Nick Jonas has spoken publicly about living with Type 1 diabetes. A November 2, 2026 company announcement described a diabetes-awareness campaign that includes his experience. His public account raises a practical question for people whose jobs involve fixed shifts, restricted breaks, travel, or rules about food and personal devices: what can a worker ask an employer to change when managing diabetes at work?
Under federal law, a covered employer generally must provide a reasonable accommodation for the known limitations of an otherwise qualified employee with a disability, unless the employer can demonstrate undue hardship. That does not mean that every requested arrangement must be approved or that every workplace is governed by the same employment rules. The useful starting point is to identify a specific work barrier, connect it to a practical change, and record how the request was handled.
The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable workplace situations and makes no findings about any named person’s employment or any party beyond what the cited decisions state. The cases address different medical conditions and facts. Their outcomes show why the employer’s response, the employee’s job and the evidence available at the relevant stage all matter.
I. What can a worker with diabetes ask a covered employer to change?
A. Identify the workplace barrier and a workable adjustment
Start with the task or rule that creates difficulty, rather than assuming that a diagnosis alone describes the needed change. A worker might need to monitor glucose while on duty, eat or drink at a predictable point, keep supplies accessible, or take a short break when symptoms require attention. Another worker may need a temporary change in shift timing while adjusting to treatment. The relevant request is the change needed to do the job or enjoy the same employment benefits, not a demand that a supervisor prescribe treatment.
The federal regulation at 29 C.F.R. § 1630.2 explains that reasonable accommodation can include adjustments to the work environment, the way a job is normally performed, or employment benefits. Its examples include modified schedules, policy changes and equipment. The same regulation says diabetes substantially limits endocrine function and that, when assessing disability, the beneficial effects of measures such as medication are generally disregarded. The assessment remains individualized; control of glucose through treatment does not by itself eliminate coverage.
Federal coverage also has a defined scope. Under 42 U.S.C. § 12111, the federal employment provisions generally cover an employer engaged in an industry affecting commerce with at least 15 employees for each working day in 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year. The statute has exceptions, including for the United States and Indian tribes. Separate federal rules can apply to federal employees, and state or local law may offer additional protection. A head count at one location alone may not answer which employer or coverage rule applies.
The same federal section defines a qualified individual by reference to the essential functions of the position, with or without reasonable accommodation. An essential function is a fundamental duty, not simply every task that appears on a long list. Look at the actual job, the written description, time spent on a duty and what happens if it is not performed. A proposed adjustment is stronger when it explains how the important work can still be done. For example, a person staffing a front desk could propose a plan for coverage during a brief glucose check instead of simply saying that the desk will be unattended whenever needed.
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s diabetes guidance identifies examples such as a private space to test or administer insulin, breaks to eat, drink or take medication, a place to rest, a modified schedule, and reassignment to a vacant position when appropriate. This is federal agency guidance explaining possible applications, not a list of automatic entitlements. The right solution depends on the person’s needs and the work. A person who can test discreetly at a workstation may have a different request from someone working around machinery or serving customers without a replacement.
A useful request describes four things: the work rule or task; the limitation or treatment need that makes the rule difficult; an adjustment that would address the difficulty; and how the essential work can continue. The explanation need not disclose unrelated diagnoses or provide an entire medical history to every manager. A worker can start by telling the person responsible for workplace requests that a change is needed because of a medical condition, then follow the employer’s process for any appropriate supporting information.
Consider a retail worker who needs immediate access to a drink or glucose supplies but normally cannot keep personal items at a register. The worker can identify the rule and ask for a safe, accessible location or an exception. If the employer has a sanitation or safety concern, both sides can discuss a sealed container, a nearby location, or another effective arrangement. The issue is not whether everyone else receives the same exception; the question is whether the adjustment addresses the employee’s need while allowing the work to continue.
For a worker on a rotating schedule, the question may be which shift pattern can be changed and for how long. A useful record could describe the present rotation, the effect on a treatment routine, the requested alternative and any existing staffing constraints. If the condition or schedule changes, the parties can revisit whether the arrangement remains effective. A request for a different shift is not a guarantee of a particular schedule, but it provides a concrete starting point for discussion.
B. Understand the limits of a request and the role of evidence
Federal law at 42 U.S.C. § 12112 includes a failure to make reasonable accommodation to known limitations of an otherwise qualified applicant or employee within disability discrimination, subject to the undue-hardship defense. The corresponding federal regulation at 29 C.F.R. § 1630.9 states the accommodation obligation and recognizes that a person is not required to accept an accommodation. If an effective accommodation is necessary to perform an essential function, however, rejecting it can affect whether the person is qualified for that position.
