KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
How Do U.S. Required Minimum Distributions Work for an American Living in France? RMDs, Treaty, and French Filing

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, employment lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

How Do U.S. Required Minimum Distributions Work for an American Living in France? RMDs, Treaty, and French Filing

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An American who retires in France can have a mandatory U.S. withdrawal arrive in the same year as a French tax return, a currency conversion, and a question from a bank or tax office. The withdrawal is usually called a required minimum distribution, or RMD. It is not a French retirement product. It is an amount that U.S. law requires an owner of many traditional retirement accounts to take, even when the owner would rather leave the money invested. The U.S. deadline, calculation, withholding, and penalty rules are therefore only the first layer of the analysis.

France asks a different set of questions. Is the recipient a French tax resident? What plan paid the money? Is the account a traditional IRA, a 401(k), a designated Roth account, an inherited IRA, or a government pension? Does the current France–U.S. tax treaty allocate the qualifying payment to the United States, and does France still require it to be reported for the effective-rate method? An RMD does not answer those questions by itself. A mandatory withdrawal can still be a treaty pension distribution, while a French return can remain necessary.

This guide focuses on an American who is, or may become, a French tax resident and must take an RMD from a U.S. retirement plan. It explains the U.S. deadlines, the treaty classification, the French forms and evidence, and the differences between an owner’s RMD, a Roth account, an inherited account, and a voluntary withdrawal. It complements the broader guide to retiring in France as an American and the general classification guide to U.S. 401(k), IRA, and Social Security benefits. The point is to build a file that another professional can audit before the payment is classified on either return.

I. What is a U.S. required minimum distribution (RMD) for an American living in France?

A. When must an American take an RMD from a 401(k) or traditional IRA?

The U.S. Internal Revenue Service describes an RMD as a minimum amount that must generally be withdrawn each year from a traditional IRA or a retirement plan once the applicable starting age is reached. The rule is a U.S. federal rule. France does not create the RMD, calculate the U.S. life-expectancy divisor, or waive a U.S. excise tax merely because the account owner lives in France. The owner remains responsible for requesting the correct amount from the custodian and keeping the calculation used for that year.

For current U.S. rules, the applicable age is not the same for every person. The IRS explains in its retirement-plan and IRA RMD FAQs that the starting age is generally 73 for people who reach that age under the current law, while the applicable age is 75 for a later birth cohort. A taxpayer should check the birth-date rule and the tax year rather than copy an age from an older article. A legislative change can alter the starting date without changing the France–U.S. treaty.

The first RMD can have a special deadline. In many cases, the first distribution may be delayed until April 1 of the year after the owner reaches the applicable age. That choice can create two RMDs in the same calendar year, because the distribution for the next year is generally due by December 31. The French tax year and the U.S. distribution year must be placed side by side. A payment received in January after a French move may belong to a different U.S. distribution year from the payment received in December, even when both appear on the same French bank statement.

The amount is generally calculated from the account value at the end of the preceding year divided by a life-expectancy factor from the applicable IRS table. The IRS Publication 590-B explains the tables and the treatment of traditional and Roth IRAs, including rules for beneficiaries. A spouse who is the sole beneficiary and more than ten years younger can use a different table in the circumstances described by the IRS. The French tax return does not replace this U.S. calculation. Keep the prior December 31 valuation, the table used, the beneficiary designation, the custodian statement, and the final distribution confirmation.

Traditional IRAs generally follow the RMD rule even when the owner continues to work. An employer plan can have a still-working exception when the person is not a 5-percent owner of the employer, but the plan document and the employer’s administration control the application. A 401(k) from a former employer should not be treated as a current-employer plan without checking the facts. The plan type, employment status, ownership percentage, and plan terms should be recorded in the same memo as the French residence analysis.

An RMD is not normally an eligible rollover distribution. A direct rollover from a traditional 401(k) to a traditional IRA can be treated differently from a cash payment, but the RMD portion generally must be paid out and cannot simply be rolled into the receiving account. This distinction matters on both sides of the Atlantic. A trustee-to-trustee rollover, a conversion from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, a cash distribution, and an RMD can appear in one year’s custodian records but represent different legal events. Do not describe all four as a “transfer.”

