on Légifrance, Article L111-1-1 CPCE.
Article L111-1-2 then limits the judge’s authority to defined situations. It provides: « Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée visant un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger ne peuvent être autorisées par le juge que si l’une des conditions suivantes est remplie »
. The conditions include express consent, an asset reserved or allocated to satisfy the claim, or an enforceable decision combined with a specific use of the asset other than a public non-commercial purpose and a sufficient connection with the entity concerned. The full list and its exclusions are in Légifrance, Article L111-1-2 CPCE.
That French mechanism is not the law governing Euroclear’s Belgian position, and a French statute cannot decide a dispute about EU institutional competence. It is nevertheless a useful test of the legal questions that any European proposal must answer. What is the asset’s use? Is it public and sovereign, or private and commercial? Is there a specific link between the asset and the claim? Has the State consented, and if so, to which asset or category? Which court has jurisdiction? Which measure is sought: immobilisation, an attachment, a transfer, a loan, or the use of income?
French case law is equally cautious. In its judgment of 25 January 2005, No 03-18.176, the First Civil Chamber stated that foreign States benefit in principle from enforcement immunity, but that the position differs when the asset is connected to a private-law economic, commercial or civil operation. The judgment can be read on Légifrance, Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 25 January 2005, No 03-18.176. The holding concerned French property and condominium charges, not Russian reserves. Its value here is methodological: the court looked at the asset’s use and its connection with the claim, rather than applying a nationality-based shortcut.
In its judgment of 19 November 2008, No 07-10.570, the same chamber repeated the distinction between sovereign activity and private-law management, while examining the treatment of assets belonging to a foreign State. See Légifrance, Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 19 November 2008, No 07-10.570. In its judgment of 28 March 2013, No 11-13.323, the Court added that a contractual waiver of enforcement immunity over public-use property must be express and special, identifying the property or category of property concerned. The official judgment is Légifrance, Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 28 March 2013, No 11-13.323.
These decisions do not resolve whether a European measure concerning Russian central-bank reserves is lawful. They show why the dispute cannot be reduced to the word “frozen.” A court or an arbitral tribunal would examine the legal source of the restraint, the status and use of the asset, the claimant’s title, the connection between claim and property, the relevant immunities and the precise relief sought. The fact that a political decision is announced in Brussels does not automatically produce an executable order in Paris or Brussels.
The immediate consequence for business is that Belgium’s exposure can make the political timetable legally material even before a new act is adopted. A French company with a bank account, receivable, guarantee or securities position connected to Euroclear should preserve its custody statements, payment instructions, contractual governing-law clauses, sanctions-screening results and communications with its bank. If the European instrument changes, those documents may determine whether the company acted in good faith, whether a payment was due before a listing or prohibition, whether an exception was available, and whether a later refusal was contractually justified.
II. What must French companies verify before touching Russian-linked funds?
A. Which sanctions and freeze checks apply to a French company?
A French company should not begin with a geopolitical conclusion. It should begin with a transaction map. Identify the payer, payee, beneficial owner, account holder, lender, guarantor, custodian, goods, services, bank route, place of performance and purpose. Then identify the legal instrument that could prohibit or condition the transaction. A Russian nationality, residence or incorporation is a risk signal, not by itself a complete answer. Conversely, a non-Russian intermediary does not eliminate risk if it is acting for a listed person, is controlled by a listed entity or is being used to circumvent a restriction.
Regulation 269/2014 is directly applicable and reaches conduct with an EU connection. Article 17 covers the territory of the Union, aircraft and vessels under a Member State’s jurisdiction, Member State nationals, legal persons incorporated under Member State law and business done in whole or in part within the Union. It therefore matters to a French company even when the account, counterparty or ultimate recipient is outside France. The regulation also contains rules on reporting, authorisations, judicial or arbitral decisions and pre-existing contracts. A payment that appears commercially ordinary can still require a specific authorisation if a listed person is involved.
The French Code of Monetary and Financial Law turns that European framework into a direct operational obligation. Article L562-4 states: « Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel »
. It covers the persons subject to the provision, including relevant professionals and legal persons established under French law or conducting an operation in France, and requires immediate information to the Minister responsible for the economy. The full text is available at Légifrance, Article L562-4 CMF.
The word “without delay” changes the internal workflow. A company should not wait until the end of the month to decide whether a suspicious payment can be processed, and it should not let the commercial team improvise a release because a contract is old or the counterparty threatens proceedings. The business must first preserve the funds, stop the relevant movement where required, escalate to the compliance or legal function, and document the legal basis for the decision. The precise reporting and authorisation route depends on the applicable regulation and the status of the person or asset.
Article L562-4-1 CMF requires internal organisation and procedures for asset-freezing and non-availability measures, including the prohibition on circumvention. The official text says that covered persons « mettent en place une organisation et des procédures internes »
, and it extends the expectation to branches established outside France. See Légifrance, Article L562-4-1 CMF. For a group, the issue is not limited to the French parent’s central compliance manual. The process should explain how a French decision is communicated to subsidiaries, branches, treasury centres and shared-service teams that may execute the payment.
