KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Ex Blocks My Visits and Will Not Return Our Child After Contact: How Expats Enforce Visitation in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Ex Blocks My Visits and Will Not Return Our Child After Contact: How Expats Enforce Visitation in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your weekend starts on Friday at 6 pm. The judgment says so. You stand in front of the building in Paris, in Boulogne, in Montreuil, and nobody opens the door. Your former partner writes that the child is sick, that the child does not want to come, that the schedule has changed, that you will see next time. Next time never comes. Then one Friday the handover happens, but on Sunday evening the child is not brought back, the phone stays silent, and Monday school starts without you knowing where your child slept. If you live in France as an expat, or if your child lives in France while you live abroad, this pattern raises the same urgent questions: what counts as a breach of your contact rights in France, who do you call first, and how do you force compliance without putting yourself in the wrong?

French law gives a clear answer, and it works in two directions. The family judge organizes contact, and the criminal judge punishes a parent who blocks it without a valid reason. The parent with whom the child lives day to day must respect the contact of the other parent. The parent who holds contact rights must return the child on time. When either side breaks the rhythm, the other side has civil tools to restore handovers quickly and criminal tools to stop repetition. This guide explains the full chain for English-speaking parents: the visitation order of the juge aux affaires familiales (the family judge, universally called the JAF), what counts as an unlawful refusal to hand over or return a child, why you must ask the JAF to change the order instead of withholding the child yourself, and how enforcement works in practice, from the written record to the astreinte (a daily penalty payment), the amende civile (a civil fine), police assistance, and the criminal complaint for non-representation d’enfant (failure to hand over a minor to the person entitled to claim the child). It also covers Paris and Ile-de-France practice, the position of the child who says no, and the cross-border overlay when one parent lives outside France.

This article is written for expats in France, binational couples, foreigners married to a French national, English-speaking residents of Paris and Ile-de-France, and parents abroad whose contact order comes from a French court. Every French term is explained at first use. The legal references below were verified during this run against the official texts and court decisions linked inline, with French quotations followed by an English translation in parentheses.

Before you go before the family judge, have your own case reviewed by a family lawyer in Paris who works in English with expatriate and international parents.

I. What French law says when your ex blocks your visits and keeps your child after contact

A. How does the French visitation order work and what counts as a breach for expats

Separation changes the family, not the legal framework. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code states that separation has no effect on how parental authority is allocated, and it adds “Chacun des père et mère doit maintenir des relations personnelles avec l’enfant et respecter les liens de celui-ci avec l’autre parent.” (Each father and mother must maintain personal relations with the child and respect the ties of the child with the other parent.) (Article 373-2, Civil Code, Legifrance). In plain English, the parent with whom the child lives cannot unilaterally cancel your place in the life of the child. Contact is the rule, interruption is the exception, and the exception must be decided by a judge.

The standard French order distinguishes two rights that English speakers often merge. The droit de visite (short visits, for example Wednesday afternoon or Saturday) and the droit d’hebergement (overnight stays, typically alternate weekends and half of the school holidays) together form what this guide calls contact. The JAF fixes the calendar: alternate weekends from Friday after school to Sunday at 6 pm or 7 pm, Wednesday afternoons in the weeks without a weekend, half of each school holiday with alternation of Christmas and summer, handover place, transport costs, and sometimes video calls between stays. When parents separate by mutual-consent divorce before a notary, the same calendar appears in the convention de divorce (the divorce agreement countersigned by lawyers and filed with a notary), which has enforceable effect. When parents go to court, the calendar appears in an ordonnance de non-conciliation (the early interim order), an ordonnance sur mesures provisoires (the interim measures order), or the final divorce or parental-authority judgment. All of these are titres executoires (enforceable titles) once enforceable, which means a bailiff, now called a commissaire de justice (a court enforcement officer), and the police can act on them.