Roth accounts require their own calendar. The owner of a Roth IRA is generally not required to take lifetime RMDs, and the IRS RMD guidance explains the different treatment of Roth arrangements and beneficiaries. A designated Roth account in an employer plan also has specific rules under recent U.S. legislation. A beneficiary of a Roth IRA can still face distribution requirements after the owner’s death. “Roth” therefore describes the U.S. tax design of the account; it does not mean that every payment, beneficiary event, or French reporting question is automatically resolved.

An inherited IRA is not the same account as the deceased owner’s IRA for U.S. administration. The beneficiary may have to keep the account titled as inherited, follow a ten-year or annual distribution rule depending on the facts, and comply with special rules for a surviving spouse. The IRS explains in Publication 590-A that a nonspouse beneficiary generally cannot treat an inherited traditional IRA as the beneficiary’s own IRA. The beneficiary’s U.S. distribution calendar should be kept separately from the French inheritance file. Death, beneficiary designation, account transfer, and later distribution are separate events.

The French starting point is tax residence, not the American label RMD. Article 4 A of the French General Tax Code provides: “Les personnes qui ont en France leur domicile fiscal sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu en raison de l’ensemble de leurs revenus.” Article 4 B identifies, among other tests, a person who has “leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal” in France. Foyer means the ordinary family home; the principal stay is the main place of actual presence. A person can be a U.S. citizen, file Form 1040, and still be French-resident under domestic law or under the treaty tie-breaker.

French domestic law also starts from a broad treatment of retirement income. Article 79 of the French General Tax Code states: “Les traitements, indemnités, émoluments, salaires, pensions et rentes viagères concourent à la formation du revenu global servant de base à l’impôt sur le revenu.” The provision also reaches retirement benefits paid as capital. An RMD can therefore enter the French legal analysis even when the treaty later limits France’s power to tax it. The fact that the custodian sent the payment to a U.S. account does not make the recipient nonresident, and the fact that the money was deposited in France does not by itself change the plan’s source.

The practical classification should be written before the French form is completed. Record whether the payment is an owner RMD, a voluntary withdrawal above the RMD, an inherited-account distribution, a Roth payment, a rollover, a conversion, a Social Security benefit, or a government pension. Record the payer and the plan’s U.S. legal identity. A Form 1099-R code is useful evidence, but it is not a complete French treaty opinion. The account agreement, plan description, custodian letter, distribution calculation, and U.S. return should tell the same story.

B. Does the France–U.S. treaty change how an RMD is taxed?

The treaty must be read in its amended form. The 1994 convention published by Decree no. 96-222 is the foundation, but later instruments changed the pension provisions. The 2009 amendment published by Decree no. 2010-28 modifies Article 18. Its Article VI replaces the first sentence with a source-state rule for qualifying social-security payments, retirement-plan payments, and similar remuneration.

The operative French sentence covers payments “sous la forme de versements périodiques ou d’une somme globale” and states: “Les sommes payées en application de la législation sur la sécurité sociale ou d’une législation similaire d’un Etat contractant à un résident de l’autre Etat contractant ou à un citoyen des Etats-Unis, ainsi que les sommes versées dans le cadre d’un régime de retraite et autres rémunérations similaires qui proviennent de l’un des Etats contractants au titre d’un emploi antérieur à un résident de l’autre Etat contractant, sous la forme de versements périodiques ou d’une somme globale, ne sont imposables que dans le premier Etat.” The wording matters for an RMD because an RMD is periodic or can be part of a lump-sum year; the treaty does not reserve the allocation rule only for a monthly pension.

Under the current source-state wording, the question is whether a qualifying payment arises from a U.S.-established retirement arrangement and is paid to the relevant resident or U.S. citizen in the treaty circumstances. A conventional U.S. 401(k) and a traditional IRA require plan-specific analysis, but the treaty protocol recognizes U.S. arrangements including qualified plans under section 401(a), individual retirement plans, individual retirement accounts, and sections 403(a) and 403(b) plans. The fact that a payment is mandatory under U.S. RMD rules does not remove it from the retirement-plan category. It is still necessary to prove the plan, payer, source, recipient status, and treaty period.

