KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
French Inheritance Law for American Families: Forced Heirship, the 2021 Compensatory Levy, and the France-US Estate Tax Treaty

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

French Inheritance Law for American Families: Forced Heirship, the 2021 Compensatory Levy, and the France-US Estate Tax Treaty

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An American family dealing with a French apartment, bank account, business interest, or family home can face three different legal questions at the same time. Which law determines who inherits? Can a French child or spouse challenge a will, trust, or lifetime gift? Which country is entitled to tax the estate, and how is double taxation relieved? French inheritance law does not answer those questions through citizenship alone. The decisive facts may include the deceased person’s habitual residence, a valid choice of law, the location of French real estate, the citizenship or residence of a child, and the wording of the France-US estate tax treaty. This guide explains the French concepts from the ground up for an American reader. “Reserved share” is the English idea closest to réserve héréditaire, the portion protected for certain heirs; the quotité disponible is the portion that may be given away freely. A notaire is a French civil-law notary who authenticates and administers many succession steps, but a notary’s involvement does not replace U.S. probate, tax, or trust advice. The practical objective is to identify the governing law, preserve evidence, calculate the protected share, and coordinate French and U.S. filings before an asset is sold or distributed.

Before you accept, sign or contest anything, have the file reviewed by an English-speaking family lawyer in Paris who handles inheritance matters for American and international families.

I. How does French forced heirship work for an American family?

A. What are the French reserved share and the freely disposable portion?

A French succession means the estate and the legal process by which the deceased person’s property, rights, and liabilities pass to the people entitled to receive them. Under Article 720 of the French Civil Code, “Les successions s’ouvrent par la mort, au dernier domicile du défunt.” In English, the succession opens at death and at the deceased person’s last domicile. That short rule matters because the date of death, the last residence, and the location of assets must be fixed before anyone can sensibly analyze a will or tax return.

The central French concept is the réserve héréditaire, or reserved share. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines it as “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires.” The English meaning is that the law protects a portion of the estate for certain heirs, called héritiers réservataires or reserved heirs. The remainder is the quotité disponible, the freely disposable portion. A will, gift, or trust arrangement can generally control that disposable portion, but it cannot be assessed in isolation from the reserve calculation.

Children and their descendants are the principal reserved heirs. The exact fraction depends on how many children are left at the deceased person’s death. Article 913 provides, in the original wording, “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” A libéralité is a gratuitous transfer, such as a lifetime gift or testamentary gift. The rule produces this basic map:

Children left at death French reserved share Freely disposable portion
One child One-half for the child One-half
Two children Two-thirds in total One-third
Three or more children Three-quarters in total One-quarter

Article 913-1, also available on Légifrance, states that descendants are counted through the child whose place they take in the succession. That can change the arithmetic when a child has died but grandchildren inherit by representation. Adoption, renunciation, prior gifts, marital property, life insurance, and the classification of a trust asset may also affect the calculation. A family should therefore avoid treating the table as a final distribution statement.

French forced heirship is not the same as a rule that every child receives an identified house or bank account. It is a value-based protection. If a parent gave a French house to one child, left the rest of the estate to a spouse, or named a U.S. trust as beneficiary, the question is whether the total benefits received by reserved heirs are at least their protected share. The remedy may be a cash payment or an adjustment rather than a forced sale of the asset. Under Article 924 of the Civil Code, “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité.” The recipient of the excessive transfer may therefore owe an indemnity to the reserved heirs.

For a general public explanation of French inheritance routes, the official Service-Public.fr inheritance guide distinguishes situations in which the deceased made a will from those in which there is no will. It is a useful orientation page, but it does not replace the cross-border analysis of a U.S. will, trust, treaty, or French asset.

This is why an American will or revocable living trust cannot be evaluated only by reading the beneficiary clause. The drafting question may have been valid under the law of a U.S. state, yet the French analysis can still require a conflict-of-laws review, a valuation of French property, and a comparison with the reserve. A joint account, transfer-on-death designation, LLC interest, or insurance policy also needs to be classified under the applicable law. The label “trust” does not by itself answer whether a French court or notary will treat the transfer as part of the succession, a prior gift, or a separate property arrangement.

