On 3 September 2026, the Appeals Chamber of the Swiss Federal Criminal Court dismissed the appeal of a man Italy wants back to serve four and a half years in prison for fraudulent bankruptcy, a sentence the Court of Rome imposed on 24 March 2023 while he was not there. Arrested in the canton of Ticino on 2 April 2026 on an extradition warrant from the Federal Office of Justice, he argued that his defence rights had been trampled in Italy and that Switzerland should either refuse to surrender him or demand a guaranteed retrial first. The Swiss judges said no on every point, upheld the surrender decision of 24 June 2026, and sent him a bill for 3,000 francs in costs. The newsletter reporting the ruling appeared on 22 September 2026, which makes this the freshest extradition precedent in Europe this week, and it raises the exact question clients put to French lawyers every month: if you were convicted in your absence abroad and France is asked to hand you over, do you go back to prison, or do you get a second trial? France answers that question very differently from Switzerland, and the difference can decide years of your life. This article explains the Swiss ruling of this week, the French test that the Cour de cassation applies when Italy, Turkey or any other state makes the same request in Paris, and the concrete defence steps to take from the first night in the extradition cell.
I. Can France extradite you to serve a sentence imposed in your absence?
A. The Swiss-Italian test case decided this month: Rome’s sentence, the Ticino arrest and a dismissed appeal
The facts read like a file that could land on any Paris desk. On 18 March 2026, the Italian Ministry of Justice asked Switzerland to extradite a man identified as A. for the enforcement of a prison sentence of four years and six months handed down by the Court of Rome on 24 March 2023 for fraudulent bankruptcy and related offences. He was arrested in the canton of Ticino on 2 April 2026 on an arrest warrant for extradition purposes issued by the Federal Office of Justice, and during questioning he refused the simplified procedure, meaning ordinary contested extradition proceedings. By decision of 24 June 2026, the Federal Office of Justice granted extradition for the fraudulent bankruptcy charges while refusing it for another count. On 22 July 2026 he appealed to the Appeals Chamber of the Federal Criminal Court, seeking annulment of the surrender on the ground, above all, that his defence rights had been violated in the Italian proceedings because his appeal in Italy had been declared inadmissible on purely formal grounds, for lack of the specific mandate to appeal required by a new law. The Appeals Chamber dismissed everything in decision RR.2026.97 of 3 September 2026.
Three holdings in that ruling matter for anyone facing the same situation in France. First, on the in-absentia complaint, the court recalled the governing principle: The court recalled the two-sided treaty rule: where surrender is sought to enforce a sentence imposed in absence, the requested state may refuse if minimum defence rights were disregarded, but surrender is still granted where the requesting state gives sufficient guarantees of a fresh trial protecting defence rights. That rule comes from Article 3 of the Second Additional Protocol to the European Convention on Extradition, and they are the same rule French judges apply. The difference is in the review: The court recalled that the mutual-assistance judge does not re-examine the merits of foreign decisions, save for serious and manifest violations of fundamental rights. Because A. had been represented in Italy by a lawyer of his own choosing, had access to ordinary remedies, and lost his appeal through the application of a procedural rule in force at the time, the court found no serious and manifest violation and therefore no reason to condition surrender on a retrial guarantee. Second, on the plea to serve the sentence in Switzerland, where he had lived since 2014 with a family and a C residence permit, the court held that the domestic provision allowing Switzerland to take over enforcement for social rehabilitation cannot be invoked against Italy, because the extradition convention contains no equivalent rule, and that Italy had never asked Switzerland to enforce the sentence in its place. Third, on family life, the court applied the strict European standard: interference with family life is an inherent and acceptable consequence of extradition absent exceptional circumstances, and long residence plus a settled family were not exceptional enough. Dual criminality was confirmed because keeping incomplete accounts that prevent reconstructing assets is punishable in Switzerland as mismanagement and failure to keep accounts. The result is a clean, severe precedent: within the Swiss-Italian corridor, a represented defendant convicted in absence, whose only complaint is a lost procedural point abroad, is surrendered without a retrial guarantee.
Why should an international reader care about a Swiss ruling? Because the requesting state here is Italy, the convention framework is the Second Additional Protocol to the European Convention on Extradition, and the human-rights ceiling is the same European Convention on Human Rights that binds France. The Swiss decision shows the floor of protection: a represented defendant gets surrendered. France, as the next section shows, sets the bar for the requesting state noticeably higher, and that is precisely where a Paris defence is built.
