KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can a French Judge Stop a Third-Country Deportation at the Airport?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can a French Judge Stop a Third-Country Deportation at the Airport?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 29 August 2026, the United States deported dozens of people to the Central African Republic, including a young Afghan whose lawyer said a US judge had protected him from removal to Afghanistan because of feared Taliban persecution. The Associated Press reported that the flight arriving in Bangui included Afghans, Iranians and nationals of other countries, and described a wider practice of sending people to countries of which they are not nationals. The facts remain those reported from the United States; they do not, by themselves, decide whether US law was complied with.

The sharper question for France and Europe is procedural. If a person is taken to an airport and told that a third country will receive them, can a French judge stop the aircraft before departure? The answer can be yes, but not because every third-country removal is unlawful. The court will identify the legal decision being executed, test whether the proposed destination is legally available, examine the risk of direct or onward refoulement, and ask whether the evidence makes the danger immediate and concrete.

That distinction matters in the Afghan case now in the news. A protection against return to Afghanistan cannot be treated as a geographical technicality that disappears when the itinerary is changed to Bangui. Nor does a news report establish automatically that the Central African Republic would persecute the person or send him onward. The decisive issue is whether the administration has made a real, individualized and reviewable assessment before the person loses access to a court. French and EU law provide several tools for that assessment, but each has a different trigger, time limit and evidential burden.

I. Can a French judge stop a third-country deportation at the airport?

A. Why the country of destination is a separate legal decision

The first step is to separate the removal order from the destination decision. Under Article L. 721-3 of the French Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners and Asylum Law (CESEDA), the administrative authority fixes the country to which the person may be sent by a decision distinct from the decision ordering removal. That distinction is more than formal. A person may have lost a challenge to the obligation to leave France while still being able to challenge the country selected for its execution, especially where new facts concern the route, admission or risk in that country.

The statutory options are defined by Article L. 721-4 CESEDA. The authority may designate the country of nationality, subject to the protection rules that apply where refugee or subsidiary protection has been granted or an asylum claim is still pending. It may also designate another country for which a valid travel document was issued under a European or bilateral readmission agreement. A different country may be used, with the foreign national’s agreement, where that person is legally admissible there. The same provision adds the non-refoulement limit: a person may not be removed to a country where life or liberty is threatened or where Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights would be violated.

This architecture answers one of the most common misunderstandings about third-country removals. A state cannot convert a destination into a mere logistical stop by changing the flight number. If the person is to be received, detained, registered, transferred or exposed to onward removal in the third country, the legality of that destination must be examined. “Legally admissible” is not the same as “the plane can land”. It requires a real legal basis for entry or stay: a travel document, an admission undertaking, a recognised status, or another arrangement that can be shown to exist for the individual concerned.

Nor is the existence of a diplomatic or operational arrangement enough by itself. The administration must be able to identify what the arrangement does, who will receive the person, what status the person will have on arrival, whether the authorities can detain or remove them, and what access they will have to an asylum procedure and to an independent court. A confidential agreement may be relevant to national policy, but confidentiality cannot erase the minimum factual material needed for an effective challenge by the person whose liberty and safety are at stake.

Article L. 721-5 CESEDA makes the destination decision contestable under the same procedure as the removal decision it is intended to execute. It also allows the destination to be challenged in the same action as the removal decision and, when it is notified later, even where the removal decision has already been upheld or can no longer be challenged. That rule is particularly important at an airport: a late destination choice, a changed route or a newly disclosed receiving state can create a new legal issue at the moment when the person needs a practical remedy.

The Conseil d’État made the separation explicit in its decision of 28 October 2024, no. 495898, available in the official Légifrance text. It held that the risk argument under Article 3 can be usefully raised against the decision fixing the country of return, but not in the same way against the distinct obligation to leave. The court also stated that the prefect must verify that the measures do not expose the person to treatment contrary to Article 3, and that a person whose refugee status was refused or withdrawn cannot be removed without a full and thorough examination of the situation and a verification of whether refugee quality remains relevant.

