On November 13, 2026, CNN reported, citing a source close to the process, that an independent commission reporting to the director of the Pan American Health Organization had determined that the United States no longer qualifies as having eliminated measles. The network said The Wall Street Journal first reported the news. PAHO had announced that the commission would review the U.S. status at its November 2026 meeting, and its published procedure provides that the PAHO Director formally communicates the resulting classification to national authorities. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention explains that measles elimination means the absence of continuous disease transmission for 12 months or more in a specific geographic area. A Congressional Research Service report dated September 29, 2026 counted 3,659 confirmed measles cases in the United States in 2026 as of September 24, 2026, the highest annual total in 35 years.
For a family, the practical question is narrower than the headline. Does losing elimination status change whether a child can attend school without the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine, and can a parent still obtain a religious exemption? The answer turns on state law, not on the international classification. Every state requires the MMR vaccine for school attendance, but states differ sharply on exemptions. In 2026, two federal courts of appeals sided with states whose laws allow only medical exemptions, one of those families has asked the Supreme Court to step in, and a federal court in Maine refused to block that state’s similar law. This guide explains what those rulings decided and what to check before you contest an exclusion or an exemption denial. The discussion is general in scope and makes no findings about any particular family, school or official.
I. Does losing measles elimination status change your state’s school vaccine rules?
A. The status is a public health finding; the school requirement comes from state law
Start with what the elimination review actually is. In a notice dated March 2, 2026, PAHO described its Regional Verification Commission as an independent technical body that reports directly to the PAHO Director and assesses whether endemic transmission has been re-established, which it defined as uninterrupted circulation of the same virus genotype and lineage for 12 months or more in a specific geographic area. PAHO said the analysis period for the United States runs from the onset of the outbreaks reported on January 20, 2025, and that the commission’s recommendations go to the Director, who formally communicates the classification to national authorities. In a later notice dated October 14, 2026, PAHO said the commission would meet from November 10 to 13, 2026. As of the date of this guide, the reported U.S. determination rests on news reports citing a source; we did not read a formal PAHO communication of the result.
Nothing in that process rewrites a state statute. The Congressional Research Service states that all states and the District of Columbia require MMR vaccination for school attendance, and that many states allow exemptions, including medical exemptions and nonmedical religious and philosophical exemptions. The same report notes that a record 4.2% of kindergartners had a vaccine exemption in the 2025-2026 school year, mostly nonmedical, and that MMR coverage among kindergartners fell to 92.4% from a peak of 95.2% in the 2019-2020 school year. Those numbers explain why public health officials worry, but they do not by themselves add, remove or suspend any exemption. A parent whose child is turned away from school in December 2026 will be turned away under a specific state statute or regulation, and that text, not the PAHO classification, is what decides the case.
The constitutional starting point is more than a century old. In Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905), decided February 20, 1905, the Supreme Court of the United States affirmed the judgment against a man who refused the smallpox vaccination ordered by the Cambridge board of health under a Massachusetts statute that made a refusing adult forfeit five dollars. The Court reasoned that “a community has the right to protect itself against an epidemic of disease which threatens the safety of its members.” For a parent today, the practical consequence is that a challenge rarely succeeds by attacking the state’s general power to require vaccines; the live questions are which exemptions your state’s statute allows and whether its rules treat religious objectors worse than comparable secular cases. The vaccine decisions discussed below all rely on Jacobson.
Elimination status also does not change what a vaccine requirement covers. The CDC page on measles questions, updated August 5, 2026, still states that measles was declared eliminated in 2000 and warns that measles could become endemic again if vaccine coverage decreases. That is guidance, not law. What matters for a school file is the list of vaccines in the state statute, the documentation the school must collect, and the deadline the statute gives a family to complete it. If you are reading this because a school sent a letter after a local case, the letter should cite the provision it relies on; if it does not, ask for it in writing before you decide anything else.
