KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Ontario Mills Shooting: Can a Teen Be Tried as an Adult in California?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ontario Mills Shooting: Can a Teen Be Tried as an Adult in California?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The Ontario Mills shooting on Friday evening, November 13, 2026, brought police to the Ontario Mills Mall in Ontario, California. In a post on its official X account that evening, the Ontario Police Department said it was actively investigating a shooting at the Ontario Mills Mall, that there were no reported injuries, that the scene was contained, that a suspect was in custody and that there was “no threat to the community.” The department added that updates would follow. Southern California outlets, including ABC7 Los Angeles and NBC Los Angeles, reported that police described the person taken into custody as a juvenile. The department’s own post that we read gives no age, no name and no charge.

Once the immediate fear passes, the question many readers ask is a legal one: if the person arrested is under 18, does the case stay in juvenile court, or can California try a teenager as an adult? The answer depends on the age of the young person on the date of the alleged offense, on the offense charged, and on a transfer hearing that California law now makes demanding for any prosecutor who seeks an adult trial.

The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the person arrested, about Ontario Mills or about anyone else connected with the incident. It explains where a California case against a minor begins, which deadlines apply in the first days, which offenses a shooting in a crowded public place can raise for a young person and for adults around that person, and how judges decide a request to move a case to adult court.

I. Where does a California case begin when the person arrested is a minor?

A. Juvenile court is the default, and the first deadlines are measured in days

California starts from a simple rule. Under Welfare and Institutions Code section 602, a minor who is between 12 and 17 years of age, inclusive, when he or she violates a state or federal criminal law is within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge the minor to be a ward of the court. The statute opens with an exception, “Except as provided in Section 707,” and that exception is the transfer procedure discussed in Part II. Until a juvenile judge grants a transfer, the case belongs in juvenile court.

The rule that a juvenile case begins in juvenile court comes from Proposition 57, which California voters approved in November 2016. In People v. Superior Court (Lara), 4 Cal.5th 299 (Cal. 2018), decided February 1, 2018, the Supreme Court of California explained that “Proposition 57 prohibits prosecutors from charging juveniles with crimes directly in adult court” and that “Only if the juvenile court transfers the matter to adult court can the juvenile be tried and sentenced as an adult.” The court applied that change to juveniles whose cases were not yet final when the measure took effect, because the possibility of being handled in juvenile court “can result in dramatically different and more lenient treatment.” For a family whose child has just been arrested in California, Lara means the case against a minor must begin in juvenile court, and an adult trial becomes possible only after a juvenile judge orders a transfer. The holding remains in active use: in People v. Lopez, No. S281488, decided January 23, 2025, the Supreme Court of California cited Lara for the presumption that ameliorative changes to criminal law extend as broadly as possible to cases that are not final, and it noted that Lara had weighed the complexities of applying Proposition 57 to pending cases and found that they did not bar that result.

The vocabulary also changes. In Lara, the Supreme Court of California quoted an earlier appellate summary of the juvenile system: a prosecutor proceeds by filing a juvenile petition rather than a criminal complaint, the minor admits or denies the allegations rather than pleading guilty or not guilty, the judge holds a jurisdictional hearing that is equivalent to a bench trial, and the judge then holds a dispositional hearing rather than imposing a sentence. The court described rehabilitation as the goal of that system. Parents who hear the words “petition,” “jurisdictional hearing” and “disposition” for the first time are hearing the juvenile equivalents of charge, trial and sentence.

The first deadlines are short, and they are written into the statute. Under Welfare and Institutions Code section 631, a minor taken into custody by a peace officer or probation officer must be released within 48 hours after being taken into custody, excluding nonjudicial days, unless within that period a petition to declare the minor a ward has been filed or a criminal complaint has been filed in a court of competent jurisdiction. If a petition is filed and the minor remains in custody, section 632 requires that the minor be brought before a juvenile court judge or referee “as soon as possible but in any event before the expiration of the next judicial day after a petition to declare the minor a ward or dependent child has been filed.” The statute calls that proceeding a detention hearing. Section 632, subdivision (c), adds that a minor who is not brought before a judge or referee within the prescribed period must be released from custody.

Both sections contain a separate, shorter track in their subdivision (b) for minors taken into custody without a warrant for a misdemeanor that does not involve violence, the threat of violence, or the possession or use of a weapon. An arrest connected with gunfire in a public place will rarely fit that description, so the general rule of subdivision (a) is the one to check. In practical terms, a parent should ask three questions in the first two days: whether a petition has been filed, when the detention hearing is scheduled, and whether the young person has a lawyer for that hearing. The detention hearing decides whether the minor stays in custody while the case proceeds; it does not decide whether the allegations are true.

