KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Joran van der Sloot: what federal law says about extorting a victim’s family

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Joran van der Sloot: what federal law says about extorting a victim’s family

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

In October 2023, Joran van der Sloot, a Dutch citizen, pleaded guilty in federal court in Birmingham, Alabama, to extorting Beth Holloway, the mother of missing woman Natalee Holloway, and to wire fraud, and a federal judge sentenced him to twenty years in prison, according to the United States Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Alabama. The case began with a federal indictment charging extortion and wire fraud for soliciting $250,000 from the mother on promises that he would reveal the location of her daughter’s remains in Aruba and the circumstances of her 2005 death. After the mother paid $25,100 through interstate and international wires, he provided information that he later described as worthless. The judgment in United States v. Van Der Sloot records guilty pleas to one count of extortion under 18 U.S.C. section 1951(a) and one count of wire fraud under 18 U.S.C. section 1343, a total sentence of two hundred forty months with the counts running concurrently, and an order entered on October 18, 2023, by Judge Anna M. Manasco in case number 2:10-cr-00237-AMM-GMB. For an American reader, this prosecution raises two practical questions that recur whenever a stranger demands money from a family: what exactly must federal prosecutors prove to turn such conduct into extortion and wire fraud, and which rights federal law guarantees victims while the case moves forward. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and does not add to the findings already made by the federal court in Alabama. Part I explains the two charges element by element, and Part II explains the victims’ statutory rights and the verifications a family should run before paying anyone who claims to hold answers.

I. What must federal prosecutors prove when someone demands money from a victim’s family?

A. How does the Hobbs Act punish extortion that affects commerce?

Federal extortion law starts with a short definition that does most of the work. Title 18, United States Code, section 1951 punishes anyone who, in the words of the statute, “Whoever in any way or degree obstructs, delays, or affects commerce or the movement of any article or commodity in commerce, by rob[…]bery or extortion or attempts or conspires so to do, or commits or threatens physical violence to any person or property in furtherance of a plan or purpose to do anything in violation of this section shall be fined under this title or impris[…]oned not more than twenty years, or both.” The full text appears in 18 U.S.C. section 1951, interference with commerce by threats or violence. The definition that follows is the one prosecutors use when the demand targets a family rather than a business: “The term ”extortion” means the obtain[…]ing of property from another, with his con[…]sent, induced by wrongful use of actual or threatened force, violence, or fear, or under color of official right.” Three ideas in that sentence decide real cases. First, the property must be obtained from the other person, even if that person technically consents to hand it over. Second, the consent must be induced by a wrongful use of force, threats, violence, or fear. Third, fear alone can qualify; the statute does not require that the defendant carry out the threatened harm. The Justice Manual summarizes the practical reach of the provision the same way, explaining that the “Hobbs Act (18 U.S.C. § 1951) which prohibits actual or attempted robbery or extortion affecting interstate or foreign commerce” a description published at the Justice Department’s Hobbs Act guidance. For a family that receives a demand tied to a missing relative, the fear element is the bridge between private anguish and federal criminal law: exploiting a parent’s fear that she will never find her child unless she pays is exactly the kind of wrongful inducement the definition describes, provided the government can also show the commerce connection the statute demands.

The commerce connection is broader than most readers expect, and a recent published decision shows how federal courts apply the Hobbs Act to demands for money. In United States v. Householder, No. 23-3565/3566 (6th Cir. May 6, 2025), decided May 6, 2025, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed convictions arising from payments made in exchange for promised official acts, explaining that “In sum, Hobbs Act extortion and honest services fraud require the government to show a quid pro quo—that is, the official received money in exchange for a promise to take specific official action.” The court added that there must be “an unambiguous meeting of the minds between the official and the payor” while emphasizing that the ways of proving that agreement are manifold, and it affirmed the convictions. The application for the reader is direct: Hobbs Act cases are prosecuted and affirmed in federal court as a matter of course, and the statute reaches attempts and conspiracies as well as completed takings, so a demand that crosses state or national lines by wire, phone, or bank transfer gives federal prosecutors the jurisdictional footing the Act requires. In the Alabama prosecution, that footing came from wires running from a Birmingham bank to an account in the Netherlands and to New York, and the judgment records the result: a guilty plea to the section 1951(a) extortion count and a two-hundred-forty-month sentence. No private agreement, partial repayment, or after-the-fact apology changes the completed offense once property was obtained through wrongful fear; those facts can matter at sentencing, but they do not erase the obtaining the statute punishes.

