KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
France Extradition 2026: Paris Courts Demand Concrete Proof of Fair-Trial Guarantees Before Any Surrender

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

France Extradition 2026: Paris Courts Demand Concrete Proof of Fair-Trial Guarantees Before Any Surrender

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Can France hand you over to a country under martial law, to serve a life sentence imposed in your absence, or to face trial years after the events? In 2026, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation gave a consistent answer: yes, but only after concrete, case-specific proof that your fundamental guarantees will hold. Three rulings handed down in Paris this year reset the evidentiary bar for every extradition file pleaded before a French chambre de l’instruction. On 10 February 2026 (no. 25-86.478), the Court upheld the surrender of a man claimed by Ukraine after verifying the concrete fair-trial assurances transmitted by Kyiv, despite Ukraine’s war-time derogations from the European Convention on Human Rights. On 14 April 2026 (no. 25-85.155), it quashed a favourable opinion concerning a man claimed by Moldova, because his lawyer, taken ill the day before the hearing, had been denied an adjournment. On 27 May 2026 (no. 25-84-904), it upheld the surrender of a man claimed by Algeria to serve a life sentence imposed in absentia, after checking every legal box one by one. A fourth ruling, on a European Arrest Warrant from Romania (6 August 2025, no. 25-84-847), completes the picture: inside the European Union, mutual trust closes most exits, and any refusal must name precisely which fundamental right is at stake. This article explains, for requested persons and their lawyers, what Paris now demands from requesting states and how surrender hearings are won or lost.

I. Requesting states must now prove fundamental guarantees concretely, case by case

A. Will this person actually get a fair trial there? The question Paris must investigate before saying yes

The first 2026 ruling every defence lawyer should know came out of a Ukrainian file. The government of Ukraine transmitted, through diplomatic channels, a request for provisional arrest and then a full extradition request for criminal prosecution against a Ukrainian national living in France, wanted under a warrant issued on 2 October 2023 for large-scale cannabis cultivation, drug manufacturing and storage, and precursor offences committed in 2020, carrying up to ten years’ imprisonment, with an earlier suspended five-year sentence to be added on conviction. Arrested and placed under judicial supervision in September 2024, the man refused surrender. By a ruling of 5 February 2025, the Paris chambre de l’instruction ordered further inquiries precisely to clarify the risk to the rights guaranteed by Articles 3 and 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and on 17 September 2025 it issued a favourable opinion. The Cour de cassation rejected the appeal on 10 February 2026 (Cass. crim., 10 Feb. 2026, no. 25-86.478).

The defence argument was ambitious and deserves attention, because it shows what Paris expects to see argued with evidence. Counsel submitted that Ukraine had exercised its right to derogate from its international treaty obligations, in particular Articles 5 (liberty and security), 6 (fair trial), 8 (private and family life) and 13 (effective remedy) of the European Convention on Human Rights and Articles 9, 14 and 17 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and that restrictions on fair-trial and defence rights resulted from amendments to the Ukrainian Code of Criminal Procedure introduced by Law no. 2201-IX of 14 April 2022, in force since 1 May 2022, governing criminal proceedings under martial law. The question put to the Paris judges was therefore direct: had the entry into force of martial law, with its derogations, deprived the requested person of the fundamental guarantees for his security, his procedure and his defence rights?

The answer illustrates the method French courts now apply, and the lesson runs in both directions. The chambre de l’instruction did not content itself with general statements about the Ukrainian justice system. It examined the information communicated by the Ukrainian authorities on the detention conditions the person could face and on his access to counsel. It recorded that those authorities had guaranteed the person’s right to “un examen judiciaire équitable et public dans un délai raisonnable par un tribunal indépendant et impartial, ainsi que le droit à la défense et à l’assistance d’un avocat” and had indicated that only an investigating judge would decide on any pre-trial detention. From these concrete elements, the judges concluded that Ukraine had provided tangible guarantees both for the physical safety of the person if imprisoned and for detention conditions fully compatible with the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. The Cour de cassation endorsed that reasoning, holding that the chamber, which had answered the essential points of the defence memorial, had “souverainement écarté l’existence du risque d’atteintes aux droits fondamentaux excipé par la personne réclamée“.

