KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Mansion Tax UK: How Will It Work From April 2028, and Can the Valuation Office Inspect Your Home?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Mansion Tax UK: How Will It Work From April 2028, and Can the Valuation Office Inspect Your Home?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

By Hassan Kohen, a lawyer at the Paris Bar.

The search mansion tax has been rising in the United Kingdom since 20 November 2026, and the questions typed after it are practical ones: mansion tax uk how will it work, mansion tax bands, mansion tax uk valuation, mansion tax home inspections and mansion tax property inspection fines. “Mansion tax” is the popular name for the High Value Council Tax Surcharge. Government guidance updated on 28 October 2026 states that the surcharge would apply from April 2028 to owners of residential property in England worth £2 million or more in 2026, and a tax information note published the same day states that it is being legislated for in the Finance Bill 2026-27. This article explains, under the law of England (United Kingdom) as it stands on 22 November 2026, how the proposed charge would work, what the council tax rules in force already allow the Valuation Office to do inside a home, what refusing to cooperate can cost, and how a band can be contested. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are not covered.

The surcharge is not yet law. Until Parliament passes the Finance Bill and the secondary legislation announced for 2027 is made, the rules that apply are those of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, under which each billing authority levies council tax on the dwellings situated in its area.

What follows is of general scope: information on English law written by tax lawyers in Paris, not advice on any particular property, valuation or bill. The figures given for the surcharge come from official documents describing a proposal, and they could change while the Bill is before Parliament.

I. Mansion tax UK: how will it work, who would pay and how much?

A. Mansion tax threshold and bands: the surcharge as officially proposed

Where the description comes from. Two official documents set out the proposal. The first is the government’s guidance on the High Value Council Tax Surcharge, updated on 28 October 2026. The second is a tax information and impact note published on the same day. According to these documents, the measure was announced at Budget 2025, a consultation on its detailed design was launched in May 2026, and the government published its full response at Budget 2026. The note states that the surcharge is being legislated for in the Finance Bill 2026-27 and that the government will bring forward secondary legislation in 2027. Everything in this section is therefore a description of what the government says the surcharge would be. Nothing in it is yet a rule that a court or a council can apply.

The £2 million threshold. The guidance describes the surcharge as a new charge on owners of residential property in England worth £2 million or more in 2026, taking effect in April 2028. The note gives the operative date as 1 April 2028. The Valuation Office would carry out a targeted valuation exercise to identify the homes above the threshold, and the government expects fewer than 1% of properties in England to be in scope. The value that counts would be the value in 2026, not the price paid by the owner and not the value on the day the first bill arrives.

Four flat-rate bands. Homes above the threshold would be placed in one of four bands, each carrying a fixed annual amount:

Value of the home (2026 values) Proposed annual surcharge
£2.0 million to £2.5 million £2,500
£2.5 million to £3.5 million £3,500
£3.5 million to £5.0 million £5,000
£5 million and above £7,500

The guidance adds that the charges would increase each year in line with CPI inflation from 2029-30, that decisions on uprating the bands would be taken alongside revaluations, and that revaluations would take place every five years, the next one in 2033. The government estimates that the surcharge would raise around £400 million a year from 2028-29. The note estimates that around 150,000 individuals and around 15,000 businesses and civil society organisations own homes in scope.

The timetable announced. Three dates matter for an owner. Draft bands would become visible to taxpayers in autumn 2027. Local authorities would issue the first surcharge bills in March 2028. The charge itself would apply from 1 April 2028. Before any of this happens, the Finance Bill must complete its passage through Parliament and the secondary legislation must be made. If the final text differs from the documents described here, the final text will prevail.

How the value would be set. The guidance describes a model-assisted valuation. The Valuation Office would use sales data for comparable properties around the April 2026 valuation date, together with the property type, its age, the number of rooms and its area, to produce an initial value. A professional valuer would then use judgment to place the property in the right band. The guidance states that most properties can be banded from information the Valuation Office already holds and that visits would be needed only in limited circumstances. Part II explains what the law in force allows during such a visit.

