KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Flight diverted to Nantes: who pays the transfer and when is EU261 compensation due?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Flight diverted to Nantes: who pays the transfer and when is EU261 compensation due?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An Irish Google Trends spike on 27 October 2026 followed press reports about flights diverted after an in-flight medical emergency. The Irish search suggestions attached to that spike included “flight diverted to Nantes”, “flight diverted to Toulouse” and “flight diverted compensation”. The reports themselves are not official findings about fault, and they do not establish that any passenger is owed a particular sum. They show the practical question that arises when a flight booked to France lands elsewhere or reaches the booked destination several hours late.

This article answers that question under French and European passenger law. The governing rules are Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, the Montreal Convention and, where relevant, French contract and tourism provisions. A diversion to another airport does not automatically cancel every right, and a medical event or storm does not automatically erase every claim. The route, the final arrival time, the reason proved by the carrier and the expenses actually incurred must be separated. The contemporary reports used for the trend context are Dublin Live’s account of an emergency diversion, the Coventry Telegraph report of a flight landing at Newcastle after an alert, The National’s report quoting the carrier’s spokesperson. They are press sources, so the legal analysis below stays general and does not attribute a breach to the carrier identified in those reports.

I. When a flight diverted to Nantes or Toulouse reaches another airport: scope, transfer and rerouting

A. Does EU261 apply when the departure is in Ireland and the arrival is in France?

The first question is jurisdictional. A flight from Ireland to France departs from an airport in a Member State. A flight from a non-EU country to France can also fall under the regulation when the operating carrier is a Community carrier and the passenger has not already received equivalent protection in the country of departure. A Bordeaux judicial judgment applying Article 3 records the operative rule as follows: “aux passagers au départ d’un aéroport situé sur le territoire d’un état membre soumis aux dispositions du traité” (Bordeaux Judicial Court, 10 March 2025, no. 23/00363) (passengers departing from an airport in a Member State covered by the Treaty). A booking that starts in Ireland and is supposed to finish in France therefore sits inside the EU framework even if the aircraft lands temporarily in another country. The second limb of Article 3 covers certain arrivals from a non-EU country on a Community carrier, subject to the protection already received at departure.

The passenger must still show a confirmed reservation and compliance with the check-in requirement. The Court of Cassation applied that proof rule in a case concerning a delayed international flight: “il résulte de l’article 3, § 2, sous a), du règlement n° 261/2004 que le régime énoncé par ce règlement est applicable à condition que les passagers disposent d’une réservation confirmée pour le vol concerné et se présentent, sauf en cas d’annulation visée à l’article 5, à l’enregistrement” (First Civil Chamber, 14 February 2018, appeal no. 16-23.205) (the regime applies when passengers hold a confirmed reservation and present themselves for check-in, except in a cancellation). The decision is a warning about evidence: a booking email alone may not prove that the passenger actually checked in or boarded.

The legal contract remains relevant alongside the European regulation. Article 1103 of the French Civil Code provides: “Les contrats légalement formés tiennent lieu de loi à ceux qui les ont faits.” (Legifrance, Article 1103) (lawfully formed contracts bind the parties as law). Article 1104 adds: “Les contrats doivent être négociés, formés et exécutés de bonne foi. Cette disposition est d’ordre public.” (Legifrance, Article 1104) (contracts must be negotiated, formed and performed in good faith, and that rule is mandatory). These provisions do not replace the fixed amounts and choices in Regulation 261/2004. They help frame a separate claim where a proven contractual loss is not covered by the flat-rate system.

For international carriage, French transport law directs the analysis to Montreal. Article L. 6421-4 of the Code des transports states: “La responsabilité du transporteur aérien ne relevant pas de l’article L. 6421-3 est régie par la convention pour l’unification de certaines règles relatives au transport aérien international signée à Montréal le 28 mai 1999” (Legifrance, Article L. 6421-4) (the carrier’s liability, outside the domestic provision cited, is governed by the Montreal Convention). The route and the type of loss therefore matter. A passenger should identify whether the request is the Article 7 flat-rate compensation, reimbursement of necessary care expenses, or proof-based damages for a distinct loss.

