KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
NHL games: what should viewers check about streaming blackouts and refunds?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

NHL games: what should viewers check about streaming blackouts and refunds?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

NHL games is the search. The problem behind it often arrives two steps later. A viewer pays for a streaming package that advertises out-of-market hockey, sits down for the home team, and finds one game unavailable in the viewer’s own market. The next surprise is quieter: the trial or season price ends, and the subscription renews. Two different bodies of law answer those two surprises, and neither one gives a simple right to watch every game or a simple right to a refund for one missed game.

Federally, a sports blackout today is primarily a matter of private distribution contracts, not an FCC permission slip. California law, by contrast, regulates in detail what a seller must show and obtain before a subscription renews, and how an online subscriber must be allowed to cancel. Between those poles, California contract-formation cases decide when the fine print shown at sign-up — including blackout, renewal and arbitration terms — became part of the bargain at all. The checks in this article follow that order: identify the rights holder for the game, read the sign-up screen as a court would, then use the renewal and cancellation notices the California text actually requires.

I. Why is a game blacked out on a service the viewer already paid for?

A. After the FCC repeal, the blackout is a contract term to locate, not an agency order to appeal

Start with the address on the account, not with the schedule graphic. The league’s own site offers a zip-code lookup that tells a viewer which team’s local broadcast area covers that zip code, together with a team-by-team list of local broadcasters. That lookup is a company communication about how its territories are drawn. It is the first document to save, because an out-of-market package and a local broadcast right are different products. A game that is local to the viewer’s zip code may be reserved to the local broadcaster listed for that team, while the out-of-market package sells the games outside that territory. The title of the package matters less than the territory line the lookup draws.

The federal regulator no longer supplies the blackout. The Federal Communications Commission’s consumer guide on sports blackouts states that from 1975 to 2014 the FCC had sports blackout rules, that those rules were very limited, and that the FCC repealed them. The same guide then gives the sentence on which the modern analysis turns: elimination of the rule may not end sports blackouts because “sports leagues may choose to continue their private blackout policies through contractual arrangements with programming distributors.” Under the heading stating that sports blackouts are privately negotiated, the guide adds that in almost all circumstances blackouts result from contractual agreements between content owners and programming distributors. That is agency guidance identifying where the operative document now sits. It does not create a viewer right to a game, and it does not forbid the league and a distributor from keeping a territory by contract.

The repeal itself is in the Commission’s Report and Order in MB Docket No. 12-3, adopted September 30, 2014. The order’s table of contents states its own structure with unusual clarity: after addressing its authority to eliminate the sports blackout rules, it examines why the rules were no longer needed to ensure wide availability, and then examines the impact of elimination on a league’s ability to control distribution of its games through retransmission consent and contractual arrangements with broadcasters and with multichannel distributors. A viewer who complains only to the FCC is therefore writing to the agency that deliberately removed its own rule. The useful federal question is narrower: which contract reserves this game, to which distributor, in this zip code, on this date?

That distinction also controls the refund conversation. The FCC guide suggests contacting the channel or system to learn why the decision to black out the event was made and registering viewing preferences for future agreements. It does not state a federal rule that a blacked-out game must be refunded, credited or unlocked. No text read for this article states such a per-game federal refund right. A refund claim, if one exists on given facts, must be found in the subscription contract the viewer actually accepted, in a specific misrepresentation about that package, or in a state subscription statute — not in the fact of the blackout alone. Keep the blackout notice shown on screen, the zip code on the account, and the date and teams involved. Those three records identify the territory decision. Without them, a support exchange is only an argument about a schedule poster.

One more federal text explains why leagues may sell rights jointly at all, and where that permission stops. The Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961, in the govinfo compilation of Public Law 87-331, provides in section 1 that the antitrust laws shall not apply to a joint agreement by which a league of clubs in professional football, baseball, basketball or hockey sells or transfers rights of member clubs in the “sponsored telecasting” of their games. Section 2 then withdraws that clause from a joint agreement that prohibits televising games within an area, except within the home territory of a member club on a day when that club is playing a game at home. Section 4 preserves the rest of antitrust law: nothing in the Act changes the applicability of the antitrust laws to other acts, contracts or conduct except the agreements to which section 1 applies. Read together, the Act is a narrow exemption for pooled sponsored telecasting, with a home-territory proviso and an express reservation. It is not a statute that orders a streaming service to carry a particular game in a particular zip code, and it is not a blanket immunity for every modern packaging practice. The word “sponsored telecasting” is the Act’s own 1961 term. Whether a given internet-only arrangement falls inside section 1 is a question the Act’s text frames; it is not answered here by analogy, because no decision read for this article decides that streaming question for a hockey package.

