On 16 October 2026, Reuters reported that Arcom, the French media and digital regulator, has opened an investigation into a France-based subscription content platform offering adult material, over suspected breaches of the European Union’s Digital Services Act. According to Reuters, Arcom sent the platform a formal request for information on 14 October, giving it fifteen days to respond or face sanctions, after a preliminary review raised concerns about child protection and transparency. The platform did not immediately respond to the request for comment, Reuters added.
For readers outside France, the story matters far beyond one company. Creators who earn a living on French platforms, subscribers who pay from London, New York, Montreal or Sydney, and businesses that advertise or process payments through these services all depend on the same legal chain: French criminal law on the protection of minors, French hosting liability rules, and European platform regulation enforced nationally by Arcom. When that chain moves, foreign users feel it in their payouts, their accounts and their contracts. The developments that follow are general in scope: they describe the checks that are useful in any comparable situation and do not describe the situation of any particular company, about which this article makes no finding. No breach has been established by any authority or court at the time of writing, signed contracts prevail over any general analysis, and only the regulator and, ultimately, the courts decide.
I. Why a French regulator can pursue a platform used around the world
A. How do French courts catch foreign websites and the companies hosting them?
Foreign readers often assume that a website edited abroad sits beyond the reach of French judges. Two decisions of the Cour de cassation show the opposite, and both matter directly for anyone using a French platform from another country.
In a judgment of 23 November 2022 (pourvoi no. 21-10.220, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2022:C100829), the First Civil Chamber ruled on a Spanish surrogacy intermediation site hosted in France by the company OVH. The association Juristes pour l’enfance had notified OVH and asked it to make the site inaccessible from France, arguing that surrogacy brokerage is prohibited and criminally punished under French law. The court approved the reasoning of the court of appeal, holding in its own words:
The court added that the court of appeal had “ainsi caractérisé l’existence d’un dommage subi par l’association sur le territoire français au regard de la loi s’y appliquant et justement retenu que la société OVH, qui n’avait pas promptement réagi pour rendre inaccessible en France le site litigieux, avait manqué aux obligations prévues à l’article 6. I. 2, de la loi du 21 juin 2004.” Three lessons follow for an international audience. First, a site edited under foreign law can still be judged “manifestement illicite” under French law when it explicitly contradicts unambiguous French prohibitions and targets a French audience, evidenced by language, clientele and marketing. Second, damage suffered on French territory brings French law into play. Third, a host that does not act promptly to cut off access from France breaches its duties under Article 6-I.2 of the law of 21 June 2004 on confidence in the digital economy (Article 6 of the LCEN, the statute of 21 June 2004 on confidence in the digital economy).
The second decision tightens the net around notification. On 26 February 2025 (pourvoi no. 23-15.966, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:C100131), the same chamber ruled against the hosting company DStorage, operator of the 1fichier.com storage site, sued by Nintendo and others over unauthorised copies of video games. The court restated the liability standard of the LCEN, as amended, in the following terms:
The judgment then recalls that under Article 6-I.5, knowledge is presumed once a notification contains, among other elements, “la description des faits litigieux et leur localisation précise” and “les motifs pour lesquels le contenu doit être retiré, comprenant la mention des dispositions légales et des justifications de faits”. For a foreign creator or right holder, the message is practical: a notification that precisely locates the content and cites the legal provisions starts the clock, and a host that stays passive afterwards answers for it. Conversely, a platform that receives a defective or vague complaint keeps a real defence, which is why every exchange with a host or platform should be written, dated and precise.
B. Why are platforms carrying adult content the priority target?
The two suspected breach areas reported by Reuters, protection of minors and transparency, sit at the exact intersection where French criminal law is strictest and where Arcom has already tested its weapons in court.