The destination printed on the booking remains the reference point when the plane lands at a substitute airport. A carrier cannot turn an unplanned landing into an unagreed new destination merely by closing the aircraft door. The passenger should record the booked airport, the airport where disembarkation occurred, the time of landing, the time of the onward transfer and the time of arrival at the booked destination. Those facts allow the transfer-cost rule and the arrival-delay rule to be examined separately.

B. Who pays the transfer from an alternate French airport?

Article 8(3) of Regulation 261/2004 addresses the situation directly: “Dans le cas d’une ville, d’une agglomération ou d’une région desservie par plusieurs aéroports, si le transporteur aérien effectif propose au passager un vol à destination d’un aéroport autre que celui qui était initialement prévu, le transporteur aérien effectif prend à sa charge les frais de transfert des passagers entre l’aéroport d’arrivée et l’aéroport initialement prévu ou une autre destination proche convenue avec le passager.” (Paris Judicial Court, 20 January 2026, no. 25/03013) (when a passenger is offered a flight to an airport different from the one originally planned in a city, agglomeration or region with several airports, the operating carrier pays the transfer between the arrival airport and the originally planned airport, or another nearby destination agreed with the passenger).

This rule is practical. If a ticket names Nantes and the aircraft lands at another airport, the carrier should arrange or pay the reasonable onward transport to Nantes or to another nearby destination accepted by the passenger. If the carrier offers a bus, the passenger should ask for the route, the departure time and confirmation that the service is free. If no workable solution is offered and the passenger must buy a train, coach or taxi, the safest file contains the receipt, the payment record, the time of the request, the carrier’s response and a short explanation of why the purchase was necessary. Article 8 does not create an unlimited budget for discretionary upgrades or unrelated travel.

Article 8(1) also gives a choice between refund and rerouting. Its operative wording is: “les passagers se voient proposer le choix entre: a) le remboursement du billet, dans un délai de sept jours …; b) un réacheminement vers leur destination finale, dans des conditions de transport comparables et dans les meilleurs délais, ou c) un réacheminement vers leur destination finale dans des conditions de transport comparables à une date ultérieure, à leur convenance” (Paris Judicial Court, 20 January 2026, no. 25/03013) (passengers choose a refund within seven days, prompt comparable rerouting, or comparable rerouting later at their convenience). Choosing reimbursement and then arranging an entirely new journey can change which care costs remain recoverable, so the choice should be made after the carrier has explained the options.

A January 2026 judgment of the Paris judicial court reproduced the same transfer rule and applied the evidence principle to a passenger’s purchase of replacement tickets. The court recorded: “frais de transfert des passagers entre l’aéroport d’arrivée et l’aéroport initialement prévu ou une autre destination proche convenue avec le passager” and then held that the claimant had proved the purchase of five tickets totalling 1,044.99 euros (Paris Judicial Court, 20 January 2026, no. 25/03013) (the transfer costs are those between the arrival airport and the planned airport or an agreed nearby destination, and the proven ticket expenditure was awarded). The case does not mean every passenger automatically recovers every receipt. It shows why the booking, the agreed destination and the purchase trail must be legible.

A May 2026 judgment from Nantes concerned a flight diverted because the runway was closed. The court stated: “Il est constant que le vol a été détourné vers [Localité 4] en raison d’une fermeture de la piste d’atterrissage … Cette nouvelle destination a entrainé une arrivée de plus de 3 heures à [Localité 3] par rapport à l’horaire initialement prévu” (Nantes Judicial Court, 22 May 2026, no. 24/02726) (the flight was diverted because the runway was closed, and the new destination caused arrival more than three hours later than initially scheduled). The court then awarded 400 euros to each of two passengers under Article 7, stating that no force majeure had been proved. The judgment is useful because it separates the physical diversion from the later arrival time: landing elsewhere does not end the analysis.

