On 23 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union (Fourth Chamber) annulled two sanctions retentions against former Russian senator Oleg Polikarpovich Tkach: the September 2024 and September 2025 acts keeping his name on the Ukraine-related restrictive-measures lists (Tkach v Council, T-584/24, ECLI:EU:T:2026:584). The Court found an error of assessment: a man who left the Federation Council in 2022, withdrew from Russian political life and acquired two new nationalities barring him from Russian office could not be kept listed on the strength of a 2022 vote and a missing public stance against the war. The case was heard on 25 February 2026, in French as the language of the case, and decided by the Fourth Chamber. For banks, counterparties and listed persons dealing with frozen funds in France, the judgment is a practical manual: what an annulment actually unlocks, what it leaves frozen, and how French courts treat the freeze in contracts and criminal enforcement. This analysis explains the ruling and its concrete consequences for assets held in France.
I. Who is Oleg Tkach and why did the General Court annul his listing
A. From the Federation Council to the sanctions list: the 2022 listing and the 2024-2025 retentions
Oleg Polikarpovich Tkach sat in Russia’s Federation Council from 2004 to 2022 and was first listed on 9 March 2022, in the wave of designations that followed the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The listing criterion at issue appears in Article 2(1)(a) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP and Article 3(1)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 269/2014: in substance, persons responsible for, supporting or implementing actions undermining Ukraine’s territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence. The criterion looks backwards and forwards at once: past responsibility can justify listing, but each six-month retention must be justified afresh on current grounds, with evidence, not memory. A vote cast in February 2022 does not freeze in time; the Council must show why it still matters in September 2024. The September 2024 retention acts, Decision (CFSP) 2024/2456 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2455, both of 12 September 2024, relied on his former senatorial status and on his vote of 22 February 2022 ratifying the treaties with the Donetsk and Luhansk separatist entities. The action for annulment was lodged on 13 November 2024 and heard on 25 February 2026.
The September 2024 statement of reasons, based on the fourth evidence file transmitted in June 2024, combined three elements: former membership of the Federation Council, the February 2022 ratification vote, and the applicant’s position as director and founder of the OLMA publishing house, concluding that he supported and implemented actions threatening Ukraine. That publishing link would become the centre of the September 2025 round, but at this stage the file already showed its limits: a past mandate, a past vote and a cultural business, with no dated evidence of current support for the war effort.
The Council then maintained the listing twice more on the same file. By the March 2025 acts, Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/527, both of 14 March 2025, the Council kept his name on the lists on the same grounds as in September 2024. The applicant adapted his claims on 15 April 2025 to cover those acts. By the September 2025 acts, Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894, both of 12 September 2025, the Council maintained the listing again, this time on the basis of a fifth evidence file transmitted to the applicant on 3 July 2025. Three retention layers, one file, one central question: can a 2022 vote and a former mandate still justify a freeze in 2024 and 2025?
B. Error of assessment: withdrawn from politics, no concrete support, and the rejected March 2025 claims
Before reaching the merits, the Court disposed of the March 2025 layer on procedural grounds: the adaptation of the application, contained in the reply, did not meet the formal conditions of Article 86(2) of the Rules of Procedure and was therefore inadmissible. The action survived only against the September 2024 and September 2025 acts. That procedural ruling explains the paradox widely reported after delivery: the September 2024 and 2025 retentions were annulled, yet the applicant remains, in practice, a listed person, because the unchallenged March 2025 acts still stand and the Council may still appeal or adopt fresh acts.
On the substance, the Court’s reasoning on the September 2024 acts is methodical. The grounds invoked, former membership of the Federation Council and the February 2022 vote, related to a period relatively distant from the adoption of the acts. Moreover, the applicant chose not to stand for renewal of his mandate in September 2022, no longer holds political office in Russia, and has since acquired two new nationalities which, under Russian law, bar him from Russian political office: in the Court’s words, he placed himself « en retrait de la vie politique russe ». Nor could the Council rely on the absence of a firm public stance against the invasion: while distance from the regime may count in some circumstances, the supposed absence of such a stance cannot qualify as the concrete act of support required by the criterion, particularly in a regime characterised by brutal repression of dissent, especially over the war of aggression against Ukraine. The Court therefore found an « erreur d’appréciation » in treating the former mandate and the 2022 vote as justifying retention.
For September 2025, the Council amended its reasons. It repeated the former mandate and the 2022 vote, recalled that the applicant had founded OLMA, now OLMA Media Group, and added that, through a system of apparent change of ownership, he continued to control and influence OLMA Media Group and in particular the Enlightenment publishing house, allegedly directly involved since 2022 in promoting Russia’s war of aggression. Notably, the Council no longer called him director. The applicant answered point by point: he had resigned as protector of the family trust as early as 2015, the Russian and Cypriot OLMA companies had been liquidated in 2014 and January 2025, and Enlightenment was by then wholly owned by Russian financial entities, leaving him no possible influence. The Court’s assessment is instructive for every future file mixing trusts and corporate layers: the evidence did show an apparent ownership reshuffle within the Cypriot OLMA Media Group, later Enlightenment, and a link retained through a daughter-controlled trust since 2017, with 75 percent of Enlightenment’s capital passing in 2021 to state-controlled financial institutions. Yet the Council failed to prove the precise role the applicant allegedly held, the concrete powers and responsibilities he supposedly wielded, and additional evidence confirmed he could no longer control or influence those entities when the September 2025 acts were adopted. A retained link is not a proven function, and suspicion about a trust is not a statement of reasons.
