KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Nigeria’s Kidnapping Crisis Reaches the ICC: Can France Investigate Crimes Against Humanity If Abuja Does Not?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Nigeria’s Kidnapping Crisis Reaches the ICC: Can France Investigate Crimes Against Humanity If Abuja Does Not?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Nigeria’s kidnapping crisis has moved into a new legal phase at The Hague. On 26 August 2026, the International Criminal Court published a decision assigning a formal communication requesting an investigation into “Systemic Kidnappings in Nigeria as Crimes Against Humanity” to a Pre-Trial Chamber. The public record identifies the document as ICC-ROC46(3)-01/26-2 and describes it as a decision of the President of the Pre-Trial Division; it does not identify a suspect, open an investigation or issue an arrest warrant. The ICC court record is therefore important precisely because it is narrow.

The timing is difficult to ignore. An Associated Press report published on 27 August, citing Lagos-based SBM Intelligence, said that 7,825 people had been kidnapped in Nigeria between July 2025 and June 2026 and that ransom payments were estimated at 7.78 billion naira, about 5.8 million US dollars. The reported number of kidnappings was 66 per cent higher than in the previous year. Those figures establish an urgent public-security crisis; they do not, without more, prove one international crime.

For French lawyers, victims and investigators, the practical question is more precise: what can be done when a Nigerian pattern may involve crimes within the ICC’s jurisdiction, but the domestic response is disputed or incomplete? The answer depends on separating four stages: an Article 15 communication, judicial assignment of a matter, authorisation of an ICC investigation and a later case against identified persons. French jurisdiction is a parallel and conditional route. It can become relevant where a suspect habitually resides in France, where a French victim creates an ordinary jurisdictional connection, or where conduct or evidence is located in France. None of those routes turns a press release into a conviction.

I. What does the ICC’s Nigeria kidnapping decision actually change?

A. Is the ICC opening an investigation, issuing a warrant or only assigning a communication?

The short answer is that the public decision is an assignment, not an investigation authorisation. The Court’s own title is the legal starting point: “Decision assigning the ‘Formal Communication Requesting Investigation into Systemic Kidnappings in Nigeria as Crimes Against Humanity’”. The document number, date and issuing authority are visible on the ICC record. The page records the preliminary phase, gives no accused person and contains no arrest warrant. A headline saying that the ICC has already opened a kidnapping investigation would therefore go beyond the public record.

An Article 15 communication is information submitted to the Office of the Prosecutor about alleged crimes within the ICC’s jurisdiction. The Court’s public guidance for the Office of the Prosecutor explains that an individual, group, State, intergovernmental organisation or non-governmental organisation may submit information. It also says that communications are screened for jurisdiction, seriousness and a possible link with an existing preliminary examination or investigation. A communication is an input into prosecutorial analysis. It is not a judicial finding that the alleged conduct occurred and it does not, by itself, make the sender a party to a case. The ICC’s official Office of the Prosecutor materials provide the institutional reference point.

The Rome Statute then sets a higher procedural gate. Article 15(1) permits the Prosecutor to initiate an investigation proprio motu on information about crimes within the Court’s jurisdiction. Article 15(3) requires a request to a Pre-Trial Chamber if the Prosecutor concludes that there is a reasonable basis to proceed. Article 15(4) gives the Chamber the power to authorise commencement only if, after examining the request and supporting material, it considers that there is a reasonable basis and that the matter appears to fall within the Court’s jurisdiction. The official Rome Statute text is the relevant source.

The new decision sits between information and an investigation. The Court’s procedural regulations contain a mechanism for a matter that is not already attached to an assigned situation. Regulation 46(3) uses the words “manifestly frivolous” in describing the limited basis on which a matter may be kept from assignment. The regulation is not a merits judgment. It is an allocation rule that ensures a filing can reach the competent judicial formation. The ICC Regulations of the Court should be read alongside the new record, not replaced by a news headline.

That distinction has several consequences. The President of the Pre-Trial Division has not identified an accused person. There is no public finding that a named armed group, criminal network, government agency or official satisfies the elements of a crime against humanity. There is no order to arrest anyone in Nigeria, France or another State. There is no direction to French courts. The assignment means that a Pre-Trial Chamber now has a procedural route to consider the matter; it does not predetermine what that Chamber, the Prosecutor or the Nigerian authorities will do.