French inheritance law also gives a reserved heir a defined period in which to act. Article 921 provides that “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” An action en réduction is an action to reduce gifts or testamentary provisions that exceed the disposable portion. The periods run from legally significant events, and notice, discovery, notarial correspondence, and prior gifts can become important evidence. An American heir should not assume that a U.S. probate deadline automatically replaces this French limitation rule.

B. When can French rules affect a U.S. will, trust, or French property?

The first cross-border question is not “Was the deceased American?” It is “Which law governs the succession?” The European Union’s Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 coordinates jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition, authentic instruments, and the European Certificate of Succession in participating EU countries. It applies in France even though the United States is not a party to the regulation. The regulation has universal application within its scope: a court in France may need to apply the law of a non-EU country, including the law of a U.S. state, when the connecting factors point there. Tax and administrative questions remain outside the regulation’s civil-law scope.

The normal connecting factor is the deceased person’s résidence habituelle, or habitual residence. That is a legal assessment of the center of the person’s life at death, not a simple count of hotel nights. A person who spent part of each year in France and part in New York may require a fact-intensive review of family life, work, health care, social ties, property, tax residence, and the length and regularity of stays. An American passport does not automatically make New York law applicable, and owning a French apartment does not automatically make the entire estate French.

The French Supreme Court illustrated the jurisdiction point in Cass. 1re civ., May 29, 2019, No. 18-13.383. The court quoted Article 4 of Regulation 650/2012: “sont compétentes pour statuer sur l’ensemble d’une succession les juridictions de l’État membre dans lequel le défunt avait sa résidence habituelle au moment de son décès.” In English, courts of the EU Member State where the deceased had habitual residence are generally competent for the succession as a whole. In that case, the deceased’s life was centered in New York, and the French court was not the court for the entire estate. That does not mean a French asset can be ignored; it means that global jurisdiction and local asset formalities must be separated.

A person may also make a choix de loi, or choice of law, in a compliant will by choosing the law of the person’s nationality. For an American, that point requires care. U.S. succession law is divided among states, and citizenship is not always enough to identify the state law that will govern a trust, probate estate, or elective share. The will should identify the intended law with the precision required by the regulation and by the relevant state’s private international law. A vague statement such as “U.S. law applies” can create a dispute rather than prevent one. A choice of law does not resolve tax, marital-property, or formal validity questions automatically.

French real estate deserves separate attention. In Cass. 1re civ., July 4, 2018, No. 17-16.515, the French Supreme Court stated that “la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire.” The case concerned French immovables and an earlier conflict-of-laws framework, so it should not be turned into a blanket rule that every French asset always applies French succession law. Its practical warning remains important: a French house or land interest can trigger French succession analysis even when the deceased lived abroad and left a foreign will.

At the same time, French courts do not reject every foreign law that lacks a reserved share. In Cass. 1re civ., Sept. 27, 2017, No. 16-13.151, the court held: “une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français.” The court examined the concrete effects of California law, the deceased person’s long residence in California, the location of the main assets, and the fact that the adult children were not shown to be in economic need. It accepted the foreign-law result in that case. This decision is a direct warning against both extremes: a French reserve is not automatically universal, but a U.S. will is not automatically immune from French review.

The 2021 change to Article 913 adds a narrower mechanism called the prélèvement compensatoire, or compensatory levy. The current text says that when the deceased person or at least one child was, at death, a national of an EU Member State or habitually resident in the EU, and the foreign succession law contains no protective mechanism for children, “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès.” The purpose is to restore the French reserved rights, within their limit, by taking from assets existing in France at death.

That condition matters for an American family. The 2021 compensatory levy is not a general right granted to every U.S. citizen who inherits a French asset. If the deceased and all children are U.S. nationals and none has the required EU habitual-residence connection, the specific statutory levy may not be available. A child who is also French or another EU national, or a deceased person who was habitually resident in the EU, can change the analysis. The applicable foreign law must also lack a protective child mechanism. This is a fact-sensitive remedy, not a shortcut around Regulation 650/2012, a valid choice of law, or the separate tax rules.

For a family using a U.S. trust, the safest sequence is therefore: identify the governing succession law; identify whether the 2021 Article 913 conditions are met; map French-situs assets that existed at death; then calculate the reserve and disposable portion. If a French asset was sold or transferred after death, preserve the title history and the account trail. A notary, French succession counsel, and U.S. trust counsel may need to review the same instrument from different legal perspectives.