Three practical consequences follow for anyone fighting an extradition request from a state in crisis, at war, or operating under emergency legislation. First, invoking the general situation of the requesting state is not enough: the Paris court requires an in concreto demonstration, file by file, of how the emergency regime affects this person, for these charges, in these detention facilities. Country reports, derogation notifications and legislative texts are starting points, not conclusions. Second, the requesting state can win by answering precisely: individualised assurances on judicial review of detention, access to counsel, and detention conditions, given case by case, carry decisive weight. Defence teams should therefore press early, through the chambre de l’instruction, for supplementary information (complément d’information) targeted at the exact gaps in the file: which prison, under which regime, with which remedy against ill-treatment, with which judge controlling detention. Third, the legal basis of this control is stable: Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure sets the bars to extradition, including political offences and cases where extradition is sought for an improper purpose, and Article 696-15 of the same Code requires the chambre de l’instruction to give a reasoned opinion, unfavourable where the legal conditions are not met. The 2026 case law turns these texts into a working method: no favourable opinion without a documented, individualised check of fundamental guarantees.

B. Even a life sentence imposed in absentia passes only after every legal box is ticked

The second 2026 ruling shows the same discipline applied to the heaviest possible penalty. On 27 May 2026, the Cour de cassation rejected the appeal of a man whose extradition Algeria had requested on 22 December 2023 for the enforcement of a sentence of life imprisonment (réclusion criminelle à perpétuité) imposed in absentia (par contumace) on 26 November 2023 by the criminal court of first instance of the Tipaza court of appeal, under an arrest warrant of 28 June 2022, for organised-group drug trafficking, storage and sale of narcotics and psychotropic substances and money laundering committed on 3 June 2022 (Cass. crim., 27 May 2026, no. 25-84-904).

What makes this ruling valuable for practitioners is the visible checklist. Before giving its favourable opinion, the chambre de l’instruction had ruled, across three earlier decisions, on the applicable extradition convention, the absence of any political character of the offences, the completeness of the documents supporting the request, the sentence-quantum condition, the absence of time-barring, and double criminality, and it had rejected the arguments based on arbitrary detention, on inhuman or degrading treatment linked to the life sentence, on vagueness of the statement of facts, and on the claim that the acts had been committed in France. The Cour de cassation confirmed that “la chambre de l’instruction n’a méconnu aucun des textes visés au moyen“.

The ruling also settles a recurring procedural trap. The final opinion had been delivered by a bench whose composition had partly changed, and the defence argued that the debates should have started over entirely and that the chamber could not simply refer back to decisions taken by a differently composed bench. The Court disagreed: the legal conditions and defence arguments had been examined, pleaded and decided with the same bench composition at each stage, so the reference back was lawful. For defence teams, the message is clear: when a file stretches over several hearings, challenge each condition as it is examined, because a point decided without objection at an earlier stage will be treated as decided. And for requested persons facing the most severe foreign sentences, the ruling confirms that a life sentence, even imposed in absentia, does not automatically block extradition where the chamber has verified, with reasons, each statutory condition and the Convention-based objections under Articles 3 and 5 of the European Convention.

Taken together, the Ukrainian and Algerian rulings define the 2026 standard: the requesting state must supply concrete, individualised material, and the Paris court must examine it condition by condition. Abstract denunciations fail; abstract reassurances fail too. Files are now won in the annexes: prison reports, judicial-control documents, individual guarantees, and complete files. Defence teams should also file the derogation instruments themselves, with their dates and scope, alongside evidence of how martial-law amendments change pre-trial detention, access to the file, and appellate review in the requesting state, so the chamber can measure the gap between paper guarantees and practice.

