KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Ex Won’t Pay Your Prestation Compensatoire in France? How Expats Enforce, Guarantee and Revise the Payment

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ex Won’t Pay Your Prestation Compensatoire in France? How Expats Enforce, Guarantee and Revise the Payment

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your divorce is final, the judgment orders your ex-spouse to pay you a prestation compensatoire — the French compensatory payment that offsets the gap in living standards caused by the divorce — and then nothing arrives. The instalments stop after two months, the lump sum never lands, or your ex announces that, now living in London or New York, French decisions no longer concern them. For English-speaking expats in France, this moment is familiar and stressful: the hardest part of the divorce seemed over, yet the money the judge awarded feels theoretical. French law anticipates exactly this situation. A prestation compensatoire ordered by a French court is an enforceable debt from the day the decision becomes final, and the creditor has a full toolbox to secure it before default and to force payment after default — guarantees imposed by the judge, seizure of bank accounts and earnings by a commissaire de justice (the enforcement officer formerly called huissier de justice), forced sale of property, and, where the debtor lives abroad, European recovery procedures. This guide explains, in plain English and with the exact legal texts, what your ex owes you, how to lock the payment down, and how to recover it when your ex refuses to pay, including from outside France and before the Paris courts.

I. What your ex actually owes you under French divorce law

Before seizing anything, you need to read the judgment correctly, because the enforcement route depends on the form the judge chose. French law treats the prestation compensatoire as a fixed, lump-sum-style payment — a capital — even when it is paid over time, and only in narrow cases as a lifetime annuity, a rente viagère. Each form carries different deadlines, different revision rules and different collection methods.

A. Capital, eight-year instalments or annuity: decoding your judgment

The starting point is Article 270 of the Civil Code, which states: « Le divorce met fin au devoir de secours entre époux. » (Divorce ends the duty of support between spouses.) The devoir de secours, the duty of mutual financial support during marriage, disappears with the divorce, and the prestation compensatoire replaces it as a one-off rebalancing mechanism: a payment that compensates, as far as possible, the disparity in living standards created by the end of the marriage. It is not monthly maintenance, though it can resemble maintenance when paid in instalments, and it is entirely separate from the pension alimentaire paid for the children or from damages for exclusive fault under Article 266.

The judge first fixes an amount, guided by Article 271 of the Civil Code, which lists the needs of the creditor, the resources of the debtor and factors such as the length of the marriage, the age and health of each spouse, their qualifications and careers, and foreseeable developments: Article 271. Then the judge chooses the payment mechanics under Article 274, which provides: « Le juge décide des modalités selon lesquelles s’exécutera la prestation compensatoire en capital parmi les formes suivantes » (The judge decides the arrangements for performing the lump-sum compensatory payment from the following forms), namely payment of a sum of money — with the divorce itself capable of being made conditional on the guarantees of Article 277 — or transfer of property, or grant of a temporary or lifetime right of use, housing or usufruit (usufruct, the right to use someone else’s property and take its income), with the judgment operating as a forced conveyance to the creditor. Note the safeguard for family assets: the debtor’s agreement is required before the judge can transfer property the debtor received by inheritance or gift.

In practice, many debtors cannot hand over a large capital sum on the day of the divorce. Article 275 answers that situation: « Lorsque le débiteur n’est pas en mesure de verser le capital dans les conditions prévues par l’article 274 , le juge fixe les modalités de paiement du capital, dans la limite de huit années, sous forme de versements périodiques indexés selon les règles applicables aux pensions alimentaires. » (Where the debtor cannot pay the capital as Article 274 provides, the judge sets payment over up to eight years in periodic instalments indexed under the rules for maintenance.) Two details matter enormously for enforcement. First, the judge must set real, quantified instalments: the Court of Cassation quashed a Paris appeal ruling that had ordered 200,000 euros payable in monthly indexed instalments over eight years without fixing the monthly amount, holding: « En statuant ainsi, sans fixer le montant des versements mensuels, la cour d’appel a méconnu l’étendue de ses pouvoirs et violé le texte susvisé. » (Cass. 1re civ., 1 July 2026, no. 24-17.045 — By ruling without fixing the monthly instalment amount, the appeal court misunderstood the scope of its powers and breached the cited provision.) If your judgment leaves the instalment amount vague, ask your lawyer to have it clarified or completed, because a commissaire de justice enforces precise sums, not aspirations. Second, only in exceptional cases and by specially reasoned decision may the judge extend payment beyond eight years, and the debtor may always pay the indexed balance early, since « Le débiteur peut se libérer à tout moment du solde du capital indexé. » (The debtor may at any time pay off the remaining indexed balance.)