Care is a different right from compensation. The Court of Cassation described the hotel component in these terms: “le règlement n° 261/2004 reconnaît aux passagers, en cas de vol dont le départ est retardé par rapport à l’heure prévue, le droit à la prise en charge d’un hébergement à l’hôtel dans l’hypothèse où un séjour d’attente est nécessaire” (First Civil Chamber, 14 February 2018, appeal no. 16-20.354) (the regulation gives passengers a right to hotel care when an overnight wait is necessary). The same decision treated care as distinct from a separate, proven delay loss. In practical terms, reasonable meals, accommodation and airport transport should be requested first from the carrier and supported by receipts; the entitlement is care during the wait, not a cash payment unrelated to actual care.

The passenger should ask the carrier for a written explanation of the diversion, the planned transfer and the rights offered. Photographing the departure board, the airport notice and the carrier’s messages can support the chronology. The Court of Cassation’s evidence decision at appeal no. 16-23.205 shows why a booking email without proof of check-in may be insufficient.

The site already contains a broader explainer on a diverted flight landing at another airport and the passenger’s transfer, hotel and compensation options. This article adds the narrower Nantes/Toulouse query raised by the Irish trend and explains how the medical-emergency or storm reason affects the separate compensation question.

II. When does a diversion trigger flat compensation, care and a damages claim?

A. Medical emergency or storm: an extraordinary circumstance is not automatic

Article 5(3) creates a narrow defence to the flat-rate payment: “Un transporteur aérien effectif n’est pas tenu de verser l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 s’il est en mesure de prouver que l’annulation est due à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises.” (Toulouse Judicial Court, 21 May 2026, no. 25/02274) (the carrier is exempt from Article 7 compensation only if it proves that the cancellation was caused by extraordinary circumstances that could not have been avoided even with all reasonable measures). The wording puts the burden on the carrier. A passenger does not have to prove that the carrier acted badly before asking the carrier to explain the event and its operational consequences.

Recital 14 gives examples: “De telles circonstances peuvent se produire, en particulier, en cas d’instabilité politique, de conditions météorologiques incompatibles avec la réalisation du vol concerné, de risques liés à la sécurité, de défaillances imprévues pouvant affecter la sécurité du vol, ainsi que de grèves ayant une incidence sur les opérations d’un transporteur aérien effectif.” (Toulouse Judicial Court, 21 May 2026, no. 25/02274) (examples include weather incompatible with the flight, security risks, unforeseen safety failures and strikes affecting the carrier’s operations). A medical emergency involving a passenger may explain an immediate diversion, but the press report alone does not establish how the later delay was managed, whether the aircraft continued, whether a replacement aircraft was available or whether the final arrival exceeded the Article 7 threshold. The same discipline applies to a storm: weather may be extraordinary for a particular flight, yet the carrier must connect the proven weather event to the cancelled or delayed service.

The Court of Cassation illustrates the required proof. In its 12 September 2018 judgment, it held: “ayant constaté que l’avion stationné à l’aéroport de Bordeaux-Mérignac … avait été foudroyé, la juridiction de proximité a pu retenir l’existence de circonstances extraordinaires, au sens de l’article 5, § 3, de nature à exonérer … du paiement de l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7” (First Civil Chamber, 12 September 2018, appeal no. 17-11.361) (after finding that the aircraft had been struck by lightning, the lower court could treat that event as extraordinary and exempt the carrier from Article 7 compensation). The Court also relied on findings that engineers inspected the aircraft and that the carrier had arranged a replacement aircraft. The lesson is evidential: a label such as “operational reasons” or “medical issue” is not the complete defence.

A September 2026 Brest judgment applied the same logic to a long intra-EU delay: “Le transporteur aérien ne peut s’exonérer de cette obligation qu’à charge pour lui de démontrer que le retard du vol est imputable à une circonstance extraordinaire, qui doit être entendue comme résultant d’un événement qui n’est pas inhérent à l’exercice normal de son activité et échappe à sa maîtrise.” (Brest Judicial Court, 1 September 2026, no. 26/00886) (the carrier can escape the obligation only by proving that the delay is attributable to an extraordinary event outside the normal operation of the business and outside its control). The court awarded 400 euros for an arrival more than three hours late because the carrier supplied no exonerating cause. This is an individual judgment, not a rule that every similar case will receive the same result.