That reasoning is not limited to a person already recognised as a refugee. The question is whether the destination decision exposes the individual to a prohibited risk. A rejected asylum seeker, a person with subsidiary protection, a person whose status has been withdrawn, and a person who presents new evidence at the removal stage may occupy different procedural positions, but each position must be identified before the route is executed. Article L. 611-1 CESEDA supplies the statutory situations in which an OQTF may be made, while Article L. 542-4 CESEDA addresses the departure obligation after a final refusal of international protection. Neither provision authorises an automatic transfer to an unexamined third-country route.

The ordinary administrative challenge is governed by the procedural provisions in force for the measure concerned. Article L. 614-1 CESEDA provides for a challenge before the administrative court against the OQTF and the associated decisions covered by that article. The destination must be pleaded expressly. A filing that attacks only the existence of an irregular stay, but says nothing about the receiving country, may leave the central safety question underdeveloped.

It is also essential to keep the legal category straight. An OQTF and its destination decision are administrative removal measures. Extradition is a judicial cooperation procedure concerning prosecution or enforcement of a sentence. A European arrest warrant has its own surrender rules. A Dublin transfer concerns responsibility between EU Member States. The Afghan flight reported by AP is described as an immigration deportation, not an extradition. A French lawyer preparing an emergency application must therefore use the correct legal route and not rely on an argument designed for an extradition hearing.

B. What non-refoulement requires before departure

The legal control is not confined to the country of nationality. Article 4 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union states: “No one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.” Article 19 adds the specific protection for removal, expulsion and extradition, including the rule that a person must not be sent to a state where there is a serious risk of the death penalty, torture or other inhuman or degrading treatment. The official English text of Article 19 of the Charter is therefore directly relevant whenever an EU Member State selects a third country.

The Return Directive expresses the same discipline in operational terms. Under Article 5 of Directive 2008/115/EC, Member States must take account of the best interests of the child, family life and health and “respect the principle of non-refoulement.” Article 13 requires an effective remedy against return decisions. The official text says that “The third-country national concerned shall be afforded an effective remedy” before an independent authority, and Article 13(2) requires the reviewing authority to be able to examine the decision, including the possibility of temporarily suspending enforcement. A remedy that exists on paper but cannot be used before an aircraft leaves is vulnerable if the claim concerns an Article 3 or Article 4 risk.

For a third-country route, the risk assessment has at least three layers. The first is the immediate risk in the proposed destination: arbitrary detention, torture, violence, discriminatory treatment, lack of medical care or a complete absence of protection. The second is the legal status on arrival: will the person be admitted, tolerated temporarily, detained while a decision is made, or handed to another authority? The third is the onward route: can the receiving state send the person to Afghanistan or another state where the individual faces the original persecution? A decision that examines only the first flight and ignores the second and third layers is incomplete.

Indirect refoulement does not mean that every possible future movement must be predicted with certainty. The court looks for a real, foreseeable risk supported by evidence. The relevant material may include the receiving country’s immigration law, the written terms of admission, the absence of a residence document, prior removal practices, reports from public bodies, the person’s nationality and profile, and any evidence that the state of origin is seeking their return. A general statement that the third country is “safe” is weaker than a document proving who will admit the person and what remedy will be available if that admission fails.

The Conseil d’État addressed the interaction between refugee status and removal in its decision of 28 March 2022, no. 450618, the official Légifrance decision. It held that, even where an exception to the refugee non-refoulement rule is invoked on security or serious-crime grounds, a Member State cannot remove a refugee when serious and established grounds show a real risk of treatment prohibited by Articles 4 and 19 of the Charter. The decision also explains that the person challenging removal normally has to show serious reasons for believing that the real risk exists, while refugee quality is an element the authorities must particularly take into account.

The 2024 decision no. 495898 adds a procedural safeguard. The prefect cannot simply adopt the asylum authority’s earlier reasoning and stop there. The destination assessment remains the prefect’s responsibility, based on the whole file available at the time. The judge reviewing the destination may assess the alleged risk even if the applicant did not produce a new fact compared with the asylum proceedings. For counsel at an airport, this means that the emergency file should place the relevant evidence in front of the judge in a form that can be read immediately, even if parts of it were already submitted to OFPRA, the CNDA or another authority.

The European Court of Human Rights reached a similar conclusion in K.I. v. France, application no. 5560/19, concerning a refugee whose status had been withdrawn after a terrorism conviction. The Court’s official press release records that returning him without a prior assessment of the “actual and current risk” would violate the procedural aspect of Article 3; the case is available through the Court’s official HUDOC material. The point is not that every Afghan or every person sent to the Central African Republic meets the same test. The point is that an earlier protection finding, or a risk finding that has never been properly displaced, cannot be ignored at the last stage.

