Two jets made contact while taxiing at Miami International Airport on the evening of Saturday, November 14, 2026. According to a statement from the airport’s communications director reported by local media, an arriving aircraft and a departing aircraft touched at the intersection of two taxiways at about 9:15 p.m.; no injuries were reported, and the airport said other taxiways were being used so that operations were not affected. News reports described one aircraft as a cargo jet and the other as a passenger jet that had just landed from abroad. No official finding on the cause had been published when this article was written, no responsibility has been established, and only an investigation and, if a dispute arises, a court can address those questions.
For anyone who was on board, missed a connection that night, or simply wants to know what passengers can do after a scare on the ground, the practical question is legal: when does a collision on a taxiway give a passenger a claim, and for what? For international trips, the main answer comes from the Montreal Convention, the treaty that governs the liability of carriers in international air transportation, together with federal consumer rules on refunds and tarmac delays. The short version: physical injury opens the door to compensation, fear alone does not, and delay losses must be proved with receipts. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the operators of the aircraft involved in the Miami incident.
I. Can a passenger recover damages after a ground collision if no one was hurt?
A. For international trips, the treaty decides the claim, and “accident” has a legal meaning
Begin with the ticket, not with the headlines. The Montreal Convention applies to international carriage of persons performed by aircraft for reward. In a September 2026 decision discussed below, a federal court in Miami summarized the treaty’s definition: carriage is international, in relevant part, when the place of departure and the place of destination are situated within the territories of two States Parties. What matters is the journey written on the ticket as a whole, so a passenger arriving in Miami from another country, or departing Miami for one, should pull up the full itinerary, including any return segment, before deciding which rules apply. A passenger whose entire trip was domestic is in a different legal position, governed by rules that this article does not cover.
When the treaty applies, it is not one option among several. Article 29 of the Convention text published by the State Department provides that any action for damages in the carriage of passengers, whether founded on the Convention, a contract, a tort or something else, can only be brought subject to the Convention’s conditions and limits. The same article closes with a sentence that matters to anyone angry after a frightening event: “In any such action, punitive, exemplary or any other non-compensatory damages shall not be recoverable.” In practice, renaming a claim as negligence, fraud or a consumer-protection violation does not escape the treaty’s conditions when the facts fall within it.
The central provision for personal injury is Article 17(1): “The carrier is liable for damage sustained in case of death or bodily injury of a passenger upon condition only that the accident which caused the death or injury took place on board the aircraft or in the course of any of the operations of embarking or disembarking.” Three conditions follow from that sentence: an accident, a death or bodily injury caused by it, and a location on board or during embarking or disembarking. A passenger seated in a jet that is taxiing to or from the gate is on board the aircraft, so the location condition is usually the easiest of the three for someone who was inside one of the planes. People who were in the terminal, on the ramp or in a different aircraft that was not involved stand outside Article 17’s text and need a different analysis.
The word “accident” does not mean any bad outcome. Federal courts apply the Supreme Court’s definition, which the Southern District of Florida restated as “an unexpected or unusual event or happening that is external to the passenger.” The definition is applied flexibly, and an injury that results only from a passenger’s own reaction to the normal operation of the aircraft is not caused by an accident. Contact between two aircraft is external to the passengers on board; whether a particular contact was unexpected or unusual in the treaty’s sense still depends on the facts that an investigation and the evidence establish, not on a news alert.
The Fifth Circuit recently explained how federal aviation rules feed into that question. In Arzu v. Am. Airlines, Inc., No. 25-10606 (5th Cir. May 14, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, in a decision issued May 14, 2026, reviewed a suit brought after a 14-year-old passenger died following cardiac arrest on an international flight from Honduras to Florida. The court affirmed summary judgment for the airline on the theory that the crew’s medical response was imperfect, holding that a crew’s departure from internal airline policy is not itself an accident. But it reversed summary judgment to the extent the claim relied on the theory that the on-board defibrillator malfunctioned, allowing that theory to go forward, because federal rules required a functional device and “a failure to comply with an FAA regulation is material evidence that an event was unusual or unexpected.” The court added that violating an FAA rule “is not itself an Article 17 accident,” but “it informs whether an event is unexpected or unusual.” After a ground collision, the practical question is therefore not only what happened but whether the operations around it complied with the federal rules that govern taxiing aircraft.