A breach takes three common forms, and French law treats them as the same family of wrongs. The first is the blocked handover: the resident parent refuses to present the child at the agreed time and place, invents a last-minute illness, schedules competing activities, claims the child refuses to go, or simply disappears. The second is the late or missing return: the contact parent keeps the child beyond Sunday evening, extends holidays unilaterally, or announces that the child will now live with them. The third is the degraded contact: systematic lateness, refusal of phone or video contact between stays, denigration that makes each handover a conflict, or repeated medical certificates produced only on contact weekends. One isolated delay caused by a train strike is not the same as a pattern, but even a single deliberate refusal to hand over the child can trigger enforcement, because each missed contact deprives the child of the other parent and deprives the entitled parent of time that cannot be recovered later.

The threshold for refusing contact is deliberately high. Article 373-2-1 of the Civil Code provides “L’exercice du droit de visite et d’hébergement ne peut être refusé à l’autre parent que pour des motifs graves.” (Contact may be refused to the other parent only for serious reasons.) (Article 373-2-1, Civil Code, Legifrance). Serious reasons mean a concrete danger for the child, proven by documents, not a general feeling that contact is difficult, not the fact that the child cried once, not the fact that the parents argue at handover, not the fact that maintenance is unpaid. A parent who stops paying the pension alimentaire (child maintenance) does not lose contact for that reason, and a parent who is denied contact must still pay maintenance. The two obligations run on separate tracks. If you are the parent denied contact, keep paying and keep proof of payment, because a judge will look at your compliance when you ask for enforcement. If you are the resident parent and you believe contact endangers the child, you need medical certificates describing precise findings, school reports, police reports, or a pending criminal complaint, and you need to bring them to the JAF quickly rather than suspending contact on your own.

Expat families face the same rules with added friction. A handover at Gare du Nord, at Charles de Gaulle airport, or at the school gate in the 15th arrondissement fails when one parent travels for work, when the school calendar differs from the home country, or when messages switch between English and French and each side misunderstands the pick-up time. Reduce this friction before it becomes a case. Ask the JAF for a calendar that names exact times, exact addresses, and who travels, with a rule for public holidays in France and in the other country, a rule for summer when flights are expensive, and a rule for video contact. Keep every exchange in writing, in one channel, with dates and times. When the other parent writes that the child is ill, reply briefly, propose the make-up dates, and ask for the medical certificate. When the other parent does not reply, go to the handover place anyway, stay for a reasonable time, and keep transport tickets, photographs of your presence without showing the child, and messages. Judges in Paris read this kind of file every day, and a calm, documented parent who always showed up carries far more weight than a parent who traded insults by text message.

The contribution to the maintenance and education of the child follows the same enforceable titles. Article 373-2-2 of the Civil Code lists the six forms that the pension alimentaire can take, stating that the terms and guarantees of maintenance are fixed by “1° Une décision judiciaire ; 2° Une convention homologuée par le juge ; 3° Une convention de divorce ou de séparation de corps par consentement mutuel selon les modalités prévues à l’article 229-1” (1. A court decision; 2. An agreement approved by the judge; 3. A mutual-consent divorce or legal separation agreement under Article 229-1) and three further enforceable forms including the notarial deed (Article 373-2-2, Civil Code, Legifrance). The practical point for blocked-contact cases is simple: check which title sets your contact calendar, because you will enforce that exact title. Bring the full judgment or agreement, not an extract, and bring proof that it is enforceable. If your order comes from a foreign court, you enforce in France under the EU regulation or the Hague framework discussed in Part II, and you may first need recognition or registration, as explained in our guide to foreign divorces recognised and enforced in France and in our Hague return guide for children taken to or out of France.

