On 11 February 2026, the General Court of the European Union in Luxembourg handed down a judgment that sanctions lawyers had been waiting years to read in “Maya Tokareva v Council.” Decided on 11 February 2026 as Case T-693/25, it annulled the Council’s decision to put Maya Tokareva, the daughter of Transneft chief executive Nikolay Tokarev, back on the European Union’s Russia sanctions list in September 2025. What makes the ruling historic is not the delisting itself. It is the ground. For the first time in European sanctions practice, the Court held expressly that the Council had breached Article 266 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union by relisting a person without curing the defects the same Court had already identified three times before. As one sanctions commentary put it, the Court found that the Council had relisted Maya Tokareva “without remedying the procedural deficiencies,” a failure the judges treated as a breach of the binding duty to give effect to judicial decisions. Seven months later, on 2 September 2026, the Eighth Chamber confirmed the direction of travel in Case T-799/25, annulling the same September 2025 acts plus the March 2026 maintenance acts “in so far as the name” of Ms Pumpyanskaya “was maintained on the list.” Two chambers, two family-member cases, one message: copy-paste relisting no longer survives judicial review.
For anyone with money, securities, real estate or business interests frozen in France, this shift matters immediately. France is where many EU listings bite hardest in practice: Paris banks freeze accounts overnight, the Treasury enforces, and French courts have so far mostly upheld the enforcement machinery, from the Conseil d’Etat’s 2023 ruling on the publication of frozen property owners to the Paris administrative appeal court’s 2024 confirmation of a ministerial freeze order. The Tokareva line of cases does not dismantle that machinery. It gives listed persons and their families a sharper weapon to attack the listing itself in Luxembourg, and a clearer path to force French banks and authorities to unfreeze once Luxembourg has spoken. This article explains what the Court actually decided, why the family-association criterion failed, how freezes operate on French soil, and what concrete steps a listed person with French assets should take now.
I. Why the Luxembourg judges annulled Maya Tokareva’s relisting
A. Three annulments the Council chose to ignore: can a listing be renewed without new evidence?
Maya Tokareva’s file is a case study in administrative persistence. She was first listed under Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014, the instrument that freezes the funds of persons associated with the violation of Ukraine’s territorial integrity. The reason given for her listing was family: she is the daughter of Nikolay Tokarev, described by the Council as the head of Transneft, a large Russian oil and gas company. She challenged the listing, and she won, repeatedly. On 11 September 2024, in Tokareva v Council (T-744/22, EU:T:2024:608), the Court annulled “les actes de septembre 2022” and the March and September 2023 acts as regards the applicant, while rejecting her damages claim. A second victory followed: A second victory followed on 26 February 2025 in Tokareva v Council (T-269/24, EU:T:2025:179), annulling “les actes de mars et septembre 2024” with the same rejection of damages. Then a third: Then a third: on 2 September 2025, the Court “annulé les actes de mars 2025” in Tokareva v Council (T-295/25, EU:T:2025:835). Three final annulments, each finding that the evidence did not support the listing, plus two rejected damages claims that left the compensation question aside.
Between those rulings, Tokareva’s lawyers wrote to the Council, in March 2025 and again in September 2025, asking it to implement the judgments. The Council’s answer, recorded in the February 2026 ruling, was striking on two levels. First, it argued that no implementation was needed at all: once the Court annuls a listing act, the act disappears from the legal order as if it had never existed, so annulment is self-executing and Article 266 TFEU requires nothing more. Second, and in tension with the first argument, it said it was still studying the 2024 and 2025 judgments to cure the defects, that this work was unfinished when the September 2025 relisting was adopted, and that the freeze had to be maintained in the meantime because lifting it would let Tokareva move her funds beyond the reach of future measures. In short: the judgments needed no execution, but the Council also needed more time to execute them, and the applicant should stay listed meanwhile.