One of those rules is 14 CFR 91.123, which addresses compliance with air traffic control clearances and instructions. Paragraph (b) states: “Except in an emergency, no person may operate an aircraft contrary to an ATC instruction in an area in which air traffic control is exercised.” Paragraph (a) adds that a pilot who has received a clearance may not deviate from it without an amended clearance, an emergency or a collision-avoidance advisory, and that a pilot who is uncertain of a clearance must request clarification. These provisions describe obligations; they do not answer whether anyone in Miami complied with them, and nothing published so far establishes how the contact occurred. Their usefulness for a passenger is analytical: under the reasoning in Arzu, a proven departure from a federal operating rule can be evidence that an event was unusual, while compliance can point the other way.
Do not confuse the treaty’s vocabulary with the safety board’s. Under 49 CFR 830.2, which defines terms for the notification of aircraft accidents and incidents to the National Transportation Safety Board, an “aircraft accident” is an occurrence associated with the operation of an aircraft in which any person suffers death or serious injury, or in which the aircraft receives substantial damage. An “incident” is an occurrence other than an accident that affects or could affect the safety of operations. The same section lists damage that is not considered substantial damage for that part, including damage to wingtips. A contact limited to a wingtip could therefore be recorded as an incident in the safety board’s terminology. That reporting label serves federal safety notifications. It is not the test a court applies under Article 17, and a passenger should not assume that an “incident” designation ends a claim or that an “accident” designation proves one.
B. Bodily injury is the gate: fear and shock alone do not open it
The hardest condition for a passenger who walked off the plane unhurt is the second one. Article 17 speaks of “death or bodily injury,” and federal courts read that phrase to exclude purely emotional harm. A decision issued this fall in Miami shows how firmly the rule is applied. In Thor v. Frontier Airlines, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-20281 (S.D. Fla. Sept. 28, 2026), the United States District Court, Southern District of Florida, in an order signed by a United States magistrate judge on September 28, 2026, addressed claims by two passengers who were removed from an international flight from Guatemala City to Miami. They alleged embarrassment, humiliation and emotional distress under several Florida-law labels. The court held that the Convention preempted those personal-injury claims and that they failed under Article 17 because the complaint alleged no wound, impairment or other bodily injury, writing that “Emotional harm damages, standing alone, are insufficient to state a claim under the Montreal Convention.” It dismissed the personal-injury claims with prejudice. For a passenger who leaves a ground collision frightened but physically unhurt, that is the core answer: fear, embarrassment and lost time do not become Article 17 damages without a bodily injury.
The same order explains how emotional harm can still matter. The court stated that “Plaintiffs can only recover for their purported emotional harm if they first sustained a bodily injury caused by the accident that, in turn, caused their emotional injuries.” The sequence is important. A passenger who suffers a neck strain when the aircraft lurches, then develops anxiety about flying, has a different case from a passenger who felt the jolt, was frightened and had no physical harm. In the first situation the emotional consequences may be part of the damages if they flow from the bodily injury; in the second, the treaty provides no personal-injury recovery at all. The Thor court also noted that the punitive damages the passengers requested were barred by Article 29 independently of the other defects.