B. What a recent sports-streaming injunction does and does not give an individual viewer

Antitrust law still polices how sports rights are packaged, but the remedy belongs to the parties who prove the market case. The clearest recent illustration is the preliminary-injunction litigation over a proposed live-sports streaming joint venture. In FuboTV Inc. against The Walt Disney Company, No. 24-CV-01363 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 16, 2024), the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, on August 16, 2024, granted a preliminary injunction after a five-day evidentiary hearing and enjoined the joint-venture defendants from launching the venture pending final adjudication of the merits or further order of the court. The order states that “Fubo is likely to succeed on its claims that by entering into the JV, the JV Defendants will substantially lessen competition and restrain trade in the relevant market in violation of Section 7 of the Clayton Act, 15 U.S.C. § 18.” A hockey viewer can use that limit in one practical way: the decision explains why a single subscription may lawfully omit a game, without giving the viewer a personal right to watch that game on the service already paid for. Likelihood of success at the preliminary stage is not a final judgment that every bundling term discussed in the opinion was unlawful, and the injunction ran between distributors and programmers. It did not award any subscriber a game, a credit or a season refund.

The factual findings are still useful at the kitchen table, if they are used for shopping rather than for threats. The opinion describes carriage agreements as the contracts by which distributors obtain rights to offer networks, describes “bundling” as the practice of requiring carriage of unwanted non-sports networks as a condition of must-have sports channels, and finds that the joint-venture defendants together owned a dominant share of nationally broadcast live-sports rights. Those findings explain a familiar shelf: one service has the national package, another has the regional network, and a third has an exclusive streaming window. Fragmentation, standing alone, is not proof that the viewer’s contract was deceptive. The deception question is different and document-specific: what did this checkout page promise about this team, in this zip code, for this class of game — nationally televised, out-of-market, or local?

Three checks convert Part I into a purchase decision. First, classify the game before paying: national telecast, local broadcast, or out-of-market stream. The league lookup answers the territory; the distributor’s schedule answers the window. Second, save the offer page that uses words such as “every,” “all” or “never miss,” together with any blackout sentence placed near it. General advertising language and a specific blackout disclosure may both be part of the record, and their proximity matters under the California renewal text discussed below, which forbids including information that undermines affirmative consent and forbids misrepresenting a material fact about the underlying service. Third, if a game is missing, ask the distributor in writing which rights holder had the game in the account zip code. The answer identifies whether the viewer bought the wrong layer of rights or was sold a layer described inaccurately. Only the second answer supports a refund demand grounded in the sale itself. The first answer supports cancellation before the next renewal, which is where California law gives the viewer enforceable tools.

II. What should a California viewer check at sign-up, at renewal and at cancellation?

A. Whether the streaming terms became a contract at all: conspicuous notice plus unambiguous assent

California viewers litigate subscriptions on the sign-up screen. The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit applies an inquiry-notice test to what it calls sign-in wrap agreements, where a link to terms is provided but the consumer is not separately required to state that the terms were read. Two recent decisions under California law reach opposite results on different screens, and the contrast is the check.

In Godun v. JustAnswer LLC, No. 24-2095 (9th Cir. Apr. 15, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, on April 15, 2025, affirmed denial of a motion to compel arbitration in a putative class action alleging that paying to ask questions had automatically enrolled plaintiffs in a recurring monthly subscription. The opinion restates that contracts are formed on an inquiry theory only where “(1) the website provides reasonably conspicuous notice of the terms to which the consumer will be bound; and (2) the consumer takes some action, such as clicking a button or checking a box, that unambiguously manifests his or her assent to those terms.” Applying that test, the court concluded that some advisals were insufficiently conspicuous and others did not explicitly advise what action would signal assent, so the arbitration term in the linked terms of service did not become enforceable against those plaintiffs on that record. For a California viewer, the practical use of Godun is evidentiary: keep the sign-up screen and the exact advisal language, because formation turned on what that screen showed and what the click was told to mean. A later printout of current terms does not reproduce the font, placement and button text the court examined.