Two limits keep this charge honest, and families and accused persons alike should understand them. The fear must be wrongful in the sense the statute means: the defendant must have no lawful claim to use the threatened consequence as leverage for the payment. A creditor who threatens a lawful lawsuit to collect a genuine debt, a lawyer who warns of legitimate court remedies, or a journalist who threatens to publish truthful information is not committing Hobbs Act extortion, because the leverage is not wrongful. By contrast, threatening to withhold the location of a missing person’s remains unless money changes hands uses fear that the defendant has no right to monetize. The second limit is the commerce element: the extortion must obstruct, delay, or affect commerce in any way or degree. A purely local cash handoff with no interstate movement, communication, or economic effect can fall outside the federal statute even when state extortion law squarely applies. That is why prosecutors in the Alabama case emphasized the wires: the indictment described money moved from Birmingham to the Netherlands and to New York, which supplied the interstate and foreign commerce the Hobbs Act requires. A family that receives a demand should therefore preserve every detail showing how the money was supposed to move, because those routing facts are what make the federal charge available.

B. When do false promises to a grieving family become federal wire fraud?

Wire fraud is the charge prosecutors reach for when the defendant’s weapon is a lie sent across state or national lines. The statute provides: “Whoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television communication in interstate or foreign commerce, any writings, signs, signals, pictures, or sounds for the purpose of executing such scheme or artifice, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both.” The full provision is published at 18 U.S.C. section 1343, fraud by wire, radio, or television. The Congressional Research Service restates the elements courts apply in practice: “To prove those fraud offenses, the government had to show (1) a scheme to defraud that employed false material representations, (2) the use of mail or interstate wires in furtherance of the scheme and (3) the specific intent to defraud” as explained in the Congressional Research Service overview of federal mail and wire fraud law. Each element maps onto the Alabama facts. The scheme was the offer to reveal the location of remains and the circumstances of a 2005 death in exchange for money. The false pretenses were the promises themselves, which the defendant later called worthless. The wires were the bank transfers the indictment describes. And the specific intent to defraud is what separates a criminal scheme from a failed honest effort: prosecutors must show the defendant meant to deceive, not merely that the information turned out to be wrong.

The Supreme Court’s most recent word on wire fraud makes the charge easier to prove in cases like this one, not harder. In Kousisis v. United States, No. 23-909 (US May 22, 2025), decided May 22, 2025, the Supreme Court of the United States held: “A defendant who induces a victim to enter into a transaction under materially false pretenses may be convicted of federal fraud even if the defendant did not seek to cause the victim economic loss.” The Court reasoned from the text of section 1343 that a scheme may satisfy the statute “even if the defendant provides something of value in return” because, in the Court’s words, “money or property is no less “obtained” simply because something else is given in return.” The opinion is a preliminary slip print that remains subject to formal revision before the bound volume publishes, but its reasoning states the law the Justices applied. The application to a family facing a demand for answers is immediate: a defendant cannot defeat a wire fraud charge by pointing out that he actually delivered something, such as vague directions, partial information, or a meeting, if the victim parted with money because of materially false pretenses. Worthless information delivered after payment does not retroactively make the pretenses true; under Kousisis, the question is whether the false statements induced the victim to send the money, not whether the victim received something in exchange. That is why the detail that the Alabama defendant called his own post-payment information worthless matters so much: it tends to show the promises were the engine of the payments rather than an honest effort that simply failed.