Proof of the physical injury is where many claims fail. In Bandary v. Delta Air Lines, Inc., No. 24-7204 (9th Cir. Sept. 23, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in an opinion filed September 23, 2026, affirmed summary judgment for an airline in a Montreal Convention suit by a passenger who had been restrained during a flight. Most of the opinion concerns a federal immunity statute that protected the airline for injuries after the crew reported the passenger’s behavior to a federal agent on board, and one judge dissented on that point. On the injuries before the federal agent became involved, the court found that the passenger had shown no triable bodily injury: apart from testimony in passing that his “bottom was hurt,” he offered no evidence of physical injury from a fall. The court then held: “Because Delta is immune for all Bandary’s physical injuries, Bandary also cannot recover for any of his alleged emotional injuries under the Montreal Convention.” A passing complaint that something hurt, without medical records or other proof, is unlikely to carry an Article 17 claim, and the emotional part of the claim falls with it.
Translate those decisions into a checklist. If you felt any physical effect after a ground collision, such as a jolt to the neck or back, a bruise from a seat frame, a head strike or a fall in the aisle, get it examined promptly and tell the clinician exactly how it happened, including the time and your seat. Photograph visible marks the same day. Keep the boarding pass, the booking confirmation and any messages the carrier sent about the event. Write down what you saw and felt while it is fresh, and note the names of companions or crew members who saw it. None of this guarantees a claim, but the cases above turned on the absence of exactly this kind of evidence. If you had no physical effect at all, the honest conclusion under Thor is that the personal-injury route is closed, and the remaining questions concern delay costs and refunds, discussed in Part II.
A passenger’s own conduct can also reduce a recovery. Article 20 of the Convention allows the carrier to be wholly or partly exonerated if it proves that the damage was caused or contributed to by the negligence or other wrongful act or omission of the person claiming compensation. Consider a hypothetical: a passenger who stands up in the aisle while the aircraft is still moving and is thrown against a seat may face that defense, even though the collision itself was not his doing. Following crew instructions during taxi is a safety measure first, but it also protects the strength of any later claim.
Finally, the treaty’s compensation structure has two tiers for death and bodily injury. Under Article 21, a carrier cannot exclude or limit its liability for damages up to a threshold stated in Special Drawing Rights, which Article 23 ties to the Special Drawing Right as defined by the International Monetary Fund. Above that threshold, the carrier avoids liability if it proves that the damage was not due to its own negligence or wrongful act, or that the damage was solely due to the negligence or wrongful act of a third party. Article 24 provides for review of these limits at five-year intervals by reference to inflation, so the figure printed in the original treaty text is not the figure to use today; check the current adjusted amount before relying on any number. The third-party defense deserves attention after a collision between two aircraft operated by different companies, because each operator may argue that the other’s conduct caused the event. Article 37 adds that nothing in the Convention prejudices whether a liable person has a right of recourse against anyone else, which leaves the carriers to sort out contribution between themselves. Whether a passenger may sue the operator of the other aircraft, which did not carry him, raises separate questions that the decisions discussed here did not decide.
One more provision is worth knowing in serious cases. Article 28 provides that, in the case of aircraft accidents resulting in death or injury of passengers, the carrier shall, if required by its national law, make advance payments without delay to meet the immediate economic needs of those entitled to compensation, and that such payments are not a recognition of liability. In Arzu, the Fifth Circuit treated an advance-payment term in a carrier’s conditions of carriage approved by the Department of Transportation as required by national law within the meaning of Article 28, and held that a contract claim built on it was preempted, meaning it had to proceed under the Convention’s conditions. A passenger who was injured should therefore read the carrier’s conditions of carriage alongside the treaty rather than treating them as separate sources of rights.
II. What else can a passenger claim, and how should the file be built?
A. Delays, missed connections, refunds and time stuck on the tarmac
A passenger who was not hurt may still have arrived late, missed a connection or spent a night in a hotel. Article 19 of the Montreal Convention provides: “The carrier is liable for damage occasioned by delay in the carriage by air of passengers, baggage or cargo.” The same article gives the carrier a defense if it proves that it and its servants and agents took all measures that could reasonably be required to avoid the damage, or that it was impossible to take such measures. Article 22 caps delay damages per passenger, again in Special Drawing Rights subject to inflation review. In practice, a delay claim asks three things: what the delay cost you in money, whether the delay caused that cost, and whether the carrier can show it did everything reasonably possible.