Article 227-24 of the Criminal Code (official text) provides: “Le fait soit de fabriquer, de transporter, de diffuser par quelque moyen que ce soit et quel qu’en soit le support un message à caractère violent, incitant au terrorisme, pornographique, y compris des images pornographiques impliquant un ou plusieurs animaux, ou de nature à porter gravement atteinte à la dignité humaine ou à inciter des mineurs à se livrer à des jeux les mettant physiquement en danger, soit de faire commerce d’un tel message, est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende lorsque ce message est susceptible d’être vu ou perçu par un mineur.” The same article closes a loophole that every platform operator knows: “Les infractions prévues au présent article sont constituées y compris si l’accès d’un mineur aux messages mentionnés au premier alinéa résulte d’une simple déclaration de celui-ci indiquant qu’il est âgé d’au moins dix-huit ans.” A tick-box “I am 18” declaration therefore protects neither the publisher nor, by extension, the platform that distributes the message. Alongside it, Article 227-22 (official text) punishes facilitating the corruption of a minor: “Le fait de favoriser ou de tenter de favoriser la corruption d’un mineur est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende.” Article 227-23 (official text) goes further for images of minors: “Le fait, en vue de sa diffusion, de fixer, d’enregistrer ou de transmettre l’image ou la représentation d’un mineur lorsque cette image ou cette représentation présente un caractère pornographique est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende.”
Arcom has already taken this arsenal to court against foreign-edited adult sites. On 5 January 2023 (case no. B 22-40.017, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2023:C100092), the First Civil Chamber refused to refer to the Constitutional Council the challenge brought by the publishers of well-known pornographic sites against the Arcom blocking procedure. The facts recorded by the court are worth quoting because they describe the standard Arcom playbook: “Les 13 et 15 juillet 2022, exposant que les sites internet pornographiques Pornhub, Tukif, Xhamster, Xnxx et Xvideos sont accessibles aux mineurs sur simple déclaration de leur part indiquant qu’ils sont âgés d’au moins dix-huit ans, en violation de l’article 227-24 du code pénal, le président de l’Autorité de régulation de la communication audiovisuelle et numérique (ARCOM) a assigné les sociétés Orange, Orange Caraïbe, Free, Free mobile, Bouygues Telecom, Colt Technologies services, Française du radio téléphone, SFR fibre, Réunionnaise du téléphone et Outremer Telecom devant le président du tribunal judiciaire de Paris sur le fondement de l’article 23 de la loi n° 2020-936 du 30 juillet 2020 aux fins de voir ordonner qu’elles mettent fin à l’accès à ces sites.” That law is the statute of 30 July 2020 on the protection of victims of domestic violence (Article 23 of that statute, whose Article 23 created the site-blocking track),
The court’s answer consolidated three points that still frame every Arcom action. First, the fifteen-day formal notice mechanism is lawful: the court describes Article 23 as “donnant la possibilité au président de l’ARCOM, qui constate qu’une personne, dont l’activité est d’éditer un service de communication au public en ligne, permet à des mineurs d’avoir accès à un contenu pornographique en violation de l’article 227-24 précité, de saisir le président du tribunal judiciaire de Paris pour qu’il soit mis fin à l’accès à ce service, dès lors que l’éditeur n’a pas déféré sous quinze jours à la mise en demeure qui lui a été adressée.” Second, requiring real age verification is proportionate: “l’atteinte portée à la liberté d’expression, en imposant de recourir à un dispositif de vérification de l’âge de la personne accédant à un contenu pornographique, autre qu’une simple déclaration de majorité, est nécessaire, adaptée et proportionnée à l’objectif de protection des mineurs.” Third, Article 227-24 itself is drafted clearly enough to exclude any risk of arbitrary enforcement. The court therefore held: “il n’y a pas lieu de renvoyer la question au Conseil constitutionnel.”