II. How do French inheritance taxes and the France-US treaty affect American heirs?

A. Which country can tax the estate and how does the treaty prevent double taxation?

Succession law and succession tax are separate layers. A family may have a French-law dispute over reserved shares even when the tax is paid in the United States, and a French tax filing may be required even when a French court does not have jurisdiction over the entire estate. The French tax expression droits de mutation à titre gratuit means transfer taxes on gifts and inheritances. The official Article 750 ter of the French General Tax Code begins: “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit.” It then uses the deceased person’s tax domicile, the location of assets, and the heir’s tax residence to determine the French reach.

In broad terms, France can tax French-situs movable and immovable property when the deceased person was not French tax resident. That is the classic concern for an American who inherits a home in Provence, Paris, or the French Atlantic coast. The provision can also reach worldwide assets in circumstances where the deceased was French tax resident. A further rule can reach worldwide property received by an heir who is French tax resident and who has been tax resident in France for at least six of the previous ten years. These are legal connection rules, not a conclusion that every American heir owes French tax on every asset.

The France-US convention on estate and gift taxes is the next layer. The original convention was signed on November 24, 1978 and published on the French side by Decree No. 80-771 on Légifrance. The protocol signed in 2004 was published by Decree No. 2007-78 on Légifrance; the French tax administration records that the protocol entered into force on December 21, 2006. The consolidated text can be read in the official France-US convention PDF on impots.gouv.fr.

The treaty does not create a universal exemption for an American inheriting in France. It allocates taxing rights according to factors such as domicile and the location or nature of the property, and it provides mechanisms to reduce double taxation. A French immovable may remain within France’s taxing jurisdiction because it is located in France. A U.S. estate tax return may still be required because the deceased was a U.S. citizen or because U.S. federal law reaches the property. The treaty can then determine which tax is credited, which allowance is available, or how the tax is computed. The result depends on the taxpayer’s status, the asset’s location, the date of death, and the treaty article that applies.

For that reason, an executor should prepare a country-by-country asset schedule before filing. For each asset, record its legal owner, beneficial owner, location, value at the date of death, debts attached to it, prior gifts, and any tax already paid. Keep a separate schedule for French real estate, French bank accounts, U.S. securities, retirement plans, life insurance, closely held companies, and trust interests. “The estate has already paid tax” is not enough: the French and U.S. systems may use different taxable bases, valuation dates, exemptions, marital rules, and credit mechanisms.

The treaty also does not decide whether an American beneficiary receives the asset under the will. That is a succession-law question. It does not decide whether a French bank will release an account on a U.S. probate order. That is a recognition and documentation question. It does not decide whether a U.S. state imposes a separate inheritance or estate levy. That is a U.S. state-law question. A French notary can coordinate French filings, but the U.S. executor or trustee should work with a U.S. tax professional who can analyze federal and state obligations, treaty relief, and the classification of trusts.

One practical distinction is especially important: the France-US convention on estate and gift taxes is not the same instrument as the income tax treaty, FATCA rules, or rules governing passive foreign investment companies. An American family buying or inheriting French assets may face several reporting regimes, but each has a different legal trigger. This article addresses succession and estate/gift tax coordination. It does not turn a French inheritance into a complete U.S. tax opinion.

B. What should an American heir do before accepting, selling, or distributing a French asset?

The first step is to freeze the facts, not the family relationship. Obtain the certified death certificate, the deceased person’s last addresses, tax-residence evidence, passports or nationality evidence, marriage and divorce records, birth and adoption records, and every will, codicil, trust instrument, beneficiary designation, and probate order. Collect the original documents and certified translations where required. A U.S. apostille may prove authenticity, but it does not by itself establish the legal effect of the document in France.

The second step is to identify the French notaire and make the U.S. professionals part of the same document flow. A French notary handles many real-estate transfers, inheritance certificates, declarations, and registration acts. A U.S. probate lawyer or trustee may control the U.S. estate. A U.S. tax adviser may calculate federal tax and treaty credits. They should work from one asset and heir matrix so that a French deed does not distribute property before a U.S. trust or tax issue is resolved.