The French court record confirms that plan classification is technical. In CAA Versailles, 28 January 2020, no. 18VE03035, the court explained that “L’assimilation opérée par cet article des ” plans de retraite qualifiés ” aux Etats-Unis aux régimes de retraite reconnus en France a pour objet de faire bénéficier de la déductibilité du revenu imposable dans l’Etat de résidence des cotisations.” The case concerned the treaty treatment of contributions and a pension trust’s income; it did not decide every RMD. Its value is the method: identify the arrangement recognized by the protocol rather than relying on a commercial account name.

The official French parliamentary answer on the France–U.S. convention is also useful background. The Senate response published on 27 August 2020 states that sums from U.S. retirement plans, whether paid periodically or in one payment, are taxable only in the United States under the applicable Article 18 rule, while France may take them into account for the rate calculation subject to the treaty mechanism. That answer is not a substitute for examining a particular plan or tax year, but it shows why a French return can contain a treaty-allocated payment without imposing ordinary French pension tax on the same amount.

The treaty does not convert every withdrawal from a U.S. account into an Article 18 pension. A taxable brokerage account, an investment partnership, a dividend, interest, a capital gain, and a distribution from a nonqualified deferred-compensation arrangement can fall under different provisions. A payment from a U.S. government pension can also belong to the public-remuneration article. The source is not proved merely by the bank’s location or the taxpayer’s passport.

Older case law shows the boundary. In Conseil d’État, 8 August 1990, no. 72536, the court analyzed a pension paid by the U.S. Treasury for services at the U.S. Embassy in Paris under the public-service article of the treaty text then applicable. In CAA Versailles, 27 May 2015, no. 13VE01761, the court likewise addressed a U.S. government pension and public-remuneration rules. Those decisions are warnings to separate a private 401(k) RMD from Social Security, a federal civil-service pension, or a state pension.

Evidence of source can decide the result. In CAA Marseille, 16 June 2020, no. 19MA01434, the court recorded that “Mme A… a en France son foyer et son lieu de séjour principal” and noted that the taxpayers “n’apportent aucun élément de nature à justifier que ces pensions proviendraient des Etats-Unis.” The practical lesson for an RMD is direct: preserve the plan statement, the custodian’s U.S. address, the account agreement, the distribution form, and the calculation that links the payment to that plan. A U.S. bank account alone is not enough.

The saving clause means that U.S. citizenship remains important. A U.S. citizen living in France normally continues to file Form 1040 and report a traditional IRA or 401(k) distribution under U.S. law. Treaty allocation may prevent France from taxing a qualifying U.S.-source retirement payment as ordinary French pension income, but it does not generally turn off the American filing system, the U.S. RMD deadline, or a U.S. excise tax for a missed amount. State income tax, federal withholding, and the foreign-tax-credit analysis must be addressed separately.

The result should be stated narrowly: a documented RMD from a qualifying U.S.-established private retirement arrangement can be allocated under the current Article 18 source-state rule, but an RMD label is not a treaty certificate. If the plan, payer, beneficiary status, residence, or tax year is uncertain, the conclusion should be limited to the facts proved. An article written for a French resident receiving a Canadian RRSP or a U.K. pension cannot be copied onto an American’s RMD.

II. How should an American report an RMD in France and the United States?

A. Which French forms, evidence, and exchange-rate records are needed?

Treaty allocation does not automatically mean “do not report.” The French tax administration explains in its guidance on foreign-source income and pensions that a French resident must consult the applicable treaty to determine whether foreign income is taxable, whether it must be declared, and how double taxation is relieved. Treaty-exempt income can remain relevant to the effective-rate method, known in French as the taux effectif. The amount may influence the rate applied to other taxable French income without becoming taxable a second time as ordinary French pension income.

The French filing starting point is Article 170 of the General Tax Code. It requires “toute personne imposable audit impôt … de souscrire … une déclaration détaillée de ses revenus.” The taxpayer should use the current tax-year instructions for Form 2042 and Form 2047, because box numbers and reporting instructions can change. A typical file identifies the gross RMD, the plan, the payer, the date, the euro conversion, the treaty article, and the reason the payment is exempt, credited, or included for the rate. Do not reproduce a box number from an old return without checking the current form.