The public record also leaves important facts unresolved. It does not identify the communication’s sender, the incidents relied upon, the proposed time period, the alleged organisational policy or the individual perpetrators. Those omissions may reflect confidentiality rather than weakness. The ICC’s OTPLink guidance states that communications are treated as confidential and that the identity of a sender may be protected. Counsel should not fill those gaps with assumptions. The first responsible legal task is to distinguish what the ICC has published from what a victim, advocacy organisation or journalist may allege separately.

Nigeria is not outside the Court’s territorial framework. The ICC’s official Nigeria situation page states that Nigeria is a State Party to the Rome Statute and that the Office of the Prosecutor has examined alleged crimes on Nigerian territory since 2010. It also records a 2020 conclusion that there was a reasonable basis to believe that war crimes and crimes against humanity had been committed in the situation. That earlier conclusion concerned a broad preliminary examination, principally involving Boko Haram and Nigerian security forces. It should not be confused with a finding that every current kidnapping is part of the same criminality.

The assignment of a new communication may place a different factual pattern before a judicial chamber: ransom kidnappings, mass abductions, captivity, sexual violence, killings or conduct attributed to several types of organisation. Whether the matter is connected to the existing Nigeria situation, treated as a new matter or found to require no further step is a legal question for the Court. The date of the assignment makes the development newsworthy; it does not settle that question.

For French counsel, the immediate benefit of the record is evidential rather than punitive. The number ICC-ROC46(3)-01/26-2 can be placed in a complaint, a request to preserve digital evidence, a victim submission or correspondence with a national prosecutor. It is a verifiable reference to a public procedural event. It must be described as an assignment decision. Using it as proof that a particular person committed a crime, or that an investigation has already begun, would weaken the credibility of the file and may prejudice victims and potential witnesses.

B. When can repeated kidnappings become crimes against humanity?

Kidnapping is not automatically a crime against humanity merely because it is frequent, cruel or profitable. Article 7 of the Rome Statute requires a listed act committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against a civilian population, with knowledge of the attack. Imprisonment or another severe deprivation of physical liberty may fall within the list. Depending on the evidence, captivity may also involve murder, torture, rape, sexual slavery, persecution, enforced disappearance or other inhumane acts. The legal analysis is cumulative: the underlying conduct, the civilian attack, the widespread or systematic character, the policy or organisational link and the perpetrator’s knowledge must be established.

The title of the new ICC communication uses “systemic”. The Rome Statute uses “systematic”. The two words are not interchangeable in a courtroom. “Systemic” may describe a national crisis, repeated institutional failure or a pattern embedded in social and economic structures. “Systematic” is a legal element that asks whether the attack is organised, non-random and carried out according to a regular pattern or policy. A national ransom total can be powerful evidence of scale. It cannot substitute for proof that the relevant acts formed one attack or a set of connected attacks.

The first legal task is to identify the attack. Nigeria’s current kidnapping figures may include armed groups, criminal gangs, local militias, opportunistic offenders and factions with different objectives. The fact that all demand ransom does not prove that they belong to one organisation. Conversely, an organisation may use separate cells, contractors or financial intermediaries while pursuing a common plan. Investigators must map command, recruitment, communications, transport, safe houses, ransom collection, release decisions and punishment of hostages. The pattern may be regional rather than national. It may also change over time.

The second task is to classify the acts. A hostage held for ransom may be the victim of unlawful imprisonment or severe deprivation of liberty. A person disappeared after payment negotiations may raise a different issue from a person released unharmed. Captivity involving violence, sexual abuse, starvation, forced labour or death requires separate proof. A ransom payment can show motive, but motive is not one of the contextual elements of a crime against humanity. It can help prove an organisation’s policy, financial structure or selection of civilians, but the legal conclusion must still be tied to the evidence.

French criminal law provides a useful comparative lens. Article 212-1 of the French Criminal Code treats as a crime against humanity, among other acts, “L’emprisonnement ou toute autre forme de privation grave de liberté physique” when committed in execution of a concerted plan against a civilian population in a widespread or systematic attack. The French wording makes the context visible. A serious deprivation of liberty is not enough on its own; the concerted plan and the attack against civilians must also be shown.

French law separately criminalises the underlying liberty offence. Article 224-1 of the Criminal Code states, in its official wording, “arrêter, d’enlever, de détenir ou de séquestrer une personne” and provides a twenty-year criminal penalty, subject to the statutory exceptions. Where a person is held hostage to obtain a condition such as ransom, Article 224-4 provides a different and heavier framework. These provisions can support a French investigation into specific kidnappings, but they do not erase the additional contextual requirements for a crime against humanity.