If the diversion ends with the passenger more than three hours late at the final destination, Article 7 sets a flat amount by distance. A Bordeaux judgment reproduces the scale: “il est prévu une indemnité de 250,00 euros pour toute annulation sur un vol de 1500,00 kilomètres ou moins, de 400,00 euros pour les vols extracommunautaires de 1500 à 3500 kilomètres, de 600,00 euros pour tous les vols qui ne relèvent pas des autres points” (Bordeaux Judicial Court, 10 March 2025, no. 23/00363) (the judgment lists 250 euros up to 1,500 kilometres, 400 euros for the intermediate band and 600 euros for longer flights). The exact band depends on the route and the regulation’s definitions, and a valid rerouting can reduce the amount when the Article 7(2) arrival limits are met. Every sentence about a three-hour threshold in a claim should carry an official decision or text link because the threshold comes from the governing rule, not from a general estimate.

The Court of Cassation also distinguishes the fixed payment from proven additional loss. In its 14 February 2018 judgment, it stated that the regulation “reconnaît aux passagers, en cas de vol dont le départ est retardé par rapport à l’heure prévue, le droit à la prise en charge d’un hébergement à l’hôtel dans l’hypothèse où un séjour d’attente est nécessaire” and that the regulation applies “sans préjudice du droit d’un passager à une indemnisation complémentaire” (First Civil Chamber, 14 February 2018, appeal no. 16-20.354) (passengers have a right to hotel care when an overnight wait is necessary, without prejudice to complementary compensation). The case relied on Article 19 of the Montreal Convention for a proven delay loss. It does not turn every inconvenience into a second award; it requires a distinct, documented loss and the correct legal basis.

A 2025 Bordeaux judgment concerning a missed connection under a single booking applied Article 7 and recorded that passengers reached their final destination more than three hours late. The court wrote: “S’agissant d’un vol au départ d’un aéroport européen les demandeurs peuvent légitimement se prévaloir de l’application du règlement européen (CE) 261/2004” (Bordeaux Judicial Court, 10 March 2025, no. 23/00363) (for a flight leaving a European airport, the claimants could rely on Regulation 261/2004). The decision awarded 500 euros in the dispute before it, while the regulation’s own Article 7 amounts remain the starting point. The comparison shows why the route, final destination and booking structure must be stated instead of relying on a headline figure.

B. How to build an English claim from France: evidence, request, mediation and court

A passenger who lands at a French substitute airport should make a contemporaneous file. Keep the booking confirmation, boarding pass or digital check-in record, baggage tag, the carrier’s diversion or incident message, screenshots of the scheduled and actual times, the airport name shown on the board, and every receipt for food, accommodation, rail, coach or taxi transport. Note the exact words used by staff when they refuse a transfer or say that reimbursement is impossible. A short written request made at the airport is easier to prove later than a memory reconstructed weeks afterward.

French evidence rules are simple but strict. Article 1353 of the Civil Code says: “Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver. Réciproquement, celui qui se prétend libéré doit justifier le paiement ou le fait qui a produit l’extinction de son obligation.” (Legifrance, Article 1353) (the person claiming performance must prove it, and the person who says they are released must prove payment or the event that extinguished the obligation). Article 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure uses similar language: “Il incombe à chaque partie de prouver conformément à la loi les faits nécessaires au succès de sa prétention.” (Legifrance, Article 9) (each party must prove, according to law, the facts necessary for its claim). The 2018 Court of Cassation decision on a delayed flight rejected a claim where the booking and a non-nominative delay certificate did not prove that the passengers had presented themselves for the flight (appeal no. 16-23.205). Evidence of boarding and final arrival therefore matters as much as the wording of the complaint.

The initial request should separate the heads of claim. First, identify the Article 8 choice: refund or rerouting. Second, identify Article 9 care expenses, with each receipt. Third, request Article 7 compensation if the final arrival threshold is met and the carrier cannot prove an extraordinary circumstance. Fourth, reserve a distinct Montreal or contract claim only for a loss that is not already covered by the flat payment. This structure prevents the carrier from treating a hotel receipt as if it were the Article 7 amount, or treating a flat payment as if it automatically settled a separate proven loss.

