KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
GoFundMe Extra Donations: What U.S. Law Says About Keeping Leftover Fundraiser Money

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

GoFundMe Extra Donations: What U.S. Law Says About Keeping Leftover Fundraiser Money

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A fundraiser passes its goal in days. The medical bill gets covered, the family finds housing, or the project costs less than expected, and thousands of extra dollars sit in the campaign account. The organizer then faces the question every American donor and recipient should understand before anyone clicks donate or withdraw: who owns the surplus, and what happens if it is spent on something else? The short answer under federal law is that the campaign’s own promises control first, the platform’s refund tools come second, and criminal fraud statutes punish organizers who raised money on statements they knew were false. Three court decisions, two federal fraud statutes, and current federal and state guidance explain where the line sits.

GoFundMe campaigns have produced some of the largest person-to-person fundraisers in the country, and the Federal Trade Commission explains the basic mechanic in plain terms: “The campaign organizer sets the goal of the crowdfunding campaign.” That single sentence carries the whole legal structure. The organizer chooses the goal, writes the story, names the beneficiary, and decides when to stop collecting. Because the organizer sets those terms, courts and prosecutors measure later conduct against them. A surplus is not automatically a crime, and it is not automatically free money either. Refunding donors, getting consent for a new use, and documenting every transfer are the practical moves that keep an organizer on the right side of the rules below.

I. Can an organizer keep donations that exceed the stated need?

A. What does the campaign promise and the platform allow?

Start with the words on the campaign page, because those words function as the deal with donors. A page that says money will pay one child’s surgery bills promises something different from a page that says money will support a family generally. Donors give against that specific story, and when the need disappears or the goal is overshot, the organizer’s safest options are the ones the platform itself provides. GoFundMe’s own help pages tell organizers who have raised funds that are no longer needed, and who have not yet moved the money to a bank, that they can send the money back to donors through a refund request, while donations to nonprofit fundraisers are typically treated as non-refundable. An organizer who keeps collecting after the need ends, or who quietly redirects the surplus to unrelated spending, abandons that protection and invites the questions described in the next section.

Donor intent matters beyond the platform as well. Courts treat solicited funds as given for the purpose stated in the appeal, so spending them on something materially different can support claims for misrepresentation or breach of the understanding on which the money changed hands. The Federal Trade Commission’s consumer guidance on crowdfunding urges donors to verify campaigns before giving, which means organizers should expect skeptical readers, screenshots, and follow-up questions. An organizer who updates the page when circumstances change, states in writing what will happen to any surplus, and keeps bank records showing where each dollar went will have answers when donors, a platform investigator, or a state regulator asks. An organizer who deletes the original story, moves money through personal accounts, or spends it on luxury items will not.

State regulators add a second layer. The California Attorney General explains that the office regulates charities and fundraisers that solicit on their behalf, including charitable fundraising platforms and persons or entities that solicit or hold charitable assets, to protect charitable assets for their intended use and ensure that donations are not misapplied and squandered through fraud or other means. Readers outside California should note the limit of that example: each state runs its own registration and enforcement system, and a personal fundraiser for a neighbor’s medical bills is not the same legal object as a registered charity. The usable point is general. Wherever the campaign runs, a state attorney general or consumer-protection office is the place that takes complaints about misused solicited funds, and organizers should assume their public statements can be read by those offices. That state-law check is described at the California Attorney General’s charities page, which also describes the registry and complaint process for charitable fundraising in that state.

B. When does keeping or redirecting the money become federal fraud?

Federal law draws its line at deception, not at the size of the surplus. Section 1341 of Title 18 punishes anyone who, having devised or intending to devise “any scheme or artifice to defraud,” or seeking money “by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises,” uses the mail or an interstate carrier to execute it, with up to twenty years in prison. The full text is available at 18 U.S.C. 1341 on govinfo. Section 1343 covers the same kind of scheme executed by wire, radio, or television communication in interstate commerce, stating that “[w]hoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television communication in interstate or foreign commerce, any writings, signs, signals, pictures, or sounds for the purpose of executing such scheme or artifice, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both.” The full text is available at 18 U.S.C. 1343 on govinfo. An online fundraiser that takes donations across state lines through interstate wires fits naturally inside those statutes when the appeal itself is false.

The most direct recent example comes from the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. In United States v. Trankle, No. 23-3233 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 9, 2026), the court reviewed the convictions of a man who created entities with charitable-sounding names, collected hundreds of thousands of dollars through nationwide solicitations, and spent the donations largely on himself. The opinion states the governing point bluntly: “these actions describe a fraudulent scheme, not a charity.” The court affirmed the mail-fraud and conspiracy convictions as well as the sentence. The usable check from Trankle is to compare every solicitation line against where the money actually went, because the court treated nationwide donation appeals that funded only the organizer as a federal fraud scheme. An organizer whose appeals promise help for others while the bank records show personal spending is presenting exactly the mismatch that decision punished.