Materiality and intent are where wire fraud cases are won and lost, so a family preserving evidence should aim at exactly those two points. A false statement is material when it has a natural tendency to influence, or is capable of influencing, the victim’s decision to pay. Promises to disclose where a missing loved one lies and how she died are about as material as statements get, because no grieving parent pays $250,000 for trivia; the entire payment turns on whether the speaker actually knows the answers. Intent to defraud is proved circumstantially: through contradictions in the defendant’s story, through demands for secrecy or cash routing that avoids banks, through escalating sums once the victim shows willingness to pay, and through admissions like describing the delivered information as worthless. The Alabama record illustrates each marker. When the defendant was brought to the United States to face the charges, the Justice Department stated that he was arraigned in Birmingham on one count of extortion and one count of wire fraud for soliciting money from the mother on promises about her daughter’s remains, that he had been temporarily surrendered under the extradition treaty between the United States and Peru, and that an indictment contains only charges, with every defendant presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty, as documented in the Justice Department statement on the arraignment and temporary surrender. Thirteen years later, the plea announcement confirmed the outcome: the defendant “pleaded guilty to extortion and wire fraud and was sentenced to 20 years in prison” after soliciting money “on promises he would reveal the location of her daughter’s remains in Aruba and the circumstances of her 2005 death” and after “being paid a total of $25,100” providing information “that he later described as ‘worthless,'” according to the 2023 plea and sentencing announcement. The lesson for any family is evidentiary: keep every message, record every call where the law of your state permits it, save every wire receipt, and never let the demand’s urgency talk you into deleting the very records that prove materiality and intent.

II. What rights and practical protections does federal law give victims’ families?

A. Which rights does the Crime Victims’ Rights Act guarantee during the case?

Federal law treats the victim’s family as a participant with enforceable rights, not as a bystander to the prosecution. Section 3771 of title 18 provides: “A crime victim has the following rights:” and then lists ten, among them “The right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court involv[…]ing release, plea, sentencing, or any parole proceeding” “The reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the Government in the case” and “The right to full and timely restitution as provided in law” together with rights to notice, to protection from the accused, to proceedings free from unreasonable delay, and to fair treatment with respect for dignity and privacy. The complete list is published at 18 U.S.C. section 3771, crime victims’ rights. In the Alabama prosecution, brought in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama, these rights had visible shape: the docket reflects that the court set ground rules for victim-impact statements at sentencing, limiting them to the victim of the charged extortion and wire fraud conduct and her immediate family, which is exactly how the right to be reasonably heard works in practice. A family in a comparable federal case should therefore expect three things as of right: timely notice of public proceedings, a chance to confer with the prosecutor, and an opportunity to be heard at plea and sentencing. Restitution is also a right, though its measure follows separate statutes and the court’s findings, so families should document every dollar of loss, including money wired, travel costs, and related expenses, and provide that accounting to the prosecutor well before sentencing.

The right to be heard matters most at the two moments that decide the defendant’s future: the plea and the sentencing. In the Alabama case, the plea and the sentencing occurred on the same day, October 18, 2023, before Judge Manasco, and the judgment records that the defendant pleaded guilty to both counts and received concurrent two-hundred-forty-month terms, as shown in the criminal judgment in case number 2:10CR237 AMM-GMB. A guilty plea does not end the victim’s role; under section 3771 the victim has the right to be informed in a timely manner of any plea bargain and to be reasonably heard before the court accepts it and imposes sentence. Practically, this means the family should stay in contact with the victim-witness coordinator at the United States Attorney’s Office, submit a written impact statement even if its members also plan to speak, and ask the prosecutor how the plea agreement addresses restitution and the factual basis. The factual basis matters because admissions made during a plea colloquy, such as acknowledging that solicited money was obtained through false promises, become part of the judicial record and can later support restitution orders and related civil claims. Families should also understand what the rights do not include: victims do not decide what charges are filed, whether a plea is offered, or what sentence is imposed. Those decisions belong to the prosecutor and the court. The rights guarantee voice, notice, and consideration, not control, and a family that understands that boundary can use its voice far more effectively.

Threats against victims and their advocates receive separate federal attention, and a recent appellate decision from the circuit covering Alabama shows how courts evaluate them. In United States v. Albizar-Martinez, No. 25-11781 (11th Cir. Oct. 3, 2025), decided October 3, 2025, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the conviction of a defendant who left a threatening voicemail for a member of Congress, rejecting claims that the message was protected political hyperbole and that the jury had been misinstructed on “the subjec[…]tive intent necessary to convict under the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023).” Reviewing the record, the court concluded that “sufficient evidence supports the conclusion that Albizar-Martinez intended to make a serious threat” and added the point readers most often misunderstand: “That Albizar-Martinez did not “actually intend to carry out the threat” is not a defense.” Like the Lewis decision, this opinion was issued per curiam on the non-argument calendar and marked not for publication, so it is used here as a recent illustration rather than as the sole basis for any rule. The application for families is twofold. First, threats communicated to a family, whether by phone, message, or voicemail, can support federal prosecution even when the speaker later claims he was venting, joking, or engaging in politics; context and intent are for the jury, assessed message by message. Second, the decision vindicates careful preservation: the court worked from a transcribed and translated voicemail, which shows why saving exact words, recordings, timestamps, and caller identifiers is the single most useful thing a threatened family can do.

