KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Hand Luggage Rules 2027: Ryanair Fees, the Free Cabin Bag and Flights to France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Hand Luggage Rules 2027: Ryanair Fees, the Free Cabin Bag and Flights to France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 18 October 2026, British newspapers announced that Ryanair, easyJet, Wizz Air and other airlines had been given a date from which they must let passengers take two free bags into the cabin. According to Wales Online, which reported the story on the morning of 18 October 2026, the European Parliament and the Council approved the rule during the summer, the act was signed in September, published in the Official Journal in early October, and will apply from 23 October 2027. The Scottish outlet The National the same day added the detail that matters most to British readers: the rules apply inside the European Union, so a flight leaving the United Kingdom may still carry hand-luggage charges on the outbound leg even when the return leg from the EU is free.

The legal source behind these headlines is Regulation (EU) 2026/2202 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2026, a text that rewrites large parts of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 on air passenger rights and of Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 on carrier liability for baggage. Its Article 11a creates a new two-tier cabin-baggage regime: one personal item that is always free, and one cabin bag that the airline must accept subject to the space available in the cabin, with fares displayed inclusive of that cabin bag before the booking starts. For travellers flying from London, Manchester or Edinburgh to Paris, Nice or Lyon, the decisive question is narrower than the headlines suggest: does this European text cover your exact flight, and what can you already claim today, before October 2027, when an airline charges you at the gate? This article answers both questions. Its first part explains what the new European hand-luggage law truly grants, with the exact dimensions and the exact conditions. Its second part deals with the British situation in practice: which flights between the United Kingdom and France fall inside the new regime, why some do not, and how to enforce your rights before the French authorities and courts when a fee was wrongly charged.

I. EU hand luggage rules 2027: what Ryanair and easyJet must let you take for free

The reform does not abolish baggage fees in general. It creates two distinct legal objects, gives one of them an unconditional free status, protects the other with a conditional right, and forces airlines to show prices that already include the cabin bag. Understanding the boundary between the two objects is what decides whether a fee debited at the airport has to be repaid.

A. How big is the free personal item: the 40x30x15 cm rule and the cabin bag beside it

The regulation defines an “effet personnel” (personal item) as “un bagage non enregistré qui respecte les exigences en matière de sûreté et de sécurité, et soit dont les dimensions ne dépassent pas 40 × 30 × 15 cm, soit dont la taille lui permet d’être placé sous le siège qui se trouve devant le siège sur lequel le passager est assis” (unregistered baggage which complies with the applicable safety and security requirements and either measures no more than 40 × 30 × 15 cm or fits under the seat in front of the passenger seat). The twin test matters: a soft bag that slides under the seat qualifies even if its shape differs slightly from the centimetre figures, while a rigid case above those figures does not. The “bagage à main” (cabin bag) is then defined as the remainder: “une pièce de bagage non enregistrée qui ne constitue pas un effet personnel et qui respecte les exigences en matière de sûreté et de sécurité” (one piece of unregistered baggage which is not a personal item and which complies with the applicable safety and security requirements). In plain terms, the small backpack or handbag under the seat is the free personal item, and the small wheeled suitcase for the overhead locker is the cabin bag.

Article 11a(1) gives the personal item the stronger protection: “les transporteurs aériens effectifs autorisent les passagers à emporter un effet personnel dans la cabine sans frais supplémentaires” (operating air carriers shall allow passengers to carry a personal item in the cabin without additional charge). The term “transporteur aérien effectif” (operating carrier) designates the airline that actually performs the flight, as opposed to the airline that sold the ticket under a code-share. No capacity exception, no fare exception and no loyalty-status exception accompanies this sentence: from the date of application, charging for a compliant personal item becomes unlawful on every covered flight.