The next provision is often overstated. Article L562-5 CMF prohibits covered persons from making funds or economic resources available directly or indirectly, or using them for the benefit of persons whose funds or resources are subject to a statutory freeze. Its current text begins: « Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement »
. Read the whole provision on Légifrance, Article L562-5 CMF. The provision does not mean that every Russian sovereign asset is automatically a listed-person freeze. It means that once the relevant freezing measure applies, indirect benefit and use must be analysed as carefully as a direct transfer.
For a French company, the minimum file should contain the following evidence:
- Identity and ownership. Record the legal names, aliases, registration numbers, nationalities, addresses and beneficial owners of every relevant party. Capture the date and source of each search, because a list can change after the contract is signed.
- Control and representation. Verify who controls the counterparty, who gives payment instructions, who signs the contract and whether an agent is acting for another person. A new intermediary, nominee director or recently formed vehicle deserves an explanation, not automatic acceptance.
- Asset classification. Determine whether the balance is an operating account, a security, a sovereign reserve, a receivable, a dividend, interest, a frozen account credit or another economic resource. The legal outcome can differ even when the nominal amount is identical.
- Transaction purpose. Describe the goods, services, financing, guarantee, insurance, technical assistance or other performance. Check whether Regulation 833/2014 creates a sectoral or services prohibition independent of the name-screening result.
- Payment chain. Map every bank, correspondent, custodian, settlement system and third-country routing point. Do not assume that a payment is outside EU scope because it starts or ends outside France.
- Timing. Compare the signature date, performance date, listing date, freeze date, authorisation date and proposed settlement date. Rules on pre-existing contracts or judicial decisions may be relevant, but they do not operate without the conditions set by the applicable regulation.
- Authority and reporting. Identify the French competent authority, the required notification and any authorisation process. Keep the submission, the response and the internal legal opinion together with the transaction file.
- Non-circumvention analysis. Explain why the structure does not have the object or effect of making value available to a listed person or defeating a restriction. A clean screening result is not a substitute for that explanation.
The file should also distinguish a refusal based on a legal prohibition from a commercial decision to avoid risk. That distinction protects both sides of the contract. If a bank freezes funds under a regulation, it should identify the measure and preserve the notice. If a company merely pauses while requesting advice, it should say that the review is ongoing rather than asserting that a counterparty is unlawful. Defamatory or categorical language can create a second dispute, especially where the counterparty is not listed and the transaction is only connected to Russia through an intermediary.
The same discipline applies to an asset held through a central securities depository or a French financial institution. A company should ask whether the restraint concerns the underlying Russian principal, income produced by it, a listed intermediary, a transfer back to Russia, or a separate service prohibition. The answer controls the next step. It may be lawful to credit a frozen account while freezing the addition; it may be possible to pay reasonable legal fees under a derogation; it may be forbidden to make any value available to a listed person; or it may require a competent-authority authorisation. Those are different legal pathways and should not be combined in one generic “sanctions issue” email.
B. What happens if a Russian state entity seeks payment or enforcement in France?
A Russian state entity can present two different problems to a French company. It may claim that a contract requires payment, or it may try to enforce a judgment or arbitral award against an asset in France. A sanctions freeze does not erase the underlying contract, and a contractual claim does not automatically authorise payment. The company must analyse both the merits of the claim and the public-law restrictions that control performance. It should not release a balance merely because the counterparty produces a foreign judgment, and it should not assume that a freeze ends every judicial remedy available to the counterparty.
For enforcement against State property, Article L111-1-1 CPCE requires a judge’s prior authorisation. Article L111-1-2 CPCE sets the conditions under which that authorisation may be granted. A third safeguard appears in Article L111-1-3 CPCE, which protects property, including bank accounts, used or intended for the functions of a foreign diplomatic mission, consular posts, special missions or missions to international organisations. The text requires an express and special waiver by the State concerned; it states: « qu’en cas de renonciation expresse et spéciale des Etats concernés »
. See Légifrance, Article L111-1-3 CPCE.
The category of asset is decisive. A bank account used for a diplomatic mission is not analysed like a commercial account. A tax or social receivable is not analysed like a private-law investment. A central-bank reserve has its own public and sovereign character, even if the reserve is technically recorded through a private custodian. The French provisions cannot be transplanted mechanically to Belgium, but they show the type of evidence a court expects: account purpose, operational use, ownership, control, express waiver, connection with the claim and the exact relief requested.
The Court of cassation’s decision of 25 January 2005, No 03-18.176, is a useful illustration. The Court held that foreign States benefit in principle from enforcement immunity, but that the immunity may not apply when the seized asset is linked to a private-law economic, commercial or civil operation giving rise to the claim. In the Court’s words: « les Etats étrangers bénéficient, par principe, de l’immunité d’exécution »
. The decision is available from Légifrance. The outcome turned on the use of French real estate and condominium charges; it does not authorise seizure of sovereign reserves.
The 19 November 2008 judgment, No 07-10.570, likewise examined the difference between an act of sovereignty and a private-law management operation. Its exact official reference is Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 19 November 2008, No 07-10.570. It is helpful for a French company because it rejects an abstract answer based only on the foreign State’s identity. The asset’s function and the claim’s relationship to that asset remain central.