B. Why must you go back to the family judge instead of withholding the child yourself

The most dangerous mistake is symmetry: your ex blocks your weekend, so you keep the child the next weekend to compensate. French law punishes both blocks, and the second block does not cancel the first. If you believe the current calendar harms the child, the lawful move is to seize the JAF (to bring the case back to the family judge) and ask for a change, not to suspend handovers while you wait. The Cour de cassation (the highest French court for civil and criminal matters) stated this rule in the strongest terms in a decision of 26 August 2026 on the criminal offence of non-representation: “Il appartient ainsi au parent qui estime que la remise de l’enfant est de nature à le mettre en danger de saisir le juge aux affaires familiales afin de modifier les modalités de l’exercice de l’autorité parentale.” (It is therefore for the parent who considers that handing over the child is likely to endanger the child to apply to the family judge to change the terms of parental authority.) (Cass. crim., 26 Aug. 2026, No. 26-80.077, Cour de cassation). The same decision explains that JAF orders can be challenged on appeal and that “leur modification peut être demandée à tout moment par l’un des deux parents, en particulier s’il apparaît que l’enfant est exposé à un risque” (their modification may be requested at any time by either parent, in particular if it appears that the child is exposed to a risk). Waiting, self-help, and silence all work against you.

The 26 August 2026 decision rejected a constitutional challenge to Article 227-5 of the Criminal Code and confirmed that the offence punishes disobedience to a court order that itself protects the child. The Court reasoned that the provision punishes disregard of a JAF decision which aims to preserve family balance and the best interests of the child by organising relations between the child and the parent with whom the child does not usually live. For an expat parent, the message is direct: if handover feels unsafe because of alcohol, violence, neglect, or a sudden radical change in the other household, file with the JAF the same week, attach the evidence, and request interim protection such as supervised contact in an espace de rencontre (a neutral supervised visitation centre), handover through a tiers de confiance (a trusted third person), or suspension pending an inquiry. Do not create a competing breach that the other parent will then use against you in the next hearing and in a criminal complaint.

Fear for the child still has procedural safeguards before any prosecution. The same 2026 decision recalls that and the decision notes the safeguard in Article D. 47-11-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, under which the public prosecutor verifies claims that the refusal was justified by violence against the child before starting a prosecution, meaning the public prosecutor (the procureur de la République, the state prosecutor who decides whether to prosecute) must verify claims that the refusal was justified by violence against the child before starting a prosecution. In practice, this means your complaint or your defence must be precise: dates, places, names of witnesses, medical units, school alerts, and any prior reports to the police or to the cellule de recueil des informations préoccupantes (the child-protection intake unit). A vague statement that contact is bad for the child does not trigger the same verification as a dated medical certificate plus a prior report.

The voice of the child fits inside this framework but does not replace it. Article 388-1 of the Civil Code provides “Cette audition est de droit lorsque le mineur en fait la demande.” (The hearing is a matter of right when the minor so requests.) (Article 388-1, Civil Code, Legifrance). A child capable of discernment (mature enough to understand, with no fixed age in the statute) can be heard by the JAF, alone, with a lawyer, or with a chosen person, but the hearing does not make the child a party and the judge keeps the final decision. The First Civil Chamber recalled on 12 June 2025 that a court cannot refuse a hearing by referring only to age without explaining why the child lacks discernment (see Cass. civ. 1, 12 June 2025, No. 23-13.900, Cour de cassation). For enforcement cases, this matters because many parents say the child does not want to go. A teenager who writes to the judge will usually be heard. A seven-year-old who repeats one parent’s phrases will be heard differently, and the judge will look for influence. If your child resists contact, do not interrogate the child on video, do not coach a letter, and do not use the resistance as a reason to cancel. Transmit the request for a hearing through a lawyer, propose a gradual resumption, and let the judge assess. Our guide on whether the French judge will hear your child explains the request routes, the hearing day, and the weight of the child’s words, including on appeal.