The Court’s Grand Chamber judgment in M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece, application no. 30696/09, is an important cross-border reference because the applicant was an Afghan who had worked as an interpreter and challenged a transfer to Greece. The official judgment is available on HUDOC. Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy, application no. 27765/09, likewise shows why an intermediate place of control cannot be treated as legally neutral when people are exposed there to ill-treatment or onward return; its official judgment is available in the Court’s database. These cases do not mechanically decide a French airport application, but they make the chain of responsibility visible.

EU asylum law supplies a parallel warning against formalism. Article 3(2) of the Dublin III Regulation prevents a transfer where systemic flaws in the asylum procedure and reception conditions create a risk of inhuman or degrading treatment. The Regulation also states that a Member State retains the right to send an applicant to a safe third country only subject to the safeguards in the Asylum Procedures Directive. The official consolidated text of Regulation (EU) No 604/2013 should be read with Directive 2013/32/EU, including the effective-remedy requirements for asylum decisions.

Jawo, Case C-163/17, judgment of the Court of Justice of 19 March 2019, is a further official EU reference. The case concerns transfer and the Article 4 Charter threshold; the case record is available through InfoCuria. Jawo is not a third-country deportation case in the narrow French sense, and it should not be overextended. Its value here is methodological: the reviewing authority must look at the actual conditions the person will face, not just at the label attached to the transfer.

Applied to the current news, the legal conclusion is restrained. AP reports that the Afghan man had US protection against removal to Afghanistan and that his family faced Taliban threats connected with his brothers’ work with the US military. That fact pattern raises a serious question about the adequacy of a third-country route, but it is not proof of the outcome under French or US law. A French court would ask for the individual’s status, the exact destination measure, evidence of admission to Bangui, the risk of detention or onward transfer, and the practical possibility of obtaining protection there.

II. What urgent remedy works when removal is imminent?

A. Which court, application and evidence can stop the flight

The emergency route depends on what is about to happen. If there is time to bring the ordinary challenge and request suspension, the lawyer may rely on the urgent-suspension procedure. Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice allows the interim judge to suspend an administrative decision where urgency exists and a ground creates serious doubt about legality. In a destination case, the serious doubt may concern the absence of legal admissibility, the failure to examine the route, a newly changed destination, or a real Article 3 risk.

When the aircraft is scheduled to leave within hours, the more direct emergency tool may be the référé-liberté. Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice empowers the interim judge, where urgency is established, to order measures necessary to safeguard a fundamental freedom against a serious and manifestly unlawful interference; the judge rules within forty-eight hours. The application must show more than an arguable error. It must connect the evidence to an immediate interference with a fundamental right and explain why an order is needed now.

The competent administrative court is normally identified by the authority and the location of the person’s detention or residence, with special rules for the removal procedure in question. The application should identify the prefectural decision, the country of return and the scheduled execution. It should request a measure that can actually be implemented, such as suspension of the departure, an order not to board or an order requiring the administration to reassess the destination. A vague request to “stop the deportation” leaves room for avoidable dispute over which legal act the court is being asked to suspend.

The dossier must be built for a judge working under extreme time pressure. The core documents are the removal order and every annex identifying the destination; the detention or escort notice; the flight details; the passport, laissez-passer or admission paper; any status decision from an asylum authority; and the evidence of the risk in the proposed country and on the onward route. If the person is protected from return to the country of nationality, the protection decision and the material that supported it should be translated or summarised in a way that lets the judge understand immediately why a change of destination does not end the risk.

Evidence of family or political profile can be decisive, but it must be tied to the legal test. A brother’s service with a foreign military, a relative’s public role, a history of threats, a prior arrest, gender, religion, ethnicity, medical vulnerability or political activity may explain the danger. It does not replace proof that the proposed destination will expose the person to that danger or leave them without a safe legal status. The strongest file connects the personal fact, the receiving state’s practice and the probability of onward transfer in a short chain that the judge can test.