The Fifth Chamber rejected that reasoning root and branch. The Court recalled the controlling principle in terms worth quoting exactly: Under Article 266 TFEU, the institution behind the annulled act must take “les mesures que comporte l’exécution” of the annulling judgment. An annulment judgment, the Court stressed, carries absolute res judicata covering not only the operative part but also the essential reasons supporting it, citing Interporc v Commission and Kaddour v Council. Applied to restrictive measures, that means the Council must re-examine the file and either relist on the basis of new reasons established to the requisite legal standard, or walk away. Maintaining a name on the list while admitting the cure is still under study is precisely what Article 266 forbids. The Court therefore annulled Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 of 12 September 2025 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894 of 12 September 2025 “réinscrit sur la liste” of persons and entities subject to the restrictive measures, rejected the Council’s request to keep the effects alive pending appeal, and ordered the Council to bear its own costs and Tokareva’s. The full text is published on EUR-Lex under Case T-693/25 on InfoCuria, and the duty to comply flows from Article 266 TFEU.
The practical consequence reaches far beyond one file. Every relisting adopted without fresh evidence after a final annulment is now vulnerable to the same plea, and Council legal services know it. The September 2026 Pumpyanskaya ruling, handed down as the Eighth Chamber’s judgment of 2 September 2026 in Case T-799/25 concerning Galina Evgenyevna Pumpyanskaya, a Dubai resident, annulled the very same September 2025 instruments, this time together with the March 2026 maintenance acts, Council Decision (CFSP) 2026/696 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/695. The case file is published on InfoCuria (Case T-799/25). Readers who want the Pumpyanskaya facts in detail can consult our companion analysis of the Pumpyanskaya freeze and the French enforcement angle; the present article focuses on the Tokareva precedent that made that outcome possible.
B. Being a daughter is not a listing criterion: how the Court reads benefitting from a leading businessperson
The Council’s substantive case against Tokareva rested on Article 2(1)(g) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP, the family-association criterion covering persons benefitting from leading businesspersons operating in Russia. The headnote of the judgment frames the dispute exactly that way: framed around the “re-inclusion of the applicant’s name,” the meaning of “benefitting from a leading businessperson” under Article 2(1)(g) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP, error of assessment and Article 266 TFEU. The statement of reasons asserted that described as “la fille de Nikolay Tokarev,” the head of Transneft, a large Russian oil and gas company, adding that she and her former husband owned luxury real estate in Moscow, Latvia and Croatia worth more than 50 million US dollars that could be linked to her father, that she had ties to the company Ronin, which manages the Transneft pension fund, that she had given the Ronin Europe address when applying for Cypriot citizenship, and that she was connected to the Ronin Trust through her property company. The conclusion drawn was that she was a close family member of an influential businessman and benefited from him.
The Court’s answer is a lesson in the difference between an intelligence narrative and legal proof. A family tie opens the inquiry; it does not close it. Under criterion (g), the Council must establish, with sufficiently concrete evidence, that the listed person actually benefits from the businessperson’s position, not merely that she shares his surname, lives in expensive property, or appears in the same corporate nebula. Luxury real estate “that could be linked” to the father is language of suspicion, not demonstration. Administrative links to a pension-fund manager, an address used in a citizenship application years earlier, and shareholdings routed through property companies show proximity, not benefit. The Court had already found the file too thin in 2024 and early 2025, and the Council returned in September 2025 with the same file. That is why the error-of-assessment finding and the Article 266 finding reinforce each other: the Council not only assessed the evidence wrongly, it repeated an assessment already judged wrongful, without the new material that settled case law from Kaddour to Haswani requires before any relisting.
Two clarifications matter for families in the same position. First, the judgment does not outlaw the family criterion itself. Criterion (g) remains valid EU law, and a relisting supported by genuinely new evidence of financial benefit, transfers, or shared control of assets could survive. The Court polices the proof, not the policy. Second, Tokareva lost her damages claims twice: annulment restores legality, but compensation for an unlawful listing requires a separate showing of a sufficiently serious breach causing quantifiable loss, a threshold the Court found unmet. Delisting is now materially easier to obtain in repeat cases; damages remain the harder fight. Anyone considering litigation should therefore frame the action around annulment first, with the Article 263 TFEU two-month time limit running from notification or publication, and treat damages as a possible second stage rather than the main prize.