Paris practice adds one more reason to return to the JAF promptly. The tribunal judiciaire de Paris (the Paris civil and criminal court) handles a large volume of binational files, and the JAF expects parents to try mediation or a clear written proposal before asking for sanctions. A parent who files after three documented breaches with a calm proposal for supervised handovers, make-up weekends, and transport sharing looks very different from a parent who files after eight months of silence with only screenshots of insults. The JAF can also order an enquête sociale (a social-worker home study), a mesure d’investigation, or a short period of mediation, and can adjust the pension alimentaire when travel costs change. If relocation is the real issue behind the missed handovers, because one parent plans to leave France or has already moved to London, Brussels, New York, or Tel Aviv, read our relocation guide on leaving France with a child after divorce before you file, because the JAF will treat the change of residence and the contact calendar as one case, not two.

II. How to enforce the handover and stop repeated refusals in France

A. How do you get the handover enforced now as an expat in Paris and Ile-de-France

Start with proof, because every later step depends on paper. For each missed handover, keep the judgment or agreement that sets the calendar, the messages showing the time and place, your reply proposing compliance, proof that you attended the handover, and proof of the absence of the child. Go to the handover even when the other parent announces a refusal, stay a reasonable time, and keep metro tickets, parking receipts, or taxi invoices. If the other parent does not open the door, do not force entry, do not shout in the hallway, and do not take the child from school against the school’s instructions. Leave, write a short factual message, and the same day ask a commissaire de justice to draw up a procès-verbal de constat (a formal written record of observed facts). The officer can record your presence, the closed door, the messages, and the absence of handover. Schools, holiday centres, and airlines can provide attendance or boarding records on request. A medical certificate produced by the other parent only for contact weekends should be kept and compared over time, because a judge will notice a pattern of convenient illnesses without hospital visits.

With two or three documented breaches, seize the JAF for enforcement and adjustment. The JAF has the widest toolbox in French family law for exactly this situation. Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code states “Il peut, même d’office, ordonner une astreinte pour assurer l’exécution de sa décision.” (The judge may, even of the judge’s own motion, order a penalty payment to ensure enforcement of the decision.) (Article 373-2-6, Civil Code, Legifrance). The astreinte is a sum per breach or per day of delay, for example 100 euros per missed handover or per day of late return, later liquidated (finally quantified) by the judge. The same article allows the JAF to extend an astreinte to a decision made by another judge or to a parental agreement contained in an enforceable title, and to apply the enforcement provisions of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures. In plain terms, you can ask the Paris JAF to attach a price to every future refusal, even if the original calendar was set in another city or in a mutual-consent agreement. Ask precisely: recall of the calendar, order to comply within a short deadline, astreinte per future breach, make-up contact weekends, adjustment of handover place, supervised handovers if conflict is severe, and sharing of travel costs.

The same article creates a civil fine for deliberate obstruction. It provides that when a parent deliberately and gravely or repeatedly blocks enforcement of an enforceable title, the judge may “le condamner au paiement d’une amende civile d’un montant qui ne peut excéder 10 000 €” (order the parent to pay a civil fine of no more than 10,000 euros) (Article 373-2-6, Civil Code, Legifrance). This amende civile punishes contempt of the contact order without sending anyone to prison, and it can be combined with an astreinte, a change of residence, or a reduction or suspension of contact for the obstructing parent. In serious cases the JAF can transfer residence to the other parent, order contact in a supervised centre, or ask the prosecutor to assist. The JAF can also order an interdiction de sortie du territoire sans l’autorisation des deux parents (a ban on taking the child out of France without both parents’ consent), entered in the wanted-persons file by the prosecutor, when late returns shade into a risk of international retention. If your ex threatens to keep the child abroad during holidays, ask for this ban together with enforcement, and read our travel-consent and exit-ban guidance alongside this article.