The opposite outcome on a clearer screen is Keebaugh v. Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., No. 22-55982 (9th Cir. Apr. 26, 2024), where the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, on April 26, 2024, reversed denial of a motion to compel arbitration for a mobile game whose sign-in screen stated the agreement language next to the play button. The panel held that the district court erred by treating the context of the transaction as nearly dispositive and that both the context of the transaction and the placement of the notice must be considered together. The viewer-side lesson is the mirror image: when the screen does say, in readable text next to the button, that tapping or clicking means agreement, a California court applying Keebaugh may treat the terms as part of the contract. Godun does not hold that linked terms never bind, and Keebaugh does not hold that any hyperlink suffices. Together they make the screenshot a legal document. Photograph the full mobile screen, not only the price line. Capture the sentence above the subscribe button, the color and size of any terms link as rendered, and the first screen after payment. If the flow was on a television app, record the device and the sequence of screens in writing the same day, because the test asks what a reasonably prudent internet user would have seen in context.

Formation is only the threshold. Even a binding subscription must be renewed and canceled the way California’s Automatic Renewal Law commands, and an arbitration clause, if formed, does not repeal that statute. Conversely, a renewal-law violation does not automatically prove that no contract existed. Keep the two inquiries separate in any complaint to the seller: first, what did the sign-up screen actually tell the click to mean; second, what did the seller later send, charge and allow at cancellation. The records differ. The first is a screen. The second is an acknowledgment, a reminder notice and a cancellation path, each of which the statute names expressly.

B. Renewal notices, online cancellation and the limits of a refund demand in California

California Business and Professions Code section 17602 is the operative text. In the version read for this article at the California Legislative Information text of section 17602, subdivision (a) makes it unlawful for a business that makes an automatic renewal or continuous service offer to a consumer in California to fail to present the offer terms clearly and conspicuously before the agreement is fulfilled and in visual proximity to the request for consent; to charge the consumer’s card or third-party account without first obtaining affirmative consent to the agreement containing those terms; to fail to provide a retainable acknowledgment including the terms, the cancellation policy and how to cancel; to fail to obtain express affirmative consent; to include information that undermines the ability to give that consent; or to misrepresent a material fact about the transaction, including the inclusion of an automatic renewal, or about the underlying service. Each element maps to a record the viewer can keep: the offer terms near the consent request, the consent act itself, and the acknowledgment. If the acknowledgment in the inbox omits the renewal price, the renewal length or the cancellation method, preserve it exactly as received. The omission is the evidence.

The reminder notice has its own clocks, and they should be quoted only as the statute states them. Under section 17602(b)(1), where the consumer accepted a free gift or trial lasting more than 31 days, or a promotional or discounted price whose applicability was more than 31 days, the notice specified in subdivision (a)(8) shall be provided at least 3 days before and at most 21 days before expiration of the predetermined trial or promotional period, subject to the electronic-contact exemption the subdivision states. Under section 17602(b)(2), where the initial term is one year or longer and renews unless canceled, that notice shall be provided at least 15 days and not more than 45 days before the offer renews. A season package is not automatically in either sentence. A trial of 31 days or less is outside the first sentence as written, and a term shorter than one year is outside the second. Do not borrow a notice period from a different offer structure. Instead, write the viewer’s own dates next to the statutory words: date of acceptance, length of any trial or promotional price, initial term length, and date any reminder arrived. That arithmetic, on the seller’s own emails, is the check the text invites.