B. What checks should a family run before paying anyone who claims to have answers?

No family should wire money to a stranger who claims to know where a missing loved one lies without running through a fixed verification sequence, and federal practice supplies the checklist. First, contact law enforcement before paying anything: the local police department handling the missing-person case and the nearest Federal Bureau of Investigation field office. In the Alabama investigation, the FBI worked with Aruban authorities to build the extortion case after learning the mother had been contacted, and agents ran the operation that documented the payments; going to the Bureau early lets agents advise whether payment would help or hinder, and in some cases agents can supervise a controlled transaction that preserves evidence. Second, demand verifiable proof of knowledge before discussing money: a detail about the disappearance that was never made public and that investigators can confirm, not vague claims of knowing the location. A genuine witness can provide one checkable fact without payment; a fraudster trades only in promises of future revelation. Third, never route money the way the demand instructs when the routing is designed to evade banks: split wires to foreign accounts, cash hand deliveries through intermediaries, or cryptocurrency transfers to new wallets are classic indicia of a scheme rather than of a legitimate reward. The Alabama wires illustrate the pattern prosecutors later mapped: funds moved from Birmingham to the Netherlands and through New York to Aruba. Fourth, memorialize everything in real time: photograph or screenshot every message, export call logs, keep bank confirmations, and write down dates, amounts, account numbers, and the exact words used about what the money would buy. Those records prove the interstate wire element, the materiality of the promises, and the intent behind them.

Three further precautions protect both the investigation and the family’s later claims. One is to resist secrecy instructions. Extortionists routinely tell victims not to call the police, claiming that publicity will kill the loved one or destroy the deal; that instruction serves the scheme, not the family, and federal victim-rights law runs the opposite direction, guaranteeing notice, conferral with the prosecutor, and the right to be heard. A second precaution is to route all communication through one trusted person and one lawyer if counsel is involved, so that no payment is made impulsively at midnight in response to a new threat. Counsel can also hold funds in escrow conditioned on verified delivery of the promised information, which converts an all-or-nothing wire into a checkable exchange and creates a paper trail of good faith. The third precaution is financial self-defense: notify the sending bank promptly if a wire was already transmitted, because banks can sometimes recall or freeze transfers within a short window, and file reports with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center and the Federal Trade Commission so the account identifiers enter law enforcement systems. None of these steps requires the family to decide whether the claimant is lying; that determination belongs to investigators, prosecutors, and ultimately a jury. The family’s job is narrower and fully within its control: slow the transaction down, force every claim into writing, keep law enforcement inside the process, and preserve the records that let the Hobbs Act, the wire fraud statute, and the victims’ rights provisions do their work. Where the demand involves threats of violence rather than promises of information, add one more step: report the threat immediately and preserve the exact threat language, because as the recent appellate illustration confirms, liability turns on whether the speaker intended a serious threat, not on whether he meant to carry it out.

Conclusion

Two federal charges and one set of victims’ rights decide cases built on demands made to grieving families. Extortion under the Hobbs Act punishes obtaining property through the wrongful use of fear, including fear deliberately cultivated in a parent who may never otherwise learn what happened to a missing child, whenever the conduct affects commerce in any degree. Wire fraud punishes schemes that use interstate or foreign wires to obtain money through materially false promises, and recent precedent confirms that delivering something of nominal value in return does not cleanse a transaction induced by lies. Victims hold statutory rights to notice, to conferral with the prosecutor, to be heard at plea and sentencing, and to restitution as provided by law, and those rights work only when families stay in documented contact with the prosecution team. The operational sequence follows from the law: report before paying, demand independently verifiable proof, refuse secrecy and evasive routing, preserve every message and receipt, and let investigators test the claims. Grief makes families urgent; the statutes reward the family that insists on verification first.

📄 Official circular