II. What the judgment changes for money and property frozen in France
A. In France the freeze still bites first: banks, the Treasury and judges who uphold enforcement
Winning in Luxembourg and recovering assets in France are two different battles, and the second starts from a position of strength for the authorities. EU regulations are directly applicable in France, so the moment a name appears in the Official Journal, every French bank, insurer, notary and company must freeze without waiting for any French decree. French domestic law then layers its own machinery on top. The definitions sit in Article L. 562-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code, which defines funds in deliberately cast-iron terms, from cash and deposits to insurance surrender values, claims and financial instruments. The national freeze power sits in Article L. 562-2 of the Monetary and Financial Code: “Le ministre chargé de l’économie et le ministre de l’intérieur peuvent décider, conjointement, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques” belonging to persons who commit, facilitate or finance terrorism. Alongside it, Article L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code allows the economy minister alone to freeze, again for six renewable months, funds linked to persons designated under United Nations Chapter VII resolutions or acts adopted under Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union or Article 75 TFEU, the very legal bases of the Russia sanctions. The compliance burden then falls on the private sector through Article L. 562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code: “Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation” all persons on national territory, banks and supervised entities, French companies for their foreign operations, and foreign companies for their French operations. And Article L. 562-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code closes the circle: “Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel”. In practice, that means the account is blocked on publication day, the bank files its report to the minister, and any payment, however routine, becomes a potential offence.
French judges have consistently backed this enforcement architecture. The leading illustration is the Conseil d’Etat’s ruling of 7 April 2023, CE, 9th-10th chambers combined, No 465879, which concerned Decree No 2022-815 of 16 May 2022 publishing the list of companies owning real estate frozen under Regulation No 269/2014. Three property companies asked the court “d’annuler pour excès de pouvoir le décret n° 2022-815 du 16 mai 2022 relatif à la publication de la liste des personnes morales propriétaires des biens immobiliers faisant l’objet des mesures de gel prises en application du règlement UE n° 269/2014 du Conseil du 17 mars 2014”. The court rejected the claim outright: “La requête de la société 33 rue de l’Université et autres est rejetée.” Transparency about frozen villas and Paris apartments, the court held in effect, is part of enforcement, not a disproportionate add-on. A year later, the Paris administrative appeal court confirmed the same severity at the individual level: in CAA Paris, 11 October 2024, No 23PA04050, the applicant had asked the Paris administrative tribunal to annul “l’arrêté du 13 juillet 2021 par lequel le ministre de l’économie, des finances et de la relance a ordonné une mesure de gel d’avoirs portant sur les fonds et ressources économiques lui appartenant ou détenus par elle.” The tribunal had rejected the claim in July 2023, and the court of appeal agreed: “La requête de M. A… I… est rejetée.” Costs followed the loser under Article L. 761-1 of the Administrative Justice Code, the standard provision that the judge orders the party liable for costs, or failing that the losing party, to pay the other side a sum for expenses outside court costs.
Creditors tempted to seize frozen assets in France face an equally strict wall, as the Cour de cassation confirmed in a widely noted 2022 ruling on Libyan funds. The First Civil Chamber held that EU Regulation No 2016/44 on Libya, combined with Article L. 211-2 of the Civil Enforcement Procedures Code, bars any enforcement against frozen funds that would remove them from the debtor’s estate or grant the pursuing creditor even a simple preference right, absent “l’autorisation préalable du directeur du Trésor,” the nationally designated authority, an interpretation the Court deemed indispensable to the effectiveness of the restrictions. The ruling, Cass. 1st civ., 7 September 2022, No 19-25.108, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2022:C100614, published in the Bulletin, quashed a Paris appeal judgment that had allowed enforcement against Libyan Investment Authority assets and confirmed the Paris enforcement judge instead. It had stayed proceedings to ask Luxembourg for guidance, and after the CJEU answered the referred question in “l’arrêt C-340/20” of 11 November 2021. Costs there were handled under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure, under which the losing party pays the other side’s non-recoverable costs. The lesson for holders of frozen Russian assets in France is symmetrical: neither the debtor’s bank nor the debtor’s creditors can move the funds without the competent authority, and French courts will enforce that standstill even at the expense of foreign creditors unconnected with the underlying wrongdoing.