Foreign wills require particular care. Article 1000 of the French Civil Code states: “Les testaments faits en pays étranger ne pourront être exécutés sur les biens situés en France qu’après avoir été enregistrés au bureau du domicile du testateur.” The corresponding Article 655 of the General Tax Code refers to registration with the French tax service and a fixed duty. In Cass. 1re civ., April 13, 2022, No. 20-23.530, the Supreme Court held that “le certificat successoral européen avait une efficacité probatoire mais ne constituait pas un titre exécutoire.” The certificate can prove heir status and rights, but it does not eliminate every step needed to execute those rights.

The 2022 decision also matters because the court stated that “le règlement excluait de son domaine matériel les questions fiscales et administratives.” In other words, Regulation 650/2012 does not erase French tax and administrative formalities. The European Certificate of Succession is an EU instrument and is not a U.S. probate certificate. If an American executor presents letters testamentary, a court order, or a trust certificate to a French bank, the bank and notary may require legalization, apostille, certified translation, a legal opinion, an inheritance certificate, or a French registration step.

The third step is to calculate the reserve before negotiating a family settlement. Start with the assets and debts at death, then add any lifetime gifts that the applicable law requires to be considered. Identify each child, representation branch, surviving spouse, and prior benefit. Determine the law that governs the succession and whether the 2021 compensatory levy is even available. If a transfer exceeds the quotité disponible, Article 924’s indemnity rule may be more practical than asking for the asset itself. If a challenge is possible, calendar the periods under Article 921 and preserve the date on which the heir learned of the alleged infringement.

The fourth step is to protect the French asset while the analysis is pending. Do not sign a sale, distribution, waiver, or family settlement merely because the U.S. probate court has closed its file. Do not transfer a French home to one beneficiary at a price that has not been independently valued. Do not assume that a surviving joint tenant, trust beneficiary, or life-insurance recipient is outside the reserve calculation. Request the title records, mortgage balance, tax statements, bank statements, insurance policies, company registers, and prior gift deeds. If the asset is rented, keep rent and expenses in a separate account and preserve the management records.

The following scenarios show why the answer changes with the facts:

  • U.S. resident, all-U.S. family, French apartment: the French apartment can create French tax and administrative work. The Article 913 compensatory levy is not automatically available merely because the apartment is in France. The governing succession law, Regulation 650/2012, the will, and the treaty must be analyzed separately.
  • French or other EU connection in the family: if the deceased or at least one child had the required EU nationality or habitual residence, and the foreign law offers no protective child reserve, the current Article 913 mechanism may permit a levy on French assets existing at death. Proof of that connection is essential.
  • California trust with adult children: the 2017 Supreme Court decision shows that a foreign law ignoring the reserve is not automatically rejected. The concrete financial effect, the deceased person’s life center, the asset map, and the public-policy analysis matter.
  • French home and a foreign will: the 2018 decision shows why French immovables need a separate review. A foreign will may be valid in the United States and still require French registration, valuation, and reserve analysis before the property can be transferred.

Before a first meeting, an American heir should be ready to answer these questions: Where did the deceased actually live during the final years? Which U.S. state’s law does the will or trust identify? Was there an express choice of law? Which children or descendants were alive at death? Did any child have French or EU nationality or habitual residence? Which assets were physically in France at the date of death? Were lifetime gifts made? Is there a French will, a U.S. will, or both? Has a French tax declaration been filed? Has any U.S. estate or gift tax been paid? Has any beneficiary signed a release? The answers determine the next document and the next deadline.

For the broader French succession framework, see the firm’s French succession and estate-sharing practice page. It is a useful starting point for locating the French procedural issues, but a cross-border file still requires the underlying instruments and a coordinated review of French and U.S. law.

Conclusion

For an American family, French inheritance law is not a single citizenship test. The result depends on the deceased person’s habitual residence, a carefully drafted choice of law, the location of French immovables and other assets, the identity and status of the children, the operation of the reserved share, and the formal steps needed to execute a foreign will. The 2021 compensatory levy can be powerful, but it has statutory EU connection conditions and does not replace the ordinary conflict-of-laws analysis. The France-US estate tax treaty can reduce double taxation, but it does not eliminate French filings, U.S. reporting, valuation work, or the need to distinguish civil-law entitlement from tax liability.

The safest approach is to preserve every instrument, build one asset-and-heir schedule, verify the applicable law before distributing property, calculate the reserved and disposable portions, and coordinate the French notary with U.S. probate, trust, and tax counsel. That sequence is especially important before a French house is sold, a bank account is released, or a beneficiary signs a settlement.

📄 Official circular