II. Paris hearings are won and lost on procedure, not only on the merits

A. A lawyer taken ill the day before the hearing can quash a surrender opinion

The most striking defence victory of the year came from a Moldovan file and had nothing to do with Moldova. On 20 October 2023, Moldova requested the extradition of one of its nationals for the enforcement of an eighteen-year prison sentence imposed on 21 February 2014 by the Chisinau court of appeal for attempted theft, robbery and voluntary homicide committed in 2010, the eighteen years resulting from consecutive sentences of two, nine and fourteen years. Arrested on 28 February 2025 and placed under an extradition detention order the next day, the man refused surrender. The Riom chambre de l’instruction twice ordered further inquiries and, on 17 June 2025, issued a favourable opinion. On 14 April 2026, the Cour de cassation quashed that opinion in its entirety and remanded the case to Lyon (Cass. crim., 14 Apr. 2026, no. 25-85.155).

The facts read like a cautionary tale for every extradition practice. The Moldovan authorities’ reply to the second inquiry reached the court registry late, on 12 June 2025 at 5:24 p.m., and was forwarded to defence counsel only on Friday 13 June at 5:05 p.m. Counsel had a scheduled medical procedure under anaesthesia on Monday 16 June, the day before the hearing, and asked for an adjournment. The chamber refused, on three grounds: counsel had known the hearing date when scheduling the procedure and could in any event send written documents, since the procedure is written; the assistance of counsel is optional in extradition proceedings; and the chamber had to give its reasoned opinion within the one-month period of Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, unless further inquiries had been ordered.

The Cour de cassation dismantled each ground. Endorsing Articles 6 § 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Articles 696-10, paragraph 2, 696-13 and 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, it restated the principle: “la personne réclamée a droit à l’assistance d’un avocat de son choix ou commis d’office“. Nothing in the ruling showed that the requested person had been heard on counsel’s adjournment request or had waived assistance, whether chosen or appointed, for preparing his defence after the late return of the second inquiry or for appearing before the court. And the general diligence requirement, the one-month period for the opinion, “ne pouvait en soi justifier le refus de report de l’audience” given the risk to the right to counsel created by counsel’s impediment, made worse by the late transmission of the new documents, and by counsel’s absence at the hearing. The chamber’s statement that counsel’s assistance is merely optional was, in substance, the error that sank the opinion.

The operational lessons are immediate and apply in every Paris extradition hearing. Never let the record suggest a waiver of counsel: if the chosen lawyer is unavailable, ask expressly on the record for appointed counsel or for time to instruct one, and make sure the court hears the requested person on that point. Document every late disclosure with timestamps, as counsel did here, because the combination of late prosecution material and an unavailable lawyer is precisely what the Court found decisive. And treat the one-month opinion period for what it is: a diligence rule with no sanction attached, which cannot by itself defeat the right to be defended. Since this ruling, any chamber tempted to push ahead without the requested person’s lawyer must reckon with a precedent that quashes the whole opinion.

B. Inside the European Union, mutual trust closes most exits and forces total precision

The fourth ruling shifts the scene inside the Union, where surrender under a European Arrest Warrant follows a stricter logic. Romania had issued a warrant on 30 January 2025 for the enforcement of a three-year-and-four-month sentence imposed on 27 June 2019 by the Brasov court of appeal for influence trading and complicity in abuse of office committed between 2006 and 2008. Arrested at home on 7 April 2025, the requested person refused surrender. On 9 July 2025, the Paris chambre de l’instruction refused to surrender him. The prosecution appealed, and on 6 August 2025 the Cour de cassation quashed the refusal and remanded the case to a differently composed Paris bench (Cass. crim., 6 Aug. 2025, no. 25-84-847).