For a third-country route, the following questions should be answered in the application itself:

  • What legal instrument makes the receiving state obliged or willing to admit this particular person?
  • Will the person receive a residence document, temporary protection, access to an asylum procedure or only a short period of physical tolerance?
  • Can the receiving authorities detain the person or transfer them to the state from which they fled?
  • What court or independent body can be reached after arrival, in what language and within what time?
  • Has the administration checked the country’s current practice, rather than relying on a general diplomatic assurance?
  • What happens if the receiving state refuses entry at the runway or refuses to keep the person after landing?

Those questions turn the phrase “safe third country” into an evidence exercise. The lawyer should attach the relevant statute or agreement, the admission correspondence, reliable country material and a short chronology. If the administration refuses to disclose the arrangement, the application should say exactly what is missing and ask the judge to require production or to draw the appropriate procedural consequence. The goal is not to make an allegation of illegality by repetition; it is to show why the court cannot approve the departure without knowing the legal and factual destination.

A person held in administrative detention must also be told about asylum rights and access to assistance. Article L. 744-6 CESEDA requires notification of rights relating to an asylum application on arrival at a detention centre and provides for legal and linguistic assistance. Under Article L. 754-1 CESEDA, an asylum application made in detention is generally subject to a five-day rule after notification of rights, while later facts remain relevant to the statutory exception. These provisions do not make every late application automatically suspensive, and they do not replace the challenge to an unlawful destination, but they can be central where new evidence emerges during detention.

The distinction between the suspension application and the référé-liberté must be preserved. The former focuses on urgency plus a serious doubt about legality. The latter requires a fundamental freedom, urgency and a serious and manifestly unlawful interference. A procedural defect may support an ordinary appeal without meeting the référé-liberté threshold. The Conseil d’État’s order of 27 March 2001, no. 231735, published on Légifrance, illustrates the point: a failure to hear the person about the destination was treated as an irregularity, but the court did not find the grave interference required by Article L. 521-2 on the facts before it. The same order recognised that a destination decision can be challenged through the urgent procedure, which means the file must establish the substantive danger as well as the procedural error.

The airport context adds a second layer of urgency. In Gebremedhin [Gaberamadhien] v. France, application no. 25389/05, the European Court of Human Rights found a violation of Article 13 combined with Article 3 because an asylum seeker in an airport waiting zone lacked a remedy with automatic suspensive effect against refusal of admission and removal. The official case-law information note is available on HUDOC. French procedure has evolved since that judgment, but the operational lesson remains: an effective remedy must reach the person before the irreversible step.

The application should therefore be filed as soon as the departure becomes credible, not when the person is already seated on the aircraft. The filing should be transmitted through the court’s available urgent channel, to the administration and, where appropriate, to the detention centre, with proof of the flight time. The lawyer should ask for an immediate acknowledgment and remain available for a hearing by telephone or video if the court uses that method. This is practical procedure, not a substitute for the legal demonstration, but a legally strong application that arrives after take-off may have to rely on a much harder remedy.

B. What happens after departure or when the state changes the route

Departure does not always make the dispute disappear. The Conseil d’État’s order of 7 December 2023, no. 489817, available in full on Légifrance, held that execution of the removal did not deprive a référé-liberté application of its object. The interim judge may order measures necessary to protect fundamental freedoms, including measures enabling the person’s return to France. In that case, the court treated the breach of an interim measure indicated by the European Court under Rule 39 as a grave and manifestly unlawful interference and ordered the authorities to take steps to allow return.

That is a powerful remedy, but it is not an automatic reversal of every completed removal. The applicant still has to establish the protected right, the serious illegality and the urgency. The Conseil d’État’s order of 22 April 2026, no. 514417, also published on Légifrance, confirmed that a completed removal does not by itself end the procedure, but refused a return order where the applicant had not produced material showing a serious risk in the destination country and had not shown the particular urgency needed for a very rapid return. The two decisions should be read together: post-departure relief exists, but proof and timing remain decisive.

If the route changes after filing, the lawyer should compare the new facts with the decision challenged. A change from the country named in the administrative decision to another receiving state may be a new destination decision, an execution outside the terms of the original decision or a factual development that strengthens the suspension request. The administration should be asked immediately for the written basis of the change. A judge cannot effectively review a destination that is described only orally by an escort or airline representative.