An employer may consider an alternative to the employee’s preferred proposal if the alternative actually addresses the limitation. A suggestion that looks similar on paper may not work in practice. A break placed at a fixed time may not address an unpredictable need; a distant storage room may not make supplies accessible when they are needed. Explain the practical problem and ask how the alternative would operate during a normal shift. If it fails in use, keep a factual record and request a further discussion rather than assuming the first decision ends the process.
Shears v. FirstEnergy Corp., No. 24-3915 (6th Cir. Jan. 5, 2026), was decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on January 5, 2026. The court affirmed summary judgment after the employee with diabetes abandoned his delay theory on appeal and the employer granted the schedule adjustment described in a doctor’s note. The decision did not decide that every delay in responding to a request is lawful. For a worker, the practical check is to preserve what was requested, when it was communicated, what documentation was supplied and what actually changed at work. The opinion was not recommended for publication and concerns the particular record before that court.
That decision also illustrates why the original problem, the proposed adjustment and later employment events should be kept distinct. A dispute about a schedule request is not automatically resolved by a later disagreement over performance. Keep the documents in sequence: the request, any response, the relevant schedule, the medical note if one is provided, and later communications. Record what each document shows and avoid assuming that an employer’s explanation or a worker’s account has already been accepted by a court.
Andrews v. Tri Star Sports and Entertainment Group, Inc., No. 23-5700 (6th Cir. Aug. 21, 2024), was decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on August 21, 2024. In that asthma case, the majority affirmed summary judgment on the evidence and arguments before it; a judge dissented. Its different medical condition and procedural record do not decide whether a worker with diabetes is covered. The practical check is to keep evidence showing the actual limitation and the requested change, instead of assuming that a diagnosis label alone explains every disputed fact. This opinion was not recommended for publication.
These cases are examples of Sixth Circuit decisions, not nationwide rulings that settle every dispute. An unpublished opinion should be read with its procedural posture and the circuit’s rules in mind. The applicable federal statutes and regulations remain the starting point, while the court that hears a particular dispute and the facts in its record can affect the analysis. The distinction is especially important when a decision about asthma or another medical condition is used only to illustrate how courts examine proof.
Undue hardship is also more specific than an inconvenience or a supervisor’s preference for uniform rules. Section 12111 describes significant difficulty or expense and lists factors including the nature and cost of an accommodation, resources, workforce and operations. A worker can ask what concrete operational issue an alternative is meant to address. The employer can evaluate the facts of its own facility and operation rather than relying solely on a general assumption about everyone with diabetes.
II. What should happen after the request is made?
A. Document the conversation, privacy and the available options
Ask for a conversation that connects the medical need to the job. Under federal regulation, an informal interactive process may be necessary to identify the precise limitations and potential accommodations. The process is practical: explain the barrier, listen to the employer’s questions about the work, compare possible changes, and test whether the chosen arrangement addresses the need. The parties do not have to agree that the first proposal is the only possible one in order to discuss effective options.
A written request can be brief. For example: a worker may say that diabetes management requires access to a monitor and a short break when needed, and that a coworker could cover the workstation during the check. The worker can ask whom to send any supporting note to and how the schedule will be handled. Keep a copy of the request and the response, including any later clarification. If the initial request is made orally, a neutral follow-up message can record what was discussed and ask whether the summary is accurate.
Medical documentation can be relevant when the disability or need for the adjustment is not known or obvious. The EEOC’s diabetes guidance says the employer may request reasonable documentation sufficient to establish the condition and explain the need for accommodation in that situation; it describes a request for an entire medical record as inappropriate because it is likely to include unrelated information. A worker can ask which question the supporting note needs to answer and direct the note to the appropriate person rather than circulating it among coworkers.
The federal rules also distinguish stages of employment. Before an offer, 29 C.F.R. § 1630.14 permits inquiries about an applicant’s ability to perform job-related functions. After an offer, the regulation permits an entrance examination or inquiry if all entering employees in the same job category are subjected to it regardless of disability. For a current employee, an employer-required medical examination or inquiry must be job-related and consistent with business necessity. These are different settings; a question permissible at one stage is not automatically permissible at another.
The same regulation requires medical information obtained under the provisions it describes to be collected and maintained separately and treated as confidential, with specified exceptions. For example, supervisors may be informed about necessary work restrictions and accommodations, and first-aid or safety personnel may be informed when appropriate if emergency treatment may be needed. The useful distinction is between sharing the information needed to implement a work arrangement and sharing the employee’s medical history generally.
Crispell v. FCA US, LLC, No. 23-1114 (6th Cir. June 18, 2024), was decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on June 18, 2024. The majority reversed summary judgment and remanded because the record contained disputes a jury could consider about a medical condition, the scope of a requested call-in adjustment and the response; a judge dissented. Reversal at that stage was not a finding that liability had been established. The practical check is to document the specific change requested, the employer’s questions and any disputed response. This unpublished case concerned a different condition and its own attendance policy.