B. What the statutes say in New York, West Virginia, Connecticut and Maine
New York is the clearest example of a state with no religious exemption. New York Public Health Law § 2164 requires every person in parental relation to a child to have the child immunized against diseases that include measles, mumps and rubella. Under subdivision 7(a), no school may admit a child, or let the child attend, for more than fourteen days without a certificate or other acceptable evidence of immunization; that period may be extended to not more than thirty days for a student transferring from out of state or from another country who shows a good faith effort to obtain the records. Subdivision 8 keeps a single exemption: if a physician licensed in New York certifies that immunization may be detrimental to the child’s health, the requirement does not apply until the immunization is found no longer to be detrimental. Subdivision 7(b) gives a parent whose child is denied entrance or attendance a right to appeal by petition to the commissioner of education under New York Education Law § 310.
The religious exemption that New York once had is gone. According to the Second Circuit’s June 30, 2026 opinion discussed in Part II, the legislature repealed the religious beliefs exemption on June 13, 2019, after the 2018-2019 measles outbreak, while keeping the medical exemption. The same opinion describes how the state enforces the law against schools, not just families: each violation of § 2164 can carry a fine of up to $2,000, the Department of Health treats each day an unvaccinated student attends as a violation, and the Commissioner of Health sustained fines totaling $118,000 against three Amish community schools. For parents, that means a private or religious school in New York has its own legal reason to refuse attendance without proof of immunization or a valid medical exemption. If your child attends school in New York and a school or health department has issued an exclusion instruction after an exposure, our separate guide on what New York parents should check about school exclusion during an outbreak walks through that narrower situation.
West Virginia has never offered a religious exemption. West Virginia Code § 16-3-4 provides that no child may be admitted or received in any of the state’s schools, or a state-regulated child care center, until the child has been immunized against diseases that include measles, mumps and rubella or produces a certificate from the commissioner granting an exemption. Subsection (h) authorizes exemptions only upon sufficient medical evidence that immunization is contraindicated or that there exists a specific precaution to a particular vaccine. A request must be accompanied by a licensed physician’s certification, the commissioner may appoint an Immunization Officer, who must be a licensed physician, to decide it, the decision may be appealed to the State Health Officer, and the final determination is subject to appeal under the state’s administrative procedures act. The Fourth Circuit noted in Perry v. Marteney that the requirement reaches children enrolled in schools, including a public virtual school, but that West Virginia law does not apply it to children taught at home, in learning pods or in microschools.
Connecticut and Maine show how repeal usually happens in stages. The Second Circuit explained in the 2023 Connecticut decision discussed below that Public Act 21-6, signed on April 28, 2021, repealed the religious exemption for schoolchildren while allowing students in kindergarten through twelfth grade who had already been granted religious exemptions to remain exempt; the act did not extend that accommodation to preschool and prekindergarten programs. The court also recorded that Connecticut became the fifth state to stop allowing religious exemptions, after Mississippi, California, New York and Maine, and that West Virginia had never exempted religious objectors. In Maine, a federal district court described in September 2026 how a 2019 law, effective September 1, 2021, repealed the religious and philosophical exemption, leaving a ninety-day grace period, a medical exemption based on a written statement from a medical professional, and a legacy provision for certain students who had an individualized education program in place by that date.
Most families live in states that still provide some nonmedical exemption. In his dissent in Perry, Judge Niemeyer observed that religious exceptions are afforded in 45 states, a figure the district court in that case had also cited. The useful checks are concrete. Read your state’s current statute and the health department’s exemption form rather than relying on a summary. Note whether the exemption must be renewed every year, whether it covers all vaccines or only named ones, whether a school may require a particular form or a notarized statement, and whether health officials may temporarily exclude exempt students when a case appears. In a footnote in its 2026 opinion, the Second Circuit listed its own earlier holding that temporarily excluding children with religious exemptions during a chicken pox outbreak was not unconstitutional. An exemption that is valid on paper can still leave a child at home during an outbreak, so ask the school how it applies exclusion rules before a case is reported, not after.
II. Can a parent still win a religious exemption in court?
A. What federal appeals courts decided in 2023 and 2026
The leading appellate decision before 2025 came from Connecticut. In We The Patriots USA, Inc. v. Conn. Office of Early Childhood Dev., 76 F.4th 130 (2d Cir. 2023), decided August 4, 2023, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a free exercise challenge to Public Act 21-6, holding that the repeal of the religious exemption was neutral and generally applicable and therefore subject only to rational basis review; it vacated the dismissal of a separate special-education claim and sent that claim back. The court reasoned that a medical exemption is not comparable to a religious one because exempting religious objectors would increase the risk of transmission among vaccinated and unvaccinated students alike. For a family, the key point is that keeping a medical exemption does not oblige a state to keep a religious one. In Miller v. McDonald, No. 24-681, decided June 30, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit applied We The Patriots to New York’s law and repeated its holding that the medical and religious exemptions are not comparable.