The criminal chamber confirmed the solidity of Article 227-24 once more on 5 February 2025 (no. C 24-86.532, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:CR00300), refusing again to refer a constitutional challenge and noting that “le texte contesté, dont il appartient au juge d’apprécier les conditions d’application à chaque situation qui lui est soumise, d’une part, a été considéré comme nécessaire par le législateur pour assurer la protection des mineurs, d’autre part, n’a pas institué une peine manifestement disproportionnée au regard de l’objectif poursuivi.” The same reading is much older than the platform era. On 12 October 2005 (pourvoi no. 05-80.713, Criminal Chamber), rejecting the appeal of a teacher convicted over pornographic photographs stored on a classroom computer, the court approved the finding that “qu’il n’est besoin de rechercher si ces photographies à caractère pornographique ont été effectivement vues par des mineurs, le délit poursuivi exigeant seulement qu’elles aient été susceptibles d’être vues ou perçues par des mineurs”. Mere potential access by a minor has therefore sufficed for twenty years, long before any debate about tick-boxes and age gates.
Today’s investigation moves on a second rail as well. According to Reuters, Arcom acts under the Digital Services Act, for which a national coordinator for platforms established in France was designated by Article 44 of the statute of 21 May 2024 securing and regulating the digital space (Article 44 of that statute, in force since May 2024), The DSA adds to the criminal-law track a regulatory track: risk assessments, protection of minors by design, transparent terms of use, and explanations of recommender systems. The transparency grievances reported by Reuters, incomplete terms and unexplained recommendations, belong to that second track. A fifteen-day information request is the opening of a procedure, not a penalty, and it should not be confused with the fifteen-day formal notice of Article 23 described above, which belongs to the site-blocking procedure before the Paris court. Both tracks can run in parallel, and both can end, if nothing is fixed, in court orders or fines. These national instruments now operate together with the European regulation, with Arcom acting as the French coordinator for digital services.
II. What foreign creators, subscribers and business partners should do now
A. How do you protect your income, your contracts and your content?
When a platform that pays creators across borders comes under regulatory scrutiny, the first casualties are rarely legal theories. They are payouts held for “verification”, accounts frozen pending new identity checks, advertising campaigns suspended, and content removed without a clear explanation. Foreign users should therefore treat the investigation period as a time to secure evidence, not as a time to panic or to sign away rights.
Start with money. Download, month by month, every statement of earnings, every invoice or self-billed invoice, every notice of withholding, and every trace of transfers to your bank, including the platform’s terms of use in force on the day each sum became due. If payouts slow down or stop, these documents decide whether you face a simple delay, a contractual dispute over payment terms, or a sum worth recovering through a formal demand. Keep also the messages in which the platform explains, or fails to explain, the hold: under the transparency logic now enforced, vague or shifting justifications weaken the platform’s position and strengthen yours. Creators who work through a company should reconcile platform statements with their own accounting immediately, because tax administrations in their home country will not accept “the platform changed its dashboard” as an explanation for missing income records.
Continue with contracts. The terms of use are the law between you and the platform until a judge says otherwise, and they usually contain three clauses that become decisive in a crisis: the clause allowing the platform to suspend or terminate accounts, the clause setting the law and the court competent for disputes, and the clause allocating responsibility for the legality of uploaded content. Read them in the version applicable to each transaction, save a dated copy, and check whether amendments were notified properly. Many creators discover too late that they accepted, by a single click, a clause sending disputes to a court far from home or a clause letting the platform withhold funds for broadly defined “investigations”. If you earn significant income through the service, have those clauses reviewed before the dispute crystallises, because renegotiating after a freeze is always harder.
Protect content next. Creators should keep, outside the platform, the originals of everything they monetise, with dates, drafts and proof of authorship, including the age-verification records of everyone appearing in adult content and the written releases for each shoot. If the platform is ordered to remove content or to reinforce its checks, the creators who can immediately prove consent, majority and authorship will be the first to have their accounts restored and the last to face accusations. Subscribers have a lighter but real task: keep receipts and bank statements for every payment, note the dates on which content they paid for disappeared, and use chargeback procedures through their card issuer only after a written complaint to the platform has gone unanswered, since banks ask for that paper trail.