B. Who would pay the mansion tax, and how it would sit on top of council tax

Council tax today: the occupier usually pays. Council tax is a tax on dwellings, but the bill goes to a person chosen by a statutory ladder. Under section 6 of the 1992 Act, the liable person is the first one found in this order: a resident with a freehold interest, then a resident with a leasehold interest that is not inferior to another resident’s, then a resident who is a statutory, secure or introductory tenant, then a resident with a contractual licence to occupy, then any resident, and only last the owner. A “resident” is an individual aged 18 or over whose sole or main residence is the dwelling. Where two or more people sit on the same rung, section 6(3) makes them jointly and severally liable. In practice, when a house is let, the tenant who lives there pays the council tax, and the owner pays only when nobody is resident.

The surcharge: the owner would pay. The guidance takes the opposite approach for the surcharge. It states that homeowners, rather than occupiers, would be liable, and that they would continue to pay their existing council tax alongside the surcharge. For an owner-occupier the difference is invisible, because the same person receives both bills. For a landlord who lets a £3 million house, the tenant would keep paying the council tax for the band shown in the valuation list, while the owner would receive the surcharge bill. The note confirms that companies and other organisations that own homes in scope would be liable too.

Why a £10 million home can pay less council tax than a £400,000 one. Council tax bands in England are still based on property values in 1991. Section 5(2) sets eight bands for England, from band A for values not exceeding £40,000 to band H for values exceeding £320,000. Those values are not today’s prices. Section 21 requires valuations to be carried out by reference to the appropriate date, which for the current lists is 1 April 1991. The Council Tax (Situation and Valuation of Dwellings) Regulations 1992 then say that the value of a dwelling is the amount which it “might reasonably have been expected to realise if it had been sold in the open market by a willing vendor on 1st April 1991”, on stated assumptions: a sale with vacant possession, the freehold or, for a flat, a lease of 99 years at a nominal rent, and a dwelling in a state of reasonable repair. Every home worth more than £320,000 in 1991 therefore sits in band H, whatever it is worth now.

The ratio between bands. Section 5(1) fixes the proportion between the bands at 6:7:8:9:11:13:15:18. Band D is the reference point at 9, so a band H home pays exactly twice the band D amount of the same area, and a band A home pays two thirds of it. Because each billing authority sets its own amounts, a band H bill in one area can be lower than a band D bill in another. The tax information note gives its own illustration: a band D home in Darlington or Blackpool worth around £400,000 pays £2,400 to £2,600 a year, while a band H home in Mayfair valued at £10 million pays around £2,100. The surcharge is presented as a partial answer to that gap. It would not change the council tax bands themselves.

A simple calculator. Because the proposed bands are flat amounts, the arithmetic is short. Take the existing council tax bill and add the amount for the surcharge band. A house valued at £2.3 million in 2026 would pay its council tax plus £2,500 a year. A flat valued at £2.6 million would pay its council tax plus £3,500. A house valued at £4.9 million would pay its council tax plus £5,000, and one valued at £5.2 million would pay its council tax plus £7,500. A home valued at £1.95 million would pay no surcharge at all. The documents describe no tapering between bands, so a small difference in value either side of a band limit would change the bill by £1,000, £1,500 or £2,500 a year. That is why the valuation, and the right to contest it, will matter far more than the arithmetic.

Deferral, exemptions and empty homes. The guidance announces a deferral scheme for owners with limited ability to pay. An owner would qualify if one of three criteria is met: an annual household income of £35,000 or less, capital savings of £16,000 or less, or a member of the household meeting disability criteria. Deferral would postpone payment until the ownership of the home changes, with a fair rate of interest, and the owner could end it at any time and settle earlier. The note states that local authorities would assess eligibility against nationally set criteria to be laid down in secondary legislation. Exemptions and discounts would apply to certain property types, including care homes, registered social housing and working farmhouses. Finally, a premium of 100% would be charged on homes left substantially unfurnished and unoccupied for 12 months or more.