A second federal case shows the same pattern on a crowdfunding platform by name. According to the Justice Department’s press release from the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of New Jersey, Mark D’Amico pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud over a GoFundMe campaign that raised approximately $400,000 from more than 14,000 donors on a fabricated story about a homeless veteran, and two participants had pleaded guilty the prior year to wire-fraud conspiracy and money-laundering conspiracy. The release states that the story about a woman running out of gas and a good Samaritan spending his last $20 was not true, that the organizers moved the donations into accounts they controlled, and that most of the money went to personal expenses including gambling, vacations, a BMW automobile, clothing, and handbags. The release notes the charge carries a maximum of twenty years in prison and a $250,000 fine. The file is available at the Justice Department’s announcement of the plea. Nothing about a large total proves guilt by itself; what made this case criminal was the false story used to obtain the money and the diversion of the proceeds. A truthful campaign that simply overshoots its goal presents a different question, answered by the campaign terms and the refund tools above rather than by this prosecution.

The Trankle record also shows how prosecutors prove these cases without a single cooperating donor. The opinion describes thousands of cross-country mailings asking for personal checks, multiple trade names suggestive of different charitable causes, and an accomplice who helped operate the entities. Jurors compared the solicitation language with bank records and concluded the operation was a business wearing charity’s clothing. That comparison is the template for every fundraiser dispute: the words that asked for money on one side, the ledger showing where it went on the other. Organizers sometimes argue that some charitable work did occur, or that donors would have given anyway. The Trankle answer is that partial good deeds do not cleanse a solicitation built on false descriptions of who the money serves. A fundraiser that delivered half its proceeds to the stated cause and spent the rest on the organizer still misled every donor who gave against the full promise.

State law reaches the same conduct through theft and deceptive-practice statutes. Most states punish obtaining property by false pretenses, false representation, or deception, and many add consumer-protection claims that let regulators or private plaintiffs seek restitution, penalties, and fees without proving a federal jurisdictional hook. The labels differ by state, and the dollar thresholds that separate misdemeanors from felonies differ too, so an organizer must read the law of the state where the donors were solicited, not just the state where the organizer lives. What does not differ is the core question judges ask: did the solicitation state or imply something about the use of the money that the organizer knew was untrue when donors relied on it? A surplus handled openly, with donor consent and clean records, answers that question in the organizer’s favor.

II. What should donors check, and how should organizers close a campaign?

A. How can a donor verify a campaign and get money back?

Donors have more leverage before giving than after. The Federal Trade Commission’s crowdfunding guidance tells readers that online platforms let people create campaigns quickly and that organizers receive the funds quickly, which is why donors should confirm who the organizer is, how the organizer knows the beneficiary, how the money will be delivered, and what happens if the goal is exceeded. Those questions are available at the FTC’s page on donating through crowdfunding and fundraising platforms. A donor who asks these questions in writing before contributing creates a record of the promise. A donor who gives to a stranger’s story with no named beneficiary, no update history, and no explanation of surplus handling has little to enforce later except a general fraud complaint.

After giving, a donor who suspects misuse has three practical channels. First, the platform: GoFundMe’s own process lets organizers return unneeded funds that have not yet been transferred, and its help pages invite users to report a fundraiser for investigation, so a donor can ask the organizer for a refund in writing and, if refused, file a platform report. Second, the state: attorneys general and consumer-protection offices accept complaints about deceptive solicitation, as the California example above shows. Third, the courts: small-dollar donors can consider small-claims procedures under their own state’s rules, while larger or coordinated cases may draw a prosecutor’s attention when the pattern shows intentional false statements rather than a good-faith surplus.

Donors are not limited to platform reports and small claims. In In re Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, No. 25-4068 (10th Cir. Aug. 31, 2026), contributors sued a church and its investment subsidiary in a proposed nationwide class, alleging fraudulent inducement of donations alongside breach of fiduciary duty and unjust enrichment. The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed dismissal, not on the merits of the fraud allegations, but because the complaints were untimely: given years of national news reports about the challenged practices, the donors, exercising reasonable diligence, should have known of the alleged scheme more than three years before they filed. The donor lesson from this ruling is that fraud, fiduciary-duty, and unjust-enrichment claims can challenge how donations were obtained and used, even class-wide, but waiting more than three years after public reports put donors on notice can end the case before the merits are reached.

