KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
mcu films: do screen credits determine who owns a screenplay?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

mcu films: do screen credits determine who owns a screenplay?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Marvel’s official movie page lists the films of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, including the forthcoming Avengers: Doomsday. The Writers Guild of America’s public directory for that film distinguishes its feature writing credit from a list of additional literary material, which the directory labels as not on-screen. Those public entries make it natural to ask what a writing credit actually tells a reader about copyright ownership.

The answer under federal law is that a credit is useful evidence about a person’s relationship to a project, but it does not by itself establish who owns the copyright in a screenplay, a contribution to it, or the finished film. The answer depends on the work being examined, the creative contribution, the relationship in which it was made, and any effective agreement or transfer. A person may receive professional recognition while another party owns the copyright. Conversely, a missing or limited credit does not settle every ownership question.

For someone writing, commissioning, financing, or adapting a screenplay, the practical starting point is to assemble the actual drafts and agreements before drawing conclusions from a title card or directory. The discussion below is general in scope and makes no findings about the ownership or contracts of any particular production. It examines federal copyright rules and identifies where decisions from different federal courts provide useful, but geographically distinct, guidance.

I. What does a screenwriting credit tell you about copyright ownership?

A. Separate the credit from the work and the contributor’s role

A credit answers a public-facing question: how a person is identified in connection with a production. Copyright ownership answers a different question: who holds a legally recognized interest in a particular protected work and, if rights were transferred, which rights remain with each party. The two questions can overlap, because credits and related communications may show how the people involved described their roles. They need not have the same answer. A credit line alone does not reveal a signed assignment, an employment relationship, or the terms of an agreement to license a script.

First identify the work. A production may start with a written treatment, move through several screenplay drafts, and become a motion picture with performances, images, sound, editing, and other contributions. Those materials are connected, but they are not interchangeable for an ownership inquiry. The person asking about a particular screenplay should identify the version and the material in question before asking who controlled the finished film. Similarly, a credit for writing services is not necessarily a statement that the credited person owns all rights in every version.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 102 protects original works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium of expression and lists literary works and motion pictures among the covered categories. It does not protect an idea or concept as such. A proposal for a plot twist and a written scene expressing that twist therefore present different questions. The distinction does not answer whether any particular scene is sufficiently original, who created it, or whether a contractual transfer changed its ownership.

Keep a dated copy of each draft and a record of what changed. If a contributor added dialogue, identify the pages and versions containing that dialogue; if another person suggested a general direction, preserve the relevant message without assuming it has the same legal character as the resulting written expression. A table that records the document, date, author as indicated on the file, and nature of the change can make an otherwise abstract dispute much more concrete. File names alone may be misleading, so compare the actual text and preserve any version history that shows how it developed.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 101 defines a joint work by reference to two or more authors intending their contributions to be merged into inseparable or interdependent parts of a unitary whole. Under 17 U.S.C. § 201(a), the authors of a joint work are co-owners of its copyright. The federal statutory language is the starting point; courts have addressed what counts as authorship and how the parties’ intent is demonstrated. Their approaches are not identical in every circuit.

In Fokiss, Inc. v. TLM Global, LLC, No. 24-cv-14096-KMM (S.D. Fla. Jan. 31, 2025), the United States District Court, Southern District of Florida, decided on January 31, 2025, that the evidence at the preliminary-injunction stage did not support the claimed co-authorship of a documentary film by the party that commissioned and promoted it. The court considered the actual creative work and the parties’ roles, applying factors drawn from other circuits. The order was preliminary rather than a final ownership judgment. For a screenplay contributor, the useful check is to preserve evidence of the specific expression supplied and the parties’ objective understanding, not just the fact that the project was funded or promoted.

That distinction matters even when a contribution was important to making a project possible. Financing, introductions, research, approval, and promotional work may be commercially valuable. The documents concerning them can also be important to a separate contract question. But a reader should not treat the commercial importance of a role as a substitute for examining the particular work and the legal basis claimed for authorship. Ask who wrote which material, who had creative control, and what the parties recorded about their respective roles.

In David v. George Chiala Farms, Inc., No. 24-cv-04040-SI (N.D. Cal. Nov. 7, 2025), the United States District Court, Northern District of California, decided on November 7, 2025, to dismiss a joint-authorship counterclaim concerning a logo, with permission to amend. Applying Ninth Circuit principles to the allegations, the court found the alleged shared intent and independently copyrightable contribution insufficient. A logo is not a screenplay, and the ruling addressed pleadings rather than a completed trial. The practical lesson for a film project is to record concrete creative expression and evidence of shared authorship instead of relying solely on directions, suggestions, or a general statement that people worked together.

Evidence of intent can take several forms. A signed collaboration agreement may specify whether the participants consider themselves co-authors. Draft exchanges, production notes, and contemporaneous descriptions of decision-making may also be relevant to how a court evaluates a disputed relationship. A credit can be part of that evidence, but the surrounding documents matter: a line naming a contributor might reflect a negotiated recognition term, a description of services, or the parties’ view of authorship. Its meaning should be read in context rather than guessed from the line in isolation.