Many readers also wonder why no name has been released. California treats most juvenile proceedings as private. Under Welfare and Institutions Code section 676, unless the minor and any parent or guardian present request otherwise, the public is not admitted to a juvenile court hearing. The same section, however, opens hearings to the public, on the same basis as criminal trials, when the petition alleges certain serious offenses. That list includes assault with a firearm or destructive device and the discharge of a firearm into an inhabited dwelling or occupied building. Section 676, subdivision (c), adds that the name of a minor found to have committed one of the listed offenses is not confidential unless the court, for good cause, orders otherwise, and it limits good cause to protecting the personal safety of the minor, a victim or a member of the public. The absence of a name in the first days of a juvenile case is consistent with that framework.

B. What a shooting in a crowded public place can mean for a minor and for the adults around that minor

The offenses that may be alleged depend on facts that are not public: who fired, at what or at whom, with what weapon, and with what intent. California law nevertheless identifies several provisions that come up repeatedly when a gun is fired in a place full of people. The first is Penal Code section 246.3, which applies, except as otherwise authorized by law, to any person who “willfully discharges a firearm in a grossly negligent manner which could result in injury or death to a person.” The statute does not require that anyone actually be hurt; it requires conduct that could result in injury or death. For an adult, it provides for imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year or imprisonment under subdivision (h) of Penal Code section 1170.

The second is possession itself. Under Penal Code section 29610, a minor shall not possess a handgun or a semiautomatic centerfire rifle, and, in the words of subdivision (c), “Commencing July 1, 2023, a minor shall not possess any firearm.” In California, therefore, a person under 18 who has a firearm in a public place raises a possession question before anyone asks how the weapon was used.

The third set of provisions matters because of what it unlocks rather than what it punishes. Subdivision (b) of Welfare and Institutions Code section 707 lists offenses that carry special procedural consequences, including murder, attempted murder, assault with a firearm or destructive device, and discharge of a firearm into an inhabited or occupied building. Whether one of those offenses is alleged affects whether a 14- or 15-year-old can ever be considered for transfer, and section 676 uses a similar list to decide whether hearings are open to the public. When a petition is filed, the first thing to read is which code sections it cites, because those citations determine the procedural path more than the headlines do.

A juvenile case does not end with a sentence in the adult sense. In Lara, the Supreme Court of California repeated that there is no “sentence,” per se, in juvenile court: after a dispositional hearing, a judge chooses among rehabilitation alternatives, and in the more serious cases may order a commitment. The adult penalties written into the Penal Code come into play only if the case is transferred: as Lara put it, only after a transfer “can the juvenile be tried and sentenced as an adult.”

Adults can face their own exposure when a child gets access to a gun. California rewrote its criminal storage law effective January 1, 2026. Under the current Penal Code section 25100, and except as provided in section 25105, a person who keeps a firearm within premises under that person’s custody or control and who knows or reasonably should know that a child is likely to gain access to it without the permission of the child’s parent or legal guardian commits criminal storage in the second degree if the child obtains access and causes injury other than great bodily injury, or “carries the firearm either to a public place” or in violation of section 417. The first degree applies when the child causes death or great bodily injury, and the third degree covers negligently storing or leaving a firearm where the person knows or reasonably should know that a child is likely to gain access. The statute does not require that the adult be a parent; it focuses on control of the premises and on what the adult knew or should have known.

Civil liability is a separate question. Under Civil Code section 1714.3, civil liability for injury to the person or property of another proximately caused by the discharge of a firearm by a minor under 18 is imputed to a parent or guardian having custody and control of the minor, who becomes jointly and severally liable with the minor, if that parent or guardian either permitted the minor to have the firearm or left it in a place accessible to the minor. The statute caps that imputed liability at $30,000 for injury to or death of one person from any one occurrence and $60,000 for all persons from one occurrence, and it states that this liability is in addition to any liability otherwise imposed by law. Two practical points follow. The statute applies only where injury to a person or damage to property was actually caused, and its conditions concern how the firearm came into the minor’s hands. A household that keeps firearms should treat those two conditions as a checklist: who can reach the gun, and whether anyone under 18 was ever allowed to have it.