The third task is to prove the organisational policy or practice without collapsing distinct actors into one label. The ICC need not prove that a formal written order exists. A policy may be inferred from repeated conduct, resources, methods, leadership statements, territorial control, recruitment or the way victims are selected. It still needs to be a policy of a State or organisation, or conduct in furtherance of that policy, depending on the charge. A collection of unrelated ransom crimes can be grave and widespread in public life while remaining legally distinct for Article 7 purposes.

The fourth task is individual responsibility. The Court does not prosecute “the kidnapping crisis” as an abstract event. It prosecutes persons who allegedly ordered, solicited, induced, contributed to, aided, abetted or otherwise participated in crimes, subject to the modes of liability in the Statute. A person who rented a vehicle, operated a payment channel or negotiated with a family may have a different legal position from the organiser who selected targets and directed captivity. Evidence must show knowledge and contribution, not simply contact with a suspect or presence in a region.

The complementarity question then becomes decisive. Article 17 of the Rome Statute generally makes a case inadmissible when it is being genuinely investigated or prosecuted by a State with jurisdiction, subject to the Statute’s unwillingness or inability exceptions. A domestic response does not automatically block the ICC, and a lack of a domestic conviction does not automatically prove unwillingness. The Court must examine the relevant national proceedings, their scope, independence, progress and genuine purpose. The AP’s ransom figures and the ICC assignment create a reason to scrutinise the response; they do not answer the complementarity test.

The same caution applies to the word “investigation”. A formal communication can trigger screening, information requests and procedural attention. It does not necessarily create victim participation rights in an investigation, a public case file or a right to demand an arrest warrant. Victims should keep their own evidence and seek advice about confidentiality before sending material to the ICC or a national authority. Once material is submitted, it may be retained, translated, assessed and potentially disclosed under the Court’s rules if a future proceeding requires it.

II. Can France investigate if Nigerian proceedings do not provide an effective response?

A. Which French jurisdictional route could apply to Nigerian kidnappings?

France cannot assume jurisdiction over every international crime simply because the victim, lawyer or news story has a French connection. It must identify a statutory basis. The first route is ordinary territorial or connected jurisdiction. If part of the conduct occurred in France, if a French-based payment channel or communications operation formed part of the offence, or if digital evidence and an essential constituent act are located in France, the general rules may support French proceedings. Article 689 of the Code of Criminal Procedure explains that offences committed outside France may be prosecuted where French law applies or an international instrument gives French courts jurisdiction.

The second route concerns a French victim. Article 113-7 of the French Criminal Code provides that French criminal law applies to any crime, and to any imprisonable offence, committed abroad by a French national or a foreigner when the victim was French at the time of the offence. This is a significant connection for a French national abducted or held abroad, but it does not mean that a French prosecutor must take over a Nigerian investigation. The authorities must still determine the facts, the offender, the applicable offence, the evidence and the relationship with proceedings in Nigeria or another State.

Where the conduct is prosecuted as an offence rather than a crime, Article 113-8 adds procedural conditions, including a complaint by the victim or rights holders or an official denunciation by the State where the conduct occurred, together with a prosecution request by the public prosecutor. The exact classification matters. A file should not cite Article 113-7 in the abstract and ignore the procedural rules that attach to the selected charge.

The third route is France’s controlled universal jurisdiction for core international crimes. Article 689-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows French courts to prosecute a person suspected of committing genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes abroad, but only within strict conditions. The suspect must have a habitual residence in France, defined by a sufficient connection assessed through the duration and reasons for presence, intention to remain and family, social, material or professional links. The text also assigns the prosecution request to the national anti-terrorist prosecutor and requires checks concerning international or national requests for surrender or extradition.

That is why the answer to the article’s title question is conditional. France may be able to investigate or prosecute a suspect connected to Nigerian kidnapping allegations if that person habitually resides in France and the conduct meets the French and international definitions. France is not given universal jurisdiction merely because Nigeria has failed to prevent kidnappings or because the ICC has received a communication. The jurisdictional file must begin with a person, a location, a time period, a legal classification and evidence of the required French connection.

The leading French case law illustrates the importance of precision. In Criminal Chamber, 24 November 2021, appeal no. 21-81.344, the Cour de cassation held that the then-applicable double-criminality requirement under Article 689-11 involved an offence in the foreign law containing the contextual element of an attack against a civilian population pursuant to a concerted plan. The decision is not a shortcut for the Nigeria analysis, particularly because Article 689-11 has since been amended and Nigeria is a Rome Statute State Party. Its continuing value is methodological: the court examines the statutory conditions and the contextual element, not the moral force of the allegations alone.