Article L. 721-5 CESEDA is particularly useful in that situation because it allows the destination decision to be challenged even when the removal decision has already been confirmed or is no longer open to challenge. The application should identify what changed: a new country, a new admission document, a refusal by the original destination, a new flight, a new risk report or a new piece of information concerning onward removal. A late change is not necessarily unlawful, but it cannot be used to deprive the person of the review attached to the actual destination.

There is also a difference between stopping a flight and securing a lawful interim arrangement. If immediate removal cannot be carried out, the administration may consider an assignment to residence where the statutory conditions are satisfied. Article L. 731-1 CESEDA permits an assignment where the person cannot leave immediately but removal remains a reasonable prospect, in the cases listed by the article. The order is not a finding that the person has won the merits case. It is a way to preserve the person’s availability while the destination, protection or travel-document issue is examined.

The right to be heard should also be framed accurately. In its decision of 5 June 2025, no. 493675, the Conseil d’État explained that an asylum applicant must have a useful and effective opportunity to present their position, but the administration does not necessarily have to repeat a separate hearing on the OQTF where the person was already able to speak about the irregular stay and the prospect of removal. For an airport application, the point is not to demand repetition in the abstract. It is to show the new fact that was never heard: the third-country destination, the admission terms, the changed itinerary or the fresh evidence of onward risk.

Where the domestic court cannot act in time, an application for an interim measure under Rule 39 of the European Court of Human Rights may be considered if the case presents an imminent risk of irreparable harm under Articles 2 or 3. The Court’s official Rule 39 page describes the mechanism as an emergency procedure for such risks, including expulsion proceedings. It is not an additional ordinary appeal against every removal order. The applicant must provide a documented case, explain the domestic steps taken, identify the imminent execution and show why the harm cannot be repaired later.

Rule 39 also matters because French courts have treated compliance with an interim measure as part of the right to an effective individual application. In no. 489817, the Conseil d’État relied on the relationship between Article 34 of the Convention and the interim measure before ordering steps for return. A lawyer should therefore preserve the full record: the request, the Court’s response, proof that the administration received it, the flight time and any act taken after notification. If a state has been told not to remove the person and proceeds anyway, that chronology may become as important as the original risk evidence.

At the same time, the person may need to seek protection immediately on arrival if removal cannot be prevented. That does not cure an unlawful prior transfer, and it may be practically impossible where the receiving state denies entry, detains the person without counsel or plans onward removal. The post-arrival file should record the landing location, the receiving authority, the status granted or refused, any detention document, requests for asylum, access to an interpreter and any onward movement. The information should be sent to French counsel and local counsel through secure channels as soon as possible.

The current Afghan story illustrates why this two-stage planning matters. The AP account describes a flight that landed in Bangui and a wider pattern of third-country removals, but public reporting does not answer every question a court would ask. It does not establish the exact terms under which each person was admitted, what status they received, whether they were detained, or whether any individual had access to a protection procedure. A sound legal analysis keeps those questions open and treats them as facts to verify, not as assumptions to repeat.

For an international family, employer, NGO or foreign lawyer seeking help in France, the practical instruction is simple: obtain the exact removal and destination decisions, the flight or escort notice, the protection history, the personal-risk evidence and every document concerning admission to the third country. Do not wait for a general press statement to identify the route. The French judge can act quickly only when the file identifies a decision, a right, a risk and a measure that can be ordered before the irreversible event.

Conclusion

Can a French judge stop a third-country deportation at the airport? Potentially, yes. The strongest application does not argue that a third-country route is automatically unlawful. It shows that the destination decision is distinct, that legal admissibility has not been demonstrated, that direct or onward refoulement has not been assessed, or that the person is about to suffer a serious and manifestly unlawful interference with a fundamental freedom. The urgent-suspension route and the référé-liberté serve different purposes, and the file must match the remedy.

The law also recognises a remedy after departure, but the decisions in nos. 489817 and 514417 show the limits: return can be ordered in an exceptional and documented case, while a bare allegation of danger will not carry the emergency threshold. For a person whose protection against return to the country of nationality is already established, a change of destination is not the end of the legal analysis. It is the moment to examine the new country, the admission document, the risk of onward removal and the time left before the flight.

We can review the order, the itinerary, the receiving-country documents and the evidence needed for an emergency application.

📄 Official circular