KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Insurance: When a Home Insurer Rejects a Lightning or Power Surge Claim

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Insurance: When a Home Insurer Rejects a Lightning or Power Surge Claim

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

By Hassan Kohen, a lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar.

Insurance is being searched for in the United Kingdom. For households in England and Wales, one practical question is what to do when a home insurer refuses to pay for electrical damage after suspected lightning or a power surge. An appliance may have stopped working at the same time as the lights went out, yet the refusal letter may say there was no proof of a covered event. Another letter may accept that there was a surge but point to an exclusion or to a precaution the policyholder was supposed to take. Those reasons call for different evidence.

This article explains the law in England and Wales as at 18 November 2026. It gives a general method for reviewing a household building or contents claim under a policy governed by that law. Start by matching each item of damage to the policy wording and the evidence of its cause. Then identify what the insurer actually disputes. The answer could turn on the scope of the cover, a technical finding about an appliance, or whether a missed precaution could have increased the risk of the particular loss. Where the insurer accepts that it owes money, a separate question is whether it has taken a reasonable time to pay.

I. Identify the cover and establish the cause of the damage

A. Read the decision against the policy in force on the day

A refusal letter is most useful when it tells you which fact or clause made the difference. Put it beside the policy schedule, the complete wording and any endorsements for the period in which the damage was discovered. The schedule identifies the cover selected, the limits and usually the applicable excess. The wording explains how the cover operates. An endorsement can alter that wording for a particular home or add a feature that the general booklet describes as optional. A booklet downloaded today may be from a different policy year or product. Keep a copy of the version issued with the policy and record the date of any renewal or change.

Open a separate line in your notes for each damaged item. A damaged roof and a failed television may have been reported together, but their claims can turn on different sections. A boiler controller might be treated as part of the building under one policy and be subject to specific wording under another. A portable device might fall under contents cover. Use the definitions in the policy and identify any optional cover actually shown on the schedule. Then record the particular event or type of damage said to trigger cover for each line. This gives you a precise basis for asking why any item has been left out.

Check whether the policy speaks of lightning, fire, accidental damage, electrical damage or failure of the item itself. These descriptions can overlap in ordinary speech. In a claim they can carry different requirements. Suppose there is a burn mark in a roof space and a failed circuit board in a downstairs appliance. The cause of the mark and the cause of the electrical failure may need separate findings. If an insurer says the circuit board failed because it was worn, ask how the technician reached that diagnosis. If it accepts a surge but says the clause covers only a narrower event, ask for the exact wording and an explanation of how it applies to the route the current is thought to have taken.

Notice the difference between a refusal of all cover and a disagreement about what a covered loss is worth. An insurer may agree to replace a failed board but decline to replace the entire appliance because a suitable board is available. It may agree that an item is damaged but deduct an excess or apply a limit. If it has put two items into one claim calculation, ask for the calculation and the wording it used. A useful estimate shows the cost of diagnosis, the part required, labour and any testing separately. Where a contractor recommends replacement, the report can explain why a repair is impractical, unsafe or unavailable. This makes a dispute about the amount easier to resolve without reopening a question of cause that both sides already accept.

The Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 62 supplies the fairness test for a consumer contract term or notice where it applies. A term is unfair where, contrary to good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties’ contractual rights and obligations to the consumer’s detriment. The nature of the contract, the circumstances at the time the term was agreed and the other relevant terms matter. An unfair term does not bind the consumer. Under section 64 of the same Act, the fairness assessment can be restricted to the extent a term specifies the contract’s main subject matter, provided the term is transparent and prominent. Section 64 also addresses assessments of the appropriateness of the price and has a specific exception for terms listed in Part 1 of Schedule 2. Both provisions came into force on 1 October 2015. These rules make the way the cover was described and presented worth recording when fairness is genuinely in issue.

A fairness complaint needs a particular clause and a reason grounded in the contract. If the household argues that a limitation was buried, retain the documents that show how the cover was presented before purchase or renewal and where the clause appeared. If the disagreement is over the meaning of words such as electrical damage or mechanical failure, identify the definitions and the competing readings before addressing fairness. A disputed fact, such as whether a board had already failed, needs factual evidence independently of how clearly either side reads the policy. A short written summary of the refusal can put the clause, the insurer’s reading and the evidence side by side.

B. Record the sequence and test alternative causes

Make a chronology before the details are forgotten. Record the last time each affected item was working, when a loss of supply or unusual event was noticed, when power returned if it had gone off, and when the damage first became apparent. Mark which times you observed yourself and which came from another person, a device log or an outage message. Keep photographs in their original form where possible. If a message gives only an approximate time or covers a broad area, record that qualification. A network notice can help establish a supply interruption in the area. It may leave open whether there was a voltage surge at the home and whether a particular item was affected by it.