The decision also helps explain why a French complaint should separate ordinary kidnapping from the international-crime theory. A Nigerian kidnapping may be prosecuted through a conventional offence if the French jurisdictional rules are satisfied. A crime against humanity requires a broader attack and a contextual plan. If the evidence supports both descriptions, counsel should present both without claiming that the broader one is already proven. If the evidence supports only a series of individual ransom crimes, the ordinary charges may remain the stronger and more realistic basis for immediate investigative action.

French jurisdiction does not eliminate the need for Nigerian cooperation. Witnesses, crime scenes, telecom records, bank information, ransom intermediaries and detention locations may be in Nigeria. A French prosecutor can request assistance through the applicable international channels, but the request must identify the acts and material sought. A general request to “investigate the Nigerian kidnapping crisis” is unlikely to be operational. A useful request identifies a victim, date, phone number, account, vehicle, location, suspect, payment, message or witness and explains why the evidence is relevant to a defined offence.

The ICC route and the French route can coexist, but they must be coordinated. Article 689-11 requires the French public prosecutor to check whether an international jurisdiction is prosecuting the person and whether another State has requested surrender or extradition. A French file that conceals an ICC request or ignores an existing Nigerian proceeding is vulnerable. A file that explains the parallel steps, identifies the precise French contribution and asks the prosecutor to communicate with the appropriate authority is more likely to be treated as a serious jurisdictional submission.

B. What should victims, witnesses and French counsel do after the assignment?

The first action is evidence preservation. A kidnapping file should contain the original communications, call logs, location data, ransom demands, proof of payment, bank records, wallet addresses, photographs, medical records, travel documents and every communication with police or negotiators. Preserve metadata and original files where possible. Do not edit screenshots to make them easier to read. Keep a working copy for translation and a preserved copy with a chain-of-custody note. A later prosecutor, French court or ICC chamber needs to know when the item was obtained, by whom, from which device or account and whether it has been altered.

The second action is to build a chronology that distinguishes knowledge from inference. Record the abduction or attempted abduction, the place of captivity, every demand, each payment instruction, any proof-of-life communication, release or disappearance, medical treatment and contact with authorities. Mark what the victim personally saw, what a witness reported, what a bank or telecom provider confirmed and what an analyst inferred from open-source material. The ICC assignment and AP report can be cited as context. Neither replaces first-hand evidence of a particular incident.

The third action is to decide which authority should receive which material. A French national victim may have grounds to report to French police, the gendarmerie or the competent prosecutor and to ask for the complaint to be connected to a cross-border investigation. A witness with information about crimes against humanity may consider an Article 15 communication to the ICC, but should understand the Court’s confidentiality and retention rules before transmitting original material. A person in immediate danger should prioritise safety and local emergency assistance over the preparation of a legal submission.

A French complaint should state the jurisdictional hook in its first pages. It should say whether the victim is French, whether a suspect resides habitually in France, whether a French bank or telecom provider was used, whether a relevant act occurred in France and whether another State or international court is already investigating. It should then set out the ordinary kidnapping theory and, only where the evidence supports it, the crime-against-humanity theory. This structure allows the prosecutor to preserve the case even if one qualification later fails.

The fourth action is to understand what France can do when the ICC later requests cooperation. Article 627 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states that France participates in repressing offences covered by the Rome Statute and cooperates with the ICC under the title that follows. The cooperation rules are not ceremonial. They govern the route by which a request is received, transmitted, executed and reported to The Hague.

For evidence and other assistance, Article 627-1 provides that requests from the ICC are sent to the competent authorities with supporting material and transmitted to the national anti-terrorist prosecutor for appropriate action. For an arrest request, Article 627-4 provides that a request for arrest for the purpose of surrender is sent with supporting documents and, after a formal check, transmitted to the Paris prosecutor general and executed across the Republic. In an emergency, it may be sent directly by any means to the territorially competent prosecutor.

Those provisions answer a question that the new Nigeria decision does not yet raise: how France would respond if the ICC later issued a formal arrest request. They do not authorise a French arrest today. The distinction protects the presumption of innocence and prevents a procedural assignment from being misreported as an arrest warrant. If an arrest request is eventually received, the person sought would have access to the statutory judicial safeguards and a defined route before the Paris investigating chamber.