The Paris judges had thrown everything into their refusal: two earlier refusals concerning the same person, in France in November 2023 and in Malta in May 2024, plus refusals in the United Kingdom and Greece for other persons convicted in the same Romanian case on unfair-trial grounds; the age of the facts and a long-running civil dispute with the Romanian state over a royal succession, in which the European Court of Human Rights had condemned Romania on 27 May 2010 for breach of the reasonable-time requirement; the deletion of the person’s data from Interpol files by the supervisory commission’s requests chamber, which had voiced serious concerns about political elements and human-rights compliance; and the age, health and family situation of the person concerned. They concluded that issuing the warrant was disproportionate and that executing it risked violating Article 1(3) of Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA.

The Cour de cassation’s correction is the passage every EAW practitioner should memorise: “l’exécution d’un mandat d’arrêt européen ne saurait être refusée pour des motifs autres que ceux que prévoient la décision-cadre et les textes pris pour son application“, subject to respect for the fundamental rights of the sought person and the founding principles of Article 6 of the Treaty on European Union, guaranteed by Article 1(3) of the Framework Decision. Two faults were fatal. First, disproportionality of issuance “qui ne figure pas parmi les motifs de non-exécution obligatoire ou facultative” provided for in Articles 3, 4 and 4 bis of the Framework Decision, a matter for the issuing authority alone. Second, by failing to specify which fundamental right execution would infringe, the chamber deprived the Cour de cassation of the ability to review its reasoning, in breach of the duty to give reasons recalled by Article 593 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, under which insufficient or contradictory reasoning equals absence of reasoning. On health-based arguments, the Court added that a chamber cannot anticipate a Member State’s inability to provide appropriate care in detention without seeking objective, precise and detailed evidence on that point. The defence’s invocation of the Court of Justice rulings of 31 January 2023 (C-158/21) and 29 July 2024 (C-318/24) did not require a preliminary reference, there being no reasonable doubt about the interpretation of the Union provisions at stake. The refusal grounds available in French law remain those of Articles 695-22 to 695-24 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, read in light of the Framework Decision.

For anyone facing a European Arrest Warrant in France, the method is therefore the mirror image of classic extradition: fewer exits, but each must be pleaded with surgical precision. Do not ask the Paris court to second-guess the proportionality assessed by the issuing judge; that door is shut. Do identify one listed ground for non-execution, name the exact fundamental right threatened, and support it with objective, precise and detailed material about this person: medical files, detention-establishment data, and, where care in detention is at issue, evidence tested through dialogue with the issuing authority rather than assumed. General context, however troubling, from Interpol-file deletions to foreign refusal decisions, only helps if tied to a specific right and a listed ground. The broader architecture of French surrender litigation, from provisional arrest on a foreign warrant to the final opinion stage, is mapped in our pillar analysis of how to challenge a foreign warrant after arrest in France, from provisional detention to the extradition opinion, which sets the procedural frame these 2026 rulings now fill with concrete content.

Conclusion

The 2026 case law draws a clear line through every surrender file pleaded in Paris. Requesting states outside the Union must earn surrender with concrete, individualised guarantees, verified condition by condition: fair and public hearing within a reasonable time, defence rights, counsel, judicial control of detention, compatible detention conditions. Requested persons defeat surrender the same way, with documented, person-specific proof rather than general denunciations, and by policing every procedural step, starting with the non-negotiable right to be assisted by counsel of one’s choice or appointed counsel. Inside the Union, the logic tightens further: mutual trust means the Paris court executes unless a listed ground for non-execution is established, tied to a named fundamental right and proven with objective evidence. Martial-law derogations, life sentences imposed in absentia, aged convictions, fragile health: none of these decides a file by itself any more. What decides it is the quality of the proof, the precision of the legal ground, and the integrity of the hearing. Parties facing a request should therefore build the file early, demand targeted supplementary information, timestamp every disclosure, and plead each condition separately, because Paris now reads extradition files the way auditors read accounts: line by line, and only the documented lines count.

📄 Official circular