Police assistance exists but follows the civil order, not phone pressure. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code allows the prosecutor, exceptionally, at the request of the interested person or of the JAF, to order police assistance to enforce a JAF decision, a mutual-consent divorce agreement filed with a notary, or an approved agreement setting parental authority terms. The French text describes “le procureur de la République peut requérir le concours de la force publique pour faire exécuter une décision du juge aux affaires familiales” (the public prosecutor may call on police assistance to enforce a family judge decision) (Article 373-2, Civil Code, Legifrance). In Paris and Ile-de-France, this route is exceptional and works best with a recent enforcement judgment that names the calendar, plus constats and a written request to the parquet (the prosecutor’s office). Do not expect officers to arrive within the hour on a Sunday evening on the basis of an old judgment alone. Build the file, obtain the enforcement order with an astreinte, then return with the order if handovers still fail. For day-to-day help, the commissaire de justice can attempt recovery of the child under the enforcement rules, and the JAF can designate a meeting place or a trusted third person so that parents no longer meet directly.

Cross-border families use the same JAF route with one extra layer. If your contact order comes from another EU Member State, Council Regulation 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter, provides for direct recognition and, for access rights, enforcement without a prior registration step when the proper certificate travels with the decision (see Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter). If your order comes from outside the EU, enforcement depends on bilateral treaties and French recognition rules, and you may need to ask the French court to declare the foreign decision enforceable before requesting an astreinte. The 1980 Hague Convention on child abduction, overseen internationally by the HCCH (the Hague Conference on Private International Law), deals with wrongful removal or retention across borders and return proceedings (see 1980 Hague Convention, HCCH), while this guide deals with enforcement inside France. When a late return after holidays turns into retention abroad, the two tracks meet: file the JAF enforcement request in France and, in parallel, contact the French Central Authority for a Hague return request. Our Hague guide explains the one-year clock, habitual residence, and the narrow defences, and our lis pendens guide explains what to do when a divorce starts abroad first.

B. How does the criminal complaint for non-representation work and when is the sentence heavier

The criminal track starts with Article 227-5 of the Criminal Code: “Le fait de refuser indûment de représenter un enfant mineur à la personne qui a le droit de le réclamer est puni d’un an d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 euros d’amende.” (Unlawfully refusing to hand over a minor child to the person entitled to claim the child is punished by one year of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine.) (Article 227-5, Criminal Code, Legifrance). Every word matters. Refuser (to refuse) covers active refusal and passive retention after contact. Indument (without lawful reason) excludes compliance with a newer court order that changed the calendar, a genuine impossibility documented the same day, or an immediate danger reported at once to the police and to the JAF. Representer (to present or hand over) means bringing the child to the entitled person at the time and place fixed by the title. La personne qui a le droit de le reclamer (the person entitled to claim the child) is the parent holding contact rights for that weekend or holiday, whether under a JAF judgment, an approved agreement, or an enforceable mutual-consent agreement. Both parents can commit the offence: the resident parent who blocks the weekend and the contact parent who keeps the child after Sunday both refuse to present the child to the person entitled to claim the child for the next period.

File the complaint correctly. Go to the police station or gendarmerie of the place where the child should have been handed over, with identity documents, the full enforceable title, proof that it was served or notified, the detailed calendar for the missed period, messages, the constat by the commissaire de justice, school records, and a chronological list of prior breaches. File a plainte (a criminal complaint) and ask for a receipt, or send a plainte au procureur (a written complaint to the prosecutor) by registered letter to the tribunal judiciaire of the handover place. Describe facts, not feelings: on Friday 12 September 2026 at 6 pm at the address fixed by the judgment of 4 March 2025, the mother or father did not present the child, you waited until 7 pm, you sent two messages, you hold the constat. Attach translations of any English messages into French, because the file will be read in French. Keep a copy of everything for the JAF, because the civil and criminal tracks reinforce each other: the criminal file proves repetition to the JAF, and the JAF enforcement order proves clarity of the obligation to the criminal court.