The money question is decisive. In the Thor order, the Southern District of Florida held that the passengers failed to state an Article 19 claim because they pleaded inconvenience, emotional harm and general references to ticket costs, while also alleging that the carrier had rebooked them on the next flight at no additional charge. The court looked for concrete losses, such as “lost wages, a missed business opportunity, a forfeited reservation, loss of prepaid accommodations,” and found none. Yet it allowed the passengers to amend their complaint to allege recoverable economic delay damages, observing that an unexpected overnight stay might logically produce costs for a hotel, meals and other incidental expenses. The lesson is concrete: keep every receipt for a hotel, a meal, ground transportation, a replacement ticket or a forfeited prepaid booking, and keep evidence of wages lost because of the late arrival. A claim built on frustration alone is the kind the Thor court found insufficient.
A refund is a different track from damages. Under 14 CFR 260.6, as shown in the eCFR up to date as of November 12, 2026, a covered carrier that is the merchant of record must provide a “full and prompt refund of the airfare, including any taxes and ancillary fees” to a consumer holding a nonrefundable ticket on a scheduled flight to, from or within the United States when the flight is cancelled or significantly delayed or changed and the consumer chooses not to fly on it, not to accept rebooking, or not to accept a voucher, credit or other compensation offered instead. The regulation also lists situations in which the refund is automatic, such as a cancellation where no alternative flight or other compensation is offered. Keep the two remedies distinct: a refund returns what you paid for transportation you did not take, while Article 19 damages compensate proven losses caused by a delay in transportation you did take. Our guide to refund rights after an FAA ground stop walks through how to compare the original flight with what a carrier offers, which applies equally when a ground collision disrupts schedules.
Passengers can also be held on board while a collision scene is secured, and federal rules limit how long. Under 14 CFR 259.4, each covered carrier must adopt and follow a contingency plan for lengthy tarmac delays. For international flights, each covered carrier must give passengers on a flight experiencing a tarmac delay at a U.S. airport the opportunity to deplane before the delay exceeds four hours; for domestic flights operated by covered U.S. carriers, the limit is three hours. Those limits have exceptions, including where the pilot in command determines that deplaning would jeopardize safety or security, or where air traffic control advises that returning to a suitable disembarkation point would significantly disrupt airport operations. Separately, the carrier must provide adequate food and potable water no later than two hours after the start of the tarmac delay unless the pilot in command determines that safety or security considerations preclude it, must ensure operable lavatories and medical attention if needed, and must notify passengers of the status of the delay when it exceeds 30 minutes. If you were kept on board after the Miami contact, note the times you were told something, when the door opened, and whether food, water and lavatories were available.
Those tarmac rules are carrier obligations set out in Department of Transportation regulations. The provisions read for this article state what carriers must do; they do not state a damages remedy for individual passengers. Their value in a private claim is evidentiary and practical: a carrier’s adherence to, or departure from, its own contingency plan helps reconstruct what happened, and under the reasoning the Fifth Circuit applied in Arzu, compliance with federal rules can inform whether an event was unusual. Keep the distinction clear when you write to a carrier, so that a request for a refund, a claim for delay expenses and a report of a tarmac-delay concern are each stated on their own terms.
B. Evidence, where to sue, and the two-year clock
Many passengers assume that an official investigation will prove their case. Federal law points the other way for the safety board’s conclusions. Under 49 U.S.C. § 1154(b), as printed in the 2024 edition of the U.S. Code: “No part of a report of the Board, related to an accident or an investigation of an accident, may be admitted into evidence or used in a civil action for damages resulting from a matter mentioned in the report.” A safety board report may help you understand an event, but a passenger who sues must build the case with other evidence. That makes your own records more important, not less.