B. The French rule: no surrender without a genuine second trial, as the Cour de cassation told Italy in 2023
France starts from a blunt statutory proposition. Under Article 696-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, “Le gouvernement français peut remettre, sur leur demande, aux gouvernements étrangers, toute personne n’ayant pas la nationalité française qui, étant l’objet d’une poursuite intentée au nom de l’Etat requérant ou d’une condamnation prononcée par ses tribunaux, est trouvée sur le territoire de la République.” Extradition from France is therefore possible to enforce a foreign conviction, including one imposed in absence, but only if none of the statutory bars applies. The most relevant bar for in-absentia cases sits in Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides that surrender is refused “7° Lorsque la personne réclamée serait jugée dans l’Etat requérant par un tribunal n’assurant pas les garanties fondamentales de procédure et de protection des droits de la défense”. A conviction system that locks the door to any fresh hearing after surrender falls squarely into that category, and the Cour de cassation has given the chambre de l’instruction a precise test to apply.
The leading decision is Criminal Chamber, 28 March 2023, No. 22-84.382, and its facts mirror the Swiss case almost exactly, except that the requested state was France and the outcome was the opposite. On 28 January 2020, the Italian authorities transmitted a request for provisional arrest and extradition of an Italian national to enforce a sentence of life imprisonment imposed by the Milan Assize Court of Appeal on 28 November 1985, final since 4 November 1986, for a terrorist-subversion attack committed on 12 November 1980. The man refused consent. By a ruling before final decision of 29 September 2021, the Paris chambre de l’instruction ordered further information from Italy, and by judgment of 29 June 2022 its fifth section issued an unfavourable opinion on extradition. The public prosecutor appealed, Italy tried to file observations, and the Cour de cassation rejected the appeal in full. The reasoning is the operating manual for every in-absentia extradition defence in Paris. First, the court restated the treaty rule: “L’article 3 du deuxième protocole à la Convention européenne d’extradition stipule que, dans le cas où l’extradition est demandée aux fins d’exécution d’une peine résultant d’une décision rendue par défaut, la partie requise peut refuser d’extrader si, à son avis, la procédure de jugement n’a pas satisfait aux droits minimaux de la défense reconnus à toute personne accusée d’une infraction.” Second, it imposed the human-rights control: “Il se déduit de l’article 6 de la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme relatif au droit à un procès équitable qu’un Etat partie à la Convention, requis aux fins d’extradition d’une personne, a l’obligation de s’assurer que celle-ci ne sera pas exposée, dans l’Etat requérant, à un déni de justice flagrant pouvant résulter, notamment, de l’impossibilité d’obtenir qu’une juridiction statue à nouveau sur le bien-fondé de l’accusation, alors qu’elle a fait l’objet d’une condamnation in abstentia au sens de la jurisprudence de la Cour européenne des droits de l’homme.” Third, it told the chambre de l’instruction exactly what to verify: “il appartient à la chambre de l’instruction, saisie d’un grief pris d’un déni de justice flagrant, de vérifier si la personne réclamée qui a été jugée en son absence, alors qu’il n’est pas établi qu’elle a renoncé à son droit de comparaître et de se défendre ou qu’elle a eu l’intention de se soustraire à la justice, aura la possibilité, si elle le souhaite, d’obtenir qu’une juridiction statue à nouveau, après l’avoir entendue, sur le bien-fondé de l’accusation en fait comme en droit.” If the answer is no, the opinion must be unfavourable. In the Italian case, the Paris judges concluded, on the basis of Italy’s own answers, that Italian law did not guarantee the contumacy convict a fresh full hearing after being heard, and the Cour de cassation upheld that sovereign assessment. Contrast this with the Swiss outcome: same requesting state, same in-absentia problem, but Paris blocked the surrender while Bellinzona authorised it. The lesson for defendants is that the forum of arrest decides the standard, and France applies the stricter one.
The European foundations beneath the French test are worth stating because requesting states invoke them too. The European Court of Human Rights held in Sejdovic v. Italy (Grand Chamber) that a denial of justice occurs where a person convicted in absentia cannot later obtain a fresh full hearing on the merits, in fact and law, before a court that has heard him, unless he unequivocally waived his right to appear and defend himself. Within the European Union, the arrest-warrant system harmonised the same idea: under the Framework Decision as interpreted in Melloni (C-399/11), surrender may be made conditional on an adequate assurance from the issuing authority that the person will have the opportunity to apply for a retrial in the issuing Member State and to be present at the judgment. France therefore sits at the intersection of three layers, the treaty protocol, Article 6 of the Convention, and, inside the Union, the warrant case law, and its judges use all three to test whether surrender would deliver the person to a system with a real second door.