The cabin bag receives a real but conditional right: “les transporteurs aériens effectifs autorisent les passagers, sous réserve de la capacité de la cabine de l’aéronef, à emporter un bagage à main dans la cabine” (operating air carriers shall allow passengers, subject to the capacity of the aircraft cabin, to carry a cabin bag in the cabin). Two consequences follow. First, an airline cannot sell a fare that excludes the cabin bag as a matter of principle; the bag is part of what the passenger is entitled to bring, and only the physical limits of the cabin can displace it. Second, when those limits genuinely bite, for instance after a last-minute change of aircraft to a smaller type, paragraph 2 provides the fallback: “Lorsque des motifs particuliers, tels que des motifs liés à la sécurité, des motifs liés à la capacité ou un changement de type d’aéronef postérieurement à la réservation, empêchent d’emporter dans la cabine un effet personnel ou un bagage à main visé au paragraphe 1, le transporteur aérien effectif peut exiger à l’enregistrement ou à la porte d’embarquement, selon le cas, que ces bagages non enregistrés soient transportés dans la soute de l’aéronef, mais sans frais supplémentaires pour le passager” (Where specific reasons, such as safety or capacity reasons or a change of aircraft type after booking, prevent a personal item or cabin bag referred to in paragraph 1 from being carried in the cabin, the operating carrier may require at check-in or at the boarding gate, as appropriate, that such unregistered baggage be carried in the aircraft hold, but at no additional cost to the passenger). A bag moved to the hold for lack of room must therefore travel free; any hold fee charged in that situation contradicts the text.

The regulation deliberately leaves the maximum size of the cabin bag itself to the airlines for now, asking only for restraint: “les transporteurs aériens devraient définir une politique raisonnable en ce qui concerne les dimensions des bagages à main de manière à permettre aux passagers de prendre en cabine un bagage à main, sous réserve de la capacité de la cabine de l’aéronef, pour autant que le bagage à main respecte les exigences applicables opérationnelles, en matière de sûreté et de sécurité” (air carriers should define a reasonable policy on cabin-bag dimensions so as to allow passengers to take a cabin bag into the cabin, subject to cabin capacity, provided the bag meets the applicable operational, safety and security requirements). Passengers must also be told the limits before paying: the recitals require travellers to be informed at booking of the maximum dimensions and weight of what they may bring into the cabin. Until the 2027 date, the size printed in each airline’s conditions of carriage therefore remains the reference, and measuring the bag against those conditions before leaving for the airport remains the safest habit.

The calendar is fixed by the final article of the regulation: “Il est applicable à partir du 23 octobre 2027” (It shall apply from 23 October 2027), after signature recorded as “Fait à Strasbourg, le 16 septembre 2026” (Done at Strasbourg, 16 September 2026). Nothing changes at the airport before that date, a point the British press correctly stressed: allowances printed on tickets sold today remain governed by today’s law, which is the subject of the next paragraphs.

That current law already limits what airlines may charge, thanks to the Court of Justice. In its Vueling judgment of 18 September 2014 (case C-487/12), the Court of Justice held that cabin baggage must in principle be treated as an essential part of passenger carriage, so no price supplement may be charged for a bag that meets reasonable weight and size requirements and complies with the applicable security rules. A fee for a small, reasonably sized cabin bag is therefore already vulnerable today before the courts of any Member State, including France. The 2026 regulation does not invent the free bag from nothing; it codifies and extends a decade-old judicial principle, adds the precisely measured personal item, and attaches the price-display duty described below. Travellers who paid a cabin-bag supplement recently should keep the receipt, because the Vueling reasoning is the legal ground on which a refund can already be demanded, while the 2027 text will make the same claim simpler to win.