The time limits are also legally significant. Article 627-10 requires information about the decision and any surrender to be sent to the ICC, and provides that the requested person is surrendered within one month after the decision becomes final unless an insurmountable circumstance delays the handover. This future-stage timetable should not be confused with the present communication assignment. A French lawyer assessing a client’s position must first identify the document actually served: a complaint, a national warrant, an INTERPOL diffusion, an ICC request or a French court order.

The fifth action is to preserve the victim’s procedural position without overstating it. An Article 15 communication does not automatically create a right to participate in a future ICC investigation. The Rome Statute and Rules of Procedure and Evidence contain distinct participation provisions that depend on the stage and the Chamber’s directions. A victim should ask whether the material is being submitted as information, a request for protective measures, evidence of a specific crime or a request for participation. Each purpose affects confidentiality, representation and possible disclosure.

The sixth action is to identify financial and digital evidence without paying a second ransom to a supposed recovery service. Ransom demands, cryptocurrency transfers, prepaid cards, mobile-money accounts and informal intermediaries may reveal an organisation’s structure. They may also expose the victim to fraud, retaliation or further danger. Counsel should preserve the evidence and communicate with investigators and regulated providers through safe channels. A public allegation that a wallet belongs to a particular group is not proof of control; the chain must be supported by account records, device evidence, admissions, witnesses or other reliable material.

The seventh action is to test complementarity rather than assume it. If Nigeria is genuinely investigating the same persons and conduct, the ICC may consider that domestic process. If authorities are investigating unrelated low-level cases while ignoring those most responsible, the result may be different. A French submission should therefore collect the case numbers, charging decisions, court dates, custody information, investigative steps and explanations given by Nigerian authorities. It should not describe an entire national system as unwilling or unable without evidence. That language has legal consequences under Article 17 of the Rome Statute.

There is a further practical reason to coordinate national and international files: evidence can be lost or become unusable when requests are duplicated without a clear chain. The same victim may be contacted by a French investigator, a Nigerian police service, an ICC analyst and a non-governmental organisation. The victim should keep a record of what was sent, under which confidentiality terms and to whom. Translations should be identified as translations. Audio and video should retain original timestamps and, where possible, device information. A lawyer can then tell each authority what is new, what is already held elsewhere and what urgent measure is requested.

The legal objective is not to force one institution to use the strongest possible label. It is to make the evidence usable at the correct level. An individual French kidnapping case may justify an ordinary criminal investigation. A connected pattern may justify a request for international assistance. A demonstrable organisational attack against civilians may support an ICC Article 7 theory. A suspect habitually resident in France may bring Article 689-11 into play. A later ICC arrest request may activate Articles 627-4 to 627-10. The sequence matters because each stage has different proof, authority and remedies.

For international media, the most accurate formulation after 26 August is therefore restrained but significant: the ICC’s President of the Pre-Trial Division assigned a formal communication concerning alleged systemic kidnappings in Nigeria to a Pre-Trial Chamber under ICC-ROC46(3)-01/26-2. Nigeria’s kidnapping statistics make the issue urgent. The assignment puts a procedural question before the Court. It does not establish criminal responsibility, open a public investigation, name a suspect or create a French arrest power.

Conclusion

The Nigeria development is a live test of how international criminal procedure responds to a mass crisis that is both criminal and potentially organised. The ICC has received a formal communication and assigned it to a Pre-Trial Chamber. That step gives the matter a public procedural address, but it is not an investigation authorisation and it is not an arrest warrant. The legal test remains whether specific acts, connected to specific persons and an identifiable organisation or policy, satisfy the Rome Statute’s requirements for crimes against humanity.

France can matter, but not as an automatic substitute for Nigeria or the ICC. French jurisdiction may arise from a French victim, a French constituent act, evidence or service provider in France, or a suspect’s habitual residence. Article 689-11 provides a particularly important but carefully bounded route for international crimes. The Cour de cassation’s decision in appeal no. 21-81.344 shows why the contextual element and the statutory conditions must be addressed directly.

For a victim or witness, the next step is a dated, secure and classified evidence file: the incident, the captivity, the ransom or violence, the communications, the actors, the financial trail, the French connection and every national or international reference. The new ICC record should be cited accurately. It should not be inflated into a finding that the Court has already determined that all Nigerian kidnappings constitute crimes against humanity.

If Nigerian proceedings are inadequate, that fact must be demonstrated through case-specific evidence. If an ICC investigation is later authorised, French cooperation rules may become relevant for evidence and surrender. Until then, a French complaint, a carefully prepared Article 15 communication and a request for targeted international assistance are distinct tools. Used together and described accurately, they can turn a global headline into an accountable legal file.

📄 Official circular