The lifetime annuity, the rente viagère, is the exception, not the rule. Article 276 provides: « A titre exceptionnel, le juge peut, par décision spécialement motivée, lorsque l’âge ou l’état de santé du créancier ne lui permet pas de subvenir à ses besoins, fixer la prestation compensatoire sous forme de rente viagère. » (Exceptionally, by specially reasoned decision, where the creditor’s age or health prevents self-support, the judge may set the payment as a lifetime annuity.) Most pre-2000 divorces produced such annuities, and litigation still rages over them: in one case that reached the Court of Cassation, « un arrêt du 13 août 1998 a condamné M. W… à payer à Mme E… une prestation compensatoire sous la forme d’une rente viagère » (Cass. 1re civ., 29 May 2019, no. 18-17.377 — a 13 August 1998 ruling ordered Mr W. to pay Mrs E. a lifetime-annuity payment), followed by a 2008 refusal to revise it and fresh proceedings in 2015. The lesson for expats: identify whether your award is capital, staged capital or annuity before choosing your weapon, because only the annuity can be revised downward for changed circumstances, while capital — even staged over eight years — is in principle fixed, with only its payment schedule adjustable.

One practical distinction closes this section. A staged capital is not a pension alimentaire. That means the fast-track public collection service for child support, the Agence de recouvrement des impayés de pensions alimentaires (Aripa), which many expats know from unpaid child support cases, does not collect your prestation compensatoire. Your route is ordinary forced execution through a commissaire de justice, plus the specific guarantees of Article 277 and the cross-border maintenance instruments described below.

B. Guarantees, death of the debtor and revision: what survives non-payment

French divorce judges do not simply order payment and hope. Article 277 gives them a preventive arsenal: « Indépendamment de l’hypothèque légale ou judiciaire, le juge peut imposer à l’époux débiteur de constituer un gage, de donner caution ou de souscrire un contrat garantissant le paiement de la rente ou du capital. » (Beyond a legal or court-ordered mortgage, the judge may order the debtor to pledge assets, provide a guarantor or take out a contract securing payment.) In plain terms, the judgment can force your ex to pledge securities or valuables (a gage), to produce a solvent guarantor (a caution), to buy a guarantee policy, or to accept a mortgage over French property — and the divorce itself can be made conditional on those guarantees being set up under Article 274. If your divorce is still in progress before the juge aux affaires familiales (the JAF, the family court judge), asking for Article 277 guarantees now is far cheaper than chasing an unsecured debtor later. If the divorce is already final and no guarantee was ordered, equivalent protection can still be built after the fact through precautionary measures: with a court authorization, a commissaire de justice can register a precautionary seizure (saisie conservatoire) over bank accounts, shares or a share in the former family home, freezing the asset before it disappears. The general enforcement principle behind all of this sits in Article L. 111-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures: « Tout créancier peut, dans les conditions prévues par la loi, contraindre son débiteur défaillant à exécuter ses obligations à son égard. » (Any creditor may, as the statute provides, compel a defaulting debtor to perform.) That single sentence is the legal basis for everything in Part II of this guide.

Death does not wipe the slate clean, a point that matters for older couples and second families. Article 280 of the Civil Code provides: « A la mort de l’époux débiteur, le paiement de la prestation compensatoire, quelle que soit sa forme, est prélevé sur la succession. » (On the debtor’s death, payment of the compensatory allowance, in whatever form, is taken from the estate.) The heirs bear it within the limit of the estate assets, and any shortfall falls on individual legatees in proportion to what they receive. The Court of Cassation applied this logic strictly in a case where a widower died leaving a second wife and a daughter, who had agreed by notarial deed in 2008 to keep paying the first wife’s annuity between them, before one of them asked the family judge to cancel her share: Cass. 1re civ., 28 March 2018, no. 17-14.389. The ruling examines when an annuity share charged to an heir can be ended and confirms that the annuity creditor’s rights run against the estate, not against the goodwill of the new family. Concretely, if your debtor dies, notify the notaire handling the succession immediately, produce the divorce judgment, and have your claim entered among the estate liabilities before the assets are distributed — once the heirs have spent the money, recovery becomes far harder. Note also that transfers made as prestation compensatoire are treated as part of the matrimonial property settlement, not as gifts: Article 281. Your ex cannot later attack the payment as an excessive donation.