The ground shifted in 2025, when the Supreme Court decided a case about classroom instruction rather than vaccines. In Mahmoud v. Taylor, 606 U.S. 522 (2025), decided June 27, 2025, the Court held that parents who objected to a school board’s use of certain storybooks, combined with its refusal to give notice and opt outs, were entitled to a preliminary injunction. The syllabus states the rule that later vaccine challengers invoked: when a law imposes a burden of the same character as the one in Wisconsin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972), strict scrutiny applies regardless of whether the law is neutral or generally applicable. In Yoder, decided May 15, 1972, the Supreme Court sided with Amish parents who had been convicted for declining to send their children, ages 14 and 15, to school after the eighth grade under Wisconsin’s compulsory attendance law. Our targeted searches of later decisions citing Mahmoud and Yoder returned the 2026 vaccine opinions discussed next, including the Second Circuit’s Miller opinion and the Fourth Circuit’s Perry opinion, both of which applied those two decisions to state vaccination laws. In 2025, after Mahmoud, the Supreme Court vacated the Second Circuit’s first Miller judgment and sent the case back for reconsideration in light of Mahmoud, which is why families following the issue expected a change.
That change did not come in New York. In Miller v. McDonald, No. 24-681, decided June 30, 2026 and reported at 180 F.4th 420, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reconsidered the case of Amish parents and Amish community schools and again affirmed the dismissal of their complaint. The court held that New York’s law is neutral and generally applicable, that the medical exemption does not give school officials discretion to choose which reasons for refusing vaccination deserve solicitude, and that the law does not impose a burden of the same character as the ones in Yoder and Mahmoud because it does not regulate what children are taught, does not require them to affirm any belief and conceals nothing from parents. For a parent in New York or Connecticut, whose federal cases go to the Second Circuit, Miller means that a federal lawsuit seeking a religious exemption from school vaccination faces binding circuit precedent that rejected exactly that claim after Mahmoud. The court described the burden as possibly serious but different in kind: “A greater burden in degree is not necessarily the same burden in kind.”
The Fourth Circuit reached the same result for West Virginia. In Perry v. Marteney, No. 24-2132, decided April 8, 2026 and reported at 172 F.4th 315, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reversed a preliminary injunction that had allowed a child whose parents hold religious objections to vaccination to re-enroll in a public virtual school without the required vaccines. The majority concluded that the family was unlikely to succeed because West Virginia’s law is neutral and generally applicable, because a physician-certified medical exemption reviewed by a state officer is not a system of individualized exemptions, and because the law is a public health measure rather than a burden of the same character as Yoder or Mahmoud. The Fourth Circuit opened its opinion by quoting Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11, for the rule that the police power embraces reasonable regulations that protect the public health and the public safety. For a West Virginia family, Perry means that enrolling in a virtual public school does not by itself create a right to a religious exemption, even though home instruction is treated differently under state law. Judge Niemeyer dissented and would have applied strict scrutiny after Mahmoud.
The dispute is not over. The Supreme Court docket for Perry v. Marteney, No. 26-319, shows that the family filed a petition for a writ of certiorari on September 4, 2026, that several amicus briefs were filed on October 13, 2026, including one listed as filed by the Governor of West Virginia and others, and that the school officials’ brief in opposition was submitted on November 12, 2026. When we read the docket on November 14, 2026, it showed no ruling on the petition. A grant of review would give the Supreme Court an opportunity to decide the question directly; a denial would leave the Second and Fourth Circuit decisions in place. Either way, nothing on that docket changes a state’s exemption rules today.