II. Arrested in Paris on an in-absentia sentence: how the defence actually works
A. Before the Paris chambre de l’instruction: the extradition cell, the ten-day hearing and the two winning arguments
Practice first, because the first 48 hours shape the file. After the extradition request is notified, if the public prosecutor decides not to leave the requested person at liberty, the statute provides that the judge “ordonne l’incarcération et le placement sous écrou extraditionnel de la personne réclamée à la maison d’arrêt du siège de la cour d’appel” (Article 696-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Release under judicial supervision remains possible where appearance at every step is sufficiently guaranteed, and in-absentia defendants with settled Paris lives should apply immediately rather than endure months of extradition detention by default. Where the person tells the public prosecutor that he does not consent to surrender, Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure drives a fast timetable: the requested person appears before the chamber within ten working days of being presented to the prosecutor general. The chambre de l’instruction then gives a reasoned opinion, within one month of appearance unless further information is ordered, and “Cet avis est défavorable si la cour estime que les conditions légales ne sont pas remplies ou qu’il y a une erreur évidente.” Cassation review is narrow by design: “Le pourvoi formé contre un avis de la chambre de l’instruction ne peut être fondé que sur des vices de forme de nature à priver cet avis des conditions essentielles de son existence légale.” That narrowness is exactly why the in-absentia arguments must be fully built at the chambre stage, with exhibits from the requesting state’s law, not saved for later.
The first winning argument is the flagrant-denial-of-justice test from the 2023 decision. Defence counsel must prove three cumulative points with documents, not assertions: the conviction was imposed in absence within the meaning of the Strasbourg case law; it is not established that the client waived the right to appear and defend himself or intended to evade justice; and the law of the requesting state, as it stands on the day of the hearing, does not give him the genuine opportunity, if he wishes, to obtain a fresh full determination of the merits in fact and law after being heard. The 2023 Italian file shows how this is won: the Paris chamber ordered a formal request for further information, studied Italy’s own answers on contumacy remedies, and concluded that Italian law gave no such guarantee, a sovereign factual finding the Cour de cassation refused to disturb. The Swiss decision of this month shows the mirror image of the same fight: there, the judges considered that representation by chosen counsel plus ordinary remedies satisfied minimum defence rights, so no retrial guarantee was required. A Paris defence must therefore distinguish the client’s file from the Swiss pattern from day one: no effective summons, no chosen lawyer with a real mandate, appeal lost on a formality the client never knew, or a remedy that exists on paper but demands proof the absent convict cannot supply. Each of those points needs the foreign statute, the summons file, and ideally a foreign-lawyer certificate explaining what remedy truly remains.
The second argument is private and family life, and the 2023 ruling shows it can win even in the gravest cases. The Paris judges found that the man had lived continuously in France for thirty-nine years, broken all ties with Italy, married, raised two children, worked, and built a stable family and professional situation with proven social integration, and the Cour de cassation held that on those motives alone the chamber could sovereignly conclude that extradition would disproportionately infringe the right to respect for private and family life. Note the contrast with the Swiss ruling of this month, where residence since 2014 with a family and a settlement permit was held not exceptional. The French proportionality review is individual and open-textured, governed by Article 696-4 combined with Article 8 of the Convention, while the Swiss court applied the stricter “exceptional circumstances” filter. For a defendant settled in Paris or the Ile-de-France, this means assembling the full integration file now: years of presence, tax and social-security records, employment contracts, children’s schooling, medical ties, and evidence that the requesting state never sought the person for decades. An unfavourable opinion on either ground blocks the Prime Minister’s surrender decree, which is why both tracks must be run in parallel from the first hearing.