Build the file in layers. First, identity and contract: the e-ticket receipt showing the full itinerary, the carrier that issued and operated each segment, and the conditions of carriage in force on the travel date. Second, the event: a written timeline with clock times, photographs or video you took yourself, the gate or taxiway area if known, crew announcements you remember and the names of witnesses. Third, injury, if any: the first medical visit, the description you gave of the mechanism of injury, imaging results, follow-up visits and expenses. Fourth, delay costs: receipts, proof of prepaid bookings you lost, and documentation of lost wages. Fifth, communications: every message to and from the carrier, with dates. Organize the material so that a person who was not there can follow it from boarding to arrival without guessing.
Where a lawsuit may be filed is also governed by the treaty. Article 33(1) allows an action for damages to be brought, at the plaintiff’s option, in the territory of one of the States Parties, before the court of the carrier’s domicile or principal place of business, where the carrier has a place of business through which the contract was made, or at the place of destination. For death or injury, Article 33(2) adds the State Party where the passenger had his or her principal and permanent residence at the time of the accident, provided the carrier operates passenger services to or from that State and conducts its passenger business there from premises it leases or owns or that are leased or owned by a carrier with which it has a commercial agreement. For a passenger who lives in the United States and flew on a carrier serving U.S. airports, those options can matter a great deal, but each condition has to be checked against the carrier’s actual operations and the ticket.
Timing is unforgiving. Article 35(1) of the Convention provides that the right to damages is extinguished if an action is not brought within a period of two years, reckoned from the date of arrival at the destination, from the date on which the aircraft ought to have arrived, or from the date on which the carriage stopped. Article 35(2) states that the method of calculating that period is determined by the law of the court seised of the case. The treaty’s text frames the period as extinguishing the right to damages, so do not wait for an investigation to finish before calendaring it. A letter to the carrier, a customer-service complaint or a refund request is not the same thing as bringing an action, and nothing in the provisions read for this article treats such correspondence as stopping the two-year period.
Read Article 35 together with the scope rules in Part I. A traveler who had a purely domestic itinerary, or a person who was not a passenger at all, should not borrow the two-year Convention period by analogy; those situations require their own sources, and the sources read for this article do not establish their deadlines. If you are unsure which category you fall into, plan around the earliest possible deadline until the question is resolved with the ticket and the governing law in hand.
Keep expectations about the outcome realistic as well. The Convention’s text rules out punitive damages, and the Thor order applied that rule to the passengers’ demand for no less than $10 million in punitive damages. Compensation under Article 17 concerns damage sustained in case of death or bodily injury; compensation under Article 19 is measured by proven economic loss caused by delay, subject to the treaty’s cap and the carrier’s reasonable-measures defense. A passenger who understands those measures early can decide whether the documented losses justify formal steps, and can avoid spending months on a theory that the cases above have already rejected.
Finally, when you write to the carrier, be precise and factual. State the flight, date and seat, describe what happened in neutral terms, attach the documents that support each element you claim, and ask for a written response. Avoid guessing about the cause of the collision or attributing fault on the basis of social media, audio clips or early reports; the cause remains for the investigation and, if needed, for a court. Statements you make early can be quoted back later, and a measured letter that separates facts, injuries, expenses and refund requests is easier to evaluate and harder to dispute.
Conclusion
A taxiway collision at Miami airport is unsettling, but for an international traveler the legal map is fairly clear. Under Article 17 of the Montreal Convention, a passenger can recover for bodily injury caused by an accident on board, and emotional harm counts only when it flows from that bodily injury, as the Southern District of Florida held in Thor and the Ninth Circuit applied in Bandary. Whether an event qualifies as an accident depends on whether it was unexpected or unusual, and the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Arzu shows that compliance with federal aviation rules informs that question. Passengers who were not hurt should focus on two separate tracks: documented economic losses caused by delay under Article 19, and refunds under the federal refund regulation when they chose not to travel on a cancelled or significantly changed flight. Keep your own evidence, because federal law bars admitting or using safety board accident reports in a civil action for damages resulting from the matters they describe, and calendar the two-year period in Article 35, which runs from the date of arrival at the destination, the date the aircraft ought to have arrived, or the date the carriage stopped.