Different federal courts have approached collaborative work in different ways. In Worrell v. Thang, Inc., No. 25-1863 (6th Cir. May 27, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit decided on May 27, 2026, to reverse the district court’s summary judgment on limitations grounds for recordings within the scope of a disputed agreement. The court also found a genuine factual dispute about co-authorship on the summary-judgment record and remanded for further proceedings. The court concluded that the estate could rely on evidence of substantial original expression without showing that every contribution could stand alone as a separately copyrightable recording. The decision concerned recordings, not a film screenplay, and it did not finally decide who owned each recording. For a collaborative script, it illustrates why the actual creative contribution and evidence of shared authorship deserve careful preservation, while the applicable circuit’s approach must be checked separately.

These decisions arise in different courts and at different stages. The Florida district court issued a preliminary injunction on the record before it; the California district court tested allegations and allowed amendment; the Sixth Circuit returned disputed issues for further proceedings. None decides ownership of a different project merely because several people contributed. For a real screenplay, the work, the relevant agreements, the evidence, and the court whose law applies can change the answer.

B. Check whether the writing was made for hire or later transferred

Even a person who wrote original text may not be the initial copyright owner if the applicable work-made-for-hire rules are satisfied. Federal § 101 identifies two routes: work prepared by an employee within the scope of employment, and certain specially ordered or commissioned work if the statutory category and signed written agreement requirements are met. A commissioned contribution for use as part of a motion picture or other audiovisual work is one of the categories listed in that provision. The category alone is not enough; the statute also requires the parties expressly to agree in a signed written instrument that the work is made for hire.

Under federal § 201(b), when a work is made for hire, the employer or other person for whom it was prepared is treated as its author and ordinarily owns the rights, unless the parties expressly agree otherwise in a written instrument signed by them. The U.S. Copyright Office’s work-made-for-hire circular is agency guidance explaining these statutory alternatives and the questions used to distinguish employment from specially commissioned work. The circular is helpful for organizing facts; the statutory requirements and the applicable judicial decisions control the legal question.

For the employment route, do not decide the issue simply by looking at an invoice, a job title, or the way a person is credited. Collect the agreement and the facts of the working relationship: who supplied tools and workspace, the nature and duration of the engagement, whether additional tasks could be assigned, how payment was structured, and whether the work was within the person’s duties. The Copyright Office’s guidance identifies these as useful questions under the relevant federal framework. No single answer should be treated as a complete substitute for the full relationship.

For a commissioned contribution, locate the signed document and read the exact description of the work. Is it a new scene for a named audiovisual project, a separate preexisting story, or a collection of services whose deliverables are not clearly identified? The intended use and the wording of the signed agreement matter. A contract heading is a reason to read the clause, not a complete analysis of whether every statutory condition is satisfied. If different people signed different documents, keep each version and all signatures with the relevant draft.

Ownership can also change through a transfer. Federal 17 U.S.C. § 204(a) states that a transfer of copyright ownership, other than by operation of law, is not valid unless the instrument of conveyance or a note or memorandum of the transfer is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed or that owner’s duly authorized agent. Section 101 defines a transfer of copyright ownership to include an assignment or exclusive license, while excluding a nonexclusive license from that definition. Whether a particular document meets the relevant requirement depends on its language and the facts.

These routes should not be collapsed into one label. A work-made-for-hire provision concerns who is treated as the author under the statute. An assignment concerns a transfer of rights. A license addresses permission to use rights and can have a defined scope. Payment is an important commercial fact, but a payment receipt by itself does not explain all of those relationships. Compare the signed contract, any later amendment, and the description of the exact material being delivered.

Credits can have their own negotiated terms. An agreement may address what name appears, how the credit is styled, or where it is shown, while a separate clause addresses ownership and use. Read both sets of provisions and any incorporated terms that actually apply. A change in a public credit may prompt a review of those documents, but it should not automatically be described as a change in copyright ownership. Likewise, a favorable ownership clause does not by itself resolve every question about how a credit must be displayed.

II. How can writers and producers check who may use a screenplay?

A. Map the chain of rights for each version and each intended use

Start with the proposed use. Reading a draft for evaluation, revising it for a film, distributing the finished movie, publishing the screenplay, and producing a later adaptation are different activities. A person deciding whether to proceed should identify the proposed act and then trace the relevant authorization. The question is not merely whether somebody has a relationship to the project; it is whether the person granting permission has the relevant right and whether the permission covers the planned use.

List the works in chronological order: an earlier story or treatment, each substantive draft, any new scenes, and the completed audiovisual work. For each entry, record the creator identified by the available evidence, the agreement governing the work, any assignment or license, and the recipient. Then follow subsequent transfers and amendments. Where an agreement covers only certain rights or uses, note that limit instead of treating it as a transfer of everything. Federal § 201(d) recognizes that copyright ownership and individual exclusive rights may be transferred in whole or in part.