B. After the opinion: prescription dates, cassation traps and the retrial you must prepare before surrender
Even where the in-absentia battle is lost, the file often contains a second line of defence that has nothing to do with absence: time. Criminal Chamber, 28 January 2026, No. 25-81.433, the freshest French extradition precedent of this year, proves the point. Turkey had requested on 27 September 2024 the extradition of a man to enforce a cumulative six years, two months and nine days from three convictions, including a 162-day sentence converted into a fine; arrested on 12 November 2024 and placed under extradition detention the next day, he received a partially favourable opinion from the Versailles chambre de l’instruction on 5 February 2025, which treated the 162-day penalty as time-barred. The Cour de cassation partially quashed that ruling and restated two rules every defence must calendar. First, on the substance: “Il résulte du premier et du troisième de ces textes que, d’une part, l’extradition n’est pas accordée lorsque la prescription de l’action ou de la peine est acquise d’après la législation de la partie requérante”, and second, on the method: “la prescription de la peine s’apprécie à la date de l’arrestation de la personne réclamée”. The chamber had applied Turkish limitation from the wrong starting point and ignored Ankara’s own clarification that the ten-year period ran from the 1 April 2015 notification, expiring after the arrest; and the court added that limitation questions belong, outside French-competence cases, to the requesting state’s rules “telles qu’elles résultent des informations fournies par ce dernier”. For in-absentia defendants the practical message is sharp: old default convictions are the likeliest to be time-barred, but the computation runs under the requesting state’s law at the arrest date, so counsel must obtain that state’s limitation certificates immediately, in writing, with start dates and interruption events. The statutory hook is Article 696-4, 5°, of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “Lorsque, d’après la loi de l’Etat requérant ou la loi française, la prescription de l’action s’est trouvée acquise antérieurement à la demande d’extradition, ou la prescription de la peine antérieurement à l’arrestation de la personne réclamée et d’une façon générale toutes les fois que l’action publique de l’Etat requérant est éteinte”. Every in-absentia file older than five years should get a full limitation memo before the one-month opinion deadline.
The January 2026 decision also contains a procedural trap that has destroyed real appeals. The requested person’s own cassation appeal was declared inadmissible because it had been filed by a Paris-bar lawyer who neither practised before the deciding court nor produced the special power the statute requires. The rule comes from Article 576 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “Elle doit être signée par le greffier et par le demandeur en cassation lui-même ou par un avocat près la juridiction qui a statué, ou par un fondé de pouvoir spécial”. In extradition, where the chamber sits far from the client’s usual counsel and deadlines are counted in days, the special power of attorney must be signed, annexed and filed with the registry at once; a brilliant retrial argument is worthless if the appeal itself is thrown out on standing. Form also governs the chamber’s own work: under Article 593 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, investigating-chamber judgments are void without sufficient reasoning allowing the Cour de cassation to verify legality, which is why defence memoirs should expressly invite the chamber to answer each plea, retrial guarantee, waiver, limitation, proportionality, so that any silence becomes a cassation ground.
Finally, prepare the retrial before surrender rather than after. If the requesting state offers a retrial guarantee to secure surrender, that assurance must be concrete: which court, under which provision, within which deadline after handover, with release pending rehearing or at least a prompt hearing, and in which language with interpretation. Inside the European Union, the Melloni framework lets the executing authority demand exactly that assurance, and France uses it. Outside the Union, the guarantee must be extracted through the further-information procedure and annexed to the file so the chamber can condition a favourable opinion on it. Parallel steps include checking how the requesting state treats absence at the assize level, because France itself tries an accused who fails to appear without valid excuse by default under Article 379-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “L’accusé absent sans excuse valable à l’ouverture de l’audience est jugé par défaut conformément aux dispositions du présent chapitre.” French judges therefore understand default convictions perfectly well; what they require is symmetry, a genuine second hearing with the defendant present, the file re-examined in fact and law, and a decision that can reverse the first. A defence that arrives at the Paris hearing with the foreign retrial statute translated, a local counsel’s certificate confirming the remedy is real and current, a limitation computation under the requesting state’s law at the arrest date, a proportionality file proving decades of French integration, and a cassation-proof power of attorney gives the chambre de l’instruction everything it needs to say no, or to say yes only with guarantees. That is the difference between the Ticino outcome this month and the Paris outcome in 2023, and it is entirely in counsel’s hands.
Conclusion
The Swiss ruling of 3 September 2026 and the French ruling of 28 March 2023 tell one coherent story from opposite ends. Europe will enforce foreign sentences imposed in absence, but only where the absent defendant either genuinely defended himself through counsel of choice or will genuinely be heard again. Switzerland found the first condition satisfied and surrendered; France found the second condition missing and refused. For anyone arrested in France on a foreign default conviction, the strategy follows directly: contest the waiver finding with proof of defective summons and absent mandate, force the requesting state to document a real retrial remedy in writing, compute limitation under that state’s law at the arrest date, build the Article 8 integration file from the first night in detention, and file every appeal with a flawless special power. Extradition judges in Paris decide on papers and dates, not impressions, and the papers must be ready within weeks. The retrial you win in the chamber is the prison term you never serve abroad.