The 28 March 2013 judgment, No 11-13.323, is stricter where public-use property and waiver are concerned. The Court stated: « il ne peut y être renoncé que de manière expresse et spéciale »
, with the waiver identifying the property or category of property. See Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 28 March 2013, No 11-13.323. A broad clause in a financing document may therefore be insufficient if it does not clearly cover the public assets that a creditor seeks to attach.
The judgment of 3 February 2021, No 19-10.669, concerns diplomatic bank accounts, not central-bank reserves, but it explains why a financial intermediary must preserve evidence of use. The First Civil Chamber held that funds in diplomatic mission accounts are presumed to be allocated to the State’s sovereign mission, while allowing proof to the contrary. The official text says those funds are « présumés être affectés aux besoins de la mission de souveraineté »
. See Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 3 February 2021, No 19-10.669. This is an analogy, not a ruling about Russian reserves, but it demonstrates why labels, account names and operational evidence can become decisive.
More recent case law should also be read with care. In its judgment of 13 April 2023, No 18-20.915, the First Civil Chamber addressed enforcement immunity and the significance of the way State property is used. The official reference is Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 13 April 2023, No 18-20.915. A French company should use that decision, and the earlier authorities, to frame questions for counsel—not to claim that a French precedent has settled the Belgian litigation or the legality of an EU reparations loan.
There is a further procedural distinction between challenging a freeze and executing a private claim. A listed person may seek review of a listing or request a derogation. A contractual creditor may seek payment or recognition of a decision. A judgment creditor may seek an attachment. A bank or French company faced with one of those steps should ask which procedure is actually being used, which authority has power to release the funds, and whether the requested action would make funds available to a listed person. It should preserve the freeze while the legal question is answered, unless a competent authority orders a permitted release.
The company’s first response should be short and controlled. Acknowledge receipt, identify the account or contract, suspend the disputed movement if required, and request the legal documents and payment instructions. Do not promise a release date. Do not describe the funds as confiscated unless an applicable act says so. Do not forward the same instruction through a different bank or affiliate while a sanctions review is open. If a court order is provided, verify its issuing court, finality, scope, asset description, beneficiary and compatibility with the EU measure. If an arbitral award is provided, verify recognition and enforcement requirements in the competent jurisdiction.
Within the first 24 hours, the legal and compliance teams should capture the relevant versions of the EU regulations, the consolidated sanctions lists, the account ledger, the custody chain and the correspondence. Within 48 hours, they should produce a written decision tree: prohibited, permitted without authorisation, permitted only after authorisation, or unresolved and escalated. The file should name the decision-maker, the evidence relied upon and the next review date. If the European Council or Commission publishes a new instrument during that period, the team should compare its operative provisions with the existing freeze rather than relying on press headlines.
French enforcement law also makes it dangerous to give a categorical answer to a Russian State entity. The 2013 decision in No 11-13.323 shows that even a waiver may have to identify the relevant public asset. The 2021 decision in No 19-10.669 shows the importance of the presumption attached to sovereign mission funds. Article L111-1-3 CPCE gives a statutory form to that protection for diplomatic property. Those principles make a Russian claim difficult in some situations, but they do not eliminate the need to examine jurisdiction, immunity, sanctions, contract law, public policy and the identity of the asset.
Finally, a French company should separate its own exposure from the custodian’s exposure. A custodian may refuse to transfer a balance because a directly applicable EU regulation requires it to do so. The company may have a contractual claim against a counterparty, but that claim does not automatically override the custodian’s regulatory duty. Conversely, a custodian’s risk assessment is not a judicial finding that the company or its counterparty committed an offence. The strongest record is one that states the applicable rule, the facts established, the facts still unknown, the action taken and the route for review.
Conclusion
The four-country push reported on 27 August 2026 is significant because it brings the use of Russian immobilised assets back into the centre of the European financial and legal agenda. It does not, at this stage, turn the approximately €210 billion held in Europe into a freely transferable fund for Ukraine. The European Council’s existing framework keeps the assets immobilised, supports a €90 billion EU-backed loan and asks the institutions to continue the technical and legal work on a possible Reparations Loan. The Commission’s 27 August briefing also shows that the process remains politically fluid: the Commission said it had not yet received the letter while confirming that the issue remained on the agenda.
For French companies, the practical response is neither complacency nor a blanket refusal of every Russian-linked transaction. It is a documented classification exercise. Identify the person and the control chain; classify the asset; check Regulation 269/2014 and Regulation 833/2014; apply the French duties in Articles L562-4, L562-4-1 and L562-5 CMF; test for circumvention; and preserve the evidence. If a State entity seeks payment or enforcement, add the CPCE rules on authorisation and State immunity, then distinguish French analogies from the separate Belgian and EU dispute.
The legal position can change quickly when the Council, Parliament or Commission adopts a new act. A business that has preserved the ledger, custody trail, screening results, contract, waiver language and decision log will be able to respond to that change. A business that has treated “frozen” as synonymous with “confiscated,” or “Russian” as synonymous with “listed,” may discover too late that its first assumption was the real compliance risk.