Businesses advertising on or through creator platforms face a distinct exposure. French law now frames commercial influence in detail through the statute of 9 June 2023 on commercial influence and the fight against abuses on social networks (Article 1 of that statute), and an advertiser whose products are promoted to minors, or whose campaigns run alongside unlawful content, can be drawn into the same regulatory conversation as the platform. Audit where your advertisements actually appear, suspend placements you cannot verify, and keep the insertion orders and brand-safety guarantees your agency gave you. Payment processors and banks handling the platform’s flows should likewise map their exposure, document their own vigilance measures, and avoid abrupt account closures that could themselves generate liability toward lawful clients.
B. What procedure lies ahead, and how do you defend yourself in France?
Understanding the sequence helps foreign readers calibrate their response instead of overreacting to headlines. The step reported by Reuters, a formal request for information with a short deadline, is an evidence-gathering measure: the regulator asks questions and the platform answers. If the answers are unsatisfactory, the instruments described in the case law above become available. On the criminal-law track, Arcom can send the fifteen-day formal notice provided for by Article 23 of the 2020 statute and then ask the president of the Paris judicial court to order internet providers to cut access to the service. On the regulatory track, the coordinator can pursue the DSA enforcement chain, which runs from further information requests to binding orders and, at the end of the road, fines and, in extreme scenarios, restrictions on access. Each step requires its own legal basis, its own adversarial exchange and, for the most serious measures, a judge. Nothing in the reported facts suggests that any sanction has been pronounced, and readers should treat every hypothesis about the outcome as exactly that, a hypothesis.
For a foreign creator, the most underestimated risk is criminal, not regulatory. Uploading content that French law regards as pornographic and accessible to minors exposes the uploader to Article 227-24, quoted in full above, regardless of where the uploader lives, as soon as the message can be seen by a minor and French courts accept jurisdiction. The OVH precedent shows how easily French courts characterise targeting of the French public, through language, clientele and marketing, and from there assert the application of French law. A creator living abroad who addresses, even incidentally, a French-speaking audience on a French platform should therefore apply the strictest standard: verified majority of every participant, documented consent, and no content whose legality depends on a subtlety of foreign law. The question whether a video is lawful where the uploader lives is the wrong question; the right one is whether it is lawful in each country where the platform shows it, starting with France.
Paris plays a central procedural role that foreigners should know. The Paris judicial court hears Arcom’s blocking applications, Paris is where Arcom itself is seated, and French counsel admitted to the Paris bar will be needed for any filing, negotiation or hearing. If you receive any letter from Arcom, from the platform’s lawyers, or from a French association, do not answer on impulse, do not delete anything, and do not post about the case on the platform or on social networks. Confirm the sender, calendar the deadline stated in the letter itself, preserve every document in its original form, and seek advice before the deadline expires. Collective action has limits: creators sometimes coordinate public campaigns against a platform, but anything you publish during a regulatory procedure can be used to characterise your own conduct, so keep strategy inside the lawyer’s office.
Finally, keep the investigation in proportion. Regulatory scrutiny of a large platform is a recurring event in digital markets, and most such procedures end in compliance commitments, transparency improvements and reinforced age checks rather than in shutdowns. The sensible posture for a foreign user is therefore neither flight nor passivity: secure your money trail, freeze your contractual position in writing, back up your content and your proofs, and monitor the procedure through official sources, Arcom’s publications and court decisions, rather than through rumours. If payouts resume and the platform demonstrates compliance, you will have lost nothing and gained a file that protects you in any future dispute.
Conclusion
A French regulator asking tough questions of a creator platform under European rules is no longer an exotic event; it is the normal operation of a system built from Article 227-24 of the Criminal Code, the hosting duties of the LCEN, the blocking procedure of the 2020 statute, and the DSA enforcement entrusted to Arcom since 2024. The case law gives foreign readers the two reference points that matter: French courts reach foreign sites that target France, and they require platforms and hosts that have been precisely notified to act promptly. For creators, subscribers and business partners outside France, the lesson is practical rather than dramatic. Document income and contracts now, verify the age and consent behind every piece of content, read the platform’s terms before the crisis rewrites them, and treat any letter from a French authority as a deadline to be handled with counsel in Paris, not as a headline to be debated online. No finding has been made against anyone at this stage; preparation, not alarm, is what the moment calls for.