Cancellation is where the California text is most mechanical. Section 17602(c) requires a toll-free telephone number, email address, postal address if the seller directly bills the consumer, or another cost-effective, timely and easy-to-use cancellation mechanism described in the acknowledgment. Section 17602(d)(1) adds the online rule: a business that allows online acceptance must allow the consumer to terminate exclusively online, at will, and without further steps that obstruct or delay immediate termination, by a prominently located direct link or button in the account, profile, device or user settings, or by an immediately accessible termination email the business formats so it can be sent without additional information. Authentication may still be required where the consumer has an account, under subdivision (d)(3), and an offline method remains available to a consumer unwilling or unable to authenticate online. A retention offer is not automatically obstruction: subdivision (e)(2) permits displaying a discount or the effects of cancellation in an online system if the business simultaneously displays a prominently located, continuously and proximately displayed direct link or button entitled “click to cancel” or words to that effect, and then promptly processes cancellation when that link is used. Record the cancellation path screen by screen. The legal difference between a lawful save offer and an obstructive detour is, in this text, the simultaneous visible exit.

Federal law supplies principles and enforcement statutes, but the viewer should not cite a vacated federal click-to-cancel regulation as if it were in force. The Federal Trade Commission’s 2021 enforcement policy statement on negative-option marketing, published at 86 Federal Register 60822, describes itself as guidance on the Commission’s interpretation of existing law for practices under which silence or failure to cancel may be treated as continuing acceptance, including automatic renewals and free-to-pay conversions. The Eighth Circuit later vacated the amended Negative Option Rule in July 2025 on the ground that the Commission’s rulemaking process was procedurally insufficient and prejudicial error had been shown, while stating that it did not endorse unfair or deceptive practices in negative-option marketing. The Commission’s current Negative Option Rule page now states that the Commission seeks public comment on the need for amendments to help consumers avoid recurring payments they did not intend to order and cancel without unwarranted obstacles. A rulemaking comment page is not an operative cancellation regulation. For a California consumer, section 17602 is therefore not a duplicate of federal law. On the texts read here, it is the precise, operative instruction set for consent, acknowledgment, reminder and online termination.

That precision also marks the limit of a refund demand for blacked-out hockey. Section 17602(a)(7), as read, makes it unlawful to misrepresent a material fact related to the transaction or to the underlying service. It does not state that every unavailable game is a misrepresentation, and it does not state a formula refunding a season price divided by games missed. The stronger demand, on documents, is structured in order. If the offer promised the viewer’s local games and the account zip code was correctly entered, send the offer page, the acknowledgment and the blackout notice together and identify the sentence that was false. If the offer disclosed out-of-market limits and the viewer bought the wrong layer, use the statute for what it does give: termination exclusively online and at will, without obstructing steps, before the next charge. If a trial converted or a promotional price expired without the reminder the applicable subdivision requires, send the acceptance date, the trial or promotional length and the empty reminder record. If the seller cannot produce the consent verification it must maintain under subdivision (a)(6) — for at least three years, or one year after termination, whichever is longer — say so in those statutory terms. Card-network disputes and court forums have their own rules, which no source read for this article supplies; do not treat a chargeback deadline, a limitations period or a tolling rule as established here. None is stated in the texts above, and none is supplied by analogy.

Conclusion

A blackout is a territory drawn by contract after a federal repeal, not a switch the FCC still controls. The first check is therefore geographic and documentary: the account zip code, the league’s local-broadcast line for that zip code, and the rights layer the checkout page actually sold. The Sports Broadcasting Act permits only the narrow pooled sponsored-telecasting agreements it describes and reserves the rest of antitrust law, while the 2024 preliminary injunction shows both that packaging power can be challenged between industry parties and that such a challenge does not itself unlock a subscriber’s game.

The subscription is governed closer to home. In California, keep the sign-up screen because Godun and Keebaugh decide formation on conspicuous notice and unambiguous assent, screen by screen. Keep the acknowledgment and every reminder because section 17602 specifies their contents and, for the trial, promotional and one-year structures it names, their timing. Cancel online where online acceptance occurred, using the direct link the statute requires to remain visible even beside a retention offer. A refund demand should then be only as large as the document that supports it: a false sentence about the service, a missing required notice, a charge without the required consent, or an obstructed termination. That discipline will not put a local game on an out-of-market package. It will prevent the second, avoidable loss — paying again for a package whose territory was never the viewer’s.

📄 Official circular