Revision rules cut both ways, so use them deliberately. An annuity can be revised, suspended or ended where resources or needs change significantly: « La prestation compensatoire fixée sous forme de rente peut être révisée, suspendue ou supprimée en cas de changement important dans les ressources ou les besoins de l’une ou l’autre des parties. » (Article 276-3 — “An annuity-form payment may be revised, suspended or ended on a significant change in either party’s resources or needs.) Either side can also ask the judge at any time to replace all or part of the annuity with a capital sum under Article 276-4, a useful exit where the debtor has come into money, for example at the final division of the matrimonial property. Capital, by contrast, is fixed once and for all; only its instalment schedule can be adjusted where the debtor’s situation changes substantially. The 2019 annuity saga cited above shows the courts policing repeat applications: a debtor whose revision claim was rejected in 2008 could not simply refile the same claim in 2015 and expect a different answer without a genuine legal or factual change (Cass. 1re civ., 29 May 2019, no. 18-17.377). For an expat creditor, the message is symmetrical: if your needs collapse — a large inheritance, a much better-paid job — your debtor may seek a cut, so keep evidence of your ongoing needs; if your debtor’s fortune grows, consider asking for capitalization of the annuity rather than waiting decades for monthly cheques.

A final structural point before enforcement: French tax and indexation mechanics affect what you actually collect. Staged capital is indexed under maintenance rules, so each annual instalment moves with the index named in the judgment — typically the consumer-price index published by INSEE — and arrears bear statutory interest from a formal demand (mise en demeure) or from service of the enforcement title. Always have your lawyer compute the indexed balance before instructing the commissaire de justice: seizing for the nominal 2008 figure when the indexed 2026 figure is 15 percent higher means leaving money behind, while seizing for more than the judgment allows exposes you to a release claim and costs.

II. How expats force payment when the debtor will not pay

Theory ends at the bailiff’s door. Once the divorce judgment is final — or provisionally enforceable, which divorce orders on money usually are — the creditor holds an enforcement title (titre exécutoire) and can act without returning to the judge for permission to collect. The sequence below follows the order a Paris practitioner uses: verify the title, send the final demand, seize, and, only if the debtor or the assets sit abroad, activate the European machinery.

A. Seize in France: the commissaire de justice route step by step

First, assemble the file. You need the full divorce judgment with the enforcement formula (formule exécutoire), the exact computation of principal, indexation and interest, the debtor’s last known address and banking or employment details, and any land-registry references for French property. Send a formal demand by registered letter giving a short deadline — eight to fifteen days is standard — and stating that forced execution will follow. This letter is not a legal prerequisite where you already hold an enforcement title, but Paris judges look kindly on creditors who warned before seizing, and the letter fixes the starting point for late-payment interest in disputed cases.

Then instruct a commissaire de justice, the merged profession that replaced the huissier de justice for enforcement work. This officer serves a commandement de payer (order to pay) and, if it fails, moves to attachment. The workhorse for cash is the saisie-attribution: seizure of bank balances. The officer serves the bank, which must freeze the attachable balance immediately, declare all the debtor’s accounts, and pay the creditor after a one-month challenge window. For debtors in salaried employment in France, the saisie des rémunérations (earnings attachment) routes a monthly slice of wages directly to you through the local court, within protected minimum-income limits. Where the debtor owns French real estate — the former family flat in the 15th arrondissement, a country house in the Dordogne — the saisie immobilière (real-estate seizure) forces a court-ordered sale, though it is slow, typically twelve to eighteen months in Paris, and proportionate only for large balances. Shares, stock options and life-insurance surrender values can also be attached under specific procedures your officer will select. The official service-public.fr guide to the prestation compensatoire summarizes the regime and points to these enforcement routes: service-public.fr, Prestation compensatoire.

Three expat-specific traps deserve attention at this stage. First, the debtor who empties a French account the week before seizure: where dissipation is feared, ask the enforcement judge (juge de l’exécution) for a precautionary authorization first, then strike without warning. Second, the debtor paid abroad but holding a French flat: skip the wage route and go straight for the property or the rental income, which a commissaire de justice can attach in the tenant’s hands. Third, the debtor who claims the staged capital should be reduced because their income fell: remember that capital is fixed and only the schedule can be revised, so keep collecting on the judgment as written unless and until a judge actually varies the instalments — a unilateral pay cut by the debtor is simply default, and each missed indexed instalment accrues for seizure.