The comparison is useful because the record can contain competing descriptions of the same conversation. An employee may understand a request as a limited exception during an unexpected episode, while a manager may understand it as permission to disregard a rule generally. A concise written description can narrow that gap: specify the circumstances, what the worker will do when able, and who will handle the related operational task. Do not promise a level of predictability that a treating professional has not supported.
If the employer proposes a trial, agree on what will be tested: who covers the work, how the employee accesses supplies, and when the parties will review whether the arrangement worked. Keep the trial tied to actual observations. An isolated inconvenience does not establish a universal outcome, and an arrangement that works for one position may be unsuitable for another. A follow-up can explain the result without disclosing unnecessary medical details.
Workers who supervise people can use the same approach. Separate the decision about an adjustment from assumptions about motivation or dedication. Ask what duty is affected and what practical arrangement would allow it to be performed. Store medical information in the appropriate restricted channel, while giving the people implementing the arrangement the work-related information they need. A policy can set out where requests go without requiring employees to explain a diagnosis to an entire team.
B. If an adjustment is refused or stops working, what can be checked next?
First identify the actual decision. Was the request denied, was a different arrangement offered, was more information requested, or did an approved arrangement fail when the worker tried to use it? Those situations call for different responses. A worker can ask for the reason in writing, explain a missed detail, supply appropriate support or identify an alternative that addresses the same barrier. Keep the question focused on the specific work need and the decision made.
If safety is raised, identify the particular duty and the evidence behind the concern. The federal definition of direct threat in § 1630.2 calls for an individualized assessment of present ability, using a reasonable medical judgment based on current medical knowledge or the best available objective evidence. The regulation identifies the duration of a risk, the nature and severity of potential harm, its likelihood and its imminence. A diagnosis alone does not describe those facts. Ask whether a reasonable adjustment could eliminate or reduce the identified risk.
A change in performance deserves the same attention to details. Identify what the expected duty was, what happened, what the worker communicated and when the relevant decision was made. An accommodation discussion does not make every work rule disappear; nor does a performance concern automatically answer whether an effective adjustment was available. The distinction matters when reviewing schedules, instructions, prior requests and the reasons actually given for an employment decision.
If the concern is retaliation, 42 U.S.C. § 12203 prohibits discrimination because an individual opposed an unlawful practice or participated in a charge or related proceeding, and separately addresses interference, coercion and intimidation in the exercise of rights. The EEOC guidance also describes protection against retaliation for requesting a reasonable accommodation. A protected request and a later unfavorable action are facts to document; the reason for the action and the other evidence still matter in a dispute.
Preserve records that the worker is authorized to keep: the request and replies, relevant schedules, notices of a change in duties, and notes made at the time of conversations. A useful timeline identifies the date, the participants, the decision and the source of the information. Separate a direct observation from an inference. If a message contains another person’s private information or confidential business material, consider the rules governing that material before copying or sharing it. The goal is an accurate account, not a collection of unrelated records.
The federal route can differ according to the employer and the kind of claim. The EEOC guidance describes a charge process for private and state or local government employment and a separate agency process for federal employees. Do not assume the same office, filing period or procedure applies to all workers. Identify the employer, the location, the event being challenged and the relevant agency process before deciding what step is available. State and local protections may add a separate route, but their terms must be checked under the relevant jurisdiction.
For an applicant, preserve the job description and the stage at which a question was asked or an adjustment was requested. For an existing employee, preserve the schedule, the policy and any changes to duties. If the issue concerns a vacant position, identify the position and its requirements rather than assuming that a new job must be created. If the need is temporary, record the expected review point and update the employer if the practical need changes. These details help distinguish a feasible proposal from an abstract request.
A dispute can also be avoided by revisiting an effective arrangement after a worksite change. A move to a new building may alter where supplies can be stored; a new supervisor may not know which restrictions have been implemented; a revised shift may conflict with an established break plan. The worker can describe the new barrier and propose a comparable solution. The employer can check the actual operational impact before deciding whether a different arrangement is needed.
Throughout, medical treatment decisions belong with the worker and the treating professional. The legal issue is how an employment rule, job duty or workplace arrangement interacts with a documented need. A written record of the actual problem, the proposed change and the response is more useful than a generalized statement that diabetes always requires one particular schedule or always prevents a person from performing a job.
Conclusion
For a worker with diabetes, the first useful step is to name the workplace barrier and propose an adjustment that addresses it while accounting for essential duties. Federal law protects qualified workers at covered employers, while allowing a covered employer to demonstrate undue hardship. The three Sixth Circuit decisions show the importance of the request, the response, the evidence and the procedural stage; they do not predict an outcome for another worker. Keep a clear record, protect medical information and check the applicable process for the employer and jurisdiction involved.