The pleading structure matters for future cases. Against the September 2024 acts the applicant raised errors of assessment and, separately, breach of proportionality and fundamental rights; against the September 2025 acts a single errors-of-assessment plea. The Court’s review is not a retrial: it checks whether the Council’s factual basis is accurate, reliable and consistent, and whether it supports the conclusion drawn, intervening where the assessment is manifestly wrong. That is why dated, individualised evidence beats status-based reasoning. Former titles and old votes age quickly, while fresh proof of current functions, or of their absence, decides the case. Tkach won because he documented his exit; the Council lost because it archived his past.
The operative part follows: the September 2024 and September 2025 acts are annulled insofar as Tkach’s name was maintained on the lists, while « Le recours est rejeté pour le surplus », and each party bears its own costs. An annulment « dans la mesure où » is not a rehabilitation certificate and not a damages award: it removes the two unlawful retentions, leaves the mechanism intact, and says nothing about what the Council may do next on new grounds.
The Council had asked, subsidiarily, that the effects of any annulment be maintained over time. The Court rejected that request as moot: since the applicant is covered by new restrictive measures, there was nothing to preserve, citing its Gutseriev judgment of 22 October 2025. On costs, each side bore its own: the applicant won on the two September layers and lost on the March 2025 layer. The « effectivité du contrôle juridictionnel » guaranteed by Article 47 of the Charter thus produced a split result, rigorous on each act, procedural on the late one.
II. What an annulment unlocks for assets frozen in France
A. The freeze in France: what banks must do and what the listed person cannot do
An EU listing freezes everything first and asks questions later. Under the Ukraine regime, all funds and economic resources belonging to, owned, held or controlled by a listed person are frozen, and no funds or resources may be made available to them directly or indirectly. In France, that freeze bites immediately: banks screen, block accounts, reject transfers and file reports, because making funds available to a listed person exposes the institution and its officers. Alongside the EU regime, France operates its own national freeze decided at ministerial level. Under Article L. 562-2 of the Monetary and Financial Code, « Le ministre chargé de l’économie et le ministre de l’intérieur peuvent décider, conjointement, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques » of persons involved in terrorism and related financing. The provision illustrates the French reflex: a freeze is an administrative police measure, renewable, supervised, and distinct from a criminal confiscation. Its scope for terrorism financing is defined by Article L. 562-1 of the same Code, while EU-regime freezes apply directly and are enforced by the same banking and customs apparatus. The EU regime is not absolute destitution by design: it provides authorisation routes, administered by each Member State’s competent authority, for basic needs, legal fees, maintenance of frozen accounts and, in defined cases, the release of funds subject to a prior arbitral or judicial decision. In practice these routes are narrow, documentary and slow, and every payment needs a prior green light; using a frozen account without one is precisely the evasion conduct the criminal law punishes.
Evading the freeze is a criminal offence, and French courts police it actively. Article L. 574-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code punishes evasion: « de se soustraire aux obligations en résultant ou de faire obstacle à sa mise en oeuvre », with penalties borrowed from customs law and customs-law rules for detection, prosecution and punishment. The investigation itself often runs through customs: in its judgment of 29 November 2023 (no. 22-85.867, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2023:CR01416, decision of the Cour de cassation of 29 November 2023), the Criminal Chamber approved customs officers’ competence to investigate freeze-evasion facts. It recalled: « Pour écarter le moyen de nullité, selon lequel les agents des douanes habilités n’étaient pas compétents pour enquêter sur les faits de soustraction aux mesures de gel des avoirs sur le fondement de l’article 28-1 du code de procédure pénale, l’arrêt attaqué retient que ce texte prévoit que ces agents peuvent effectuer des enquêtes judiciaires sous le contrôle du procureur de la République s’agissant des infractions douanières, mais également s’agissant des infractions connexes aux infractions douanières. » And: « Ils en déduisent qu’il résulte de ce renvoi de l’article L. 574-3 aux textes du code des douanes que les agents des douanes habilités ont bien compétence pour effectuer des enquêtes judiciaires sur cette infraction en application de l’article 28-1 du code de procédure pénale. » That competence rests on Article 28-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, under which designated customs officers « peuvent être habilités à effectuer des enquêtes judiciaires sur réquisition du procureur de la République ou sur commission rogatoire du juge d’instruction ». The full text of the penalty provision is at Article L. 574-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code. For anyone holding or moving funds in France, the message is symmetrical: the freeze is enforced by banks upstream and by customs and criminal courts downstream.