B. Why fares must now include the cabin bag before you click book

The second pillar of the reform answers the complaint every low-cost passenger knows: a headline fare of twenty-nine euros that becomes sixty at checkout once the cabin bag is added. The regulation provides: “Lorsque des tarifs aériens sont proposés ou publiés, les tarifs aériens autorisant un bagage à main sont affichés par défaut avant le début de toute procédure de réservation” (Where air fares are offered or published, air fares allowing a cabin bag shall be displayed by default before the start of any booking procedure). Comparison sites and intermediaries are bound by the same default, and the recitals state the purpose openly: “les passagers devraient pouvoir comparer plus facilement les tarifs aériens qui incluent les bagages à main (un bagage de cabine)” (passengers should be able to compare more easily air fares that include cabin baggage), with a duty imposed on “les transporteurs aériens, les intermédiaires et les méta-moteurs de recherche de toujours afficher par défaut le tarif aérien incluant un bagage à main avant le début de toute procédure de réservation” (air carriers, intermediaries and metasearch engines always to display by default the air fare including a cabin bag before the start of any booking procedure). The European Parliament summary of the political agreement describes the same core rule: one personal item such as a small bag or backpack travels free of charge. Airlines remain free to sell a cheaper ticket to volunteers travelling light, since “Ce paragraphe n’empêche pas les transporteurs aériens ou les intermédiaires de proposer des offres commercialement différenciées aux passagers qui choisissent volontairement de voyager sans bagage à main” (This paragraph does not prevent air carriers or intermediaries from offering commercially differentiated deals to passengers who voluntarily choose to travel without a cabin bag). The difference is one of presentation: the no-bag fare becomes the opt-in discount, and the with-bag fare becomes the displayed reference.

This display duty extends a rule that already exists. Article 23(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1008/2008 on air services already requires that “Le prix définitif à payer est précisé à tout moment et inclut le tarif des passagers ou le tarif de fret applicable ainsi que l’ensemble des taxes, des redevances, des suppléments et des droits applicables inévitables et prévisibles à la date de publication” (The final price to be paid shall be specified at all times and shall include the applicable passenger or freight fare as well as all applicable taxes, charges, surcharges and fees which are unavoidable and foreseeable at the time of publication), and that “Les suppléments de prix optionnels sont communiqués de façon claire, transparente et non équivoque au début de toute procédure de réservation et leur acceptation par le client résulte d’une démarche explicite” (Optional price supplements shall be communicated in a clear, transparent and unambiguous way at the start of any booking process, and acceptance by the customer shall result from an explicit step). Pre-ticked boxes adding luggage or priority boarding therefore already breach European law on departures from the EU, and screenshots of such boxes are evidence worth keeping. The pricing freedom of airlines, recalled by Article 22 of the same regulation, “les transporteurs aériens communautaires et, sur la base de la réciprocité, les transporteurs aériens des pays tiers fixent librement les tarifs des passagers et les tarifs de fret pour les services aériens intracommunautaires” (Community air carriers and, on the basis of reciprocity, third-country carriers freely set passenger fares and freight rates for intra-Community air services), survives the reform untouched: carriers choose their prices, but they must show them honestly and cannot make the Vueling-protected cabin bag disappear from the displayed fare.

Two practical abuses are outlawed alongside the baggage rules and deserve mention because they strike the same passengers at the same airports. Boarding-pass fees disappear: “Les passagers ne sont pas refusés à l’embarquement au motif qu’ils ne se sont pas acquittés d’un supplément de frais pour pouvoir utiliser leur propre version imprimée d’une carte d’embarquement délivrée numériquement” (Passengers shall not be denied boarding on the ground that they have not paid an additional fee to be able to use their own printed version of a digitally issued boarding pass), and a home-printed pass is valid where “elle soit imprimée clairement et qu’elle soit lisible par machine” (it is printed clearly and is machine-readable). Name-spelling corrections are free as well. Families gain adjacent seating for children under fourteen without extra charge. These satellite rights share the logic of the baggage right: the ticket price must cover the normal performance of the carriage, and extras can only pay for genuinely optional services.