What already exists for empty homes and hardship. That premium mirrors a power councils already have for council tax. Under section 11B, a billing authority in England may increase the council tax on a long-term empty dwelling, meaning one that has been unoccupied and substantially unfurnished for a continuous period of at least one year. For financial years from 1 April 2021, the maximum increase is 100% for a home empty for less than five years, 200% between five and ten years, and 300% from ten years. Breaks of six weeks or less are ignored when counting the period. For hardship, section 13A requires every billing authority in England to run a council tax reduction scheme for people in financial need, and allows it to reduce any council tax bill to such extent as it thinks fit, including to nil, in a particular case or for a class of cases. Whether these existing powers would reach the surcharge itself depends on the final text of the Finance Bill and of the regulations to come.

II. Mansion tax home inspections, fines and challenges: what the Valuation Office can do today

A. Mansion tax home inspections: tribunal approval, written notice and property inspection fines

What the guidance says about visits. The guidance states that, in some limited circumstances, the Valuation Office may need to visit properties to make sure the banding is accurate. Where that is necessary, the visit would take place in the same way as it does at present in council tax, by prior agreement, and in line with the government’s code of practice on powers of entry. The law in force for council tax is therefore the best guide to what an owner can expect. That law draws a sharp line between a visit agreed with the owner and an entry made under a statutory power.

A statutory entry needs a tribunal’s approval. Since 1 October 2015, powers of entry for council tax valuations in England have been governed by section 25A of the 1992 Act. When a valuation officer needs to value a dwelling in England for the purpose of any of the officer’s functions, the officer, and any servant of the Crown authorised in writing, may enter on, survey and value the dwelling. That power is subject to strict conditions. The valuation officer must first obtain the approval of the tribunal, which section 25A(9) defines as the First-tier Tribunal. Section 25A(3) is explicit: “The tribunal must not give its approval unless it is satisfied that the valuation officer needs to value the dwelling.” The tribunal may also decide any question arising from the application and set the arrangements for the entry, including whether it may take place on more than one day.

At least three working days’ written notice. Once the tribunal has given its approval, section 25A(4) requires at least three days’ notice in writing of the proposed entry. Under section 25A(7), Saturdays, Sundays, Christmas Day, Good Friday and bank holidays in England and Wales do not count. A person authorised by the valuation officer must, if asked, produce the written authorisation. In practice, an owner who receives a notice of entry can check three things: that a tribunal approval exists, that the notice period has been respected once weekends and holidays are excluded, and that the person at the door holds a written authorisation.

The fine for obstruction: level 1, £200. The only offence attached to the power of entry is in section 25A(6) of the 1992 Act: “A person who intentionally delays or obstructs a person in the exercise of a power under this section is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 1 on the standard scale.” The standard scale is set by section 122 of the Sentencing Act 2020. For an offence committed on or after 1 October 1992, level 1 is £200, level 2 is £500 and level 3 is £1,000. Three features of the offence deserve attention. It requires intention, so a genuine misunderstanding about a date is not the same as obstruction. It is a criminal offence tried in a magistrates’ court, not an automatic penalty added to a bill. And, on the wording of section 25A, it concerns the exercise of the statutory power, which exists only once the tribunal has approved the entry and written notice has been given. A request for a visit by agreement is not, in itself, an exercise of that power. Declining such a request does not trigger the section 25A offence, although it may lead the valuation officer to apply to the tribunal.

The code of practice on powers of entry. The guidance refers to the government’s code of practice on powers of entry. That code rests on the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. Section 47 requires the Secretary of State to prepare a code containing guidance about the exercise of powers of entry, which may cover the considerations before and when exercising them and after exercising them, such as the keeping of records. Under section 48, the code is laid before Parliament and comes into force by an order approved by each House. Its legal effect is set out in section 51. A relevant person, meaning a person specified or described by order, must have regard to the code. The same section adds: “A failure on the part of any person to act in accordance with any provision of the powers of entry code does not of itself make that person liable to criminal or civil proceedings.” The code is nevertheless admissible in evidence, and a court or tribunal may take into account a failure to have regard to it. A visit carried out without the courtesy and record-keeping the code expects is therefore not unlawful for that reason alone, but the failure can be raised in later proceedings.