A screenplay can draw on an earlier work without making all rights in the two works identical. Federal § 101 defines a derivative work as one based on one or more preexisting works, and the Copyright Office’s guidance on derivative works explains that protection in a derivative work concerns the new material rather than automatically extending to preexisting material. That guidance notes that its registration policies and practices have been superseded by the Office’s later Compendium. For present purposes, the useful distinction is between permission to use an earlier work and rights in original material added in a later version.

Suppose a producer receives a draft adapted from a separately created short story. A practical review would identify the short story, the person or entity with authority over the relevant adaptation right, the signed document granting that right, and the terms under which the screenplay’s new material was supplied. Then it would examine any later revisions. A credit for the adaptation could help identify a contributor, but it does not tell the reviewer the scope of the underlying permission or whether another party retained rights in the earlier work.

Next compare names across records. A writer may use a professional name in a credit and a legal name in an agreement. A production company may have an affiliate, a former name, or a successor named in later documents. Those differences do not automatically establish or defeat a transfer, but they are reasons to obtain the documents connecting the parties. Check the entity that signed, the capacity of the signer, the work identified, and whether the document addresses the particular use under consideration. Preserve attachments and schedules; a list of material covered by an agreement may be located outside the main signature page.

Copyright Office registration records can be useful leads, but read what each record identifies. A record for a motion picture and a record for a separate screenplay may concern different works or different claims. A registered claimant’s name may prompt a request for the underlying transfer document; it does not allow a reader to infer every contractual condition or resolve every competing claim without the rest of the evidence. Save a copy of the record, note the work and version it describes, and compare it with the agreements and drafts.

When the record is incomplete, distinguish an unanswered factual question from a legal conclusion. If a contributor cannot locate an executed agreement, the next step is to search for the final signed version and any amendments, not to assume that an unsigned draft expresses everyone’s final agreement. If several documents describe the same contribution differently, arrange them by date and identify who signed each one. A later document may be an amendment, a separate license, or an agreement about a different work; its effect turns on its terms and the applicable law.

Keep a separate list of unresolved points. Examples include an unidentified earlier draft, a signature made by an entity whose authority is unclear, a contribution described differently in two schedules, or a proposed use that is absent from the available license. For each point, record the document or person that could clarify it. This makes the review actionable without suggesting that a missing document proves wrongdoing or that a public credit proves ownership.

B. Build a useful record before a dispute or new deal

A writer can begin with a project folder containing the earliest independently created material, successive drafts, relevant instructions, the deal documents, invoices, and communications about delivery and acceptance. Preserve original files and their metadata where available, as well as readable copies. A summary can explain the history, but it should point back to the source documents so that another reader can distinguish a contemporaneous record from a later recollection.

A producer can make the same exercise easier by keeping a clear deliverables schedule. Identify each work received, its version, the person or entity supplying it, and the agreement under which it was delivered. If a script contains material originating outside the immediate writing team, note the source and the permission relied on. The purpose is to connect a particular planned use to a particular right, not to collect names without understanding what each person supplied.

For an ongoing collaboration, document how decisions are made and what the parties intend. If one person controls the final script while others contribute individual scenes, explain that arrangement accurately. If contributors intend to create a joint work, say what they mean and address ownership and permitted uses in a signed agreement. If the parties intend a commissioned work made for hire, check the actual statutory conditions rather than assuming the label settles the issue. If they choose a transfer or license, specify the rights and uses the arrangement addresses.

It is also useful to record the difference between a draft that was delivered and material that eventually appeared on screen. A contributor’s material may be revised, replaced, combined with another contribution, or remain in a version that was never filmed. Those facts can matter to a question about a particular work, even though they do not by themselves resolve an agreement about credit or ownership. A document comparison and a dated delivery record are more informative than a later general description of the project.

When reviewing a credit, obtain the complete relevant credit terms and the actual form of the published or proposed credit. Note whether the provision addresses a screen credit, another form of acknowledgment, or both. Compare that material with the ownership and license provisions without assuming they have identical purposes. If the records appear inconsistent, write down the precise inconsistency: for example, the agreement names one version while the credit refers to the overall film. That question can then be examined against the documents rather than resolved by inference.

If someone requests permission to use a screenplay, ask for a clear description of the intended use, territory, medium, and version. The person responding can then compare the request with the rights actually held and any limitations in prior agreements. If the intended use changes, review whether the existing authorization covers the new activity. A permission to evaluate a draft, for example, should be read on its own terms before being treated as permission to distribute or adapt it.

Finally, preserve both sides of the record. Evidence that supports a claimed contribution is useful, but so are agreements or communications that limit the scope of the claim. A reliable review considers signed transfers, work-made-for-hire terms, license language, and later amendments alongside the creative history. It also distinguishes a final court decision from a preliminary ruling or an allegation. The goal is a specific answer about a specific work and use, supported by documents that can be checked.

Conclusion

A screenwriting credit can help identify a contributor, but it does not by itself establish copyright ownership. Start with the work and version, identify the actual expression and the parties’ roles, and read the signed agreements and any later transfers or licenses. Federal work-made-for-hire rules, joint-authorship principles, and the applicable court’s approach may each affect the answer. Keeping drafts, credit terms, and the chain of rights together makes it easier to decide what is known and what must be clarified before the work is used.

📄 Official circular