An electrician or repair technician can give more useful evidence by identifying the item, recording the tests undertaken and explaining what was found. Ask the expert to state the likely type and location of the failure, any signs that support a sudden external electrical event, and whether an internal defect, age or earlier fault could explain the result. A qualified person should decide what is safe to inspect, retain or remove. Where an item needs to be made safe or disposed of promptly, record the reason, take photographs if safe and ask for a written description of any damaged parts. Where there is time to arrange it, ask the insurer what inspection it wants before a component is discarded.

Consider a hypothetical kitchen in which two appliances and a router stop working on the same evening. A router and an oven may share a supply event while the second appliance has an unrelated fault. A report that merely lists all three as broken gives little help with that possibility. Two devices failing on different circuits within a narrow time window may make a common event worth investigating. The recent service history of each device can still matter. A previous repair for an intermittent fault, a record of normal operation later that evening, or a diagnosis of a failed component can all change the picture. The report should say which inferences the evidence supports and which remain uncertain.

Separate cause from location. For example, a policyholder might assume lightning hit the building because several sockets stopped working, while a technical report points to a transient arriving through the supply. The difference may matter if the insurer reads its wording as requiring a direct strike. Conversely, the absence of a visible strike mark does not establish what happened inside a power supply. Ask which physical findings the insurer regards as material under the particular clause. Where the parties have different technical reports, compare the underlying observations. If the same photograph is being read in two ways, asking each expert what would distinguish those possible explanations can be more informative than obtaining a third general opinion.

Keep a record of steps taken to protect the property and preserve evidence. If the lighting or heating could not safely be used, record when the problem was identified, whom you informed and any emergency work that followed. Put diagnosis and urgent safety work on a different line from reinstatement and improvements. An invoice that includes both replacement of a damaged controller and an upgrade to the system should say what each part cost. If the household was already planning the upgrade, the earlier quote can help show the difference between the work it would have paid for anyway and the work it says was caused by the insured event. Keep evidence of temporary expenses separately and explain why they were incurred.

II. Challenge the stated reason and document any payment delay

A. Distinguish a missed precaution from a limit on the cover

Section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015 addresses terms aimed at reducing the risk of loss of a particular kind, in a particular place or at a particular time. It excludes terms defining the risk as a whole. Where the provision applies and a term has been breached, the insurer cannot rely on the breach to exclude, limit or discharge its liability for the loss if the insured shows that the breach could not have increased the risk of the loss that actually occurred, in the circumstances in which it occurred. The contract date matters. Section 22 of the same Act sets which contracts and variations Parts 3 and 4 apply to, and gives Part 4A its own rule based on when that Part came into force. For a household policy that has been in place for years, use the documents to establish when the relevant contract was entered into. That is a question to settle separately from whether a missed precaution increased the risk. Proof that the breach has not been established as the direct cause of the damage can leave that statutory question unanswered.

Start with the precise conduct said to breach the policy. Was a device supposed to be protected by a particular kind of equipment? Did a requirement apply at the time and to the part of the building in question? Was the condition complied with, and can a dated inspection or invoice establish that? Those questions come before any alternative argument about the relevance of a breach. Ask whether the insurer says the event falls outside the insured risk altogether or whether it says that the event came within the cover but a precaution was missed. The clause’s wording and role matter more than the label in the refusal letter.

Suppose a refusal identifies a missed precaution aimed at reducing water damage while a home is empty. The claimed loss is confined to an electrical component. An electrician’s report tracing the failure to an external surge and finding no water ingress can help explain why the missed precaution could not have made that particular loss more likely. If the investigation finds damp or water in the vicinity of the failed component, the argument needs to address what effect it could have had. The relevant question is how the breached requirement relates to the particular loss on the evidence, including the type of damage, the place where it occurred and the conditions then present.

Now suppose the clause required an appropriate surge protection device for the circuit serving a damaged appliance. A technician who confirms that the circuit had no such device and explains that a suitable device could have reduced the risk of the failure has identified a difficulty for a section 11 argument. The remaining questions might include what the policy actually required and whether the appliance was connected through the circuit the insurer identified. If a surge might instead have reached it through a different connection, the point needs a technical explanation. A simple statement that lightning protection is imperfect leaves open whether the omitted protection could still have reduced the risk. If the refusal turns on a limit defining cover for the event itself, setting aside a missed precaution under section 11 cannot bring an uninsured event within the policy.