An Ohio decision shows what happens when the fundraiser’s story itself is false. In State v. Burgett, No. C-180029 (Ohio Ct. App. Dec. 27, 2019), reported as 2019-Ohio-5348, the defendant ran a GoFundMe campaign built on false claims about her child’s medical condition, a jury heard evidence that included the platform’s own corporate records identifying each donor and amount, and the Court of Appeals held that evidence sufficient to support raising the telecommunications-fraud offense to a third-degree felony, while reversing the restitution award and remanding for the trial court to redetermine the victim and economic loss under intervening Ohio Supreme Court law. The concrete lesson from Burgett is that false statements in an online fundraiser can support a fraud conviction on the platform’s own donor records, subject to the age limitation stated here: this 2019 Ohio decision is used only as a historical illustration of how courts treat false online-fundraising statements, not as a statement of current Ohio law, which later decisions may have changed. Prosecutors keep their own records, but donors should keep theirs too: receipts, screenshots of the original appeal, and any messages with the organizer are the exhibits that make a later complaint credible.

Platform investigations deserve a realistic expectation. A reporting tool can freeze payouts, demand documentation, or return money still in transit, but platforms generally cannot claw back funds already withdrawn to an organizer’s bank account, and they do not decide criminal guilt. A donor report should therefore be short, dated, and attached to evidence: the campaign link, screenshots of the original promise, the receipt, and the organizer’s response or silence. That same packet serves for a state complaint and for small-claims court. Donors sometimes hesitate because each gift is small, yet small-claims procedures exist precisely for modest disputes, and a row of identical small judgments tells a clearer story than one angry post. Filing rules and dollar caps for those courts vary by state and change over time, so a donor should read the current rules of the local court rather than relying on general descriptions.

B. What are the tax consequences and the clean way to close the books?

Personal crowdfunding gifts generally do not count as taxable income to the person who receives them. Section 102(a) of the Internal Revenue Code states the rule in one sentence: “Gross income does not include the value of property acquired by gift, bequest, devise, or inheritance.” The full provision is available at 26 U.S.C. 102 on govinfo. That rule covers genuine gifts, which is what most personal fundraisers collect: money given out of generosity, with no goods, services, or repayment expected. Two limits matter. First, the exclusion does not cover income earned on the gift, such as interest the donated funds earn while sitting in an account. Second, money called a gift that is really payment for work, including wages routed through a fundraiser by an employer, is treated as compensation, not as a gift. An organizer who also runs a business should therefore keep fundraiser money strictly separate from business receipts.

The giver’s side has its own paperwork. The Internal Revenue Service explains that the person who makes a gift, not the person who receives it, is the one who may have a filing duty: an individual who gives more than the annual exclusion amount to one person generally must file a gift-tax return, Form 709, even when no tax is ultimately owed because of the lifetime exemption. The agency’s questions and answers on the subject are available at the IRS gifts and inheritances FAQ page. Most small donors to a fundraiser will never approach that threshold, but a single large contribution can trigger the form, and the duty sits with the donor. Separately, contributions to a personal fundraiser are not charitable deductions for the donor, because the recipient is not a qualified tax-exempt organization; only gifts to eligible charities qualify, a different regime that the fundraiser’s page should never promise without a determination letter to back it up.

Closing a campaign cleanly depends on which situation the organizer faces. When the goal is simply exceeded, the straightforward path is to stop promoting the page, post a public update stating the final total and the intended use of the surplus, and either refund the excess through the platform’s process or obtain written consent from donors for the new purpose. When the beneficiary dies or the purpose becomes impossible, the organizer should freeze withdrawals, notify donors, and return the money rather than repurposing it unilaterally. When the campaign supported a registered nonprofit, different rules apply: nonprofit donations are typically treated as irrevocable, and the organization, not the individual organizer, decides how unused funds serve its mission. In every case the records that matter are the same: the original appeal text, dated updates, donor communications, transfer receipts, and bank statements showing the funds were kept apart from personal spending. An organizer who can produce that file answers a donor complaint, a platform review, or a regulator’s letter in hours; one who cannot invites the fraud analysis of the first part of this article.

One structural choice prevents most disputes: keep fundraiser money in a dedicated account that no personal spending touches. Commingling turns every later question into an argument about tracing, while a separate account with card statements matching the campaign ledger answers those questions at a glance. Organizers raising money for someone else should go further and name that person as the beneficiary inside the platform wherever the platform allows direct beneficiary delivery, so withdrawals flow to the stated recipient rather than through the organizer’s hands. The extra setup takes minutes and removes the organizer from the chain of custody that prosecutors and plaintiffs otherwise reconstruct line by line.

Conclusion

A surplus in a fundraiser is a paperwork problem before it is ever a legal problem. The campaign’s stated purpose decides what the money is for, platform refund tools handle money that is no longer needed, and federal fraud law punishes only the organizer who obtained donations through false statements and spent them on something else. Donors protect themselves by verifying the organizer and the plan before giving and by keeping written records. Organizers protect themselves by updating the page when facts change, freezing and returning money whose purpose has failed, and keeping every transfer documented. Surplus funds handled that way remain what they were meant to be: generosity that arrived faster than expected.

📄 Official circular