The same judgment confirms how the investigation chain works once evasion is suspected. The court of appeal had noted that the judicial customs service was seised through a transmission detailing the prosecutor’s requisitions, so it acted on the prosecutor’s authority. The Court of Cassation endorsed that analysis: « En effet, en premier lieu, dès lors que les modalités de constatation, de poursuite et de répression du délit de soustraction aux mesures de gel des avoirs dans le cadre de la lutte contre le terrorisme sont prévues par le code des douanes, cette infraction constitue une infraction prévue par le code des douanes au sens du 1° du I de l’article 28-1 du code de procédure pénale. » On the two appeals before it, the Court rejected one and partly quashed the other (decision of the Cour de cassation of 29 November 2023). Customs investigation, prosecutorial control, criminal punishment: the triangle is closed.
B. After the annulment: release, relisting risk, damages and contract fallout
What does the annulled person actually recover? The annulment removes the legal basis of the two retentions with retroactive effect, so funds frozen solely under those acts must be released and banks must update their screening. In practice, release is rarely automatic the next morning: institutions wait for the consolidated list update, verify which acts still cover the name, here the surviving March 2025 acts, and process authorisation requests for derogations such as basic needs, legal fees or frozen-account maintenance through the competent national authority. Until the listing genuinely disappears from the annex in force, compliance departments keep the block. That is why an annulment victory and continued listing can coexist, and why the first task after any delisting judgment is to check, act by act, what still designates the client.
Relisting risk is the second horizon. The Court censured specific grounds at specific dates; it did not declare the person unsanctionable forever. Fresh acts on new, better-documented grounds remain legally possible, and the Council’s appeal remains available. The rational response is to treat the window between judgment and possible fresh acts as a compliance project: close or regularise positions that depended on authorisations, document the change of circumstances the Court recognised, and prepare observations proactively, because the next statement of reasons will have to answer the withdrawal-from-politics finding.
The Council may still appeal to the Court of Justice. An appeal does not rewrite the file in the meantime: the March 2025 designations continue to bite, which is exactly why the General Court saw no need to preserve the annulled acts’ effects over time. Until an appeal succeeds or fresh acts replace the old ones, compliance teams must therefore manage two truths at once, a headline annulment and an intact freeze.
Damages are the third horizon, and the narrowest. EU courts award compensation for unlawful listing only where the breach is sufficiently serious and the harm proven, a high bar that mere annulment does not clear by itself. In French domestic law, the baseline is compensatory: under Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code, « Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure. » And force majeure itself is strictly defined by Article 1218 of the Civil Code: « Il y a force majeure en matière contractuelle lorsqu’un événement échappant au contrôle du débiteur, qui ne pouvait être raisonnablement prévu lors de la conclusion du contrat et dont les effets ne peuvent être évités par des mesures appropriées, empêche l’exécution de son obligation par le débiteur. » A listed debtor therefore cannot simply invoke its own freeze against its creditors.
That last point is settled at the highest level. In its plenary judgment of 10 July 2020 (no. 18-18.542, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2020:PL00653, decision of the Cour de cassation of 10 July 2020), the Court held: « Ne constitue pas un cas de force majeure pour celle qui le subit, faute d’extériorité, le gel des avoirs d’une personne ou d’une entité qui est frappée par cette mesure en raison de ses activités. » Applied to Bank Sepah, designated over the Iranian nuclear programme, it added: « Il en résulte que l’impossibilité où se serait trouvée la banque Sepah, qui n’a pas contesté sa désignation devant les juridictions de l’Union, d’utiliser ses avoirs gelés pour exécuter l’arrêt du 26 avril 2007, ne procède pas d’une circonstance extérieure à son activité. » A freeze imposed because of your own activities is not an external event: creditors can still sue, interest still runs, and the annulment of one retention does not rewrite the contracts signed while it applied.
Conclusion
Tkach is a double lesson. For listed persons, it shows the argument that works: documented, dated withdrawal from the functions that justified listing, concrete proof such as non-renewal of mandate and incompatible new nationalities, and a line-by-line attack on each retention act, because courts review each maintenance separately and procedure punishes late adaptations. For banks, counterparties and counsel in France, it recalls the enforcement triangle: immediate freeze and reporting upstream, customs investigation and criminal punishment for evasion downstream, and no contractual shelter in force majeure for the person targeted because of its own activities. An annulment opens the door to release and to costs arguments, but only a check of every act still in force, here including the March 2025 layer, tells whether the door is genuinely open. The file checklist writes itself: identify every act still designating the client with its exact date and grounds, align bank screening with the consolidated annex rather than press headlines, route each needed payment through the authorisation procedure before moving anything, preserve evidence of changed circumstances for the next statement of reasons, and calendar the appeal window. In sanctions litigation, winning the judgment is the midpoint: the months after delivery, authorisations, list updates, possible appeal and possible fresh reasons, decide what the victory is worth.