Federal trial courts elsewhere have followed the same path. In We The Patriots USA, Inc. v. Makin, No. 2:26-cv-00369, a parent who objects to vaccines on religious grounds asked the United States District Court for the District of Maine to stop school officials from enforcing Maine’s vaccination requirements against his partially unvaccinated son. In an order dated September 8, 2026, the court denied a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction, found the plaintiffs unlikely to succeed because the law is neutral and generally applicable, and concluded that the burden the father described did not share the character of the burdens in Yoder, Mahmoud and a 2026 Supreme Court parental-rights decision. That order cited Miller as 180 F.4th 420 and Perry as 172 F.4th 315, which shows that the two 2026 appellate decisions are already being used outside their own circuits. A later order in the same case denied an injunction pending appeal, so the First Circuit may address the question next.
B. Practical checks before you contest an exclusion or an exemption denial
First, identify the exact rule being applied to your child. A school letter should name the statute or regulation, the vaccine or dose that is missing, and the date by which the record must be produced. In New York, § 2164(7)(a) gives fourteen days, extendable to not more than thirty days for a transfer from out of state or from another country when the family shows a good faith effort; in West Virginia, § 16-3-4(c) bars admission until the child is immunized or holds an exemption certificate, while § 16-3-4(e) allows provisional enrollment under the commissioner’s minimum criteria so that immunization can be completed, provided the child has at least one dose of each required vaccine. Those are different regimes. Do not assume that a deadline you read about in another state applies to yours.
Second, if your child has a genuine medical reason, build the medical file before the school deadline. In New York, the statute requires a certification from a physician licensed in the state, and the Second Circuit’s 2026 opinion explains that the state’s regulations define the qualifying condition by reference to a medical contraindication or precaution to a specific immunization consistent with national immunization guidance, require a completed medical exemption form and must be reissued annually. In West Virginia, § 16-3-4(h) requires a licensed physician’s certification and a decision by the state’s Immunization Officer. A letter that simply states a preference against vaccination will not meet either standard. Ask the physician to identify the specific vaccine, the specific contraindication or precaution, and how long it is expected to last.
Third, use the administrative appeal that your state provides before going to court, and keep every document. New York gives a parent whose child is denied entrance or attendance a right to petition the commissioner of education under Education Law § 310. West Virginia allows an appeal from the Immunization Officer to the State Health Officer, followed by an appeal under the state’s administrative procedures act. Request the decision in writing, keep copies of every form and physician statement you submitted, and note who told you what and when. The statutes we read do not themselves state a filing deadline for those appeals, so check the governing regulation or the agency’s instructions immediately rather than waiting.
Fourth, be realistic about a federal lawsuit. The families in Miller and Perry sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, the federal statute that allows a person to sue a state actor who deprives them of rights secured by the Constitution. That route remains open, but the Second Circuit has now rejected the claim that a school vaccination law without a religious exemption violates the Free Exercise Clause, the Fourth Circuit has held that such a claim is unlikely to succeed, and the District of Maine reached the same conclusion at the preliminary injunction stage. A new case in another circuit is not bound by those decisions, but it will have to explain why they are wrong. The strongest arguments that remain are case specific, for example evidence that officials applied a medical exemption with open-ended discretion or that the legislature acted out of hostility to religion; both Miller and Perry rejected those arguments on the records before them.
Fifth, separate the school question from the broader public health response. What the reported loss of elimination status may change is how often local officials see outbreaks and, with them, exclusion notices for students who are not immune. If your state allows a religious exemption, ask the school now how it will treat exempt students if a measles case is confirmed, how long an exclusion would last and what proof of immunity ends it. If your state allows only medical exemptions, the decisions of 2026 mean that the practical choices are a qualifying medical exemption, vaccination, or an educational setting that the statute does not cover, such as the home instruction that West Virginia law leaves outside its requirement.
Conclusion
The reported loss of measles elimination status is a serious public health signal, but it does not change the law that decides whether a child may attend school. That law is state law. New York, West Virginia, Connecticut and Maine require vaccination for school attendance with no religious exemption for new students, and in 2026 the Second Circuit in Miller held that New York’s law does not violate the Free Exercise Clause, while the Fourth Circuit in Perry held that West Virginia’s law is likely constitutional, both after the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in Mahmoud. A federal court in Maine has followed them. The Perry family’s petition asks the Supreme Court to revisit the question, and its fate is the development to watch. Until then, families in states that still allow nonmedical exemptions should read their state’s current rules and exclusion policies closely, and families in states without them should focus on the medical exemption process, the statutory deadlines and the administrative appeals their state provides.