A focused complaint can deal with alternative positions without confusing them. First say what the technician found about the cause and which part of the wording you say responds to that damage. Next explain why the breach alleged in the letter did not occur, if you have evidence of compliance. If necessary, deal separately with why a missed precaution could not have increased the risk in these particular circumstances. Attach the pages relied on and give each report or photograph a short identifying label. This lets the insurer answer the precise issue or say which part it still needs to investigate. For readers comparing legal terminology across jurisdictions, the Paris law firm’s English-language overview explains the firm’s French-law practice. The analysis here concerns household insurance in England and Wales.

B. Keep the coverage dispute, complaint and payment calculation separate

A claim chronology and a complaint chronology serve different purposes. The first shows what happened to the property and when the insurer received the evidence. The second records when you challenged the refusal, which outcome you requested, which issues were answered and what remained in dispute. Identify whether you want the insurer to reopen the causal investigation, reassess an exclusion, approve repair of a specific item, or pay an amount it has accepted. If you want reimbursement for an additional expense, list that expense with its date and document. Ask for a response that distinguishes accepted items from rejected ones and explains any amount withheld.

Where a complaint is within the ombudsman’s compulsory jurisdiction, section 228 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 requires the ombudsman to determine it by reference to what is fair and reasonable in all the circumstances. The determination is given in writing with reasons. It includes a date by which the complainant is to say whether they accept or reject it. Acceptance makes the determination final and binding on both parties. Silence by the specified date is generally treated as rejection, subject to the limited exception in subsection 6A. The date for accepting a determination is distinct from any time limit for bringing a complaint in the first place. Check the dates that apply when deciding how to proceed and keep any final response and referral correspondence.

Consider a policyholder who sends a second repair report after a refusal. A precise complaint identifies the paragraph of the first report that blamed wear, the test in the second report that points to a different mechanism and whether the insurer considered that test in maintaining its decision. It can also identify any item already accepted. A chronology that says the insurer took too long may be accurate but hard to assess until it shows what material arrived when. Keep the acknowledgement or receipt of each report, list requests for more information and note what question each request was intended to resolve. A dated file helps show both why a genuine investigation took time and whether part of the claim could have been decided sooner.

For policies to which it applies, section 13A of the Insurance Act 2015 implies a term requiring the insurer to pay sums due within a reasonable time. The provision was inserted with effect from 4 May 2017. Reasonable time includes a reasonable period for investigation and assessment. The type, size and complexity of the claim, applicable rules or guidance and factors outside the insurer’s control can matter. An insurer that shows reasonable grounds for disputing the claim does not breach the term merely by withholding the disputed amount while the dispute continues. Its conduct in handling the claim can still matter to whether and when it breached the term. Start by identifying what amount was due and what the insurer says prevented it from paying at the relevant time.

In a hypothetical claim, the insurer accepts a repair to a fire-damaged room but is still investigating whether a surge also damaged equipment elsewhere. Record what was accepted, when, whether an amount was agreed and the dates on which the insurer received the repair estimate and any further evidence. If it withholds the whole amount, ask whether the outstanding investigation affects the item already accepted and why. If the insurer says that stock delays made a repair impractical, ask how that bears on the payment decision under the policy. A decision about what work the insurer will arrange and a decision about when a sum already due should be paid can raise different issues.

Section 13A distinguishes a remedy for breach of the implied payment term from recovery of the policy payment itself and from any right to interest. A household claiming that payment delay made a temporary expense larger should keep receipts and show when each extra cost arose. For example, if temporary heating was needed immediately after the incident and remained necessary while payment was delayed, separate the initial expense from any additional period said to result from the delay. Explain when repairs could realistically have taken place and what other factors affected the timetable. A receipt establishes that a cost was incurred. The surrounding evidence explains why the household attributes all or part of it to the way the insurer dealt with the payment.

Conclusion

A refusal after suspected lightning or a surge is easier to assess when each damaged item has its own policy clause, diagnosis and repair figure. Start with the refusal as written. A disagreement about whether a covered event occurred calls for evidence of cause. A disagreement about a breached precaution calls for both the wording and an explanation of whether that breach could have increased the risk of the loss that occurred. A disagreement about repair or replacement calls for itemised estimates, the applicable limits and a clear account of what the insurer has already accepted.

The evidence may establish a supply interruption while leaving the cause of a particular failure unresolved. Where the insurer has accepted that a sum is due, the records of what was accepted and when can also show whether there is a separate payment issue. Keeping those questions distinct gives any reviewer a specific decision to assess and makes clear what still needs to be proved.

📄 Official circular