The French pension allowance is a domestic calculation rule, not the treaty conclusion. Article 158, paragraph 5(a) states that “Les pensions et retraites font l’objet d’un abattement de 10 %” subject to statutory limits. If Article 18 removes a qualifying RMD from French income tax, applying the allowance mechanically may blur the treaty position. If France can tax a different payment, the allowance may matter. The classification must come before the arithmetic.

The same care applies to withholding. Article 204 A governs the French prélèvement à la source, or withholding at source, for categories including taxable pensions. A U.S. custodian normally does not operate French payroll withholding, so the absence of a French deduction is not proof that France has no reporting requirement. A French payer’s withholding, if one exists in a different part of the file, does not by itself settle treaty relief.

The source rules must be distinguished by residence direction. Article 164 B is relevant when analyzing French-source pensions and similar income for a person who is not French-resident. Article 182 A provides for withholding on French-source pensions paid to people who are not French tax residents. These provisions do not decide the result for a French resident receiving a U.S. RMD, but they show why the payer, source, and residence must be recorded before a form is completed.

The evidence file should contain at least the following items:

  • the retirement-plan name, account type, plan address, custodian, and U.S. statutory description;
  • the prior year-end account value and the IRS table or calculation used to determine the RMD;
  • the distribution statement, Form 1099-R, Form 5498 or equivalent custodian record, and any withholding statement;
  • the date the RMD was requested, the date it was paid, the gross amount, the currency, and the amount actually received;
  • the beneficiary designation and the death certificate or inherited-account documents when the RMD belongs to a beneficiary;
  • the French residence facts, including the home, travel calendar, family location, and treaty residence analysis;
  • the U.S. Form 1040 reporting, any Form 5329 or excise-tax analysis, and state-tax records where relevant; and
  • the exchange-rate source and method used to convert the dollar amount into euros.

Use one consistent currency method for the payment, withholding, and any credit. The bank’s conversion may be useful evidence, but it is not always the only possible method. Record the date and source used, and keep the calculation that turns the dollar amount into the number reported in euros. A later amendment is difficult to defend when the taxpayer cannot explain why one RMD used the payment-date rate and another used an annual average.

The French and U.S. files should cross-reference each other without being identical. The French return describes the treaty position and the French reporting consequence. The U.S. return reports the distribution under U.S. law and preserves the RMD calculation. A Form 1099-R can show the gross distribution and withholding; it does not prove that France should tax the payment. A French tax assessment can show a French amount; it does not prove that the United States should abandon its own RMD rule.

The foreign-tax-credit question must be kept separate. If the treaty gives the United States exclusive taxing authority over a qualifying RMD, a French income-tax credit is not the mechanism that creates the result. If a different payment is taxable in France and the United States, Article 24 and domestic foreign-tax-credit rules may matter. A credit cannot be claimed twice, and a taxpayer should not use a French credit calculation as a substitute for identifying the treaty article.

FATCA and account reporting are also different from income taxation. A French resident may have to declare a foreign account or contract under French reporting rules, while a U.S. citizen may have FBAR and Form 8938 obligations. Automatic information exchange can make an account visible to both administrations, but it does not classify an RMD. The taxpayer still needs to describe the plan, the payment, the beneficiary status, and the treaty position accurately.

B. What happens with Roth accounts, inherited IRAs, missed RMDs, and disputes?

The most common mistake is to treat every payment from a retirement account as an owner’s RMD. A traditional IRA owner may have a lifetime RMD, while a Roth IRA owner generally does not. A designated Roth account in a 401(k) can have different lifetime rules after recent U.S. legislation, but a beneficiary may face post-death distribution rules. An inherited traditional IRA can require distributions even when the original owner would not yet have reached the applicable age. The title on the account, the owner’s death date, the beneficiary’s status, and the applicable U.S. distribution year all matter.