II. Flying from the United Kingdom to France: does the free bag apply to you

A British reader planning a weekend in Paris faces three distinct situations, and the answer differs in each. The 2026 regulation draws its territorial lines in the amended scope of Regulation 261/2004: it covers “aux passagers au départ d’un aéroport situé sur le territoire d’un État membre auquel les traités s’appliquent” (passengers departing from an airport located in the territory of a Member State to which the Treaties apply), whatever the nationality of the carrier, and it also covers “aux passagers au départ d’un aéroport situé dans un pays tiers et à destination d’un aéroport situé sur le territoire d’un État membre auquel les traités s’appliquent, à moins que ces passagers ne bénéficient de prestations, d’une indemnisation et d’une assistance dans ce pays tiers qui sont équivalentes et correspondent aux fins du présent règlement, si le transporteur aérien effectif qui réalise le vol concerné est un transporteur aérien de l’Union” (passengers departing from an airport in a third country to an airport in the territory of a Member State to which the Treaties apply, unless those passengers received equivalent benefits, compensation and assistance in that third country, if the operating carrier of the flight concerned is a Union carrier). Since Brexit, the United Kingdom is such a “pays tiers” (third country), and the “transporteur aérien de l’Union” (Union carrier) condition decides the fate of the London to Paris leg.

A. London to Paris with Ryanair or easyJet: which flights are covered and the UK catch

A Paris to London flight is always covered, on any airline: it departs from an airport on Member State territory, so the first branch of the scope rule applies and the carrier’s nationality is irrelevant. A passenger boarding at Paris-Charles de Gaulle with one personal item and one cabin bag will therefore, from 23 October 2027, be protected against any charge for the personal item and against any systematic charge for the cabin bag, and will see with-bag fares displayed by default. This is the straightforward case, and it is also the one French enforcement authorities will police, as explained below.

A London to Paris flight is covered only if the operating carrier is a Union carrier. Ryanair’s operating companies are Irish, hence Union carriers, so a Ryanair flight from London Stansted to Paris Beauvais falls inside the regulation once applicable, and the free personal item travels with the passenger in both directions. The situation requires concrete verification for other low-cost tickets: the airline group named on the advertisement is not always the company that operates the aircraft, and a flight number or ticket code does not by itself prove which legal entity performs the flight. The booking confirmation and the conditions of carriage name the operating carrier, and only that document answers the question reliably. Where the operating carrier is established in the United Kingdom and the flight departs from a British airport, the European regulation does not apply to that leg, even though the destination is Paris.

The British domestic regime explains why this gap matters. Under the United Kingdom’s retained passenger-rights rules, as summarised in the official government travel guide, protection covers flights that leave a British airport on any airline, flights that land in the United Kingdom on a British or EU airline, and by extension the mirror situations on the European side. The retained rules reproduce the delay, cancellation and baggage-liability protections, but they do not contain the new free personal item or the default with-bag fare display, because London has not adopted the 2026 reform. The “catch” flagged by The National is therefore exact: on a London to Paris ticket sold by a non-Union operating carrier, the outbound cabin-bag fee remains lawful after 2027, while the Paris to London return on the same reservation, departing from EU territory, is governed by the European text. Two legs, one reservation, two legal regimes: the departure airport, not the passenger’s passport, decides.

Until 23 October 2027, none of this helps at the check-in desk, and the advice for this winter and next summer stays practical. Measure the bag against the allowance printed in the fare conditions, photograph the bag in the airline’s sizing frame if staff contest it, keep every receipt for a supplement paid at the gate, and contest pre-ticked luggage options with a screenshot, since Article 23 of Regulation 1008/2008 already requires an explicit opt-in. The Vueling case law described in the first part supplies the legal ground for a refund claim on a cabin-bag fee charged for a reasonably sized bag, and the French enforcement route below shows where to file it. For the general picture, an earlier guide explains the EU free cabin bag rules, size limits and how to claim on Ryanair flights to France.

B. How to claim in France: the DGAC complaint, the refund of unlawful fees and the French courts

France enforces European passenger rights through the civil aviation authority, the Direction générale de l’aviation civile. The official service-public.fr procedure states the two-step path: it provides a form for travellers whose airline refused compensation or stayed silent, and it requires a prior written complaint to the company before the authority can act. The sequence is therefore rigid: written complaint to the airline first, keeping proof of sending, then the DGAC online form if the carrier refuses or stays silent. A claim filed with the DGAC without that prior step is inadmissible, and many passengers lose months by reversing the order. The DGAC route also covers amounts beyond baggage, such as the standardised lump-sum compensation for cancellations and long delays under the linked Regulation 261/2004, which no airline term can remove.