Information notices: 21 days, then a level 2 fine. Most valuations do not require anyone to enter a home. The more common tool is a written request for information. Under section 27 of the 1992 Act, a valuation officer may serve on a person who is or has been an owner or occupier of a dwelling a notice requesting information of a description specified in the notice and stating that the officer believes it will assist in carrying out the officer’s functions. The recipient must supply the information if it is in their possession or control, in the form and manner specified, within 21 days beginning with the day on which the notice is served. Under section 27(4), a person who fails without reasonable excuse to comply is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 2 on the standard scale, which is £500. Under section 27(5), a person who knowingly or recklessly makes a statement that is false in a material particular is liable to imprisonment for up to three months, a fine not exceeding level 3, which is £1,000, or both.

What the Valuation Office may use, and who may see it. Section 27(7) allows a listing officer to take into account any other information available, whatever its source, and section 27(6) obliges the council to pass on to the listing officer information that would help. An owner should therefore assume that planning records, sale particulars and earlier answers to the Valuation Office are all part of the file. In the other direction, section 21 protects the information. The Commissioners may appoint people outside the Crown service to help with valuations and may disclose survey reports and section 27 information to them, but a person who uses or discloses that material otherwise than for the purposes of the valuations commits an offence punishable by up to two years’ imprisonment on indictment.

New offences announced, not yet enacted. The tax information note states that new legislation will also create criminal offences to ensure effective administration of the surcharge. Their content depends on the Finance Bill as finally passed and on the secondary legislation. Until then, the offences that exist are those described above: obstruction of a statutory entry, failure to answer an information notice without reasonable excuse, and false statements.

B. Mansion tax valuation: how to challenge a band, how to appeal and what happens if you do not pay

The route announced for the surcharge. The guidance states that a homeowner who wishes to dispute a banding decision, including whether the property is in scope at all, or their liability, would first make a challenge to the relevant body, and could then appeal to the Valuation Tribunal for England if not satisfied with the outcome. It adds that more information will be published on the kinds of evidence that can be used and on how evidence is assessed. The detailed procedure is not yet law. The council tax procedure in force is the obvious template, and it shows the kind of deadlines an owner should expect.

Council tax challenges today: a written proposal. The Council Tax (Alteration of Lists and Appeals) (England) Regulations 2009 govern challenges to a council tax band in England. Under regulation 4, the billing authority or an interested person, which includes the owner, may make a proposal to alter the list on stated grounds: for example, that the listing officer determined the wrong band, or that an event listed in regulation 3 has occurred since the band was first shown. Time limits apply. A person who becomes the taxpayer for a dwelling may make a proposal within six months of first becoming the taxpayer, unless the tribunal has already determined a proposal on the same facts. Where the listing officer has altered the list, a proposal against that alteration must be made within six months of the notice of alteration.

What the proposal must contain. Regulation 5 requires a written notice served on the listing officer stating the proposer’s name, address and capacity, identifying the dwelling, setting out the alteration sought and giving the reasons for believing the list to be inaccurate. The listing officer must acknowledge receipt within 28 days. If the officer considers the proposal invalid, regulation 7 allows an invalidity notice within four weeks, against which the proposer may, within four weeks, either make a further proposal or appeal to the Valuation Tribunal for England.

The decision and the appeal deadline. Under regulation 9, the listing officer has four months from the service of the proposal to decide whether it is well founded in whole, in part or not at all, and may reach an agreement with the proposer on a different alteration. A written decision notice follows. If the officer decides not to alter the list as proposed and no agreement is reached, regulation 10 allows the proposer to appeal to the Valuation Tribunal for England within three months beginning on the date on which the decision notice was served. A late appeal may still be authorised by the tribunal’s President, but only where the delay arose from circumstances beyond the appellant’s control. Missing the three-month window is the most common way to lose a good argument.