The refund clock in Article 8(1)(a) is explicit: the regulation refers to reimbursement “dans un délai de sept jours” (Paris Judicial Court, 20 January 2026, no. 25/03013) (within seven days). A passenger who chose rerouting should not simultaneously request a full refund for the same unused journey without explaining the alternative claim. The choice and the chronology should be stated in one paragraph, with the booking reference and the final airport.

If the flight was sold as part of a package or a linked travel arrangement, the travel organiser may have an additional role. Article L. 211-16 of the French Tourism Code begins: “Le professionnel qui vend un forfait touristique mentionné au 1° du I de l’article L. 211-1 est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage” (Legifrance, Article L. 211-16) (the professional selling a package is automatically responsible for performance, whether the services are performed by that professional or by other travel providers). The passenger should address the airline for the operating-flight rights and the organiser for the package-performance issue, while avoiding double recovery for the same loss.

For an unresolved consumer dispute, Article L. 616-1 of the Consumer Code provides: “Tout professionnel communique au consommateur … les coordonnées du ou des médiateurs compétents dont il relève. Le professionnel est également tenu de fournir cette même information au consommateur, dès lors qu’un litige n’a pas pu être réglé dans le cadre d’une réclamation préalable” (Legifrance, Article L. 616-1) (the professional must give the consumer the details of the competent mediator and repeat that information after a dispute has not been resolved by a prior complaint). This is a route to an amicable process, not proof that the passenger has won. Check the carrier’s current mediator information and keep the initial complaint and the response.

Where no transport was supplied, French consumer law also contains a specific tax-and-fee refund rule. Article L. 224-66 states: “Les transporteurs aériens et les personnes physiques ou morales commercialisant des titres de transport aérien remboursent les taxes et redevances individualisées et affichées comme telles dans le prix du titre qu’ils ont vendu, dont l’exigibilité procède de l’embarquement effectif du passager, lorsque le titre n’est plus valide et n’a pas donné lieu à transport.” (Legifrance, Article L. 224-66) (air carriers and sellers of air tickets refund itemised taxes and charges that became due only upon actual boarding when the ticket is no longer valid and no carriage occurred). This provision concerns those itemised amounts; it does not replace the Regulation 261/2004 refund or compensation analysis.

Finally, Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code states: “Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure.” (Legifrance, Article 1231-1) (the debtor may be ordered to pay damages for non-performance or delay unless performance was prevented by force majeure). In an air-passenger file, that general rule must be read with the Montreal Convention, Regulation 261/2004 and the contract’s facts. It cannot be used to bypass the European regulation’s definitions or to assert that a press report has already established fault.

The written request should end with a clear amount and a document list. Ask the carrier to state the operating carrier, the reason it relies on, the evidence for that reason, the final arrival time used, the transfer it arranged and the payment decision for each receipt. If the response invokes “extraordinary circumstances” without identifying the event, its duration and the reasonable measures taken, ask for those missing particulars once and preserve the answer. A judge can decide the dispute; the article cannot decide it from the trend or from a headline.

Conclusion

A flight diverted away from Nantes or Toulouse creates several separate legal questions. Regulation 261/2004 can apply because the journey departs from an EU airport or arrives in France on an EU carrier. Article 8 gives the passenger a choice between reimbursement and comparable rerouting, and Article 8(3) places reasonable transfer costs between the substitute and planned airports on the operating carrier when the rule’s multi-airport conditions are met. Article 9 covers meals, accommodation and airport transport during the wait. Article 7 may add a flat payment when the final arrival passes the relevant threshold, unless the carrier proves an extraordinary event that could not have been avoided with reasonable measures. A medical emergency or storm can be part of that proof, but the label alone is not proof.

The strongest file records the booked destination, the alternate airport, every request for help, every receipt, the final arrival time and the carrier’s explanation. French evidence rules require each side to prove the facts supporting its position. A package organiser, mediator and the courts may have roles alongside the operating carrier, while Montreal and French contract law remain available for a distinct, documented loss. The Irish trend explains why the question is urgent; the verified texts and decisions determine the answer in the individual file.

📄 Official circular