Costs follow a regulated tariff plus the officer’s disbursements, and the bulk of execution costs falls on the debtor by statute, advanced by you and recovered from the seized funds. Keep every receipt: where enforcement succeeds, you recover the advances from the debtor; where the debtor is genuinely insolvent, consider converting pressure into negotiation — a discounted immediate payment against a full discharge, recorded in a signed settlement (protocole transactionnel), often beats years of chasing an empty pocket. And where the debtor has died, redirect the same machinery against the estate: serve the notaire, lodge the claim, and if necessary attach estate accounts before distribution, relying on Article 280.

B. Recover from abroad and litigate in Paris: the cross-border playbook

Many expat debtors assume that leaving France puts the judgment beyond reach. Within the European Union, that assumption is wrong. The prestation compensatoire in annuity or staged-instalment form is treated as a maintenance obligation for cross-border recovery, so Council Regulation (EC) No 4/2009 on maintenance obligations applies: Regulation (EC) No 4/2009 on maintenance obligations. The French creditor obtains a European extract of the judgment and sends it through the French central authority to the authority of the debtor’s country, where it is enforced without a fresh trial on the merits. Where the debtor sits in a Hague Maintenance Convention state outside the EU, such as the United States, the 2007 Hague Protocol and Convention channel provides a comparable transmission route through central authorities. The applicable-law background for the divorce itself, where relevant, comes from the Rome III Regulation on the law applicable to divorce: Regulation (EU) No 1259/2010 (Rome III), and jurisdiction and children issues from Brussels II ter: Regulation (EU) 2019/1111 (Brussels II ter). Your enforcement lawyer should confirm on the judgment’s European certificate which instrument the clerk will stamp — staged capital with indexation travels as maintenance, while a pure transfer of a specific property is enforced under the general civil-recognition rules instead.

For debtors in England post-Brexit, recovery runs through the Hague 2007 route and English registration of the French order, with London solicitors instructed alongside your Paris lawyer; for debtors in the United States, the state-level enforcement office in the debtor’s state processes the transmitted French order, with timelines measured in months rather than weeks, so start early and keep the French precautionary seizures alive in the meantime. For debtors in the Gulf states, Switzerland or Asia, where no maintenance treaty may operate, the realistic levers are French assets — attach the Paris flat, the French bank account, the French salaries or French-source rents — plus negotiation backed by the threat of criminal exposure: deliberate, organized non-payment of a court-ordered family debt can, in persistent cases, support a complaint for abandon de famille (family abandonment) where maintenance-type sums are concerned, and at minimum demonstrates bad faith that colors every later family hearing.

Paris practice adds its own layer. The Paris judicial court (tribunal judiciaire de Paris) concentrates enforcement challenges before the juge de l’exécution, who hears disputes over seizures of Paris accounts and Paris property swiftly, often within weeks for urgent release applications. If your debtor challenges the seizure, expect arguments about incorrect indexation, provisional enforceability, or confusion between capital and annuity — all defeated by the precise judgment arithmetic and the texts quoted in Part I. Keep a litigation reserve: the debtor’s standard counter-move is a request to stretch the schedule under Article 275 or to substitute capital for annuity under Article 276-4, and the creditor who arrives with bank statements, proof of the debtor’s lifestyle and a clean computation wins those hearings. Throughout, coordinate with the notaire liquidating the matrimonial property: Article 275 allows the creditor, after liquidation of the regime, to petition for payment of the indexed balance, so the final property accounts and the enforcement file should advance together rather than in isolation.

Limitation periods close the picture. The standard five-year limitation for enforcing a money judgment runs from each due date, and each enforcement act — a commandement, a seizure, even a registered demand acknowledged by the debtor — restarts the clock. In practice, never let an unpaid instalment sleep: diary every due date, send the demand within weeks, and instruct the commissaire de justice within the quarter. Stale claims invite the debtor’s prescription defence and halve your negotiating power.

Conclusion

An unpaid prestation compensatoire is not a moral defeat but a collection file like any other — with better tools than most. Read the judgment to identify capital, staged capital or annuity; activate the Article 277 guarantees and precautionary seizures before assets vanish; enforce through the commissaire de justice with exact indexation; and where your ex has left France, transmit the order through the European maintenance system rather than accepting that borders end obligations. The debtors who escape are usually those whose creditors waited, computed loosely or seized in the wrong country — errors this guide now lets you avoid. Put the file in order, move quickly, and make the judgment pay what the judge intended.

📄 Official circular