II. Can the case be moved to adult court, and how do judges decide?

A. Age sets the outer limit: 16 and older, with a narrow exception for 14- and 15-year-olds

Transfer to adult court is not automatic for any offense. Under section 707, subdivision (a)(1), when a minor is alleged to have committed, at 16 years of age or older, an offense listed in subdivision (b) or any other felony criminal statute, the district attorney or other appropriate prosecuting officer “may make a motion to transfer the minor from juvenile court to a court of criminal jurisdiction.” The motion must be made before jeopardy attaches, and the juvenile court must then order the probation officer to submit a report on the minor’s behavioral patterns and social history, including any statement offered by the victim. Two consequences follow. A motion is a request, not a result. And the offense must be a felony or a listed offense; for an offense such as Penal Code section 246.3, which can be punished either in county jail or under section 1170, subdivision (h), how the charge is actually filed and treated matters, and that question should be raised as soon as the petition is available.

For younger teenagers, the rule is much narrower. Subdivision (a)(2) allows a transfer motion for an individual who was 14 or 15 years of age at the time of a listed offense only if that individual “was not apprehended prior to the end of juvenile court jurisdiction.” The Legislature adopted that limit in Senate Bill 1391 in 2018, and district attorneys challenged it as an unlawful amendment of Proposition 57. In O.G. v. Superior Court, 11 Cal.5th 82 (Cal. 2021), decided February 25, 2021, the Supreme Court of California rejected that challenge: “We therefore hold that Senate Bill 1391 is a constitutional amendment to Proposition 57.” The court described the bill as amending Proposition 57 to prohibit minors under the age of 16 from being transferred to adult criminal court. A targeted search of decisions citing O.G. returned a recent published application by the Court of Appeal, In re J.C., discussed in the next paragraph, which relied on O.G. for the statute’s constitutionality in September 2026.

In In re J.C., No. B345707, decided September 2, 2026, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, applied that limit to a case that had moved between criminal court and juvenile court for more than a decade. A grand jury had indicted J.C. in 2013 for two murders alleged to have occurred in 2009, when he was 15 years old. After Proposition 57, Senate Bill 1391 and Assembly Bill 2361 changed the law, the juvenile court granted the People’s latest transfer motion in March 2025. On appeal, the court observed that “Our Supreme Court affirmed the constitutionality of this statute in” O.G., noted that J.C. was 19 years old when indicted and therefore still within the juvenile court’s jurisdiction, and accepted the prosecution’s concession: “The People correctly concede the error.” It reversed the transfer order and remanded the matter to the juvenile court for further proceedings. One justice dissented, arguing that the result could work a miscarriage of justice given the seriousness of the offenses and the passage of time. For a family in California, J.C. shows that age at the time of the alleged offense, not the seriousness of the accusation alone, can rule out an adult trial for a 14- or 15-year-old who is apprehended while the juvenile court still has jurisdiction.

The practical check is therefore a date, not an opinion about the case. Before anything else, a family and its lawyer should confirm the young person’s exact age on the date of the alleged conduct. A 15-year-old arrested within hours of an incident is, under the statute as the Court of Appeal applied it in J.C., outside the reach of a transfer motion. A 16- or 17-year-old can be the subject of a motion, but only through the hearing described below. And because the statute speaks of age “when the minor was 16 years of age or older” at the time of the violation, a birthday that falls between the incident and the filing of the petition does not change the analysis.

A word on terms used in the news. Older articles and some websites still refer to “direct file” or a “fitness hearing.” Lara explained that the hearing once called a fitness hearing is now called a transfer hearing under section 707, and that Proposition 57 eliminated direct filing by prosecutors. A reader who finds a description of a prosecutor filing a juvenile case directly in adult court is reading about the law as it stood before November 2016.

B. The transfer hearing: clear and convincing evidence that the minor is not amenable to rehabilitation

The heart of the system is section 707, subdivision (a)(3). After receiving the probation report and any other relevant evidence that either side wishes to submit, the juvenile court decides whether the minor should be transferred. To order a transfer, “the court shall find by clear and convincing evidence that the minor is not amenable to rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court.” The judge must consider five criteria: the degree of criminal sophistication exhibited by the minor; whether the minor can be rehabilitated before the juvenile court’s jurisdiction expires; the minor’s previous delinquent history; the success of previous attempts by the juvenile court to rehabilitate the minor; and the circumstances and gravity of the offense alleged. If the court orders a transfer, it must recite the basis for its decision in an order entered upon the minutes, including the reasons supporting its finding that the minor is not amenable to rehabilitation. The statute also postpones any plea to the petition until the transfer hearing is over and provides that a plea already entered is not evidence at the hearing.

Each criterion comes with factors that the court “shall give weight to.” For criminal sophistication, the statute lists the minor’s age, maturity, intellectual capacity, physical, mental and emotional health, impetuosity or failure to appreciate risks and consequences, peer or adult pressure, family and community environment, childhood trauma, involvement in the child welfare or foster care system, and status as a victim of trafficking or sexual abuse. For rehabilitation, it lists the minor’s potential to grow and mature. For the offense itself, it lists the actual behavior of the person, the person’s mental state, the person’s degree of involvement in the crime, “the level of harm actually caused by the person,” and the person’s mental and emotional development.