An inherited account also raises French succession questions. The beneficiary’s receipt of the account, the transfer into an inherited account, and the later distribution are not necessarily one French tax event. The treaty analysis may concern the later retirement payment, while French inheritance rules may concern the transmission at death. Keep the beneficiary designation, estate documents, account statements before and after death, and any notarial or probate document together. Do not call the entire account “inheritance” on a French return if the payment is later characterized as a pension distribution under the treaty.

A voluntary withdrawal above the RMD can have a different planning consequence even when it comes from the same account. A taxpayer who takes the minimum amount in December and an additional lump sum in January has two legal events and potentially two tax years. A direct rollover is different from a cash withdrawal. A Roth conversion is different from both. The French file should list every event with its date, amount, plan, payer, and U.S. reporting form.

The U.S. penalty for a missed RMD is a separate issue. The IRS may impose an excise tax on an amount that should have been distributed, subject to statutory relief and correction procedures. The taxpayer should calculate the shortfall, request the missing distribution, keep proof of the correction, and determine whether a waiver or amended U.S. filing is available. French treaty relief does not erase a U.S. failure-to-take penalty. Conversely, a U.S. penalty does not automatically become a deductible French tax or a French income item.

An RMD paid in kind should be documented carefully. If securities leave the account instead of cash, the custodian’s valuation, date, number of units, and later sale records should be retained. The French reporting amount may depend on the value at distribution, while a later sale can create a separate gain or loss under the relevant law. A payment in kind should not be reported as a cash withdrawal merely because the account statement uses the word “distribution.”

If the French tax administration treats a qualifying U.S. RMD as fully taxable French pension income, the taxpayer should first identify the exact error. It may be a residence issue, a plan-classification issue, a missing treaty claim, a currency error, an incorrect form line, or a distinction between an RMD and another payment. The response should attach the plan documents, RMD calculation, distribution form, residence evidence, treaty text, and a payment-by-payment schedule. A general statement that “the treaty exempts my retirement” is less useful than a table showing the payer, plan, date, article, and evidence for each amount.

The taxpayer should preserve deadlines from both countries. A French administrative claim, a response to a proposed adjustment, a correction to an annual return, a U.S. amended return, and an IRS penalty-waiver request are different procedures. The notice date, tax year, payment date, and proof of submission should be recorded. Do not send the same narrative to both administrations without checking that the residence, gross amount, withholding, and treaty position are consistent.

The useful working table has one row per payment and these columns: tax year; distribution date; account owner; beneficiary status; plan type; payer; gross dollars; withholding; euro conversion; RMD or voluntary status; U.S. form; French form; treaty article; French tax result; and documents held. Add a column for unresolved points, such as a Roth conversion, an inherited account, a state-tax payment, a government pension, a payment-in-kind, or a missed RMD. That table prevents a broad account label from being applied to transactions that have different legal character.

The safest review is therefore not a single percentage calculation. It is a source-and-event review. Confirm the U.S. RMD amount, confirm the French residence, confirm the treaty version, classify the plan, separate private and public pensions, complete the relevant French reporting, and retain the evidence. The general guide to U.S. retirement and Social Security classification in France can provide context, but a mandatory RMD still deserves its own calendar and payment schedule.

Conclusion

For an American living in France, an RMD is first a U.S. distribution obligation and then a cross-border classification question. The IRS determines when the withdrawal must occur and how much must be taken. France determines domestic residence and begins with its rules for worldwide income. The amended France–U.S. treaty then asks whether the payment comes from a qualifying U.S. retirement arrangement and assigns the taxing right under the current Article 18 source-state language. The fact that the distribution is required does not make it a French pension, and the fact that the treaty may prevent French income tax does not necessarily remove the payment from a French reporting file.

Before the first RMD after moving to France, collect the prior year-end valuation, the IRS calculation, the plan documents, the beneficiary information, the Form 1099-R, the U.S. filing, the French residence evidence, the treaty article, and the currency conversion. Keep traditional, Roth, inherited, public, Social Security, rollover, conversion, and voluntary payments in separate rows. If the French administration questions the result, a payment-by-payment evidence file is more persuasive than an account label or a bank statement.

📄 Official circular