When a change takes effect. Regulation 11 fixes the date from which an alteration has effect. An increase in value caused by works takes effect only from the day the alteration is entered in the list, while a reduction in value takes effect from the day the circumstances causing it arose. Where the band was wrong from the day the list was compiled, a correction that lowers it takes effect from the day the list was compiled, whereas a correction that raises it takes effect only from the day it is entered. These rules protect owners against backdated increases and allow backdated reductions, and section 24 of the 1992 Act allows the regulations to provide for the resulting payments and repayments. Section 24 also limits when a band may be changed at all: broadly, after building or other works followed by a qualifying sale, after a material reduction in value, or when the listing officer is satisfied that the band was wrongly determined.

Disputes about liability rather than value. A different route applies when the dispute is not about the value but about who must pay or how much. Under section 16 of the 1992 Act, a person aggrieved by a decision that a dwelling is chargeable, that they are liable, or by the calculation of the amount, must first serve a written notice on the billing authority stating the matter and the grounds. An appeal to the valuation tribunal is then possible if the authority replies that the grievance is not well founded, if it replies that it has taken steps but the person remains aggrieved, or if two months pass without any reply. For the surcharge, the same distinction is likely to matter: a challenge to the band would go to the valuation body, and a challenge to liability, a deferral decision or an exemption would go to the local authority.

Preparing the evidence. The guidance lists the evidence the Valuation Office intends to use: comparable sales around the April 2026 valuation date, property type, age, number of rooms and area. An owner whose home is close to £2 million, or close to one of the band limits at £2.5 million, £3.5 million or £5 million, can usefully keep a record of the condition of the home in spring 2026, of its exact floor area, and of the features that a model may miss, such as structural defects, an unusual layout or restrictions on use. A valuation report prepared by a surveyor as at April 2026, and the sale prices of truly comparable homes at that time, are the kind of material that a challenge would rely on. The assumptions that will govern the surcharge valuation have not yet been published, and the 1991 assumptions used for council tax should not be taken for granted.

What happens if the surcharge is not paid. According to the tax information note, local authorities would be responsible for administering and enforcing the surcharge, and where charges remain unpaid they could apply to the magistrates’ court for a liability order and enforce it in line with the council tax enforcement framework. That framework appears in section 14 of the 1992 Act, which gives effect to Schedule 2 on administration and collection, Schedule 3 on civil penalties and Schedule 4 on the recovery of sums due. Section 14(4) adds that, once a liability order has been made, the billing authority may use the procedure for taking control of goods to recover the amount that remains unpaid. An owner who cannot pay should therefore act before arrears build up, by asking the council about the deferral scheme once it exists, rather than waiting for enforcement.

Conclusion

The “mansion tax” that is being searched across the United Kingdom is, on 22 November 2026, a proposal. According to the government’s guidance and the tax information note of 28 October 2026, the High Value Council Tax Surcharge would apply from 1 April 2028 to owners of homes in England worth £2 million or more in 2026, with four flat annual amounts of £2,500, £3,500, £5,000 and £7,500, payable by the owner on top of the existing council tax. The next dated steps announced are the passage of the Finance Bill 2026-27, secondary legislation in 2027, draft bands visible in autumn 2027, first bills in March 2028 and a first revaluation in 2033. Until the Bill is passed, the figures may change, and the final text will prevail over every description given here.

The questions about home inspections and fines already have answers in the law in force. A valuation officer may enter a home in England under section 25A of the Local Government Finance Act 1992 only with the approval of the First-tier Tribunal and after at least three working days’ written notice, and intentional obstruction of that entry is punishable by a fine of up to £200. Failing without reasonable excuse to answer an information notice within 21 days is punishable by a fine of up to £500, and a knowingly or recklessly false answer by up to three months’ imprisonment, a fine of up to £1,000, or both. The government states that surcharge visits would take place in the same way as council tax visits, by prior agreement and in line with the code of practice on powers of entry.

For owners close to a threshold, the decisive moment will be the publication of draft bands in autumn 2027. The council tax procedure in force shows what to expect: a written proposal stating reasons, a decision within a fixed period, and an appeal to the Valuation Tribunal for England within three months of the decision notice. The detailed rules for the surcharge, the criminal offences it would add and the assumptions behind its valuations remain to be established by the final legislation.

📄 Official circular