The most recent appellate decisions show that these words carry weight. In In re O.F., No. A166528, decided March 13, 2026, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, First Appellate District, reversed an order transferring a young person to criminal court in a case arising from a 2019 double murder. The court explained that Assembly Bill 2361 raised the prosecution’s burden to clear and convincing evidence and required a specific finding on amenability, and that Senate Bill 545 made the statutory factors mandatory. It held that “The heightened standard of proof applies throughout this analysis,” found that the juvenile court had not given weight to several now-mandatory factors, and stressed that “the gravity of the offense is not dispositive,” because the judge must also evaluate the evidence of the minor’s actual behavior, degree of involvement and the level of harm actually caused. The court ordered a new amenability hearing under current law. For a California family facing a transfer motion, O.F. means the defense can insist that every one of the five criteria be weighed through the question of amenability, and that an incident in which no one was injured be assessed on the harm actually caused rather than on the harm that might have occurred.

The same body of law can also support a transfer, and the outcome turns on evidence. In In re H.J., No. E088015, an opinion certified for publication and filed on October 21, 2026, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Fourth Appellate District, Division Two, affirmed a transfer order entered by the Superior Court of San Bernardino County, the county in which Ontario is located. The case was unusual: the transfer hearing concerned a 2009 murder committed when H.J. was 17, but it took place on a remand ordered years later, when he was in his thirties. The court reviewed the decision for abuse of discretion and the findings for substantial evidence, and it relied on testimony that the most appropriate youth program had rejected him, that the remaining period of juvenile supervision would be about two years, and that his record in custody included continued violence. H.J. illustrates what a transfer hearing actually examines: a probation report addressing each criterion, expert evaluations, the services that exist for this particular young person, and the time the juvenile court would have to deliver them.

Read together, O.F. and H.J. describe the same test applied to very different records. In O.F., the Court of Appeal emphasized uncontradicted evidence of the young person’s engagement with services in juvenile hall, his academic progress and his potential for growth, and it reversed the transfer order for a new hearing. In H.J., the absence of an available program, a short remaining period of juvenile control and a history of violence in custody supported the order. The statute does not ask whether an offense was frightening; it asks whether the prosecution has shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that this minor will not be rehabilitated within the juvenile system.

For a family that learns a transfer motion has been filed, the work is concrete. Obtain the probation officer’s transfer report as soon as it is available and read it criterion by criterion. Gather school records, including any individualized education program, medical and mental health records, records of counseling or therapy, and information about family circumstances and any childhood trauma, because the statute requires the court to give weight to each of those subjects. Identify the services the young person has already received and whether they fit his or her needs, since the adequacy of previous services is a listed factor. Ask which juvenile programs could accept the young person and for how long, because, as H.J. shows, program availability and the length of remaining jurisdiction can decide the hearing. And remember that the hearing comes before any plea: what is said about the facts during that period should be decided with counsel.

The calendar matters too. Because section 707 requires the motion to be made before jeopardy attaches, the transfer question is resolved at the start of the case, before any jurisdictional hearing on the allegations. The detention hearing under section 632 comes even earlier. A family that waits for the facts to settle before engaging with the process may find that the most consequential decisions, custody pending the case and the forum in which it will be heard, have already been made.

Conclusion

When police report that a suspect is in custody after shots are fired in a public place and news reports describe that suspect as a juvenile, California law supplies a clear sequence. The case begins in juvenile court under Welfare and Institutions Code section 602, as the Supreme Court of California confirmed in Lara. A minor in custody must be released within 48 hours, excluding nonjudicial days, unless a petition is filed, and a detained minor must then see a judge before the end of the next judicial day. Firearm possession by anyone under 18 is prohibited, grossly negligent discharge is a crime even when no one is hurt, and the adults who control access to a gun can face separate criminal and civil consequences.

An adult trial is the exception. It is unavailable for a 14- or 15-year-old who is apprehended while the juvenile court still has jurisdiction, as O.G. and J.C. confirm. For a 16- or 17-year-old, it requires a motion, a probation report and a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the young person is not amenable to rehabilitation in the juvenile system, a finding that O.F. requires judges to make through every statutory factor, including the harm actually caused. The first practical step is to confirm the young person’s exact age on the date of the alleged conduct, read the petition’s code sections, and prepare for the detention and transfer hearings with the records the statute tells the court to weigh.

📄 Official circular