B. How to turn a Luxembourg annulment into a French unfreezing: the procedure that now works
The system described above explains why the Tokareva precedent is such a practical breakthrough. French enforcement is rigorous but derivative: banks freeze because the EU list says so, and the minister maintains because the EU list says so. Remove the name from the EU list and the entire French pyramid loses its foundation. The action for annulment under Article 263 TFEU, brought before the General Court within two months of the listing’s notification or publication, is therefore the master key. Tokareva shows what a well-run challenge looks like: contest each six-month maintenance act separately so that every renewal is before the Court, write to the Council to demand implementation after each victory, and, when the Council relists on identical grounds, plead Article 266 TFEU front and centre alongside the error of assessment. The Pumpyanskaya sequel proves the template travels: same contested September 2025 acts, same family-benefit criterion in Article 2(1)(g) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP and Article 3(1)(g) of Regulation No 269/2014, same outcome. Where the Council once calculated that relisting cost it nothing, it must now calculate that a reasoned relisting requires fresh investigative work within each six-month cycle, a far heavier burden across hundreds of names.
Once the General Court annuls, the French unfreezing follows a predictable sequence, but each step needs active pursuit rather than passive expectation. First, the bank: send the judgment to the bank’s sanctions-compliance department with a formal demand to lift the freeze on the accounts concerned, keeping in mind that cautious banks sometimes wait for the Official Journal update removing the name. Second, the Treasury: the Directorate General of the Treasury administers the national register of freezes, and a reasoned request attaching the judgment accelerates the update that banks rely on. Third, the property layer: where the freeze caught Paris apartments or Riviera villas, the publication machinery examined in the 2023 Conseil d’Etat case works in reverse, and notaries and land registries need the updated status before any transaction can proceed. Fourth, parallel French litigation: while the Luxembourg action runs, a challenge to any purely national implementing measure, such as a ministerial freeze order of the kind the Paris court reviewed in the October 2024 case, can be brought before the administrative tribunal, though applicants should expect the French judge to follow the EU listing closely and should coordinate both tracks through one counsel. Our broader analysis of ownership and control disputes after the Court of Justice’s 2026 clarification, in the Inter Rao Lietuva ruling of 3 September 2026, covers the neighbouring battlefield of trusts and corporate control, which often decides cases where the family criterion fails.
Three warnings complete the picture. First, limitation periods are unforgiving: each maintenance act restarts its own two-month clock, and missing one renewal leaves the freeze in place for another semester even while an earlier challenge succeeds. Second, the Council can still win relistings the hard way, with genuinely new bank records, transfer documents or proof of shared enjoyment of assets, so listed families should use the annulment window to document the separation of patrimonies, independent income and arm’s-length transactions rather than assuming the file is closed. Third, damages remain exceptional: Tokareva’s compensation claims were rejected in both the 2024 and 2025 judgments, and French law offers no shortcut around that EU position. The realistic objective is delisting plus the rapid, documented unfreezing of French accounts, securities and property, with interest and losses preserved as a second-stage claim only where the file supports it. For families, executives and trustees caught in the Russia sanctions net with assets in France, the months after Tokareva and Pumpyanskaya are the most favourable litigation window since 2022, and it will not stay open indefinitely.
Conclusion
The Tokareva judgment of 11 February 2026 rewrites the economics of EU sanctions litigation. By holding for the first time that relisting without curing prior defects breaches Article 266 TFEU, the General Court turned the Council’s routine of semi-annual renewals from a cost-free habit into a justiciable obligation to produce new evidence each cycle. The Pumpyanskaya annulment of 2 September 2026 shows the precedent biting on the very next file. In France, where banks freeze on publication day under Articles L. 562-4 and L. 562-5, where the Conseil d’Etat upheld the publication of frozen property owners in 2023 and the Paris court confirmed a ministerial freeze in 2024, and where even creditors cannot touch frozen funds without the Treasury’s prior authorisation, the Luxembourg annulment is the only key that opens every French lock at once. Listed persons with French assets should therefore treat the coming renewal cycles as litigation deadlines: file in Luxembourg within two months, plead Article 266 alongside the substance, and drive the French unfreezing with the judgment in hand. The Council can still list on solid proof. What it can no longer do is list on a memory.