The sentence becomes heavier in two situations that expats meet often. Article 227-9 of the Criminal Code states “Les faits définis par les articles 227-5 et 227-7 sont punis de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 45 000 euros d’amende” (The acts defined in Articles 227-5 and 227-7 are punished by three years of imprisonment and a 45,000 euro fine) in two cases (Article 227-9, Criminal Code, Legifrance). The first case is retention beyond five days without telling the entitled person where the child is. The second case is unlawful retention outside French territory. A weekend that stretches into a week of silence, or a holiday in France that ends with the child kept in another country, moves the case from one year to three years. The Cour de cassation confirmed on 21 June 2023 that French courts keep jurisdiction when the handover should occur in France even if the child is retained abroad, holding that “le lieu de commission du délit de non-représentation d’enfant est celui où l’enfant doit être remis” (the place of the offence of failure to hand over a child is the place where the child must be handed over) and, absent detail in the order, the home of the entitled parent (see Cass. crim., 21 June 2023, No. 23-80.031, Cour de cassation). For a parent in Paris whose child should have been returned to Paris but is kept in London, Algiers, or New York, the complaint can therefore be filed in France.

Criminal courts look at the reality of obstruction, not at labels. On 23 March 2022 the Criminal Chamber rejected the appeal of a mother convicted of non-representation after she blocked the father’s court-ordered contact in a neutral place during divorce proceedings, leaving a suspended prison sentence and civil damages in place (see Cass. crim., 23 Mar. 2022, No. 21-80.885, Cour de cassation). The lesson is practical: an ordonnance de non-conciliation or interim contact order must be obeyed until a later judgment changes it, and the argument that the divorce has since been pronounced does not erase breaches committed while the interim order applied. Judges also punish inventive defences. Claiming that the child was too young to travel, that the other parent arrived ten minutes late, or that maintenance was unpaid does not amount to lawful reason. Claiming danger requires contemporaneous proof and an immediate JAF application, as the 2026 decision above explains. If violence is alleged, the prosecutor must verify before prosecuting, but the parent must provide checkable details, not general statements.

For practical guidance on complaints and victim support, the public service pages explain how to file and what to bring. The service-public.fr English and French pages on parental authority, contact disputes, and reporting a failure to hand over a child list the competent court and the documents to attach (see Parental authority: contact disputes, service-public.fr), and the justice.fr portal describes seizure of the JAF and enforcement of family decisions (see justice.fr, Ministry of Justice portal). Legal aid, called aide juridictionnelle (state-funded legal aid for low-income litigants), can cover JAF proceedings and criminal complaints when resources fall below the threshold, which matters for expats between jobs or on a single income after separation. Ask a Paris lawyer at the first meeting whether your household qualifies and whether the other parent’s obstruction justifies an urgent hearing date. Urgency exists when contact has stopped entirely, when retention exceeds a few days, or when a foreign departure is feared, and in those cases file the JAF request and the criminal complaint the same week rather than choosing one track.

Conclusion

When your ex blocks your visits or keeps your child after contact, French law does not ask you to wait or to retaliate. It asks you to prove, to return to the JAF, and to enforce. Keep the full title that sets the calendar, attend every handover, record each breach the same day with a constat, and file for enforcement with an astreinte, make-up time, and, where needed, supervised handovers or a travel ban. In parallel, file a criminal complaint for non-representation with the same documents, because repetition proven in one file strengthens the other. Never suspend handovers yourself while you wait for the next hearing. If safety is the true reason, say so immediately with dated evidence and ask the JAF to change the terms the same week, since only the judge can suspend or reshape contact for serious reasons. For expats in Paris and Ile-de-France, and for parents abroad with a French contact order, this two-track method restores the rhythm fastest: a clear civil order that prices every future refusal, backed by a criminal file that punishes deliberate disobedience, with aggravated penalties when retention lasts beyond five days in silence or crosses the border. The broader context helps too. Our guides on full custody and residence before the JAF, on relocation permission, on whether the judge will hear your child, on foreign divorces recognised in France, and on Hague return after international removal each solve one neighbour problem, while this guide solves the enforcement problem inside France. Bring your calendar, your proofs, and your proposal for the next handover to your first legal appointment, and act within days, because in contact cases time lost is never fully recovered.

📄 Official circular