Before the courts, French judges draw a clear line that travellers should understand, because it decides which receipts are refundable and which are not. Surcharges that correspond to a service genuinely outside the ticket, such as an extra checked bag or overweight hold luggage accepted in the contract, are enforced as written. The tribunal judiciaire of Clermont-Ferrand confirmed this on 11 July 2025 in a dispute between a passenger and Air France over 220 euros for a third checked bag and 375 euros for overweight bags: the court verified the conditions of carriage, found the supplements contractually due, and rejected the repayment claim. The same judgment recalls the two civil-code provisions that frame every refund action: “tout paiement suppose une dette ; ce qui a été reçu sans être dû est sujet à restitution” (Every payment presupposes a debt; what was received without being due is subject to restitution), the répétition de l’indu (repayment of an undue payment), and “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer” (Any act of man which causes damage to another obliges the person by whose fault it occurred to repair it), the general fault liability that can support a damages claim where the airline’s conduct was wrongful.

Cabin-bag fees belong on the other side of that line whenever the bag was reasonably sized, and French consumer law supplies the lever. Article L212-1 of the Code de la consommation treats as unfair any term where “sont abusives les clauses qui ont pour objet ou pour effet de créer, au détriment du consommateur, un déséquilibre significatif entre les droits et obligations des parties au contrat” (terms are unfair which have the object or effect of creating, to the detriment of the consumer, a significant imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties), and Article L241-1 adds the sanction: “Les clauses abusives sont réputées non écrites” (Unfair terms are deemed unwritten). A standard term that makes the passenger pay extra for the very cabin bag the Vueling judgment calls an essential element of carriage creates exactly that imbalance, and a French court can therefore strike the term and order restitution of the fee under Article 1302. The practical file is simple to assemble: the booking confirmation showing the fare, the airline’s baggage conditions, the gate receipt, a photograph of the bag with its dimensions, and a copy of the prior written complaint. Small claims of this type fall within the jurisdiction of the tribunal judiciaire of the passenger’s domicile for a consumer contract, and the DGAC complaint can run in parallel as administrative pressure.

Lost, damaged or delayed baggage obeys a different regime that travellers often confuse with the fee question. The tribunal judiciaire of Poitiers recalled on 4 July 2025 that the Montreal Convention of 28 May 1999 applies in France and that its Article 17 makes the carrier liable for “du dommage survenu en cas de destruction, perte ou avarie de bagages enregistrés, par cela seul que le fait qui a causé la destruction, la perte ou l’avarie s’est produit à bord de l’aéronef ou au cours de toute période durant laquelle le transporteur avait la garde des bagages enregistrés” (damage sustained in the event of destruction, loss or damage to checked baggage, by the mere fact that the event which caused it took place on board the aircraft or during any period in which the carrier had custody of the checked baggage). The same court applied the Convention’s ceiling, then 1,288 special drawing rights per passenger following the Walz judgment of the Court of Justice, and ordered payment of the proven shortfall. Readers facing a hold-baggage loss will find the full protest procedure and the current ceiling explained in the related guide on checked baggage that was lost, damaged or delivered late. The distinction to remember is clean: fees concern what the passenger pays to bring the bag, liability concerns what the carrier pays when it loses or breaks it, and each follows its own text.

Conclusion

From 23 October 2027, European law gives every passenger on a covered flight a free personal item of up to 40 × 30 × 15 cm, a conditional right to a cabin bag that can only be displaced by genuine lack of cabin space and then travels free in the hold, and fares displayed with the cabin bag included before booking starts. Paris departures are covered on every airline; London departures are covered only on Union operating carriers, which leaves a visible gap for British travellers that no headline should hide. Until the new text applies, the Vueling judgment already protects reasonably sized cabin bags, the opt-in rule of Article 23 already polices checkout boxes, and the French route runs from a written complaint to the airline, to the DGAC form, to the consumer unfair-terms action for a refund. Travellers who keep their receipts, photograph their bags and complain in writing first hold every card the law deals them, in 2026 as in 2027.

📄 Official circular